Ващенко Ю.В. Банківське право
Подождите немного. Документ загружается.
161
"; ?%@?"DC", (&"'&;) !=!"&, !%J= D?!<-
' R?=!'» E!#$!&!; K&?" C"!?A!@! H+*
+, &" 14 $& 2003 . - 189 D$&%J%! K!?!J%
E! D"F#% H+' "#!&!@! '!"$!@* (?" — K!-
?!J%).
T@"! D K!?!J%' &"E!&"?A' D !@"DC"; &+!-
&'!@ D+!!&#$& +, D E$A DE!H"@ ?%@?"DC",
(&"'&;) !=!"&, !%J= D?!<' R?=!', $ !@"-
DC"; &*$"RA!H+"&#A+!, ##$%' DE!H"@ ?%@?"DC", (&"-
'&;) !=!"&, !%J= D?!<' R?=!', I +%"&+
H+*.
"E!&"! ! #$$$" 63 T+!* +, «K! H+ " H+"&-
#A+* "?A"#$A» H+ D!H!&’D" !D!H?$, &E!&J*&$ $
E!#$"F! E!!&?;&$ E&? &*$"RA!@! "#!&!@! '!"-
$!@* $ E!@' F!@! D"F#% D *=*&' &'!@ D+!-
!&#$& E! DE!H"@ ?%@?"DC", (&"'&;) !=!"&, !%-
J= D?!<' R?=!'. TD<%" !+*'%$ I !+*'%$'
D !H'%J%' !#$*E!'. K!!+ $ %J' !#$*E* ! = E-
C"&+"& H+* &D<I$A# &"E!&"?A' EC"&+!' H+*
("?",) D?%J! &" ,= *+C"!?A= !H!&’D+"& D E!@!J%'
D +%"&+!' H+* ("?",).
K&? &*$"RA!@! "#!&!@! '!"$!@* !D!H?-
;$A# H+!' D *=*&' &'!@ D+!"& +,, M! %@*?;-
;$A E$ DE!H"@ $ E!$", ?%@?"DC", (&"'&;) !-
=!"&, !%J= D?!<' R?=!', CA!@! K!?!J%,
!'$&!-E&!&= +$"& C"!?A!@! H+* +,, +$"&
E!&!&J%!@! !@*, EF$= &+! $ &"E!&"!
! C= D+!"&, %+!'%C"F *E D !D!H+ "#!&= D=!-
"& H!!$AH D &"'&' @!R%F, D%?A#A+!@! +!'"$%$* H-
+"&#A+!@! @?*.
K!@' D"F#%
"#!&!@! '!"$!@* !D!H?;$A#
$ %?"D*;$A# H+!' ? DH%DE%<% *+C"!*& &*$-
"RA!H+"&#A+!, ##$%' DE!H"@ ?%@?"DC", (&"'&;)
!=!"&, !%J= D?!<' R?=!'. K!@' D"F#%
"#!&!@! '!"$!@* !D!H?;$A# H+!' &"E!&"! !
!+%'= E'"& F!@! "?A!#$" D !H#?*@!&*& +?"I$"& " E!-
$%H*;$A E!#$"F!@! !!&?% & E!C%#" E!&%% "#!&!-
@! '!"$!@*.
K!@' D"F#% "#!&!@! '!"$!@* ';$A '"#$$
&D<%" D+!!&#$&!' +, !D+ "#!&= !E%C"F,
+" E"?@;$A "#!&!'* '!"$!@*, "R" !D+ $+= !E%-
C"F, +" &"E!&"! ! #E%C"+ $ E'"& "?A!#$" #'!#-
. .
162
$"F! &D<;$A# $ E!!&?;;$A# H+!' E!#$"F"F !#!&",
$+!J D *=*&' &"E!&"!@! !&"+, !'*& $
&%#% D'" ! +!@! D"F#;I$A# E!&!&J%' !@!' D
E!@!J%' D C"!?A' H+!' +,.
K!?!J%' C"!?A!@! H+* +, &D<%" !H!&’D-
+!&" %+&"D$ E&? $ E!@' "#!&!@! '!"$!@*.
,
*(%%
H!&’D!+ H+"& E!&!$ "%$"+C"; !#"H, +" D"F#;-
;$A "#!&" !E%C",, D+"E?%F * T+!" +, «K! DE!-
H"@ $ E!$"; ?%@?"DC", (&"'&;) !=!"&, !%J=
D?!<' R?=!'» $ * T+!" +, «K! H+ " H+"&#A+*
"?A"#$A».
