THE TRIBUTE SYSTEM AND JAPAN 439
records were sent to Japan. A set of the hon tally records was also
placed in the Chekiang provincial governor's office (which handled
popular and financial affairs).
When a ship went from Japan to China, it sailed with the proper hon
tally, which was then checked against the record book at the Board of
Rites in Chekiang and Peking. When the checking was completed, the
tally was collected. The converse, Ming ships going to Japan bearing
nichi tallies, did not in fact occur. None of these tallies exists today, but
according to a sketch in the Boshi nyumin-ki, the "hon character num-
ber i" was stamped in red ink on the tally sheet. On the reverse side
were various pieces of information, such as the number of tribute
items presented, the auxiliary gifts for the envoy and members of his
party, and the cargo, number of ships, and sailors of the "official
merchants" (those merchants recorded on the tally). These writings on
the reverse side were called
p'i-wen
or pieh-fu.
Over the century and a half from Ashikaga Yoshimitsu to 1547,
nineteen missions were sent to the Ming.
I03
The fourth Ashikaga sho-
gun, Yoshimochi, severed relations with Ming China, and in the latter
half of the Yung Lo emperor's reign, the wako incursions became
severe. The sixth shogun, Ashikaga Yoshinori, restored the tribute
relationship with the Ming. The Muromachi bakufu monopolized
trade until the eighth mission in 1401, but starting with the ninth
mission to Ming in 1433, temples, shrines, and daimyo joined in. The
eleventh mission during the tenure of the eighth shogun, Yoshimasa,
was the largest in the course of Japan-Ming relations. On this occa-
sion, the Ming concluded the Hsuan Teh treaty, which stipulated that
from then on there could be one mission every ten years, each consist-
ing of three ships and three hundred people.
A conflict regarding the Ming trade developed between the
Hosokawa and Ouchi houses, based respectively in Sakai and Hakata.
This confrontation became severe during the sixteenth and seven-
teenth missions to the Ming in 1511 and 1523, and on the latter
103 Here I follow Tanaka, Chusei laigai
kankeishi,
pp. 159-60. There are many other studies of
Japan-Ming relations after Yoshimitsu's time. See Kayahara Shozo, "Nichimin kango boeki
ni okeru Hosokawa Ouchi nishi no k6so," Shigaku zasshi 25 and 26 (September-October
1914,
February-March 1915); Akiyama Kenzo, Nisshi
kosho
shiwa (Tokyo: Naigai shoseki
kabushiki kaisha, 1935); Fujita Motoharu, Nisshi kdlsu no kenkyu,
chu-kinsei
hen (Tokyo:
Fuzambo, 1938); Akiyama Kenzo, Nisshi
koshoshi
kenkyu (Tokyo: Iwanami shoten, 1939);
Makita Tairyo, Sakugen nyuminki no kenkyu (Kyoto: Hozokan, 1959); Sakuma Shigeo,
"Mindai chuki no taigai seisaku to Nitchu kankei," Hokkaido
daigaku
jimbun kagaku ron-
shu,
no. 8 (1971); Kobata Atsushi, Kingin boekishi no kenkyu (Tokyo: Hosei daigaku
shuppankyoku, 1976). See also the short but useful guide by Sakai Tadao, "Mindai bunka
no Nihon bunka ni ataeta eikyo," Rekishi kyoiku 11 (October 1963).
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008