Ершов Ю.Г. Философия права
Подождите немного. Документ загружается.
1
1
1
3
",<11<-><10+-*<1.!H5?1, G,6<>G16+*1G10;
,",1!2-*101-,:61/,+2-,",?1-,H+7,",11M,,<2;
-,",16-01B0,/>(171MG1/,:H516,1M,,<2-,1/,;
--0,101B0,/5-,<17,K:106-*111-/+,8,51<,,+?1
,11, :,01-1I*2-,5J1-!!,5?1-,-,*L51:1:<+7?1
/,0H5?10,,<5?1-,G*KLG?1012-,-?11,/6+>1
/0,0>1 ,-, ,-1 01 /,+,<1 -,,0-01 -1 <=6!,6><1
/0,<?1/6!-<0KL<12-2!K1/0,-! P,-71-,-0;
+*KLG1.60,",1",-!6-0(1
1 /,-6!-+7,<1 , L-01 ",+:<1 S.6+:<T1
-,0-*1 06!L<1 -/,-, ,<1 ,,6H1 S0<-,1 GT1
,,851 <=6!1 ,+7><1 , L,-*<(1 A-/-*1
0+-1 01 /-/01 !-+01 0,,<K1 <,",2-+>G1 -,;
, L-0?12,1-,:611,0>1!-+,0*16+*1:0*1",+:<1
S.6+:<T(1
,1 !1 ",+:<1 601 -,,>(1 F61 91 , L-0,;
/,+2-*?1 M,,<2-*?1 !+7!,;/,-0+7-*?1 -0*;
:*1-1M..0,-7K1!/0+*1M,,<,511-,H+7><1
/,H--<?1 -,G*KL*1 606!+7>51 M,!+7!>5?1 ;
+",:>51 1 (6(1 , +1 , L,-(1 ,*1 91 -/:<?1 /0;
+>511:!81",-!6-0,51H+,-,-?11/0+,?1
<KL51,/6+!K1M2-!K1,-!?1, ,-*KL51<=;
H,+7>1,,8*(1
D-,2-*1 /1 /,:+?1 2,1 ,-,0!1 6<,2;
-G1 ,051 01 -.1 <=H,+7>G1 ,,851 1 H,;
+7,51 ",-!6-0,-1 -,-0+*1 /,1 -!0?1
-<,,/6+*1,6,0?111M,-,0(1O,1 ,018+,1:;
/+101,-,0>G16,!<G1FF(1
1 -0,1 0<*1 01 -0*:1 -1 -, >*<1 01 ,-,2,<1 -1
C=6!,6*1 ,<--*1 K-,01 ,<6,0+1 /271 ;
01,/6+*1,6,0?10+K2KL5101- *1, L,-71-,;
?1-,0>11M2-?1!+7!>11*:>,0>?1+",:>11
6,+,"2-1 -0*:?1 , L1 ",".2-,1 <-,G,=6?1
, L!K1 M,,<2-!K1 ,-,0!1 1 6,-,2!K1 2-+,-7(1
F , L*1M1/:?1-",6*1/,61,6,<1/,<K10-1-;
+?1/,-,*,1/,=0KL11-<,,/6+*KL5-*1,;
(17<,,/6+1,6101-<,<1, L<106191M,10>=;
1
3
1 0,+1 ,61 ,,-+7,1 ",1 &5%551 1 61 5
54,1 1 31 5361 356551 55!961 1
5551 651 631 &5%51 53-.B1
65515!9655135817,"+-,1A+H1FF1,1/;
H/G1<=6!,6,",1/01S%E'$T1+:H*1,6,<1/011
-<,,/6+1:+K2-*10111
911-,:61-!0,",11:0-<,",1",-!6-0Y1
9116, ,0,+7,<1/-,611:0-<,<!1",-!6-0!1
+1, P6K1-1<Y1
911!-,0+1+K ,",16!",",1/,+2-,",1-!-?1-0,;
