Ващенко Ю.В. Банківське право
Подождите немного. Документ загружается.
311
4. #!&" D# &?;$!@! %@*?;& $ &?;$!@! +!$!?;
D+"E?%" + & +$= D@?A!@! D+!!&#$&, $+ " & +$= #E%C"?A-
!@! D+!!&#$& +,.
5. #A!@!" %J' D"F#% &?;$= !E%C"F $%$!",
+,, D@?A" ECE &?;$!@! %@*?;&, E!&!&J%
%J&= !@"& " *+C", H+"& $ "R= +%$!-"#!&=
*#$!& +, & %@*?;&" &?;$= !E%C"F, E& F !H!&’-
D+ #*H’I+$"& &?;$= &"!#, E!!+ D"F#% &?;$!@! +!-
$!?;, &"E!&"?A"#$A D E!*R% &?;$!@! D+!!&#$&
&#$!&?%" %+%$!' H"%$* ""#$"& +, «K! ##$%'* &-
?;$!@! %@*?;& " &?;$!@! +!$!?;» &" 19 ?;$!@! 1993 .
- 15—93.
6. "E!&"! ! %+%$* H"%$* ""#$"& +, «K! ##$%-
'* &?;$!@! %@*?;& "
&?;$!@! +!$!?;» &?;$% %@*?;-
& & +," D"F#;;$A H"%$ ""#$"& +, $ C"!?A-
F H+ +,.
7. C"!?AF H+ D"F#;I &"E!&"! ! &D<%= #E%C"-
?A' D+!!' E!&!&J%A &?;$% %@*?;&, &D<I E!-
!+ D"F#% !E%C"F & "!D%'"F &?;$"; !@"D!&*I " D"F#;I
&?;$F +!$!?A D H+' $ "R' "#!&' *#$!&',
+" !$'? ?"C%D";
C"!?A!@! H+* D"F#% &?;$=
!E%C"F.
8. C"!?AF H+ +, &I @%%?A" $ "&"*?A" ?"-
C%D", D"F#% &?;$= !E%C"F.
9. "E!&"! ! %+%$* H"%$* ""#$"& +, «K! ##$%'*
&?;$!@! %@*?;& " &?;$!@! +!$!?;» &?;$F +!$!?A &
+," D"F#;;$A C"!?AF H+ +, (@!?!&F !@ &?;-
$!@! +!$!?;), !@ %J&!, E!$+!&!,
#?*JH, %J&F '-
$F +!'"$%$ +,, ""#$%#$&! D&’D+* +,. !'%C"F" H+
I @%$' &?;$!@! +!$!?;.
10. H’I+$!' &?;$!@! +!$!?; '!J*$A H*$ % H*A-+" !E%C", D
&?;$' C"!#$', #'% $", +" <"$+! &D<%" * %+%$" H"%-
$* ""#$"& +, «K! ##$%'* &?;$!@! %@*?;& " &?;$!-
@! +!$!?;».
11.
H#@ E& $ !H!&’D+"& *<#+"& &?;$= E&!&"!# D?%-
J$A &" $!@!, < I &! %D%$', < %%D%$' D &?;$'
D+!!&#$&!' +,.
. .
312
12. ?#"+C" ;<= !#"H $ ,= E%#$&C$& %D%$"&
$ %%D%$"& &"E!&"! ! D+!!&#$& +, D"F#;I$A#
E"#$&" &!= +$%",&:
1) '"#C%D=!J% ( $%$!", +, < D ,, '%J');
2) D"F#% E"EI'CA+!, "?A!#$" E"#$&" T+!"& +,-
(D"F#;I$A#, < ").
