Ершов Ю.Г. Философия права
Подождите немного. Документ загружается.
1
1
1
3
, +<1-<,51:1911/,-,1/, +<1,6,",1:1
06,01!",+,0,",1:*?1,1-*"0101!",51!:+1:>1
/6+7>1 :<*1 =:1 1 -<1 2+,01 01 , L-01 91
0-0,?1+",:,?1<.:2-,?1?1,2,1=?1/;
0,0,(17<*1:71911,+7,1-!1!",+,0,",1/011
-!<1 !",+,0,51 /,+?1 ,1 1 -,H,!+7!>51 .,;
<?1 ,6+<>51 ,1 ,-, ,-51 H0+:H?1 1 +"?1
<+7,-?1!,0*1, L-0,",1:0*?1,,8*112;
+,0!(11
1-0*:1-1M<1-:!1,<<?12,1-<*1:71,,--*11
2-+!1 ,+1 /,+:,0>G1 .,<1 :*?1 /,-,+7!1 1
5?1 0,;/0>G?1 ,+1 2!0-0+7,1 , L-0,1 <(1
/<?1 -/!-*1 ",6>1 0>*-+,-7?1 2,1 -!6 ,;<6H-G1
M-/,01 /,1 6+!1 ",-,0-1 :<,",1 ! 5H>;<7*1
W+,10>!6+1671:+K21,10<*<,-1/,-+6",191
<,=,1 /6-071 0:>01 0,:<!L*1 /,-608G1 1 0,, L1
-+*?1,,>51/,-+6,0+1 >1:106,<1,1/:1",1
/-G2-1 ,+7><(1 SF-K6?1 -?1 0-0*1 /, +<11
,+7>G1+21+1:*VT
%
1,;0,>G?1-<*1:710>-!/1
16-<!KL*1<?1/,-,+7!1-61:>G1/-!/;
,01 ,+78-0,1,,--*11 658<1-+,*<1-+*?1-,;
0><?1M2-<11+",:><1<78-0<(1;7G?1+21
+1,-!-01-<,51:10>/,+*1+7!K1.!HK1
/,1,,8K11!",+,0,51/,+1",-!6-0?1,/6+K1<;
>11"!<,-(171M,51,21:*18,-!H*131%EER1",61
-6++18+7>518"101-,,!1-,L*1/<*1-<;
,51:(11-,,0-01-12(1#1-(1#$?1I-<*1:710/6716,11
,<>1<,=1!-0+07-*1.6+7><1:,,<1012-01-;
+K2+7,51<>1:*1:1,-, ,1*=1/-!/+*1/,01
=:1/1/6,-0+1, 0*<,<!1/011--<,1",1
6+1 -1 !2-<1 /-*=>G1:-6+5J(1 1M,<1,-1, P*-;
<>11<,0>1006*1<,,*11/<1-<,51:1
01-,0<,513,--191,1/<!L-0,108/,+2-?1
!,0,6-0,1->1-<+,-710,51017,01B0,/>?101-,, L-;
0,1 H0+:,0>G1 -(1 ,1 !",+,0*1 /,+1 6,+=1!,0,;
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
1,1<K1,,>G1/-G,0;<+-,0?1<7*?1/,-,+7!1,1:+2;
<>?16,+=>1-,6=7-*101-/H+7>G1G11,"6110>G,6711-0, ,6!(1
1
3
6-0,07-*11-K<!><1-,, =*<1H+-,, :,-?11
-G,671:1/H/1-,"+-,0,-1/0,0>G1-6-0110-;
0>G1H,-5(1
1,0,<12",+,0,<1,6-131/,1-0K1-1/6>6!L<1
/,:,8+,1 :2+7,1 -,L1 2-+1 -,-0,01 /-!/+;
