Ершов Ю.Г. Философия права
Подождите немного. Документ загружается.
1
1
1
3
/01 2+,01 1 ,-,0>G1 -0, ,6(1 1 -0,K1 ,267?1 M,1 061 1
!0+2K1"!:101B0,/5-,51,<--1/,1/0<12+,0;
?1B0,/5-,<1-!61/,1/0<12+,0118,<1<-,01
S,"17,01B0,/>T?1!0+2K1-,,01--<,*1-/,,0(1
411 1 =+, 1 /,6+=1 0,/5-,51 --<1 ,,+*1+871
,"6?1,"61/,151-2/>10-1H,+7>1-6-01:L>1
!8,",1/0?11H,+7>1-,1--<,*1=+, >1
1<781<=6!,6>G?1,1, L51-,1:L>1"=6,<1
-0,G1 /01 <,=1 -*!7-*1 1 %$;%)1 +(1 B--0,?1 2,1 :1
,16++7,10<*1<,",1<,=1:<7-*11817!61
/,*1/2-,1:216+*1-H
%
(11
F<<11,?12,11! =1!+0>G116-*>G1",6,0101851
-1H1"=6-,",1/,0,0*1010610>!=6>G1;
-H,,0>G1<",0116<,-H51/-K-*1<+H;
5?11,-, ,1:6!<>0KL5-*1,1:,,-118,-!H?1 :;
,,6+7-0,1/,1 ,7 1-1M-<:<,<12:<,1-8+7;
,?1/,:0,+**1/,60-1/,61M-<:<10-12,1!",6,(11
<11<?1<,=,1:.-,071"!<-2-51-60"1
01 ,--5-,<1 :,,6+7-01 91 01-,,!1-<,"!+*H1/,0;
6*1-! P,01/0?1-8*1G1-0, ,6>1SM,10>=-*?101
2-,-?101-!L-0,<1,-1,+1606!+7>G1/0,0>G1
,0?101/0!K1,267?16,",0,,0T(171,21:*1-0, ,6>?1/;
0,1 0-1 01 ,+7851 -/1 +:!K1 -0,K1 -!L,-71 01 ,<G1 1
,<,0>G1 G?1 , -/20KLG1 -,0<-,1 "=6;
-,;,++0,1 -!L-0,01 +K651 1 /H/G1 +2,51
-0, ,6>11/1<<!<1+7,",1-+*(10,0>1,<>1
/,1-!1-0,51"!<-2>?1/,-,+7!1/,0,21/,:0,+!191
,1:/LK1, L7-*1-1+K67<11-1I0<J1-,H+7;
,;/,+2-,",1 <G:<?1 :0,+7><1 , P<1 6<-;
,0*?1<1 >1 +"<110+<1H+*<1,,11, ,-,;
0>0+,-7(1 462-,1 /0,/,<1 /6-0+*1 2+,01
0>-851-,H+7,51H,-7K?1,,!K1",-!6-0,16,+=,1,G;
*7?11, L-0,1/:07(1,"2*1!",+,0*1/-;
-*1,+,",1 ",-!6-01 /,60+*11 ,+7,11 1-,+7,1
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
1,6, 1-<(11239C6F78 1,,,+1Q1%%11B0,/5-,51,0H1/,1:L1
/01 2+,01 1 ,-,0>G1 -0, ,611 M0,+KH*1 +1 0,+KH*V1 331 -1 C,-(1!;(1
7*1%%(10,(1%EEF(1Q1)(1
1
3
/-!/!K10,+K?1-,+7,1-0, ,6!K10,+K11,0!K(11-G1
/61 -!6 ><1 -/0<1 +K61 ,-"K-*1 -, -0,",1
0,+:P*0+*?1 H0>?1 +K ,51 -<,-,*+7,-(1 7,-,*;
1 <--,0,51 :0+,-1 1 ,+7,1 //*-0!1 /,*0+K1
,6>G?1 M"2>G1 !?1 ,1 1 /,,=61 <--,0>51 /1
