Ершов Ю.Г. Философия права
Подождите немного. Документ загружается.
1
1
1
3
-,08-0,01 E=6-,",1 ,6-1 3J?1 /6!-<;
0KL51: ,!18,H/H110-1:<5101E=6;
-51,6-1 -1!2,<1,/>1 ",1/<*1-!6<(18,H/H*?1
: ,*1 7,0,<1 /,1 ,6.H1 1 -,08-0,0K1
"=6-,",1:,,6+7-011D--+6,0+7-<1H,<12;
-,",1/01/1:613?1/,+!2+18,,1, -!=6?1
>+1,6, 101,* 1#$$E1"(?11/71=!+1I4-1,</;
J11-0,<1 -51,>+1, -!=61,6+7>G1 :<511
6,/,+51 -,1 -,,>1 &3+9,1 +356B1 , L*1 ",1
,"1 01 .,<1 /6+,=51 ,/071 01 !/,<*!>1 7,01 1
g(1<1, :,<?1, G,6<,1",0,711,1/,.--,+:;
<?1 1 ,1 6<,:<1 :,,0,2-,",1 /,H--?1 !KL<?1
6+*1/,0>8*12-01:,,6+7-0?1/0+2*11-<!;
+,0*1 8,,",1 !"1 1 M-/>G1 -,, L-0?1 1 -!!1
"=6-,",1, L-0?17CD(17-<1:,,0,2-016,+=1
>71 ,>,51 6+*1 6+758",1:0*1 10,2-,",1 -<,, ;
,0+*?1 -,6=71 /,<<,1 /*<>G1 S,1 :,,6+*1 1 /0,;
/<+*<T?1L11, >1.,<H,>1-0*:191,10-G1
-! P,01 /0,/<+7>G?1 /0,,G+7>G1 1 /0,;
, *:+7>G1/,H--,0(11
,-,+7!101K62-,51,<?101,2,<1-2?10>=;
K-*1 1 :/+*K-*1 ,/6+>1 /,+2-1 6?1 ,,>1
6,+=>1 0,-/<7-*1 1 , L, *:+7>1 6+*1 0-G1 2+,01
, L-0?1 :0-<,1 ,1 G1-! P0,",1 ,,8*1 1/6/;
-K1,<>?1/,-,+7!1,-, ,1:21<16<,2-,1
.,<,01 :,,6+7,51 S/6-0+7,5T1 0+-?1 K;
62-1 ,.,<+*KL51 ->1 ,+78-01 -+*?1 ,-,0;
>G1-,H+7>G1"!//11, L,-5(1462-*1,<1<,=11
6,+=1 >71/6-0+11-:1,/6+51/0,0,51H+1
1 -,,0-0!KLG1 /0,0>G1 -6-01 1 +:H?1 -+!=LG1
+"!1, L-011 2+,0(1 A5-0,-71+K ,",1:,1 /*;
<!K1 :0-1 ,1 :-,0,-1 01 ",1 +:H1 ,-,0>G1
-,H+7>G1 "!//?1 <+7,;G2-,51 1 ,":H,,51
, -/2,-1 ",1 -/,+*(1 U,,6+7?1 !:>01
4((1E,80?1 /<*1 !",+,0,;/0,0!K1 ,<!?1 6,+=1 -.,;
<!+,07101511/:?1,,>1 >160+10,:<,=,-71
/0,/<+K1 1 ,+7,1 /0+7,1 ,+,071 M!1 ,<!?1 01
1
3
,2,<1 -,,0-01 -1 1 :,,6+7><1 0>=<1 S0,+51
:,,6+*T?1,116,-,0,1!-0+071/!<1/,H--!+7;
,",16,:>0*1/:1/-!/+*?1/6!-<,>1M,51
,<,5
%
(1
O!1=1/, +<!1811/6+,=*1(A(10+,0><1
1 4(4(14",0><1 /,-+6,0+7,-71 M/,01 :6*1 :,?1 01
