Ершов Ю.Г. Философия права
Подождите немного. Документ загружается.
1
1
1
$
3
+,0*(1+-71/61, L-0!1H+,-,-711,":,0;
,-7?1 H+/0+>51 G1 :0*(1 C>1 !=1 !/,<*!+1
-<,1 8,,?1 , L/-G,+,"2-,1 /,*1 0+-1 91 ,,8;
1 6,<!KL51 1 /,62,51 0,+(1 ,1 -1 -!1
0+-71 01 , L-0?1 0+-71 1 0,+0,1 , L-0,1 ,,8?1
0,:KL1 01 :!+71 0:<,65-0*1 -,H+7>G1 "!//1 1
, L,-51+K65(1,1-7101-<,<1, L<10610+-710,:1
1 -+6-01 6..H,0,-1 , L-01 1 -,H+7>1
"!//>?1 :1 G2-,",1 G1 G1 0:<,65-0*?1 ;
!KL",1,/6+,51,":H11/,*6(1
1WL1 0-",1 0+-71 ,/6+*-*1 01 3651 -/1 91
1",-/,6-0,?1, -/20KL10>/,+1/:?160>Y1
61 $.551 91 2:1 -/,-, ,-71 1 !<1 /2-1
+:,071.!H1-,H+7,",1!/0+*Y10156
51-/191-,!62-0,11-,"+-,01/,:H51-! P,01
1, P,010+-(1
E,-!6-0*1 0+-71 *0+*-*1 /! +2,;/,+2-<1 ,;
,8<1",-/,6-011/,62*1<=6!1-,H+7><1"!//<(1
0,0,1-,:?1,<>1/0?1-!>1/011(6(10-"6101,51
+1,51<1/,+:,0>?1/,-,+7!1 >1/01,/,-6,0;
,1",-!6-0,<116><1/,+2-<1-,,,8<1-,H+7>G1
"!//(1F-K610>11,?12,1/0,0>16,>1/, K1
: =,16,+,"2-51G?10>=*1->10/,+1,/;
6+>G1-,H+7>G11/,+2-G1-+(1
, G,6<*1 6+*1 0,-/,:0,6-01 H+,-,-1 , L-01 1
",1!/0+*1/,+2-*?1",-!6-0*10+-71+:!-*1
0-"61 2:1 --<!1 0+->G1 ,",0?1 //1 /!=6*?1 01
6*+7,-1,,>G10>=-*11-!L-0!KL*1-,H+7,;
+--,0*1-!!?111-, -0>1:,,<,-1/,+(1
81,<217(7(14+-0?1/,61/,+2-,510+-1-,6;
=1/,H+16-!0,",1-+*?1,,+!<,",1-<,;
0,:-*1 <,L1 0+-!/0+*KL",1 -+,*?1 /0L*1 ",-!;
6-0101<8!16+*1/,60+*1-,01 ,+78-01-+;
*
%
(1,?16=1-0*1- 11-+!= !1:,,6+7-0,?1,+;
,1",-!6-0,11<,=1-0-11!+K1-!0,-7?1-<,-,*;
+7,-71/011-,H+7,",1.,<(11
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
17<(113C933F77,*1/0(1C(?1%EE@(17(1'#(1
1
$
3
,/, !<1:, 7-*10,10:<,,,8*G1/0?10+-?1
",-!6-011/,+(1
3"!+*H*1 6*+7,-1 +K651 -1 , G,6<,-7K1 /, ;
10+->5?1/!6+7>51G?1/,-,+7!101-,H+7,<1
0:<,65-01 -+0K-*1 :+2>?1 /,,51 /,0,/,+,=;
>1->?10>KL1:1:+2,",110,",1/,+,=*1
+K651 01 --<1 , L-0>G1 ,,85(1 A?1 0,*1
