were made, touching upon the genuine experience of the
common soldier.
It wasn’t until 1946, though, that some of the bitterness
of lost youth and shattered dreams could be played out on the
screen with the release of The Best Years of Our Lives. The film
was a hit and a Best Picture Academy Award winner. For the
most part, however, unlike the antiwar sentiment prevalent in
films after World War I, World War II has traditionally been
presented to movie audiences in a very positive light, even
years later in films such as The Longest Day (1962), A Bridge
Too Far (1977), and The Dirty Dozen (1967).
The difference between the antiwar attitude of most
World War I movies and the prowar attitude of most World
War II films was succinctly summed up in purely Hollywood
terms by Jeanine Basinger in her excellent book, The World
War II Combat Film, when she wrote, “World War I was a
flop and World War II was a hit.”
Although World War II received “A” movie treatment,
the Korean conflict was relegated mostly to “B”s. Director
Samuel Fuller, working on a shoestring, didn’t hesitate to put
his personal stamp on the war in some of the most com-
pelling war movies of the early 1950s, such as The Steel Hel-
met (1950) and Fixed Bayonets (1951).
If Korea was casually overlooked by Hollywood, Vietnam
was consciously avoided by the industry. In the late 1960s and
early 1970s, most filmmakers saw the mass audience as too
politically polarized to make successful movies on the subject.
John Wayne ignored the conventional wisdom and starred in
and directed the pro-Vietnam War film The Green Berets
(1968). It was a poor movie that received awful reviews, but
it was mildly successful at the box office.
Later, as the emotional wounds caused by the Vietnam
War began to heal, a handful of thoughtful movies appeared
in the theaters, among them, Coming Home (1978), which
dealt with the effects of the war on its survivors. Go Tell the
Spartans (1978) became the first movie about that war to
present a realistic and intimate story of soldiers in combat.
The Deer Hunter (1978), a sprawling saga that tried to come
to terms with the American male ethos and its relationship to
the war, stalked away with the Best Picture Academy Award.
The best was yet to come, however, when, the following year,
Francis Coppola’s brilliant psychological examination of the
dark side of the conflict, Apocalypse Now (1979), was released.
After this brief flurry of interest, though, the war wasn’t
graphically presented to film audiences again until 1986 in
the Academy Award-winner Platoon, on the heels of which
came Stanley Kubrick’s Full Metal Jacket (1987), followed by
BRIAN DE PALMA
’s harrowing Casualties of War (1989), all of
these movies crackling with pent-up rage and disgust for the
waste in human life.
In the meantime, however, America refought the Viet-
nam War in movie fantasies such as Sylvester Stallone’s
Rambo II (1985) and Chuck Norris’s Missing in Action (1984)
and their sequels. If America couldn’t win the Vietnam War
in fact, Stallone and Norris would finally win it in the movies.
With only a few exceptions, the films of the 1990s either
took a self-congratulatory glance back at World War II or
explored more recent military adventures in the Balkans or
in the Persian Gulf. Deterrence (1999) was ahead of its time
in dramatizing a nuclear showdown between the U.S. presi-
dent and Uday Hussein, but the film was released long
before the situation in Iraq became confrontational, and the
film disappeared from sight. Three Kings (1999) was far more
successful, perhaps because of its casting (George Clooney,
Mark Wahlberg, Spike Jonze, and Ice Cube) but mainly
because of its irreverent tone in treating the war in Kuwait
as a black comedy.
A far more serious look at American adventurism in the
Third World was provided by Black Hawk Down (2001), which
took place in Somalia, where American forces attempt to cap-
ture some of a warlord’s top lieutenants. Some American sol-
diers are killed on the mission, and others are wounded. When
the American soldiers return “to leave no man behind,” the
American rescuers are attacked by thousands of Somalis. Nine-
teen Americans and more than 1,000 Somalis died because of
this foolhardy mission. The film, based on an actual incident,
highlighted the limitations of superior American technology in
a Third World setting. Michael Winterbottom’s film, Welcome
to Sarajevo (1997), was also based on a true story by an ITN
reporter covering the turmoil in the Balkans.
The World War II films suggested that, of course, war
was hell, but it had to be approached with a winning attitude.
Michael Bay’s Pearl Harbor (2001) was an expensive epic star-
ring Ben Affleck and Josh Hartnett as soldier buddies who
compete for the affection of Kate Beckinsale. Of course,
Pearl Harbor was a military disaster, but the flop film takes a
more positive approach by ending with Jimmy Doolittle’s air
attack over Tokyo.
STEVEN SPIELBERG
’s Saving Private Ryan (1998) was at
first glance a wrenching representation of the Normandy
invasion, as American soldiers were cut down on the con-
tested beaches, but after an initial bloodbath, the film shifted
to a story involving
TOM HANKS
leading a squad of soldiers
on a rescue mission to find and bring back Private Ryan
(Matt Damon), whose three brothers have been killed in
action. The search was undertaken to prevent a repeat of the
real-life Sullivan tragedy, in which all five Sullivan brothers
were killed. The movie suggests that the search was worth it,
but there is a lingering doubt because of the incredible sacri-
fices that had to be made for a single soldier. Still, the film
made more than $190 million.
The Thin Red Line (1998) came out six months after Sav-
ing Private Ryan and concerned the war in the Pacific. Again,
the Americans were successful, but in the aftermath of their
victory, the audience saw the humiliated and humanized
Japanese, and the question arose of whether or not the vic-
tory was worth the sacrifice. Saving Private Ryan swamped
Terrence Malick’s adaptation of the James Jones war novel
because Spielberg concentrated on exterior action, whereas
Malick attempted to probe existentially into his characters,
posing philosophical issues such as “Maybe all men got one
big soul,” as the dialogue attests. The irony was that The Thin
Red Line was based on a novel written by the author of From
Here to Eternity, the iconic 1953 war film.
Bruce Beresford’s Paradise Road (1997), which grossed
only $2 million, was a far more serious treatment of an Aus-
WAR MOVIES
446