13. T D@?A' E&?!' &*<+ %D%$"& * "!D%'"F &?;$"
E"?@I D=*&;
,= &?;$" =*+ & *E!&!&J%= H+= *
$%'" &E?$ DH!@!&!#$%F, DD<%" & +!$+$=, ?% % E"D"-
R% 90 +?%= "& D $ '$!@! !!'?% (&E#+ &&"D!,
&$J!, '$!, %+?C",) E!*+C",, M! %+#E!$*I$A#, & D" %+#-
E!$* !H"$ (E!#?*@), E& "$%?%+$*?A!, &?#!#$" — D '!'%$* E"-
E# +$ H! "R!@! !+*'%$,
M! D#&"<*I &+! !H"$, -
E!#?*@, %+#E!$ E& "$%?%+$*?A!, &?#!#$". K%%&M%
DD<%!@! $%'"* E!$%H*I "&"*?A!, ?"C%D", C"!?A!@!
H+* +,.
14. T E!*R% E&? D"F#% &?;$= !E%C"F '!J% D-
#$!#!&*&$# "#!&, '""#$$& $ +'"?A &"E!&"?A-
"#$A.
$&$+, /!
1. ="' "'* *-
"' "'* "'.
2. "F ' +& "' P?
3. # -$ -
< *"'! "' -
?
4. "' %?
5. # $% $"*'! "' *"'-
' "' "'?
6. # F
<?
7. #
$& F %"!
< "'0 ?
8. # $ 0 -
"'? L &" $& -
"0 " $ -
"' ?
9. < $"*'! ’ %0 -
* "'* "'?
10. # $"!! &
$( "'* ?
313
/!$ &$)'$%$( +&"&!
*;%;D #/%. A%D; ’D; / &/ H"% #/%
28 $D 1996 . / % #/%. > %"D. — . — *.:
«*%», 1997.
[%+% " #/%.
"+% " #/%
C; *; (; #/% «A %;' @; @-
D ; @; ;@» " 19 @; 1993 . E 15-93 //
"'; &/ H"% #/%, 1993. — E 17. — ;. 184.
A +% #/%: #/% " 20 ;D 1999 . //
"'; &/ H"% #/%. — 1999. — E 29. — ;. 238; 2000. —
E 14—15—16.
A % ; + "D+;+: #/% " 7 "D 2000 . //
"'; &/ H"% #/%. — 2001. — E 5—6. — ;. 30.
#/% «A D" !& !' @;» " 23 -
D 1994 . E 185/94-H.
AGD D" %"$ "%"+%& ! !D
!'/ @;% ! 'G #/% "D ;% +%& '; ; -
"D '%& @;%& , !;"G ;@ AD -
+ #/% " 17 $D 2004 E266, !K; (-
;; @;%/ #/% 16 %D 2004 . ! E897/9496.
AGD D" %"$ +%' ' #/% "%"+-
%& ! !&% 'G !%";'% !%";'% 'G& ;-
+ ; @; #/% ; D !' " ';%-
; + #/%, !;"G ;@ AD -
+ #/% " 14 G;D 2004 E484, !K; (-
;; @;%/ #/% 9 %;" 2004 . ! E1430/10029.
AGD D" %"$ +%' ' #/% "%"+-
%& ! %%;D !'/ @;% ;%;/ #/% D !
;G, !;"G ;@ AD + #/% "
14 G;D 2004 E483, !K; (;; @;%/ #/% 9 %-
;" 2004 . E 1429/10028.
AGD D" %"$ +%' ' #/% "%-
"+%& ! !'FD !%";'% (@%"%$%'% ; >!%$-
%'% '%) @;%& ; && ! 'G'% #/%, !-
;"G ;@ AD + #/% " 14
G;D 2004 . E 485, !K; (;; @;%/ #/% 5
%;" 2004 . ! E 1413/10012.
=;D D" !"D ;@ ;%'D ! !
;%'%, ';%'% ; !%%'% D'%, !;"G -
;@ AD + #/% E 136 " 24.03.99.
" E. . A @D @;%& "% // ;>. … "%.
". @%". . — L, + "'D #/% '. S
(", 1996. — 23 .
. .
314
+ #/%: $. %. *. ;.: < . (., =-
>> . ?., *;@ . ., A$% . ., % . . ; . / !.
". . . . — *.: %"%$% C' «= ?», 2000. — 384 .
E . (G"% @;% >": $+% ", ;% //
% #. — + 2004. — . 44.
