Ершов Ю.Г. Философия права
Подождите немного. Документ загружается.
1
1
1
"
3
2-51.,!-?1/,-,+7!101 2-01,-,0>1-,G*+-71,<6;
,;6<-0*1--<(1A?165-0+7,?1-<1.1-!L;
-0,0*1",-!6-010>=1-,H+7,10-0,?1-!L-;
0!KL101, L-0Y1,,1-,G*-*1101G1-G?1,,>1/;
6!K1 1 /:K-*1 01 -!-1 6<,2-G(1 ,+1 ,",?1 01
M/,G!1"+, +:H1,<2-*16H*11!"+! +K1-,H+7;
,51/,+*:H?1</!+,0K1<--,0><1-,:<101!",6!1
0+-711-, -0,-71<!L<(1
,11-,1: >0711/,1,?12,1/1+K ,<1/,6G,611",;
-!6-0!1,,1/6-1,51-0,51-!L,-,51-,,,51911
<G:<1 !/0+*1, L-0><1,,8*<1/1/,<,L1
0+-(1
1B-+1, L-0,11/0L,101:<!?1,1",-!6-0,1-,;
-,1 :1 :,, :>G1 /,+2-G1 -!!?1 ,/6+,51
--<>1 ,",01 0+-1 1 !/0+*?1 -6-01 /,66=*1 , ;
L-0,",1 /,*6(1 ! +2,;/0,0,51 G1 -!,01
",-!6-0?1 /0+>51 1 +"+7,1 :81 ,.+,01
01, L-0?11/,1-K1/,!11-=10=,-710,/,-11,1/;
0101, L-0V1,1-,*1H0+:H1! 6+7,1-06+7;
-0!191:01",-!6-01/,1/!16<,:H11-0, ,6>1
-0*:,1-1-,08-0,0<1<G:<1!/0+*?1/,-,<1
H1-1/, +<>1351&36*
110,/,-13%51&36*(1B6;
-0,1, L!+7!,",11/0,0,",1/,"--1-,-,101/G,61
,1 :/+7,;6,:0,++7>G1 ,<1 1 -8K1 6,:0,+;
+7,",1"!+,0*16*+7,-1"=611G1, P65(1
1/0>51/+10>60"-*1:L1-! P0>G1/011/0,;
0,",1-!-1+2,-?10-1 ,+1=-,1,"210+-?1-,;
08-0,01--<>1/0,0>G1-6-01!/0+*(11
7,0<>1 !-+,0*1 !K1 8+7,",1 ,:1 ,1 /,;
<*1/015511<G:<1+--,0,",1/,0, ,-0?1
/:*1:1/0,<1.!H51-,H+7,",1,</,<--(1
81 "!<>1 <,"!1 >71 /06>1 01 /,+7:!1 M,",1 !;
0=6*V1
3:01 , L-01 01 -,0<>G1 H0+:,0>G1 -G1
61/,1/!10-1 ,+78",1!-+,=*116..HH(1C,=;
,1 -,+7,1 !",6,1 -/,71 , 1 ,-,0*G1 -,H+7,51 -.;
H1S*0+*K-*1+1,-,0>1-,H+7>1"!//>1+--<1+1G1
1
"
3
6,1 :>071 /,;6!",<!?1 /,1 <1 *<1 1 -,+7,1 6,1
0>6+*71M+<,01-,H+7,51-!!>T?1,1"+0,1016!",<(1
D1781-061, L-011/,0,-,*K1-, -0,011
-, -0,0?1 ,,01 <,",1 !6?1 -2+,-71 6,-;
,2,1 "! ><1 1 !-+,0><(17",6*1:,1 !0+2+,-71 2-+,1-;
<,-,*+7,165-0!KLG1"!//1+K65?1G1-,K:,0?1--,HH511
(/(?1,++0>G1-,01-,0-*1 ,+78?1,1!-+,=*K;
-*1 1 :,, :*-*(1 O,,<2-?1 H,+7>?1 ",+7;