T@"! "D T+!!' «K! DE!H"@ $ E!$"; ?%@?"DC",
(&"'&;) !=!"&, !%J= D?!<' R?=!'» #*H’I+$
E%&!@! "#!&!@! '!"$!@* E"#$&" = !@"-
?"& H! ?%J' <!' D&"%= +!E"F !+*'%$"& "%$"-
+*I !#"H, +" D"F#;;$A "#!&" !E%C",, M! D@"! D C' T-
+!!' E"?@;$A "#!&!'* '!"$!@*.
T '%$!; "%$"+C", %D%$"& &D<;$A#:
x ? "D<= !#"H — E"D&M%, "'’ $ E! H$A+!&", $ -
!J%, #%" $ !'% E#E!$ (H! "R!@! !+*'%$, +F
E!#&"<*I !#!H*), $ &<" $ !@, M! F!@! &&, '"#C% E!-
J&, "%$"+C"FF !'% D@"! D %J&' %I#$!'
"D<= !#"H — E?$+"& E!$+"& $ "R= !H!&’D+!&= E?-
$%J"&;
x ? ;<= !#"H — F'%*&, ;< %#,
!+*'%$ E! E"$&%J% %J&!, %I#$C", (&+?;<;-
< *#$!&<" !+*'%$, "!'C"; M!! E!#!&= !#"H $ ,=
E!&!&J%A $!M!), "%$"+C"FF +! D@"! D V'
%J&' %I#$!' E"EI'#$& $ !@"DC"F +,, %+-
&"D$ H+*, & +!'* &"+$! =*!+, $ !'% H+"&#A+!@!
=*+*.
T '%$!; "%$"+C", %%D%$"& &D<;$A#:
x ? "D<= !#"H — E"D&M%, "'’, E! H$A+!&" (* D" F!@!
&!#$"), $ !J%, #%" $ !'% E#E!$ (H! "R!@!
!+*'%$, +F E!#&"<*I !#!H*), $ &<" $ !@, M! F!@!
&&, @!'#$&!, '"#C% E!J& H! $'<#!&!@! E%%H*-
&;
163
x ? ;<= !#"H — E!&% F'%*&, '"#C%D=!-
J% $ %+&"D$ H+*, * +!'* &"+$! =*!+, " !'% H-
+"&#A+!@! =*+*. *H’I+$* E%&!@! "#!&!@! '!"$!-
@* I$A# $+!J +!E" ?%@?"D!&!@! &$@* $!@!&%?A!@!,
H+"&#A+!@! < #*!&!@! %I#$* H! D#&"<%% !$"?A! %-
I#$C"F% E!#&"<% *E!&!&J%!@! !@* "!D%'!, %J-
& E! %I#$C"; &"E!&"!, ;<!, !#!H.
%$"+C" !#!H % I !H!&’D+!&!; * D" D"F#% "-
#!&!, !E%C", !#!H', M! "R% H*? "%$"+!&", H!
*+?% *@! '"J H+', D%I#$!&' & +,".
D", +M! !#!H "I + E%#$&+ "R!, !#!H, H! *
#*H’I+$ E%&!@! "#!&!@! '!"$!@* &+I #*'"&
#$!#!&! $!@!, M! !#!H &#$*EI &" &?#!@! "'%" H! &@!!!-
%J*&<%' I "R !#!H, #*H’I+$ E%&!@! "#!&!@! '!"-
$!@* D!H!&’DF D E&?' C"I, #$$$" $ E!?!J%A "R=
D+!"&, +" %@*?;;$A C; E!C%**, "%$"+*&$ $+!J !#!-
H*, &" "'%" +!, D"F#;I$A# "#!& !E%C" H! + I &@!-
!!%J*&<%'.
