Ващенко Ю.В. Банківське право
Подождите немного. Документ загружается.
271
&+?*, & +!'* &+?+!' I "D< !#!H, I E*H?"<' !@!-
&!!'.
! &"!# H+* $ &+?+ D =*+!', +F &%#%-
F &+?, D#$!#!&*;$A# E!?!J% E! !@!&" H+"&#A+!@!
=*+, +M! "R% % &#$!&?%! D+!!' H! % &E?&I "D
#*$" !@!&!* H+"&#A+!@! &+?*.
T@"! D" #$$$%; 1059 &"?A!@! +!%+#* +, !@!&"
H+"&#A+!@! &+?* *+?I$A# * E#A'!&"F !'". K#A'!&
!' !@!&!* H+"&#A+!@! &+?* &&JI$A# !%J!;,
+M! &%#% @!R!&!, #*' E"$&%J%! !@!&!!' H+"&#A-
+!@! &+?* D &<%; !M!, +J+ H! #%$"+$ < "R!-
@! !+*'%$, M! &"E!&"I &'!@', &#$!&?%' D+!!', "-
R' !'$&!-E&!&' +$' * #%" H+"&#A+!, "?A-
!#$" (H+"&#A+' E&?') $ D&<' "?!&!@! !H!!$*.
D" %!%J E#A'!&!, !' !@!&!* H+"&#A+!@! &+?-
* C%F !@!&" I "+<%''.
"E!&"! ! #$$$" 1061 &"?A!@! +!%+#* +, H+ &-
E?<*I &+?+!&" E!C%$ #*'* &+?* & !D'"", &#$!&?%-
!'* !@!&!!' H+"&#A+!@! &+?*. [+M! !@!&!!' % &#$!&-
?%F !D'" E!C%$"&, H+ D!H!&’DF &E?<*&$ E!C%$ *
!D'"" !H?"+!&!, #$&+ C"!?A!@! H+* +,. + 'I
E&! D'"$ !D'" E!C%$"&, +" &E?<*;$A# &+? &-
'!@*, +M! "R% % &#$!&?%! !@!&!!'. D" D'%R% H-
+!' !D'"* E!C%$"& &+? &'!@* !&F !D'" E!C%$"&
D#$!#!&*I$A# ! &+?"&, &%#%= ! E!&"!'?% &+?+"&
E! D'%R% E!C%$"&, D" #E?&!' !!@! '"#C D '!'%$* &"-
E!&"!@! E!&"!'?%, +M! "R% % &#$!&?%! !@!&!!'.
#$!&?%F !@!&!!' !D'" E!C%$"& #$!+!&F &+? H!
&+?, &%#%F *'!&= F!@! E!&%% * D" #$ &-
D<%= !@!&!!' !H#$&, % '!J% H*$ !!#$!!A! D'%-
R%F H+!', +M! "R% % &#$!&?%! D+!!'. K!C%$ H-
+"&#A+F &+? =!&*;$A# &" , #$*E!@! D %'
=!J% &+?* * H+, ! , +F E%%*I F!@! E!&%%;
&+?+!&" H! #E#; D =*+ &+?+ D "R= E"#$&.
K!C%$ H+"&#A+F &+? &E?<*;$A# &+?+!&" F!@!
&'!@* D" #E?&!' +!J!@! +&$?* !+%'! &" #*' &+?*, %-
&$%H*&" * C%F #$!+ E!C%$ DH"?AR*;$A #*'* &+?*, +*
=!&*;$A# E!C%$, +M! "R% % &#$!&?%! !@!&!!' H-
+"&#A+!@! &+?*. D" E!&%% &+?* &E?<*;$A# *#" -
=!&" ! CA!@! '!'%$* E!C%$.
T@"! D" #$$$%; 1062 &"?A!@! +!%+#* +, =*-
!+ D H+"&#A+' &+?!' D=!&*;$A# @!R!&" +!R$, +"
. .