>?1/,+2-116!"1:+2*1<=6!1!6,<11/+,<1
-=K-*1:1-21:0*1-1-,H+7,",1, -/2*?1,-1
!+7!,",1 1 , :,0+7,",1 !,0*1 -+*?1 /,0>8*1
!,0*1<+7,",1/, +*112-01=:(1!6,1-;
",6*1!0671 <!L",1/,+*101 ,KLG11-+!=LG1
/,1 5<!?1 <KLG1 -, -0>1 6,<1 1 :<+7>1 !2-?1 ;
H?1 -G,0>1 /,+->?1 0,<, +?1 6,<8KK1 M+,!1 1
<,",16!",(1
2-+,=1, L-0,51=:10>60"11/0>51/+1
/,-1, L-0,",1-,"+-*(17,/,-0+<1:+2>G1;
-,0110> ,,51,</,<-->G1851/,6,+0-*1-;
,/,1/6-0+1,16<,116,<,01/,:;
H5110,+1 ,+78-0(17+6!KL518"1:+K2-*101!<1
!2>071 ->1 <78-01 S1 G?1 /,62<?1 -,0-*1
0-1 ,+78T?116,/!-71G1/,60+*?106!L",116- +;
:H1 , L-0?1 :LL71 ,1 /,:0,+1 /01 =6,",1 2+,01
:0-<,1,1",1/,-G,=6*11/,+,=(1
-1M,1, P0,1!0+201,+711H,-71!/0+*1
-+,=,,":,0><1/,H--<?101<G:<G1!/0+*191
:21",-!6-011/011"+058G1"!+*,,0(11!-;
+,0*G1 -,0<,",1 !2,;G2-,",1 /,"--?1 ;
H,+:H1 1 "+, +:H1 <,0,",1 -,2-,",1 /,H--1
"!+!KL*1 ,+71 ",-!6-01 *0+*-*1 ,P<+<><1 M+<;
,<1 +K ,51 -!!>1 , L-0,",1 /,:0,6-0(1 ,1
!,<G1,-+51/,:0,6-0?1/, +<1-,2,01->7*11
M"?1 -,.2-1 , ,-08*-*1 M,+,"2-*1 /, +;
<?1 0,>1 ,.+>1 -,*+7,1 6!K1 , G,6<,-71
, LH,+7,",1 1 <=H,+7,",1 91 ",-!6-0,",1 91
"!+,0*1M,,<2-<11-,H+7><1:0<(1,+1,;
1
1
1
"
3
",?1 /,-+61 ",6>1 6<,-!K1 <1 /H/+7,1 ,0>1
0,:<,=,-1 01 81 -+,=58G1 0,/,-,01 <,0,",1 >*1
F":H51 F P6>G1 H5?1 ,/KL5-*1 1 <=6!;
,6,1 /0,(1 7+,0,<?1 ,+71 /01 1 -6-01 /6,0L*1
,.+,010,10!G11<=6!,6>G16+G10,:-1 !;
0+7,1 -1 =6><1 6<?1 <"-+7*1 +*1 :0*1 <,0,51
H0+:H1S/10-G11/,0,2*G11/,/*>G160=*GT1
-06+7-0!1,16H*G1/0L*1/011/0,0,",1",;
-!6-0101,-,0,1-6-0,1151-,H+7,",1/,"--(1
<1 -<><1 /0,1 81 -,H,!+7!!K1 :62!1
.B1((1"H1, L-0101,":,0,1H+,1016-01
",1/,0,20>G1-,,11/,-,*,1:<*KLG-*1!-+,05(1
0,10> >011:>0<!K13+131/1/,;
--0,1-,H,,<0,51"!+*H?101,,,<1, L,-71H;
,-51/>01:+2*1016+G1:>G1-,H+7>G1"!//1
S-! !+7!T?1-,-0+*KLG1, L-0,(1
7,:61 /0,0,",1 ",-!6-01 /,1 -!L-0!1 *0+*-*1 :65