D. +. %; + @; ;@ D
>/ "G D // "';;% >' #/:
\D& " ]+/ ;/: . . +. — *., 2003. — . 242—245.
D . A ;% @D @;%& '-
%& #/ // % #. — %;" 1999. — . 18—21.
+F 9. %; @; @D #/ // %
#. — + 1999. — . 22—24.
"' . 8. + : $. %. — *.: ?' =;,
2004 — 376 .
8" =. +. AD;;D %!$D @;%& ! !-
";' #/% // % %: !% %& + "'/
"G/ ";/ G% #/%. — 2003. — E 1 (19). — . 242—246.
8" =. +. A @D +%& @;%&
#/ // ;>. "%. … ". @%". . — *.: *%/+% -
+% %;; ' M$, 2004. — 13 .
8" =. +. HG%' !D @;%& // A #-
/%. — 2003. — E 11. — . 41—45.
315
15
M
D
§ 1. &%$%!B " *% $*, /&!>, %!$-
> /+!)! /$'% (= /$'$%!= $*$%’%.
§ 2. ! /+!! /$'%, *$&% ($*$%’$%!=
/+;%).
§ 1. ( ,
% %
" " ’*
%!H="! DD<$, M! H+ $ "R" "#!&" *#$-
!& '!J*$A H$ *<#$A * E!$+!&= E&!&"!#= * &!=
#$$*#=:
x + !#!H, M! #E;$A #E&?; E!$+"&, DH!"&
(!H!&’D+!&= E?$%J"&);
x + E?$+ E!$+"&, DH!"& (!H!&’D+!&= E?$%J"&).
’* ,
@ % % ,
* (’*" )
E H+"& " %H+"&#A+= "#!&= *#$!& #E&-
?; E!$+"&, DH!"& $ "R= !H!&’D+!&= E?$%J"& E!?@I *
&%%" =*+"& E?$+"& E!$+"&, $, &"E!&"!, E%%=*-
&" #*' E!$+"&, DH!"& F "R= !H!&’D+!&= E?$%J"& ! H;-
J%$"& $ %J&= C"?A!&= !"&.
H!&’D+ H+"& $ "R= %H+"&#A+= "#!&= *#$!&
& #%" E!$+!&= &"!# &D<%", & E%R* <%@*, & T+!"
+, «K! ##$%'* !E!$+*&», T+!" +, «K! H-
+ " H+"&#A+* "?A"#$A», T+!" +, «K! E!!+ E!@-
R% D!H!&’DA E?$+"& E!$+"& E%% H;J%$' " %J-
&' C"?A!&' !'».
. .
316
"E!&"! ! #$$$" 5 T+!* +, «K! ##$%'* !E!$-
+*&» "#!&" *#$!& &"+&;$A =*+ E?$+'
E!$+"& " DH!"& (!H!&’D+!&= E?$%J"&) ?R% D *'!&
E%’&?% ' !+*'%$, M! E"$&%J*I &D$$ ,= !H?"+
& !@" %J&!, E!$+!&!, #?*JH.
T@"! "D D+!!&#$&!' +, H+"&#A+" =*+ E"E-
I'C"& — ;<= !#"H $ "D<= !#"H E%%H*&;$A !H?"+*
& !@= %J&!, E!$+!&!, #?*JH. +, &"E!&"! ! #$$$"
5 T+!* +, «K! ##$%'* !E!$+*&» "#!&" *#$-
!& D!H!&’D" "#?$ E!&"!'?% E! D+$$ =*+
E?$+ E!$+"& " DH!"& (!H!&’D+!&= E?$%J"&) — ;<!,
< "D<!, !#!H — #*H’I+$ E"EI'CA+!, "?A!#$" ! !-
@* %J&!, E!$+!&!, #?*JH, & +!'* !H?"+!&*I$A# E?$-
+ E!$+"&.
L"#!&" *#$!& E!<;$A &$+!&" !E%C", D =*+!'
E?$+ E!$+"& — #*H’I+$ E"EI'CA+!, "?A!#$" (+"'
H+*) D $ !$' "#!&!; *#$!&!; !+*'%$?A!
