composed mainly of calcium carbonate. Limestones,
and sediments that eventually solidify to form them,
are referred to as calcareous (note that, although
they are carbonate, they are not ‘carbonaceous’: this
latter term is used for material that is rich in carbon,
such as coal). Sedimentary rocks may also be made of
carbonates of elements such as magnesium or iron,
and there are also carbonates of dozens of elements
occurring in nature (e.g. malachite and azurite are
copper carbonates). This group of sediments and rocks
are collectively known as carbonates to sedimentary
geologists, and most carbonate rocks are sedimentary
in origin. Exceptions to this are marble, which is a
carbonate rock recrystallised under metamorphic
conditions, and carbonatite, an uncommon carbon-
ate-rich lava.
3.1.1 Carbonate mineralogy
Calcite
The most familiar and commonest carbonate mineral
is calcite (CaCO
3
). As a pure mineral it is colourless or
white, and in the field it could be mistaken for quartz,
although there are two very simple tests that can be
used to distinguish calcite from quartz. First, there is a
difference in hardness: calcite has a hardness of 3 on
Mohs’ scale, and hence it can easily be scratched with
a pen-knife; quartz (hardness 7) is harder than a knife
blade and will scratch the metal. Second, calcite
reacts with dilute (10%) hydrochloric acid (HCl),
whereas silicate minerals do not. A small dropper-
bottle of dilute HCl is hence useful as a means of
determining if a rock is calcareous, as most common
carbonate minerals (except dolomite) will react with
the acid to produce bubbles of carbon dioxide gas,
especially if the surface has been powdered first by
scratching with a knife. Although calcite sometimes
occurs in its simple mineral form, it most commonly
has a biogenic origin, that is, it has formed as a part
of a plant or animal. A wide variety of organisms use
calcium carbonate to form skeletal structures and
shells and a lot of calcareous sediments and rocks
are formed of material made in this way.
Magnesium ions can substitute for calcium in the
crystal lattice of calcite, and two forms of calcite are
recognised in nature: low-magnesium calcite (low-Mg
calcite), which contains less than 4% Mg, and high-
magnesium calcite (high-Mg calcite), which typically
contains 11% to 19% Mg. The hard parts of many
marine organisms are made of high-Mg calcite, for
example echinoderms, barnacles and foraminifers,
amongst others (see 3.13). Strontium may substitute
for calcium in the lattice and although it is in small
quantities (less than 1%) it is important because
strontium isotopes can be used in dating rocks
(21.3.1).
Aragonite
There is no chemical difference between calcite and
aragonite, but the two minerals differ in their
mineral form: whereas calcite has a trigonal crystal
form, aragonite has an orthorhombic crystal form.
Aragonite has a more densely packed lattice structure
and is slightly denser than calcite (a specific gravity of
2.95, as opposed to a range of 2.72–2.94 for calcite),
and is slightly harder (3.5–4 on Mohs’ scale). In
practice, it is rarely possible to distinguish between
the two, but the differences between them have some
important consequences (18.2.2). Many invertebrates
use aragonite to build their hard parts, including
bivalves and corals.
Dolomite
Calcium magnesium carbonate (CaMg(CO
3
)
2
)isa
common rock-forming mineral which is known as
dolomite. Confusingly, a rock made up of this mineral
is also called dolomite, and the term dolostone is now
sometimes used for the lithology to distinguish it from
dolomite, the mineral. The mineral is similar in
appearance to calcite and aragonite, with a similar
hardness to the latter. The only way that dolomite can
be distinguished in hand specimen is by the use of the
dilute HCl acid test: there is usually little or no reac-
tion between cold HCl and dolomite. Although dolo-
mite rock is quite widespread, it does not seem to be
forming in large quantities today, so large bodies of
dolomite rock are considered to be diagenetic
(18.4.2).
Siderite
Siderite is iron carbonate (FeCO
3
) with the same
structure as calcite, and is very difficult to distinguish
between iron and calcium carbonates on mineralogi-
cal grounds. It is rarely pure, often containing some
magnesium or manganese substituted for iron in the
Limestone 29