+.551 .,<,5?1 /6/,+"KL51 /,-/>51 /G,61 ,1
/*<,",1 !/0+*110<8+7-0!?1 ,10<8+7-01 91 1-;
<!+,0K?1/,1<1,-1!+7!>1, L-0?1!,0*1<--,0,51
,-,:,-1:62?1-,*LG1/61, L-0,<?11+2,51,0-;
0,-1"=61:1G18(1
,1/0161",-!6-0,<11, L-0,<1:,,<11
, ,-,01-,2-?1/0,1/,,=6-*1M,,<2-<11-,H;
+7><1 ,,8*<1 1 !1 ,":,0,51 /!6+7,51
:L>1 -,1 -,,>1 ",-!6-0?1 /,-+61 ,.H+7,1 0>=1
/0,101:,,6+7-011,G*1",1/,-6-0,<1-!6(11
81-,=+K?1!+7!10+-1,--5-,51M+>16H,;
,10,-/,:0,61 ,HK11 /<!L-0,1-/,+7:,0;
1/,+2-G1-6-01!/0+*?1 :,,-+7,11-/1
G1+"+7,-(1,M,<!1/0,10,, L118,-!H*1012-,-1
01 +7,51 /,+1 0,-/<-*1 1 .,<+7>51 1 <+,-!;
L-0>51 .,1 ,"2*1 G1 6*+7,-(1 ,,-/;
,1 :21 H,-51 /01 01 -,:1 /,+,;6<;
-0,51 M+>1 0-G1 !,051 :,,<,1 /0L1 1 8,;
-!HK1 01 1 ,+1 2<1 /6<1 0!:,0-,",1 //,60*1 +1
H,0*1/,1,.H+7,;,=-0><1/,0,6<(1
1
"
3
1 -,*L1 0<*1 ,6,51 :1 0=58G1 :621 !/+*1
,-,01/0,0,",1",-!6-0101,--5-,<1, L-0?1/6*1<1
65-0+7,",?1 1 1 <<,",1 G1 *0+*-*1 :01 ,;
1 1 /1 ,-!H,,",1 ,,+*(1 8,-!H,>51
,,+71 ,-,0>0-*1 1 , P0,<1 /01 01 .,<+7,<1
-<>-+1 91 1 /0,!-,0+*G?1 ,=>G1 01 ,.H+7>G1
,<0>G1 G1 ?1 /=61 0-",?1 01 ,-!H1 ",-!6-0(1
,1 <K1 7(4(1407*?1 ,-!H,>51 ,,+71 I<,=,1
,G:,071 1 -/H+7>51061",-!6-0,516*+7;
,-?1 /0+,51 1 , -/21 /0+7,",1 /<*1
,-!H1 1, !-+,0+>G1 K1:,,0?1 1:L!1:/+;
>G101G1,-,01,-!H,,",1-,*1",-!6-0J
%
(1F-,0*1
6*?1:+,=*101-,:61,"1,-!H,,",1/0,-!6*1
S,1<,=1:>07-*11!",6,191,-!H,><1-!6,<?1;
!+,<?1 -,0,<1 1 (/(T?191 .!H1 1 01 -/,1 <=6!1 :;
><1 00*<1 0+-?1 ,,+71 :1 /,62<1 <1 =1 -,:6;
><1 :,<?1 6,/!L1 6<-0,",1 /,:0,+1 1
, !:61 K,(1 =,1 /,62!7?1 2,1 6+,1 1 6,+=,1
-0,67-*1 ,+7,1 +871 1 ,<,,,+K?1 ,1 1 0+K271 01 6*;
+7,-71 ,"1 ,-!H,,",1 ,,+*1 ,H!1 /0,/;
<+7,51 /?1 ,01 S:,,0?1 /,-,0+51 -/,+;
+7>G1,",0T1/,1, LK1-!6,0?1"=6?1+ ,16=165-;
051 ,>G1 ,",01 !/0+*?1 01 ,,>G1 "=61 !-<;
0K1 !81 -0,G1 ,-!H,>G1 /0(1 1 /,+,<,2*1
,-!H,,",1-!616,+=>10G,6711--<,1-/,,01",;
-!6-0>G1 ,",01 , 1 , P<1 /01 1 , *:,-5?1 -/,,01
