
GENESIS
&
DEVELOPMENT7
Archimedes and the Sphere
Arc lengths, surface areas, and volumes—these con-
cepts were all investigated by the geometers of ancient
Greece. Archimedes, for example, demonstrated that
the volume enclosed by a sphere is 2/3 the volume
of the circumscribing cylinder and that the surface area
of a sphere is (also) 2/3 the area of the cir cumscribing
cylinder (including its circular ends). Stated more
explicitly, he proved that the volume and surface area
of a sphere of radius r are 4πr
3
/3 and 4π r
2
, respectively.
These results must have pleased Archimedes, for
he requested that his tomb be decorated with a sphere
and cylinder and that the ratio giving their relationship
be inscribed. His wishes were carried out, as we learn
from Cicero, who in 75
B.C. rediscovered and repaired
the overgrown, forgot ten site:
“I remembered some verses which I had been
informed were engraved on his monument, and
these set forth that on the top of the tomb there was
placed a sphere with a cylinder. . . . I observed a
small column standing out a little above the briers
with the figure of a sphere and a cylinder upon it . . .
When we could get at it. . . . I found the inscription,
though the latter parts of all the verses were almost
half effaced. Thus one of the noblest cities of
Greece, and one which at one time likewise had
been very celebrated for learning, had known
nothing of the monument of its greatest genius . . . .”
The restored grave of Archimedes eventually van-
ished again. However, in modern times, workers exca-
vating the site of a hotel in Syracuse reported coming
upon a stone tablet inscribed with a sphere and a cylinder.
Kepler and Solids of Revolution
In 1612, Johannes Kepler (15711630) took up residence
in Linz. As the wine harvest was good that year, the
Danube River banks were filled with wine casks. “This
being so,” in the words of Kepler’s biographer, Max
Caspar, “as husband and good pater-familias,hecon-
sidered it his duty to provide his home with the necessary
drink.” Accordingly, Kepler had some wine barrels
installed in his house. After seeing a wine merchant esti-
mate the volume of a cask by simply inserting a measuring
stick, Kepler set himself the problem of deve loping a more
scientific system of calculating volumes.
Inspired by these wine barrels, Kepler derived
formulas for the volumes of several solids of revolution
(not all of which were suitable for wine storage).
Among other results, he rediscovered Pappus’s for-
mula, 2πb πa
2
, for the volume of the torus, an inner-
tube-shaped solid that is generated when a disk of
radius a is revolved about an axis a distance b . a from
its center (Figure 1). The rigorous deductions of
Archimedes were somewhat beyond Kepler, who
resorted to the very free use of infinitesimal arguments.
In Kepler’s own words: “we could obtain absolute and
perfect proofs from the books of Archimedes if we did
not shrink from the thorny reading of his writings.”
Kepler published the results of his investigations in
1615 at his own expense. Despite Kepler’s strenuous
efforts to recoup his outlay, sales were limited to one
nobleman, two mathematicians, and a library.
Arc Length
The arc length problem (known then as rectification)
was also revived by mathematicians in the 1600s. Some
leading philosophers believed rectification to be inso-
luble. Descartes, for one, was emphatic on this point in
his G
´
eom
´
etrie: “The ratios between straight and curved
lines are not known, and I believe cannot be discovered
by human minds.” The idea that it might be possible to
compare the arc lengths of two different curves seems
to have originated with another philosopher, Thomas
Hobbes (15881679). Hobbes communicated his idea
to Rober val in 1642, and, by the end of that year,
Roberval was able to prod uce equal length arcs of the
Archimedean spiral
ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
x
2
1 y
2
p
5 arctanðy=xÞ (Figure 2a)
and of the parabola y 5 x
2
/2. Three years later,
a
x
y
b
m Figure 1
625