,+1,/-,",1/-!/191!-+0,;,-<,+7,",(1
0-0,51 0,,<1 2+,01 91 -/,-, ,-1 -<,<!1
,-,:071 :2<,-71 1 H,-71 0-0>G1 ,051 -,1
-,,>1, L-01010<8+7-01",-!6-0191-,,0-0!1
!+*10,,<*11-/,-, ,-711<1-<,-,*+7,1-!;
671912,16+*1",1*0+*-*10>",6><?112,10>",6><(1IW+,;
0!(((?191 /,620+1 O(4(1 7,+,070?1 91 6,+=1 >71/6,-0;
+1 0,:<,=,-71 65-0,071 1 -0,51 -G1 1 -?1 6+*1 /, 1 1
,/>>G1 0>0,6,0?1 6+*1 ,8 ,1 1 /85J
%
(1 2+:<1 01
6,<1-+!211,=6-01-2+0,-1M",-2-,",1;
606?1G,*111-+K21/,6, ,",1/,06*(1A+,1016!",<(1
D(18?1 /,:0851 -,0<-<,-71 -2+0,-1 1 <,+?1
<11<1:LL+1/H/1!+,510,,<1606?1
2,1 G,,8,1 06,101 ",1/,<1-0, ,6>12+,0?1I/H/1
,,,5101,,81!-,5-01, L-01*10>=K101-+6!K;
L51.,<!+111,611<,=1/!671<*1 >71-2-+0><1
?11,1G,21S?11,1/6-0+*1- 1 +",/,+!216!;
"G1+K65TY1=6>510/01-71-0,",1-2-7*11,<1/!?1,;
,>51<!1-<,<!1/6-0+*-*1G,,8<?1-+1,+7,1,1M<1
1,-1!L 1-0, ,616!"<1-<7-*11/,6, ,51H+J
#
(1
1 <G1 !+,51 0,,<1 +2,-71 , +61 0,:<,=,;
-7K1 65-0,071 1 -0,51 -G1 1 -?1 6, 07-*1 !-/G1 +1
/71/,=(171M,51,21:*1:,!116+16,10!;
",1-,-,**12+,01 91",1-,,0>G1=+5?1!-<;
+5?1-,511(6(1::+21!",+,0,",1:,11L1;
0,/+,L><1 -! P0><1 <*<?1 /,1 :<2K1
O(4(17,+,070?1 0>=1 K62-51 "!<:<191 :!-+,0,1
/60+7,1 6,01 =6,<!1 2+!1 , L-0(1 I,-+61
, -/20-*1H+,51-,0,!/,-7K1 ,05?1:/+*<>G101
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
166F)3F75/10,0,51"+:<11"!<-2-51-<>-+1/0133180M--H*(1
C(?1%EE$(17(1#%%(1
#
157!17,2*111F1(1(@(1W(1#(17(1'E(1
1
1
1
3
/,H--!+7>G1,6-G11//*-0!KLG1,<!?12, >1-1+K67;
<1, L+-711-1h/,H+7><1/-!/<i(1,0>11
/:!</H*10,0,-?1-,",1,",0,>1/0+1/,+H5;
-,",1 0<8+7-0?1 :6=*1 1 , >-?1 -,G1 5>1
-+6-0*?1 "+-,-71 -!6 ,",1 : +7-0?1 /0,1 /,6-!6;
<,",11:L!11(16(J
%
1<1-<><12*1: ,,-711;
!,-+7,1 -, +K61 /,H--!+7>G1 ,<1 0>-!/K1 <;
,51 H0+:,0,-1 /0,0,51 --<>1 , L-0(1 3:!<-*?1
6+:,0,-71 1 !,-+7,-71 -, +K6*1 /,H--!;
+7>G1"51<,"!1,:7-*1,51=1.+780,516+H;
5?111/,0,:"+8>1/0,0>1,<>(1,1-<,1G1+2101
:,,6+7,51 --<1 /,:0,+*1 6071 /H/+7!K1