0+-71,/-*116, ,0,+7,1/,621 ,+78-01-;
+*(1,1 /1 0,:,01 ,->G1 -,H+7>G1 /,0,25?1
0> ,1,/6+>G1H+511-6-0165-0*1,/-*110,+;
0,1 8?1 1 !",:!1 /<*1 -+>?1 /1 , G,6<,-1 91
-/,+7:,01 -<>G1 =-G1 <(1 +->51 -/,-, 1 "!+*H1
0>1 :1 -<,51 /,6>1 , L-0>G1 ,,85?1 -+6>;
0KLG-*1:1 -,2,",1<,",, :*11-2/<,51-+,=;
,-1606!+7>G1/,-!/,0?10:<,65-05191G1/,-,1
/0-116,51H,+7,10> ,,51<,6+(11
1+-7?1-<*L*-*1 >71.,,<1!/,*6,2*16*+7;
,-1+K65?1-,/,62*1G10,+7?16,+=?1-G,6*1:1, P0;
>G1 6H51 1 , -,*+7-0?1 /,66=071 1 !/+*71 ,61
:1 G?1 +,,071 1 :/L71 6!"(1 2-+,0<1 -,:6*1
/,2,51 ",-!6-0,-1 *0+*-*1 /,+2-*1 ,-,+6H*1
, L-0(1E,-!6-0,?1:6<,1/,0,-,*<1:+2>G1
/,+2-G1 -+?1 -/,-, ,1 871 0,:KL1 01 , L-01
:62(1D6*1-,+6,-1, L-010>1:1,-,:*10:;
<,-0*:,-10-G12+,01, L-0?1:0-<,1,1,",?11<1
-,H+7><1"!//<1,1,,-*-*(17,:10:<,-0*:,-1
0=,11,+7,16+*1:+2>G1-,H+7>G1"!//?1,116+*1:;
+2>G1/,+2-G1-+?16+*1,,>G1:2-!K1,-!-0!1,/;
6+*1 -,H+7*1 :(1 ,+2-<1 /*<?1 60=*<1
!6,1,-!L-0+*71-0,1/,"<<>?11-2*-71-16!"<1/,;
+2-<1 2*<(1 D:1 M,",1 0,:1 : =,-71 /,+;
2-,",1 ,</,<--1 1 -6-01 6,-=*1 -,H+7,51 -,;
+6,-(1D101M,<1 ,+78*1,+71/6+=1",-!6-0!(11
3:!<-*?1/1M,<1<>16,+=>1/,<71,1G1-+G1-<,;
,":H1 1 -<,"!+*H?1 ,,>1 -!L-0!K1 01 , L-01
/,<<,1-!H,+7,1,":,0,510+-?191-0*:>1-1
-,H+7,51 /,6,51 -<,",1 2+,01 1 /02>G1 .,<1 ",1
1
1
1
$
3
=:6*+7,-(1 ,1 ,-!-01 +1 /+21 0+-1 06!1 1
:!8K1 --<>1 ,<0,51 "!+*H?1 0,:-K1 ;
/6-:!<,-1 !6!L",?1 6,<,0K1 0,+1 -+7,",?1 -;
=K1:LL,-12+,0(1
,-/*1 -,H+7,51 - +7,-1 1 +"11 ,:21
:!-+,0,51 /,:0,-1 +K ,51 !/,*6,2,-(1 2/,*6,2;
,-71<,=16,-"7-*160!<*1/*<,1/,0,/,+,=><1-/,-,;
<19112:1"<,:HK?1-,"+-,0?1,</,<--1<=6!1
:+2><1-<1165-0*<?111/,-6-0,<1/-;
-?1"! ,",1/,60+*1,6G1-,0101/,+7:!16!"G(1
7+6,0+7,?1 <=6!1 /0,<1 1 0+-7K1<,"!10,:71 1
0,:K11,+7,1,,8*1-!<+7,",10:<,65-;
0*?1 ,1 1 ,.+>1 ,,8*?1 ,=*1 +7,-71 -,+,;
0*11/,0, ,-01-,H+7>G?1H,+7>G11/,2G1;