,+7851-/16+KL*1H11K62-,51G1:,;
,0,2-,",1 /,H--(1 1 ,1 =1 0<*1 ,1 , LK10<1
1-,:61-G,6,51,2-,51,-,0>1,H/H1 !6!L",1
:,1 91 --<>1 -,<1 1 /H/,0?1 0>=KLG1 <,0,:;
:2-1 1/,+2-10:"+*6>1 ,+78-01, L-0Y1.,;
<,01 :,0,",1 <--01 ,2-G1 :5?1 ,/6+*K;
LG1, P<11-!!!1 !6!L",1:,?1"H>11"+! !1/;
0,0,",1 "!+,0*Y1 ,-!,01 .,<>1 1 -,6=*1
/,1 :,?1 /6-0+,",1 01 :+2>G1 -,0>G1 0;
G?1 ,!!KLG1 ,H/H*G(1 1 M,<1 M/1 "+0,1 91 6;
0,1 :<>-+!1 1 K62-1 "<,,1 .,<!+,01 ,;
>G1/0,0>G1,<Y1,H?1+"<H*1:,?1((1/6;
1 ",1 /,!1 /,-6-0,<1 ,/6+,51 K62-,51 /,H;
6!>1 , *:+7,51 K62-,51 -+>(1 -1 M,1 91 /,-+6,0+7;
,-71/G,61,1:,,6+7,51H0>11, -!=6K1:;
,,/,?1/*K1:,11",1,/! +,0K
#
(1
71.+,-,.-,;/0,0,51,21:*1"+0,101-,6=1
0>8!/,<*!,51 ,H/H1 91 -<+1 , -/271 /0,0,51
G1 :,?1((1",1-,,0-01, L51+,"1-,H+7,",1
:0*11 :,0>G1H,-51!+7!>?1/H/<11/:<1
/01S"!<:<?1-/06+0,-7?10-0,?1,<0,-7?1--;
<,-711(6(T?1<=6!,6,<!1/0!118,-!H?1/,H6!;
1+"<H1:,(11
1-,0<,51,2-0,51.+,-,.-,;/0,0,51+;
!1!-+0-*10<110,/,-!?1/,-0+,<!1L11:1
2+,02-,51H0+:H191,1-0*:116-01K62-G1:;
,,011:,,01, P0,51+7,-1S8,-<,-?1/,6>?1, ;
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
17<(11633F7'1,*11/1<+:H11<-HH1,2!=6*1!",;
+,0,;/0,0,51 ,<>1 331 3<-H>51 +:1 ,2!=6>G1 .,<1 -!L-0,0*(1
B !"?1%EE'(17(1%R$(1
#
17<(1133F6F7',&7/%6F71, +<>1,11/1:,,0,2-,",1/,;
H--1013,--5-,516H13313,--5-51K62-51=!+(1%EER(1Q1#(1
1
1
1
3
L-0T(1W-><1-+!2<1:6-71*0+*-*1/, +<1-,,,8*1
:,1 1 , L!2,51 ",1 1 K62-,",1 :,(1
(7(1X+K1-G,61:1,,-1G1/,0,/,-0+*?1
-2*?12,1/,<1, L!2,",1:,11"!+*,1,/;
6+,",1 /,H--?1 ,-!!KL",1 , G,6<!K?1 !-,52;
0!K?1 -!L-0!K1 1 /,0,*KL!K-*1 -0*:7?1 /,:0,+*1 1 /0,;
0!K1,<!1-271-/H.2-,51:,06,-7K1, L!2,",1
:,(1
1 -01 0>8:+,=,",1 <,=,1 ,-,07?1 2,1 01 >;
8<1 ,--5-,<1 , L-01 /,;/=<!1 -!L-0><1 6.;
,<1:,,6+7,516*+7,-1,--*1-+ *1,H*1:,;
,6+*1 1 "+! >1:,,<,-1 "!+!<>G1 :,,<1 ,;