,6,1,/6+,",1-,,0-0!KL<1,6,<(1
1,<1-+!2?1,"6101-,-01<,",H,+7,",1",-!6;
-01 -!L-0!K1 "!//>1 +H?1 , +6KL1 !-,520><1 M2;
-<?1 +",:><1 1 S+T1 *:>,0><1 2<?1 :2+7,1
,+2KL<-*1 ,1 G-1 ,-+7,51 2-1 -+*?1 1
M1"!//>1-!L-0,1!-!/K1/,12-+,-1,-,0,<!1;
-+K?191<=6!,6,1/0,1,/6+*1G1-!-1012-01
H,+7,",1<78-0(11,+21,1,6,01H,+7>1
<78-011*0+*K-*1-! P<1/011-<,,/6+?1
:,1<=6!,6,1/0,10,:+"11",-!6-01, *:+7-01
/,1 /:K1 G1 ,-, >G1 /0?1 -,GK1 G1 -,H,!+7!,51
!+7,-116-<H1+H?11<1/6+=LG(1
, +<1:L>1/01H,+7>G1<78-01"+, +71
/,1 -0,<!1 G!?1 /,-,+7!1 0-1 ",-!6-01 01 ,51 +1 ,51
-/1 0+K2K1 01 -0,51 -,-01 :,, :>1 ,M2-1
"!//>(18,<1,",?1, G,6<,-71<=6!,6,;/0,0,",1;
"!+,0*1 0,/,-,01 H,+7>G1 <78-01 , !-+,0+1
-!L-0><1,"2*<1010,:<,=,-*G1MG1<78-01
,:>071 0+*11/,+!1-0,G1",-!6-0191101-<>-+1
:,,6+7-0?111.2-,51/,+(11-0*:1-1M<1, ;
L-*1 0<1 1 ,?1 2,1 IZ1 -!L-0,01 H,+7>G1
<78-0101,!=1,+2KL",-*1,1",16,<!KL",1
-+*1 ->1 <,=1 -,:671 +7!K1 !",:!1 01 +:H1
/01 +H<?1 /6+=L<1 1 H,+7,<!1 <78-0!(1
?1 /1 /,-+6,0+7,<1 /,061 +871 .,<+7,;
K62-,",1 0-01 <,=1 0,:!71 -,-,*?1 ,,,1
<,=,1<,071h6-<H5101:!+71,-!-0*16.;
1
1
1
3
.HHJ(
%
1,M,<!1<=6!,6,1/0,1.-!1-/H;
+7>1/01H,+7>G1<78-011-/,+7:,0716,-,*1
-0,51!+7!>11-/,06,071-0,K1+"KY1<716,-!/11;
.,<H11,6,<1*:>?1-0, ,6,?1!-,11/-7<,1/,+7:,;
07-*1 ,6><1 *:>,<Y1 !2-0,071 01 81 0,/,-,0?1 -K;
LG-*1G1-,0?11",+7,<11<-,<1!,0Y1-,:6071
-, -0>1 /,-0+7-?1 !+7!>1 1 +",:>1 --,;
HHY1:00716H,>1,-+1G,:*5-0,0*Y1,-!L;
-0+*71 /,.--,+7!K1 /,6",,0!1 -0,G1 H,+7>G1 6;
,0Y1!/, +*7101,.H+7>G16,!<G1-0,1<11.<;
+?11M,1/*,11,6,<1*:>11<,",16!",
#
(11/;
16-<H*1H,+7>G1<78-01,--*101-,0;
<,<1<1-/,-><1*0+<1910,10:<,,,8*G1
<78-01-1!+7,51H5(1,M,<!1-/H+->1/,1/0<1
2+,01-0*10,/,-1,1.,<,01FF?17,01B0,/>11
6!"G1 <=6!,6>G1 ,":H51 /,1 :L1 /01 2+,0?1
006!1M..0,-1<=6!,6>G1 -6,011 6*+7,;
-1!:>G1,":H5(11
