Ершов Ю.Г. Философия права
Подождите немного. Документ загружается.
1
1
1
3
-0
%
(1 A?1 0*61 +1 0,:<,=,1 -+7-0,1 ,<71 !/, +;
1015+7,;+--.H,,<1-<>-+1<1I/0,J1/,1
,,8K1 1 +K ><1 ,"6;+ ,1 -!L-0,008<1 +1 ><1 -!;
L-0!KL<1--<<1:,,6+7-0(1D:<-*1+1/1M,<1
81,,811I!+2,<!1/0!J11/,6!1/011;
,0,",V1-<1+1<>1,,-7-*11=<!170,518,1
1/,*6!?1!8KL<!1M+<>1/012+,0?1<1-;
<><1 -/06+0,<!V1 7<,H,-71 /0?1 6=1 *0+**-71 /,;
6!,<1 6,-,2,1 /,:6",1 /,,=6*1 -,1 2+,02-0?1
!1 /,<*1 ",1 0+K2,-1 01 --,2-?1 ((?1
0,:KL1 01 :!+71 ,/,-,H,":1 1 :00KL-*1
0<-1 -1 2+,02-0,<1 2+1 2+,02-,51 6!G,0,-?1 , +;
6KL1 :+2,51 <,51 I*0+,-J1 01 -,?1 0>=KL1
"!<-2-1 6+>1 1 H,-(1 ,:0,1 /0,1 0-"61
/6!1 1 , L, *:+7,-7?1 ,1 -<1 , L, *:+7,-71
6,+=1 >71H,-,1, ,-,0,5(1
,1 ,,8K1 =1 ,1 0-<1 /,6<1 /01 H+-,, :,1
/<*71/,*1I/0,J?1, ,-,0,1L1E"+<(1<H;
51.+,-,.1/6+"+1:+271-,+7,106,01/011%T1
&3351&3651S+191/,-,6!8*1/06T?1G;
:!KL1 /,/>1 -/,*LG1 ,1 /01 -,,1 -271 ,0><1
-, -0>?1 ,"2>1 /6-0+*11 #41 5!1 91 /,/>1
:-071-271/0,<1,?12,1<11*0+*-*Y1RT1&3&1
9165-0*?1/,1,,8K11,,><1-,08KL51G11!=6;
-*1 01 ,<;+ ,1 , ,-,01 MG1 65-051 1 /0,<>G(1
D--+6,01 /01 01 -0*:1 -1 /,0,/,+,=><1 <!1 /,*<1
/0?1 /,1 <K1 (8(17<"!++?1 61 0,:<,=,-71 ,+1
"+! ,,11, P<,1/,<7165-01/0110-1<<,.,:>?1
,,>1 ,,1 //01 01 :>G1 -!H*G?1 ,H071 1
/-06,,<!?1/-06,:,?1/-!/>51-",0,1,?12,1/,,51<1
,.H+7,;0+->51 G?1 /6!1 1 +"+7!K1 +";
<,-7
#
(11
,:0L*-711,<0,-1/0?1,<<?12,1/0,1911
,+7,1,?12,1,"2,10>1:1=:6*+7,-1, L-;
0?1 /0,1 /,*0+*-*1 1 ,+7,1 01 .,<G1 -!H,+7,51
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
17<(11,*1/011",-!6-0(1C(?1%EE)(17(1#%(1
#
1,6, 1-<(11DA%A57'10,11/0,1331E,-!6-0,11/0,(1#$$#(1Q1R(1
1
3
,<0,-?1 ,1 1 01 ,<0>G1 /0,0>G1 !-,0+*G?1
/0,0>G1 /H/G?1 /0,0,51 /,+1 01 :+2>G1 ,-+*G1
:,,6+7-0(1 7+6!1 /*71 0,1 0<1 1 <?1 2,1
.,<+7*1 ,/6+,-71 91 1 -!L,-,1 2-0,1 /0?1 1
