Ващенко Ю.В. Банківське право
Подождите немного. Документ загружается.
131
C"!?AF H+ +, I !D&"? < &"'!&?I * %!-
@"DC", H+* E!$@!' !!@! '"#C D '!'%$* !$' D-
& H+* %!@"DC";.
*
"
K'*#!& %!@"DC" D"F#;I$A# * D" "#$!$!, D@!D
E?$!#E!'!J!#$" H+*.
"R% E! %!@"DC"; H+*, +"' E%%$&!%, 'I '"#-
$$ "!'C"; E!:
1) *@!* E! %!@"DC"; * D" D?$$ H! EI;
2) ED<% E%#!?A!@! #+?* +!'"#", ? E!&%%
%!@"DC",;
3) ED<% E%#!?A!@! #+?* %&"D"F!, +!'"#", ?
E!&%% "&%$DC", $ %&"D", '$%"?A= C"!#$%F, M!
E%%H*&;$A !H?"+* H+* (H+"&);
4) ED<% %D?%J!@! *$!, M! 'I #%$"+$ -
C"!?A!@! H+* +,;
5) #$!+ E!&%% %!@"DC",;
6) #+? E&?" ( %+$!"&) E"#? %!@"DC",.
%!@"DC" !DE!<I$A# E"#? D$&%J% C"!?A-
' H+!' +, E?* %!@"DC",, +F +"' "R= %!H-
="= D=!"& E!&% E%%H<$ E! C"!?A!'* H-
+* +, &"E!&"= !+*'%$"&, %!H="= ? %J&!,
%I#$C", !&!@! H+* H! ? %I#$C", D'" " !E!&%A !
*#$!&<= !+*'%$"& "#*;<!@! H+*.
+ &&JI$A# %!@"D!&' D '!'%$* &%#% C"!-
?A' H+!' +, D'" ! %J&!@! %I#$* H+"&.
D" E'*#!&!, %!@"DC", "R%, E%%H<%" E*+$-
' 2—6 <#$ E%R!, #$$$" 28 T+!* «K! H+ " H+"&#A+*
"?A"#$A», EF';$A# C"!?A' H+!' +,, *@!
E! %!@"DC"; % E"E#*I$A#, D@?A" *'!& %!@"DC",
&D<;$A# E!#$!&!; E&?" C"!?A!@! H+* +-
, " I !H!&’D+!&' ? &+! *#"' #$!!'.
@! E! D?$$ H! EI *+?I$A# H+', M! %!-
@"D*;$A# R?=!' D?$$ H! EI, * E#A'!&"F !'".
@! E! D?$$ H! EI '"#$$A E!?!J%, M! %-
@*?;;$A E$, &D<%" * #$$$" 28 T+!* «K! H+ " H-
+"&#A+* "?A"#$A».
. .
132
@! E! D?$$ H! EI HI D+!!, #? D '!-
'%$* D$&%J% ,, H"?AR"#$; * &" $%$ @!?!#"& +C"!%"&
(*<#+"&) D@?A= DH!= +!J!@! D H+"&.
< ("
H*$A, %'I "R!, ;<!, !#!H, "J H+, ?"+&"C"
+!, &+?+? H $+F '#!&F %D!# * #*#E"?A#$&". %, H%D*-
'!&!, E!&’D! "D !#!H?&' E&!&' #$$*#!' H+*, #E%C-
"+!; D"F#;&!, ' "?A!#$". =!&*;<, M! H+ I &%-
?+' "#!&' E!#%%+!', EE% F!@! "?A!#$" %
'!J% % E!D<$# D<"F +"?A+!#$" "D<= $ ;<-
= !#"H — +?"I$"& CA!@! H+* $ E!&’D= D ' !#"H. [+
#E&%?&! DD<;$A * #&!,F E*H?"+C", . I&#A+F $
.T*H!+, !' "D F@!?!&"R= D&A + * "?A!#$" H+"&,
$+ " & E!C%#" ,= ?"+&"C", I D=#$ +?"I$"& " &+?+"& H+*
95
.
