520 Melting in planetary bodies
crystallization of high-pressure ices, so that liquid H
2
O would be sandwiched between the
ice Ih shell and the planet’s silicate mantle (or crust?). Focusing on Titan and Ganymede,
then, we ask our next question: is cryomagmatism possible in these worlds? If the com-
position of the icy envelope is pure H
2
O then, as we saw, the answer is no. Liquid H
2
O
would freeze when attempting to ascend through the ice Ih shell (this is a convoluted way
of saying that ice floats on water). And yet, there is geologic evidence for cryolavas in both
of these worlds. The most likely explanation for this is that the material that encases these
satellites is a mixture of H
2
O with other volatile compounds, chiefly NH
3
and perhaps CH
4
as well. These additional components have two effects that may facilitate cryomagmatism:
they lower the melting point of ice, and they lower the density of the liquid.
Melting phase relations for the binary system H
2
O–NH
3
at low pressure were summa-
rized by Kargel (1992). Three intermediate crystalline compounds form between Ice Ih and
solid ammonia: ammonium dihydrate (NH
3
.2H
2
O), ammonium hydrate (NH
3
.H
2
O) and
diammonium hydrate (2NH
3
.H
2
O). These give rise to three eutectics, and a peritectic at
which ammonium dihydrate melts incongruently to ice Ih plus a liquid richer in ammonia
that NH
3
.2H
2
O. Everywhere between the composition of the peritectic (∼33 wt% NH
3
) and
the H
2
O end of the binary join the H
2
O–NH
3
melt is at equilibrium with ice Ih. Therefore,
a subsurface liquid layer in a water–ammonia icy satellite containing between 0 wt% and
33 wt% NH
3
can exist at equilibrium with an ice Ih shell.
What is the buoyancy of these H
2
O–NH
3
melts relative to the Ice Ih country rock? An
equation of state for H
2
O–NH
3
liquids has been calibrated by Croft et al. (1988). Their
equation consists of an isothermal Murnaghan EOS (Section 8.2.1) and a polynomial zero-
pressure thermal expansion term. It is somewhat unwieldy because the calibration changes
with composition along the H
2
O–NH
3
join. We cannot discuss it here owing to space
constraints. We can state some of the key results of the Croft et al. EOS, though. First, it
predicts that the density of H
2
O–NH
3
liquids is always lower than that of pure H
2
O liquid at
the same pressure and temperature, and that density decreases with increasing NH
3
content.
Second, it shows that H
2
O–NH
3
melts may be more or less dense that ice Ih, depending on
pressure and melt composition. Third, it suggests that the melts that form by incongruent
melting of ammonium dihydrate are less dense than ice Ih, which is the solid phase that
these melts are at equilibrium with. The melt becomes denser than ice Ih with decreasing
NH
3
content, but a compositional interval exists within which the Clapeyron slope of the
ice Ih melting reaction changes from negative (i.e. as in the pure H
2
O system, Fig. 10.16)
to positive. Under those circumstances the melt can ascend through the ice Ih crust and
eventually be extruded on the surface of the satellite.
And herein lies a significant problem: if a satellite-wide liquid layer of low-density H
2
O–
NH
3
melt forms, it is gravitationally unstable relative to the ice Ih shell. This would produce
a short-lived surge of magmatic activity, at the end of which refractory ice Ih would underlie
a less-dense mixture of H
2
O–NH
3
ices, making further igneous activity difficult. This is
not altogether different from the formation of anorthositic crust from a primordial lunar
magma ocean. The problem is that, in contrast to the volcanically dead Moon, there appears
to be geologically recent cryovolcanism on Titan, and perhaps on Ganymede as well. One
possible way out is that the liquid layer underlying the ice Ih shell is not positively buoyant
after all, but merely close to being neutrally buoyant, and that cryomagmas are “squeezed”
to the surface by tectonic processes driven by convection of the ice Ih shell (see Mitri
& Showman, 2008). Another possibility is that a satellite-girdling liquid layer does not
exist at all, because the average internal temperature is lower than the solidus, and that
convection causes only local decompression melting of ices, as in silicate planets. If the