,1!1/160,5>G1-6,01/<*1,<1<=6!;
,6,",1 /01 ,,-+7,1 -<,,/6+*?1 /,*0+-71 /,;
0,/,+,=*1-,,(1,+,-711/0,0,51+ +:<1/,1
,,8K1 1 M2-<1 1 +",:><1 <78-0<?1 ;
.+7,0><101!K1!+7!!K1-6!?10>:>0K11=:1;
+",/*>16H(116,-=1,/6+,",1!,0*1
2-+,-?1 01 !-+,0*G1 ,</,",1 /,=0*1 1 "51
-/H+7>G1 /0?1 /6-0+1 M2-G1 <78-01 ,;
:>0K-*1 ",071 01 !+7!!1 ->1 /,=0*?1 -,;
0*-*1 ,+1 "--0><1 1 6+7><1 01 -0,G1 /*:*G?1
2<11-0,51I-,2-,51,6J(1
:1/01 1-<,,/6+11 ,=6-0,1/;
:K1 /01 1 ,6+?1 ((1 /,-+61 !",=1 ,;
+7,51H+,-,-1",-!6-0(1oA17--*1E+7,514--< ;
+1FF1/*+1-+6!KL!K1.,<!+,0!11I0,1,6,011
-<,,/6+116,+=,1,-!L-0+*7-*16+*1/,6>016-;
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
1 "C597 ,1, +<>1 :L>1/01 H,+7>G1 <78-01 33152,-7(1 8!+7!(1
F L-0,(1#$$)(1>/(1#(1S#FT(17(1#R'(1
#
1<1=(17(1#@%(1
1
3
01 H1 +1 -,:6*1 //*-051 6+*1 ,-!L-0+*1 M,",1
6-01 01 !81 H,+7,",1 -!0J(1 U,,-71
,6+*1 /:-*1 +871 ,"6?1 ,"61 271 61 ,1 ,6G1 1
,*G?1 G,6*LG-*1 01 /,621 6!",<!1 ",-!6-0!1 01
!81<=6!,6,",1/0(1
71,21:*1/011<,"!1 >710,:06>101 -,+K11
/H/1 ,+7,51 H+,-,-1 ",-!6-0?1 1 /0,1 1
-<,,/6+1 /!<1 ,6+*(1 6,/!-<,1 --<071
M,->1 1 , :+2>1 -! -H1 1 I!+7>1 H,-J?1
,,60"KL110,,51/+1/0?1->11/, ,-1+K;
6516!",51M2-,51/6+=,-(17/--*1/,/>1
/,-,71 ",-!6-0,?1 ,/KL-*1 1 ,5;,1 M2-51
,</,?1 -!--0,1 ,6+*KL*1 6!"1 M,->1 +1 /6!;
-<0KL*1G1--<+*HK?1,:21-,2-,160=1
0-/*7?10,:,=6KL1M,H:<?1H,+:<118,0:<(171
6!",51 -,,>?1 <,0,1 -,, L-0,1 +"1 :,",0,,2>51
:/?1/,1551<?11!,01/H/,0?11+K ,1081
60+1 1 /0,1 0> ,1 ,6<1 -0,",1 <-1 01 <,0,<1 -,;
, L-01 1 -0,",1 , L-0,",1 -,*?1 ,G**1 <1-<><1 6+*1
",1-0, ,6!10> ,1-0,51-,2-,51-!67 >(1
1 !/,L*1 /, +<!?1 -,1 /,<7?1 2,1 /0,1 ,6,01 1
-<,,/6+165-0!101--<16!"G1/0?11",1,>1
.,<>1:0-*1,1!+7!,;-,2-G?1/,+2-G116!"G1
!-+,051 =:1 6,",1 ,61 1 6,",1 ",-!6-0(1 81 -06;
+7-0!1,/>1S,,-+7>5T10,/5-,51-,?1,+7,16,-;
,2,1 6++7,1 1 6<,2-,1 :01 H,+7,51 ",;