272
"FR? ! H+* "'’ &+?+ &" "R!, !#!H, +M! !@!-
&!!' H+"&#A+!@! &+?* % E%%H<%! "R%. K CA!'* &&-
JI$A#, M! &+?+ E!@!&# !%J @!R!&= +!R$"&
&" "R!, !#!H, &R ,F %!H="" " E! =*!+ D &+?-
!'. !R$, E!'?+!&! D=!&" =*!+ &+?+, E"?-
@;$A E!&%%; &"E!&"! ! #$$$" 388 CA!@! !%+#*.
"E!&"! ! #$$$" 1063 &"?A!@! +!%+#* +, "D<-
H! ;< !#!H '!J% *+?#$ !@!&" H+"&#A+!@! &+?-
* (D!H$ &+?) +!#$A $%$A!, !#!H. !#!H H*&I
E& &+?+ D '!'%$* E%’&?% %; ! H+* E%R!,
&'!@, M! &E?&I D E& &+?+, H! &J% %; "-
R' #E!#!H!' '"* #+!#$$# $+' E&'. ! H*$$
!#!H!;, +!#$A +!, D!H?%F H+"&#A+F &+?, E& &+?-
+ C" E& ?%J$A !#!H", + D!H? &+?. D<%
"'%" "D<!, !#!H H! F'%*& ;<!, !#!H, +!-
#$A +!, D!H?%F &+?, I "#$!$!; *'!&!; !@!&!* H+"&-
#A+!@! &+?*. [+M! !#!H, +!#$A +!, D!H?%! &+?, &"-
'!&?# &" A!@!, !#!H, + *+?? !@!&" H+"&#A+!@!
&+?* +!#$A $%$A!, !#!H, 'I E&! &'@$ E!&%%
&+?* H! E%%&%#$ F!@! #&!I "'’.
T@"! D" #$$$%; 1064 &"?A!@! +!%+#* +, *+?%
!@!&!* H+"&#A+!@! &+?* D "D<!; !#!H!; " &%#%
@!R!&= +!R$"& ,, =*!+ D &+?!' E"$&%J*;$A# !M-
!; +J+!;. !M"F +JC" &+D*;$A# F'%*& "
'"#C%D=!J% H+* (F!@! "?",), !'% =*+ D &+?!',
$+!J *#" @!R!&" #*', D=!&" =*!+ $ #E#" D -
=*+, $+!J D?R!+ @!R!&= +!R$"& =*+* '!'%$
E%’&?% !M!, +J+ * H+. "!'!#$" E! &+?, &+-
D" & !M"F +JC", I E"#$&!; ? !D=*+"& D &+?!'
'"J H+!' " &+?+!'. < H+"&#A+!@! &+?*, &E?$
E!C%$"& D ' " &+! !DE!J%A &+?+ E! E%%-
=*& @!R!&= +!R$"& D =*+ D &+?!' "R' !#!H'
D"F#;;$A# H+!' * D" E%’&?% !M!, +J+. [+M!
!M* +J+* &$<%! H! E&%%! * %E$F ?
E%’&?% #$, H+ D D&!; &+?+ &I F!'* !&*
!M* +J+*.
"E!&"! ! #$$$" 1065 !MF (%E!D$F) #%$"+$
E"$&%J*I #*'* &+?*, &%#%!@! * H+, " E& &+?+
(&!?!"?AC #%$"+$) !%J D" #E?&!' &#$!&?%!@!
#$!+* #*' &+?* $ E!C%$"&, &#$!&?%= #%$"+$!', *
H+*, +F F!@! &&. D" !#$!+!&!@! E%’&?% !M-
!@! (%E!D$!@!) #%$"+$ ! !E?$ H+!' &E?<*I$A#
273
#*' &+?* $ E!C%$, +" &E?<*;$A# D &+?' &'!-
@*, +M! *'!&' #%$"+$ % &#$!&?%F "RF !D'"
E!C%$"&.