K%% H! E"#? D"F#% "#!&!, !E%C", #*H’I+$ E%-
&!@! "#!&!@! '!"$!@* D’#!&*I '!J?&"#$A &"%#%-
,, ! "#!&!, !E%C",, M! &"E!&"! ! T+!* E"?@I
"#!&!'* '!"$!@*. D" &&?% $+!, "#!&!,
!E%C", &! E"?@I %I#$C", &"E!&"' #*H’I+$!' E%&-
!@! "#!&!@! '!"$!@*. ? CA!@! & %I#$" "+#*I$A#
!#!H, M! D"F#;I "#!&* !E%C";, & "#!&!, !E%C",
$ E"#$& ? ,, D"F#%, $ $ #*'. K!!+ %I#$C",
"#!&!, !E%C",, M! &"E!&"! ! T+!* E"?@I "#!-
&!'* '!"$!@*, &#$!&?;I$A# ? H+"& — C"!?A'
H+!' +,, ? "R= #*H’I+$"& "#!&!@! '!"$!@*
— H"%$!' ""#$"& +,.
*H’I+$ E%&!@! "#!&!@! '!"$!@* 'I E&! &"'!-
&$# &" DH%DE%<% D"F#% "#!&!, !E%C", * D" &#$-
!&?%, M! C "#!& !E%C" '"#$$A !D+ $+!,, M! D@"!
D T+!!' E"?@I "#!&!'* '!"$!@*, $ D!H!&’DF "%-
$"+*&$ " E!&"!'$ E!&!&J%F !@ E! !#"H, M! D"F#-
;;$A DD<%* "#!&* !E%C";, $ ,, =+$%.
T@"! D" #$$$%; 64 T+!* +, «K! H+ " H+"&#A+*
"?A"#$A» H+' DH!!I$A# &"+&$ $ &%#$ !"'"
(!'%") =*+. +' DH!!I$A# &#$*E$ & !@!&""
&"!# D +?"I$' — ;<' < "D<' !#!H' *
D", +M! &+I #*'"& #$!#!&! $!@!, M! !#!H &#$*EI %
&" &?#!@! "'%".
. .
164
+ D!H!&’DF "%$"+*&$ &"E!&"! ! D+!!&#$-
& +,:
x +?"I$"&, M! &"+&;$A =*+ & H+*;
x +?"I$"&, +" D"F#;;$A !E%C",, M! E"?@;$A "#!-
&!'* '!"$!@*;
x +?"I$"&, M! D"F#;;$A !E%C", D @!$"&+!; H%D &"+$$
=*+*, #*'*, M! E%%&M*I %+&"&?%$ 50000 @&%A;
x !#"H, *E!&!&J%= "$ &" "'%" DD<%= +?"I$"&.
=*!+ +?"I$* &"+&I$A# $ DD<%" !E%C", D"F#;-
;$A# ?R% E"#? E!&%% "%$"+C", !#!H +?"I$"& $
&J$$ D=!"& &"E!&"! ! D+!!&#$&, +% %@*?;I &"!-
# * #%" DE!H"@ ?%@?"DC", (&"'&;) !=!"&, !%-
J= D?!<' R?=!'.
+ 'I E&! &$%H*&$, +?"I$ D!H!&’DF $ !-
+*'%$ " &"!'!#$", %!H="" ? D’#*& F!@! !#!H, #*$" "-
?A!#$", "#!&!@! #$*. D" % +?"I$!' %!H="-
= !+*'%$"& < &"!'!#$%F H! *'#!@! E!
%E&&= &"!'!#$%F E! #%H% H+ &"'!&?I +?"I$* * F!@!
!H#?*@!&*&". D" &!#$" E D"F#%" "%$"+C",
'!$&!&!, E"!D M!! +?"I$!' %!#$!&"!, "!-
'C", H! &'#!@! E! "!'C", D '%$!; &&%% &
!'* H+ 'I &$ "!'C"; E! "#!&" !E%C", +?"-
I$ #E%C"?A! *E!&!&J%!'* !@* &+!&<!, &? D E-
$A "#!&!@! '!"$!@*.
? "%$"+C", +?"I$ — ;<!, !#!H H+ 'I "%-
$"+*&$ "D<= !#"H, +" I &?#+' C"I, ;<!, !#!H,
';$A E'F H! !E!#%%+!&F &E?& %, $ !$'*;$A
%+!!'"<* &@!* &" ,, "?A!#$". D", +M! ;< !#!H
I @!#E!#A+' $!&#$&!', H+ 'I "%$"+*&$ "D<=
!#"H, +" ';$A "#$!$* *<#$A * C"F ;<"F !#!H". ?"I$ 'I
&$ E%%H<%" D+!!&#$&!' &"!'!#$", +" &$%H*I
H+ D '%$!; &+! &'!@ D+!!&#$&, +% %@*?;I &"!-
# * #%" DE!H"@ ?%@?"DC", (&"'&;) !=!"&, !%-
J= D?!<' R?=!'. D" % $+= &"!'!#$%F
+?"I$!' =*!+ % &"+&I$A#, & D" &!#$" "R% &"-
+$= =*+"& H+ &"'!&?I & D"F#%" !H#?*@!&*&.