-,01 -,H+7>G1 -+,01 1 "!//?1 ,6,01 1 ",-!6-0(1 A;
<2,-711/,60=,-71/,+2-,51 ,7 >12-,1/0,611
-<+K1 G1 +1 >G1 /,+2-G1 -+1 !871 ,<>1
/0?1/,0,/,-071:,,-1H+-,, :,-7?1/,/>7;
-*1 0-1 01 65-0!KL1:,,6+7-0,1 /,/0?1 6!<>1
-K<!><1+151M",-2-<1-<(1
1 -+!25,1 -",6*1 1 2-+!1 ,+1 ,/->G1 /-!/+;
51,,-*1536"13353-17164115
36+1 533&.+1 S/,6=,-71 0+-T(1 8,!/HK?1
/=61 0-",?1 01-/,++7,51 0+-?1,,-*11,6,<!1:1 -;
<>G1,/->G11 0-/,KLG1-,H+7,;"0>G1*0+5(1
F1:!81-<1,-,0>1, L-0?1-,:60*1,",<>51:>01
<=6!16+H*<10-01/61:,,<11+7,51/;
,51/0+2*11!",+,0,51,0-0,-(17<L1!",+,0;
,;/0,0,",1,,+*1,1/-!/+510+-?1++11 ,;
"-01 1/-!/+*<1 6,-?1 0=-0?1-+ ,51 6/,;
0,-1 -06+7-0!1 ,1 0,:-1 H,+7,",1 +H<;
*11/,:0,+10+-71<!LG?1<1 ,+?12,1/,1-0,<!1G;
!1 ,!/H*1 , +61 -+K2+7,51 +,-7K1 1 --G,;
6+7,-7K1151-,1-,,>10+-5(18,!/H,>1/-!/;
+*1 !6,1 ->0<>1 006!1 -,"+-+7,",1 G1 G1
-,08*?16=10><,"+7-0,10:*110-"61, =+!-*1:;
:1-G1+K6511,-!-0*16,0*11 ,7 1-1,!/H5(1,1
1
$
3
M-/><1,H<?1!6+7>510-1!2,51,!/H101, L<1
<--01+7,51,!/H,,51/-!/,-11/0>81%9
)n?1,-+7>1,!/H,>16**11"-!K-*?11-;
-+6!K-*1 1 1 :>0K-*(1 1 <--,0,-1 ,!/H,>G1
/-!/+51 -06+7-0!1 , 1 ,206,<11 ,-!-0!1 +7;
,-71!",:>1:*?11M,11-,K11</1/,1;
:, +2K1 I, ,,51 01 /,",GJ1 +1 -621 ,6+7>G1 :00;
8G-*1+1I/,6-0+>GJ12,0,0(11
I8,!/H*?191,<21((15!0?1911-0,6-*11/<;
0,<!10:*,22-0!?1,-, ,101!-+,0*G1>,2,51M,,<;
?1-0, ,6,51,",0+116<,(15, :<?1.0,:<?1/,;
H,:<?10:,->11/,+2-1H+?16H1/G,61/,;
+2-G1+6,011",-!6-0>G12,0,0116,+=,-1
/,2>G1/:6,01,/,H5112->G1.<?10-,0;
1,<<2-G1-!!1:1-21",- K6=?1/0,61",-!6;
-0,",1 <!L-01 01 H,>1 , L-0?1 -/,+7:,01
-0*:51 /-!/>G1 -,, L-01 1 (6(1 *0+*K-*1:0!+,0><1
.,<<1,!/HJ(11
7",6*1012-01,-,0,51-"2-,51H+1/613,-;
-51-,08,10,1/,-0+1:621<,6:H1, L-;
0(1 ,1 ,!</,0,1 ",-!6-0,1 "61 1 ,"61 1 <,"+,1
871,51:62\1,+1,",?1,!</,0,1",-!6-0,1
1/,-,1,6+<,1,1,":,0,51/-!/,-?1,,1-<,1