T@"! D" #$$$%; 340 !#E!#A+!@! +!%+#* +, %E!-
D$" !E%C", H+"& E!?@;$A * D?*<%" +!R$"& * &+? $
!D'"M% !M= (%E!D$=) #%$"+$"&. %E!D$ *$&!-
;;$A# D =*!+ +!R$"& * @!$"&+!&"F H! * H%D@!$"&+!&"F !-
'", * @&= H! & "!D%'"F &?;$", M! !D'"M%" ;<'
!#!H' < @!'' (+?"I$') ,= =*+= * H+*
!@!&"= D#= E%&F #$!+ DH%"@ H! H%D DD<%-
$+!@! #$!+* " E"?@;$A &E?$" &+?+* &"E!&"! !
D+!!&#$& $ *'!& !@!&!*. !@!&" H+"&#A+!@! &+?*
(%E!D$*) *+?I$A# * E#A'!&"F !'".
D<% &+?* (%E!D$*) '"#$$A# " * #E%C"?A!'* H-
+"&#A+!'* D+!!&#$&". +, &"E!&"! ! #$$$" 2 T+!* +-
, «K! H+ " H+"&#A+* "?A"#$A» &+? (%E!D$) — C%
+!R$ & @!$"&+!&"F H! * H%D@!$"&+!&"F !'", * &?;$" +,
H! & "!D%'"F &?;$", +" !D'"M%" +?"I$' ,= "'%= -
=*+= * H+* !@!&"= D#= &D<%F #$!+ DH%"-
@ H! H%D DD<% $+!@! #$!+* " E"?@;$A &E?$"
&+?+* &"E!&"! ! D+!!&#$& +, $ *'!& !@!&!*.
§ 2. 6 *" (") (
T D+!!&#$&!' +, !D"D;$A# & &
&+?"& (%E!D$"&):
x &+? &'!@*;
x #$!+!&F &+?.
+, &"E!&"! ! #$$$" 1060 &"?A!@! +!%+#* +,
!@!&" H+"&#A+!@! &+?* *+?I$A# *'!&= &<" &+?*
E%R* &'!@* (&+? &'!@*) H! *'!&= E!&%%
&+?* D" #E?&!' &#$!&?%!@! !@!&!!' #$!+* (#$!+!&F
&+?).
!@!&!!' '!J% H*$
E%%H<%! &%#% @!R!&!, #*'
"R= *'!&= ,, E!&%%. T !@!&!!' H+"&#A+!@! &+?*
%D?%J! &" F!@! &* H+ D!H!&’DF &$ &+? H! F!-
@! <#$* E%R* &'!@* &+?+, +"' &+?"&, D!H?%=
;<' !#!H' "R= *'!&= E!&%%, +" &#$!&-
?%" !@!&!!'. '!& !@!&!* E! &"'!&* &" E& !%-
. .
274
J &+?* E%R* &'!@* I "+<%'!;. [+M! &"E!&"! !
!@!&!* H+"&#A+!@! &+?* &+? E!&%$I$A# &+?+!&"
F!@! &'!@* ! #E?&* #$!+* H! ! #$ "R= !H#$&,
&D<%= !@!&!!', E!C%$ D C' &+?!' &E?<*;$A# *
!D'"" E!C%$"& D &+?' &'!@*, +M! !@!&!!' %
&#$!&?%F H"?AR &#!+F E!C%$. [+M! &+?+ % &'@I
E!&%% #*' #$!+!&!@! &+?* D" #E?&!' #$!+*, &#$!&-
?%!@! !@!&!!' H+"&#A+!@! &+?*, H! E!&%% #*'
&+?*, &%#%!@! "R= *'!&= E!&%%, E"#? #$
&D<%= !@!&!!' !H#$& !@!&" &&JI$A# E!!&J%-
' *'!&= &+?* &'!@*, +M! "R% % &#$!&?%! !-
@!&!!'.
§ 3. *(
*" (") (
T@"! "D #$$$%; 19 T+!* +, «K! H+ " H-
+"&#A+* "?A"#$A» H%D !$' H+"&#A+!, ?"C%D", % !D&!-
?I$A# D"F#;&$ !!<#! "?A"#$A E! D?*<%; &+?"&
$ "R= +!R$"&, M! E"?@;$A E!&%%;, " ; +%$"&,
$+!J &%#$ =*+. #!H, &" * D"F#%" H+"&#A+!, "-
?A!#$" H%D H+"&#A+!, ?"C%D",, %#*$A +'"?A*, C&"?A* <
'""#$$&* &"E!&"?A"#$A D@"! "D D+!' +,.