+871 -/,-, 1 0>=*1 ",1 ,<0,-?1 ((1 M,1 2-0,1 0,1
<,",<1:0-1,1--<>1-,2,01/01101-+!21:0;
8,-1 .,<+7,51 ,/6+,-1 <,=1 >71 /,6,+,1
/1 /,<,L1 +,"1 /01 +1 :,?1 ,"2+7,",1 +1
-8+7,",1,+,0*(1
?1/<?1!1-,08,+",101-<71, *:,-51
/0,0,",1-0,5-01 >711<,=?1((1/,!6711G1-/,+K1
",10,:<,=,?1/,M,<!1/,*1I-<5,;/0,0,51-!-1-,;
08,+",J1,+2-*1,1, L/*,",101<G1/01
<?12,1:6-71-,2K-*1/0101-,",<1/,<1M,",1-+,01
-1, *:,-*<1<,+7,",1G(1
81!:,,<0,",1/,6G,611/0!11,:21!<;
+*1 , P0,51 ,+1 ,<0,-1 /0(1 0,0*1 ,<?1
!6!21, , L,51<,6+7K1, L-0>G1,,8511/,06;
*1+K65?1/,:0,+*1-! ,6,0711,,6,0712+,0;
2-!K16*+7,-7?1871-/,>11,.+>?1/6!/=671
-,H+7>1 60H?1 0,--0+071 -/06+0,-7(1 1 ,;
<0,",1 /,6G,61 1 <,=1 >71 -,08-0,0*1 :,,6;
+7-0?1 : ,1 /0+1 :,,6+7,51 G?1 !21 1
--<:H1 ,<0>G1 ,0?1 01 -,0<>G1 !-+,0*G1 91
-,:6*1 .,<H,,;/,-,0>G1 --<1 1 6!"G1 /-/;
0>G1/0+51/0,0,51-+!= >(1,<0>51/,6G,610>;
-!/1 ,-,0,51 /0,0,",1 0,-/*1 1 /0,0,51 /,/"6>?1
((1I/0,10,, LJ10-"61-!L-0!101,,;-,2-,51
.,<1 ,/6+,51 /0,0,51 --<>(1 ,H?1 ,+7,1 01 M,<1
-+!216,-"-*1:,,-7?10G,0-0,1/0?1-G,6*L1:1
",1,.H+7,",1!-,0+*116,, :*1/,<*(1
A+*1 /,<*1 -/,-, 1 -!L-0,0*1 /01 , G,6<,1
/,<71,1",1.,<+7,51,/6+,-(10,10-"61-!L-;
0!?1 !6!210,/+,L><101,/6+!K1-!+7!K1.,<!Y1
:,1 /6-1 /61 <1 1 ,/6+*1 :,0*1 --<(1
A5-0,-71/010,:<,=101,2,-1, ,:2*101;
-1,<>1, -,*+7-0?10>:>0KLG1/0,0>1/,-+6-0*?1,/;
1
1
1
3
6+*1MG1/,-+6-05112-0?1/-!LG1-! P<1/;
0,,,85(11
D?1<11<?11 >11 >+10=>16+*1/0,0,2-,511
/0,/<+7,51/1:621.,<+7,51,/6+,-1
16,, :,",1/,<*1-1/0,0,51,<>?12<!1-+!=?1
/<?1 /,H6!>1 "<<2-,",1 S*:>,0,",T?1 +,"2-,",1
+1-<2-,",1,+,0*1:,?1,16+,11-2/>0K1
<,",<,-1/011",10+K2,-101=:71, L-011!+7;
!>101H+,<(171.+,-,.-,;/0,0,51,21:*1-,H,!+7!;
*1/,61/01 !10<*11G!?12-0!?11,+7;
,11/0,0,<!?1,111-,H+7,<!1-!-!1,+,0+*?101H+,<1911
-<,<!18,,<!1,-!1-,H+7,",1 >*1/0
%
(1
D-!H,+:H*1 /01 6,-"-*1 1 -,+7,1 ",1 :;
+,=<1 01 ,<0>G1 G1 +1 !-0,<1 /6/-51 , ;