? "%$"+C", " &J$$ D=!"&, !#$$"=, *'+* H+*,
? E"$&%J% !#!H +?"I$ — ;<!, !#!H $ ? D-
H%DE%<% #E!'!J!#$" H+* &+!*&$ E&? &*$"RA!-
@! "#!&!@! '!"$!@* $ E!@' F!@! D"F#%, * $!'*
<#?" M!! &&?% "#!&= !E%C"F, M! ';$A #*'"&F
=+$%, H+ 'I E&! &$%H*&$ E%%H<%* D+!!&#$-
165
&!' "!'C";, + #$!#*I$A# "%$"+C", C"I, !#!H $ ,, +%-
"&+"&, * !@"& %J&!, &?, +" D"F#;;$A @?
$/H! +!$!?A D "?A"#$; C"I, ;<!, !#!H, H+"&, "-
R= ;<= !#"H, $+!J D"F#;&$ E%%H<%" D+!!-
&#$&!' D=! M!! DH!* $+!, "!'C", D "R= J%%?.
+D" !@ %J&!, &?, H+, "R" ;<" !#!H D!-
H!&’D" E!$@!' %#$ !H!<= "& D !$' DE$*
H%D!E?$! $ H+* $+* "!'C";.
? "%$"+C", +?"I$ — "D<!, !#!H $ &J$$ D=!-
"&, !#$$"=, *'+* H+*, ? E"$&%J% F!@! !#!H,
H+ 'I E&! &$%H*&$ "!'C";, + #$!#*I$A# "%-
$"+C", C"I, !#!H, * !@"& %J&!, &?, H+"&, "R=
;<= !#"H, $+!J D"F#;&$ D=! M!! DH!* $+!,
"!'C", E! C; !#!H*, + I %!H="!; ? &+! E-
&? &*$"RA!@! "#!&!@! '!"$!@* $ E!@' F!@!
D"F#%, * $!'* <#?" M!! &&?% "#!&= !E%C"F,
M! ';$A #*'"&F =+$%. +D" !@ %J&!, &?-
, H+, "R" ;<" !#!H D!H!&’D" E!$@!' %#$
!H!<= "& D !$' DE$* H%D!E?$! $ H+*
$+* "!'C";.
%$"+C" +?"I$ H+* % I !H!&’D+!&!; E D"F#%"
+!J!, !E%C",, +M! +?"I$ H*& "R% "%$"+!&F &"E!-
&"! ! &'!@ D+!!&#$&, +% %@*?;I &"!# * #%" D-
E!H"@ ?%@?"DC", (&"'&;) !=!"&, !%J= D?!<-
' R?=!'.
T &!#$" "R% *E!&!&J%!@! %J&!@! !@* E!
#+#*& %J&!, %I#$C", ;<!, !#!H H! %J&!,
%I#$C", #*H’I+$ E"EI'CA+!, "?A!#$" — "D<!, !#!-
H, &D & *#$!&?%!'* E!+* ;<!, !#!H "+$&-
!; H! !@!?!R% "D<!, !#!H E!'%?!; < &D H%D-
&"#! &"#*$A!; H+ D+&I =*!+ $+!, !#!H " %&"-
+?! I "!'C"; #E%C"?A! *E!&!&J%!'* !@*
&+!&<!, &? D E$A "#!&!@! '!"$!@* M!! $-
+!@! =*+* $ % E%%=!&*I < "R' R?=!' % !DE!-
JI$A# +!R$' CA!'* =*+* ! !$' !DE!-
J%A DD<%!@! !@*. &E+* %=!J% E!$@!'
#%' !H!<= "& DD<%= !DE!J%A H! "R% #**
#$!#!&! &J$$ < %&J$$ D=!"& M!! C= +!R$"& H+
&"R*I E!&’D" D ' E$ &"E!&"! ! D+!!&#$&
+,.
