
241
I. '>/E &$! *%> N%&@,E'J' D'O %I@:;,%AB$ NA;R;E; DE;N?,' +:;!BH+; &'=>-
+%AB$=.
% &$=!A$ %J!%!% NA%F!@A' I@:+=;I '!A'J' N ,@:$=A;,$= 'I&%:+$< :%,/ — %-
%!$ D! %E?-P%DD%:% %E?-%H+$. 'J' =;,:%E; 27 J:/!AH / I. %GI/!$H N% 30 ,I =$!
>+'E;B$.
/!;A', J@A@:%E?A'J' >@,:@+%:H @I',:%+;*A'< &%:+$< %:%D>?,'< A%B$< D/E' &$!-
!%A' I$A'I@+A'I/ 'D>+:$E/.
$% " 2005 . $! =;D/G/ K/J%>/, R' >+%=>H / N%G$!A$F
*%>+;A$ %J!%!%, N%J;A/E' >$I =$F>?,'='>E/PD'=B$= .
':H! $N DE', — &'>+'I $:%,>?,'< %:I$< +% !$E?A;B@O &'E$B$< / I. ">@K$H &'=>-
+%AB$ &$!$:=%E; N%I$A'=%A;F %=+'I'D$E?. =% &'=>+%AB$ +% !=% I;:A;G P;+@E$ N%J;-
A/E;, &':%A@A' !@>H+? '>$D.
'!A'I/ $N >$E &'DE;N/ I. '>/E %I@:;,%A>?,% %=$%B$H &'I;E,'=' :'ND'ID;E%
P;+E'=;F !$I. %J;A/E' 14 *'E'=$,.
I. %G%=$E? =$! =;D/G/ N%J;A/E' *@+=@:' '>$D, 19 *'E'=$, &':%A@A'. >$ &':%-
A@A$ +% N%J;DE$ — I;:A$ P;+@E$.
9 2005 . @&'!%E$, I$>+% >-/=@F:% $:%,>?,% &'E$B$H =;H=;E% >G'=%A,/ N
=@E;,'O ,$E?,$>+O D'Q&:;&%>$=.
/E' =;,E;,%A' >%&@:A;F N%J$A ,%N%G>+%A>?,;G I;:'+=':B$= !EH NA@M,'!P@AAH
D'Q&:;&%>$=. %D@N&@*/=%E% :'D'+/ >%&@:$= J:/&% /,:%<A>?,;G I;:'+=':B$= N$ >,E%-
!/ 72-J' ',:@I'J' I@G%A$N'=%A'J' D%+%E?F'A/.
'Q&:;&%>;, / +. *. %=$%D'ID;, &@:@=@NE; !' I$>BH NA@M,'!P@AAH. $>EH :'N=%A-
+%P@AAH =>$G D'Q&:;&%>$= >+%=>H =;D/G. $I /,:%<A>?,;G I;:'+=':B$= N%J;A/E; A%
I$>B$, % '!;A — &'I@: =$! :%A A@=!'=N$. %J;A/= +%,'P ='H,% N %N%G>+%A/, *@+=@:'
!$>+%E; &':%A@AAH. %J;A/E;: ,'I%A!;: D%+%E?F'A/ &$!&'E,'=A;, %+$P@= E@J
$,+':'=;*, ,%&$+%A %J:%F ":$F ;G%FE'=;*, ,%&$+%A A!:/R@A,' @:J$F ;,'-
E%F'=;*, ,%&$+%A :%P@=>?,;F %E@:$F $,+':'=;*, &:%&':R;, %A%:>?,;F E@,-
>%A!: =%A'=;*, >+%:M;F >@:P%A+ $+A;,'= A!:$F A%+'E$F'=;*, >+%:M;F >@:P%A+
@+:;, $:% =%A$=A%, >+%:M;F &:%&':R;, Q!'F 'E'!;I;: ;,'E%F'=;*.
':%A@AAH '+:;I%E;: I%F': 'NE'= J': ;,'E%F'=;*, :H!'=;F %G+$H:'= E@-
,>%A!: ;,'E%F'=;*, :H!'=;F M%J%A E@,>%A!: =%A'=;*, :H!'=;F @!;, %,-
>;I ;,'E%F'=;*, :H!'=;F ':H*@=>?,;F ;G%FE' A%+'E$F'=;*, >@:P%A+ @=H-
,'= ;,'E% =%A'=;*.
$E% /,:%<A>?,;G +% ,%N%G>?,'J' I;:'+=':B$= D/E' =$!&:%=E@A' !' %J!%!%, %
N=$!+; — E$+%,'I -130 D:'FA;G ;E — !' I$>+% %IM+%FA ($I@**;A%).
%I =;,'A/=%E;>H =$!&'=$!A$ I@!;*A$ &:'B@!/:;. $I@**;A; MEHG N%J;DE;G &:'-
EHJ%= A% ,:%<A/.
!" 2005 . %&%!A;,; =D;E; ='!$<= %=+','E'A;, H,%
=@NE% A'=$ $:%,>?,$ I'A@+; =$! &':+/ I$>+% %>:% !' @A+:%E?A'J' D%A,/ :%,%. :%-
&;E'>H B@ N% 20 ,I A% &$=!@AA;F >G$! =$! %J!%!%. :'M$ D%A!;+; N%G'&;E;.
% 15 ,I A% &$=!@A? =$! %J!%!% &'DE;N/ I$>+% E?-">/K$H =*;A@A' A%&%! A% %=-
+'D/>. 8 '>$D N%J;A/E'. :'Q &%>%P;:$= N%G'&E@A' = N%:/*A;,;.
$! =;D/G/ %=+'I'D$EH &'DE;N/ !$E?A;B$ &'E$B$< / I$>+$ $,:;+ N%J;A/E' &:;A%F-
IA$ M$>+? *'E'=$,.
%A$M@ A@=$!'I% ND:'FA% ':J%A$N%B$H «%:'H :%,A%» 'J'E'>;E% =$FA/ %A+;/:H-
!'=;I /J:/&/=%AAHI. '=>+%ABHI N%&:'&'A'=%A' &:;&;A;+; A%&%!; $ !;=@:>$<.
+:%+; =$! !;=@:>$< A% A%K+'=;G +% @A@:J@+;*A;G 'D’Q,+%G !'>HJE; 10 IE:! !'E.
!" 2005 . =% N%I$A'=%A$ %=+'I'D$E$ =;D/GA/E; /
&$=!@AA'->G$!A$F *%>+;A$ I$>+% '>/E. =% $:%,>?,;G >'E!%+; N%J;A/E;, R@ !='G
D/E' &':%A@A'. /E; NA%*A$ P@:+=; $ &'I$P I;:A'J' A@>@E@AAH.