D&’D+* D C' D&<F! &J?&' I <"$+% &%@*?;& *
D+!!&#$&" ?"+&"C"F!, E!C%* H+*. K!?"D*I'! E!-
?!J% H+"&#A+!@! D+!!&#$& +,, +' %@?'%-
$*;$A# DD<%" &"!#.
$J%, &"E!&"! ! #$$$" 1 T+!* +, «K! H+ " H-
+"&#A+* "?A"#$A» ?"+&"C" H+* — E!C%* EE%
*+C"!*& H+* + ;<!, !#!H &"E!&"! ! E!?!-
J%A CA!@! T+!*.
+ '!J% H*$ ?"+&"!&F:
1) D ""C"$& &?#+"& H+*;
2) D ""C"$& C"!?A!@! H+* +, (* $!'* <#?" D
D&!; +%$!"&).
"+&"C" H+* D ""C"$& &?#+"& D"F#;I$A# & E!+*,
E%%H<%!'* D+!!&#$&!' +, E! @!#E!#A+" $!&#$-
&, D *=*&' !#!H?&!#$%F, E%%H<%= C' T+!!', $
)' :E) . [+
H<'!, &"'"* &" "-
R= ;<= !#"H, ? ?"+&"C", H+* !"I, ?R% D@! F!@!
&?#+"& I %!#$$A!. +% E!?!J% D+"E?%% * T+!" #'% D
'%$!; D=#$* "$%%#"& +?"I$"& H+* $ DH%DE%<% #$H"?A!#$"
"#!&!-+%$!, ##$%' %J& & C"?!'*.
"+&"C" H+* D ""C"$& C"!?A!@! H+* +,
D"F#;I$A# &"E!&"! ! T+!* $ !'$&!-E&!&= +$"&
C"!?A!@! H+* +,.
95
D =., A . "+&"C" H+"&. @"DC" E!C%* // "#+ . —
&"$%A 2003. — . 11—14. — . 11.
133
C"!?AF H+ +, D!H!&’DF E!$@!' &!= "&
E"#? EF$$ "R% E! ?"+&"C"; H+* E!&"!'$ E! C%
L! @$*& &+?"& "D<= !#"H. D" !#+J% &
#*!&!'* E!+* "R% C"!?A!@! H+* E! ?"+&"C";
H+* C"!?AF H+ +, $+!J E!&"!'?I E! C% L!
@$*& &+?"& "D<= !#"H.
5
* (
"I; D FE!R%"R= E"#$& EE% H+* + ;-
<!, !#!H I F!@! %E?$!#E!'!J"#$A.
K&! D&%% ! #** "D D&!; E! &D H+* %E?-
$!#E!'!J' $ F!@! ?"+&"C"; ';$A:
1) +%$! H+*;
2) C"!?AF H+ +,.
%$! E&?;$A %+!'%!&' ?#$!' ! C"!-
?A!@! H+* +, D&* E! ?"+&"C"; H+* E
#$"
!D+ %E?$!#E!'!J!#$" H+* D !&' !+*'%$?A!
E"$&%J%= !+D"& &!#$" %&+!= @!R!&= D!-
H!&’DA H+* E%% '. [+M! E!$@!' !!@! '"#C D
E&?% D& DD<%" !#!H % !$'? &"E!&"A C"!-
?A!@! H+* +,, &! ';$A E&! D&%*$# ! #** "D
D&!; E! &D H+* %E?$!#E!'!J'.
T+!!&#$&! +, E! &"!&?% E?$!#E!'!J!#$"
H!J+ H! &D F!@! H+*$!' E !D@?" #*!' #E-
& E! &D H+* %E?$!#E!'!J' D#$!#!&*I$A# & <#-
$", M! % #*E%%<$A !'' T+!*.