5?1/6!-<0KLG1 -<!K1 :7?1 91-1 #'1 6,1 )(1 F-+-71
,+7,1 ,-, ,1 *=1 /-!/+*?1/,-*"KL1 1=:711 ! 5;
-0,1/1,*"2KLG1, -,*+7-0G1S2(1#1-(1%$)T?1/,-*"+7-;
0,1 1 =:71 ",-!6-0,",1 +1 , L-0,",1 6*+*1
S-(#''T?1/,-*"+7-0,11=:71+H?1,-!L-0+*KL",1/0,;
-!61+1/60+7,1--+6,01S-(1#E)T?1-,!61
/0,,G+7,",1,"1S-(1R%'T?1",H61S-(1R)'T(18,<1
,",?1 -H1 0-G1 -51 F-, ,51 2-1 28?1 /6!-<;
0KLG1 0,:<,=,-71 0>-*1 -<,",1 /",0,?1 6,/!-;
K1 +70>51 0> ,1 -!6,<1 :*1 01 061 + ,1
-<,51 :?1 + ,1 /,=:,",1 +8*1 -0, ,6>?1 + ,1
+8*1-0, ,6>11-,1,1&1+1%#16,1#$1+(17<*1:71
1:2-*1=L<?1+H<?1-,0808<1/-!/+*101
0,:-16,1%&1+?16,-"8<11<,<!10>-*1/",0,1
F);+",10,:-(1
7<>51 /",0,1 <,=1 >71 /061 01 -/,+1
,+7,1 /,-+1 0>-*1 ,,2+7,",1 /",0,1 ,</;
><1-!6,<1S-(1F1C=6!,6,",1/1,1"=6-G11/,+;
2-G1 /0GT(1 O,1 :2?1 2,1 =+, 1 /",0,,",1 1
-<,51:16,+=1/,510-1-!6 >1-H?1/=61
2<1 /",0,1 !61 -/,+(1 1 -,,0-01-,1 -+,=085-*1
/,51!",+,0,16+,?1/,1,,,<!10>-1-<>51/;
",0,?1 !61- ,0,1G,0><17!6,<1316+*1/,0101
/,*616:,16=1/1,-!-01=+, >1,-!=6,",(15;
H,?1<KL1/0,1/-1/,-101/,*616:,?1<,=1
/,-,071 -/,+1 /",0,(1 ,-+1 ,+,*1 =+,;
>1 0-<1 -!6 ><1 -H*<?1 2+,0?1 /",0,>51 1
-<,51:?1<,=1 >71/,<+,01:6,<131S/(1I0J1
-(1&E18,-!H13T(11
1
1
1
3
1-0*:1-,10-!/+<1 3,--101 7,01 B0,/>
%
1 >+1:61
2:1 :61 31 IF1 /,M/,<1 -,L1 /<*1
-<,51:101-0*:1-10G,=6<13,--1017,01B0,/>J1,1
%F1<*1%EEF1"(11<1<21*61<1,":H,,",1G;
?1/0+>G11 /-,61 3,--11,,,+!1Q1F1 ,1
##1,* *1%E&@1"(?11B0,/5-,51,0H1,1:L1/012+,;
011,-,0>G1-0, ,61,1@1,* *1%E)$1"(177*1#18,0H1
6,/!-10,:<,=,-71/<*1-!6<1-<,51:101-+!;
2*G?1 -2/>0KL1 /6!-<,>G1 :,,<(1,,,+1 Q1F11
M,518,0H1/6!-<0?12,1",-!6-01912+>17,01
B0,/>1,<*K1-<!K1:7?1-,G**10,:<,=,-711/;
<*101:,1,+7,1010,,10<*(11
1-1M16,!<>1 >+1/,6/->1:6,<13?13,-;
-*1 0:*+1 1 - *1 , *:+7-0,1 01 21 G1 +1 ,<71
-<!K1:7?1:<011/,=:><1:+K2<?116,1M,;
",1 00-1 <,,51 1 1 /<(1 C,,51 65-0!1 1
