Ершов Ю.Г. Философия права
Подождите немного. Документ загружается.
1
1
1
3
><?1"!//,0><11606!+7><1-<?1606>1-+;
0K-*1 -1 6+<<,511 + ,1 G,-1 1 G*?1 20>1 -+<1 1
0:<,- +<?1+ ,1/6-:!<>5?10-, L511H+-,, ;
:>51 /,*6,(1 2<1 01 M,<1 ,-1 0=,1 /,62!71
6K1D(4(1D+71,,-+7,1/,6>1/! +2,;0+-,",1;
"!+,0*1 2+,02-G1 0:<,,,8511 IA,+=1 >71
,,2+7,1 ,0"!1 " +7>51 /6--!6,1 ,1 I085J1
/,61/011",-!6-0?16,+=1 >71!-<,11!-0,1G1
I0!**J?1 I6!80,;6!G,0*1 -!L,-7J
%
(1 ,1 D(4(1 D+7!?1
:21/0101,<?12, >1-,:6071016!812+,01<,0>1
6+*1+!28",1/,06*(1:1/,+,=+7,",1/01-,-,1
01,<?12,12+,0?1!-<,01-1,206,-7K1",1, P0,1-,;
6=11, P0,1:2?1-<1, *=1- *1-, +K671",1
/0+?1,!-*11G11,+7,101-+!2*G1/**1-,:;
+7>G185?1,11-0,G1/,-6-0>G1/,>0G11;
-0>G1/, !=6*G(
#
1
F* 7-51/0,,1%E%'1",61, ,0+1I- *>510J1
!--,51!+7!>?101,<12-+1101:01,2-0,",1I0,:;
,=6,",1 --0,",1 /0J(1 1 -,0-51 /,61 , L-;
0,",1 :0*1 -<1 <1 I$55$1 &36*1 !/, +*+-*1
1211-1M/,<1I !=!:*J?1/,16,+,"2-<1/2;
<1,H+-71-<1, G,6<,-711-!L-0,0*11,;
2-,51 1 !2 ,51 6-H/+>(1 B--0,?1 2,1 .+,-,.-,;
/0,0>1 /, +<>1 : >0+-71 ,1 -+!2*1 1 -+!2K?1 .";
<,1 1/,62,1 I:> +<><1-<J16,"<:,0;
,51 .+,-,.1 1 6,+,"(1 ,+7,1 01 /,--,0-51 /,61 01
,2-0,51+!1-+1/,*0+*7-*1-7?1<,,".11
!2 1/,1.+,-,.1/0(1F02*1/, ,-1/,6,+*1
K62-,",1 6,"<:<?1 8*1 <,6,+,"2-G1 /, +<1
/0,0,",1 /,:*?1 /,0>8*1 !+7!>1 /0,0,",1 <>8+*?1
,1/,1-K1/,!1-/+>02>101/,<1-<,",1/6<1.;
+,-,.1 /0(1 A-!--,><1 ,-K-*1 1 /, +<1 1
.!H?1-/H.1/<*<>G1<,6,0?1-,,,81-1,;
51",-!6-011/0(1
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
1!)A57!1F1-!L,-1/0,-,:*1331D+71D(4(17,2(111#1(11C(?1%EER(1(%(17(#'F(1
#
1!)A57!(17, (1],2(111%$1(1(@(11C(?1%EE@(17(1%&$9%&#(1
1
3
F61 :1 /0,2+7>G1 0,01 ,/6+*1 /6<1
.+,-,.1/6-0+1,2,51:*1A(4(8<,0(1F1-2+?1
2,1I/6<1.+,-,.1/01<,=,1 ,G:,0711:;
,!1+,"?16+11,1/,:*1/0,0,",1 >*J
%
(1
,1/,<1.+,-,.1/010+K21011/6<!K1, ;
+-71.+,-,.K11,K1/,:*?1, L!2>1<,6>?1,G;
0>0KL1 /,61 M"6,51 .+,-,.1 <=6-H/+>1 -0*:?1