L-0><1 -,:<?1 -,+7,1 -,:6<1 --<1 /0,,G;
+7>G1,",011/,H--!+7>G1/0+1G16*+7,-(1;
0,1 !6,,-!L-0<,1 :1 ",-!6-0,",1 //?1 /0;
+,",11/<1/0,0>G1,<?181-/,,0?1/!=;
61 1 -/,+K1 1 -, +K6K1 /0?1 :1 /0,!;
8+5(1 3"!+*H*1 6*+7,-1 +K651 -1 , G,6<,-7K1 /;
, 1 0+->5?1/!6+7>51G?1/,-,+7!1 01-,H;
+7,<10:<,65-01-+0K-*1:+2>?1/,,51/,0,;
/,+,=>1->?10>KL1 :1:+2,",1 10,",1 /,;
+,=*1 +K651 01 --<1 , L-0>G1 ,,85(1 ,M,<!1
:81 -,H+7>G1 /,0,25?1 0> ,1 ,/6+>G1 H;
+511-6-0165-0*1,/K-*110,+0,18?11!",:!1
/<*1-+>(1+->51-/,-, 1"!+*H10>1:1-<,51
/,6>1 , L-0>G1 ,,85?1 -+6>0KLG-*1 :1 -,;
2,",1 <,",, :*11 -2/<,51 -+,=,-1 606!+7;
>G1/,-!/,0?10:<,65-05191G1/,-,1/0-116,51
H,+7,51 0> ,,51 <,6+(1 +-7?1 -<*L*-*1 >71
.,,<1 !/,*6,2*1 6*+7,-1 +K65?1 6,+=?1 -G,6*1 :1
, P0>G1,,8511, -,*+7-0?1/,66=0711!/;
+*71 ,61 :1 G?1 +,,071 1 :/L71 6!"(1 3:!<-*?1
/1M,<1<>16,+=>1/,<71,1G1-+G1-<,,":H11-;
<,"!+*H?1 ,,>1 -!L-0!K1 01 , L-01 /,<<,1 -!;
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
17<(11(A56F7!7+,-,.*1/0,0,2-0(1B !"?1%EEF(17(1)&;&F(1
1
3
H,+7,1,":,0,510+-?191-0*:>1-1-,H+7,51/;
,6,51-<,",12+,011/02>G1.,<1",1=:6*+7,-(1
,1 ,-!-01 +1 /+21 0+-1 06!1 1 :!8K1 --<>1
,<0,51"!+*H?10,:-K1/6-:!<,-1 !6!L;
",?1 6,<,0K1 0,+1 -+7,",?1 -=K1 :LL,-1 2;
+,0(1
3:!<-*?1 0,-/*1 -,H+7,51 - +7,-1 1 +"1
16,+=,10-11!0=6K1,1 :!-+,0,51/,:0,-1+K;
,51!/,*6,2,-(12/,*6,2,-71<,=16,-"7-*160!<*1
/*<,1 /,0,/,+,=><1 -/,-, <1 91 1 2:1 "<,:HK?1
-,"+-,0?1 ,</,<--1<=6!1:+2><1-<1 165;
-0*<?111/,-6-0,<1/--?1"! ,",1/,60+*1,6G1
-,0101/,+7:!16!"G(1
C>101H+,<1-,+6>1-1/,:H51(D(1F0-/*11I:;
0*10=,-71-,,-*1/0101!-+,0*G16<,2-,",1",;
-!6-01-1.!H*<1S<,6<T1-<!+,0*?1/,,L*11
,"2*1 1 6,/!-<,-71 I<+:HJ1 ,0-0,;
-101:,,6+7-0?1/11!2,;,2-G1,/6;
+*G?1<11<?1,<<?12,1,0>1,H/H1/0?1K;
62-,51 ,0-0,-1 1 6,+=>1 I-<7J1 01 2-01 /;
,,51G-!1/012:1",K1",-!6-0,;