E"$&%J%!@! E!&"!'?% !@* %J&!, E!$+!&!, #?*-
JH E! &D$$ =*+ !H?"+ & !@= %J&!, E!$+!&!,
#?*JH.
L!' " D'"#$ E!&"!'?%A &D<;$A# C%$?A' !@-
!' %J&!, E!$+!&!, #?*JH E! &D$$ =*+ !H?"+ &
!@= %J&!, E!$+!&!, #?*JH +,.
&'!@ D+!* DFR? #&!I D+"E?% " * &"E!&"!'*
E"D+!!'* +$" C"!?A!@! H+* +,. +, &"E!&"!
! E*+$* 1.13 #$*+C", E! E!!+ &"+$$, &+!#$ "
D+$$ =*+"& * C"!?A"F $ "!D%'"F &?;$=, D$&%-
J%!, E!#$!&!; K&?" C"!?A!@! H+* +, &"
12.11.2003 . - 492, * D" &"+$$ E!$!<!@! H! &+?!@!
(%E!D$!@!) =*+ E"EI'C; ! !$' H+!' E!&"!-
'?% E! &D$$ =*+ !H?"+ !@!' %J&!, E!$+!-
&!, #?*JH (?" — E!&"!'?%) (1) !E%C", D C' =*+!'
D"F#;;$A# ?R% "D D=*& +!R$"&. $!; E!<$+* &$-
+!&= !E%C"F D =*+!' E"EI'C & H+* I $ %I#$C",
!$' H+!' DD<%!@! E!&"!'?%. K!&"!'?% DH%-
"@I$A# & #E&" D ;<!@! !!'?% =*+. $+!&"
!E%C", D =*+!' &"!+%'?%!@! E"!D"?* ;<!, !#!-
H-E"EI'C D"F#;;$A# E"#? !$' H+!' E!&"!'-
?% E! &D$$ =*+ !H?"+ !@!' %J&!, E!$+!&!,
#?*JH D '"#C%D=!J%' &"!+%'?%!@! E"!D"?*. K!&"-
!'?% 'I &"E!&"$ DD+* +!"C E!&"!'?% &" E?$-
+ E!$+"& E! &"+$$ =*+ & *#$!&" H+*, DD<%-
317
!'* & !$+* 1 ! K!+* E! E!$+!&' !@' E!&"-
!'?% E! &"+$$ (D+$$) =*+"& & *#$!&= H+"&,
D$&%J%!@! +D!' %J&!, E!$+!&!, '""#$C", +-
, &" 01.08.2001 - 306 " D%I#$!&!@! & ""#$%#$&" ;#$C",
+, 31.10.2001 D - 923/6114.
%!H="! D&%*$ *&@* $%, M! D+!!&#$&!' +,
E%%H<% &"E!&"?A"#$A H+"& $ "R= "#!&= *#$-
!& D %#&!I<#% E!&"!'?% E!$+!&= !@"& E! &"+-
$$ (D+$$) =*+"& +?"I$"&. "E!&"! ! E*+$* 12 <#-
$ 1 #$$$" 11 T+!* +, «K! %J&* E!$+!&*
#?*JH* & +,"» E%%H<%!, M! !@ %J&!, E!$+!&!,
#?*JH ';$A E&! D#$!#!&*&$ ! *#$!& H+"&, M! % E!-
? &"E!&"' !@' %J&!, E!$+!&!, #?*JH & *#$-
!&?%F D+!!' #$!+ E!&"!'?%A E! D+$$ =*+"& E?-
$+"& E!$+"& H! !DE!<? D"F#% &$+!&= !E%C"F D
=*+!' E?$+ E!$+"& ! !$' E!&"!'?% &"E!&"-
!@! !@* %J&!, E!$+!&!, #?*JH E! &D$$ =*+
!H?"+ & !@= %J&!, E!$+!&!, #?*JH, "#!&" (R$-
") #+C", * !D'"" &C$ %!E!$+!&*&= '""'*'"& !-
=!"& @!'.