-,:61 +",/*>1 !-+,0*1 6+*1 /,H0*1 , :-?1
/,-!H?1, 6>?1,",0+1,!=<11 6:<Y1,,1
-<,1 <+:,0,?1 /,60*1 0-1 I,/,<1 1 01 ,:H!J1 1
/ "*11-+KY1,,1-,0-*1 ::L><1/610!;
<1108<1!",:<(1, +<1,!/H?1<1-<><?1*0;
+*-*1/, +<,51=:-/,-, ,-1 /0,0>G1 ,<?1-!6 ,51
--<>?1:0-<>G1-6-01<--,0,51.,<H(18,!/H*1
-,0-*11 /,-,1 .,,<1 6- +:H1, L-0?1,1 !";
,:,51-<,510,:<,=,-1",1 -!L-0,0*101<G1H0+:,;
0,",1",-!6-0(1,!010,10-1-.>1, L-0?1-01;
/2><1-/,-, ,<1 -!L-0,0*?1 ,!/H*121 0,-/,:;
0,671- *101-8>G1 <-8 G12:1.,<,01H;
,->G1 ,H51 1 -*=+7-0,?1 +2,-7?1 ,>-7?1 -;
/H/,-7(1 X,1 1 !-,520>1 ,!/H,>1 -1 !=1
1
1
1
$
3
1 /,-,1 :0+K1 / >+71 :1 -0,51 /,0,/0,51 6*+7;
,-?1,10-!K1101:01-<,51,!/H(1U"0*1
->1,6+7>G1"=6?1-,H+7>G1"!//?10-",1, L-0101
H+,<?10,:65-0!*110!KK1108KK1/,+!1",-!6;
-0?16.,<!*1",-!6-0,;/0,0>1<G:<>?1.,<!*1
,/6+>1 0-0>1 !-,01 01 , L-0?1 ,!/H*1
<1 0-1 , G,6<>1 /:1 6+*1 1 0>6+*1 01 -<,-,*;
+7,1-,H+7,;/0,0,1*0+(1
1/,1:,+KH16+*1oAAA18,"--1FF1",-!6-0<;1
!2-<1 >+1,<6,0>1,/6+>1<>1/,1 ,7 1-1
,!/H5?101,<12-+11
T1 --<,1 60,-1 H,+7,",1 :,,6+7;
-0191,1/,H--!+7>G1,<?1,G0>0KLG10-106>1,!/;
H?16,1-,,0-0!KLG116+=LG1-H5Y11
T1: ,16<-0>G1<G:<,01/,1/6!/=;
6K1,!/H11:+,!/, +*10+-7KY1
0T1: ,1/0,0>G1/,+,=516+*1,.-H1-6-011
<!L-0?1 /, >G1 01 :!+71 ,!/HY1 /<1
M,,<2-G1-H511/6/**<?1/2-><11,!/H
%
(1
1 H,+7,<1 /+1 /,0,65-0*1 ,!/H?1 !0;
=6,<1 :6,<1 3,--5-,51 6H1 R%($'(#$$&1 S;
%)F&T?1,!/H*1,/6+11,61:1!",:13,--5-,516;
H?1 !:>1 ,-,0>1 /0+*1 1 <>1 /,0,65-0*?1
!-,0+1 271 /0,,26>G1 :,,6+7>G1 ,01
3,--5-,51 6H?1 ,,>1 , G,6<>1 6+*1 , -/2*1
M..0,-1 ,!/H,,51 6*+7,-(1 O1 <>1 -+!;
=1+:H17"1H,+7,51 :,/-,-191/0,0,51
:,/-,-1 , L-01 1 ",-!6-0?1 :L1 8,-!H?1 ,;
-!H,,",1 -,*?1 :,,-?1 /0,/,*6?1 , L-0,;
",-!6-0,51 1 M,,<2-,51 --<(1 8,!</,0,-71
",-!6-0,",1 //1 6+1 ",1 I/,:2><J1 1 ,+7,1
6+*1,<<2-G1-!!?1,116+*1/,H+7>G1M,,<2;