2-,!2>1 1 -/H+7>1 <,6>1 /,:*?1 0>=KL1 01
,+7851 -/1 !=1 /,6!1 /0,0,",1 :*(1 C,6,+,"2;
-1.!H1.+,-,.1/0101M,<1-+!21, L>11+:!1
/!511<,6,01/,:*1/010,10-<1",1, P<?10!G1
-0*:51 1 6H51 :,,<,",1 :0*1 /0,0>G1 *0+51 01
G16-0?1H+,-,-11--<,-(1
?1 /<?1 ,/6+71 K62-,1 :21 G1 ;
",51 1 I0J1 1 I,0-0,-7J?1 :1 +:1 G1 -0*:1 -1
-,6=<1 .+,-,.-G1 ",51 I/2J1 1 I-+6-0J1
0,:<,=,Y1/, +<1 /2,51-0*:101/01<11,+7,1
!0-+7,;,2-,?1 ,1 1/,-6-0,1 /2-,1
:2(1F10>G,611810,/,-,01,1-,,,810,:;
<,=,-1165-0+7,-?1-0, ,6>11, G,6<,-?1;
-?1H+110,+101/0?11,/6+1->11(6(11M,<16;
+,110-"61/0,06>1,:>0K-*116,+=,<1!,01:*1
,-,01.+,-,.-,51,11<,6,+,"(11 11
1 2-01 /<1 <,=,1 !/,<*!71 6-!--K?1 :";
0KL!K1/, +<!1K62-,",1/,<*1->(17",6*1.;
+,-,.-1 0><1 0>"+*6*11 6*1 ,1 0,:<,=,-1 6,-=*1
-,+K,51->101-!6 ,51/Y1/,0,/,-0+1-;
>1 1 :!+71 K62-,51 ,H1 /-!/+*101 -!6 ;
,<1: +7-011,H1, L-0,;/,+2-,51,/-,;
-1-,08,",1/-!/+*?10,111/6-0+1,1.;
G1 /01 01 2-01 -,+K,51 02,51 ->
#
(1 7,0<,1
/,<1->11.,<>16*+7,-1-! P1/,:*11
65-0*1-0*:,1-110+K2<101I65-0+7,-7J116!G,0;
!K1+7,-7(1-H1-0*:1->1-1/,+:,-7K1:511
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
13AD6F7,16<1.+,-,.1/01331E,-!6-0,11/0,(1%EE@(1Q'(1
#
17<(1/<119C6F7'!1D-101!",+,0,<1-!6,/,:0,6-01331-1C,-,0;
-,",(1!;(17(1%%(1%EE)(1Q1RY1--.7'(1,-!1+1,<>1:,,01->V1331
E,-!6-0,11/0,(1%EEF(1Q1'(1
1
1
1
3
-0*:11/,+,>1-12<10<1<,6,+,"2-1,,1
-,,0-0!1 -!=61 ,1 ,<?1 2,1 -1 /,<,L7K1 -!6 ,51 0-1
I!-0+0K-*1,+7,1.>11 , -,*+7-0?1 <KL1!",;
+,0,;/0,0,1:2(((1/6<,<1-+6-0,510-1*0+*;
K-*11+K >1.>11, -,*+7-0?11+871-!L-0>16+*1
--+6!<,",16+11+87101"HG1/6<1!",+,0,;/,H-;
-!+7,",1 6,:>0*J
%
(1 D+1 =?1 /<?1 !:>01 ((1
702,011IZ-<81/,*51I,-,0J11I!-+,0J1S.+,;
-,.-G1",5(191/$(T1+,=+,1-0,51,/2,111/,;
<1/,**1 I*01-1 /,0,5J(1,,>1 K->1!0=6;
K?1 2,1 *01 -1 /,0,51 *0+*-*1 ,-,0<1 ,-0, ,=6*1 ,1
!",+,0,51 ,0-0,-?1 2,1-(1')1->01<,1*0!1-1
/,0,5?1 2,1 ,-+7>1 , -,*+7-01 ,-0, ,=6*?1 /2-;