+' <!', #$!+ ? E! $+= E!&"!'?%A 'I H*$
&#$!&?%F D+!!'. +F #$!+ H*& &#$!&?%F #$$$%; 24
T+!* +, «K! E"EI'#$& & +,"». K!$%, + &"!'!,
DD<%F D+! &$$& <"#$A * D&’D+* H*$$' ;<!,
#? !#E!#A+' +!%+#!' +,. #A!@!" $%'" -
E&?% H+' $ "R' "#!&' *#$!&' E! &"+-
$$ (D+$$) =*+"& +?"I$"& % &#$!&?%F "&" D+!-
*. +F $%'" &D<%! &+D' &M% K!+!' E!
E!$+!&' !@' E!&"!'?% E! &"+$$ (D+$$) -
=*+"& & *#$!&= H+"&. " #$!&$A 3 " D &"+$$
(D+$$) =*+*. +' <!', D !'?A!, $!<+ D!* E"#-
$& ? %?"DC", E!$+!&' !@' E&, &D<%!@! *
E*+$" 12 #$$$" 11 T+!* +, «K! %J&* E!$+!&*
#?*JH* & +,"», &"#*$". K!$% !@ %J&!, E!$+!&!,
#?*JH F!@! %?"D!&*;$A, E! M! #&"<$A, D!+%', ?#$ %-
J&!, E!$+!&!, '""#$C", +, &" 29.04.2005 .
- 8493/7/19-1117 «K! D#$!#*& "#!&= #+C"F D E!-
*R% $%'""& E!&"!'?% E! &"+$$ /D+$$ H+"&-
#A+= =*+"&». DD<%!'* ?#$" K & +!#$" E"#$& ?
%?"DC", &M%DD<%!@! E& E!$+"&C"& &!$A #$*+-
C"; E! E!!+ &"+$$, &+!#$ " D+$$ =*+"& *
C"!?A"F $ "!D%'"F &?;$=, $+!J K!!+ E!-
. .
318
$+!&' !@' K!&"!'?% E! &"+$$ (D+$$) =*-
+"& & "#!&= *#$!&=. H"+ E!$+!&= !@"& * CA!'*
E$" #$?! " ""#$%#$&! "#"& +,. #&!I'* ?#$"
&" 18.05.2005 . - 24-48-41 ";#$ !D’#&, M! "F#!, D+!-
!' $%'" ? E!&"!'?% E! &"+$$/D+$$ =*+"& %
E%%H<%F. K!$% D '%$!; !$' E!#?"!&!#$" "F E?-
$+"& E!$+"& $ !@"& %J&!, E!$+!&!, #?*JH E
&D$$" !H?"+ & !@= %J&!, E!$+!&!, #?*JH =*+"&
E?$+"& E!$+"&, &"+$= * "#!&= *#$!&=, ";#$
&&JI !C"?A' ! &#$!&?% D+!!' $%'"* E!-
&"!'?% E! &"+$$ (D+$$) =*+"& & "#!&= *#$-
!&= !$'*&$# $%'"*, E%%H<%!@! * E. 2 K!+*
K.
"E!&"! ! #$$$" 12 T+!* +, «K! ##$%'* !E!$-
+*&» "#!&" *#$!& D!H!&’D" E!&$ !@' %-
J&!, E!$+!&!, #?*JH ,= E#A'!&F DE$ &"!'!#$" E!
&"#$A " *= +!R$"& E!$!<= $ &+?= (%E!D$=) -
=*+= E?$+"& E!$+"& — +?"I$"& C= *#$!& * E!+*,
&#$!&?%!'* D+!!'. "E!&"! ! #$$$" 62 T+!* +,
«K! H+ " H+"&#A+* "?A"#$A» "!'C" M!! ;<=
" "D<= !#"H, + '"#$$A H+"&#A+* $I'C;, !D+&I$A#
H+', D!+%', !@' %J&!, E!$+!&!, #?*JH +,-
,= E#A'!&* &'!@* D E$A !E!$+*& H! &?;$!@!