T@"! D &M%DD<%' K!?!J%' C"!?A!@! H+*
+, ? DH%DE%<% ?%J!, %?"DC", *+C"F #*H’I+$
. .
166
E%&!@! "#!&!@! '!"$!@* H+ #$&!;I K!@'*
"%$"+C", " &&<% +?"I$"& H+*, + #'E%% 'I
&+?;<$:
) E!!+ D"F#% "%$"+C", +?"I$ E" <# &#$!&-
?% &"!# D ';
H) D=! M!! *$!<% "!'C", E! +?"I$ $ E!!+
,= E!&%%;
&) E!!+ DH%DE%<% !+*'%$?A!@! "+#*& "!-
'C", E! +?"I$;
@) E!!+ $ +$%", +?#"+C", +?"I$"& &"E!&"! ! !C"-
+ D+* D"F#% ' !E%C"F, M! '!J*$A H*$ E!&’D"
D ?%@?"DC"I; (&"'&') !=!"&, !%J= D?!<'
R?=!', H! "#*&' $%!D'*;
_) E!!+ E!&%% D=!"& M!! E%%&"+ "!'C", E!
+?"I$ H! !#!H*, + "I &" F!@! "'%", * D" &+% #*'-
"&* M!! ,, !#$!&"!#$", D *=*&' D+* E!&%% $-
+' +?"I$!' !E%C"F D ?%@?"DC", !=!"&, !%J= D?!<-
' R?=!';
) D=! M!! !$+!&!@! &&<% +?"I$ $ E!!+ ,=
E!&%%.
*
K!!+ E!&!&J%!'* !@* "!'C", E! "-
#!&* !E%C";, M! E"?@I !H!&’D+!&!'* "#!&!'* '!"-
$!@*, &#$!&?;I$A# &"E!&"! C"!?A' H+!' +-
, — ? H+"&.
"!'C", #*H’I+$' E%&!@! "#!&!@! '!"-
$!@* E!&!&J%!'* !@* & *#$!&?%!'* E!+* % I
E!*R%' H+"&#A+!, H! +!'%C"F!, $I'C".
*H’I+$ E%&!@! "#!&!@! '!"$!@*, ,= E!#!&"
!#!H $ "R" EC"&+ % %#*$A #CE?"*, '""#$$-
&*, C&"?A!-E&!&* $ +'"?A* &"E!&"?A"#$A D -
E!&!&J%!'* !@* "!'C", E! "#!&* !E%C";,
+M! &! "? & '%J= T+!*, &"$A +M! $+' "' DE!-
"! R+!* ;<' H! "D<' !#!H', $ D "R" ",,
E!&’D" D &+!' T+!*.
KC"&+' #*H’I+$"& E%&!@! "#!&!@! '!"$!@*,
+" "#?? E!&!&J%!'* !@* E!&"!'?% E! "-
#!&* !E%C";, M! E"?@I D@"! D T+!!' "#!&!'* '!"-
167
$!@*, DH!!I$A# E!&"!'?$ E! C% !#"H, +" D"F#;;$A
"#!&* !E%C";, $ H*A-+= $%$"= !#"H.
#?"!+ E!*R% C"I, &'!@ EC"&+' #*H’I+$"& E%-
&!@! "#!&!@! '!"$!@* #$*EI &"E!&"?A"#$A,
E%%H<% D+!' +,.
&E+*, +!? * EC"&+"& #*H’I+$ E%&!@! "#!-
&!@! '!"$!@*, +F D"F#;I "#!&* !E%C";, &+;$A
'!$&!&" E"!D, M! "#!& !E%C" D"F#;I$A# D '%$!;
?%@?"DC", (&"'&) !=!"&, #*H’I+$ E%&!@! "#!&!@!
'!"$!@* D!H!&’DF &$ E!&!&J%!'* !@* "-
!'C"; E! $+* "#!&* !E%C";.
&E+*, +!? #*H’I+$ E%&!@! "#!&!@! '!"$!@*,
+" D"F#;;$A "#!&" !E%C",, E"!D;;$A H! E!&" H*? H
E"!D;&$, M! $+" "#!&" !E%C", E!&’D", ';$A &"!R%-
H! ED<%" ? "#*& $%!#$<!, "?A!#$", $%!-
#$<= +$"& < $%!#$<= !@"DC"F, &! D!H!&’D" %-
@F! E!&"!'$ E! $+" "#!&" !E%C", E!&!&J%F !@
$ E&!!=!!" !@, &D<%" D+!!&#$&!'.