K E"@!$!&C" #E& ! !D@?* #* !$'*I !H_*$!&-
F &#!&!+ C"!?A!@! H+* +, M!! !C"?A!#$" ?"-
+&"C", H+* H! "R% C"!?A!@! H+* +, E! &"-
+?+ H+"&#A+!, ?"C%D", $ ED<% ?"+&"$!.
C"!?AF H+ +, D!H!&’DF $ ! "D DD<%-
= !+*'%$"& E!$@!' '"#C D !$' DE$* #**.
T+!!&#$&!' E%%H<% &"R?A !?A C"!?A!@!
H+* * DD<%!'* E!C%#": %@$&F &#!&!+ M!!
!C"?A!#$" &"+?+ H+"&#A+!, ?"C%D", $ ?"+&"C", H+* I
E"#$&!; ? D?R% D& H%D !D@?*.
[+M! H+-H!J+ % #E!'!JF &+!$ #&!, D!-
H!&’D &"E!&"! ! "R% #** E! E'*#!&% #$@%
E!$@!' R%#$ '"#C"& " D C%F <# % !#@*$! !'!&?%!#$%F
. .
134
M!! %#$*+$*DC", &D<%!@! H!@*, C"!?AF H+
+, D!H!&’DF &"+?+$ ?"C%D"; $ ""C";&$ E!C%-
** ?"+&"C", H+*.
E& E! &D H+* %E?$!#E!'!J' D D&!;
+%$!"& '!J% H*$ E!*R% ?R% E"#? &"+?+ H+"&-
#A+!, ?"C%D",. K CA!'* E"#? &"+?+ H+"&#A+!, ?"C%D",
#C" H+* % !E*#+I$A#.
@, +F ""C";&& "R% E! ?"+&"C";, ED<I ?"+-
&"$!. "+&"$! E#$*EI ! &+! !H!&’D+"& %@F!
E"#? &"+?+ ?"C%D",.
K!$@!' !!@! '"#C D EF$$ #E& ! !D@?*
#* E!&% &D<$# #$!#!&! E!D!&* E! ?"+&"C"; H+*.
V' E$', M! EF'I$A# ! !D@?* #*!' * #E&"
E! ?"+&"C"; H+*, I &#!&!+ C"!?A!@! H+* +,
M!! !C"?A!#$" ?"+&"C", H+* $ &"E!&""#$A D#$!#*&
E!C%* ?"+&"C", D H!+* C"!?A!@! H+* +, &'!-
@' T+!*.
#&!I'* "R%" #* E!&% E"$&%$ +$** ?"+&"-
$! H! ED<$ $+!@!, M! &"E!&"I &'!@' T+!*.
V!; E"#$&!; &"=?% +$* ?"+&"$!, ED-
<%!@! C"!?A' H+!' +,, '!J% H*$ &"#$A +!-
?"+$* "$%%#"&, +F #$& &"!'F #**.
!D@? #E&
& #*" M!! ?"+&"C", H+* % D*EI "?A-
!#$" ?"+&"$!, ED<%!@! C"!?A' H+!' +,.
K!C%* ?"+&"C", H+* E!& H*$ D&%R% % E"D"-
R% $A!= !+"& D &"+?+ H+"&#A+!, ?"C%D",.
C"!?AF H+ +, 'I E&! E!!&J*&$ E!C%-
** ?"+&"C", H+"& $%'" ! !!@! !+*, ##$%'!*$&!-
;;<= H+"& — $%'" ! &!= !+"&.
"+&"$!!' D"F#;I$A# !E*H?"+*& &"!'!#$%F E! &"-
+$$ ?"+&"C"F!, E!C%* * @D%$" «!&F +*’I» <
«!?!# +,» D =*!+ H+* * #$!+, E%%H<%" D+!-
' +,, D EF$$ C"!?A' H+!' +, "-
R% E! &"+?+ ?"C%D", H! &?#+!' H+* "R%
E! ?"+&"C"; H+*.