"E!&"! ! #$$$" 48 T+!* +, «K! H+ " H+"&-
#A+* "?A"#$A» #E%C"?"D!&' H+' (D &$+!' !M!@!)
DH!!I$A# D?*<$ &+? (%E!D$) &" "D<= !#"H & !H-
#@=, M! E%%&M*;$A 5 &"#!$+"& +E"$?* H+*.
"E!&"! ! #$$$" 52 T+!* +, «K! H+ " H+"&-
#A+* "?A"#$A» H+ '!J% *+?$ *@! D E!&’D' !#!H-
', +" E%%H<;$A =*& &"#!$+"& $ +!'"#"F=
D"F#% H+"&#A+= !E%C"F, +" '%R" D&<F=, $ -
=*& &"#!$+"& D &+?' " %E!D$', +" H"?AR" D&<F-
=, * D", +M! EH*$!+ H+* !D&!?I D"F#;&$ C% H%D
R+! ? "#!&!@! !D&$+* H+*.
T@"! D" #$$$%; 57 T+!* +, «K! H+ " H+"&#A+*
"?A"#$A» &+? "D<= !#"H +!'%C"F= H+"& @$*-
;$A# & E!+*, E%%H<%!'* D+!!&#$&!' +,. +?-
"D<= !#"H %J&!@! !M!@! H+* +, @$*-
;$A# %J&!;. #$*E!'* E$" ' H"?AR %$?A!
275
D*E'!# E&!&!'* %@*?;& @$*& &+?"& -
#%?%.
T@?AF E!!+ D?*<% H+' +, @!R!&= +!-
R$"& (+ * C"!?A"F, $+ " & "!D%'"F &?;$") H! H+"&#A+=
'%$?"& &" ;<= " "D<= !#"H ,= E!$!<", &+?" (%-
E!D$") =*+ $ !D'"M% !M= (%E!D$=) #%$"-
+$"& &D<%F * K!?!J%" E! E!!+ D"F#% H+'
+, &+?= (%E!D$=) !E%C"F D ;<' " "D<-
' !#!H', D$&%J%!'* E!#$!&!; K&?" C"!-
?A!@! H+* +, - 516 &" 03.12.2003 .
T@"! D K!?!J%' E&!&% %@*?;& H"?AR!#$" E$A
M!! &+?= (%E!D$=) !E%C"F 'I #E!D$&F =+-
$%. !H$!, #$!! #'!#$"F! &"R*;$A ,= * !@!&!". $!F
J% <# K!?!J% '"#$$A E%&" &'!@ M!! *'!& %E!D$=
!@!&!"&.
T!+%', &D<%!, M! !@!&!!' H+"&#A+!@! &+?* (%E!-
D$*) '!J% H*$ E%%H<%! &%#% @!R!&= +!R$"& H! H-
+"&#A+= '%$?"& "R= *'!&= ,= E!&%%. +" &+?
(%E!D$) I *'!&'. '!& D &+?!' % '!J*$A #*E%%<$
D+!!&#$&* +,. [+M! #$!+ DH%"@ *'!&= &+?"&
(%E!D$"&) &D<%! !@!&!!', $! $+" &+? (%E!D$) !H?"-
+!&*;$A# + #$!+!&". [+M! #$!+ DH%"@ *'!&= &+?"&
(%E!D$"&) !@!&!!' % &D<%!, $! &! !H?"+!&*;$A# +
&+? (%E!D$) &'!@*.
*', #$!+ $ *'!& EF' &+?"& (%E!D$"&) &D-
<;$A# '"J H+!' $ &+?+!' !@!&"= D#=.
T?*<% H+!' &+?"& (%E!D$"&) ;<= " "D<=
!#"H E"$&%J*I$A#:
x
!@!&!!' H+"&#A+!@! =*+*;
x !@!&!!' H+"&#A+!@! &+?* (%E!D$*) D &<%; !M-
!, +J+;
x !@!&!!' H+"&#A+!@! &+?* (%E!D$*) D &<%; !M-
!@! (%E!D$!@!) #%$"+$;
x !@!&!!' H+"&#A+!@! &+?* (%E!D$*) D &<%; "R!@!