-!6-0,-1 -+!=1 /6/,->+,51 !/+*1 .6+:<?1
-*1 H,+7,;",-!6-0,51 , ,-, +,-(1 71 M,51
,21 :*1 /<+<1 6*1 I"! :HJ1 3,--?1 /,6<1
H,+7,;!+7!,510,,<51H,+7,;",-!6-0>G1
.,<1.6+:<?10>:>0KL*11=:1L1,6!1.,<!1/0,0,",1
"+:<191.555365581
H,+7,101",-!6-0,-1,6,013,--?1/,1<;
K1 O((160,-*?1 0>=-*1 01 -,+7-01 ",-!6-0;
,-11 :1M2-,51,1,",1+1,",1,6?1((1
,1",1-,2-,",1/,=0*Y1018,,<1/6-0;
+7-01 6,",1 ,61 01 ,"G1 ",-!6-0,51 0+-1 1
1
1
1
3
!/0+*Y1 01 :/+1 ,6,",1 *:>1 01 2-01 ",-!6-;
0,",110616+,/,:0,6-011<Y101-/H.1/<;
*1.6+7,",1:,,6+7-0?1!2>0KL",11+1>1
H,+7>1 ,-, ,-
%
(1 B--0,?1 2,1 0-1 M1 /:1
65-0+7,",1 -<,,/6+*1 ,61 01 .60,<1 ",-!;
6-0116,+=>1/,0,271/H/!1,+7,51H;
+,-,-1.6H?1/,!1.6+7,",1:,,6+7-0?1
:/+K1, L",1",-!6-0,",1*:>11,10-51
.6H?1/,+,<!10,/0K11/,/,H,+7,<!1/6-;
0+7-0!101,"G10+-11!/0+*1"=61I!+7,5J1
H,+7,-11(/(1
1-,0<>G1!-+,0*G101-,6=1/011-<,,/6;
+11/0,1<-,10>G,61<,10!1-<,,/6+;
(1,+*1+:H*1,6,<1-0,",1/011-<,,/6+1
:0-1 ,1 ,",?1 -, +K6K-*1 +1 01 65-0+7,-1 01 6,51
-1 /01 1 -0, ,6>1 "!//1 1 606,0?1 , :!KLG1 ,6(1
B-+1-!0,1",-!6-0,1"!1-0,<1-,"=6<1, ;
+61 0-<1 "=6-<1 1 /,+2-<1 /0<?1 <,=,1
-27?1 2,1 ,61 01 H+,<1 /,+7:!-*1 /0,<1 1 -<,,/6+;
?1-+1=1<1<-,1G1/,/?1,1/0,1,611-<,;
,/6+1!8-*(11
g+,-,-711- +7,-71.6H10,10:<,,,8;
*G1 -1 1 -,-0><1 2-*<1 91 .?1 ,/6+*<>51 /=61 0-",1
-,6=+7,?1/,+2-11-,H,!+7!,?1G,*11+7:*1";
,,071/,:0!K1,+711-<,-,*+7,1:21,-;
!H,,;/0,0>G1,<(1"0>12>1,--5-,",1.6;
+:<1 ,6+<>1 ,1 , L",1 :-,",1 -,-,**1 ,--5-,",1
-,H!<?1 *0+**-71 1 ",1 :!+7,<1 1 /2,5(1 1 M,<1 -<>-+1
/, +<>1.6+:<191-,-0*12-71 ,+1, L511"+! ,,51
/, +<>1!/+*1",-!6-0,-101H+,<?1.,<,0*1
0+-?1 +"<,51 <,+7,1 1 -,H+7,?1 <KL51 0*!K1
/,"<<!1 65-05?1 21 6!G,0,;0-0>1 ,>?1
/-+6!KL51H+1, L",1 +"(1
A,1G1/,?1/,1H,-1/0?1-0, ,6>1+2,-?1, L-;
0>G1--,HH511-,K:,011-!16,<!KL<101-,:;
