Ершов Ю.Г. Философия права
Подождите немного. Документ загружается.
1
1
1
$
3
6,0+,1:<21,1, G,6<,-1-G,671:1,-!H,,",1
0,/0*1 0-G1 .,<1 -, -0,-1 91 2-,5?1 ",-!6-0;
,5?1<!H/+7,511>G(1
A5-0+7,?1 -",6*1 /=1 /,+,;6,+,"2-,1
/,0,/,-0+1 2-,51 1 -,H+-2-,51 -, -0,-1
0,1<,",<
1, !=+,1-0,K1 -!6,-7116,"<:<?1!6+7>51
0-11-,,,81:+2>G1.,<1-, -0,-11G,:*5-0,0;
*1 ,/6+*K-*1 <,=-0,<1 ,>G1 .,,01 1 M,,<;
2-,51/,+,51",-!6-0(1D-,*1:1/61-11
!6!1 1 ",1 M..0,-71 01 /,+,-7K1 ,",-!6-0+,51
M,,<?1-,*1-06+7-0!11,1"0>G1/,-+6-0*G1
>,2,51 -G1 01 ,,+*1 -,1 -,,>1 ",-!6-0(1 <1 1
<?1 :1:,,6+7,511/,+H5-,51:L>12-,51-, -;
0,-1 0,:<,=,1 6, 7-*1 -0, ,6>1 0,,<,51 +2,-?1
:0-<,-1 1 -<,-,*+7,-1 2->G1 +H(1 +",/,+!21
,+1:0>G1M,,<1<101:2+7,51<16,-";
-*1<+><11-6<1 :-,<?1-/,-, ><1-,:60716,1&$1n1(1
7071 /6+1 -/,+7:,0K?1 -/,*=K1 1 0+6K1
2-,51 -, -0,-7K?1 !8KL<1 , L-0>51 -?1
<,=,1+87101-,,0-01-1:,,<11,+7,1+871/,1-!6!(1
!6,1:<7?12,101-,0<,513,--12-*1-, -;
0,-71 :LL1 01 <<+7,51 -/(1 8<+1 1 2,0;
1 /,;/=<!1 !2-0!K1 01 /6+1 -, -0,-?1 M;
!K1 :-1 !",+,0><1 16<-0><1 <,6<?1 "! ,1
!8K1 /0+1 2-,51 ,!H(1 6/**1 <+,",1 1
-6",1 :-1 + ,1 /,"+,LK-*1 !/><?1 -L><1 -1
",-//,<1 .-,0,;/,<>8+><1 "!//<?1 + ,1 /,";
K1/,6165-0<1+,",0,",11.-,0,",1/--"(11!-+,;
0*G1-,0<,513,--?1/1+21,",<,",12-+1 ,;
,01 K6=,51-.>?1=0!LG11-,<!K1: ,!K1/+!?1
",0,71,1:0-<,-110,,<,-1"=611/6-0+*;
-*10,:<,=><(1/,2<?1/, +<1.-,0,51-<,-,*+7,;
-11,6,",1:1!-+,051"=,0,-1-!L-0!116+*1
/0,:L>G1 ,":H5?1 1 6!"G1 -!,01 "=6-,",1
, L-0(1
,1 /,61 "=6-,",1 , L-01 1 -0,6-*1 1 2-,51
-, -0,-(1,+18,,127161,1/,-,0,-12;
1
$
3
-,51 =:1 606?1 0+K2KL51 1 ,+7,1 <!L-0>1
,,8*?1 ,1 1 0!KK?1 6!G,0!K1 =:7?1 <=+2,-,1
, L?1 +2,1 /, +(1 7,"+-,1 2(%1 -(#R1 8,-!H1
3?1=6>51<1&36511&355651%51 -
81 O,1 /0,1 ,:21 /6,-0+!K1 2+,0!1 1 ",;
0!K1 ",-!6-0,<1 0,:<,=,-71 ,,+,071 .,<HK1
,1-<,<1- ?1//*-0,071:"+8K1-0651+2,",?1;