,H!1.2-,<!1-,-,*K1-!6 ,510+-11 :!-+,0!K1
,/,!16+*1 ,7 >1/,01/,:0,+11-+*(11
E!<-2-1H,-11H,-1/01-,0/6K?1, ;
:!*1 6,1 H+,(1 9%1 $.1 /01 :+K2;
-*101,<?12,1,,10>-!/11, P0,10,:<,=>511, ;
G,6<>51 <-8 1 -,H+7,51 -0, ,6>?1 -<!+!KL51 0,2;
-!K1 0,-7?1 -<,-,:1 2+,01 1 ",1 ,0-0,-7(1
30>10,:<,=,-?1-/06+0,-7?1-0, ,610> ,?1-+,011-,;
0-1 91 M1 , L2+,02-1 H,-1 -,-0+*K1 .!6<1
/0,0,",1 -!-1 +2,-101 H0+:,0,<1 , L-0(1 1 M,<1
/+10G,0-0,1/01-71,-, >51-,H+7>51.,<?1-0*;
:>51 -1 -,2-1 0,:KL<1 /0,<1 =6,",1 2+,01 1
"=611-0, ,6!?10-0,11-/06+0,-7?1, !-+,0+;
>1 -,H+7,51 /,6,51 +2,-(1 2=1 -<,1 -+,0,-,21
I/01(((12+,0J1-1"!<-2-51-<>-+161K62;
-,",1 :/+*1 , L2+,02-,5?1,6,0,51-!L,-1 /, ;
,-511-,012+,01, L-0(1012+,010>=K11
:LLK1 /02>1 /6/,->+1 6,-,5,",1 2+,02-,",1
-!L-0,0*?1:0-<,1,1->11H,+7,-?1-,H+7,;
",1 /,+,=*1 1 /,.--(1 1 K62-,<1 6-!-1 ",*1
I6,-,-0,J1 0>=1 ,P<+<,1 -0,5-0,1 2+,0?1 :;
0-<,1,1,",?11,1-<1+1,!=KL1+K610,-/<K1
1,H0K1",11+2,-7(11
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
166F)3F757/12:(1-,2(17(1#%@(1
1
3
52,-71, 0*<,",?1-/06+0,1-21((16,0?1
6,+=1 0--,,1 !2>07-*1 /1 81 0-G1 ,-,0>G1 0,;
/,-,01 /,1 !",+,0,<!1 6+!(1 ,1 ",1 <K11 IZ6*+7,->51
/,6G,611/,-,K1-!!>11->K1-,6=*1+2,-1
61 0,:<,=,-71 -, 71 -06*?1 , P0,1 G:!KL1
?1 2,1 0-7<1 <+,0=,1 01 !",+,0,<1 -!6,/,:0,6-0J
%
(1 3-;
-<,1=6,",1, 0*<,",12+,01016-01",12-011
,?1"=6112-,",1+H1/,:0,+*16071-/06+;
0!K1,H!1",1=:,",1/!11/,06*1012-01, 0*<,;
",?1,/6+*71-/,-, >11.,<>1",1/0,-/*(1
E!<:<1/01-,-,1101,<?12,1-/,1,1/0101-!61*0;
+*-*1 ,+1H0+:,0,51.,<,51:8*1-,H+7>G1
,.+,0(1462-51,.+1/,1 01<G1,/6;
+,51/0,0,51/,H6!>?1/6!-<01<-<+7,1-,;
"!K1 1 6,-,0!K1 "!<HK?1 8-*1 1 ,-,01 -H,;
,0,510,+1",-!6-0(11<10=,1-<+1<=6!;
,6,",1 -,, L-01 :+K271 <=6!,6>1 ,.+>1 01
<1,<11/H/,01<=6!,6,",1/0?1G,*?11-,=+;
K?1,,10-1 0<*1-+0-*1-1/,51I60,5>G1-6;
,0J101",/,+2-G1,,8*G(1
1 ,2-0,51 K-/!6H1 ,-!-0!1 , L/:;