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
1 7<(11 "E3F6957 5'1 3,--5-51 .6+:<1 1 -,0<>51 H,+7,;
",-!6-0>51"+:<1331E,-!6-0,11/0,(1%EEF(1Q1%$(17(1&(1
1
3
1 /,+2-G1 M+1 :,",1 !,0*?1 /,0,2*1 .6+7;
,511",+7>G10+-511 !6!10>G,671:1/6+>1,.;
,6+7,",1 -/,1 <=6!1 -K:,<1 1 ",1 0--+<?1 ,,>5?1
/06?1-52-18-*1-,101/,+7:!1-!0191!/+<1
/-+,0!,51I0+10+-J?1-,/*=,51-1006<1.6;
+7>G1 ,!",01 1 -!1 /,+/6,0?1 ,<,51 0> ,,-1
/:6,01 -/! +1 1 "+01 , +->G1 S0>GT1 6<-;
H5(17,6=<1=1M,51 ,7 >1/<!L-0,1*0+*-*1/;
-/6+1 -, -0,-?101 /0!K1 ,2671 1/,6>1
-!->11:0+<!K1:1G1->70!K1!(11M,<101-,,;
1 ,-K-*1 0,/,->1 M..0,-1 M,,<?1 :0*1 /6;
/<+7-0?1 6+,0,51 H0>?1 -,:6*1 ,2G1 <-(1
/<?11,<214((1E ,0?1I2,0251/,:0,+?1 :;
:,?1 ::,-71 ,6+7>G1 6,+=,->G1 +H1 1 70;
,<1 80:1 ,-, ,1 ,206>?1 Z/G,6-*1 ,-,07?1
2,1 1CA?11/,!!>?11-!6>10,1<,"G1 -! PG1-0,;
0:-,",1",110-"61:LLK1/012+,0?11,"61
6=1-+!=1<+7,<!1<!J
%
(1
1 ,,>G1 -,2G1 ,--5-51 .6+:<1 ,/6+*;
-*101 2-01 I.0,",J?1I<H,,",J11(6(1 ?1(C(1
A, >1 :>01 ",1 I.,<><J?1 /,6:!<0*1 I,1 -,;
-,*1 ",-!6-0>G1 1 /0,0>G1 -!,0?1 /1 ,,,<1
:.-,0*1 01 ,<G1 /01 ,-!H*1 .60>G1 ,;
,851 :2+7,1 ,+2-*1 ,1 +7,1 -+,=085-*1 1 -!;
L-0!1 --<>51 :>01 <=6!1 6+,0><1 1 65-0;
+7><1-,-,*<1 ",-!6-0,51 --<>J
#
(1 06?1 !6,1
-,"+-7-*1-10>06<10,,<1I.,<,-J?161L1012;
-01,-,0,",1/:?1:1-<<1.60,",1!-,5-;
0191/,+2-,",?1/0,0,",11M,,<2-,",10-0(1;
60,1 ",-!6-0,?1 1 -06+7-0!1 <,0,51 ,/>?1 <,;
=1 >711-<<2><?11/1M,<10/,+1=:-/,-, ,511
6<2,1:00KL5-*1--<,5(1181/, +<>1-<;
<?1/,;8<!1<K?16,1-G,671:1,",?12,11-!L;
-0!1=-,51:0-<,-11.,<>1",-!6-0,",1!-,5;
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
1463F71UL1/011-0, ,612+,01910=5851-,-0,51M+<1/1,-!L-0;
+1",-!6-0,51H,+7,51/,+1331E,-!6-0,11/0,(1#$$)(1Q1%(17(#&(1
#
1 ,64-5A57 (1 ,0>51 .6+:<11 <,6+71 !6!L",1 ",-!6-0,",1 !-,5-01
3,--5-,516H(1,0,- -?1#$$R(17(''(1
1
1
1
!