-G?1 /,+2-G1 1 0,>G1 ,!,01 851 ->?1 2,1
0>0,61 /, +<!1 ,!/H1 1 !,071 :L>1 H,+7,51
:,/-,-13,--(11
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
17<(118533F7''78,!/H*?1!2*11.2-*1331E,-!6-0,11/0,(1%EEF(1Q1&(1
7(1&$(1
1
$
3
1, L<1061,!/H,>1/-!/+*191M,1:/L;
>1 !",+,0><1 :,<1 /,61 !",:,51 :*1 , L-0,1
,/->1 6**?1 -,08<>1 /,-6-0,<1 -/,+7:,0*1 6,+=;
,->G1/,+,<,251+1<KL",-*1",-!6-0,",1-!-101
H+*G1+2,",1, ,"L*1+1:1,>->G1/, !=65(16;
+7>51 :,1 IF1 /,0,65-01 ,!/HJ1 ,/6+*1 1
-+6!KL<1 , :,<11 I:+,!/, +1 -+!= ><1 /,+,=<?1
621 0:*?1 /,+!21 0:*?1 ,<<2-51 /,6!/1 + ,1 ,1
-/,+7:,01 .:2-<1 +H,<1 -0,",1 6,+=,-,",1 /,+,=;
*10,/1:,><1-<1, L-011",-!6-0101H+*G1
/,+!2*10>",6>1010616"?1H,-5?1,",1<!L-01+1
!-+!"1 <!L-0,",1 G?1 >G1 /01 6+*1 - *1 +1 6+*1
7G1+H?1+ ,1:,,1/6,-0+1,510>",6>1!:;
,<!1 +H!1 6!"<1 .:2-<1 +H<J(
%
1 0,06>1 !:>0K1
1 -+,=,-71 1 /,+,!1 6.H?1 ,,*1 1 !2>01 0-G1
0,016211/,+!2*10:*?165-05?11, *:+7,106!;
LG11.,<+7,<!1/,+!2K1<+7,510>",6>?1:,1-!+*LG1
,0!K101 !6!L<11(6(
#
17",6*1,!/H*1,G0>01 ,+18;
,516/:,1/0,!85(11",10+K2K110,,0-0,?1+1
:,,1/-0,1, L-0,",1<!L-01+1/+Y1/;
,=101!,011",-!6-0!K1+1<!H/+7!K1
-+!= !?101-/6+1 K6=>G16,G,6,0?1I,",0+K10+*<J1
91, -/21 :167"1 /**1 0>",6>G185?1 :+K21
",-!6-0>G1 ,,01 01 -G1 ,/6+>G1 +H1 +1
,</5Y16211/,+!210:*?11<,",16!",(1,,51,!/;
H*1 -,-6-0!1 -1 6!"<1 /-!/+*<?1 1 G1 !6,1 ,6+71
6!"1,16!"Y101,,>G1-+!2*G1M+<>1,!/H1/-!-;
0!K?1,11*0+*K-*1,/6+*KL<(1
O,1<,">1/,1-0,<!1-,6=K1:,>Y1/*1
1!0=61/0,0>G1,01-1-/,+7:,0<16:.,<H1
1 , <Y1 .+7-.H*1 :!+7,01 0> ,,01 1 .6!<,0Y1
/0,0,51 /,:0,+1 ,",01 ",-!6-0,51 0+-1 1 6,+=,-;
>G1+HY1 !8*1,-!H,,",1/,*61:,,6+7,51
1/0,/<+7,516*+7,-(11
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
17, 1:,,6+7-013(1#$$&(1Q1)#1SW(1%T(17(1F##&(1
#
12A67!87D.,<H,*1 :1/,0,65-0*12+,011, L-01,!/H1331
E,-!6-0,11/0,(1#$$E(1Q1E(1
1
1
1
$!