,1/,<1-!L,-1/012+,0?1<K1<-,1:>1/,6;
G,6>(1F <10<11/,:HK1-,,,01+--2-,",1
--0,",1/0?1-2KLG?101-,,0-01-1:0-,51.,;
<!+,5?12,1/012+,01*0+*K-*1",1,P<+<><1-0,5-0,<1
1 /6+=1 =6,<!1 -1 <,<1 ,=6*(1 DG1 /,:0H*1 01
:,,6+7-011"*1+:H11<*1.1 :;
2+7,511 :!-+,0,51/02,-1--0>G1/0?1,16;
+*K-*1 2-0<1 I/,=6,-J?1I,2!=6<,-J?16=1
I-0*L,-J(1 ,6, >51 0:"+*61 S !0+7*1,01 I--;
0,-J1 /0T1 /6-0+*-*1 1 0><?1 1 !/,L><(1 F1
/,0,21 .<1 -,2,-1 /,+,;/0,0,51 ,-;
!H1,-,0>G1/011G16*10/0>1.,<!+!-*101M/,G!1
,0,",1 0<?1 ,1 :00K-*1 ,1 /,,+*1 1 /,,+K1
,-,0>G1/0?1 ,+78*12-712+,02-011/,1-51671=01
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
D
7'3E35AC6F7 "1C-,11,+71+2,-1, 0*<,",101/6<16,:>0*1/,1!",;
+,0,<!16+!1331E,-!6-0,11/0,(1#$$R(1Q1'(17(1@&(1
1
1
1
3
01 -.>1 G1 65-0*1 1 (6(1 ,+1 ,21 /,:H*1 ,,01
+ ,;K62-,",1 /,6G,6?1 -0*:>0KLG1 ,P<+;
<,-71/012+,01-1",12-0,<1-,H+7,",1-! P?1,;
-K6191-1,/6+><1G,<10:<,,,8516061
1 ",-!6-0?1 /1 ,,,<1 /01 2+,01 /,:0!K-*1 1
1 ,"21 0+-?1 1 1 <1 -0, ,6>?1 1 1 /*:*1
1-,H+7>1 +"1(6(1
,M,<!1/012+,01, +6K11I--0,5J?11!+7;
!,;-,2-,51 /,6,5?1 6,+=>1 >71 ,->1 1 /,;
-6-0,;-,H+7><1/0<1?101,+21,16!"G1,G*;
<>G1 :,,<1 -,0?1 , -/2071 1 ,6+7>1 -,,>1 2;
+,02-,51 =:6*+7,-?1 1 ,<+7,1 -!L-0,01 1
:01 2+,01 1 , L-01 01 H+,<(1 , ,-?1 +=L1 01
,-,01MG1-,0?1*0+*K-*1/6/,->+<10,-/,:0,6-01
6,51 .,<>1 , L-0,",1 :0*1 1 1 !+7!,",1 -,6;
=*(1 ,M,<!1 1 !/, +*-*1 G1 G-1 1 --;
0>G1 1 ,P<+<>G1 /01 2+,0(1 ,-*"+7-0,1 1 M1
/01 /6-0+*1 !",:!1 -<<1 ,-,0<1 2+,02-,51 H0+;
:H(1[,?12,1-",6*1/6-0+1,1/0G12+,0?1
/!-71 1 01 :,51 /H?1 *0+*-*1 ,P<+<><1,</,;
,<1 1 ,+7,1 + +7,5?1 ,1 1 -,H+;6<,2-,5?1 1
,-00,516,+,"5(1
012+,010,:K101+K ,<1, L-0?11G1/0,,-;
,0,51 *0+*K-*1 /*:*1 6061 1 ,/6+>1 -,H+7;
>1 +"11+210,:<,=,-1+:,0711/*:*(1
8=6*1 M/,G1 <1 ,/6+>51 ,1 -,H+7>G10,:<,=,;
-5?1 1 :621 /,"--0,",1 :0*1 2+,02-,",1 , L-01
-,-,101,<?12, >1-/,+7:,0710,:<,=,-101/,+,51<(11
M,<1/+1+*1[*1%#%)1",611<1:2<116+*1-0,;
