3.5 Bivectors and Null Flags 185
(Span{v})
⊥
is called the null flag of ξ and is, we claim, an accurate geomet-
rical representation of ξ “up to sign”. To see this we examine the effect of a
phase change
ξ
A
−→ e
iθ
ξ
A
(θ ∈ R).
Of course, the flagpole v is unchanged, but
¯
ξ
˙
X
→ e
−iθ
¯
ξ
˙
X
so F
ab
→
σ
a
A
˙
X
σ
b
B
˙
Y
(e
−2θi
AB
¯
ξ
˙
X
¯
ξ
˙
Y
+ e
2θi
ξ
A
ξ
B
¯
˙
X
˙
Y
). A spinor mate for e
iθ
ξ
A
must
have the property that its ß-inner product with e
iθ
ξ
A
is 1. Since dim ß = 2,
it must be of the form
e
−iθ
η
A
+ kξ
A
for some k ∈ C.Thus,
w
a
−→ −σ
a
A
˙
X
[(e
−iθ
η
A
+ kξ
A
)(e
−iθ
¯
ξ
˙
X
)+(e
iθ
ξ
A
)(e
iθ
¯η
˙
X
+
¯
k
¯
ξ
˙
X
)]
= −σ
a
A
˙
X
[e
−2θi
η
A
¯
ξ
˙
X
+ ke
−iθ
ξ
A
¯
ξ
˙
X
+ e
2θi
ξ
A
¯η
˙
X
+
¯
ke
iθ
ξ
A
¯
ξ
˙
X
]
= −σ
a
A
˙
X
(e
2θi
ξ
A
¯η
˙
X
+ e
−2θi
η
A
¯
ξ
˙
X
) − (ke
−iθ
+
¯
ke
iθ
)(σ
a
A
˙
X
ξ
A
¯
ξ
˙
X
)
= −σ
a
A
˙
X
[(cos 2θ + i sin 2θ)ξ
A
¯η
˙
X
+(cos2θ − i sin 2θ)η
A
¯
ξ
˙
X
]+rv
a
=cos2θ
−σ
a
A
˙
X
(ξ
A
¯η
˙
X
+ η
A
¯
ξ
˙
X
)
+sin2θ
−σ
a
A
˙
X
i(ξ
A
¯η
˙
X
η
A
¯
ξ
˙
X
)
+ rv
a
,
where r = ke
−iθ
+
¯
ke
iθ
= ke
−iθ
+(ke
−iθ
) ∈ R.Now,−σ
a
A
˙
X
(ξ
A
¯η
˙
X
+η
A
¯
ξ
˙
X
)=
w
a
. Moreover, observe that if U
A
˙
X
= ξ
A
¯η
˙
X
− η
A
¯
ξ
˙
X
,then
¯
U
A
˙
X
= −U
A
˙
X
so, by Exercise 3.4.6, iU
A
˙
X
is Hermitian and therefore, by Theorem 3.4.2,
u
a
= −σ
a
A
˙
X
iU
A
˙
X
defines a covector u
∗
in M
∗
.Thus,w
a
→ w
a
cos 2θ +
u
a
sin 2θ + rv
a
so the phase change ξ
A
→ e
iθ
ξ
A
leaves v alone and gives a
new w of
w −→ (cos 2θ)w +(sin2θ)u + rv .
Exercise 3.5.7 Compute w
a
u
a
,v
a
u
a
and u
a
u
a
to show that u is orthogonal
to w and v and satisfies u · u =2.
Thus, we picture w and u as perpendicular spacelike vectors in the 3-space
(Span{v})
⊥
tangent to the null cone along v.Then(cos2θ)w +(sin2θ)u
is a spacelike vector in the plane of w and u making an angle of 2θ with
w. After a phase change ξ
A
→ e
iθ
ξ
A
the new w is in the plane of v and
(cos 2θ)w+(sin2θ)u. The 2-plane containing v and this new w is the new flag.
Thus, a phase change ξ
A
→ e
iθ
ξ
A
leaves the flagpole v unchanged and rotates
the flag by 2θ in the plane of w and u (in Figure 3.5.2 we have drawn the
flagp
ole
vertically even though it lies along a null line). Notice that if θ = π,
then the phase change ξ
A
→ e
πi
ξ
A
= −ξ
A
carries ξ to −ξ, but the null flag
is rotated by 2π and so returns to its original position. Thus, ξ determines a
unique null flag, but the null flag representing ξ also represents −ξ. Hence,
null flags represent spin vectors only “up to sign”. This is a reflection of what
might be called the “essential 2-valuedness” of spinors, which has its roots in