Sources of Food-grade Protein
G S Gilani and N Lee, Bureau of Nutritional Sciences,
Health Canada, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada
Copyright 2003, Elsevier Science Ltd. All Rights Reserved.
Background
0001 Comparison of data from different countries has in-
dicated that countries with low gross national prod-
ucts also tend to have a low food energy availability.
In addition, there are major differences in the pattern
of foods in the diet in such countries compared with
wealthier countries. In particular, the availability of
animal-protein foods is significantly lower in poor
countries. Compared to the developed world, a
greater proportion of the protein consumed by people
in developing countries is derived from low-quality
protein sources such as cereals. Moreover, the pat-
terns of indispensable amino acid (IAA) composition
in the proteins are such that there is a significant
difference between the diets of rich and poor people
with respect to lysine. Standard tables of amino acid
composition show that the values for cereals range
from 26 to 38 mg of lysine per gram of protein, while
the values for animal foods range from 70 to 100 mg
of lysine per gram of protein. A recent analysis of
the world’s balance of dietary IAA demonstrated
that average lysine intakes were low in poor, de-
veloping countries. This would indicate a consider-
able risk of inadequate levels of intake, especially in
vulnerable subgroups such as children and pregnant
or lactating women. Strategies to alleviate the pos-
sible global problems of a low lysine supply could
include increasing dietary diversity as well as either
supplementing cereal-based foods with food-grade
proteins high in lysine or fortifying cereals with
lysine.
Food-grade Proteins
0002 In this chapter, sources of food-grade protein are
defined as products made by processing certain food
ingredients in a manner that significantly increases
their protein content. They are often referred to as
protein flours, protein concentrates, and protein isol-
ates. Some examples are milk-protein isolate, whey-
protein concentrate, casein, lactalbumin, egg-white
solids, gelatin, soybean-protein flours, concentrates,
and isolates, pea-protein concentrate, canola-protein
concentrate, mycoprotein, cottonseed protein, and
wheat gluten.
0003These protein sources could be used to improve the
protein nutriture of populations by increasing the
protein content of the diet, increasing the quality of
the proteins in the diet, or a combination of both. It
should be noted that increasing the protein quantity
and/or quality of a diet is ineffective if energy require-
ments are not met.
Animal-protein Products
0004Most animal sources of food-grade protein (except
gelatin) are excellent sources of all the IAA (Table 1)
and have a high protein digestibility (See Protein:
Quality). High-protein-quality animal products in-
clude egg proteins, casein, milk protein isolate, lac-
talbumin, whey-protein concentrate, beef, tuna, and
chicken meat products. These products are especially
high in key IAA such as lysine, methionineþcystine,
threonine, and tryptophan, which are limiting in
poor-quality vegetable-protein products. Among the
animal-protein products, egg white contains the
highest amount of methionineþcystine, and lactalbu-
min and whey-protein concentrate contain the
highest amounts of lysine and tryptophan, while egg
white, tuna, beef, and chicken meat products contain
the highest amounts of threonine. Therefore, these
animal-protein products could serve as supplements
to low-quality proteins limiting in one or more of
these IAA.
0005The protein efficiency ratio (PER) values of most
high-quality animal-protein products are higher than
that of the standard for the method, which is casein
(Table 2). In contrast, proteins with protein digest-
ibility-corrected amino acid scores (PDCAAS) ex-
ceeding 100% are truncated to 100%, implying that
values exceeding 100% do not contribute any add-
itional benefit in humans. This is not true, especially
when these proteins are used as supplements to poor-
quality proteins. Therefore, there is an urgent need to
revise the PDCAAS method to permit the use of
untruncated PDCAAS values for high-quality
animal-protein products so that their supplementary
value, when combined with lower-quality protein
sources, can be identified by their PDCAAS values.
0006Gelatin is a unique animal protein product which is
devoid of tryptophan and is also limiting in all other
IAA. This complete lack of nutritional value has not
stopped some individuals from using it as the basis for
weight-loss drinks. After several illnesses and deaths
were associated with the use of these products in very-
low-calorie diets, Canada introduced a requirement
that any product containing gelatin or collagen or
hydrolyzed gelatin or collagen must carry a caution-
ary statement advising people not to use it as a sole
source of nutrition.
PROTEIN/Sources of Food-grade Protein 4873