*
Most coatings will crack if they are formed to asmaller-than-recommendedbend radius.
*
The product length can be incorrectly specified. Products that are too long maynot fit onto the
runout table or they cannot be handled. Precut products that are too shortmay not be able to pass
throughthe roll forming mill. In apostcutting operation, the minimum length is usually
restricted.
*
Products are frequently copied from competitors or product designs are acquired through
acquisition or licensing agreement. Even if acompanyhas amill with the same number of passes,
the same shaft diameter,and roll space as the original manufacturer of that product, it is not
certain that the plant will be able to form the product to the specifications. Other parameters
such as the horizontal distances between passes, mill characteristics, the cutoffpress, and other
influencing factors havetobecorrect in ordertoproduce the right product.
*
It is usually not possible to roll form aproduct to tighter tolerancethan in the past production
runs while using the same tooling,equipment, and speed. Occasionally,the plant can manage
better length tolerances, at alower speed and ahigher scrap rate.
Althoughthe above-mentioned problems occur frequently in roll forming plants, all of them can be
prevented with proper screening of the design, drawings, and tolerances before an order is accepted.
10.4.3 Problems Created by the Material
Let us assume that aplant with good equipment and properly set up good tooling is roll forming a
good-qualityproduct. Onceproduction commences, all products would be within the specified
tolerances and qualitywithout adjusting the equipment if the material were perfect. However,perfect
material does not exist. Fluctuation in material thickness, wi dth, mechanical properties, and surface
quality(coating),aswell as deviation from straightness and flatness and other properties will influence
the product quality. Therefore, the operator must adjust the machine to compensate for all these
material imperfections.
Commercial tolerances on the materials are generally quite loose. Variation of the material
properties can be so widethat it is impossible to compensate by adjusting the equipment and tooling.
In such cases, the product cannot be manufactured within the required tolerances. To prevent this
possibility, manufacturers often specify tighter than the standardtolerances for material thickness and
width. However,they frequently overlook the adverse effect of the fluctuation between the minimum
and the maximum yield strengths, and accept the excessive but still within the standard camber in the
strip.
Fluctuation in thickness, width, and camber can be checked easily in the plant. However,itismore
difficult to detect, check, and measurethe fluctuation in the mechanical properties and changes in the
metallurgical properties, both of which influence flatness and straightness. Owing to the intricacy of
determining these factors, material is frequently thought to be the cause of problems that could actually
be originated by the equipment, tooling,orincorrect setup.The simplest method to determine whether
or not the problem is caused by the material is described in Section 10.4.7 (“Proof Coil”).
10.4.4 Problems Caused by Equipment
Inevitably,every plant will haveproblem(s) with its equipment. The roots of the problems, in most cases,
can be traced back to the following:
10.4.4.1 Equipment
*
The capabilities of the available equipment are inadequate for the job; either the equipment has
been improperly specified or the companyfailed to select the right supplier.
*
The equipment is not properly maintained. Most people havetheir car serviced regularly,but they
do not apply this rule to rollforming mills. Many companies do not haveapreventive/predictive
Equipment Installation, Roll Setup, Maintenance, and Troubleshooting 10-33