!'C", M! E%%I$A# D@"! D &'!@' CA!@! T+!*, I
$+!;, M! 'I !H'%J%F !#$*E. H'" DD<%!; "!'C"-
I;, ,, !D+$$ $ D=#$ E!&!&J%' !@!', #*H’I+$'
E%&!@! "#!&!@! '!"$!@*, !@' &+!&<!, &?-
$ C"!?A!@! H+* +,, +" &"E!&"! ! D+!!&-
#$& DH%DE%<*;$A %@*?;& $ @? D "?A"#$; #*H’I+$"&
E%&!@! "#!&!@! '!"$!@*, D"F#;I$A# &"E!&"!
! D+!!&#$&.
E!&!&J%!'* !@* DH!!%! E%%&$ H*A-+!'*
!%J* &" #*H’I+$"& E%&!@! "#!&!@! '!"$!@* "-
!'C";,
+ '"#$$A +!'%C"F* < H+"&#A+* $I'C;, D
&$+!' &E+"&, E%%H<%= #$$$%; 13 T+!*.
L"#!& !E%C", M! E"?@I !H!&’D+!&!'* "#!&!'*
'!"$!@*, M!! +!, !$' "!'C", !H?"+!&*I$A#
E!&!&J%' !@!'. K!!+ &D$$ !H?"+ "#!&!,
!E%C",, M! E"?@I !H!&’D+!&!'* "#!&!'* '!"$!@*,
&#$!&?;I$A# H"%$!' ""#$"& +,.
*H’I+$!' %J&!@! "#!&!@! '!"$!@* (D &$+!'
E!&!&J%!@!
!@*), M! &"E!&"! ! D+!!&#$& &+!-
*I *+C", %@*?;& $ @?* D H+' + #*H’I+$'
E%&!@! "#!&!@! '!"$!@*, &"!#$A# C"!?AF
H+ +,, +F D!H!&’DF:
x &'@$ &" #*H’I+$"& E%&!@! "#!&!@! '!"$!@*
&+! D&A $ !H!&’D+"&, E%%H<%= T+!!';
. .
168
x E!&!$ E%%&"+* #$* !@"DC", E!%#"F!, E"@!$!-
&+ EC"&+"& $ +%"&+"& E"!D"?"&, &"E!&"?A= D E!-
&%% &*$"RA!@! "#!&!@! '!"$!@*, &J&$ D=!-
"&, E%%H<%= T+!!';
x E" <# D"F#% @?* E%%&"$ &+! &'!@ +-
$"& D+!!&#$& D E$A DE!H"@ $ E!$", ?%@?"DC", (&"-
'&;) !=!"& $ "#*&; $%!D'*, &J&$ & *#$-
!&?%!'* D+!!&#$&!' E!+* D=!"&, E%%H<%=
T+!!';
x "!'*&$ E!&!&J%F !@ E! &&?%" &E+
E!*R% D+!!&#$& #*H’I+$' E%&!@! "#!&!@!
'!"$!@*;
x DH%DE%<*&$ DH%"@ "!'C",, !%J!, &"
#*H’I+$"& E%&!@! $ %J&!@! "#!&!@! '!"$!@* "
E&!!=!!= !@"&;
x E!@!J*&$ D E!&!&J%' !@!' H*A-+" !'$&"
!+*'%$, M! #$!#*;$A# E$A, E!&’D= D
&+!' &-
'!@ T+!*;
x &$ E!&!&J%!'* !@* "!'C"; " !+*'%$,
%!H="" ? &+! E!+?%= A!@! D&A (D &$-
+!' "!'C", M!! !#!H#$!@! J$$ @!'), * E!+*, &-
D<%!'* D+!!&#$&!'.