+!$!?; #$!#!&! !E%C"F D =*+' +!+%$!, ;<!,
!#!H H! "D<!, !#!H — #*H’I+$ E"EI'CA+!, "?A!#$"
D +!+%$F E!'"J!+ <#*, E#A'!&* &'!@* #** H! D
"R%' #**. '!@ &"E!&"!@! %J&!@! !@* !$-
' "!'C",, + '"#$$A H+"&#A+* $I'C;, E!&:
1) H*$ &+?% H?+* %J&!@! !@* &#$!&?%!,
!';
2) H*$ D E"E#!' +%"&+ %J&!@! !@* (<
F!@! D#$*E+), #+"E?%!@! @%H!&!; E%<$+!;;
3) '"#$$ E%%H<%" C' T+!!' E"#$& ? !$'
C"I, "!'C",;
4) '"#$$ E!#? !' D+!*, &"E!&"! ! +=
%J&F !@ 'I E&! !$' $+!, "!'C",.
% E&! E!$+!&= !@"& !$' "!'C", &" H-
+"& !H'%J%% T+!!' +, «K! %J&* E!$+!&* #?*J-
H* & +,"». "E!&"! ! E*+$* 5 #$$$" 11 CA!@! T+!* !-
@ %J&!, E!$+!&!, #?*JH ';$A E&! !%J*&$
H%D!E?$! &" E?$+"& E!$+"&, $+!J &" *#$!& C"!-
?A!@! H+* +, $ +!'%C"F= H+"& * E!+*, &#$!&-
319
?%!'* T+!!' +, «K! H+ " H+"&#A+* "?A"#$A»,
!&"+ $/H! +!E", !+*'%$"& ?R% E! &"#$A H+"&#A+=
=*+"&. !'C" E! !H#@ $ !H"@ +!R$"& =*+=, * $!-
'* <#?" E! %=!J% * &#$!&?%" $%'" &?;$!, &-
*<+ &" #*H’I+$"& E"EI'CA+!, "?A!#$" I$A# &+?;-
<! E"#$&" "R% #**.
L"#!&" *#$!& &+!*;$A !*<% E?$+"& E!$+"& "
DH!"& (!H!&’D+!&= E?$%J"&) E%%=*& E!$+"& " DH!-
"& (!H!&’D+!&= E?$%J"&) ! H;J%$"& * &#$!&?%F D+!!'
$%'". %'" &+! H+' !*<%A E?$+"& E!$+"&
&D<%F * T+!" +, «K! E?$"J" ##$%' $ E%%+D
@!R%F & +,"». "E!&"! ! #$$$" 8 CA!@! T+!* H+ D!-
H!&’DF &+!$ !*<% +?"I$, M! '"#$$A# & !D=*-
+!&!'* !+*'%$", +F "FR!& E!$@!' !E%C"F!@! <#*
H+*, & %A F!@! =!J%. D" =!J% !D=*-
+!&!@! !+*'%$ +?"I$ ! !H#?*@!&*;<!@! H+* E"#? D+"-
<% !E%C"F!@! <#* H+ D!H!&’DF &+!$ !*<%
+?"I$, M! '"#$$A# & CA!'* !D=*+!&!'* !+*'%$", % E"D-
"R% #$*E!@! !H!<!@! .
L"#!& &"E!&"?A"#$A H+"& D %&+! H! %-
?%J% &+! !*<%A +?"I$"&—E?$+"& E!$+"& D E%%-
=*& #*' E!$+"&, DH!"& (!H!&’D+!&= E?$%J"&) E%%H-
<% T+!!' +, «K! E!!+ E!@R% D!H!&’DA
E?$+"& E!$+"& E%% H;J%$' $ %J&' C"?A!&'
!'». "E!&"! ! E*+$* 16.5 #$$$" 16 CA!@! T+!* D
E!*R% #$!+"& E%%=*& E!$+"&, DH!"& (!H!&’D+!&=
E?$%J"&) ! H;J%$"& H! %J&= C"?A!&= !"&, &#$!&-
?%= T+!!' +, «K! E?$"J" ##$%' $ E%%+D @!-
R%F & +,"», H+ #E?<*I E%; D +!JF %A E!#$!<%,
&+?;<;< %A #E?$, * !D'"=, &#$!&?%= E"E*+$!'