,85(1,+2-1,1<,=1, P*-*7-*1/,;:,<!?101:0;
-<,-1,1,>G1-+!201S01,2,<1,"?106<,?1-<+;
<1!6=710+-7T11=+<1!-,71/G,611>,2><1,;
,8*<1 :1 !21 <,,/,+:<1 /,:0,6+5?1 -+ ,-7K1 +1
-/,<,L,-7K101-/,+1:,,0?1:<1!,0<1/0,-,:;
*11/0,0,51!+7!>?1:<-0,0<1:;:1! =1/0,0>G1
-!,0?1 6+*1006*1,,>G1 1-,:+1!-+,0*191-!1
6,0+7,",1!/0+*1S-TY12-,1K62-191,-!-0;
<1/6<,",11-,6=+7,",1:"2*1<=6!1/,-><11
,-!H,><1:,<?1:,,<11!:,<?1:,,<116!"<1
S,<1!:T1/,6:,><1<(1
1
2535"165&35"111)1
%(1W,1,1/,:0H*1/0V1
#(181-0*:>1K62-1:,>11:,,<;
,-1, L-0,",1:0*V1
R(1F/6+1,-,0>1/H/>1:,,0,2;
-0(1
@(1 W<1 , -/20-*1 1 65-0,-71 :,,6;
+7-0
V
1
1
3
1
323DF35F5C&DE&23
3DF3,B'&3
1
0,101-,H+7,51+7,-1911-,-,*?11-2*1
--<1 ,<?1 ,?1 /=61 0-",?1 6*+7,-71 /,1 -/,+7:,0K1
K62-,",1-!<*16+*18*1-,H+7,1:2<>G1
:62Y1 6!"<1 -+,0<?1 /0,1 +7:*1 -0-1 ,+7,1 1 K62;
-,516,"<?1,.H+7,<!1:,,6+7-0!(1F+0*-71,1
/,<*1, L-0,51=:11-,0,!/,51/6<,516*;
+7,-1 -<G1 +K65?1 <>1 6,+=>1 1 /0,1 --<071 1
,-, ,",1,616*+7,-7?12,1/,:0,+*1I-G07J1-<>-+1/0?1
-,-,*L5101",16<?10165-0?1+:H?1/2-,<1
"!+,01, L-0>G1,,85(10,0*16*+7,-71
/,1-0,<!1-,6=K1I-G0>0J10-1,-,0>12>1!0;
-!<12+,02-,",1<?10>-!/*1110,-/,:0,6-0,1,<;
0,",1 /,*6?1 /0,/<+7>G1 1 /0,,G+7>G1
-!,01, L-0?111/,H--1:8*1-,H+7>G1/,;
0,25?111-/,-, 11-6-01-,"+-,0*1-,0?16,-;
=*1,</,<--,0?111/,H--1-<,:<*12+,0101
G,61 ,-0,*1 ,<1 1H,-51 /0?1 ?1,H?1 1 /, ;
=1-,H+7,51+7,-(1
0,0*1 6*+7,-7?1 -/H.1 1 -,6=*?1 0:<,;
-0*:1 -1 6!"<1 06<1 2+,02-,51 6*+7,-1 1 (/(1 0-1 01
,+7851 <1 /0+1 0<1 ,2-0>G1 /0,06,0(1
, G,6<,-71 1 :!2*1 /,620+-71 01 ,G1 ((1 8!6;
*0H0?1 A(4(1 8<,0?1 (C(17>>G?1 (D(1!"-,",?1 A((1 7;
.!++?1D(B1(U<,5-,",116(1
?1/,1<K14(7(1->/?1-",6*1/,61+:H51
/01/2-10,10-G1-+!2*G?1/*<,1+1,-0,?1/,<;
-*16*+7,-712+,0?165-0*?1/,062-1>1+K651
91 I/,H--1 ,-!L-0+*1 /0,0>G1 /6/-5?1 6*+7,-7?1