<=6!1.6+7,510+-7K111-! P<Y1,/,-,01:;
,,-10> ,,01101, L1/6-0+7>1!2=6*?11
1 01 /6-0+7>1 ,">1 ",-!6-0>G1 ,":H5?1
-/,>1 ,1 -,,0-01 <=6!,6,",1 1 0!",1 /0?1 , ;
01 6,+=,->G1 +H1 1 (/(1 3:!<-*?1 M,51 ,</H1
6,+=1 -,,0-0,071 <G:<1 -/H+7,51 ,-!H,,;
/0,0,51 ,0-0,-1 0,0>G1 01 -/,+1 851
,-!H,,",1 -!61 S/<?1 ,-0, ,=61 ,1 6,+=,-1
0>-8G16,+=,->G1+H?1/.,<,01-,-01",-!6-;
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
17<(11FC)571, +<>1,11/1,-!H,,",1,,+*11/0,;
-!6*1331-1C,-(!;(17*1%%(10,(1%EE)(1Q1@(1
1
1
1
"
3
0>G1 ,",0?1 !<>8+,1 -/,+*KLG1 8*1 ,-!;
H,,",1-!6T?1-+6,0+7,?1/0,110,: !=61-/H+7,;
",1-/,++7,",1/,:0,6-0(1
0,11/,61/,:0,+111 711",1/!191;
,01 K62-*1 -!L,-71 /0,0,",1 ",-!6-0(1 1 /0,0,<1
",-!6-01 ,"20K-*1 I,<6>J1 ",-!6-0?1 1 :,,6;
+7>51 /,H--1 ,-,01 1 :60,<1 -<>-+?1 -/06+0,-1 1
-+,=08G-*1 01 "=6-,<1 , L-01 -,H+7,1 /,+:>G1 /;
0,/*:*G(1
,60,6*1,,>1,"?10,;/0>G?1-,"+-<-*1-1!62><1
,/6+<1 /0,0,",1 ",-!6-01 (7(1 --*H<1 1 &3
65651 $53"1 53-.1 1 51 &!%5
&5%5161116-555411611
!81 &36B1 51&361165!51%56113
%
(1,;0,>G?1<,=,1,1-.,<!+,071-+6!KL1
,-,0>1 /:1 /0,0,",1 ",-!6-0?1 ->0KL1 ",1
-!L,-711
;1/0-0,1"=6-,",1, L-0161",-!6-0,<?1/,6;
2,-71",-!6-01 ,,+K1:+,",110,,",1-,, ;
L-01 ",-!6-0>G1 -,K:,0?1 ,":H51 1 , P65?1
+:!KLG1->1-0,G12+,0(1E=6-,1, L-0,1911
0851,-16+*1",-!6-0?1,1+7,1-,6=?1,,;
,1 ,/,-6!-*?1 !/,*6,20-*1 1 ,.,<+*-*1 2:1 "!+*;
HK1 /,06*1 +K651 01 --<1 0:<,65-0*1 -,H+7>G1
"!//11-!,01/0,0><1,<<?1/0+<11/H/;
<(1:1,2,",10>=*1G11-<>-+1,,851"=;
6-,",1, L-0?1-/1",1:+,-?10,:<,=,1!-/8,11
H+/0+,1"!+,01",1:0*Y1
;1/,1/0161/,+,511:,,<?10G,0-0,1:;
,1616<-0><1,<116<-0><18;
<(1 G,0-0,1 /01 /,62*1 ",-!6-0,1 , L-0!?1 /,;
-,+7!1 01 /,+2-G1 ,,8*G1 ,,1 ,:21 ,P<+<,1
/0,1,611-!0?1",1,2!=6<,1/0,1,/6+*71
.,<!11 -,6=1",-!6-0?1G1",-!6-0,",1 <;
G:<?1 ,-!H,>1 /H/>1 ,":H1 0+-?1 1 :;