/,>?1,1,,,+1Q1F1111.H,01E,-!6-0;
,51A!<,5(1A/!>1, LK-*11<K1: +5?1/,60;
+*KL1 ,+78-0,1,,>G10>-!/K1:1,<!1<,,*11
-<!K1 :71 1 6=1 !K1!0+2*1 2-+1 -,-0,01 /;
-!/+*?1/6!-<0KLG1 1 /<(1 O,1 /,60=6;
K1,/,->1, L-0,",1<*?1/,62-1/,0,6<>1-,;
H,+,"<?11<1-0,G1: +51-->+K-*16/!>1E,;
-!6-0,51A!<>(11
,1101*61-1B0,/5-,",17,K:?160,1-+K208G1
M!1<!1:*?1,/,->1<,"!1-06+7-0,071,1,<1=1-;
<,<(1 ,1 M,<!1 /,0,6!1 !0=6-*?1 2,1 :,,6+71 6,+=1
>710>8?1++!+7,11 0-0,?1 -6",1!,0*1;
-+*Y1 :,,6+7>51 :/1 !:,,",1 ! 5-01 6,+=1
-+!=71 /<,<1 /,6,+*1 G2,51 =-,,-(1 4/++*;
H*116<,110,+1 ,+78-01,616,+=1 >71-,;
,-1-10-0><1*<1,-*1-+*11;
,6!11/, +<2,-7K18*10,/,-,01->11-/06;
+0,-11.6!<G(11
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
1*<16+7,",1:,1,1#R($#(%EEF1Q1%E191U1IF1/-,613,--5;
-,516H112-0!17,01B0,/>J181-10:*+11- *1*61, *:+7-0?1
,6,1:1,,>G191/061H,+7,",1:,,6+7-0101-,,0-01-1, L;
/*><1<=6!,6><1,<<11-6<
(1
1
3
7!L-0!11-!"! ,1K62-*1,H1:,,-1<,;
,*?1/,-,+7!11
;1",1, P*0+11/6!-<,,18,-!H51311-,,;
0-0!KL<1.6+7><1:,<Y1
;1-1<,<1:6*12:1:6131Q1'#@?11/,:=191
/**1 ,-,0+*1 8,-!H,,",1 7!61 31 R;1 ,1 #1
.0+*1 %EEE1 "(1 S,1 :/1 :*1 01 061 -<,51 :1 6,1
006*1 -!61 /-*=>G1 1 0-51 ,1 3,--T1 /,8+,1
<,",1 +?1 ,1 -,,0-0!KL1 :<*1 S6,/,+*T1 01 .6;
+7>1:,>1 111 0->(106?101 ,* 1#$$E1"(18,;
-!H,>51 -!61 31 ,/6++?1 2,1 <,,51 1 -<!K1
:711<,=1 >71,<11/,-+1006*1-!6,01/-*=>G1-1
%1*0*1#$%$1"(110-51,13101-0*:1-1, *:+7-0<1
/,1/,,,+!1Q1F(1
;1,,,+1Q1F11B0,/5-,51,0H1,1:L1/012;
+,011,-,0>G1-0, ,611.H,0?1:2?10-1",1,;
<0>1/6/-*11<K1K62-,51-+>(11
,1.+,-,.K1/01-!K?101/0!K1,267?1-,6;
=+7>1-/>1/, +<>1-<,51:(1
2-+<1 ,-,0>1 "!<>1 -2+1 /,0,01
-<,51 :1 S ,+H,-,0T?1 -/,+,=>1 /,1 -/1
! >0*1G1! 6+7,-101"+:G1, L-0,",1<*
%
?1-1
,,><1 +7:*1 1 -27-*1 01 6<,2-,<1 ",-!6-0?1
G,*?106<,?1+7:*110,:0,67101 -,+K101-0*:1-1",1-!;