",10<?1118"10/6101:01/012+,0?12<1A;
+H*1/012+,011"=61%'&E1",6(1
A+1 !0-+7,",1 1 ,,;-,2-,",1 01
:01 /01 2+,01 0>=-*1 01 ,<?1 2,1 /01 2+,01
!0-+7>1 /,1 ,,8K1 ,1 0-<1 "=6<?1 /,=0KL<1
+1G,6*L<-*11,16,",1",-!6-0?1/,1,,8;
K1 =1 1 2+,02-0!1 01 H+,<1 0,<,-71 -,2-,",1
/,H--1 61 ,+78,1 :,, :1 --<1 /01 :>G1 ",-!;
1
3
6-0(1 3+7>1 /0;-0, ,6>?1 ,/6+*KL1 K62-51
-!-1+2,-?1<K1/H/+7,1:216+*1,H1-;
/1 :0,-?1 6<,2,-1 ,51 +1 ,51 --<>(1 DG1
-81 :1 -21 ,0>G1 /0?1 1 1 ,,-<>G1 1 :*6!1
I--0>GJ?1*0+*-*1,6<1:10=58G1/,:+51, L;
-0,",11/0,0,",1/,"--(11
1-,12+,02-01/,-+=0-*1,/6+*1+,";
1 :0*1 61 /01 2+,011 ,1 +2>G1 S606!+7>GT1
/01911"!//,0><1S/0<1:+2><1-,H+7>G1"!//T?1,1G1
91 1 ,++0><1 S/0<1 H5?1 ,6,0?1 0-",1 2+,02-0T(1
!=!:,;6<,2-10,+KH1[oAA191[oAAA100(1:,,6;
+7,1 :/+1 "0>1 /0?1((1 /0?1 :LLKL1 2-;
!K1-.!1=:6*+7,-12+,01,1",-!6-0,",10<8;
+7-0(1 1 ,H1 [oAAA10(1 01 ,+1 :0>G1 -G1 B0,/>1 1
4<1,.,<+*K-*1"!//,0>1->101061-,-+,0>G1/;
0+"511/01,6+7>G1-,H+7>G1"!//11+--,0?11012+1
[[10(10,:1H+>51*61-/H+:,0>G1, +-51:,,6;
+7-01S,-+0,",?1 ,2",?1",",?1/,<>8+,",11(6(T?1
"!+!KL",1"!//,0>1/0(1"2-51,/>1<,0>G10,511
/,H-->1 6,+,:H1 0>:0+1 1 =:1 ,++0>1 S-/,;
-*KL-*11,6+7>1,6>11HT110-, L1S6+*10-",1
2+,02-0T1/0(1I71/*<1/,-+1,,51<,0,510,5>?191
,<217(D(1E+!8,0?1916+H511,0H51FF1/,1/0<1
=L?1 -,08,+G?1 0+6,0?1 =H0?1 !6*LG-*;
<",011(/(12K1.,<,07-*1<=6!,6>1-6;
>1 "!//,0>G1 /0?1 /,:=1 /,+!2KL1 :/+1 01 -6G1
",+7>G1,":H5J
%
(11
E,0,*1,1,<?12,1<=6!,6,1/0,?1,H!*1,/>1
:0*1<,0,51H0+:H101061, L/:>G191, L2;
+,02-G191,<11/H/,0?1-,"+-!10,+1",-!6-01-1:;
+2><1 M,,<2-<?1 /,+2-<?1 -,H,!+7!><1
--<<?1 <>1 1 6,+=>1 !/,L71 /, +<!1 -,,,8*1 , ;
L2+,02-,",11H,+7,",(1
120=6-*?1 2,1 6+*1 /0+7,",1 /,<*1 /,6>1
/01 , G,6<,1-G,671:1 ,-!-0*1!0-+7,-101-,;
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
13C6F7!1D606!+7>?1"!//,0>?1,++0>110-, L1/0101!-+,0;
*G1<!+7!+7!+:<1331,+-(1#$%$(1Q1F(17(1%R%
(1
1
1
1
!