+>1 01 6,51 -7?1 1 >1 6,/,+*K1*0!1 -1/,0,5?1 1/,1
,+78,<!1-2!1G1+211, *:+7,(1C=6!1<1,+7,1-!<;
<10-G1/2-+>G1016-/,:H12(1%(1-(')128131, P0>G1
1 -! P0>G1 !-+,051 -,-0+*1 ,-,01 91 -,0,!/,-71 6,;
/!-<>G1 6,-,2>G1 /:,01 6+*1 ,-0, ,=6*1 ,1 !",+,0,51
,0-0,-
#
(1
5,",;<,6,+,"2-*1 .!H*1 .+,-,.1 /01 /,1 ,;
,8K11K-/!6H1<1 ,+10=?12,1!"+! +1/,;
H--1/,:*1/01 0>0,61:1/6+>1-!!,51,":;
H1K62-,",1:*1S/+6>1 !191,-+0>191-;
,,;,2-T(17",6*1:01"=6-,",1/01;
<>-+<,101M,,<2-,51,?1!",+,0,",19101<6H>1
1 /-G,+,"?1 6<-0,",1 91 01 ,1 !/0+*?1 -;
<5,",19101M11(6(11
G2-51/,"--1/0,611,<!?12,101/0,/<;
+7,516*+7,-10-1 ,+781<-,1:<K1/-!/+*1
1/,-!/?1-0*:>1-1-/,+7:,0<1G2-G1!-,5-01
:+2,",1 :2*11 M,+,"2-?1 -/,>?1 /,=>1 1
0:>0>?1 -0*:>1 -1 -/,+7:,0<1 G?1 1 <,",1 6!",(1
,M,<!1 ,+,=,51 /2-,51 :6251 -,0-*1 ,2*1
0+.H*1 IG2-GJ1 /0,!85?1 , -/20KL*?1
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
17<(110A5A570017+6-0>10-101!",+,0,;/,H--!+7,<16,:>01331
3,--5-51K62-51=!+(1%EER(1Q1#(1
#
1F32C6F7''14!+7>10,/,->1,-0, ,=6*1,1!",+,0,51,0-0,-101-0*;
:1-16*+7><1-*<1331E,-!6-0,11/0,(1%EEE(1Q1%#(17(1)R9))(1
1
3
-1,6,51-,,>?1<-<+7>51M..1-+>1:,?1-16!",5191
-+K2KL*10,:<,=,-71/2*1!L 1, L-0!11"=;
6!1 /<<1 , ,-,0>G1 -H5(1 3:!<-*?1 6+*1
,",12, >1871M!1/, +<!?1, G,6<,1-1 ,+7851,2;
,-7K1/6-0+*71-,-01/0,!8*101/,+,510:<,-0*;
:1 0-G1 , :!KLG1 ",1 /:,0?1 ,=KLG1 -!L-0>1
M+<>1/,-G,6*L",1-, >*(1
,M,<!?1 61 +1 271 , 1 ,/6+1 /,+2-,51 /;
-!/,-1+1!-,0+1/:,01!8*1H,+7,",1
1-,0,",10,/0*?1,1/0,0,<1"!+,01,G>1,!;
=KL51 -6>1 +1 , 1 !",+,0,;/0,0>G1 /, +<G1 -/+;
H1,",011512+,0?1910,10-G1MG1-+!2*G1-, -0;
,1/0,0,?1K62-,?181,-,0>0-*11/6<,<1
-,6=1 ,/6+,",1 061 2+,02-,51 6*+7,-?1
0+K2,51 01 .!H,,01 !+7!>?1 , L-01 01 H+,<(1
7+6,0+7,?1 1 6,+K1 .+,-,.1 /01 0>/61 +:H*1
"0,51 .!H1 .+,-,.1 /,1 , , LK1 :!+7,01
:0*1 0-51 --<>1 !2,",1 :*1 /<+7,1 1 K-;
/!6H?1 0>*-K1 , L",1 G1 1 /0+,-1 G1
0:<,65-0*(11