16.4.1 E*+$* 16.4 #$$$" 16, $ R$" #+C",, &#$!&?%" E"-
E*+$!' 17.1.7 E*+$* 17.1 #$$$" 17 CA!@! T+!*, $+!J %#%
"R* &"E!&"?A"#$A, &#$!&?%* C' T+!!', D E!*R%
E!+* #&!I<#!@! $ E!&!@! &%#% E!$+*, DH!*
(!H!&’D+!&!@! E?$%J*) ! H;J%$* H! %J&!@! C"?A!&!@!
!*. K CA!'* E?$+ E!$+"&, DH!"& (!H!&’D+!&= E?$%-
J"&) D&"?AI$A# &" &"E!&"?A!#$" D %#&!I<#% H! %E!&%
D=*& $+= E?$%J"& ! H;J%$"& $ %J&= C"?A!&=
!"&, &+?;<;< =!&* E%; H! R$" #+C",. %'
E! ! *#$!& H+"& E?$"J!@! !*<% D &#"' &'
E!$+!&= E?$%J"& &&JI$A# %A F!@! %I#$C", * C= *#$-
!&=.
. .
320
% E!?!J% T+!* 'I *J% &J?&% D<%, !#+"?A+
&"E!&"! ! #$$$" 50 ;J%$!@! +!%+#* +, E!$+,
DH! (!H!&’D+!&" E?$%J") $ "R" !=! %J&!@! H;J%$*
&D;$A# D=!&' & !=! %J&!@! H;J%$* D '!'%-
$* D=*& IF +D<%F#A+F =*!+ %J&!@!
H;J%$*.
% &&JI$A# E!*R%' #$!+"& D=*& E!$+"& "
DH!"& (!H!&’D+!&= E?$%J"&) D & H+*, +M! $+% E!*-
R% #$?! #?"+!' %@*?;& C"!?A' H+!' +-
, %+!!'"<= !'$&"& $+!@! H+*, M! ED&!$A ! H-
+* &"?A!@! D?R+* +!R$"& $+!'* +!%#E!%$#A+!'*
=*+* ? D"F#% D=*&.
[+M! * 'FH*$A!'* H+ H! F!@! E&!#$*E+ &"!&-
?;;$A E?$!#E!'!J"#$A, &"?"+ $%'""& D=*& E!$+"&,
DH!"& (!H!&’D+!&= E?$%J"&) !DE!<I$A# D '!'%$* $+!@!
&"!&?%.
K #$@%" +!R$"& $ 'F E?$+"& E!$+"&—+?"I$"&
H+"&, #$=*&?A+"& #$=!&= !@"DC"F H! <?%"& "R=
%H+"&#A+= "#!&= *#$!&, #$&!%= &"E!&"! ! D-
+!*, E!$+!&" !@ H! %J&" &+!&C" % ';$A E&
D&%$$ #$@% D?R+ +!R$"& +!%#E!%$#A+= -
=*+= H+"&, $+!J #$=!&" $ E"&" ! = %D%&
H+"&, #$=!&= !@"DC"F H! %H+"&#A+= "#!&=
*#$!&, #!'!&= &"E!&"! ! D+!!&#$&.
§ 2. ,
* (’*" )
5
(" " )
K!!+ !E!$+*& EH*$+* H+"& (%H+"&#A-
+= "#!&= *#$!&) &D<%F * T+!" +, «K! !E!-
$+*& EH*$+* E"EI'#$&».
"E!&"! ! E*+$* 4.1.2 #$$$" 4 T+!* +, «K! !E!-
$+*& EH*$+* E"EI'#$&» !=! &" D"F#% H-
+"&#A+=, #$=!&= $ "R= !E%C"F D "#!&= E!#-
?*@, $!@"&?" &?;$' C"!#$', C"' EE%', H!@!-