3
H+7,51 ,":H1 :+2>G1 , L-0?1 -,0<-<,-1
6,+,"2-G1 1 /,:0+7>G1 !-,0,?1 ,/6+*KLG1 -,;
6=1 G1 +1 >G1 !+7!,;-,2-G1 --<1 /01 1
-,,0-0!KLG1 ,51 /0,/,<*(1 6-0+*1 ,1 /;
0G12+,011-!1:,?10:<,-0*:1G1-1",-!6-0,<10-"61
0>=K1,-, ,-1,51+1,51H0+:H(18=6*1H0;
+:H*?1=6*1H,+7*1!+7!1G:!K-*1,-, ><1
6-0,<1 :+2>G1 -/,-, ,01 H,-,;,<0,51 "!+*;
H?1 /1 M,<1 ,<0>1 --<>?1 -!L-0!KL1 01 ,<1 +1
,<1 , L-0?1 /,1 ,,8K1 6!"1 1 6!"!1 <,"!1 ,-71 1
0:<,/,66=0KL5?1 1 1 ,!!KL51 G(1 1
M,<?1:1-+K2<1-,-,*51G,-11,<?101, L-01,61
:1 --<1 *0+*-*1 06!L5?1 , -/20KL51 -,H+7!K1 -,+;
6,-7?10>/,+*KL51"0!K1.!HK(11:/6,51H;
0+:H1 6,<!1 /0,?1 ,1 0,0-1 1 /,,<!?1 2,1 2,51
!+7!1:2+7,1/-!L16!G1606!+:<1S-,"+-,1,;
,><1 -/,-><1 <.,+,"<<T?1 2>51 /,+-1 91 , ;
L1-,10-<112<1,++0:<116H,+:<(1,1
.,<>17,+,16+1,+2,1:0K1,-, ,-11"2-,",1
/,+-?11<-,51, L>191, L10>G?101,+21,10,-;
,2,",1 /+--,",1 ",-!6-0(1 8,2,?1 01 :/6,0,;
/5-,51!+7!1:,110-0,-7?1/0,11<,+71:+;
2K-*?1,1:+2K-*101<G16-01916-01-/06+;
0,-1 1 6+1 6,+=,",(1 0,1 1 --<0-*1 1 2,1
08?1 2!=6,1 2+,0!?1 ?1 /<?1 01 ,.!H-,<1 8;
(1 ,M,<!1 /,621 /0!?1:,,/,-+!8,1 /,061 /,;
+,=+7,1 -H,!-*1 <,+7K(1 ,\1 1 M0,+KH1 /0?1
/6-0+,51 /-,51 ,51 H0+:H,>G10,01 1
:>0<1/G,6,01,1,6,",1/1, L-0>G1,,8511
6!",<!?1 <,=,1 1 !=,1 /,-+=071 6-0,1 G1 /:,01
/0?1,,>1, G,6<>116,-,2>16+*10>6+*1/0101
2-01-<,-,*+7,",1.,<(1
6--!6,<1 , >6,",1 -,:*?1 2-,1 /,6/+*;
<><1 -6-0<1 <--,0,51 .,<H1 1 6, ,-,0-><1
-/!+*H*<1 /,+,0?1 *0+*-*1 /6-0+1 , 1 -+<1 S1
811",1,P<+<,512-T11+"1/<0,51
1 !-085?1 /,,L*KL51 /<,-71 1 -+/,51 .:<(1
1
"
3
,+1 ,",?1 01 ,2-G1 --+6,0*G1 <,=,1 0-71
/,/>1 /,0,/,-0+*1 !",+,0,",1:,,6+7-0?1/,;
-,,",11<=6!,6>G1/H/G?111M,;/0,0>G1
/H/G1<!-!+7<-G1,6,0(1<1-<><10,-/,:0,6;
-*1 :6=,1!-08510,/,H:<101-01:+2;
>G1!+7!1S+1,6+7>G1M+<,0T?16,"<1,1/,+,<11 :;
!-+,0,<1 /0,-G,6-01 ,<,;"<-,",1 /01 61 0-<1
6!"<1/0,0><1-<7*<(1
C=6!1<?1/1 ,+10<+7,<11"+! ,,<1,,81
18!11<!-!+7<-,<!1/0!1,:>0-*?12,1,1,"61
1-0,6+-*1,+7,11+",:,516,"<11!+7!?1"!+!*1
/,061<!-!+7<1110!KLG?1101,1=10<*11/,-,1