<,",1G(1W-!K1=:71<,=,1,/6+711.:2;
-!K1 1 6!G,0!K1 -.!?1 ,,*1 ,,+!-*1 -<<1 60;
6,<?1><1-+,0<?1-.!?1-0, ,6!K1,108",10,:65-0*(1
U,,6+7-0,11<,=10,"7-*101M!1-.!?11/,,<!1;
",*1 I2-*1 =:7J1 1 <1 K62-,",1 -,6=*Y1 /;
0,0,1"!+,01!-0+01+871/6+>11/,-,;
0,-1 S/0,-T1 1 6,/!-<,",1 0<8+7-0(1 0,0,1
",-!6-0,1 <,=1 ,+7,1 01 -+K2+7>G1 -+!2*G?1 1 ,-,01
:,11-/H+7,",1-!6 ,",18*?1!871/,-,;
0,-712-,51=:?1:,<7-*1-1+2,51,-/,6H51
+1-,6=<1+.,>G1/",0,,0(1
1 /1 :,,0?1 , -/20KLG1 6-0,1 "=6-,",1
, L-01 1 /0,0,",1 ",-!6-0?1 :LLKLG12-!K1 -, -;
0,-7?1 <+,1 1 -61 /6/<+7-0,?1 6,+=,1 <-,1
:<K1 &3.&"1 %1 &3&355B1 53%
551 31 1 55&5551 3356(1 1 /0,<1
-+!21 271 61 ,1 :L1 -,H+7,51 ,-,0>1 "=6-,",1 , ;
L-01,1-G1>?1,"61IZ:,,6+71, *:1!-,071
01 /0,0>G1 ,<G1 -+6!KL1 /,+,=1 91 -1 , *:+7,1
6,+=1 !2>07-*1 /1 ,/6+1 -/1 K62-,51 ,;
0-0,-(11,6+7>G1-+!2*G?1!-0+0<>G1-!6,<?1,;
0-0,-71+ ,1 -<-*1/,+,-7K?1+ ,1:2+7,1-;
=-*J
%
(1 3:!<-*?1 /1 M,<1 !2>0K-*1 601 , -,*+7-011
%T1/,/+1+1 ,<<2-,1 .-,1/6/<+71/,1-, -;
0,510?1+1#T1!621-!/+1/,1017G1+H191;
6=,-71 ,0?1!-,520,-71! +*?1, <?1<,82-0,1
,",011(6(17,H+7>51-<>-+1<,,/,+7,",1:,,;
6+7-01:+K2-*1/=610-",101-,G1!-+,0512-;
,51 ,!H?1 /2<1 1 ,+7,11 ,0>G1 >G?1 ,1 101
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
%
1'3E.A57'(1H/>1/0,0,",1"!+,0*1>,2>G1,,85(17(R@(1
1
1
1
$
3
-.1 65-051 ,",01 ",-!6-0,51 0+-?1 /,-,+7!?1 1
60,1!=1:0-,?191<,,/,+:<1: =,10611GL2-;
0!?1/::<!11:"0K(1
=5851/H/1 /0,0,",1 -,-,**1, L-011",-!;
6-019165!51311&3&351581
F1,:21:/1 1/!6+7>51!611-0, ,6>510> ,1
2+,0191 ,71+11 ,7(1U6-71<,=,10-/,<71G;
>1 2>1 -,0-,",1 -,H+:<11 -7*1 01 !",+,0,<1 ,;
6-1,11:>0<,<1!*6-0?1--<1, *:+7,51/,/-;
?1 ,261 1 =+7?1 /!01 01 6,<1 ,6>G?1 ",-!6-0,1
-/6+1 0>/!-,01 0>-8G1 1 -6G1 -/H+7>G1
!2 >G1:06511(6(?1:<!KL1-, ,51--<!10M,,;
<2-,",1/!=6*11!6!(1, G,6<,1,<7?12,101-,;
,0-01 -1 ,<<1 <=6!,6,",1 /01 /!6+7><1