3
,:+7>1 :*1 ,!</,0>G1 2,0,01
, >2,116K1/,21,",1:!+7?1/,,<!12,11<-1!-;
>G1S:=+,0>G1 +1 :>G?1 1 018T1 /,*0+*K-*1
,0>1 :,6>1 1 0><,"+1 0:*,(1 81 /0+,?1 H+7,1
/0+7-0,11<1-+16+*1,+7,",1,,+*1616*+7,;
-7K12,0,0?1/,M,<!1,,1, >2,16,0,+7-0!-*1/,66=<1
,,,51 I/<,51 ,<>J1 ,!/H?1 /-*1 +871 -6+7;
>11,/->1.,<>11/,*0+*(1I,.--,+7!K1-+ ,-711
+7!K1,,0,-71",-!6-0,",1//112-!K1
0>",6!1 01 !-+,0*G1 ,.+1 -,0?1 91 -21 F(1 A<-?1 91
-+6!1 /:71 0=5851 !/0+2-,51 /, +<,51 -",6*8;
513,--?10+*KL5110-1-.>1, L-0,51=:11!-!"! ;
+*KL5165-01*61"0>G1.,,0J(
%
11
1 *0+*-*1 /H51 1 ,<6H*1 I8,0H1 /,01
,!/HJ1SFF?1#$$R1"(T1/,1-,:6K1-/H+:,0>G1",;
-!6-0>G1,",01/,1 ,7 1-1,!/H5?1-+!= 1-, -0;
,51 :,/-,-10,10-G106,<-0G?1/,-,+7!101/,-+610;
<*1 !2-+-71 -,, L*1 ,1 6,+=,->G1 /-!/+*G1 ,.H;
,01!=1-!L-0!KLG1-+!= (181:0-,?1-,:61-+!= 1-, ;
-0,51 :,/-,-101-+!= G1-, -0,51 :,/-,-191M,1
/,"--1 01 I6!!K1 -,2,-7J(1 5K ,51 0!06,<-0;
>51 ,,+7?1 ,-, ,1 01 !-+,0*G1 /,=*1 ",--!!1 H;
:<,<1 1 /,",51 :1 <+7><1 +",/,+!2<?1 : =,?1
,1+1/,:6,?121 !-,07?1-+!=711:,!?1106,<;
-0,<!1!,0,6-0!(1,,<!1/,10*61+1<,=,16*7-*11
M..0,-71/,6,+*1,!/H1-/,++7,510+-7K?1
0,1116!"<?1.,<+7,1,11:0-<><1-!!;
<?1 ,1 1 6+1 , P6><1 -1 K1 , L<1 /,+2-<1 1
<!L-0><1 -<(1 ?1 ,<21 7(4(1 A-,0?1 0*61
+1 <,=,1 !/,071 1 /,!!!?1 /,-,+7!1 IZ/,*6,1 :;
2*116,+=,-71/,!,,011.2-*1:0-<,-71G1,1
/:6-G1 -!!?1 1 =1 ,1 ",+7>G1 M+?1 6+K1
M1,">1/--0><?1-+1271:G,61,1,!/H1010>-8G1
M8+,G10+-J(
#
11
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
1,D9CA57618,!/H,116+1/,+,<,2<11,271,/-1331E,-!6-0*1
-+!= (1#$$E(1Q1)(17(1'(1
#
1,35A96F77,<,01,,+7,51001",-!6-0,510+-11,"21
,!/H1331E,-!6-0,11/0,(1#$$#(1Q1R(17(1%$(1
1
$"
3
U,,6+7,100611/<1/,**1:,,;
",1 , ,"L*1 :2+7,1 , +"21 !",+,0,1 /-+6,01
,!/H(1 A+*1 ,",1 2, >1 ,-!671 :,61 10:*,2?11
, *:+7,16,:>07?12,1,1!+1+1/,+!2+10:*(11,/;
6+>G1, -,*+7-0G16,-,2,16,:7?12,16,16,+=;
,-,1 +H,1 , +61 <!L-0,<1 1 0<?1 /,-G,=61
,,>G1,,11 01 -,-,*1, P*-71 +"+7><1-,2<1
6,G,6,0(1 1 +8<1 !6!1 1 <>1 ,/0,;,:>-,",1 G;
1 /,1 0>*0+K1->,",1<!L-01 01-+!21 -,<5101
2-,-1 2,0(1 1 ,.-H1 <!L-01 :1 ,;
!/H,>1 /-!/+*?1 /**1 0,1 0-G1 H0+:,0>G1