+K65(13--<0*1!+7!!18?15(3(17K*510>6+*1
01 <1 1 /6/-*?1 ,,>1 "!+!K1 081 /,061
2+,011/*<,11:"0K1",1+",:,51-,0-110!;
51 <,0H1 /,-!/,0(1 ,-,*,1 -->+*-71 1 --+6,0;
*10,>G1-+<-G1!2>G?10,10>6+*101,<0;
>G1/6/-*G18191.G191H,+7>1-/,-, >1,+;
,0*1,6,:2>G1/6/-518,11-!>1<!-!+7<;
-<1/0,06<118*?1/,1,,><1M1-,210,, L1
G*1<,+2(11M,<1+K21810,, L1/:01-+!=7?1
/=610-",?1-<12+,011!6,0+0,K1",1<-G1
/, ,-5(1 IF6,0<,1 /6/,+"-*?1 2,1 +K *1 -+<;
-*1,<1H+11/,66=11:L!1,6,51:1/*1,-;
,0>G1 H,-51 81 91 +"?1 =:?1 :!<?1 /,6,+=;
*1,611-, -0,-(1!6,1:<7?191/,62015(3(1
7K*5?1912,1+871/0*1:1G1/,-6-0,10>=1
,",,,0!K1 /,6!1 8?1 1 ,-+7>1 ,+781 /,62;
0K1",1-0-!K1/0+,-7J
%
(1,60=61M!16K11
7((1,, ,0?1 -->+*-71 1 /,L+7!K1 271 ,,1 01 ,;
-+6<1 /+,<2-01 1 -0*>1 8 >?1 /,0,:"+-08",?1 2,1
I=:7?1<!L-0,112-71=6,",12+,014++G1-6++1/;
,-,0><11-0*L><ZJ
#
(1
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
17<(11ECA53578B1X11+"*?10-0,-7?1/0,1331E,-!6-0,11/0,(1
%EEF(1Q1&(17(1%#R(1
#
166543C6F71F-,0>1H,-1-+<191, P>1,G>181331E,-!6-0,11
/0,(1#$$R(1Q1#(17(1E@(1
1
1
1
#
3
1<G1M,51-0-,51H,+7,;/0,0,51, ,-,0,;
-12+,0!1/6,-0+*-*16,-,2,18,*1-0, ,610> ,;
1 65-05?1 -+1 ,1 1 /6!-<,,1 8,,<11 : ,*-71 , 1
606!+7,<1/0?181-+61:1<?12, >1,,11,;
-+,1!L 16!"<11, L<!1 +"!(1:<,-0*:>1<=6!1-, ,51
61 -/06+0,-1 1 0-0?1 2,1 /,60=6-*1 -<1
8,1 1 -!>(1 +K2*1 01 - *1 1 ,2,1 ,/6+>1 /0+1
/,06*?181,K6711-0,6-*11<+,2,<!11=-,,<!1
,,+K1 61 =6><1 8",<1 /0,0,",?1 ,1 /:01 !271
",1 ,H071 !1 +1 !K1 -!HK1 1 /,-!/71 01 51 /,;
-+<-(1FG**1606!+7,1/0,?181-+61:1<?1
2, >1,,11-/,+7:,0+-7101!L 1-<16!"G11, L<!1
+"!(1D-+K2+7,1:21-+<1,0,61:!<!?1/,-,+7!1
,0271:1-,08>1/,-!/?1-1,0-0,-71<,=1
,+7,1+H,?1, +6KL1-0, ,6,510,+5(1
[,?12,1H,+7,1-.,<!+,0>1,<>18;
1 <,"!1 <*7-*1 -1 2<1 0<1 1 :<<1 , :1
=:?1, L-0>G1,,85?191101 M,<1<,=,1 0671/;
2!1 ",1 /,:+7,51 !-,520,-?1 ,-, ,1 -1 !2,<1 ,",?1
2,1 :LL<>1 8,<1 H,-1 91 :<>1 ->1 1 /,;
,-12+,0(1
A?1 :!<-*?1 01 ,",<1 -,6=1 81 <,=,1 !0;
6711,?12,1-,0-<110*=-*1-1-,0<><1/6-0+*;
<1 ,1 /0G1 1 -0, ,6G1 2+,01 S,1 =1 -<,1 <,=,1 !0671 01