!+*'%$, M! E"$&%J*I &%#% @!R!&!, #*' H! H+"&-
#A+= '%$?"& " &"E!&"I &'!@', *#$!&?%' D+!!', "-
R' !'$&!-
E&!&' +$' * #%" H+"&#A+!, "?A-
!#$" (H+"&#A+' E&?') $ D&<' "?!&!@! !H!!$*.
K!C%$" #$&+ D &+?' (%E!D$') !E%C"'
&#$!&?;;$A# H+' #'!#$"F!. C"!?AF H+ +,-
&#$!&?;I "+$&" !D'" E!C%$= #$&!+ ? H+"&
D *=*&' #$*C", @!R!&!-+%$!'* +*.
. .
276
+ #E?<*I &+?+* #*'* &+?* (%E!D$*) " =!&"
D ' E!C%$:
x * C"!?A"F &?;$", +M! @!R!&" +!R$ "FR?
&+?F (%E!D$F) =*!+ * C"!?A"F &?;$";
x * &?;$" &+?* (%E!D$*), +M! @!R!&" +!R$ "FR?
&+?F (%E!D$F) =*!+ & "!D%'"F &?;$", H!
*'!&= $ & E!+*, E%%H<%= !@!&!!', &"E!&"! ! D-
& &+?+ — & "R"F "!D%'"F < & C"!?A"F &?;$";
x * H+"&#A+= '%$?=, +M! &+?F (%E!D$F) =*!+
&"+$F * H+"&#A+= '%$?=, H! *'!&= $ & E!+*, E%-
%H<%= !@!&!!', &"E!&"! ! D& &+?+ — * C"-
!?A"F &?;$".
K!C%$ &+? (%E!D$), D?*<%F &"E!&"! ! !@!-
&!* H+"&#A+!@! &+?* (%E!D$*), +M! "R% % E%%H<%!
!@!&!!', =!&*;$A# &" , #$*E!@! D %' =!-
J% ! H+* @!R!&= +!R$"& H! H+"&#A+= '%$?"&, !
, +F E%%*I E!&%%; @!R!&= +!R$"& H! H+"&#A+=
'%$?"& &+?+* H! #E#; D &+?!@! (%E!D$!@!) -
=*+* &+?+ D "R= E"#$&.
#!H?&!#$" D?*<% @!R!&= +!R$"& H! H+"&#A+= '%-
$?"& &+? (%E!D$) %@*?;;$A# &*$"R"' E!?!J%-
' H+"&, !D!H?%' &"E!&"! ! D+!!&#$& +,.
+ ';$A &#$!&?;&$ !#!&" *'!& D?*<% H+"&-
#A+!@! &+?* (%E!D$*) &"E!&"!@! &*. TD<%" *'!&
';$A H*$ !E?;%" H+!' R?=!' !D'"M% &"E!&"!,
"!'C", & *#$!&" H+* & D@?A!!#$*E!'* ? +?"I$"&
'"#C". "!'C" '!J% !$+!&! !D'"M*&$# H+!' *
D#!H= '#!&!, "!'C",.
!R!&" +!R$ &+?" (%E!D$") =*+ E%%=!&*;$A#
;<' !#!H' D E!$!<= =*+"& " E!&%$;$A# H+'
& H%D@!$"&+!&"F !'" E!$!<" =*+ ;<= !#"H.
+ '!J*$A E%%=!&*&$ @!R!&" +!R$ &+?F
(%E!D$F) =*!+ ;<!, !#!H D ,, "R!@! &+?!@!
(%E!D$!@!) =*+*, &"+$!@! & CA!'* H+*, ?R% & D"
D'" H+!' E!+* H*=@?$%#A+!@! !H?"+* =*+* ;<-
!, !#!H, E!&’D!, "D:
i DE!&J%' H+!' E!C%* D'" =*+"& +?"I$"&
% D ,= ""C"$&!;, * &E+= $ & E!+*, &D<%= !'-
$&!-E&!&' +$' C"!?A!@! H+* +,;
i D'"!; *'!& !@!&!* H+"&#A+!@! &+?* (%E!D$*).