!2,1/,:1/0,0,51,<>11,"20-*1,+7,1
--+6,0<11-!!,51,":H?1:,0,51.,<>10>;
=*?1/,51 +:H?1,1 -1 , G,6<,-7K1/6/,+;
"10>*-1-,2-G11-,H+7>G1!-+,0511/211
/,*0+*?1 M..0,-1 65-0*1 M,51 ,<>1 1 "!+*HK1
, L-0>1 ,,8*1 1 /,061 "=6(1 F-K61 -+6!1
0>0,61 ,1 ,<?1 2,1 /0,1 91 -+,=>51 -,H+7>51 .,<?1 0+K;
2>51 01 .!H,,01 1 :01 , L-01 1 --<>1
:,, :>G1, L-0>G1,,85191M,,<2-G?1/,+;
2-G?1 0-0>G?1 6<,".2-G1 1 (6(1 ,M,<!1 0,:;
<,=,1 1 , G,6<,1 -071 0,/,-1 ,1 0:<,65-01 , L51
,1/011-,H+7,51.+,-,.11.!6<+7,",1:;
6+1, L51.+,-,.(11
,+1,",?1-,*1.+,-,.11/0,0,51,1/,:>0;
?12,1<,10181/, +<1:,,<,-51, L-0,;
",1:0*?1,/6+1-,01+--,011-,H+7>G1"!//?1
0>*-16!G1M/,G1G,6*1,=16!"1016!"1.+,-,.*1
1
1
1
3
1/0,(12<1M18*101, ,G1-+!2*G1<,"+10>=7-*101
0-7<1 , , L,51 1 ,0+2,51.,<?1/<*1061 :+2;
,;!0-+7>G1/H/,0(10,-,:101-0,51H,+7;
,; -,51.,<10>G,611!,071, L51,1,1/,;
611:21, L-0112+,0?1-<>*-7101-0,<1-,6=;
1 -1 , +-7K1 -, -0,1 .+,-,.-G1 0,/,-,0?1 6=1 /6;
-0+**1-, ,51, :?101-,H+7,51.+,-,.(14-16,+;
=1 <71 0*,1 /6-0+1 , 1 ,-,0>G1 2G1 1 :,,;
<,-*G1:0*1, L-0?1/2G?10>:>0KLG160,1
/,06?1 /-!/,-7?1 /0,0,51 "+:<?1 0:<,65-01
:+2>G1.,<1, L-0,",1-,:*(1
1 -,0<>G1 .+,-,.-,;/0,0>G1 --+6,0*G1 ;
!+,,10,:-1,+71,/,+,"1/0?1:00KL5-*101
-<,-,*+7!K1 ,2-!K1 1 !2 !K1 6-H/+!(1 O,1
-0*:,11-1, L<1,/,+,"2-<1/,0,,,<101-,0<;
,51.+,-,.1101H+,<1, L-0,:?111-1/<1
"=6-,",1, L-011/0,0,",1",-!6-0?1!",+7><1
<<1,,>G1*0+*K-*1/011-0, ,6>12+,0(11H0+;
:,0,<1, L-012+,010-101 ,+7851-/1, 1:;
<1 I2+,01 K62-,",J1 S^_`_1 abcded]bfT?1 /0,0,1
>1 ,,,",1 -,-0+*1 0=>51 <,<1 606!+7,",1 1
-,H+7,",1 >*(1B-+1/0,0!K1,K1-!101/0!K1
,2671-!H,+7,1 >1/0?1,1/0,0!K1,/,;
+,"K1 -!1 M<,H,+7,;0,+0,?1 -,+,"2-,1 ,;
,81 2+,01 1 /0!1 91 01 :0-<,-1 ,1 ",1 M2-,5?1
!+7!,;H0+:H,,51 62,-(1 1 /0,0,51 ,;
/,+,"1 1 /651 /+1 0>G,6*1 "!<-2-1 -/>1
",-!6-0,;/0,0,516*+7,-191/0,0*1!+7!12;
+,011, L-0?1/-G,+,"*1/0?1-0, ,612+,01016;
-011"511,"25(1