!6,<11-2K-*11%T1 ,1+1-+!= ?10>/,+*<*11,-,;
01 0-!/08",1 01 :,!K1 -+!1 /",0,1 -!611 #T1 0,*1
-+!= 11 RT1 ,1 /,1 <, +:H1 01 !-+,0*G1 2:0>25>G1 , ;
-,*+7-01S/<?10,10<*1-G5,",1 6-0*T(11,-,01
=1/6/<+7-,516*+7,-1+=1-0, ,616,",0,,0191
-(%1 1 @#1 E81 31 !-<0K1 1 01 /6,-0+1 "=6<1 1
K62-<1+H<10,:<,=,-1-<,-,*+7,18710,/,-1
,1 :+K21 6,",0,?1 0> 71 +K !K1 :1 /6!-<,>G1 01
:,,6+7-01 <,6+51 6,",0,,0?1 0+K271 01 6,",0,1 /,1 -,;
"+8K1 -,,1 +K >?1 1 /,0,2L1 :,,6+7-0!1
!-+,0*11(6(1
0,?1 <,=,1 -,"+-7-*1 -1 65?1 2,1 "=6-,1 , ;
L-0,1-712,1 ,+10>-,,?12<1/,-,12+,02-,1, L;
-0,?1,+71-,,1,,1-,-,1:1+K65?1271/0,-,:1/,6;
<-*1 6,1 , G,6<,-1 /:71 1 0,/+,71 01 =:71 --;
0>1 1 ,P<+<>1 /01 2+,01 1 "=6(1 7/71
0,/+,L*101=:71/012+,011=:7116,-,5,1-!L-;
0,0?11-<7K11,6!?11!6?1,6>G?1, :,0?1,H?1
1-,/,0+1",-!6-0,510+-?1!8KL51",1/;
0?1<,=1-+!=716=><1<1-,,0-0*16,51",;
-!6-0,;/0,0,51 --<>1 /, ,-*<1 "=6-,",1 , ;
L-011,/6+*11012-016<,2-,5?1/0,0,511
"!<,5(1
1
$
3
,1 6+,1 1 -2/>0-*1 ,+7,1 -,H+7,;
"!<-2-<1 .!H*<1 /0(1 G,0-0,1 /01 /6,;
/6+,1,-, ><1G,<1-0*:51<=6!1/0,0><11/,:;
0,6-0><1 ,,8*<1 >,2,51 M,,<(1 E,-!6-0,1
"!11-"+>1, ,51-0*:?1-G,6*L1,1, L-011
"!+!<,51 --<>?1,?1,6,0<,?1-<-*1 1 ,",-!6;
-0+K1, L-0>G1,,851-,+7,?1-,+7,1M,16,;
/!-1 , L-0,(1 A=1 /<+7,1 1 M/,G1 ",1 /;
+:<11-0, ,6,51,!H?16+1, L-0,",1,":;
<1 1 ",-!6-0,1 1 "=6-,1 , L-0,1 0,1 <,",<1 !-+,0,11
, L-0,1 0-"61 ",-!6-0,1 ,":,0,?1 1 ",-!6-0,1 -!;
L-0!1,+7,1/1+21101<G1, L-011",1-/H;
.2-*1 .,<1 1 -!1 !/0+*(1 ,1 0:<,/,,;
01 , !-+,0+,1 6-0,<1 1 :,, :<1 .!H51 1 -,H;
+7>G1,+51-<,",12+,0?1,,>51,6,0<,10>-!/1
1 2+,<1 , L-0?1 1 "=6,<1 ",-!6-0(1 F6,:2,1 !-;
,0712!K1"71<=6!1",-!6-0,<11"=6-<1, L;
-0,<1101,/-+7,<?1101,<0,<1-<>-+10,:<,=,191
-,+7,1 ,1 -,2-1 :<201 1 :0-<1 ,1 ,,51
-,H+7,51-!H?1<11<?1:6+1MG160!G1-.1*0;
+*-*1, G,6<><1/60+7><1!-+,0<1+K ,",16<,;