3
-0?111<,6+51.6H?1,1:<,01,?11,!;
?1+68.11+<(18,</+-10-G1/<,01=:1",-!;
6-01/,,=61,",<,12-+,1,< H5?1.,<1",-!6-;
0,",1!-,5-01:0-1,1, L-0,;/,+2-,",1-,*?1
!,0*1 -,H+7,;M,,<2-,",1 :0*1 ->?1 M2-,",1
-,-01 -+*1 1 /,8+,",1 01 <=M2-G1 ,,8*G?1 ,1
/,+,=*1",-!6-0101<=6!,6,<1-,, L-011(6(1C-;
8 >1 -/6+*1 0+-?1 -/71 0,,<,-1 1 -<,-,*;
+7,-1,+7>G1/,6:6+51",-!6-01-,+7,1
:,, :>1 01 -0,G1 ,>G1 /,*0+*G?1 2,1 /,60-1 G1
/,61!K;+ ,1,6!;6-0!K1I/0+7!KJ1<,6+71/,-,1
0,:<,=,1S,-K610,1<,",<1-G,+-2-51G1-/,,0101
851+!1,1.6+:<?101,,,<1-,,>1I1-+>8J1
6!"16!"?1/2<1/,+*,-71,21:*1!:>011/,+;
2-!K1"=,0,-7T(16+:<1<,=1/<71.,<>?1
01,<12-+11:0->1?1,11,-,01!0-+:!KL51
,+1-, +K6*1,-,0>G1/011-0, ,612+,011"=6(1
,1,"61 !616,"<2><1 ,01!-*1-<<101
.60>G1 ,,8*G1 1 /<,",1 !-+,0*1 0,/;
0*1-! P,01.6H(1
I,<,-7J1=1851.6H191/*<,1/,,=611
/,6,+=1 I<<,",1 ,-!H,+:<J1 ,--5-,51 /,+;
,;/0,0,51--<>?1,1-7?1/,<<?16+0,",1G;
1 0-51 -!H,+7,;,<0,51 --<>1, L-01/1
-,G1 0,:<1 1 K,:<?1 /,-*1 6;
H51<,,/,+:H10+-11-0>0*16<,(1,+2;
-*1--<1/**185?1,-,0*11/!6+7,<11
H+:,0,<1-/6+1-!-,01+K ,",1,6101;
-G1 !:,51 "!//>1 , +6+51 ""-,51 -, -0,-1 1 //;
1/!=6*?1/H/+7,1-,0<-<1-1H+*<1/0,;
0,",1",-!6-011"=6-,",1, L-0(1
1-<,<1, L<106181/, +<1,2-0,",1.6;
+:<1-,/*=,1-1!/+<1-!12-,51-, -0,-11
>,2>G1 <G:<,01 "=6-,",1 , L-0?1 :0-<,-7K1
-6-01 <--,0,51 .,<H?1 /,+2-<1 1 6,+,"2-<1
/+K+:<,<?1-+,0,<?1/,1/!16,-=*10-1 ,+7851<>1-,H;
+7,511606!+7,51-0, ,6>(1A0=11M<1H+*<1/,1, ;
1
"
3
G,6<,-1 1 <,=1 1 >71 6++7><?1 /,M/><?1 ,/6+*;
<><1 /,+2-,51 /,0-,51 6*?1 :/+*<><1 6,-"!><1
!,0<1 <=M2-,",1 -,"+-*1 1 ,+,-1 "=6?1 !+7;
!,",1/+K+:<11,-0,*1, L2+,02-G1H,-5(1
F P0,?1 -<,51 /,61 .6+:<1 /-!L1 /,0,;
21 <=6!1 H,-<+7><1 1 H, =><1 6;
H*<?1 /,6, ,1 , P0,-1 /,0,251 <=6!1 !6,<1 1
/+,<?1 !/0+*KL<1 1 !/0+*<><(1 -1 ,1 /-!L1
--<1 , L-0>G1 ,,85?1 -,:60<>G1 2+,02-,51
6*+7,-7K?1-+6,0+7,?11/,<71G1-,6=?11,;
-!0,1 :871 , G,6<,1 -1 !2,<1 -,0?1 2!0-01 1
H,-5?1 ,/6+*KLG1 M!1 6*+7,-7(11M,<1 /+1=:71
.60,",1 ",-!6-01 /6-0+*1 -, ,51 /,H--1 /,-,*;