g0+:H*10>:0+11=:1.+,-,.K11-<,-,*+7;
,1 ,2-,1 --!=6?11 -<+1/,*71 -,1 1
!-,5-0,1<101H+,<11-,H+7,51=:1012-,-(1g0;
+:H*1=1/,,6+1/0,2+7,101+,1.+,-,.11,;
2-,1/0,-,:?1-<!1I6K1/0J(1,1,,8K1165;
-0!KL<!1 /0!?1 ,.,<+,<!1 :,,6+7,?1 .+,-,.*1
/01-,G*1-0,K1,,-+7!K1-<,-,*+7,-7(171-<,;
1
3
",1 2+1 ,1 0>-!/1 1 ,-,:1,-,051/0,/,*6(1
,:6?1 01:0>G1 /0,0>G1 --<G?1M1,-,0*1!=1 0G,;
6*101-<,1-,6=1:,,6+7-0?1-/,+7:!K-*1165;
,1,/061",-!6-0,510,+1+1=?1, ,,?1.+,-,;
.*1/010>-!/1-1,51+2>G1K62-G1--<11
/0,/,*6?1 *0+**-71 -0,, :><1 I-!6,<1 :!<J1 61 65-;
0!KL<1/0,<?1/,0,/,-0+**1<!1>1/0,0>1/H/>1
+1 :00*1 6+781 /=(1 81 /-+1 B((! H,5?1
I(((-,*1/,:>0?12,10-*51/,"--1/,+,=+7,",1/;
01 , !-+,0+1 2-<1 ,,8<1 1<!?1 1*1 1
0,:<,=1,+7,11/,201/0,0,",16+J
%
(1
,6, >51 ,.+1 G1 1 ,+7,1 6+*1 0:<,,,;
8*1.+,-,.11/0?1,+71-,,101<10>=K-*1+7>1
/,0,2*1 M/,G?1 /,0,/,+,=,-71 -,H+7,;+--,0>G1
0,::5?1 -<1 ,6,",1 , L-0,",1 -,*1 6!"<(1 U6-71 ",1
-0,, :1-,-,101,<?12,1,.H+7,1,2-,1/0,;
-,:1 -+6!1 :1 0,+51 ",-!6-0?1 ,"61 1 .+,-,.-,1
<>8+1,+7,11*0+*-*1,0><?1,"61-0, ,6,1,1/!=;
6*?12751 >1,11 >+,108510,+(1,1/,:1-!L,-1
/0?1 "+! ,,1 /,,01 01 -+,=>1 /0,0>1 *0+*1 1
/,H-->1 0,:<,=>1 01 <G1 ,+7,1 K62-,51 6,"<(1
5871 ->01 ,"2-,1 6-0,1 /01 1 :,,<,-51
-,2-,",1 /,H--1 1 H+,-,",1 :0*1 , L-0?1 <,=,1
/,*71-,11/,6!1/0,0>G1,<?1-!,0?1G1.!H1
1,+7101, L-0,<1/,"--(1
1<G1.+,-,.1/01,-,10-10,/,-1,1,<?11
.+,-,.-1 ,-,0>?1 H,-1 65-0+7,1 ,02K1 ;
-<1+K65?1*0+*K-*1, L2+,02-<?111-0*:>1-1,2!;
=6<12+,011",1/, ,L<(1+,-,.-,51/, +<,5?1
/*<!K1 -0*:,51 -1 /,0-60,51 =:7K1 =6,",1 2+,0?1
*0+*-*10,/,-1,1,<?12,1-71:,(1F1",18*1:0-?1;
<1 >71 /0,/,*6!1 1 , L-0,<!1 -,KY1 >71 +1 <!1
/!=6KL<1/:,<10+-?1/0LKL<12+,0101 1
M,51 0+-?1 +1 0>=<1 -,+K,51 H,-1 2+,0?1
/68-0!KL",1",-!6-0!(14+,"2,11/=610-",1<,=;
,1/,-0710,/,-1, 1-G,6,<1/,<1/0(181/-+1:;
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
17<(11! H,51B((15H1/,1MH+,/61/0(1C(?1%E%R(17('F(1
1
1
1
!