=!&" E!C%$ D &+?' (%E!D$') ;<=
!#"H &"E!&"! ! *'!& !@!&!* H+"&#A+!@! &+?* (%E!D$*)
277
H+ '!J*$A E%%=!&*&$ E!$!<F =*!+ ;<!,
!#!H H! D=!&*&$ E!E!&% &+?* (%E!D$*).
K!&%% !D=*+!&= !E%C"F D &+?' (%E!D$-
') =*+' ;<!, !#!H DH!!I$A#, +"' !E%C"F,
E!&’D= D %?"DC"I; 'F!&= E& #*'* &+?* (%E!D-
$*) &"E!&"! ! *+?%= !@!&!"& D#$& $ D+!!&#$&
+,.
!R!&" +!R$ &+?" (%E!D$") =*+ "D<= !#"H
'!J*$A H*$ &%#%" @!$"&+!;, E%%=!&" D "R!@! &+?!@!
(%E!D$!@!) =*+* H! E!$!<!@! =*+* " E!&%$;$A# H-
+' @!$"&+!; H! & H%D@!$"&+!&"F !'" DD<%F * !@!-
&!" =*!+ &+?+ ? E!&%% +!R$"& < D D&!;
&+?+ "RF F!@! =*!+. + '!J*$A &"E!&"! !
*'!& !@!&!* H+"&#A+!@! &+?* (%E!D$*) E%%=!&*&$
"D<' !#!H' =!&" E!C%$ D &+?' (%E!D$')
,= E!$!<F =*!+, ? E!E!&% &+?* (%E!D$*) H!
&&$ @!$"&+!;.
+ E!&%$;$A &+? (%E!D$) $ #E?<*;$A =!&"
E!C%$ * #$!+, M! &D<%" *'!&' !@!&!* H+"&#A+!@!
&+?* (%E!D$*) '"J &+?+!' " H+!'.
T !@!&!!' H+"&#A+!@! &+?* (%E!D$*) %D?%J! &"
F!@! &* H+ D!H!&’DF &$ &+? H! F!@! <#$*
E%R* &'!@* &+?+, +"' &+?"&, !D'"M%= ;<'
!#!H' "R= *'!&= E!&%%, +" &#$!&?%" !@!&!!'.
+ &E?<*I &+?+!&" E!C%$ #*'* &+?* (%E!D-
$*) * !D'"", +F *#$!&?;I$A# & !@!&!" H+"&#A+!@! &+?-
* (%E!D$*). [+M! !@!&!!' % &#$!&?%F !D'" E!C%-
$"&, $! H+ D!H!&’DF &E?$$ ,= & !D'"" !H?"+!&!, #$&+
C"!?A!@! H+* +,.
+ 'I E&! D'"$ !D'" E!C%$"&, +" &E?<*;$A#
&+? (%E!D$) &'!@*, +M! "R% % &#$!&?%! !@!&!!'.
D" D'%R% H+!' !D'"* E!C%$"& &+? (%E!D$)
&'!@* !&F !D'" E!C%$"& D#$!#!&*I$A# ! &+?* (%-
E!D$*), &%#%!@! ! E!&"!'?% &+?+ E! D'%R%
E!C%$"&, <%%D ! '"#CA D <#* #? &"E!&"!@! E!-
&"!'?%, +M! "R% % &#$!&?%! !@!&!!'.
#$!&?%F H+!' &"E!&"! ! !@!&!* H+"&#A+!@!
&+?* (%E!D$*) !D'" E!C%$"& &+? (%E!D$) #$!+
H! &+? (%E!D$), &%#%F *'!&= F!@! E!&%% &
D" #$ &D<%= !@!&!!' !H#$&, % '!J% H*$ !-
!#$!!A! D'%R%F H+!', +M! "R% % &#$!&?%! D+!-
!&#$&!' +,.
. .