,",1-,"+-,0*1-,0/6KLG1-,01:+2>G1-,H+7;
>G1"!//?101/0!K1,267191M2-G11,+7>G(1
,1<,"G1-,2G?1, LKLG-*11-,<1/,0,;
251 ,--5-,",1 .6+:<?1 ",1 8,<!?1 !-,520,<!1 -,;
-,*K?1 0-1 :2-!K1 -0,6-*1 1 /-+,0!,<!1 I/6!1 -!0;
,0J?1:+,510,+1M2-G11",+7>G1M+?1/-+6!K;
LG1 -0,1 0+->1 < H(1 C=6!1 <1 -/:<1 01 3,--1 91
:,,<,-71<,6:H,>G1H+,0?10>:>0<*1-/6,<1
",-!6-0?1,-,<16:,":H11,.+,<1-,-0>G12-;
51",-!6-0?1,-, ,1,"61,,1",<6,1/,1:<<1;
,11,+2-0!1,6,0?1-,-0+*KLG1",1-+(1
5 +:H*1 /,+2-,",1 =<?1 208*-*10<-1 -1
/-,5,5?1 , !=+1 :*6,1 :,<>-+1 01 , L-01
/=",1I<,+7,;/,+2-,",16-0J?1-/1-<>G1:;
,, :>G1 <,0,::2-G1 1 6,+,"2-G1 ,H5(1
7,1+1!60+*7-*10:>0<12!0-011M<,H51/,1/,0,6!1!L<+;
*?165-0+7,",1+1<<,",?1H,+7>G12-116,-,;
-0?16-<H1/,1M2-,<!1/:!(1D616<,;
?10-0?1--0>G1/011 -0, ,6?1-,/*=>1-1 /;
0,<1,6,011-<,,/6+?101,-1/=",1=,;
0*1,6,0101G1.,<1/,+2-,51-<,-,*+7,-?1
:,,<,1 0>:0+1 /,6P<1 M2-,",1 -<,-,:*1 1
I0,,-,>GJ11I7-,>GJ1,6,0(11
1
1
1
#
3
7,:6>1 01 -,0-,1 0<*1 .,<>1 /,+2-,51 1 !+7;
!,510,,<16+*1<,"G1,6,01 >08513,--5-,51</;
1,:+?1,-, ,101/0>16-*+*?1!-,*KL10,:65;
-011G1-,H+7,;M,,<2-,?1/,+2-,11!+7!,1
:0(1O,->;,6,-1/-+101M,H?1!/+*+1
-0,1-<,-,:?10,/1,"2*<1I-0G!J?11/,H+1
/,0,65-0*1/,016H,+7,51S</-,5T16!>1
/5,;",-!6-0,51 K,(1 A!",1 6+,?1 2,1 I!1
H,+7,",1 ",-!6-0J1 01 !-+,0*G1 /-,51 1 :-1
-,K:,",1 ",-!6-01 -1 !-/G,<1 :>">0+1 ,<+!>1
M+>1-/! +110,,<5?101,<12-+10!*1/:11
1-,K:,51 K,?1116!"<1,6<(11
D-G,6*1:1/,1H,-51"=6-,",1, L-0?1<>1
/,66=0<1 /,:HK?1 -<>-+1 ,,,51 -,-,1 01 ,<?1 2,1 I0-1
,6>?1 -+*KL1 -!?1 /:K-*1 ",-!6-0,;
, :!KL<?111,61M2-*1"!//11<,=1116,+=1
, +671/<!L-0><1/0,<11,,+7161,;
5?1-!<10+-11/,6><1-!-<(130-0,1/01
1, *:,-51, !-+,0+01, G,6<,-71-,,6,0>G1
851 -1 !2,<1 -,01 :+2>G1 H,+7>G1 "!//1 1
/1-, +K616<,2-G1/011-0, ,612+,0110-51
,1 ->J
%
(1 F021 6!G!1 1 /H/<1 "=6-,",1
, L-01 1 :01 H,+7,;!+7!>G1 0,,<5?1 -/,;
-, >G1-,27-*116,/,+*71H,+7,;,+7>10;
,,<?10>-!/*1" ,51.,<,51-<,,/6+*1,6,0?1G,*1
1 /1 M,<1 -+6!1 /,<71 /,1 0,:<,=,-71 M,2-,",1
:G01 H,+7,;!+7!,51 0,,<1 01 H+*G?1 /,0,;