3
<2+7>51 ,--5-51 K-1 1 .+,-,.1 (D(1,0",,6H0?1
I,"61 ,0"K1 /0,1 01 -<,51 6?1 :>0*1 ",1 -+<?1 ,1
<K10106!1/0,11/,,=61-+>11/,:0,+11: >0K1
/0,110>=1-/06+0,-11-0, ,6>191,1/0,?1,,;
,1:60106,G,0+*+,11/,60"111 ,7 !11,,,10-"61
/,2+,-71-0*L><16,-,*<1+HJ
%
(1<1-<><1.+,-,.*1
/01 -,0-*1 -/,-, ,<1 6!G,0,",1 !0=6*1 1 -<,!0;
=6*12+,02-,51+2,-?112-116,-,-0?1!+7;
,-110,,<(1
--,,1/,:1/0?1/,,0101",1-!L,-71
0,:<,=>1 ,+7,1 +871 01 "HG1 -, -0,1 K62-,51
,?16=1-+127161, 1, L51,1/0(1!2,1/,;
:1/0,0,51,<>11<,=1,"207-*1,+7,1+:,<1
1 , ,-,0<1 1 -!!,51 ,":H?1 /1 /<;
*11(/(1, G,6<1!21H+,-,",1-,2-,",11-,H+7,;
",1 ,-1 1 -,:6*1 1 .!H,,0*?1 M..0,-1
0,:65-0*11,+7,11"!+!<,1, L-0,1,,8?1
,1 1 01 H+,<1 1 =:71 , L-01 1 606,0(1 IW+,02-5J1
-<>-+1/0?1",10+K2,-7101--<!1<,",, :>G1, L-;
0>G1,,85?1-<1,+71/0101:01H0+:H1910-1
M,1 /,0>81 ,+71 1 :21 .+,-,.1 6+*1 /,<*1 /01
1 .,<1 , L-01 1 !+7!>(1 D<,1 1 ,/6+*?1 /,1
-!?1/6<1.+,-,.1/01(7(1--*H11I+,-,.*1/;
01:<-*1--+6,0<1-<>-+1/0?1",1-!L,-11/,*;
*?1",1,-,0511<-101<?1",1H,-11:2<,-?1",1
,+101=:12+,0?1, L-011",-!6-0?101-!67 G1,6,01
12+,02-0J
#
(1
U21.+,-,.1/01101,<?12,1,1->01-,H;
+7>51-<>-+1:,?1-,65-0!1:0K1M2-G10:"+*6,011
"=6-0,-1K-,0
R
?1, L51/0,0,51!+7!>1-,H!<(1
+,-,.-,1,-<>-+1*0+511/,H--,01/0,0,51=:191
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
1 6F%66E#3F7!1D6*1/0101.+,-,.1+(7,+,070(1C(?1%E$%(17(%&;%E(1
#
1 39395#7'1+,-,.*1/0(1C(?1%EE'(17('(1
R
1,+1606H1+1:6?1G:!*1-,-,*10>-8",1K62-,",1, :,0*1
01-?1:0->51/0,061D(7(19021:<2+11IE+0>516,-,19101!6,0+0,;
+7,<1, -/21/0,0,51!+7!>1G?1,1/,+!210>-81K62-,1, ;
:,0?1 01 G1 2,027<1 <>8+1 1 :>H0,-?1 1 ,1 1 -/H/,;
-J(17<(118,<<!-(1%E&&(1Q1%@(17(1&F(1
1
"
3
, G,6<*1 /6/,->+1 0,2-,",1 :0*1 K62-,51
!(11-0,K1,2671/0,061-0,<10>0,6<161.+,;
-,.1 0,:<,=,-71 8,G1 , , L5?1 !"+! +*KLG1 ,K1
-,H+7,",1/,:*1165-0*(1
7",6*1:+21.+,-,.1/011,1/01/, ;
+,1 ,0>1 2>(1 O,1 !=1 1 :"21 .+,-,.1 1
K-/!6H?1 1 -,1 91 1 0>6+1 6-H/+1 01 <G1
K62-,51!(13:01/0,06*1: =,10>0,61
1, , LKL1/6-0+*1,1-!L,-11-<>-+1/0?101,1
=10<*1,K1/01<+,1-!K1!<,:+7>1,-;
!H?1,,0>1,1+7>G1/0,0>G1/,H--,011*0+5(1
1M,<1-<>-+1.+,-,.*1/011 >10>-11.!6<;
