92
CARBONATE DIAGENESIS AND MICROFABRICS
cyanobacteria in the Bahamas. Cayeux (see Sedimentologists),
in 1935, had provided a superb range of black and white
photomicrographs. Sander in 1936 (English version 1951) in a
book remarkable for its scientific discipline, had given us the
terms "geopetal", "internal sediment", and "fabric" (from
"gefuge"). iiadding (1941-1959) had written superb analyzes
of Swedish Paleozic limestones.
The first sign of a new start came from work in the
universities. From Cambridge, in 1954, llling made a major
lithofacies study of the sediments on the Great Bahama Bank.
From Liverpool, Bathurst, in 1958 and 1959, offered criteria,
based on metalurgical fabrics, for distinguishing space-filling
from replacement calcite. At much the same time, in the
University of Texas, Austin, Folk (see Sedimentologists) gave
us in 1959, the extremely successful system for recognizing
limestone types, such as biomicrite and biosparite. An
extraordinary group of workers in Shell Development Com-
pany were producing innovative ideas: for example Ginsburg,
in 1956, continuing his earlier research done in the University
of Miami, published an extensive study of the Florida seafloor.
Murray, in 1960, examined a range of porosity-forming
processes and Dunham, in 1962, 1969, and 1971, compiled a
classification of allochems involving the valuable concepts of
"grain-supported" and "mud-supported", also "vadose silt"
and "meniscus cement".
Now a search could be made for diagenetic environments.
Where had lithification taken place? Ginsburg in 1957, showed
that the Pleistocene Miami Oolite, while friable in seawater,
was cemented with calcite in freshwater. The supply of
carbonate for the calcite came from dissolved aragonite.
Schlanger in 1963, confirmed that freshwater lithification had
taken place just below unconformities. Research on the
Pleistocene of Bermuda in the 1960s, by Friedman, Gross,
Land, Mackenzie, and Gould, led to a concept of freshwater
lithification, the new calcite being regarded as either sparry
cement or neomorphic replacement. All sparry calcite was
assumed then to be of freshwater origin. The idea of meteoric
lithification had great appeal—no heat, no pressure. The
interpretation of process was aided by the new alliance
between fabric and analysis of elements and isotope ratios.
The concept of changing composition of pore water was
clarified by the development of stains in the 1960s by Evamy,
Shearman and Dickson. Cathodoluminescence (CL) was
applied by Sippel and Glover following the pioneer work of
Amieux.
Marine diagenesis was examined as well. IUing in his 1954
paper recorded beach rock and Bathurst in 1966 described
micritization of shells by boring cyanobacteria followed by
cementation. Yet, far from today's seas, in New Mexico, Pray
was mapping Mississippian bioherms with clastic dikes of
synsedimentary origin wliich were clearly in a marine cemented
substrate.
Indeed, in the 1970s a new world of submarine cementation
was opening up with the work of Schroeder and Ginsburg on
Bermuda reefs and on other reefs off Jamaica by Land and
Goreau. In the Persian Gulf cemented crusts in shallow water
had been located by Shinn, Taylor, and llling. Evidence of
cementation in deep sea sediments in dredged blocks was
revealed by Fischer and Garrison in 1967.
Older marine cemented limestones were recorded too by
Purser in Jurassic hardgrounds in the Paris Basin and by Zankl
in the Jurassic and Trias of Germany and Austria. Void-filling
cements were found in Devonian reefs in Germany by Krebs.
Further support came from Bromley's Chalk hardgrounds in
Denmark.
The study of the finer fabrics was greatly helped by use
of the transmission electron microscope, as in the book by
Fischer, Honjo, and Garrison, and even finer detail was
revealed by the scanning electron microscope pioneered
especially by Alexandersson and Loreau.
A most valuable international conference on carbonate
cements took place on Bermuda in 1969 when four diagenetic
environments were distinguished: the intertidal marine, the
submarine, the vadose freshwater, and the phreatic freshwater.
Many of these were later described from Belize by James and
Ginsburg in 1979.
An understanding of aquifer hydrology became increasingly
pressing and was helped by work such as that by Back and
Hanshaw published in 1970. There was thus a successful
Penrose Conference in Vail, Colorado, combining hydrologists
with sedimentologists. At that meeting a significant leap
forward was taken by Meyers who introduced the use of CL
zoning to reveal cement stratigraphy.
The study of freshwater aquifers led to the recognition of
caliches by Esteban, Read, and Klappa and a range of soil
textures.
Now some consolidation of ideas was necessary and five
important books appeared: Bathurst on carbonate sediments
and their diagenesis, Wilson's great summary of carbonate
lithofacies in the Phanerozoic, Fliigel's acute study of
microfacies, with visual identification of allochems supported
by the books of Majewske, and of Horowitz and Potter.
The deformation of carbonate sediments during burial was
being revealed by Mossop's research on pressure-dissolution in
Devonian reefs, by Mimran in steep limbs of folded Cretac-
eous Chalk, and by Dickson and Coleman in 1980 who showed
with isotopic analysis of calcite cement zones a long history of
growth during burial. The later cement zones are commonly
ferroan.
It was becoming clear that the amount of calcium carbonate
required to fill the pores with cement must have been
considerable, even exceeding the original mass of the sediments
as proposed by Choquette and Pray in 1970. The importance
of a local source through pressure-dissolution was suggested
by Hudson in 1975. Calcite cementation in some Jurassic
limestones is late burial because it post-dates fracture of
micrite envelopes, as demonstrated by Emery, Dickson, and
Smalley in 1987. A useful terminology for pressure-dissolution
fabrics was presented by Buxton and Sibley in 1981, i.e., "fitted
fabric", "dissolution seam", and "stylolite". With the author's
permission Bathurst in 1991 tightened up their definition of
"fitted fabric". Lithification of coccolithic chalk by pressure-
dissolution over tens of millions of years was demonstrated by
Matter, and by Scholle, in 1974. Bathurst in 1983 dealt with
burial calcitization in terms of compaction fabrics.
Dolomite, too, could have a deep crustal origin, both as
replacement and cement. Choquette found it could be a
fracture fill, as did Grover and Read, Moldovanyi and
Lohmann, and Dorobek. Mattes and Mountjoy found
dolomite related to pressure-dissolution. Wardlaw revealed
fine detail by using resins to make pore casts.
The role of early cementation in preserving sediment from
compaction was emphasized for Jurassic hardgrounds by
Purser in 1969, for the Jurassic Smackover by Swirydczuk in
1988 and for the Carboniferous Limestone of England by
Hurd and Tucker in 1988. James and Bone in 1989 showed