0,-7K?1 /,60=,-7K1 M<,H*<?1 :2-!K1 91 ,</;
,-7K(1
8,2,1 =?1 1 -+!25,1 -<><1 ! 6+7><1 6,0,6,<1
I&356J1 -2-*1 0,:<,=,-71!51 54!?1,,*1 ;
/,/0<101-+!21/06*1-<,51:101-/,+(1F6;
=6>?1-1:0-,51 6,+518!1 >+,1:<2,?12,?1-+1-61
+,",16*11!+H1, >2,",10,/5-,",1",,610:/,?1 :1
, P*-*1 /2?1 :6=71 <!=2!1 -81 6H1 /*1
+?1,1,10-"61 !61:7191:12,(11-+!21=1-<,51:;
7K16+<<1 -,+K112+,01+10,0?1+10,0(1,1
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
17<(113F781A,0,6>1I:J11I/,0J1-<,51:13317,H,+,"2-1--+6,;
0*(1%EEE(1Q1%$(11
1
1
1
3
2,1 <,=1 >71 2!6,0L5?1 2<1 :71 -,+K,1 0,0,",1
2+,0V1
A+1-+6!1-,<+7>51"!<1 ,1,<?12,?1,+71-,,1
-<*1 :710-10,11 0,--,01 /,+,=*?1 -!L-0,00;
8",16,1! 5-0?1,1/6/,2+71/,/08<1/,+!271G,71
!K;,1 3+1 5&.+?1 /,<<,1 !6,0+0,*1
<,+7,",1 2!0-01 <-?1 ,1 ,-08",-*1 01 =0>G1 /-!/(1
C+,1,",?12,1!6,1,=671,12+,0?1/",0,,",11/,;
=:,<!1+16++7,<!1-,!1:+K2*?10-/+-1!6,0,;
",1M!::<191<,=,1/6-071-,<,-71,G>G1<1/,:;
0,6-0?11,,,<1 !6!1:*>1,",1,61,-!=6>(1
6H,>?1,101-!L-0!KL?10:<,-0*:>1<;
=6!1-, ,516,0,6>110,;/0>G?1-<*1:7115661
/-!/,01 S1 ,:>01 /6!/6+7,",1 0,:65-0*T1 ?1
0,;0,>G?11611,+2-0,1-,08>G1*=G1/-!;
/+5(11
1 /0,<1 -+!21 , G,6<,1 /*71 0,1 0<1 :+;
2*1 2-,51 /0H1 S/6!/=61 /-!/,",1 /,06;
*1 01 !6!L<1 2+,0?1 1 -,0808",1 /-!/+T1 1
, L51/0H?1/0+,511/6!/=61/-!/,;
",1/,06*16!"G12+,01, L-0(12<?101, L<1-+!21
/1:21:*106!L*1,+71,0,6-*1-,, =;
*<1<,12-,51/0H(11,,81-<,51:10,;
/,-1 ,1 2-,51 /0H1 --0><1 , :,<1 ,/6Y12,1
=1--*1, L51/0H?1,1,1/2-1165-0!1
6+*11:>0<>G1-+!25>G1+1-!0>G1/-!/,0(1
O,1 +K6?1 1 !<KL1 -6=071 - *1 01 ,.+,51 -!;
H?1-/,-, >1/,",:,071,6+>1/,-+6-0*1-0,;
G1/,-!/,0?1-,08KL1/-!/+101-,-,*1..?1
</!+7-0,?1 01 -,-,*1 ,-,",1 +,",+7,",1 ,0+*(1
-G,+,"*1 1 /-G*1 ,/+1 6,-,2,1 .,0?1 ! 6;
+7,1 -06+7-0!KLG11 6+*1 -,:*1 , >2,",1 2+,01
0,:<,=*1 -<*1 :71 1 -,0-*1 -<>-+,, :!KL51