-,"+-*1 -1 0>=,51 01 :,1 0,+5ZJ(
%
1 ,1 -71 +:H*1
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
1339-8CA571,,>1-/>1--+6,0*1,-!H,,",1/0,-,:*1331
E,-!6-0,11/0,(1#$$)(1Q1%(17(E#(1
1
1
1
3
/010>-!/11.,<1/2-,516*+7,-1/,1,-!L;
-0+K1 /01 1 0>/,+K1 , *:,-5?1 /0,1 , 1
I=:7J?10,/+,L*-7101 -,:+7,;0,+0>G1/,-!/G1S65-0;
*GT1-! P,01/0?11606!+7>G?111,++"+7>G(11
2-01 ,</,?1 -,21 /0,0,51 !+7!>1 1 /0,0,51
--<>1--<01/0,0!K16*+7,-7101<,",, :11
06,0?1 -6-01 1 -! P,01 4((1 7<,
%
(1 0,1 1 ,-, >5?1
-+,=>5?1 0!1 6..H,0>51 061 6*+7,-1 -;
-+6!-*1 01!6G1 D((1C+,0,51 ,1 !2>G?1<,6,+,"2-1
0>0>G1 ,-,0*G1 6,+",-,2,51 /0,0,51 /,+1 ",-!;
6-0?1 H+,51 1 0:HK1 K62-G1 .,<1 :L>1
!+7!>(1 <**1 6*+7,-!K1 /6"<!1 01 <G1 /0,;
0,51-.>?1E(D(1D,,011((15*8,10>6+*K1-,+7,1
-!!1/0,0,516*+7,-?101<G1,,>G1/,-<0;
-*1-*1/-/01.+,-,.-,;/0,0>G1--+6,0511
%T1/,H--!+7!K?1,/->0KL!K10:<,-0*:71-! P?1, P?1
H+?1 :!+71 1 /,-+6-051 /0,0,51 6*+7,-Y1 #T1 06,;
0!K191!6?1, L11"11RT10<!K1S0160!G1.,<GT191!;
+7,51 1 !<!+*0,5(1 1 <1 -/06+01 :",0,1 ,1 60!G1
.,<G1/0,0,516*+7,-11,2-,5191/0,0,2-,51
S:,,6+7,5T1 6*+7,-1 ",-!6-0?1 !2,51 6*+7,;
-1 --+6,0+7-G1 /0,0>G1 -!,01 1 !2=65?1,.;
H+7>G1,",01,+,0*1/01911/,0-60,5?1,"2;
,51K62-<1:,<
#
(1,1/,0,6!10:<,-0*:1/011";
>1<,=,1:<7?12,1,1,6-0>11"2-?11!+7;
,1 91 /,1 (1 [5:"?1 ",++6-,<!1 --+6,0+K1 ">1 1 -;
,21!+7!>11IZ<>1:<2<?12,1/2-,<!1,/0+;
K1 /0?1 21 ",0,*?1 -!6,/,:0,6-0!?1 ,0>1 >1 1 >+1
6+7>1,-,0>1/0191010>-,,51-/1/-!L1G1-,;
-*:*J?1/,1-5167101:+2>G1.,<G1/0,0,51=:1-0,;
:*1",0>11-,-*:+7>12-0
R
(11M,<1,-1-,;
0-*1*-,?1/,2<!11/,/!+*>11M1+0:,1-H;
,01-!6 >G1:-6519101-+!1:2+7,1/-!L51<1;
+7,-(1 1
1
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
17<(113DAC67(13:01/0,0,51!+7!>11/0,0,51/,"--(1B !"?1
%EEF(17(1#&&;#E&(1