6211/6+>(11M,<1-<>-+1/<1/011/,+2-*16;
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
1 39395#7'(1+,-,.*1/0(1C(?1%EE'(17(%$F(1
1
"
3
<,*1 :>0>11 01 6<,1 1 !-+,051 6+*1 +:;
H1 /01 ,61 1 0+-7?1 01 /01 6<,*1 /0L-*1
0,10-6,:0,+,-7?101,"2>51:,,<1/,:0,+10+-?1
,+/>?101-+1/,-,",1 ,+78-0161<78-0,<Y1-2;
:K1 -,H+7*1 :LL,-71 +2,-1 1 /0,1 ,-KLG-*1 01
<78-01 +K65?1 "!//?1 /,+2-G1 /51 1 .H51 ,;
-071 -0,K1 /,:HK?1 6<,2-51 /+<:<?1 0,:;
<,=,-71 , -!=6*1 1 0> ,1 +70>G1 85?1 65;
>51 1 /,+2-51 /+K+:<(1 D<,1 01 !-+,0*G1 1 ,";
2,",1/0,<10-0+-*1:,=6K-*1/,+2-1.,<>10,;
=6:<1 1 !+71 +2,-?1 /0+1 :,1 0>,=6-*1 01 ;
=<1+2,510+-?1016-/,KY1
;12,1:6+1, L-0,51S01,<12-+1/5,5T?1
",-!6-0,;6<-0,51 1 /,:0,6-0,;G,:*5-;
0,516*+7,-(1F-!-01-!H,+7,",11.!H,;
+7,",1 :"2*1 /! +2,;0+->G1 /,+,<,251 <=6!1
",-!6-0><1 ,"<1 //*-0!1 ,/0,-?1 H,;
+7,-11 M..0,-1 +:H10-G1.!H51",-!6-;
0?1-06+7-0!1, 1",16-/,2,-Y1
;1 -0, ,61 6*+7,-1 606,01 1 G1 , P651 /,1
/H/!1191I3-34516B1%511-&395JY1
;1 /*<,1K62-,1 65-01 ,-!H,>G1,<(18,;
-!H*1-+!=153351!-1-,:6*11-,08-0,0*1
/0,0,",1",-!6-0113310> ,1-6-011<,6,01M,",1
/,H--?1"1556116.,0101,":H1
16*+7,-1-!,01",-!6-011G16,+=,->G1+HY1
5351:,,/,-+!8,",1/,06*11:0*1/0,0,51!+7;
!>1"=6?12,0,0?16,+=,->G1+H1+K ,",1!,0*?1, L;
-01 01 H+,<Y1 5351 -,,0-0*1 ,-!H,,;
/0,0,<!16+!1+7,5165-0+7,-
%
Y1
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
1,1<K1<,"G1/0,06,0?1-+6!1!2>071-1:/+*101,--5-,<1F-;
,0,<1U,1H,-51:+,",16<,2-,",11/0,0,",1",-!6-0(1F1-,-,;
1 010,:,01 *0,1:0>8>G?1 /,M,<!1 /,+,-7K1 1 ,-!L-0<>G1I:6-71 1
-52-J1 ,=65(1 I!6,0+0,,-7?1 0>:>0<*1 , <20><1 1 /,,<!1 ,-!;
L-0<><16=6<?191*=+>51 711/!1/0+7,",10,-/**18,-!;
H13(1*1!6,0+0,,-71//*-0!1 -/--,51,H1
1-,2;
-,",1 :2*?1 <81 , P0,51 G-1 -+7>G1 1 !*:0<>G1 1 -,,J(1
S7<(11(D78(17,0<*1,--5-*1",-!6-0,-711!+7!16<,1331
E,-!6-0,11/0,(1#$$E(1Q1%(17(1%$(T1
1
1
1
"!