"!'!#$" E! &"+$$ ?"+&"C"F!, E!C%* E!&" '"#$-
$ F'%*& $ "R" %+&"D$ H+*, M! ?"+&"*I$A#, $*
EF$$ C"!?A' H+!' +, "R% E! &"+?+
?"C%D", H! $* EF$$ "R% &?#+ H+* E! ?"+&"C";
H+* " ED<% ?"+&"$!, &"!'!#$" E! ?"+&"$!.
K!$@!' !!@! '"#C D !E*H?"+*& !@!?!R% E!
&"+$$ ?"+&"C"F!, E!C%* +%$! ';$A E&! D&-
135
$ ?"+&"$!* E! #&!, &'!@ ! H+*. % !D&!?I$A# !E*H?"-
+*& H! !D@!?!R% "R' <!' &"!'!#$%F E! %E?$!-
#E!'!J"#$A H+* ! EF$$ "R% E! F!@! ?"+&"-
C";. #!H, &" * !D@!?!R%" !, "!'C",, %#*$A
&"E!&"?A"#$A D@"! D D+!' +,.
T+!!' &#$!&?%" #E%C"?A" &'!@ ! !#!H, + '!J%
H*$ ED<% ?"+&"$!!' H+*. +, ?"+&"$!!' '!J% H*-
$ ED<%!:
1) "D<* !#!H*, + &"E!&"I &'!@', M! &#*&;$A# T-
+!!' ! $'<#!&!@! '""#$$!;
2) ;<* !#!H*, + D"F#;I E!%#"F* "?A"#$A M!-
! $'<#!&!, '""#$C", $ ?"+&"C", H+"&, M!!
*$!#A+=, ;<= H! +!#?$@!&= E!#?*@ " 'I %
'%R% $A!= EC"&+"& D #%$"+$!' C"!?A!@! H+*
+, E&! D"F#% $'<#!&!, '""#$C", $ ?"+&"-
C", H+*.
TH!!I$A# ED<$ ?"+&"$!!' H+* "D<* H!
;<* !#!H*, + &+!*&? *+C", $'<#!&!@! '""#$-
$! * CA!'* H+*.
L"#!& &"E!&"?A"#$A, J$$ $ D!!&’ ?"+&"$!
';$A H*$ D#$=!&" D@"! D D+!!&#$&!' +, !'-
$&!-E&!&' +$' C"!?A!@! H+* +, $ !@!-
&!!'
E! ?"+&"C"; H+* &"E!&"! ! D+!*.
T EF$$ "R% E! &"+?+ ?"C%D", $ ED-
<% ?"+&"$!:
1) EE;$A# E!&!&J% D@?A= DH!"&, #E!#$%%J-
!, " E&?" ( %+$!"&) H+* $ $'<#!&!@! -
'""#$$!, +F %@F! E%%I ?"+&"$!* &#" #E&;
2) H+"&#A+ "?A"#$A H+* D&%R*I$A# D+"<%' $%=-
!?!@"<!@! C+?* +!+%$= !E%C"F * D", +M! C% #E$-
'% DH%%J%; H! DH"?AR%; ?"+&"C"F!, '#;
3) #$!+ &+! &#"= @!R!&= D!H!&’DA H+* $ D!-
H!&’D M!! #E?$ E!$+"& " DH!"& (!H!&’D+!&= E?$%-
J"&) &&JI$A# $+', M! #$&;
4) EEI$A# =*& E!C%$"&, %*#$!F+ (R$*,
E%") $ "R= %+!!'"<= #+C"F E! &#"= &= DH!@!&!#$"
H+*;
5) &"!'!#$" E! "#!&% #$!&M% H+* E%%#$;$A H*$
+!"%C"F' < #$!&$ H+"&#A+* $I'C;;
6) *+?% *@!, E!&’D= D &"<*J%' 'F H+* <
E%%<%; F!@! 'F $%$"' !#!H', !E*#+I$A# & E!+*,
E%%H<%!'* T+!!';
. .
136
7) #+#!&*;$A# %R$, +?%F 'F! (& $!'* <#?"