1 0-",1 K62-,",1 :*?1 2,1 1 61 ,-,01 -",6*1
,+78-0!1-/H+-,010+K271.+,-,.K1/0101-,-01
/0,06*(1 1 81 0:"+*6?1 /,-+6,0+7,1 8*1 0,/,-1
/6+=,-1-.>1+K >G1.+,-,.-G1/, +<12-,;
!2,",1 :*?1 0,:<,=,1 1 /:071 G1 /,<=!,2>51
G?10,:KL511->1.+,-,.116!"G1!(11
E,0,*1 , 1 6+7>G1 ,-,0G1 /01 S/0,1 1 -0, ,6?1
-/06+0,-7?10-0,?1--0,1/0,11(6(T?1<>1,"61
1-<,=<1,,071G1,1-!L,-1.+,-,.-,",1/,<*1<;
(11M,<1/+?1/,1<K17(D(1C-<,0?1IZ-+1.+,-,.*1
0,, L1 /6-0+*1 -, ,51 !21,1 /6+7>G1 ,-,0*G1 2;
+,02-,",1 >*(((?1 -,,0-0,?1 .+,-,.*1 /01 <,=1
>71,/6+1012-01!2*1,1/6+7>G1,-,0*G1/;
011,6,",1:1-/,-, ,012+,02-,",1 >*J
%
(1,M,<!11+;
8,1,-,0*1/6+,=1 --<071.+,-,.K1/011
1-/H+:,0!K1.+,-,.-!K16-H/+!?1/,6G,6*L!K1
1 --+6,0K1 /0,0,51 +7,-1 -/H.2-<1 .+,-,.;
-<1 <,6<(1 7,"+-<-*1 -1 ((!,0><?1 2,1 I.+,-,.*11
/0,1 91 1 0,/0>1 ,</,>?1 <,1 .+,-,.*?1 1 1
/0,1/61.+,-,.1/01,-,0,/,+"KL1-0,5-0ZJ(
#
1
1,1=10<*1:621-,-,101,<?12, >1/,6,+71/,+,=1
0L5?1 ,,,1 L1 01 2+1 /,8+,",1 01 E((1 X8021
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
17<(11+,-,.*1/0(1[7,0?1#$$)(17('(1
#
11C6F7' 1+,-,.*1/01S,,;<,6,+,"2-51-/T1331E,-!6-0,11
/0,(1#$$E(1Q1R(17(1#@(1
1
1
1
#
3
,-,!<,10>:+1-+6!KL<1-+,0<11I+,-,.>11=+K1
-G,671-1 11:<+K?11K->11G,*1/,6*71-0,G1"+:1,1
:<+1 /,0>8J(
%
1 7,1 ,<71 /2!1 2-,",1 ,,8;
*1E((1X80211-,0<,51<!1.+,-,.1--0;
,",1 /0(1 F1 -2+?1 2,1 ,1-,:61 .+,-,.<?1/,.--,;
+7,1 1 :KL<1 /,:0,",1 /01 1 :621 /0,06*(1
F-K61 91 :621 :0*1 .+,-,.1 /,:0,",1 /0?1 H;
+,5112-,1--+6,0165-0!KL",1/0?1-,0;
8-0,01/,*5,",1//1K-/!6H11(/(11
3:+2*101/,6G,6G11/,<K1/01<=6!1.+,-,.<1
1/0,06<1: =>11:,,<>?1,1-,1:6!<7-*1,1
/2G1 /,62-1 "+! ,G1 -G,=65?1 ,2,1 ,/6+*71 /,;
+<>11"H>?101<G1,,>G16,+=>1- +=7-*1/,:H1
0:<,/,<*1 K-,01 1 .+,-,.,0?1 -,H,+,",0?1 ,/,+,;
",01 1 !+7!,+,",0(1 ,2-51 -/,1 ,1 /0,/,<1 0;
=?1/=610-",?1-0,<1/2-<1/,-+6-0*<1918;
1 0,/,-1 ,1 -!L,-1 1 /,61 /0?1 ",1 H+*G1 1 .!H*G1
/6,/6+*1 G1 :,,6+7,",1 "!+,0*1 , L;
-0>G1 ,,85?1 /,06*1 1 6*+7,-1 +K65?1 .,<1 1
-,2,01/0(11
+K+:<1 .+,-,.-G1 !25?1 <,",, :1 -/,-, ,01
,-<>-+*1<11:+,=*1",1:!+7,01:,,<,10>:>;
0K11=:1/+K+:<18,+1.+,-,.1/0191/,210-1:;
0->1 .+,-,.-1 --<>1 /,+!2+1 -0,1 0>=1 01 ,;
H/H*G1/0?1/2<1,"61<*1-<,1,6+,1,,81