2-,",1 /,*6(11.,<+7,<1 :6+?1-.1"=6;
-,",1 , L-01 91 M,1 -.1 -0, ,6,5?1 0,,<,51 0,-1
"=6?1 ,,>51 0>-!/1 1 -<,-,*+7>5?1 :0-;
<>51606?1/-+6!KL51-0,12->1->11H+(1E;
=6?10-!/KL1<=6!1-, ,5101,,8*101M,51-.?1.,;
<+7,1 0>?1 1 1 ,,8*1 "!+!K-*1 "=6-<1
/0,<(1 7,+71 =1 0,,<><1*0+*K-*1 1--,HH?1 , L-;
0>1 -,K:>1 1 --,HH?1 ,,>1 -,:6K-*1 "=6<1 01
M,51-.(1
,*1 -.1 91 M,1 -.1 /! +2,;0+->G1 ,,851 1
-!,0?101,,,51",-!6-0,1 1//10+-10>-!/1
,1<1, L-0101H+,<116,+=,165-0,071,+7,101, LG1
-G(1B-+1"=610-!/K1+1,:>0K-*10*!><101
/! +2,;0+-!K1 -.!?1 ,1 0,:K1 /! +2,;/0,0>1 ,;
,8*160,*,",1,6(18,"61"=610>-!/K112+>1,;
":H?1 "!<,51 /! +2,;0+-><1 ,,8*<1 1
1
1
1
$
3
-!<?1 ,"61 ,1 !-0+0K1 M1 ,,8*1 /,1 -0,51
0,+11.,<!K?101, L<11H+,<?1//1/! +2,510+-?1
,1 +:!K1 ,-!H,,;/0,0>1 ,,8*(1 1 ,<1 -+!;
2?1,"61,10-!/K101,,8*1-1/6-0+*<1//1
/! +2,510+-?10,:K1,,8*1.,<+7,",10-;
0?1 "!+!KL-*1 01 ,-,0,<1 6<-0><1 1 /,H--!;
+7><1 /0,<(1 1 M,<1 ",-!6-0,1 01 <G1 /! +2,;
/0,0>G1,,851<,=10,"7-*1012-!K1-.!?101-.!1
"=6-,",1 , L-01 +871 6,1 ,/6+,",1 /6+(1 1 ,;
,<1",-!6-01.,<+7,10-0,11-, +K61/6;
+,010<8+7-0101-.!1"=6-,",1, L-01",0,1
01<!1:0,-1/0,0,51--<>Y1016<,2-,<1,-;
!H,,<1 ",-!6-01 ,,1 , -/20-*1 /0,<1 "=61
, =+,071>1/! +2,510+-101-!6?1/61+H,<1,,,",1
.,<+7,10>112->?116,+=,->1+H?11,">1",-!;
6-0(1 D-!H,+7*1 -!!1 "=6-,",1 , L-0?1
-<,*1 1 -,2-1 :<*?1 0+K21 ,/6+>1
- +7>1M+<>?111,-!H,,1",0*1
-,0,!/,-71"=6-G1/0?1:0-<*1, L-0*1-.1
:+2>G16, ,0,+7>G1--,HH511,>*1-71,<<!;
H5(1 761 MG1 ,</,,01 -,2-,",1 :0*1 "=6;
-,",1 , L-01 ,-, ,1 0>6+*-*1:0-<*1 -.1 2-,51
=:?10,:0>8KL*1H,-71=6,51+2,-?1,6+7,",1";
=6(1 7,0<,1 "=6-,1 , L-0,1 <>1 --<0<1
1-,0,!/,-71",:,+7>G1,,851<=6!1"=6<?1
, -/20KLG1+:HK1G1-<,6*+7,-11-<,,";
:H101M,,<2-G?1-,H+7>G?1-,H,!+P!>G?1/,+2;
-G1 1 >G1 -.G1 =:6*+7,-1 01 0> <>G1 <1 .,;
<G(1F-,01:0*1"=6-,",1, L-0191M,1-0, ,61"=;
61 1 G1 -,, L-01 ,1 ",-!6-01 01 0> ,1 /,,0?1 /6;