#
17<(11!C655AC6F7!&78335C67'1F-,0>1.+,-,.1/0(1C(?1#$$%(17(#%F;#%E(1
R
1,6, 1-<(11937A5%7A1j_`_1kbelmf(111:08",16*(1C(?1%EE#(17(ER;E@(1
1
3
, G,6<,-716*+7,-,",1/,6G,611/0!1/*<,10>;
1 :1 <,6,+,"2-,",1 ,"-01 6*+7,-1 1 .+,;
-,.-,51 ",?1 /,:0,+*KL",1 51 0>-!/71 01 2-01 0=;
58",1 /H/1 /,:*(1 1 -0,1 0<*1 O(E(1 461 0>6++1
/*71,-,0>G1.!H51",1I6*+7,-7J?1=6*1:1,;
,>G1<,=1 >71-/,+7:,016+*1--+6,0*1/011/,6;
--<>1, L-0(1 A*+7,-7?1 /,1O(E(146!?10>-!/111
%T1, P*-+7>51/H/?1->0KL510-, L!K1,-,0!12;
+,02-,",1<Y1#T1/6<1!2,",1--+6,0*1912,1-;
2+*<,1 1 0,-/,:0,6<,1 01 ,2-,51 1 ,/6;
+,51!2,516-H/+>1S016,<1-+!219101,1/0TY1
RT1/6<1!/0+*191,?12,1<,=1 >71,":,0,101.!;
H,!KL!K11:00KL!K-*1--<!Y1@T1/6<1/,,;
0*191-,:61-/,-, ,011!-+,0516+*1,0>G106,016*+7,;
-Y1 1 )T1 H,-7?1 ,/6+*KL*1 <-,1 1 -<>-+1 2+,02-,51
6*+7,-101:+2>G1!+7!>G1--<G
%
(11
+7:*1/,51<<,1,21:*?1!0=6KL51/<;
+<,-716*+7,-,",1/,6G,611/0!(1,;/0>G?1-211
-,,?1012-,<1061/0,0*16*+7,-711-!L-0!?11
,<,0,2-*1 6*+7,-7?1 1 /0,/<+7*1 -71 ,;
=11-!L,-71,51S/0,0,5T16*+7,-
#
(1
,;0,>G?1 606!+7,1 /6/-?1 0-"61 --2;
,1 1 606!+7>51 -+!251 1 , L,1 1 ,><1 +;
H<?1 1 ,021 /:<1 ,<1 /01 1 .,<+7,;
,/6+,",?1 , L, *:+7,",1 1 ,G*<,",1 ",-!6-0,<1
/0+1/,06*
R
(18101M,<1-+!21 >71-1<?12,1,>51
10,+0,",1/,06*12+,0?1-,08<>51/,61,,+<1",1
-,:*1 1 /,-*L51 06?1 /:-*1 /-!/+<1 ,<;
0,?1, L, *:+7,11.,<+7,;,/6+,V1
1 /,0,**1 !1 ,<0:<?1 :<<?1 2,1 01 2-,<1
0611-!L-0!11,6,",10612+,02-,516*+7,-?11
M,1!=160,1*0+*-*1-,H+7,;.+,-,.-,51-,<,5(1<11
<?1 /,<*1 ,1 60,5-0,-1 /0?1 !/,<*!,51 <?1 <,=,1
!0=67?1 2,1 /,H--!+7*1 -,,1 /01 01 <-<+7,51
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
17<(11/EA5751C,6,+,"*1!(17-<,-7(1A*+7,-7(1C(?1%EE'(17(#)$(1
#
17<(113-.7'17!L,-71/01101/,-G1,0>G1,51+1I,-0:<J1-,",1
<>8+*V13313,-(1K62-51=!+(1%EER(1Q1#(17(1)F(1
R
1<1=(17(1)'(1
1
1
1
!