2LG11-G,6><1/H/<(1
/,+1 :!<,1 /6+,=16+*1H+7,51 S.6+7,5T1
0+-1-,71I-0,10:<,,,8*1-1H,+7><1, :,0;
*<191-/! +<?10,,<><1, +-*<110,,<><1,;
!"<19116,",0,,51,-,01S=++7,1<-<+7,1!.H;
,0,T?1((?1/,;,<!?12<1-1, >2><1-! P<1916<-;
0><1 , +-*<J
#
(1 7/,>1 ,,-+7,1 ,+7,51 ,";
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
1 97 *(1 1 /-G1 <,6:H1 ,--5-,",1 .6+:<1 331 +-7(1 #$$#(1
Q1%%(17(#F(1
#
197*(11/-G1<,6:H1,--5-,",1.6+:<(17()R(1
1
$
3
:H1 0+-1 ,"61 !/!-K1 :1 06!?1 2,1 /H/1 -6=1 1
/,0,0-,01 1 0=5851 ,"2+71 <,,/,+:H1 0+-1
-/,-*-*111I0+7,J1:6+10+-5(18,"61-;
",6*1!0=6-*?12,13,--1 +=?1,"21!*1.,<1
",-!6-0,",1 !-,5-0?1 1 >851 .6+:<1 /G,6-*1
/71:;:1!",:>1-/61->101-+!21,:1,1",?1,1:1
/,6, ><1 :-,<1 ->0-*1 1 -,+7,1 /++*H*1 1 !+7!,;
H0+:H,><1 ,-, ,-*<1 3,--?1 -,+7,1 ,-H*1 ;
!<*1S+1=+*T10>-071 ,+1-+,=>11" 1.,;
<>1:6+*10+-5(1
262,51/6-0+*-*1.,<!+14(4(1C+!<,011I6;
+:<191,<+7>5?1/2>51061,/<:H1,+7,;
/,+2-G1-0*:510!1,",1+1,",1/,+2-,",1-,, ;
L-0J
%
(1 :<,,,8*1 H1 1 ",,01 0-"61 /6-0;
+*K1-, ,51,/6+!K1<!1-,2*1H+:H?1-1,6,51
-,,>?1 1 -<,-,*+7,-?1 -1 6!",5(1 F/>1 <,0,51 -,1
6<,-!1 !+,,1 -8*1 /,+,<,251 1 ,</;
H1-! P,01.6H(1AH+:H*10+->G1/,+,<,251
/,:0,+*1",+7><11<-><1,"<10+-1,0-0,1
/<71 8*1 /,1 =:,1 0=><1 0,/,-<?1 ,/0,1
",07110,:KL1/, +<>(11
7,0<,-71-016+<<!11+1.6H*191-,K:1-! P;
,0?101,,,<1IH+7*J?11",+7*?11<-*10+-71
-!<+7>1 /,1 ,,8K1 1 "=6<?1 G1 /, ,-*<?1
-<?1H,-*<?1 +1=1/61<1,26,1:610;
,,",1/+:<(1:<>51,,+71.6+7,510+;
-1 1 0+-1 -! P,01 .6H1 6,+=1 , !-+0+07-*1 ,;
,+<1:1-, +K6<11:L,51/011-0, ,61"=6(10,;
2+,<18*10,/,-?1-G,6><1/H/,<?1:6KL<1,;
H/!+7!K1<!?1<1/6,-0+*-*1.,<!+?1/6+,=*1
O((160,-*,<11I6H*11-! P1.6H191",-!6-0,1
-710,:2>?1:,!,00>1",-!6-0(1D1,2,11=1
1 2-71 /,1 ,/6+K1 1 <,=1 1 1 6,+=1 -,*71 0>81 1
6=11,6,<1!,01-1H+><?111",-!6-0,191-! P1.6;
H1 1 *0+*-*1 0,/0><?1 0,:2><1 -1 .6H5?1 /,;
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
1(3CD6F7160>1/H/>1",-!6-0,",1!-,5-011,H/!+7>51
-/1331F L-0>1!11-,0<,-7(1#$$%(1Q1@(17(FF(1