/,251 1 .,<1 6*+7,-?1 1 ,0-0,-71 :1 -6+>51
0> ,11",1:!+7>?11+21",-!6-0>G1"51;
,51 -0, ,6>(1 E=6-1 -0, ,6>1 <,"!1 +:,0>07-*1 <1
/,+?1 2<1 ,+781 <+7*?1 ++!+7*?1 -,H,!+7;
!*1 :?1,,,51, +6K1"=616+*1-<,,":H(
11
G,61-,2-,",1:0*1/,H--10:<,/,,0*1",-!;
6-01 1 "=6-,",1 , L-01 /,6,+=-*(1 C,0,51 ,/>1
1
$
3
/,:+?1 2,1"=6-,1, L-0,?1!<,1016!G1 +--2;
-,",1 + +:<1 1 "+,<-,51 6H1 1 :0-;
<*?1 2,1 ,6+*1 ,1 ",-!6-01 -.1 2-,51 =:6*;
+7,-?1 :1/,<,L1",-!6-011<,=1 >71IH-0,<1;
606!+7,51 -0, ,6>J?1 /G,61 1 :8<><1 <1 -<<1
/,0,2*<101:!+71<,,/,+:H1M,,<?1/,:0,;
+1!/>G1-, -0,0?1,-1-,H+7,",10-0?1, ,-;
*1+--,0>G116!"G1,.+,0?1-,H+7,51!L<+,-1
1/,+2-,51/--0,-1 8,G1 -+,01 -+*?1/,6;
2-1-<*<,510,+KH,><1/,*-*<?12,1<,=,1;
"+*6,1 /,6<,-,071 -, >*<1 01 3,--1 /,-+1 %EE%1 "(1
7+,=085-*1 01 51 /,-,<<!-2-51 -< ,:1 ,0>G1 M,;
,<2-G1 ,,851 1 G1 ,-+51 *0+*-*1 1 1 "=;
6-<?1 -,1 <+7><1 , L-0,<?1 1 -/,-, ><1 -+!;
=71 .!6<,<1 /0,0,",1 ",-!6-0(1 A"6H*1 1 <;
+:H*1, L-01//*-0!K1-,:6K1- +7,-101-,H;
+7,51-.11 M,,<?11 :2191/,0,65-0!K10>G,6!1
->1:1:-(11,51-!H1",-!6-0,1, *:,10>-!;
/71 ",<1 - +7,-?1 -,:6071 /<+<>1 !-+,0*1 6+*1
-,:6*1 /,6+,51 -,H+7,51 "H(1 ,1 01 ,--5-,<1
/,--,0-,<1 , L-01 H1 G,-?1 /,1 ,=6KL*-*1 6<,;
*1/<1.,<!11:>0<,51I!/0+*<,516<,;
J?1,":H*1/! +2,510+-1 !61-,1<H510,-;
-,0+*1 6<,2-G1 ",-!6-0,;/0,0>G1 .,<1
S,,-+7,1-0, ,6>10> ,>1,",010+-?1,0-0,-71
/0+7-01 /61 0>-8<1 ,",<1 ,6,",1 /6-0+7;
-0?1,-!H,,1:/+1,<1/0,0,",1",-!6-0T(1
,10!1,1-,1*",11-,GK1.,<11<,6,01
6<-0,;,<6,",1!/0+*(1A+*1",-!6-01-1-+7;
><1,+><11M--<1-+6<1.,<,01"=;
6-,",1 , L-01 01 !-+,0*G1 !/+*1 /0,0,51 ",-!6-;
0,-191 ,+1-+,=*1:621/,+1.,<,0*?11
=1, G,6<,1!-+,01+"<H1,0,510+-(1!6,-1
.,<,0*1 "=6-,",1 , L-01 01 3,--1 , !-+,0+>1
.,-,0,51/-,5,51M,,<2-,51--<>?1:<1,-;
+ +<1"!+!KL51,+1",-!6-0?11=1",1<;
+:H5?1."<H5?1/,0>8,51,.+,-7K?1!",:,51
1
1
1
$!