3
191 /,606,<-0,-71 -!6!1 +K ,",1 -/,1 ,1 /0?1 <=6!1
<1 >1,110,:+11/0,0,10-0,10-G1-,,1-/,191
1 ,+7,1 <=6!1 ,0,/,:0,6+*<?1 0-!/08<1 <=6!1
-, ,51016,",0,>1,,8*?1,11<=6!1",-!6-0,<11.:;
2-<11K62-<1+H<1S-(1%F1E=6-,",1,6-101
2-01/,/08G?1,,>1<K1/0,110,:<L10;
6?1:>011"=6?111K62-G1+HY1012-01/;
2+51061911,+7,1,">1",-!6-0,510+-11G1
6,+=,->G1 +H?1 ,1 1 +K >1 ",-!6-0>1 ,">?1 ,">1
<-,",1-<,!/0+*11G16,+=,->G1+HTY1
;11,+7,1/,621<78-01 ,+78-0!?1,11";
1:L>1:,>G1-,01<78-0(1
3:!<-*?1 /<1 65-0+7,1 /0,0,",1 ",-!6-01
<,=1 >71/2-+,1",:6,1 ,+78Y1-1/,+><1,-,0<11
<1,,-*-*1?111/H/1/,-,0,-16/!?1
-!61/-*=>G?1:0-<,-71-!6511(6(Y10>6+*K-*11:>;
0<>1 IGJ1 /6/,->+1 /0,0,",1 ",-!6-0?1 /, !=6K;
L1 :,,6+*1 1 /0,0,2-0!?1 1 6,/!-KL1 !,/2;
-,",1 !0+2*1 /,.+,51 /-!/+5?1 06!L1 1 ,;
0<,-1/,-+6-051/0,<>G165-05
%
(11+K ,<1-+!;
21 !",+7>51 <71 /0,0,",1 ",-!6-01 91 .5
1 1 &5%1 31 -9"1 %5+1 65,1
&361&31.51+!551&35-65811
A+*1 -,G*1 2!0-01 +7,-1 -+6!1 /,<7?1 2,1
,H/H*1 /0,0,",1 ",-!6-01 0>=1 -, ,51 -,H+7,;
/0,0,51 6+?1 -:1 /6-0+51 ,1 0,:<,=,<1 1 =+<,<1
!-,5-01/! +2,;/,+2-,510+-(11<,0,51-,11
>+,11,6,",1/0,0,",1",-!6-0?1/,+,-7K1-,0/6KL",1
-1",1-G,6><1:<>-+,<11/6:2<(11
C-,?1,,,1:<K1/012+,0101!+7!1, L-;
010,, L1101/,+2-,51!+7!1012-,-?10,1<,",<1,/;
6+*-*1 G,<1 /,+2-,",1 =<?1 !,0<1 -,H+7;
,;M,,<2-,",1:0*1->?1:,,6+7-0,<11-,;
2-<1 6H*<?1 ,-, ,-*<1 /0,0,",1 <+1 ";
=611(/(11+K ,<1/,+2-,<1!-,5-01",-!6-01/;
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
1,6, 1-<(11C35%3)7(1F1/,*1/0,0,",1",-!6-01331F L-0>1!;
(1%EE$(1Q1#(1
1
""
3
011-0, ,6>1"=61/6-0+*K1-, ,510=5851/,+,;
K62-51 1 -,H+7>51 -!?1 , P0,1 0>-!/KL51
<+,<1 6,-=51 6,",1 , L-0?1 ",1 I0:,51 ,2;
,5J?1/,:+<1H0+:,0,-(1O,1/,:+71->01
+7!K1 6,-!/,-71 6+*1 +2,-1 6!G,0>G1 1 <+7>G1
+"?1 <G:<,01 ,6,0+-*?1 0,+:P*0+*Y1 01 ,1 =1 0<*1
M,1 91 /<,1 !-+,01 -,08-0,0*1 -<,",1 2+,0?1
!/,2*1",12-116,-,-0?1:0-<,-?10,:<,=,-51
/,+,H,",1-,H+7,",116!G,0,",1:0*(11
11 M,<1 <>1 0/+,!K1 /,6G,6<1 1 /, +<1 !-+,051 1
/6/,->+,1 -,0+*1 1 :0*1 /0,0,",1 ",-!6-01 91
"=6-,<1, L-011/-!L51<!1M,,<2-,51:0-;
<,-1+2,-1,1//1/! +2,510+-(1E,0,71,1"=;
6-,<1, L-01<,=,1+871,"6?1,"61,,1-,-,1:1:;
