To successfully standardize test measurements, careful attention and consideration must be given to testing
details (both operators and machine), sample preparation, and prehistory in terms of microstructure,
thermomechanical processing, and composition.
Both indentation crack length (fracture) and indentation strength methods can be successfully used to measure
K
Ic
only at ambient temperature in ceramic materials where neither significant slow crack growth nor R-curve
behavior is observed. Simple sample preparation and small sample size are needed for such techniques.
Double torsion is applicable at high temperatures when enough material is available and under conditions
where notch/crack geometry is established to allow for nearly uniform K
I
value at the crack front.
Various double-cantilever techniques are advantageous because they use a small amount of material. Analytical
solutions are available for accurately computing K
I
values from double-cantilever configurations. However,
loading fixtures and details are difficult and cumbersome, especially for high-temperature use. In ceramic
multilayer electronic capacitors, miniaturization of the double-cantilever beam has proven to be useful.
The Japanese Industrial Standards (JIS) Association committee on the standardization of fine ceramics adopted
the use of both indentation crack length/fracture and single-edge precracked beam techniques as standards in
JIS R 1607 in 1989. However, these and other techniques still need to resolve the meaning of average resistance
to crack growth and the undesirably high cost of machining, sample preparation, and fixturing.
The following sections briefly describe some common methods of fracture toughness testing. More information
is also provided in the article “Fracture Resistance Testing of Brittle Solids” in this Volume.
Double Torsion Technique. This type of specimen test is popular and allows the use of a variety of specimen
geometries. Basically, the specimen is a thin plate of about 75 mm by 25 mm by 2 mm (3 in. by 1 in. by 0.08
in.). A variety of specimen width-to-length ratios can be used. The specimen sometimes has a side groove,
which is usually cut along its length to guide the crack. Best results are obtained without a groove, provided
that there is good alignment. The specimen is best loaded and supported by ball bearings. It can be studied in
terms of crack-growth behavior as well as fast fracture toughness measurements.
The double torsion technique requires a large amount (volume) of material, which may not always be available.
The technique also suffers from the fact that the crack front is curved, which means that it is not under a
uniform stress intensity. However, the technique is useful at high temperatures and severe environments and
requires no particular fixtures (simple loading conditions).
A rigid machine is essential to conduct either precracking work or experiments where crack velocity is related
to specimen compliance (during constant deflection or deflection rate trials). Some strain energy is stored in the
test machine because of its finite compliance.
Indentation Fracture. Interest in this technique stems from its simplicity and the small volume of material
required to conduct K
Ic
measurements. A Vickers indentation is implanted onto a flat ceramic surface, and
cracks develop around the indentation in inverse proportion to the toughness of the material. By measuring
crack lengths, it is possible to estimate K
Ic
. The crack morphology formed during the elastic-plastic contact
between a sharp indenter and a brittle medium consists of both median and lateral vent cracks. It must be noted
that under small indentation loads, only small, shallow cracks form. The median vent cracks are used for
fracture toughness computations.
Crack dependence on sample preparation is well known for shallow cracks. The preparation of the sample
surface, using effective polishing to achieve a stress state representative of the bulk, is recommended in order to
achieve maximum crack length. Annealing also can be used. Ratios of crack length to indent radius of about 23
or more are recommended in order to achieve consistent results. In addition, the crack length must be measured
immediately after the indentation to minimize possible post-indentation slow crack growth, especially in
glasses, glass-ceramics, and ceramics that have a glassy grain boundary.
Chevron Notch Method. This method is gaining popularity because it uses a relatively small amount of
material. The fracture toughness calculations are dependent on the maximum load and on both specimen and
loading geometries. No material constants are needed for the calculations. The technique is also suitable for
high-temperature testing, because flaw healing is not a concern. However, it requires a complex specimen shape
that has an extra machining cost. A sawed notch is induced in a test bar that is usually 3 mm by 4 mm by 50
mm (0.12 in. by 0.16 in. by 2 in.). The notch angle varies from 30 to 50°. On subsequent testing of the
specimen, a crack will develop at the chevron tip and extend stably as the load is increased, and later there is
catastrophic fracture.