3
-/61 .6H1 1 <,"<1 6!"<1 "0><1 .,<(1
1 +!?1 /,-0*L,51 +:!1 -.,<H51 /,-,<<!;
-2-G1-?1, L-*10<110,:,01!",:1
"=6-,<!1, L-0!1-,1-,,>1I"=6-GJ1M+<,0191
<.,:>G1 -!!?1 H,+-2-G1 1 8,0-2-G1
-,K:,0?1M-<--G116+7>G1,":H5(1A.,-71
/,-,<<!-2-,51 6<,1 01 851 -1 :-0+*1
!<71 ,/<-2-51 :6,1 /,1 /,0,6!1 /,:,868G1 .,;
<+7>G1:<51/,+,;/0,0,51--<>1110,:<,=,;
-51.,<,0*16<,2-,51!+7!>1<--(1,1<=;
6!10+-7K11, L-0,<1-,1-1,2!=6,51 K,11
,+"G2-G1 "!//,0,?1 3,--*1 !61 ,+7,1 <H51
6<,2-,",?1/0,0,",11"=6-,",1, L-0(1I, *;
:+7,J1 /,061 ",-!6-01 /,,=61 +,"2!K1 ;
HK1 "=61 91 ,:1 ,1 "=6-,51 ,0-0,-11 !2;
-*1010> ,G11.6!<G?1!+,1,10,,51-+!= >?1
!/+>1 +,",0?1 ,/+>1 :1 0!?1 /,:61 1 , L-0,<1
-/,11(6(1
1-,0<,51+!1<>1G,6<11, ,-,01;
, G,6<,-1 ",-!6-0,51 "+<H1 , L-01 1 6=1
H+-,, :,-1 0<8+7-01 ",-!6-0?1 01 <G1 :,?101
6+1"=6-,",1, L-0101-+!212:0>25>G1-!H5?11
1, ,-,01, G,6<,-1,H11+--2-1+ ;
+7>1/6-0+*1,1"=6-,<1, L-011/0,0,<1",-!;
6-0?116?1/6/,+"KL1,/,!11>,2!K1-GK11
-, -0,0;606!+-,0(1 ,/>1 ",-!6-01 0:/,1
!-7-*1:1,":,-,511"!+*0,516*+7,-1<,;
=10>:07101/G,6,<1, L-01+871G,-?1GK?16"6;
HK1 1 <+:HK1 , L-0(1 F-K61 , G,6<,-71 ",-!;
6-0,51 /,+1 -,:6*1 -,0>G1 !-+,051 6+*1 6+75;
8",?1-<,-,*+7,",1:0*1-!,01"=6-,",1, L;
-0?1 -<,6*+7,-1 "=6?1 -,:+7,51 /,+1 6+,"1
0+-1 1 , L-0?1 1 /,6<*<,51 +7><1 1 :,><1
+, ,0<1 !/><1 :-,<1 -0,G1 -,01 0,1 0+->G1
-!!G(1
,16=16,-,2,1:+,1"=6-,1, L-0,11, +6;
1 0--,,<1 <G:<<1 , -/2*1 /01 2+,0(1
1
$"
3
7!!>1 1 /H/>1 "=6-,",1 , L-01 1 01 -,-,*1
-/07-*1 -1 -KL51 6..HH51 1 !-+,=<1 -,;
H+7,;M,,<2-,51 =:(1 3>,2>1 <G:<>1 -/,-, >1
,,6,071 +871 M,,<2-!K1 0,-7?1 ,1 1 8K1
:62!1 -,H+7,51 "H?1 -*1 /,0,251 , L-01
6,-"-*1 2:1 0,-71 ",-!6-0>G1 -!!(1 81 ;
:!+710:<,65-0*1 MG1/,H--,0?1"=6-,1, L-0,101
-,0<>G1:0>G16<,*G1/6-0+*1-, ,51!1;
-!H,+:,0,51 ,!H1 <=6!1 <,=-0,<1 :;
+2>G1 "!//,0>G1 -,0?1 65-0!KLG1 -,08,1 :0;
-<,1101/,H+7,51,//,:H16!"116!"!1012-01"!//1
60+*11",-!6-0,(1
3,+71",-!6-0116,+=1-0,67-*11,+1/--0,",1;
+K6+*1+1/,-,",1-/,++*(1E,-!6-0,1,/6+*1!-;