/, !6+7,51-+,5(1 -G,+,"2-1 <G:<>1 :L>12;
+,01,1 +",/*,51.,<H10>-*K1-G1/61
:<(1 8<,+,"2-1 --+6,0*1 ",0,*1 ,1 ,<?1
2,1 +H?1 -,08KL1 *=1 /-!/+*?1 + ,1 0,, L1 1
1
3
6!<K1 ,1 /,-+6-0*G?1 + ,1 -<,6*,1 --2>0K1 1
-0,K1 :0,,+0,-7?1-,, :+7,-7?1 1 ,?1 2,1 ,1 1 !;
6!1/,5<>(11
1*61+1!",:1:165-016+*1.2,",1,-;
-<1+1<7*(1W,1=1--*1/6-0+51<+7;
,",1<?1:<>8+*KLG1*=,1/-!/+1-1-2,<11 :;
:,-7?1,1",2-510>0,61, 1,-!-01!1G1-G1
/61 -<,51 :7K1 /6-0+*-*1 1 <<!<1-/,><(1,1
IM-/,<!J1 <K1 I0,,0J1 !",+,0,51 -6>?1 -<*1
:71 %%51 0>/,+*1 -6=0KL!K1 ,+71 /,1 /6,0L;
K1*=G1/-!/+*Y1/!-7116+*10-G1S,2,19116+*1<;
>G1 ! 5HT?1 ,?1 <1 1 <?1 0>/,+*(1 ,?1 :<21 7(1 H11
IB-+1 1 -!L-0!K1 +K6?1 ,,>G1 !",:1 -<,51 :1 <,=1
,-,07?1,19101-+!1, L51--191/,1-!<<,<!1M..!1
91M1",*1 I,</-!-*J1 ,=-,2KL<1 M..,<?1,,;
>51,:>01+21-<,51:11, L-0,101H+,<J
%
(1
1,1 /,0,6!1 0,,",1 "!<1 , >2,1 --!=6K1 11
00+1 +1 -<!K1 :7?1 ,<+1 +1 1 -,01 00+?1 -;
-1 *=G1/-!/+511<*-*?1,--*1,6,511,51
=(1 BL1 6, 0+*K?1 2,1 01 -61 0?1 ,"61 1 ",,6-,51
/+,L61 =-,,1 :>0+1 0,,0;1 <,0?1 <,1 0,1
0<*1 M,",1 /! +2,",1 -/+*1 -,08+,-71 ,+781
,+2-0,1 <>G1 =(1 7",6*?1 /,1 <K1 -/H+;
-,0?1 -0*:71 <=6!1 ,+2-0,<1 *=G1 /-!/+51 91 1 --;
<,51 :5?1 G,<1 , L-0>G1 ,,85?1 0!;
/,+2-,51 , -,0,5?1 !,0<1 +,",+:H1 -+;
*1 1 6!"<1 .,<1 91 -+,=1 1 ,6,:2?1 !1
L+7,",1:!2*
#
(11
F<!1-<,51:1-0*:>0K1-15616,5 1
61 >5612635&"
(
811%E&R1"(1#%1-1S2+>17,01B0,/>T1
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
1'A#A571<*1:71013,--1:,2+,-7V13313,--5-*1K-H*(1%EEE(1Q1R(17(1)#(1
#
1<1=(17(@E(1
R
13H,+7,-71M,",16,0,616+*1, L-0,",1<*1,206(1,60+*KL<!1
,+78-0!1 :0-,?1 2,1 -,"+-,1 8,0H1 7,01 B0,/>1 ,1 /6,0L1
,:<?1,,!K13,--*1.H,0+?1/,101851-1-,G*-*1-<;
*1 :7?1<>1 1<,=<1 ,071 M-6H1 ,-,0?1->0KLG-*1 :1";
H5(1 ,1 -71 /,H+7><1 ! 5H<1 61 8-1 ->7-*1 :1 /6+<1 3,--1 /,-+1
-,08*1/-!/+*(1
1
1
1
!
