470 Lubricant Additives: Chemistry and Applications
for example, boric acid to reduce Cu/Pb corrosion. In some cases, this can improve the antiwear prop-
erties but usually reduces the effectiveness of the dispersant at dispersing soot. Clearly a balance has
to be found, and formulators will use different dispersants to meet the various requirements.
19.3.11 SLUDGE
Under certain conditions, sludge will accumulate in an internal combustion engine. During the
1980s, this problem intensi ed throughout the world, particularly in gasoline engines in Germany,
the United Kingdom, and the United States. The origins of the problem are most likely related to fuel
quality, drive cycles, extended oil-drain intervals, and the redirection of blowby gas into the rocker
cover. Sludge build up, if left unchecked, can spread throughout the engine, leading to reduced oil
ow through the lter and drain-back holes on the valve-deck. In extreme situations, this will lead to
engine seizure. The problems were not linked to poor-quality lubricants. However, as lubricant tech-
nology evolved, it was found that newer lubricant formulations could help alleviate the problem.
Sludges can be split into low-temperature sludges and high-temperature sludges. Sludges
formed at low temperatures will tend to be soft and easily removable from surfaces by wiping. As
previously mentioned, the sludge-forming mechanism is thought to be accelerated by the transfer
of blowby gases into the oil. Blowby gases contain water, acids, and partially burned hydrocarbons
in the form of oxygenates and ole ns. The ole ns react further with nitrogen oxides to form oil-
insoluble products. Fuels with high-end boiling points or with high aromatics also tend to contrib-
ute to more sludge. Once formed, highway driving will exacerbate the problem as the engine runs
hotter, thereby causing the sludge to bake on.
Sludge formation is reduced by the addition of basic succinimide dispersants particularly the
high-molecular-weight types. The addition of boric acid to a succinimide dispersant to make a lower
TBN dispersant will reduce the effectiveness of a dispersant in dispersing sludge [7]. Although
this indicates that basic dispersants are required to neutralize sludge precursors, it has been found
that very high levels of basic nitrogen are not necessarily required for sludge dispersion in gasoline
engines. For Sequence VE performance, high-molecular-weight PIB bis-succinimide dispersants
have demonstrated excellent performance. This would appear to indicate that the mechanism of
sludge formation in a gasoline engine is different from the agglomeration of soot in a diesel engine,
which do require high levels of basic nitrogen especially in low-saturate mineral base stocks.
Although bis- and monosuccinimide dispersants are used in both gasoline and diesel engine oils,
it would be fair to say that, more recently, diesel engine oils have tended to higher levels of basic
dispersants, with correspondingly higher levels of PIB monosuccinimides compared with gasoline
engine oils. One of the big challenges for formulators since API CG-4 has been to develop lubri-
cants that meet the requirements of both gasoline and diesel engine oils, the so-called universal
engine oils. This requires careful formulation with both bis- and monosuccinimide dispersants.
When formulating engine oil, it is also important to consider the interactions between the
succinimide dispersant and other additives such as zinc dialkyldithiophosphate (ZDDP). A complex
between ZDDP and succinimide polyamine has been observed in laboratory tests especially where
there is a high basic nitrogen to ZDDP ratio [8]. As the level of basic dispersant is increased,
sludge and wear will improve. Above a critical concentration of dispersant, the antiwear properties
of the ZDDP will be dramatically reduced as the basic nitrogen forms a stable complex with the
ZDDP effectively reducing its antiwear capability. It has been demonstrated that the ZDDP–amine
complex retards the rate of peroxide decomposition by ZDDP [9], which in turn accelerates the
formation of sludge. Sludge will usually increase in line with wear, so clearly a high level of ZDDP
with a suf cient dispersant level to disperse the sludge is required. High levels of ZDDP permit
high levels of dispersant to be used in the lubricant thereby giving superior engine sludge and wear
performance. However, phosphorus has been implicated in exhaust catalyst poisoning. Because of
this, a maximum phosphorus limit of 0.1 wt% in the lubricant has been applied to recent API and
ILSAC speci cations. This means that where phosphorus limits are imposed for API SJ and ILSAC
CRC_59645_Ch019.indd 470CRC_59645_Ch019.indd 470 10/31/2008 2:34:17 PM10/31/2008 2:34:17 PM