+,0*1 ,</,<--1 1 +:!1 G1 /,-6-0,<1 -0,51 /,+(1
U,,<><1-,<1",-!6-01*0+*-*16,-=101M,<1
/,H--1<<+7,",1,--!-?1/,6061/0,0,51,-,0>1
/,61-+,=!K1--<!1-0*:511,,85101, L-0?1<1-<><1
,,161,/6+!K1"K1,1,-1-,H+7>G1",:;
<,0(1E,-!6-0,1/6-1, G,6<,51160,51-,0<;
,512+,02-,51 H0+:H1/! +2,;0+-,51.,<,51 -,H;
+7,",1 , L=*?1 ,,*1 !/,*6,201 1 ,":!1 ",?1
, -/201 ",1 :,/-,-71 1 !/0+*<,-7(1 A*1 .,<1
/1 ,/6+>G1 !-+,0*G1 *0+*1 -, ,51 -!H,+7,;
,<0!K1-6!?1 +",/*-0!KL!K1-<,!0=6K1+2;
,-?1 /,:0,+*KL!K1 51 +:,0>071 -0,1 -!0>1 /01 1
-0, ,6>?1-<,-,*+7,1!2-0,07101/,+2-,51=:(1F";
2,-710,:<,=,-1"=6-,",1, L-0101, -/21
/01 2+,01 !1 !/,2*1 ",-!6-0(1 I3:",-!6-0+;
J1 "=6-,",1 , L-01 1 ,:21 -,:6*1 -+ ,",1 ",-!;
6-0(1E,-!6-0,11-!<10>/,+*10+->G1.!;
H51/,+!2+,101-,0<,<1<1--<!1-6=11/,0,0;
-,011 "!<-2-1 S/,1 /01 2+,01 /,1,,8K11
",-!6-0!TY1 6<,2-1 S/,6,+1 ,2!=6*1 +2,;
-1,1",-!6-0?1-,:61<--,0,51-,H+7,51 :>TY10-;
0>1 S61 0-01 1 -/06+0,-TY1 ,"21 0-0+;
-*1S:6+10+-5T(1
1
1
1
$#
3
A?1>,165-0+7,1-,65-0!1 ,+1M..0,;
<!11H,+7,<!106K1G,:*5-0?1/,1-0,51/,610611
,+7851-/10-01S/!-716=1.,<+7,",T?12<1*;
+ ,1 /68-0!KL*1 M,,<2-*1 --<?1 ,?1 -,"+-,1 0-1
,51=1-, -0,51/,6?1,11-,6=101- 1G1<G;
:<,01-,H+7,51:L>1916+*12+,011, L-0(1DG1-,:6?1
,,+!1 1:001/<!L-0,1",-!6-0,?1<,1
-1M<1H+*<10<80KL-*101M,,<!19101:0-<,-1,1
1-,-,**(11
F/6+1I-,H+7,J1,:2?12,1",-!6-0,1-+!=1
, L-0!11-<-*1<<:,071<!L-0>?1M,,<;
2-1:+2*?1-/,-, -0!1M,,<2-,<!11, L-0,<!1
/,"--!10-G1-0,G1"=6(11
D:<*?1/,:,8681-1 !=!:,51, L-0,51--;
<,51 /,-+1 M,,<2-G1 /,*-51 #$;R$;G1 ""(?1 /0+1 1
-7:><1 :<*<1 01 ,1 1 /1 ",-!6-0,",1
!/0+*(1 3:!<-*?1 ",-!6-0>51 <G:<1 1 ,!61
!/0+*16+<1, L-011//+1-!L-0>G1:<;
51 91 ,-+-71 0-1 1 =1 -6-01 65-0*1 /! +2,51 0+-?1
/,66=0KL51 601 ,-,0,/,+"KLG1 /H/1 !=!:,",1
/011 M,,<2-,1 ",-!6-0,1 -=1 /H/1 0-0?1
/,+2-,1 91 /H/1 -0, ,6>(1 86+7,1 :<+,-71 -,;
6=1 6*+7,-1 ",-!6-0?1 "!+!KL",1 60=1 1
-,H+7,1,,0,51>,2,51M,,<?11-,H+7,5?11
1,+7,1/,+2-,516<,?11-,H+7,;/,+2-,5?11
1 ,+7,1 .,<+7,;K62-,51 -/06+0,-(1 7,H+7*1