3
-/1 0>=1 ",1 I2-,!J?1 /0+,-71 1 1 !K1
/6<!K16*+7,-7?111-<,1- *(1A+?1/0,0*1,<1
/6/,+"1 ,-,:,-71 /,06*?1 "!+!<,",1 1 ,+7,1
,<,51/0?1,11-<<1-! P,<(1!6!216-,0,51/-,;
+7,1,/6+,<!1!"!1+H?1,1-,:61/0,,,81
2:16*+7,-71,>G1+H?15-+9,B1-+9,11
&339+9,1K62-1.>(1
,H--!+7>1,<>?1-1,6,51-,,>?10>-!/K1M..;
0><1 ,-,0<1 65-051 /0,/<+*?1 01 ,<1 2-+1 1
+K ,",1 2+,0?1 -1 6!",51 =1 91 !-0+0K1 /6+>1 0<8;
+7-01",-!6-0101-.!1/0,0,",1-!-1"=6(13:;
<>,-7?1,.,<+,-71/,H--!+7>G1,<10>:>0160,*;
1/,-+6-0*111+1:LL,-71"=61/610--+<11
/,:0,+,<1 /6-0+51 /0,,G+7>G1 ,",0?1 +1
-*,-7118+7,-71/6-0+51G1=1,",01
/10>/,+1-+!= ,",16,+"(1
6H,,1 ,<,061 2-,1 ,"20+,-71 +:,<1
-0,61 /0+1 1/,21 1-+,-71"+0,",191/,H--1+:H1
:,1 01 65-0*G1 "=61 1 :+2>G1 -,H+7>G1 -!,01
SM,,<2-G?1/,+2-G11(/(T1/181/2-G1:;
62(1A*+7,->51/,6G,61/,:0,+*1871/, +<!1:+2*1
I6!G1 1 !0>1 :,J?1 /,-,+7!1 65-0!KL1 /0,1 01 ,+7851
+1<7851<11-,0/61-1-<1,<0>G1,0(1IU;
:,J1/,:0,+*K1+06,071,-, >?1!=1!/,<08-*?1/<>1
,+,0*1 -,01 S,"2+7>?1 -8+7>?1 -/,;
-+7>T?11=1+,"1:,11+,"1/0?10>,-;
<>11,-,01/,.--,+7,",1/0,-,:*(1
0,0*1 6*+7,-7?1 !6!21 -/H.2-<1 06,<1 2+,;
02-,516*+7,-?1-101-0,<1-,6=10-11,6,0>1
/:(1,;/0>G?1/0,0>1-!>11,<>11M+<>1
, L-0,51 --<>1 0>-!/K101 2-01 :!+7,01 /0,;
0,51 6*+7,-1 +1 -6-01 1 ,-!L-0+*?1 +1 /6<1
/, :,0*?1 +1 1 -! P(1 ,;0,>G?1 /0,0*1 6*+7;
,-710>-!/1-/,-, ,<1!6,0+0,*1/, ,-5?1;
-,01 1H+5?1-0*:>G1-1-<,+:H512+,02-G160;
6,01 01 <G1 -,H+7,51 -0, ,6>(1 ;7G?1 /0,0*1 6*+7;
,-710>/,+*1"0!K1.!HK1/,1,,8K1,10-<1
1
"
3
6!"<106<16*+7,-?1!/,*6,20*1G?1-,:60*1--<!K1
H+,-,-71 , L-0(1 ;20>G?1 ,1 !2-0!1 01 .,<,0;
?1 .!H,,01 1 6+758<1 :01 -! P;
, P>G11-! P;-! P>G10:<,65-0*G11,,8*G?1
0>-!/KLG1-,2<1160=!L<1-+<1:0*1, L;
-0112+,0(1
F L-0>1,,8*112+,02-*16*+7,-71911
/,-,1 0851 ,-1 6+*1 /01 S1 -,,0-0!KL51 K6;
2-,51 ,01 ",-!6-0T?1 ,1 +7,?1 .2-,1 -,6;
=?1,,,1,/,-6!-*?1!/,*6,20-*11,.,<+*-*12;
:1"!+*HK1/,06*1+K65101--<1 0:<,65-0*1-,H;