",1/!=6*J(
%
10,0*1,<101-H?1010,:<,=,-1
/!=6*1/0L-*101 +",1/,=+(1
,1 ,,=6-0+1 /01 -1 -+<1 0,1 /,,<!?1 2,1
-+19110,, L1/!=6?110,, L1-1!L 1
=:11-, -0,-?1,1+871,1/!=611-1
!L ?1 ,,,1 !81 , L/:>1 /01 1 -0, ,6>12;
+,01 1 "=6(1 0,1 /!6+7,1 /,,<!?1 2,1 -!L-;
0!K1/0+?1,,>1, G,6<,1-, +K67(1:11<;
1",-!6-0,",1/!=6*?1:2<*1/,1/",0,!1-!;
6?11-01/61-, ,51H+1/2*1.:2-G1-651
+1!=*12+,02-,",16,-,-0(11M,<1-+6!1,<;
7?12,1:1: =,1-,6=101- 1<,<1>?1:;
+K2KL5-*1 01 /6!-<,>G1 2",+,0><1 ,6-,<1 31 +;
81+1,"21/011-0, ,610,0,",1+H1S2(%1-(1@R1
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
1 6F93857 1!1 E,-!6-0,1 /!=61 1 /0,0*1 ",*1 331 3,--5-51
K62-51=!+(1#$$&(1Q1%(17(1%&(1
1
1
1
3
2813T(1F-,0><1H+*<1:*1*0+*K-*110,--,0+1
-/06+0,-?1 -/0+1 ,-!=6,",?1 /,.+1 -,0;
8*1,0>G1/-!/+5(1
1A, ,0,+7,1 -/,+1 606<1 /0+1 /,06*1
+",6*1 -<,/!=6K1 1 ,=6-0,1 08<!1 0,:65;
-0K1 ",-!6-0(1 g+1 6<,2-,",1 , L-01 /6/,+;
"K1/,-/!K1:<!108",1"!+,0*1/,06*1+K;
651-<,"!+,0<?10!<1,,+<1-<,51+2,-1
-0,G165-05?1,-,:<1-,H+7,",1:2*1G1H+511/,;
-+6-05(1 ,2-,51 +70,51 +--2-,<!1 /6;
-0+K1 ,1 <,6G1 ",-!6-0,;/0,0,",1 "!+,0*11
! =6*1 1 /!=6*1 91 -",6*1 *0+*-*1 ,H1 /01 1
.,<>1 0,:65-0*1 2:1 /0,0,1 -<!+,0?1 /,,L?1
,"2(1014((1C+7,?1, L*10<11,?12,1:;
621 /01 -,-,1 1 ,+7,1 01 -6=01 /0,!851 1
:1 0,0>G1 +H?1 ,1 1 01 -<!+,01 /0,<,",1
/,06*1101/,,L1+H?165-0!KLG101-G1, L-;
0(1 F-, ,-71 /,,L+7>G1 -H5?1 /,6201 ,?1 01
, -/21G1-,H+7>G1H+51S +"T?1616,-=*1,,;
>G1 <,6+71 /0,<,",1 /,06*1 /,66=0-*1 K62;
-<1-6-0<?1,-, ,1G1H+5?16,-=1,,>G1>;
<1-/,-, <10,:<,=,(10,0,1/,,L1--<0-*1
1.,<11<1K62-,",1,6, *16, ,0,+7,",1:-+!;
=,",1/,06*?101:!+712",1 6+*1-! P10,:"=6;
*1 -!/K1 +",/*>1 /,-+6-0*1 91 /<?1 /,2>1
:0*?1 ,61 1 <6+1 1 (/(1 :1 /,,L+7>G1 -;
H5?1-214((1C+7,?1I !61,:2716+758160=1
!2,51<>-+11K62-,51/1/,1/!1-8*1/,;
:0>G1 2+1 01 /0?1 !0+2*1 h-<!+!KL",1 0-i1",1