&?#" +!R$ H+* F!@! =*+=) H+*, < "R" !H'%J%
M!! !DE!J% F!@! 'F!'. +?% !&= %R$"&
H! "R= !H'%J%A M!! !DE!J% 'F!' H+*$ %
!E*#+I$A#;
8) &'!@ D D!H!&’D' H+*, M! &+? E" <# E!-
&%% ?"+&"C",, '!J*$A E%’&?$# $"?A+ & '%J= ?"+&"-
C"F!, E!C%*.
"+&"$! D #&!@! ED<% D"F#;I $+" E!&!&-
J%:
1) EF'I ! #&!@! &" 'F! H+*, &J&I D=!"& M!-
! DH%DE%<% F!@! DH%%J%;
2) &+!*I *+C", D *E&?" $ !DE!J% 'F!' H+*;
3) D"F#;I "&%$DC"; $ !C"+* 'F H+* D@"! D D-
+!!&#$&!';
4) &+!*I E!&!&J% !@"& *E&?" H+*;
5) !<!?;I ?"+&"C"F* +!'"#"; $ !'*I ?"+&"C"F* '#*;
6) E%’&?I ! $%$"= !#"H &'!@ M!! E!&%% %H"$!-
#A+!, DH!@!&!#$" H+*, * $!'* <#?" <%%D #*!&" !@;
7) 'I E&! !$'*&$ +%$ ? &E?$ &="!, !E!'!-
@ EC"&+', M! D&"?A;$A# &#?"!+ ?"+&"C", H+*, +F
&"R+!!&*I$A# & E%R* <%@* D =*!+ +!R$"&, !%J= &"
E!J* 'F H+*;
8) D &"+$$ ?"+&"C"F!, E!C%* E!&"!'?I EC"&-
+"& H+* E! D&"?A% $ D"F#;I F!@! &"E!&"! ! D+!-
!&#$& +, E! EC;;
9) D&?I & *#$!&?%!'* D+!!&#$&!' E!+* DE%%-
<% E! D&?%= ! H+* &'!@= +%$!"&;
10) D&?I &"'!&* &" &+! !@!&!"& $ & *#$!&?%-
!'* D+!!&#$&!' E!+* !D&I ,=;
11) &J&I D=!"&, #E'!&= &&?% $ E!&%%
'F H+*, M! D=!$A# * $%$"= !#"H;
12) E%%I * &#$!&?%!'* E!+* DH%"@ !+*'%$
H+*, +" &"E!&"! ! !'$&!-E&!&= +$"& E"?@;$A
!H!&’D+!&!'* DH%"@;;
13) &J&I D=!"&, +", F!@! *'+*, *$A '!J?&"#$A
!$'$ '+#'?A* &*<+* &" E!J* +$&"& * F+!!$-
RF #$!+;
14) %?"D*I 'F! H+* ? D!&!?% &'!@, &+?;<%= !
%I#$* &'!@ +%$!"&;
15) E!&"!'?I E! #&!I ED<% %J&F !@ D E$A
H+*$#$& & %#$%F #$!+ D EF$$ "R% $
137
I %J&!'* !@* D E$A H+*$#$& "!'C"; ?
&%% I!, HD = M!! E"EI'#$&-H+*$"&;
16) D"F#;I "R" E!&!&J%, E%%H<%" T+!!'.
T ED<% ?"+&"$! ! A!@! E%%=!$A E& +%-
"&+ (!@"& *E&?") H+*. K!$@!' $A!= "& D
ED<% ?"+&"$! +%"&+ H+* DH%DE%<*;$A E%%<*
H*=@?$%#A+!, $ "R!, !+*'%$C", H+*, E%<$!+ " R$'E"&,
'$%"?A= $ "R= C"!#$%F H+* ?"+&"$!*. D" *=-
?% &" &+! DD<%= !H!&’D+"& &" !#!H %#*$A
&"E!&"?A"#$A &"E!&"! ! &'!@ <!@! D+!!&#$&
+,.
K &+!" #&!,= !H!&’D+"& ?"+&"$! D #&!,' #$$*#!'