-G?1 /,:0,++1 0-7<1 -!L-0,1 -:71 G1 !,07(1 D-;
G,6*1:1<,0,51/11/<+7,11,--5-<1!-+,0;
*<10/,+1, ,-,0,1/6+,=100-101812",+,0>51,;
6-1 -7K?1 /6!-<0KL!K1 ,0-0,-71 :1 1 :>;
0<,1:,,1, ,"L?1?1 /<?101D+?1"612;
,01 6,+=1 !<71 6,:>071 +"+7,-71 /, ,",1
<!L-0191-0,",11-0,51-<7(18-?11018?101-,,0-;
01-,1-751RE)12",+,0,",1,6-1/1,206,<1/0>8;
1 -, -0,-1 1 -G,6,01 ",-!6-0,",1 ,1 61
",1 :,><1 /,-!/+*<?1 <,=,1 ,071 !:*1 1 G1
-,2(11-+!21!6,0+0,+7,",1, P*-*1-+!=L51
<,=1 >71:1+8<1-0, ,6>11-,16,1)1+Y1:H101
-!<<G1--<0-*11:,>516,G,6Y12-71-, -0,;
-?1/0>8KL*1:,!K?10:>-0-*(1
,-,+7!12<16+?1<1 ,+1,!/H*1/, 1.,;
<>1 :,L>G1 <,",G,6,0>G1 -G<1 -1 0+*+7><1 /><1
10-G1G1M/G?1/,M,<!1,-, ,10=,1-/,+7:,01M,,;
<2-G1-/,-, ,01/,0,65-0*?1, ,>G1<,61;
+:1 .-,0,51 6*+7,-1 1 /,+!2*1 6,-,0,51 .,;
<H1,1/2>G1/-!/>G1,/H*G(1506H*10,:<,=,;
-51 +"+:H1 6,G,6,01 ,1 ,!/H,,51 6*+7,-1 +1
-!L-0,1,-+,=10,:<,=,-1/<*1-G<1G1+";
+:H1 -01 /,61 -,<1 H+-,, :,-71 -,08*1 ,;
!/H,>G1/-!/+5(11
C,"?1 /2<1 , L/:,?1 6<,2-1 ",-!6;
-01-,:+7,1/,8+11:0-,1,"21/:!</H1;
1
1
1
$#
3
0,0,-1 6+*1 ",-!6-0>G1 -+!=LG1 006!1 551 ,/-;
,-1,!/H16+*1, L-0(
1,:<!L><16<","<1S,,-;
+7,1:> +<>G1/012+,0T1<,=,1/,<7?12,12+,0?1
/,-!/*1 1 ",-!6-0!K1 -+!= !?1 6,+=1 >71 :2+7,1
",,011:0-,<!1!L<+K1-0,G1/0(1D:0-,?12,1016<,;
2-G1 ",-!6-0G1 0-1 6,+=,->1 +H1=",6,1 /,6;
K16+HK1,1 6,G,6G?101,,>G1 !:>0K1-!<<>11-,2;
16,G,6,011-G,6,0?10+K2*160=<,1160=<,1<!;
L-0,(1 5K ,1 -,,0-01 6,G,6,01 1 -G,6,01 61 /0,1
/6-0+K1+,",0>G1,",01:60712,0!1-,,0-;
0!KL1 0,/,->(1 B-+1 2,0,01 /,-,1 : >+1 !:71 :,;
>51-,216,G,6,0?1/<?1/,+!2,1-+6-0,?1,1;
-1,0-0,-71:1!/+!1+,",0(11,-!-016,:;
+7-01 :,,-1 6,G,6,01 0,: !=6-*1 !",+,0,1 6+,1 /,1
.!1 :,,",1 , ,"L*(1 4/++*H*1 1 /:!</H1 0;
,0,-1+1=11<,+7,<!16,0,6!1,1:0-101--<1H,;
->G1,,61/0,0,",1",-!6-0110,-/<-*(11
81 0-7<1 65-0,1 -6-0,1 ,7 >1 -1 6,+=,-><1
/0,!8*<1 ,!!1 31 --<01 1 :>0;
<!K1 6-0+.HK1 91 ((1 +81 /01 :<71 !,0,6*;
L!K1 6,+=,-71 01 -,,0-0!KL<1 -/,++7,<1 ,"(1 7!;
6 *1 /1 6,-,2,1 ! 6+7,1 /,:+?1 2,1 -1 /,6, ;
><1 /*,<1 01 ,".1 --2>071 1 !-/8!K1 7!1 01
-.1!/0+*1!=11/G,6-*116-0+.H*16+*1<,;