-6-0?1 ,+1 :,-,,",1 -/,+7:,0*1 !/0+2-G1
<,6,010,:65-0*ZJ
%
1
1,M,<!1 , G,6<,1 0>6+*71 60,5-0!K1/,6!1/;
0,0,",1 /!=6*11 --0!K1 1 -! -6,0!K(1 2
61 /!6+7,-71, !-+,0+1H,-><1-,6=<1
/0?1!3561-+11<+7*1:L1/01";
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
17<(11()C67'1462-1/,,L*11:,06,-71-,H+7>G1-H51331
F L-0>1!11-,0<,-7(1%EE&(1Q1@(17(1'F9'&(1
1
3
!-*1",-!6-0,<(1<1<,6,01! =6*10,0-1
1-<10,/,-1,1/<1/!=6*101:!<>G1/;
6+G(1,1E(1[!?1/!6+7>1-H1/01 !K-*11
/,,<!?12,1 :1G10,, L11 >+,1 >1<,0,011/,-+!8KY1
,1!=>11"1,",?12,1->1G?1,16, ,0,+7,1
-, +K61/0,0>1!-,0+*?11 !6!1/->101=0!1
<?1,11G,21-, +K671,<>1 :1/!=6*(1:1--<>1
/!=6*1 /,-+!81 /0,0><1 ,<<1 >+,1 >1 -0*:,1 -1
-,<1 >71, <!><
%
(1
1!=61 /,60+*1 -,H+7>1 /,-!/?1 , -/;
201 :,,-7?1 ,G*1 /0,/,*6,?1 0>-!/1 -6-0,<1
-,H+7,",1 !/0+*?1 /,-,+7!1 , -/201 /,621
65-051+K651",-!6-0,510,+?1-+!=L51S016+T1, L;
-0!(1D1-",6*?1101, ,:<,51-,2-,51/-/01/!;
=61 !61, G,6<,16+*1,G>1/0,/,*6?1-, -0,;
-?1/011-,01"=611,":H5?1-,:6*1,<+7;
>G1 !-+,051 6+*1 6*+7,-1 ",-!6-0,51 0+-1 1 0+-1
<-,",1-<,!/0+*(10,1,6+<,1,1-+>?1,1-71-/,;
-, ,-1 /0,0><1 <,6<1 /,6,+071 -,/,0+1 G1
+1>G1+H?16, 07-*1/0,0><1,<<1/,62*1G10,;
+165-0!KL<1K62-<1!-,0+*<(1--+7,1/0,1
911/0,(1,1, ,-,0,1/<1-+>11-+1916+,1
1,6,11,1=(1-+1910/0,0,1*0+?1-,-,*L101/,;
60+?1 /,/1 -0, ,6,51 0,+1 +K ><1 -6-0<?1 01 ,<1
2-+151=-,<?1!=KL<11,-, +*KL<12+,0;
2-,16,-,-0,(1
1!=61<1 ,+11<,=1 >71-06,11-+K?1
/,-,+7!1+:!-*101<,",, :>G1.,<G11/6!/=6?1
/-2?1K62-*1,0-0,-7?1/0,0,--,0+11
/,H--!+7*1, -/2(1
C>1 /!=6*1 :+2K-*1 01 :0-<,-1 ,1 -/,-, 1
0,:65-0*1 S/,1 , P!1 0,:65-0*?1 G!1 /0,0,",1 0,;
=*1 01 -.!1 /0?1 -0, ,61 1-,01/!=6<,",1 +HT11
:!+71S/0,0>G1/,-+6-05T1G1/<*(1?1/,1G;
!1/0,0,",10,=*1 ,1/6-0+*K1-, ,51/0,0>1,";
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
1,6, 1-<(1 39395#7'(1+,-,.*1/0Z17(1FRF9FR'(1
1
1
1
!
