H — F H — Cl
Electrostatic potential maps for HF and
HCl indicate the location of electron den-
sity in the molecules. Note the color of
the map near the hydrogen end of each
molecule. The more intense blue color in-
dicates less electron density around the
hydrogen. How does this compare to the
relative acidities for HF and HCl?
Why Do Acids Have Different Strengths?
As with so many answers to chemical questions, the key to differing acid strengths
lies in structure. For binary acids such as HCl or HF (shown in Figure 17.9),
where the electronegative atom is bonded directly to the hydrogen, smaller atoms
have the valence electrons present in a smaller space. This higher electron density
results in stronger bonds between the electronegative atom and hydrogen, which
makes these acids weaker (less likely to donate the proton). That is why HF is
weaker than HCl. However, if the sizes of the atoms bonded to hydrogen are
about the same, the acidity increases with increasing electronegativity of the atom
bonded to hydrogen, because the polarity of the bond also increases. This is why
HF is a stronger acid than H
2
O, which, though it is not binary, has two H—O
bonds.
Consider a “generic” oxygen-containing compound with a central atom, A, as
shown in Figure 17.10. If A has a high electronegativity, then it will have a ten-
dency to form a covalent bond with oxygen, which is also highly electronegative,
while weakening the bond between the oxygen and hydrogen. The hydrogen can
then be easily removed, which means the compound is acidic. The more elec-
tronegative the central atom (A), the more acidic the compound (see Figure 17.11).
Chlorine is more electronegative than sulfur, which, in turn, is more electroneg-
ative than phosphorus. This means that perchloric acid (HClO
4
) is inherently
stronger than sulfuric acid (H
2
SO
4
), which is stronger than phosphoric acid
(H
3
PO
4
). We do not see the difference between perchloric and sulfuric acids in
aqueous solution, but phosphoric acid is noticeably weaker in water than either
of these other compounds.
For the same central atom (sulfur, for example), the higher the oxidation
state, the higher the attraction for electrons and the stronger the covalent bond
between the sulfur and oxygen atom. This tends to weaken the O—H bond in
these compounds, as described above. This is why H
2
SO
4
(with sulfur in the +6
oxidation state) is a stronger acid than H
2
SO
3
(where sulfur is in the +4 oxida-
tion state). For the same reason, HNO
3
is stronger than HNO
2
, and the strength
of so-called chlorine “oxoacids” is HClO
4
> HClO
3
> HClO
2
> HClO.
This model explains why a compound such as NaOH is basic. Let’s look again
at Figure 17.10, where “A” is Na. Sodium has a relatively low electronegativity and
therefore will not form a strong covalent bond with the oxygen atom. The bond
728 Chapter 17 Acids and Bases
ClHFH
FIGURE 17.9
Compare the relative sizes of the atoms
in HCl and HF.
A
OH
A
OH
e
–
density pulled toward A e
–
density not
pulled toward A
Weaker
bond
Electronegative A Less electronegative A
Stronger
bond
FIGURE 17.10
In this “generic” oxygen-containing com-
pound the central atom, A, is bonded to
an oxygen atom, which is itself bonded
to a hydrogen atom. If A is highly elec-
tronegative, it will weaken the bond be-
tween oxygen and hydrogen.
Stronger
HHOO
O
O
H
PHHOOSO
2
HOO
3
Cl
FIGURE 17.11
Chlorine is more electronegative than
sulfur, which, in turn, is more electroneg-
ative than phosphorus. The result is that
HClO
4
is inherently stronger than sulfuric
acid (H
2
SO
4
), which is stronger than
H
3
PO
4
. The listed structures are examples
of resonance structures of each molecule.
Video Lesson: Trends in Acid
and Base Strengths