data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e5ced/e5ced20127a918091732a9946cfe62470930daeb" alt=""
Cooling down of the two-layer specimen to RT and
heating up to 300°C for the plasma spraying of the
ceramic TBC.
Spraying of the ceramic top coat: the molten YSZ
particles are rapidly cooled down. The high tensile
stresses, which should result in the TBC
are
consid-
ered to relax through the formation of microcracks.
Thus the tensile strength of the YSZ-TBC provides
an upper boundary value for the remaining residual
TBC stress.
Cooling down of the three-layer system to RT.
As shown in Table 4, the residual stresses in the
YSZ
top coat and the NiCoCrAlY bond coat, which are
calculated on these assumptions, are quite similar to the
values obtained from the bending experiments.
flection of the specimen reaches 1 mm, which corre-
sponds to bending stresses at the interface with the top
coat of 720 and 650 MPa at 600°C and 950°C respec-
tively. In any case, the resulting stresses of 780 and 610
MPa should be sufficient to induce cracking in the me-
tallic bond coat. However, the cracks stop at the inter-
face between top coat and bond coat (Fig.
10
and 12),
which proves the high ductility of this metallic layer.
If we assume that the BC only fractures in a brittle
mode below the ductile-to-brittle transition temperature
(DBTT), then 600°C seems to be above this temperature
and it is unlikely that the calculated stresses can be
maintained. The conducted experiments lead to the
conclude that the DBTT of the NiCoCrAlY layer is
below 600°C.
Top coat Bond coat
Bending experiments
-55
MPa 215 MPa
Thermoelastic calculation -63 MPa 200 MPa
Table
5:
Residual stresses in top and bond coat
In the case of the high temperature tests, thermal
stresses have to be added to the residual stresses to
obtain the stress distribution in the TBC system before
bending. Fig. 14 shows the respective stress distribu-
tions at RT, 600 and 950°C.
Bond coat
v
Substrate
-4
b
200
-
ii
!!
RT
I1
1
ii
-0-
600°C
-0-
950°C
Fig.
14:
Stress
situation in
a
TBC
specimen at RT.
600
and
950°C
With increasing temperature, the compressive resid-
ual stress in the top coat relaxes and tensile stress de-
velop. Thus the ceramic layer expands at a lower rate
than the two metallic materials (Table
1).
At 950"C, the
calculated thermal stress
(T~~~~~=~O
MPa is already
significantly above the bending strength of the YSZ
layer and cracks are formed thermally before any me-
chanical loading (Fig. 11).
Following the same thermoelastic considerations,
nominal bond coat stresses can be derived. In the bond
coat, the tensile residual stress relaxes
(60
MPa at
600°C) and compressive stress develops
(-40
MPa at
950°C). At the end of the bending experiment, the de-
CONCLUSION
Using in situ observations of cracking in a TBC
system during bending, the critical stresses of ceramic
top coat and metallic bond coat were determined. Re-
sidual stresses of about
-55
MPa and 215 MPa in top
and bond coat were deduced respectively. These values
are in a good agreement with residual stresses predicted
from linear elastic calculations. With increasing tem-
perature, tensile stresses develop in the YSZ top coat as
a result of thermal expansion mismatch. They are suffi-
cient to induce thermoelastic cracking at 950°C.
At high temperature, the cracks do not penetrate the
metallic bond coat, reflecting the high ductility of the
NiCoCrAlY material. The change from brittle fracture
at RT to non-fracture at 600 and 95OOC indicates that
the ductile-to-brittle transition temperature (DBTT) of
the material is below 600°C. Complementary bending
tests at temperature between RT and 600°C would allow
a more precise evaluation.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
The authors are grateful to Ms. Funke, IWV1, For-
schungszentrum Jiilich, for providing the coated speci-
mens.
REFERENCES
1
W.J. Brindley, Thermal Barrier Coatings of the
Future, J. of Thermal Spray Technol., 6[1], (1997)
3-4.
S.
Stecura, Optimization of the NiCrA1Y/Zr02-
Yz03 Thermal Barrier System, Adv. Ceram. Mat.,
P. Fauchais, A. Vardelle and M. Vardelle, Recent
Developments in Plasma Sprayed Thermal Barrier
Coatings, Workshop on Thermal Barrier Coatings,
85" Meeting of AGARD, Structures and Materials
Panel, 13-17 October 1997, Aalborg, Denmark.
R.V. Hillery, B.H. Pilsner, R.L. McKnight,
T.S.
Cook and M.S. Hartle, Thermal Barrier Coating
2
I[
11, (1986) 68-76.
3
4
528