3
2*?1 , <*1 1 ,0>1 65-0*
%
(1 +",/*>1
/,-+6-0*1 ,1 /<*1 <1 /!=6*1 0>-!/K1 01 061
/0,0,",1!,1S+81-/H+7,",1/0T1+ ,1/2*1
061S<,+7,",?1<+7,",?1.:2-,",T(1
5.551 S,"61 !/, +*-*1 <1 I;
-!H,,-7JT1/01,:2?12,1,,1/6-0+*11/,-,1
6?1/H/>?1!-,011(6(?1-0,5-0>1/0,-,:K?11
0>-!/1 1 --<1 , P0,0>G1 K62-G1 ,<?1
+:!<>G1/1/,<,L1",-!6-0(11M,<12-01/0,1-;
,0-*1 ,,-+7,1 -<,-,*+7><1 1 ,+7,1 ,1 ,6+7>G1
+H?1,11,1, L-0101H+,<?1-,:61-<!10,:<,=,-71:,;
,-(1,61:,,-7K1/,<-*1,51=<1I, L-0,51
=:?1,"610-1+H?10+K2*11",-!6-0>1,">?1!,;
0,6-0!K-*1/1,/6+1/0,<,-1+1/0,<,;
-1/,06*1+871,6<1<19165-0!KL<1K62;
-<1 ,<<?1 0>=><1 01 :,1 1 6!"G1 ,.H+7>G1
K62-G1 -,2GJ
#
(1 A5-0+7,-71 /01 0,:<,=1
01 :,,-?1 ,1 ->0-*1 01 :,,-1 1 2:1 :,;
,-7?10>-!/KL5116-0,1/,:0,51 .,<>11H,-;
,",1-,6=*(1
4!+:!*1 /, +<!1 /6+,=,",1 !-?1 01 <G1
6,",1-1<>1-,:+7,106<1:",0,1,1/01/<+7;
,11",-!6-0,;,":,0,<!1, L-0!1101-0*:1-1/, +;
<<?1/=0<><1-,0<><1,--5-<1, L-0,<?1,6;
+<><1,1",160",1/,8+,",(1,1<,1/,1M<1/2<?11
>11 >+10=1:",0,1,1--<,-1/0?1-,08-0,01
K62-,51G?10>-,,516.0,-1,<1/0?1"+0><1
,--*10,/,-1910,1<*12",1-!L-0!K11:00K-*1M116!"1
-,,>?1-0,5-011.,<>10>=*1/0V11
5K >1 /,/>1 -,-!,071 H,+-2-!K1,-;
!HK1 /0?1 -0*:>0*1 1 ,+7,1 -1 "!+*H51 , L-0>G1 ,;
,85?1/<<1-,0?1 ,-0<1, L",1 +"?1 !;
6!101,2,<1,"1-,-,*+7>?1<1 >1!0*<101-,;
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
1 0,0>1 ,"2*?1 /<?1 /,6/-1 ,1 0>:6Y1+81 -/H+7,",1 /01 91
!+,01:8*11G11,81,!=*Y1, <1910,:+,=1-/;
H+7,51 , *:,-1 /,1 *016+*1"-H1 01 FAY1 ,0>1 65-0*191/<1
.:2-,51-+>?1-/H+7>G1-6-0?1/<1,"-+7,",1,!=*(
11
#
17<(113C933F71,*1/0(1C(?1%EE@(17(1EF(1
1
"
3
H+7,51 H,-1 /01 ,1 1 -,/,0,=6+-7(1 0,?1 !6!21
--,2-<1 2+,<1 2+,02-,51 6!G,0,-?1 0>=1
,-, ><1, :,<1 /:1+2,51-0, ,6>12+,011",1--;
0>G1 /01 1 <.:2-,51 6,-(1 71 M,51 ,21 :*1
<,=,1 /,66=71 /.,-1 O((18!:H,01 S"!<1 <T1 01
,H1A+H1:0-<,-17X41S%''F1"(T1,1-<,,206,;
-1:/+>G10151-11I2,10-1+K61-,:6>10><?12,1
,16+>17,:6+<1,/6+><1,P<+<><1/0<?1
-61,,>G1<K-*1/011=:7?1-0, ,6!111-<+11
-2-7KY12,1/0+7-01/:0>1, -/2071M1/011,-!;
L-0+*K1-0,K10+-71-1-,"+-*1G?1<1,1!/0+*K?112,1-;
+1.,<1/0+7-01-,0-*1" +7,516+*1H+1-<,",1-0,;