+7>G1 "!//1 1 -!,01 /0,0><1 ,<<?1 /0+<1 1
/H/<(1F-K61-+6!?12,1 :1*-,",1/6-0+*1,1G;
?1-<>-+11-/H.1-,6=*1,",1+1,",1, L-;
0,",1,,8*10,:<,=,1M..0,11H+/0+,1
"!+,01M,",1,,8*(1
811+K *12+,02-*16*+7,-7?1/0,0*10+K2101
- *1H+7?1/6<?1-6-011-/,-, >165-0*?1:!+7(17/;
H.1 /6<1 /0,0,51 6*+7,-1 :+K2-*1 01 ,<?1 2,1
<10>-!/1+K *16!"*16*+7,-71+K65191 /,1-/,*=;
K1<!L-0,<?1,:K1!-+!"?1/,6=1/,:06,",1,0;
?10-!/+K101 110,-/K16511(6(1U621/0,0,51
6*+7,-1 1 -,-,1 01 ,<?1 2, >1 , -/271 "!+*HK1 -,;
0<-,",1!6?1, -/271,":,0,-7?1!-,520,-71:;
,, :>G1-0*:5101, L-0101-,,0-01-1-<1+K651
1, L-0101H+,<(17+6,0+7,?1/6:2,-71/0,0,51
6*+7,-191!/,*6,2071+K !K1!K1/6<!K16*+7;
,-7?1/,:0,+*1--<071 1012-01-, -0,",1/6;
<1 /0,0,",1 !6(1 0,?1 <1 , :,<?1 0>-!/1 1 061
!6,0,51 6*+7,-1 -+,=,",1 ,/,-6!KL",1 G?1 ,1
-,-,1 01 -,081 -! P<1 65-05?1 /6!-<,>G1
, L, *:+7><1,<<1+1-,"+8*<1-,,(1
9-,?12,16*+7,-,1/,<1/01, *:>011;
+:!1/0,0>G165-0511,/H5?1G1-,-011/,-+6,0+7;
,-?1 /,-!1 ,/<+7>G1 -/,-, ,01 8*1 /2-G1 :;
62(11M,<1-+!211<-,1H+:,0>G1/6/-511;
-!H51 /G,6*1 " 1 606!+7>1 /0,0>1 -6-01 91
1
1
1
#
3
6,",0,?1,6,-,,1-6+?1-,"+-,0>1-.>1,0-0;
,-1 1 (6(1 F1 01 ,+7851 -/1 , -/20K1 S01 <G1
, G,6<,51- +7,-T10,:<,=,-71/,*0+*1-,H+7>;
<1 -! P<1 H0>?1 G,:*5-0,51 /6/<20,-?1
0:<>G1 ,051-/,+*1, *:+7-0(1,6, >1/0,;
0>1 -!!>1 -,:6K1 =+<!K1 M,,<2-!K1 1 !K1 6;
<!1, L-0(11
,6,+=1 +:1 -!!>1 /0,0,51 6*+7,-1 0;
6110>6+K1,-,0,516H>1+K ,516*+7,-191H+;
/0+,",165-0*(1462-1,,0,165-0?1
11/0,0*16*+7,-7101H+,<?10-"610+K2,101,-1
+7,51=:1+K65?1-,:6-*11 ,0*<(1<-1-1<1
<,=,1 0>6+71 ,/6+>1 :,,<,-1 .,<,0*1
K62-G165-05(1
,;/0>G?1 +K ,1 65-01 <1/0,0,1 -,6=?1 ,,;
,1+ ,1"+<!-*1:,,<1/,-6-0,?1+ ,1,/6+*;
-*1, L<12+<11-<>-+,<165-0!KL",1:,,6+7-0(11
,;0,>G?1 H+?1 /,:>0KL1 -,6=1 K62-,51
6*+7,-?1,/6<20K-*1011:62G11-6-0G16,-=*(1
7,0,!/,-71 ,6+7>G1 K62-G1 65-05?1 /,62;
>G1, L<!1:<>-+!?1-,"+-,0>G1/,1H+11/,*6!1-,08;
*?1, :!1K62-!K1,/HK(1F/H1/,-+=0K-*1