0-<>G11-<,-,*+7>G1"=6?1-,:KLG1- *1,0><Y1
01-0,K1,267?1<,1/0,0,1",-!6-0,1"!1+;
:HK12+,0!1",1,-,0>G1/011-0, ,6(1B-+1--<071
/011-0, ,6>1"=6101,-10:<,65-0*1+2,-11
",-!6-0?1 ,1 ,1 /6:2>1 -+!=71 /6+,<1 ,-!L-0;
+*1",-!6-0,510+-(1
1 -0*:1 -1 M<1 ,-,0<-*1 1 /,:+7,<1 I6,:!<;
J?1 :.-,0,<1 (7(1--*H<1 01 ",1 .!6<+7,<1
!611IF206,?12,1-,2-1-+,=085-*1<1h3
51 5!965F1 *0,1 1 -,,0-0!1 ,<!?12,1 <1 , ,:2-*(1
671 -,, L-0,<1 "=61 *0+*-*1 1 "=6-,1 , L-0,?1 ?1
/,0?1",-!6-0,(11-.1=1"=6-,",1, L-01910,/;
1<,0K191<>1<<16+,11:11-1"=6,<1S1-1
/,+2-,51."!,5?11-1-! P,<1/! +2,;0+->G1,,8;
511/! +2,",1/0T?11-12-><?1/,+2-<11/! +2;
><?12+,0,<191,-+<12->G1-,0?1-! P,<12-,",1
/0?1!2-,<1"=6-,;/0,0>G1,,85J
%
(1
A5-0+7,?1 01 !:,;K62-,<1 /,<1 <1
I"=6J1,:21K62-!K1-0*:716061S+2,-T1-1
",-!6-0,<(11M,<1-+!216,!<1, P*-<,(1,1,"61<>1
:6<-*1 0,/,-,<1 ,1 /,-G,=61 -+,01 I"=6J1 01 !-;
-,<1 *:>?1 ,1 6,-,2,1 >-,1 0>*-*-*?1 6=1 /,1 -<,<!1
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
1 39395#7'12:(1-,2(17(%%$(1
1
1
1
"#
3
:0!2K?12,1,,1/,:0,6,1,1I",,6J1S"6T?1/0,2+7,1
<1 /,+2-;5+7,1 -,6=1 1 , ,:21 ",,6;
-G1=+5(1,:6?1/,1<1:,<-01,--5-,51/! +1-1
-,2*<1 + +7>G1 0,/5-G1 .+,-,.,01 1 M,,<;
-,0?1,<21A((1<,.0?1"=61210>-!/711
-! P1 /0?1 ,,>51 <+1 1 ,+7,1 ,/6+>1 , *:,;
-?1,111<12,1-.,<!+,0>1/0(1,6, ,1:;
<-0,01-0,<1-,2,<10/,+1:,,<,1<+,1, L;
-0,;/,+2-!K1 /!1 -,0*L",-*1 !3 -551 , ;
L-0101U/6,51B0,/(1,?11:0-,?1 !=!101/0,61-1
.H!:-,",1 *:>1 ,:21 0-1 ,",1 =1 ",,=?1 -+6,0;
+7,?1/,1/*<,<!1-<>-+!?11-<!1.,6+7,<!1 -,+K:<!1
/G,61<,1I",,6-,J1, L-0,(1/,-+6-0101!--,<1
*:>1<>1-,+<-*1-1,/+<1"0>G1,,H51-+,;
01 I !=!J1 1 0-G1 ,1 ",1 /,:0,6>G1 91 !1 4(1 +,1 01 /,M<1
IA06H7J?1!1(1C*,0-,",1SI6710,51/,-+651/G,6?1
!=!5JT?1 !1 4(1 E561 91 I !=!>J1 01 IC+728;
8 +728JZ1 4+,"2>1 /,H-->1 !6!1 /,-G,671 1 01
-<,51 B0,/1 91 <>1 !:<1 /,1 I-,<,1 , *1 !=!:J?1
/,1,?12,1/G,6711 ,!1010>"+=,51! 8191I !;
=!:,J?11(/(1 -1=1 -!1 /,-,1 1/0,2+7,1, ;
-,*+7-0,19101-60,0,51.,6+7,51B0,/1 >,0+1/,;
",0,11 I8=6>5?1 ,1 -6++1 "+,,1 ",,6-,",1 0,:6!G?1 -,;
0-*1 -0, ,6><J?1 ,,,51 -,,0-0,0+,1 , >2,1 /0,?1 /,1
,,,<!1 -7*?1 ! =0851 01 ",,61 ,1 -0,",1 .,6+1 1
/,=085101<1",611,6167?1-,0+-*1+2,1-0, ,6><(1