",1 -!L-0,0*?1 ,61 <1 /0,1 :<71 +1 ,<71 ?1
!2671,0,1/0+7-0,?1,-,0,11MG1/H/G?11!-;
,0710+-7101,51.,<?1*?1/,1",1<K?1+!281, -/;
21",1 :,/-,-711 +",6-0J
%
(1
D<,1H,->1/:1/010>=K1,-, ,1<-,1
1 ,+71 /01 1 02,",?1 !0-+7,",?1 --,2-,",1
2+101=:1, L-011!+7!>(1, *1.,<!1:,?1
H,-12+,02-,",1-!L-0,0*1<1-<><1/6K1,/;
6+!K1H,-71:,!(1C>1:6+*<1/,:HK?1-,"+-,1,;
,,51-, -0,1-/H.2-,1-,6=1/0?101,+21,1
6!"G1 -,H+7>G1"!+*,,0?10>=1 6-0,1-0, ,6>?1
0-011-/06+0,-(11
;1 36651 1 365&36?1 :+K2KL-*101 -,:<;
10-G1606,01,6,51-,H+7,51/,--7K?1,6,511,51=1
0,51 <,5(1 30,/01 1 0-0,1 91 ",1 0:<,-0*;
:>?1,11,=6-0>(1F612+,011<,=1 >7101
6!",<!?1((1=6>51, +61/,0,<><1,-, ,-*<1;
++!+7,",?1.:2-,",?10,2-,",1:0*?1.,<!;
-*1165-0!101:+2>G1-,H,;!+7!>G1!-+,0*G(120*71
:+2>G1 +K651 /,1 ,6,<!1 -6!1 0,:<,=,?1 1 /2;
-*1 /,/>1 -6+71 M,1 SI!0+,0JT1 91 061 1 6"6H1
, L-011!+7!>(181! 6+7,1/,:+10-<*1-,;
*?10-1/,/>1-,:671, L-0,1.2-,",10-01:,;
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
17<(11753#6F75'(?1"!<1<1S,0T(18:-1-,0<,",1/0,-,:*1331
0,06(1%EE@(1Q1R(17(1)(1
1
1
1
#
3
,<,1/0,6*11,6<11<1=1"0><1:!+7<(1O,1
91 0-0+-1 ",-!6-0,51 K,?1 ,:>0KL5-*1 ,+1
I0,5J?1!-0+0KL51-610-011,,+!KL51
",1 -, +K6Y1 /*1 1 -,H+7,1 =602-0,1 -+*?1
I<*KL",J1 -0,1 /01 1 -0, ,6>1 1 ",0!K1 I/5!JY1
/,*1 6<1 :0*?1 :-,51 1 6"6H*(1 A+*1 !0+,01
G>1 <+,2*1 "+<H*1 <<+7,1 6,:0,+,",1 1
<-<+7,-71:/L,",?1/2<1/,61:/1/,/610-?12,1
/0>81 !,071 :!*6,-?1 /,-6-0,-?1 *0+*-*1 /,6;
+,1,0,-<11/6,0><(1 H/1I:/L,10-?12,11
:8,J1:/!-10165-01<G:<>1,-0H11,<,;
=*1, L-0,",1:0*(1 D<,101,<1 , L-01 H;
+7><1 -,0-*10>-:>0191IH01:!<J?1<-;
-,0,51 91 -,H+7,;/-G,+,"2-*1 !-,01 1 /--0,-71 1
,.,<:<(1
120=61 0-01 1 0,/0*1 -61 0>G?1
((10-01K62-,",1910=58*12?1-,6=1/;
0(181/,620+1(1W2?1I-*1/061-,-,101/;
:1:10-<10,",12+,02-,",16,-,-011-0, ,6>?101
G1 >1!-+,0*G12+,011G,6+-*?11,1 >1/,+,=1
1:<+(1O,110>=-*1010-01/0?11K62-,51
0,:<,=,-1 65-0,07?1 ,,*1 /-00-*1 +H!1 1 ,;
0,<!(1 ,1 1 1 -0, ,6,1 /,+7:,01 M<1 /0<1 061 1
0,<!1/, K1=:>G1 +"?1,1/:1M,",1;
0-0?10>KL",1:1-<,",1,-,0,",12+?1-,-0+*?101
-0,K1 ,267?1 /<,1 ,01 /06>J
%
(1 :*1
I/06J1 91 01 /,*0+1 , L-01 0,2-1 H0>G1 1