E"&;I$A# ! E%#$&+ C"!?A!@! H+* +,.
*A-+ !#!H, M! &'#! E%%R+!JI !#$*E* ?"+&"$!
! H+*, F!@! +$&"&, +@, DE#"&, !+*'%$"&, %#% '""#$-
$&* H! +'"?A* &"E!&"?A"#$A D@"! D D+!!&#$-
&!'. K&!!=!!" !@ D!H!&’D" &$ !E!'!@* ?"+&"-
$!* & F!@! !H!$" E"#$&" E#A'!&!@! D&%%.
"+&"$! EEI EF' &'!@ +%$!"& E"#? D+"-
<% !!@! '"#C D !E*H?"+*& !@!?!R% E! E!<-
$!+ ?"+&"C"F!, E!C%*.
"+&"$! E!$@!' $A!= '"#C"& D !E*H?"+*& !@!-
?!R% E! E!<$!+ ?"+&"C"F!, E!C%* D"F#;I $+" D-
=! M!! D!&!?% &'!@ +%$!"&:
1) &D<I #*'* DH!@!&!#$" +!J!'* +%$!* $ &"!-
#$A &'!@ ! E%&!, <%@ E!@R%;
2) &"=?I &'!@ * D" ,= %E"$&%J%;
3) &"E!&"! ! &'!@ !'$&!-E&!&= +$"& L!* @-
$*& &+?"& "D<= !#"H I L!* E!$@!' &C-
$ !H!<= "& "D #$ %!#$*E!#$" &+?"& E!&F
E%%?"+ &+?+"&, +" ';$A E&! &"R+!*& +!R$"& D
&+?', "D &D<%' ,= !D=*+!&!, #*', M! E"?@I &"-
R+!*&;;
4) #+?I E%%?"+ +C%E$!&= ' &'!@ ? D$&%J%
C"!?A' H+!' +,;
5) #E!&"MI +%$!"& E! +C%E$*& &'!@;
6) M!$J E!$@!' $A!= $J"& E*H?"+*I !@!?!R% E!
%A " '"#C%, % '!J !DF!'$# D E%%?"+!' &'!@, $ E!
$* E! CA!@! E%%?"+* C"!?A!'* H+* +,.
%$! ';$A E&! "#?$ ?"+&"$!* #&!, DE%%<%-
M!! &D= ' &'!@ E!$@!' !!@! '"#C D !$-
' E!&"!'?%.
. .
138
"+&"$! 'I E&! D !D&!?* C"!?A!@! H+* +,
E!@R$ &'!@ ! H+* ! '!'%$* D&%R% #+? E%-
%?"+* &'!@ $ F!@! D$&%J% C"!?A' H+!' +,-
?R% D *@!', M! DH%DE%<*;$A D"F#% ?"+&"C"F!,
E!C%*.
"+&"$! D!H!&’DF * &!'"#<F #$!+ D ED-
<% "#?$ E!&"!'?% &#"' +?"I$', +" +!#$*;$A#
E!#?*@' &"E!&"?A!@! DH%"@, E! %!H=""#$A &?*<-
$ #&!, C"!#$" E!$@!' $A!= '"#C"& D !@!?!R% E!
E!<$!+ ?"+&"C"F!, E!C%*.
$%"?A" C"!#$", M! E%%H*&? &"E!&"?A!'* DH%-
"@" H+* " % H*? &?*<%" &?#+' & DD<%F * E!&"-
!'?%" #$!+, &&J;$A# !', +" % '!J*$A E%$%-
*&$ +%$! H+*. " C"!#$" E%%=!$A * !DE!J%
C"!?A!@! H+* +, ? E!&%% D+!' &?#-
+'.
F!, +% D&%$I$A# #$@% * ?"+&"C"F"F E!C%*-
", !C";I$A# ?"+&"$!!' * E!+*, &#$!&?%!'* D+!!&-
#$&!' +,. ? 'F, +% E!I$A# *+C"!", !C"!<
&$"#$A I E!<$+!&!;.