3
,6, +1 6,/,+1 B0,/5-,51 8,0H1 ,1 :L1 /01
2+,011,-,0>G1-0, ,61,,,+,<1Q1F1, 1,<1-<;
,51:101<,10<*(1,,,+1-+1/0><16,!<,<1
<=6!,6,",1/0?1-6+08<1,<!1-<,51:1/;
0,0><1, *:+7-0,<1",-!6-0?1/,6/-08",11.H;
,008",1 ",(1 ,?1 /,6201 ((1 ,5H,0?1 /,6/-1 1
.H*1,,,+1Q1F1*0+*-*1/0,<?1,11, *:,;
-7K1-!0,",1",-!6-0
%
(1
1-,,-71:*1+K61/-G,+,"2-10,1-0*:>0;
K1 51 !5+1 53651 6?1 -/,-, ,51 /6!;
/=671/-!/,-716!"<1-6-0<(1
C+,1,1:6+*1 <1 ,1,<?12,1-<*1 :71/,61
+K6*<1&331 5511<1-<><1-/,-, -0!1!0+2K1
2-+1*=G1/-!/+5(1A5-0+7,?1-+1 >1013,--1:71
/,:0,6+-71 /! +2,?1 ,51 0>0,61 >+1 >1 :!-+,0(1 752-1
=1+!281/,/*711,2-0>1+0:,>1/,"<<>?1/,1
:><1 +<1 01 21 6*1 1 ,21 , +7,1 6<,-!KL1
-H>1-+*?1=-,,-?1! 5-0(17->+1=11,?12,1-<*1
:71,<1!1/-!/165-5 51&36?1, >2,1
0-21,K11/,<1,6,51<!6,-191I", ,",1
<,"+1 -/0\J(1 C=6!1 <1 1 M,1 "!<1 1 -,+K?1 /,;
-,+7!1 :0->1 .>1 6!G,0,",1 /,=6*1 ! 5H1 :1 0<*1
6++7,",1,=6*1:?1G1"+! ,,",11-",1-**101
-,6*,<(1 ,:1 /6,-?1 :8<>51 H,+7,;
!+><1-,:<11! 0+1,612+,0?11:71 !6!16!;
",",(13:!<-*?1/1/*1:-1,1,<?12,12+,01,/6+*;
-*16!80,;6!G,0><12-0<?11108,-7K(1
A+*1 ,+78-01-+*1*0,1! 6+7>16,0,6>?1/,;
,5165-0+7,1:0!2L1 -,11:7191M,1!6513
1!611,<1:191/:1.6-5655153
6Y1",-!6-0,11<1/01,<71=:716=1!1/-!/;
,0(181 ,+78,<!1-,=+KB11/,+7:!-*1/,/!+*,-7K?1;
:+,-71 >?1 :!-+,0*16*1,1-6=01/-!/,011-,;
",-7K1:*?1151 -! 5+(13H,+7,1, P*-71
,1,,81<,=,1,+7,1,H,51+7,51M..0,-1
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
17<(116#6F7''(1F,811-<,51:1:! =>G1",-!6-0?13,--117,;
01B0,/>1331F L-0>1!11-,0<,-7(1#$$$(1Q1%(17(@'(1
1
"
3
6*+7,-1/0,,G+7>G11-!6 >G1,",0
%
(117X4?1
-?1 ,+78-0,1 8,01 ,,,51 /!K1 /<1
-<,51:?1:0,1 ,+H,--,160=(1C,"1",1
!2-1 /,-6+1 ,1 *=G1 /-!/+51 16=1/=+1
/,K1 -0,G1 +:G?1 01,<12-+1 65(1,1,1/,+"K?1 2,1
",-!6-0,1 6,+=,1 /<71 6!"1 <>1 /,1 :L1 ,1 /;
-!/,-(1 8:71 =1 !0,61 ,1 MG1 <?1 /,-,+7!1 ",-!6-0,1
-21-0,516,+"1/,1, -/2K1 :,/-,-1, L-010>/,+;
><(1,1-71.2-1-<><1:*<1",-!6-0,1,/;
06>01 -0,K1 :6*+7,-71 /,1 /6!/=6K1 /-!/+;
5(1U1/,-+616-*+?1/,16><1,.H+7,51--;
?1,+2-0,1/,/08G1 :10-1013,--1/<,1011:1
/0>81 ,+2-0,1 ! 5-0(1 ,*,?1 2,1 01 /,60+*KL<1
,+78-01-+!201I/,/081 :10-J191=0>1*=G?1,1