/6/<20>G1 +K65?1 ,,>?1 01 <G1 !-,0+>G1 :,;
,<1 0>G1 0,:<,=,-5?1 -<,-,*+7,1 S-0, ,6,T1 ,/6+*;
K1H+11-6-01-0,516*+7,-?11/,0,2L1:,;
!?1 -0,51 M"5?1 -0,<1 +<1 1 -/,-, ,-*<?1 /0;
LKL<1 M1 0,:<,=,-1 01 65-0+7,-7(1 3:!<-*?1 /1
M,<1 +7,1 /, >1 S-! P0>T1 /01 !6!1 0;
><(1I462-,1S.,<+7,T10-0,1-! P,01/0?191
:<215(D(17/6,,0?191-,-,1101,<?12,1,1, +6K1
,6,0><1 /,1 -0,<!1 ,,<!1 -,6=K1 /0<1 1 , *;
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
1A23A57(12:(1-,2(17(1EE(1
1
$
3
:,-*<?110,10:<,-1G1/011, *:,-5?1,/6+>G1
,6,511,51=10,, *:+7,5
%
1,<,51/0(1DG1K62-,1
0-0,1/,*0+*-*1<,10,10:<,-1/011, *:,-5?1
:6>G1,<<J(1,<+7,-71/0,0,",10-0110;
-0,1 .2-G1 -! P0>G1/01-,:6K1 ,/6+>51/,*;
6,10-0110-0?1-,"+-,0>G1/,16,<!1,-,0K11
, L51 ,<(1 3:+21 01 /, >G1 /0G1 *0+*-*1 :,,;
<><1 :!+7,<1 65-0*1 /H/1 /0,0,",1 S.,<+7,",T1
0-0?10,51/0,-/,-, ,-1606,0(11
<1 , :,<?1 01 K62-,<1 -<>-+1 0-0,1 ,:21
0-0,1 01 /0,;?1 6;1 1 6+,-/,-, ,-?1 0-0,1 /61
-!6,<11:,,<?10-0,101-G,6>G1/0,0>G10,:<,=,-*G?1
:0-<,1,1/,+?1->?1/,.--11(6(1U,,6+7,1/;
:1 K62-,",1 0-01 +K651 1 , +6+51:> +;
<>G1/011-0, ,61-,-0+*1-!L,-,1,/6+1-,0<;
,",1"=6-,",1, L-011/0,0,",1",-!6-0(1
F-,07-*11M,<191:21!/!-71:106!1,271-7;
:,1 , -,*+7-0,(1 A,-,2,1 60,1 0>60!1 "/,:1 ,1
6- +:!KL51 ,+1 0-01 01 -/6+1 6,G,6,01
-+*11/2>1/-!/,-(1,1,,<!1:<2K19(D(1
E+-,",11 IE+0><1 01 ":-1 60,-?1 0+K2*1 /;
-!/,-7?1 *0+*-*1 1 -<1 /,1 - 1 !,071 !6,0+0,*1 0;
+7>G?1-,H+7>G116+7>G1/, ,-5?11-/71:+;
25?1I:>0J1010,:<,=,-*G1G1!6,0+0,*16+*1:+2>G1
-,H+7>G1 "!//(1 U0-7?1 !6,0+0,,-7?1 /,<1 -;
<,510,:<,=,-1=71+!281/G,6*1+87101-0J
#
(11,;
+,=01M!16K101,-,0!1-0,51"/,:>?17(E(1F+7,01-1/<;
<1<<2-G11-"2-G1<,6,01! 6+7,1/,;
:+?1 2,1 ,/6+,1 0-0,1 01 -/6+1 6,G,6,01
<,=1 ,:>071 +",/*,1 0,:65-01 1 M,,<2-,1
:01, L-0(11,1=10<*160=1-,H+7,51--<>11
,21<-<+7,",1:>01<=6!1 6><11 ,"><191;
,+1 ,/-,<!1 -,-,*K1 , L-01 91 20,1 -,.,5(1 F;
-K610>0,610,11IZ1,2*>1/,/>10,+KH,,0?1/;
0,06,0116!"G16*+5?1-<*LG-*11!-,0+K10-;
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
18AAE656F78!1,*1",-!6-011/0(1C(?1%EEE(17(1%%%
(1
#
1AA59CA7*!18<,+,"*(18!-1+H5(17 (?1#$$#(17(1%F$(1