,0-0,-71 ",-!6-01 :+K2-*1 01 0>G1 <G1 /,1
/,6,+K1 .-,0>G1 1 M,,<2-G1 :-,0?1 /,",:;
,0K1 1 /+,0K1 S01 60>G1 1 ,!KLG1
.,<GT(1
,+7,1/,-+10,,51<,0,510,5>101*610>-,,:0>G1
/+-2-G1 -1 +",6*1 0,:,-851 -+1 1 ,":,;
0,-1!6*LG-*?1G1/511/,.-,K:,01101:!+71-;
,0+*1, L-01I<--,0,",1/, +*J1,-+ +,1",-/,6-0,1
/0*L",1+--11-+,10,:<,=><1061*61-!L-0;
>G1M+<,01/0,0,",11-,H+7,",1",-!6-0(11 ,+1
:0>G1:/6>G16<,*G101/,-+0,>1",6>1",-!6-0,1
1
$
3
-,0+,-71 0-1 01 ,+7851 <1 -6-0,<1 :8*1-,H+7;
>G1 /,0,251 1 2:1 -+1 1 /,60+?1 1 2:1 ,<;
/,<-->1 <=6!1 :+2><1 /,+2-<1 1 M,,<2-<1
-+<(1-1 ,+781/:11/2-,1/<1/,+!;
2+11, L6<,2-1611-!>?11:6+;
1 0+-5?1 0G,0-0,1 :,?1 /+K+:<1 <5?1 0>-,*1
,+71 -!6?1 "+-,-7(1 D<,1 /,M,<!1 -",6*1 /,*0+*-*1 0,:;
<,=,-71 ,/6+71 -,0<,1 H0+:,0,1 ",-!6-0,1
1 ,!61 1 -6-0,1 -,H+7,",1 ,</,<--1 91 /,1 -,6=;
K?111/0,0,1",-!6-0,191/,1.,<(1
E,-!6-0*1 0+-71 6,+=1 -/,-, -0,071 ,-,+6;
H1 , L-0?1 :1 ,,,51 +!281:<>-+>1 ",-!6-0,51
0+-11<,"!10,/+,7-*101=:7?1/,-,+7!1, L-0,11*0;
+*-*1<,,+,<?11-!!,0,?1,1-71-,-,1:1+--,011
-,H+7>G1 "!//?1 -+,01 -,1 -0,<1 -, -0><?1 :+2><?1
/,62-1/,0,/,+,=><1-<(11G1!-+,0*G1!<+,1
/-/6+1 6,G,6,0?1 K6=>G1 -6-01 <,=1 -"+;
=071/*=,-7101, L-011/0+*71",101/,:0,1
!-+,(1F-, ,10=,1M,101,-, >G1!-+,0*G1,--5-,",1, L;
-0?1 ,,>1 01 -+!1 -,0,!/,",1 0,:65-0*1 ,>G1 -,;
2-G1/21/0+1-!11:-,<!1-,-,*K(11
1D<,1 , L-,H+7>1 :621 1 H,+7,;
",-!6-0>1->1-,H+7,",1",-!6-01/,0,-,*1
/,6<1 !,051 !/0+*1 1 /,/><1 ,G0>071 60;
><1"!+,0<10-1-.>1=:1, L-0112+,0(1
F-,0,1/6:21-,H+7,",1",-!6-01-,-,101
,<?1 2, >1 >71 !-,520><?1 6=><1 "!+*0,;
,G+7><1 <G:<,<?1 ,,>51 ",0,1 , -/2;
01/,-,1/0,<,<!1/,06K1",01"=6-,",1, ;
L-0?1 .!H,,01 ,,,",1 G,6-*1 01 ,"2-,51
0:<,-0*:110:<,65-01-,10-51--<,51-,H+7>G1"!;
+*,,0?1 -<!+,01 /,06*1 +K65?1 "!//1 1 , L,-51 -,1 0-51
--<,51<+7>G116!G,0>G1-,0(1
1 ,51 <1 -,H+7*1 /,+1 ",-!6-01 !2>01
, P0>1 ,0*1 "H1 , L-0?1 :81 -,H;
+7>1 /,0,2*?1 -,G*1 ",1 - +7,-71 91 ,1 M,",1 01
/0!K1 ,2671 :0-*1 -,H+7*1 1 !+7!*1H,-71 ",-!;