G,,8,1 ->>G1 ! 5-0(1 F1 ,51 /0H1 !<>8+>G1
! 5-01<,=,1",0,71/1,51M..0,-1 ,>1/0,;
,G+7>G1,",0V1
2-1 1 /.1 <--,0,",1 -,:*1 G,6-*1
/,+,=1 ,1,<?1 2,1 :71/,/1-<,1 0=,1:1,-,0>G1
/012+,0191&36511 -110>-8!K1H,-71, L-0(1
7!L-0!K1.,<!+>?1/,1,,><1=:712+,0191I61 -H;
>5J1S4(7(1!8T?1I6,01-0>8J?1I--0,1/0,J?11
/6+=1, L-0!11",-!6-0!11(/(?1/,1M,51/21;
,110/011,<7?1/!-716=1/,1:,!(1F >2,1,1;
+0K-*1 1 0-2>51 0,/,-1 91 /,1 ,<!1 /0!1 ! 5H1,;
<1=:71!16!"G1+K65V11
7/,1 01 /+,-,-1 .,<+7,;+,"2-G1 "!<,01 1 !;
+,",1/,6G,611/, +<1-<,51:106101!/?1/,;
-,+7!1",!1M-!+>?1<.:2-1H,-1
910-0>?1+",:>?1M-2-(1
D:1 0-0>G1 1 +",:>G1 "!<,01 ,,-+7,1
! 6+1 :-1 ,1 !%56%51 351 -B1 :=;
"KL51:<>?1"! >1->?106!L11/ =;
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
11#$$E1"(1013,--1 >+,1:"-,0,1%&?#1>-*21! 5-0?1/1M,<1, !=,1
''?1 E1 >-*21 ,/,:>G1 !/1 1 /,/+,1 :1 0-1 @&?)1 >-*21 2+,0(1 ,/1
,.H+7,51 --?1 /,-+61 /*71 +1 /-!/,-71 =",6,1 ,-+1 1 #?@1 n1
=",6,?1<-8 >1/,-*"+7-011=:711<!L-0,1"=613,--1:=>101
&?)1:(1S7<(11!5673D#3F7'(15!0*1 :,/-,-71331D:0-*(1#$%%(1%1.0+*(117(1FT(1
1
1
1
#
3
K12+,02-,51+2,-7K(11M,<16,-,2,1/,:+7;
,1 ,?1 2,1 /,60+*KL<!1 ,+78-0!1 1 /G,61 01 ",+,0!1
<>-+71 ,1 "2-,51 ,+1 1 :06,51 2+,02-,51 -!67 1
&%1/1&51351-8181 >1G2-1
!GL*16+*1+8*12+,01=:11-,:60+-7?11 >1
/+211 >+1-/H+7,1/,6",,0+191! =61 01-/06+0,;
-1 -/,+*<,",1 /",0,1 /,1 ,,8K1 1 /-!/!?1 6+*1
,<+7,",12+,01I! 5-0,1/,1:,!J11/,G,61 --+6;
,?1+21",16!8!11+,<*1-!67 !(1,+1,",?1-!6 >1/,H-;
->?101,,>G10,:<,=,10>-1-<,",1/",0,?1/,1-0;
6+7-0!1G1!2-,0?10-"61/,G,6*101-,-,*15",1
M<,H,+7,",1/*=*?110>->51/",0,1/0,611
/-G,+,"2-,<!18,!10-",1-!6 ,",1/-!-0*(1
,:H*1-,,,01-<,51:?11/0+,?1:+7;
,1/,0,/,+,=1"!<<11/,0,0
%
(11/0,1<-,1
0>G,611351 -9"15!961,1-<>G1*=G11-/;
0<>G1/-!/,0
#
(1U6-71,1--<0-*11/0,0,1,";
2?1-+K2+7,1/,1-0,<1/,-+6-0*<16+*12+,0?1
/-!/08",10-1<>-+<>11<>-+<>1,<>10-0,;
-11/0?11-6=0KL51M+<1/0,0,51"!+*H(1E,;
-!6-0,1 <1 +"<,1 /0,1 1 /-21 /-!/,-?1
<1 -<><1 91 1 .:2-,1 !2,=1 /-!/?1 ";
!KL1, L-0!1 :,/-,-71,1/,0,*1M<1+H,<1*=,;
",1/-!/+*(1
A+1<>1-+0<-*1-165?1-/06+0,1,H0<,5101