A!"<1 -+,0<?1 /02>51 -<>-+1 !=!:,",1 , L-01
1, L-01",,6-,",1-0*:1-1+2,51-0, ,6,512+,0\1
81 1 0-*,1 /,*?1 "=6-,1 , L-0,1 !=6-*1 01
.,<+7,;+,"2-,<1 ,/6+(17!L-0!KL101-,0<;
,51+!1,21:*1.+,-,.,0?1/0,06,011/,+,+,;
",0101H+,<1-G,6*-*110>6+1,"2,",12-+1/:;
,01 "=6-,",1 , L-0Y1 -1 6!",51 -,,>?1 <>1 -+0<-*1
-,1-1,/-<?1/2-+<?12<1,H/!+:H5(1?1
/,1 <K1 4(4(1 A<0?1 "=6-,1 , L-0,1 0+K21 01
- *1 6, ,0,+7,1 -.,<,008-*1 /02>1 -<,!/0+*K;
L-*1, L,-1+K651S-<7*?1,/,H*?1, L-0*1,";
1
#$
3
:H*?1 0,2-51 -,K:?1 ,.--,+7,1 , P61 1 (/(TY1
/,:0,6-0!K1 1 2-!K1 =:71 +K65Y1 -.!1 -<,!/0+;
*1-0, ,6>G1 606,011 G1,":H5
%
(14+,"2,11 ,;
+2-*1 +,"2-,51 -,",-7K1 /,6G,61 /,+,+,",0?1 ,/6;
+*KLG1"=6-,1, L-0,11-.!1/,+2-,",1 >*1
2+,02-0?10+K2KL",11.,<>1=:6*+7,-?11
!611-, -0,-7?1-<7K?1+K ,07?1!6,0+0,1/02>G1
/, ,-5?1G, 11(6(11
7,H,!+7!,1:<1"=6-,<!1, L-0!1/6;
14(7(14G:?1-0*:>0*1",1:0!K1.,<!1-1+ +7,51H;
0+:H5?1-!L-0!KL511,-,01",,6-,51=:?1 -;
,",1 <>8+*?1 ,0,;6=>G1 ,,851 1 >?1 ,-,:;
*1H,-51+2,-?1+2,51H0>112-,51-, -0;
,-(17/06+0,1,<2-*?12,1"=6-,1, L-0,191M,?1
/=610-",?1,-1+2,51,0-0,-1:1, L-0,?1-/,-, ;
,-71 .,<,071 1 /,66=071 -/H+7>1 -!>?1 ,;
":H?1--,HH?1/0+>11:L!11:<1, ;
L-0101H+,<
#
(1A!"<1-+,0<?11<,=1 >71"=6-,",1
, L-01 :1 "=61 91 2+,01 -1 !-,520><1 0-0;
><1 2-0<?1 , +6KL",1 2!0-0,<1 -, -0,",1 6,-,;
-0?1 :0-<,-?1 !0=<1 /01 1 -0, ,61 6!"G1 "=6?1
:,,/,-+!8,-7K?1-,+6,-7K?1-,0-7K11/,*6,2,-7K(1
E=6-,1, L-0,1<1=:-/,-, ?12<101 ,+7851-/;
1",12+>1, +6K10>-,<1!,0<1-,H+7,",112+,02;
-,",1 /+?1 -+6,0+7,?1 -/,-, >1 1 -<,-,*+7><1 1
H0><165-0*<?1/2<11,+7,16+*16,-=*1-, ;
-0>G1H+5?1,110,1<*1, L-,H+7>G1H,-511I<+,5J1
1 I ,+78,5J1 3,6>?1 6<,?1 -0, ,6>1 1 -/06+0,-1 1
(/(1E=6191M,12+,0?1, +6KL51"=6-<1<!=-;
0,<?1 ,1 -71 ",,0>51 8+7,1 ,-071 -0,1 "=6-,1
6,-,-0,?1 ,,7-*1 :1-0,1"=6-1/011H,-1,;
>,",1, L-0(1
1U-+!=010<*1/,:H*18(7(1E6=0?1-,"+-,1,;
,,51 I"=6-,1 , L-0,1 91 M,1 --<1 , -/2*1=:;
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
17<(11,DAA3F7/17,,,81/,*51/,+2-,511",-!6-0,510+-101!-;
+,0*G1.,<,0*1"=6-,",1, L-01331E,-!6-0,11/0,(1%EE@(1Q1'(17(R$(1
#
17<(11.A373713,--*111-,2-,",1,/>(1C(?1%EE$(1(1R(17(1F#(1