--<G1-,H+7,;,<0,51"!+*H1+K ,51H0+:HT?1
,1<1/,+,-7K1</,!10>0,61,1,<?12,1I(((101-",6*8<1
<1:!<11 /-/01/,6207?12,1/0+7,1/,;
<<>5181/6-0+*1-, ,51G,*11-,"!K?1,101,1=1
0<*1" !K?1"!<!K1--<!?1H+!K11!6,0+0,1
-,01 2+,0?1 , <+7!K1 6+*1 ",1 1 0,/;
<!K?1 /,,L*KL!K1 0,2-51 /,6G,61 1 ,!=KL<!1 <!1 1
-<,-,*+7,-71 -!=65?1 -/,-, !K1 ,071 1 0>:,01 0;
<J
%
(1
7,0<,-71 , ,-+1 /,0,21 <=6!1 !0-;
+:<,<1,-,0>G1/0?1,H/!+7,1/,,=6>G1/,-;
-<1G--0,<?1-1,6,51-,,>?11<,=-0,-7K1H0;
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
17<(11ECA53578B(12:(-,2(17(1%#'(1
1
!$
3
+:H51 1 +",:,;6,+,"2-G1 --<1 91 -1 6!",5(1 E+, ;
+:H*1 -1 /-!L51 51 !.H51 1 -6:H51 , L-;
0>G1,,851:,,<,10>:0+1,0,1-<+1;
H,+7>G1!+7!11-,GK1-0,51-<, >,5162,;
-(1 O,1 -<+?1 -,/*=,1 -1 -,H+7><1 0-0,<?1
6-<H51 S1 01 <G1 !+7!,;-,2-G1 /,+K-,01
I,-,191U/6J?1I701914"J?111G10,-/,:0,6-0101<;
G1 ,6+7>G1 ",-!6-0?1 /<!L-0,1 0,/5-GT?1 /;
0,611/, +<2,-1,+,",1,,8*11/0<12;
+,0(1 ,M,<!1 1 0=1 /,-1 -,"+-*1 1 ,-!0,",1
6+,"1<=6!1H*<?1,6<11H0+:H*<1/,10,/,-<1
1<=6!,6>G1-6,01/012+,011G1:/+*101
H,+7>G1 :,,6+7-0G?1 1 1 M..0,-1 <G:;
<,01G1+:H1H,+7><1/0+7-0<(1
D?1<,1/012+,010>-!/K12-><10,/+,L<1
/0?1((1 :!-+,0,",1, L-0,",16,:0,+*1-<,6*+7,;
-1-0, ,6,",12+,0(1,16+*1,/6+*1, P1/0,0,51:;
L>1+2,-1:,,6+71-/,+7:!11-<,-,*+7>1;
",191/012+,0?1:,>1->11-! P0>1/0(1
F L<16+*1G1*0+*-*1,?12,1,1K62-1,/,-6!K1-,H;
+7,;:2<>1->1+2,-(11,1=10<*1:6-71/61<1
12-0,1:+2>G1!,0*1/0,0,",1, -/2*1MG1;
-,0(18=6>51/,-+6!KL51!,071*0+*-*1:0!,51K;
62-,51.,<,51/6>6!L",?11 >10>-1:1",?1, +6*1
-0,51-/H.,511-<,-,*+7,-7K(1
7,H+7>51 -1 -,0-*1 65-0+7,1 ,G*<><1
:,,<?1 ,"61 ",1 +:H*1 , -/21 -,,0-0!KL<1
/0,0><1-6-0<?1,"61<+7>10,:<,=,-1!6,0+;
0,*1 /, ,-51 /,6/+>1 K62-<1 "*<(1
FG*<>51:,,<1-11/,-,1,=1<-,1-! P1
01--<1, L-0>G1,,85?110>=1",1/0,0,1/,;
+,=1 01 , L-0?1 2*1 -1 0:<,,,851 ",-!6-01 1
+2,-191"=6(1F-,0>1/011-0, ,6>?1-,-0+**1*6;
,1 /0,0,",1 -!-1 +2,-?1 -,:6K1 0,:<,=,-1 /,*0+*1
>G1/0?1, G,6<>G1 6+*1,<+7,51 =:6*+7,-12;
+,011, L-0(1