K!?!J%' C"!?A!@! H+* +, E! D"F#%
H+' "#!&!@! '!"$!@* &D<%! E!!+ %I#$C",
"#!&!, !E%C", $ "!'C", %J&!'* +!'"$%$*
D
"#!&!@! '!"$!@*. K%%H<%!, M! ?"D "#!&=
!E%C"F D '%$!; &&?% $+=, M! &"E!&"! ! D+!!&-
#$& +,, +% %@*?;I &"!# * #%" DE!H"@ ?%@?"-
DC", !=!"&, !%J= D?!<' R?=!', E"?@;$A "-
#!&!'* '!"$!@*, D"F#;I$A# EC"&+' H+* E%% ,=
E!&%%', $+!J * E!?AR!'* & E!C%#" !H#?*@!&*&
+?"I$. [+M! EC"&+ H+* D’#*I, M! "#!& !E%C" E"-
?@I "#!&!'* '!"$!@*, $! &" % E"D"R% 12 @! -
#$*E!@! !H!<!@! &"E!&"! ! &*$"R"= E!C%* H+*
E!&"!'?I E! C% &"E!&"?A!'* EC"&+* (!#!H", + &+!-
*I F!@! *+C",), +F EF'I "R% E! E!$%H* %I#$C",
C"I, !E%C",. *$"R"' E!C%*' H+*, +" %@?'%$*-
;$A E!!+ E!&"!'?% EC"&+!' H+* ("?",) &"E!&"-
?A!'* EC"&+* (!#!H", + &+!*I F!@! *+C",) E! &&?%-
* !E%C";, M! E"?@I "#!&!'* '!"$!@*, 'I
DH%DE%<*&$# "+#*& =!J% $+!@! E!&"!'?%
! &"E!&"?A!@! EC"&+ (!$' &"E!&"?A' E-
169
C"&+!' $+!@! E!&"!'?%) $ EF$!@! ' "R% M!!
%I#$C", C"I, !E%C",. %I#$C" "#!&= !E%C"F, M! E"-
?@;$A "#!&!'* '!"$!@*, D"F#;I$A# * &"E!&"!'*
%I#$", +F !'*I$A# $ &%%$A# H+!' ("?"I;) " I %?%+$-
!' !+*'%$!' &D<%!, #$*+$*. L!'$ " #$*+$*
%I#$* $ E!!+ %I#$C", "#!&= !E%C"F * %I#$" &-
D<;$A# &"E!&"?A' EC"&+!' H+* ("?",) D *=*-
&' &'!@ CA!@! K!?!J%.
T %D*?A$$' &J$$ D=!"& M!! D’#*& #*$" $ '%-
$ E!&%% +?"I$!' !E%C",, + E"?@I &*$"RA!'*
"#!&!'* '!"$!@*, " E! C; !E%C"; !E!&;;$A-
# "!'C"I; E! EF$% &"E!&"?A' EC"&+!' "-
R% #$!#!&! E!&%% H! &"'!& & ,, E!&%%"; -
H! % E!&!&J%!'* !@* "!'C", E!
C; !E%C";.
"R% E! H! % E!&!&J%!'* !@-
* "!'C", E! "#!&* !E%C";, + E"?@I &*$"R-
A!'* "#!&!'* '!"$!@*, EF'I$A# &"E!&"?A'
EC"&+!' H+* H! "?", &"E!&"! ! &*$"R"= E!C%-
* H+*, &#$!&?%= * K&?= &*$"RA!@! "#!&!-
@! '!"$!@* H+*, % E"D"R% 10 !H!<= "& D %I#$-
C", $+!, !E%C",.
K!?!J%, M! #$!#*;$A# %?"DC", H+' #&!,= !H!&’D-
+"& + #*H’I+$"& E%&!@! "#!&!@! '!"$!@*, '"#$$A#
$+!J " * !'$&!-E&!&= +$=, +" &D<;$A E!!+
D"F#% +!+%$= !E%C"F. T!+%', &"E!&"! ! E*+$*
2.17 #$*+C", E! H%D@!$"&+!&" !D=*+ & +," & C"!-
?A"F &?;$", D$&%J%!, E!#$!&!; K&?" C"!?A!@!
H+* +, - 22 &" 21.01.2004 ., +M! H+ &"'!&?I +?"I-
$* * &+!" E?$"J!@! !*<% D !E%C"I;, + '"#$$A
!D+ $+!,, M! E"?@I "#!&!'* '!"$!@*, $! $+% E?-
$"J% !*<% +?"I$ H+ E!&%$I F!'* H%D &+!. +,
E!&%$;< $+% E?$"J% !*<% & %A =!J%, 'I
D!H$ F!@! D&!!$!'* H!C" E# E! E<* E!&%%
!+*'%$ H%D &+! (D !H!&’D+!&' E!#?' <#$*
2 #$$$" 7 T+!* +, «K! DE!H"@ $ E!$"; ?%@?"-
DC", (&"'&;) !=!"&, !%J= D?!<' R?=!'» $
C%F E*+$) $ DD<$ $* F!@! E!&%% (C% D#&"<*I$A#
E"E#' &"E!&"?A!@! &+!&C, &"E!&"?A!@! EC"&-
+, +F EF'I "R% M!! &"%#% !E%C", +?"I$ !