? D"F#% !C"+ 'F ?"+&"$! 'I E&! D?*<$
E"#$&" !@!&!* #E%C"?"#$"& D !E?$!; ,= E!#?*@ D =*!+ ?"-
+&"C"F!, '#, +M! "R% % &#$!&?%! C"!?A' H-
+!' +,.
K"#? E!&%% "&%$DC", $ !C"+ 'F H+* ?"+&"-
$! !DE!<I E!J 'F &"+$= $!@=, +M! C"-
!?A' H+!' +, % &#$!&?%! "RF E!!+ F!@!
E!J*.
K!!+ E!J* 'F H+*, #+?, *'!& $ #$!+ E-
H 'F E!@!J*;$A# D C"!?A' H+!' +, $
E!&"!'?;$A# <%%D D#!H '#!&!, "!'C",.
D" =!J% &!= " H"?AR% E!E!DC"F M!! EH
'F H+* ?"+&"$! E!&!$A +!+*# (*+C"!). K!!+
E!&%% +!+*#* (*+C"!*) &D<I$A# D@"! "D D+!!-
&#$&!' +,.
F! H+*, M!! !H"@* +!@! &#$!&?%! !H'%J%, E!-
I$A# D+$= $!@=
. D+$= $!@= H%*$A *<#$A !#!-
H, +" &"E!&"! ! D+!!&#$& '!J*$A '$ DD<%% 'F!
* &?#!#$" < E"#$&" "R!@! %<!&!@! E& &"E!&"! !
C&"?A!@! D+!!&#$& +,.
K!!+ *#$*E+ &'!@ H+* %@*?;I$A# C&"?A' D+!!-
&#$&!' +,.
139
"+&"$! 'I E&! &#$&$ &"+$" $!@ C"" EE%
$ &'!@ H+*, +M! "RF #E!#"H E!J* (*#$*E+) &'!@
H+* % &#$!&?%! C"!?A' H+!' +,.
!R$, !%J" & %D*?A$$" ?"+&"C"F!, E!C%*, #E-
'!&*;$A# D!&!?% &'!@ +%$!"& * $+"F <%@!&!#$":
1) * E%R* <%@* D!&!?A;$A#:
) &'!@, DH%DE%<%" D#$&!;;
H) &'!@ L!* @$*& &+?"& "D<= !#"H, M! &-
+? * &E+=, &D<%= D+!!&#$&!' E! @$*&
&+?"& "D<= !#"H;
&) &E?$ &="!, !E!'!@ D&"?A%' EC"&+' H+*,
* $!'* <#?" &"R+!*& +%$*, !$'!@! C" C"?";
@) &$$, E!&’D" D !H!$!; ?"+&"$!, & $!'* <#?":
x !E?$* %J&!@! '$;
x E*H?"+C"; !@!?!R% E! ?"+&"C"; H+*;
x E*H?"+C"; & !@= "!'C", E! E!!+ E!J*
'F H+*;
x &$$ ?"+&"$!, E!&’D" D *$'' " DH%%J%'
+$&"& H+*;
x E!&%% *$*;
x !E?$* EC" EC"&+"&, D?*<%= ? D"F#% ?"+-
&"C",;
) D!H!&’D, M! &+? &#?"!+ DE!" R+! J$-
$; $
D!!&’; @!'.
K%%?"<%" &$$ &"R+!!&*;$A# E"#? %?"DC", ?"+&"-
$!!' <#$ ?"+&"C"F!, '#, +M! "R% % E%%H<%! T-
+!!';
2) * *@* <%@* D!&!?A;$A# &'!@ &+?+"& — "D-
<= !#"H & <#$" E%%&M% #*', E%%H<%!, ##$%'!;
@$*& &+?"& "D<= !#"H, &'!@, M! &+? "D D!-
H!&’DA H+* E%% EC"&+';
3) * $%$;
<%@* D!&!?A;$A# "R" &'!@.