1-, -0,1/0,06K1S/<?1M:-H+:<T(1,10-;
"61 01 H1 0<*1 .+,-,.1 /01 G,6+-71 /, +<>1
-!L,-1/0?1",1H,-?10,:<,=,-51 ",1/,:*Y1 ,61
:1.!6<+7>G10>0,6,01:+K2+-*101/:1:1/0,<1
0>=*11:<20>G11/G,6*LG1-,,?1,191 -,+K,51
H,-12+,011",1"+0,",1<.:2-,",1,/6+*191
-0, ,6>(11
D-G,6*1:1!0-+7,-1-<+*1+K651910,10-10;
<11!10-G1,6,01911/,-!1/,6+,51/06>?1I6,+=,;
",J101, L-0,51=:?17(11/-+11I+,-,.*1/0?1
/,1 ,-,0,<!?1 6H,,;/2-,<!1 1 -,6=K?1 -71
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
1233353FA2741F L*1,*1/0(1C(?1%E%%(17(1%)9%F(1
1
$
3
/,:1 , L-0,",1 6+?1 !*-1 ,",?1 <1 6,+=1
>71 +",5?1 :!<>5?1 -/06+0>5?1 I,<+7>5J1 -,51
, L-0J
%
(1 ,6!01 0>0,61 -,0<,",1 --+6,0+*1
D((1C+,0,51,1,<?12,1I/6<,<1.+,-,.1/01*0+*;
-*1+,"1:0*1/01S01,<12-+11",1,5T?1/,**1
1 <,61 <>8+*1 ,1 ",-!6-01 1 /0(1 1 M,<1 , G,;
6<,1 ,<7?1 2,1 +,"1 :0*1 /01 -,6=1 01 -*,<1
061 0-1 0,:<,=>1 /,H-->1 -<>-+,, :,0*1 01 , +-1
/019101<-8 G11-,?1112+,02-,51606!;
+7,-(1 +,-,.*1 /01 0>*0+*1 2+,02-,1 -,6=1
01 /6<>G1 .,<G1 /0J
#
(1 ,51 /,6G,61 -!+1 /+,6,0,;
!K1 <,6,+,"2-!K1 /-/0!1 -:1 :+2>G1 .+,;
-,.-,;/0,0>G1 6H51 1 "+! ,,",1 /,<*1 6+1
-,2-,",11+,"2-,",101:01/0(11
C>1=?1/,6>,=0*?1,/6++1 >1$55$+1&3611
53+1 555%,B1 &5-6",1 1 .5",1 55
61 &3681 ,51 /,6G,61 /6,/6+*1 1 , L!K1 -!!!1
.+,-,.1/0?1:,,<,1-,0/6KL!K101-0,G1M+<G1-1
,+1 , L<1:6+<1 .+,-,.191 ,,+,"5?1",-,+,;
"511 -,+,"5(10,<,10>6+*7?1 0,;/0>G?1$55$
5&3656+1 555+?1->0KL!K1-,/2-,-71/01
606!+7,<!11-,H+7,<!1 >K1+K651S,6+<,<!?101
-0,K1,267?1,1 >*10,, LT?18KL!K1/, +<>1,/6+;
*1 +7,-1 1 65-0+7,-1 /0?1.,<1 ",1 -!L-0,0;
*(1,;0,>G?1 $55$5&3656+1 555+1 /1 1 !2;
1,1<,6G11+,"1/,:*1/0,0>G1.,<,0(13,B1
$55$5&3656+155+1/1,K?1, ,-,0>0KL!K1
0> ,1H,->G1/:,01/0(1,H?1-/06+01/,-;
,01 0,/,-1 ,1 , G,6<,-1 3-3!51 $55$5
&365651 &35511!2*1,1/H/G11.,<G1/;
0,0,516*+7,-?1:,,0,2-011/2-,51+:H1
/0(1 ,+1 ,",?1 -+1 <:H*1 .+,-,.-,51 /-,+,"1
0,, L?11/0+,?11616+781-<,51/,-,010,/,-1
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
145C71A!G,0>1,-,0>1, L-0(106101-,H+7!K1.+,-,.K13313!--,1
:! =7(1D:1-,1-,H+7,511/0,0,51<>-+(15(?1%EE%(17(1#)R(1
#
1(A56F7!1+,-,.*1/01S,1<.:11"<0T(1B !"?1%EE)(1
7(1F(1