2-01 H2,5?1 1 ,<!1 =1 0,51 /,1 -!L-0!191 -<*1
:71 680+1 /,=:,",1 -,6=*(1 ,1 6+*1 -1 -1 -!6,<1
/-*=>G1-<*1:711-/,-, 1:*1, G,6-*16,,;
=?12<16++7>51-,1:+K2*
R
(181-06+7-0!1,/>1
7X4?1 -!6 >1 /,H-->?1 -0*:>1 -1 0>-<1 01 ,"1
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
181/,:+1-,H,+,"2-1--+6,0*?1:<10,/,-1,16,/!-<,-1-<,51
:110> ,1<=6!1-<,51:7K11/,=:><1:+K2<1 :1/011/,;
<+,01:,1!<7812-+,1-,,,01-<,51:(1
#
11-0*:1-1,0,51-<,51:111-<,, ,,>1",-!6-011, L-01,1
,+1,/->G11-/0<>G1/-!/,01:*0+*K1,1,,-1/,<*1
1165-0*1/,1/6,0LK1/,-6-0,51!",:>?1/,-,+7!1:6=>51
/-!/1+81-0, ,6>165-0*(1
R
1<1=(17()$(1
1
$
3
-<,",1 /",0,?1 , G,6*-*1 ",:6,1 6,,=?1 2<1 /,=:;
,1 -,6=1 :+K2,",?1 1 1 6+1 --<0K-*1 /,1
-,+7!1 :1 -1/,6, ,51/,0,51 0-G1<+,0(1F0+;
K-*16=>1-!->11,+7,1-!6 ,51--<>11",-!6-;
0101H+,<?1,11-,,?1!2-0!KLG101--<,16+(1F61
/,H--?1 /0,6*L51 1 -<,<!1 /",0,!?1 , G,6-*1 01 -6;
<1-!<<,51/<,1011<++,16,++,0(17,6=1=101
K7<1-,1/<,1#)1>-*216,++,0101",6?12,1",:6,16;
80+?16=1 -+16,/!-71-651-,1=:1/,=:,1:;
+K2,",101-,,1+(
%
10,-!611<,=1 >71680><19101
,<1-+!21,,1061160+70H12+,02-,51=:?12-11
6,-,-0?1 :,,<,1 <,=1 -!6 >1,8 ?1 /,:0,+11
-/06+0,-7(1
4+,"2,51-!H*1 >+1 >11013,--(1C=6!1<?1/,;
=:,1 :+K21 91 6,-,2,1 -!,0*1 <1 1 M..0,1
0>/,+*1.!HK1:*?1-,:<!K1*=-1-,6*,",11
,"=61, L-01,1,/->G1/-!/,0(1
E,0,-*?12,1-+1+7:*1/<*71!K;+ ,1<!1;
:*1 :;:1 0,:<,=,-1 ,8 1 -+6-0*?1 ,1 !=,1 ,<71
!",+,0,1 /-+6,01 0,, L(1 7!61 /-*=>G?1!2-160,;
,0?1 :0-<,-71 -!6 ,",1 : +7-0?1 606!+7;
,-71:*110,:<,=,-71/,<+,0*1916,-,2>1!-+,;
0*1 /1 :21 -+K2+7,51 <>1 :*(1 -,-,*;
+7,-71M,51"!<H1-+6!1:1-0*1=6,",1!-+,;
0*1-1+7,51/,51-!6,/,:0,6-0(11
5K61/,+"K?12,1,<1:1/1>165-0!KL51
--<1:5?1I+ +7,5J1/,1,,8K11! 5H<11
-+7<?1/1G+,-1,:>-11-+6-0*?1 !61/6;
-:!<,1 /,,=671 %6651 !--5(1 ,M,<!1 ,1
6,+=1 -,G*7-*1 0<,1 91 61 56,1 3-1 1 3
,1 61 5!96?1 /,-,+7!?1 /!-71 01 <+,51 -/?1 ,1 3
61 /-!/+*?1 -0*:>1 -1 ! 5-0,<?1 566531
%6651<-1/,-608G11*0+*-*16-0,1&36
651<,51:*1:1 ,+1*=1/-!/+*(1S,;
,51-,,1-+K2+7,51<>1:*10>-!/K1:1
-,L1 -,-0,01 /-!/+5?1 1 /6/,+"KLG?1 1
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
13,--5-*1":(1#$$E(1%F1,* *(17(1E(1