'!@ +!J!, #$*E!, <%@ D!&!?A;$A# & '"* -
=!J% =*!+ +!R$"& &" E!J* 'F H+* E"#? E!&-
!@! D!&!?% &'!@ E!E%%A!, <%@.
D" %!#$$!#$" +!R$"&, !%J= &" E!J* 'F
H+*$, ? E!&!@! D!&!?% &#"= &'!@ !"I, <%@ &'!-
@ D!&!?A;$A# E!E!C"F! #*'" &'!@, M! ?%J$A +!J-
!'* +%$!!&" !"I, <%@.
D" &"'!& +%$! &" D!&!?% &D!, & *#$!&-
?%!'* E!+* &'!@ ?"+&"$! % &=!&*I #*'* @!R!&=
&'!@ CA!@! +%$!.
. .
140
'!@, D&?%" E"#? D+"<% #$!+*, &#$!&?%!@! ?
,= E!, % !D@?;$A# " &&J;$A# E!@R%'.
'!@, % D!&!?%" D %!#$$"#$; 'F, &&J;$A#
E!@R%'.
D", +M! '!'%$ D+"<% #$!+* ?"+&"C", D?R?#
%E!' +$& H+* " %@FF E!J '$'% #?"+!' "#-
$!$* &$$* ,= &$!#$", ?"+&"$! E%%I $+" +$& & *E&?"-
&D<%"F C"!?A' H+!' +, ;<"F !#!H", +
D!H!&’D &J$ D=!"& M!! E!!&J% E!@R% DH!@!-
&!#$" +%$!"& H+* D =*!+ !$'= +$&"&.
F!, M! D?R?!# E"#? D!&!?% &'!@ +%$!"&,
E%%I$A# &?#+', 'F! %J&= H+"& — &"E!&"!-
'* !@* E&$DC", ? #$*E!@! E!J*. !R$, !%J-
" &" E!J* CA!@! 'F, #E'!&*;$A# ! %J&!@! H;-
J%$* +,.
F! +!!E%$&= H+"&, M! D?R?!# E"#? D!&!-
?% E!$%H +%$!"&, E"?@I &+!#$; &"E!&"! !
D+!!&#$& +, E! +!!E%C";.
"+&"C" H+* &&JI$A# D&%R%!;, H+ ?"+&"!&'
D '!'%$* &%#% DE#* E! C% ! %J&!@! %I#$* H+"&
E"#? *=&?% D&"$* ?"+&"$!.
+%'" E!?!J% D+!!&#$& E#&<%" ?"+&"C", H-
+"&#A+=
!H’IA. +, H+"&#A+% !H’I ?"+&"*I$A# D
"R%' F!@! *<#+"& H! D ""C"$& C"!?A!@! H+*
+, D "R%' #** * D", +M! "?A"#$A $+!@! H+"&-
#A+!@! !H’I #*E%%<$A $'!!E!?A!'* D+!!&#$&*
+, H! D@!J*I "$%%#' &+?+"& H+"& < #$H"?A!#-
$" H+"&#A+!, ##$%'. "+&"C" H+"&#A+!@! !H’I %
EEI "?A!#$" H+"& — F!@! *<#+"&.
5
1. %'" «%@*?;&» E! &"!R%; ! H+"&#A+!, "?A!#$"
'!J !D@?$ * R!+!'* $ * &*DA+!'* !D*'"". R!+!'*
!D*'"" %J&% %@*?;& & #%" H+"&#A+!, "?A!#$" +D "
&+?;<I &#; ##$%'* D=!"&, +" &J&;$A# *E!&!&J%' !@-
' %J& ? DH%DE%<% #$?!@! $ "F!@! *+C"!*& H-
+"&#A+!@! #%+$!*. &*DA+!'* !D*'"" H+"&#A+% %@*?;&
—
C% "?A"#$A *E!&!&J%= !@"&, + E!?@I * &" E&!&=
+$"& * #%" H+"&#A+!, "?A!#$".