We now have three kinds of limits: the left-hand limits and right-hand limits
defined on the preceding page and the two-sided limits defined on page 881.
Example 9 exhibits a function that has a right-hand limit at x 3 but no left-hand
or two-sided limit. The function in Example 8 has both a left- and a right-hand
limit but no two-sided limit.
When a function has a two-sided limit L at x c, then it automatically has L
as both the left- and right-hand limit at x c. Example 5 illustrates this clearly.
Figures 13–5 and 13–6 show that as x gets closer and closer to 3 (on both sides
of 3), the corresponding values of
f (x)
e
x
x
3
3
1
get closer and closer to 1. So it is certainly true that when x takes values to the
right of 3 (that is, x 3), the corresponding values of f (x) get closer and
closer to 1—and similarly, when x takes values to the left of 3. A similar argu-
ment applies in the general case.
EXAMPLE 10
The graph of the function f in Figure 13–11 shows that f (2) 1 and that
lim
x2
f(x) 3, lim
x2
f (x) 3, lim
x2
f (x) 3.
Figure 13–11
The graph also shows that
lim
x6
f (x) 5 and lim
x6
f (x) 4,
so the two-sided limit, lim
x6
f (x), is not defined. ■
y
x
2468
2
1
4
3
5
SECTION 13.1 Limits of Functions 887
Two-Sided
Limits
Let f be a function and let c and L be real numbers. Then
lim
xc
f(x) L exactly when lim
xc
f (x) L and lim
xc
f (x) L.
CAUTION
Whenever a calculator was used in the
preceding examples, we were careful
to say that the information it provided
suggested that the limit was a
particular number. Although
calculators can provide strong
numerical and graphical evidence for
the existence of a limit, they do not
provide a proof of this fact. In fact,
calculators can occasionally be
misleading (see Exercise 63).