"G1 2,0,01 ,:>0-*1 ",:6,1 ,+1 -!,0><1 :<?1
2<18.1+1,1<+7,1+8(1
7/06+0,1 /,0,:"+81+,:!"1-,:6*1<,-.>10-;
, L51/<,-11,!/H?10,, L1/0,0,<!1"+:<!(1
,1/1M,<1,-!-0!K1211*->1/6-0+*1,1,<?12,1
/,<-*1/,61I<,-.,51/<,-J?11<,1<>1
1 -/,-, >1 , L-0,",1 0,:65-0*1 ,+1 M..0>1 1
/<+<>(1 1 ,2-0,51 +!1 -->+K-*1 1 ,/>1
7X4?101,,>G1 ,+1F$n1:, +2>G101-10:*,2,01
0>*0+>1 /,1 /-7<<1 -+*1 SI!6*LG-*JT1 01 -/H+7>1
-+!= >1/,1 ,7 1-1,!/H5?1-,, L08G1,1.G1:2+7;
,",1 -G,=6*1 , :1 =:1 2,01 1 0,:<,=,-51 ",1
-+!= ,",1/,+,=*(18,2,?1<+7,-718",1-+*1
1
$
3
/,1,K6711<+7,-71+,",/++7L?1,?1<,=1 >7?1
-,1 , 71 0<1 1 -,:6?1 0,--,0+1 +7,51
:0-<,-1 -6-01 <--,0,51 .,<H?1 -/,-, >G1 /,0,;
671 -<,-,*+7,1 --+6,01 .,01 ,!/H?1 /=61
0-",101G1-!!G?1,,>1<1 ,+1/,60=>11-<1
6,+=>1M<1:<7-*(1
06?1 /1 M,<?1 2,?1 -, -0,?1 1 -,-0+*1 /, +<!?1
0>-!/+*1 7CD?1 +?1 -=<?1 F L-0,51 /+>?1 6!"G1
,":H51"=6-,",1, L-0116,+=>1/,0-71010,:6!;
G?1/,+!271.,<+7>1,/-1+10,, L1:<+207-*(11
1 M,<1 ,-1 :-+!=01 0<*1 /6+,=1 /,;
.--,134E71(17,,+,01,1,<?12,10-*,1/! +2,10>-:;
,1-,<101!81:,,0?1,<1<,+101,,81",;
-!6-0>G1 -+!=LG1 6,+=,1 --<07-*1 1 M2-,1
, 0?1 U2?1 ,,1 6,+=,1 0+271 :1 -, ,51 , *:+7,1 ,;
>,1, P*-191I,!61!1",167"11<++,>1>?1
01-+!1G1/21",1->10+61,",<><1-,-,*<?1/,2;
<!1,6111=1.<1/,+!21,1",1",-!6-0>1::>J1
1(6(11(/(
%
171M,516510/,+1-,"+-!-*165-0!KL*101,;
,>G1 -G1 ,<1 !",+,0,",1 /01 ,1 ,.-H1 dm1 cl`1 91
,.-H?1/1,,,51 <*16,:>0*1:,,-1/, ;
*1<!L-01/,--*11",10+6+7H1S01-+!2?1,"61
0,:K1 6,-,2>1 ,-,0*1 /,+"7?1 2,1 ,,1 /,+!2,1 01
:!+71,!/H,>G165-05T(1U,,6+7,100611
/<1/,**1:,,",1, ,"L*1:2+7,1, +";
21!",+,0,1/-+6,01,!/H(1A+*1,",12, >1,-!671
:,6110:*,2?11, *:+7,16,:>07?12,1,1!+1
+1/,+!2+10:*(11,/6+>G1, -,*+7-0G16,-,2,1
6,:7?1 2,1 6,1 6,+=,-,1 +H,1 , +61 <!L-0,<1 1
0<?1/,-G,=61,,>G1,,1101-,-,*1, P*-71
+"+7><1-,2<16,G,6,0(1
10>:>01-,<*16*1,1, G,6<,-106*1,;
6-,01 M2-,",1 /,06*1 ",-!6-0>G1 1 <!H/+7>G1
-+!=LG?1 <KLG1 -+!1 ,<0,;/0,0>G1 ,0?1 /,6/;
+>G1 6*+7,-7K1 -/H+7>G1 ,<--51 /,1 --+6,0K1
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
16C66F7'13,+71, L-0101,.+1-,01331E,-!6-0*1-+!= (1#$$&(1Q1)(1