0,1 0-G1 -.G1 /0,0,51 6*+7,-1 S/0,0,2-,5?1 K-;
6H,,5?1/0,+:H,,5116(T?1,1/-!-0!K101;
,1+K ,",10+K2,",1011-! P(1
>6+1 K62-G1 ,/H51 /,:0,+*1 -,-071 , ;
L!K1 -G<!1 /0,0,51 6*+7,-?1 /6-0+*KL!K1 -, ,51 /,;
-+6,0+7,-71-+6!KLG1-65111
%T1,,0,2*191+:1-! P,<1/2-,51-!;
H?10,:<,=,-511/0,0,",18*1-1!2,<1-0,G1;
-,0110,:<,=,-5Y11
#T1,<0*1910>*0+1-,0,!/,-1, *:+7>G1/;
0+1 1 ,05?1 ,,><1 6,+=1 /,62*7-*1 6*+7,-71 01
6,51-!HY11
RT1 /,6",,0+7*1 91 /,-,01 ,2,51 1 /,<=!,2;
,51H+5?1-,-0+1/+165-05Y11
1
1
!$
3
@T1 K6,;,-!0*1 91 ,:H*1 +1 .,<,;
0101-6+G1-! P0>G1/011K62-G1, *:,-5Y11
)T1-/,++7*191-,081<2>G165-05101-,,;
0-01-1/6/-*<1:,11/*><1, *:+7-0<Y11
FT1,,+7*191+:1G,616*+7,-11-,081/1
, G,6<,-1,,0,2>G165-05Y11
'T1,H,2*191,/6+1/,+,>16,-=*1:!+7?1
-,,0-0*1",1/0,0,51<,6+11<2,51H+(1
,<<,1 +:H1 /01 01 6*+7,-1 -! P,0?1 ((1
/0,+:H,,516*+7,-?1/0,0*16*+7,-71<,=1
/1, G,6<,-10+K27101- *1/0,:L!K16*+7,-7?1
-,-,*L!K1 01 , L1 1 K-6H,,<!1 ,"!1 :1 :L,51
!8,",1/0?1+1/0,, -/2+7!K?1/6/,+"KL!K1
/<1S016,/!-<>G1-+!2*GT1-, -0>G165-051+H1
/,10,:65-0K11-/0,",1,"(1
3:!<-*?1/1-,081/0,0>G1,/H51165-051
-! P!1/G,6-*10>/,+*71:+2>1,":H,>165;
-0*?15+7>101K62-,<1,,8(1
2-*1 /,+7:1 ,1 +--.H1 1 0>*-*1 /,-+;
6,0+7,-1 K62-G1 ,/H51 -,-,1 010,:<,=,-1 G1
!/,*6,2*?1 /,0>8*1-,"+-,0,-?1 -,L*1 0<1
1:110>/,+1 ,(1U2+7,1, +"2-*1,,+71
:1 ,2><1 1 -0,0<><1 -/,+<1 , *:,-51 +H<?1
!2-0!KL<1 01 6,51 6*+7,-(1 8,<1 ,",?1 6*+7,-;
>51/,6G,611/0!1/,:0,+*1--+6,0711/<*71-<,-,*;
+7,1.,<!<>1-! P0>1/011-,,0-0!KL1<1
, *:,-1 2:1 -,081 606!+7>G1 K62-G1
65-05?1,-,0>G11, LG16,:0,+*G1:,(1
<1 , :,<?1 /0,1 0>-!/1 1 061 6*+7,-?1 -,;
-,*L5101-,:611/<1, L, *:+7>G1,<11;
,<0>G1 K62-G1 -6-0?1 /0+,51 1 "!+*HK1
0:<,-0*:,51 6*+7,-1 +K651 6+*1 6,-=*1 , G,6;
<,",1:!+7(1
+81/,62!7?12,16*+7,->51/,6G,61I0,:0L;
J101.!H,,01/01"+0,1I:0,J1+K ,516*+7,-1
91-<,",12+,0(1<1-<><1/,6,+0-*1 -,-711.,;
<+7,-71 /,6G,61 1 +:H1 /0?1 !2>0-*1 :+21 01