!E%C"F, +" E"?@;$A "#!&!'* '!"$!@*, $ &"H$+!'
R$'E H+*).
. .
170
T@"! D E*+$!' 11.13 &+D!, #$*+C", +M! !E%C" '"#-
$$A !D+ $+!,, M! E"?@I "#!&!'* '!"$!@*, $! H+
'!J% &"'!&$ +?"I$* * &+!" %?%+$!!@! !D=*+!&!-
@! !+*'%$/#$C"F!@! !DE!J%, E%%!@! E! $%?%-
!*. + E!&"!'?I +?"I$ D#!H' ##$%' E! E<* &"-
'!& * &+!" %?%+$!!@! !D=*+!&!@!
!+*'%$/#$C"F!@! !DE!J% (D !H!&’D+!&' E!#-
?' <#$* 2 #$$$" 7 T+!* +, «K! DE!H"@ $
E!$"; ?%@?"DC", (&"'&;) !=!"&, !%J= D?!<-
' R?=!'» $ C%F E*+$).
"E!&"! ! E*+$* 5 @?& 1 !D"?* #$*+C", E! +-
#!&" !E%C", & H+= +,, D$&%J%!, E!#$!&!; K&-
?" C"!?A!@! H+* +, - 337 &" 14.08.2003 ., * -
D" D"F#% !E%C"F D @!$"&+!; H%D &"+$$ =*+* #*'*,
M! E%%&M*I 50000 @&%A H! %+&"&?%$ C"I, #*' & "!D%'"F
&?;$", D '%$!; "%$"+C", !#"H * +#!&= !+*'%$= ';$A
DD<$# $+" %+&"D$:
x ? "D<= !#"H-%D%$"&: E"D&M%, "'’, E! H$A+!&"
!#!H, + D"F#;I !E%C"; D @!$"&+!;, $ !J%, #%"
$ !'% E#E!$ (H! !+*'%$, M! F!@! D'";I), $ &<"
$ !@, M! F!@! &&, '"#C% E!J&, "%$"+C"FF
!'% D@"! D %J&' %I#$!' "D<= !#"H — E?$+"&
E!$+"& $ "R= !H!&’D+!&= E?$%J"&;
x ? "D<= !#"H-%%D%$"&: E"D&M%, "'’, E! H$A+!&"
(* D" F!@! &!#$") !#!H, + D"F#;I !E%C"; D @!$"&+!;,
$ !J%, #%" $ !'% E#E!$ (H! !+*'%$, M! F!-
@! D'";I), $ &<" $ !@, M! F!@! &&, @!'#$&!,
'"#C% E!J& H! $'<#!&!@! E%%H*&;
x ? ;<= !#"H-%D%$"&: F'%*&, '"#C%D-
=!J%, "%$"+C"FF +! D@"! D V' %J&'
%I#$!' E"EI'#$& $ !@"DC"F +,, %+&"D$ H+*,
* +!'* &"+$! E!$!<F =*!+ ("D DD<%' F!@! !'%-
), E"D&M%, "'’, E! H$A+!&" !#!H — E%#$&+ C"I,
;<!, !#!H, + H%DE!#%%A! !%J*I, &!#$A H! E%-
%+D*I @!$"&+*, $ !J%, #%" $ !'% E#E!$ (H!
!+*'%$, M! F!@! D'";I), $ &<" $ !@, M! F!@!
&&;
x ? ;<= !#"H-%%D%$"&: F'%*&, '"#C%D-
=!J%, %+&"D$ H+*, * +!'* &"+$! E!$!<F =*!+
("D DD<%' F!@! !'%), E"D&M%, "'’, E! H$A+!&" (* D"
F!@! &!#$") !#!H, E%#$&+ C"I, ;<!, !#!H, +
H%DE!#%%A! !%J*I, &!#$A H! E%%+D*I @!$"&+*, $ -