278
K!C%$ H+"&#A+F &+? (%E!D$) &E?<*;$A# &+?-
+!&" F!@! &'!@* &"E!&"! ! #$!+"&, &D<%= * !-
@!&!" H+"&#A+!@! &+?* (%E!D$*).
[+M! &"E!&"! ! !@!&!* H+"&#A+!@! &+?* (%E!D$*)
&+? E!&%$I$A# &+?+!&" F!@! &'!@* ! D+"<%
#$!+* H! ! #$ "R= !H#$&, &D<%= !@!&!!',
E!C%$ D C' &+?!' &E?<*;$A# & !D'"" E!C%$"& D
&+?' &'!@*, +M! !@!&!!' % &#$!&?%F &MF
E!C%$.
[+M! &+?+ % &'@I E!&%% #*' #$!+!&!@! &+?-
* (%E!D$*) "D D+"<%' #$!+*, *#$!&?%!@! !@!&!!'
H+"&#A+!@! &+?*, H! E!&%% #*' &+?* (%E!D$*),
&%#%!@! "R= *'!&= E!&%%, $! E"#? #$ &D-
<%= !@!&!!' !H#$& !@!&" *&JI$A# E!!&J%'
*'!&= &+?* &'!@*, +M! "R% % &#$!&?%! !@!&!!'.
E!$+*& !=!"& &" &+?= (%E!D$=) !E%C"F
;<= $ "D<= !#"H D"F#;I$A# &"E!&"! ! D+!!-
&#$& +,.
§ 4. + $
#$%' @$*& &+?"& "D<= !#"H &D<%
* T+!" +, «K! ! @$*& &+?"& "D<=
!#"H». "E!&"! ! CA!@! T+!* L! @$*& &+?"& "-
D<= !#"H &"R+!!&*I &+?, !D'"M%" =*+=, M! %
&+!#$!&*;$A# &+?+!' ? D"F#% E"EI'CA+!,
"?A!#$".
"E!&"! ! #$$$" 87 T+!* +, «K! H+ " H+"&-
#A+* "?A"#$A» C"!?AF H+ +, D!H!&’DF E!$-
@!' &!= "& E"#? EF$$ "R% E! ?"+&"C"; H+* E!-
&"!'$ E! C% L! @$*& &+?"& "D<= !#"H. D"
!#+J% & #*!&!'* E!+* "R% C"!?A!@! H+*
E! ?"+&"C"; H+* C"!?AF H+ +, E!&"!'?I E!
C% L! @$*& &+?"& "D<= !#"H.
"E!&"! ! #$$$" 96 T+!* +, «K! H+ " H+"&-
#A+* "?A"#$A» &'!@ L!* @$*& &+?"& "D<=
!#"H, M! &+? * &E+=, &D<%= D+!!&#$&!' E! @-
$*& &+?"& "D<= !#"H, D!&!?A;$A# * E%R* <%-
@*. *@* <%@* D!&!?A;$A# &'!@ &+?+"& — "D<-
279
= !#"H & <#$" E%%&M% #*', E%%H<%!, ##$%'!; @-
$*& &+?"& "D<= !#"H, &'!@, M! &+? "D D!-
H!&’DA H+* E%% EC"&+'.
"E!&"! ! #$$$" 42 T+!* +, «K! C"!?AF
H+ +,» (?" T+!) C"!?AF H+ +, I
+%$ L!* @$*& &+?"& "D<= !#"H E" D#$&*
C"= EE%"& D C"!; % J<% "%+#* "?C", $%'"!' 5
!+"&.
T@"! D" #$$$%; 2 T+!* «K! ! @$*& &+?"&
"D<= !#"H» *<#+' L!* @$*& &+?"& "D<-
= !#"H (?" — L!) I H+ — ;<" !#!H, +" D%I#$-
!&" & %J&!'* %I#$" H+"&, +F &%%$A# C"!?A'
H+!' +,, $ ';$A H+"&#A+* ?"C%D"; E&! D"F#;-
&$ H+"&#A+* "?A"#$A. <#$A * L!" DD<%= H+"& I
!H!&’D+!&!;.
<#+ L!* D!H!&’D" #E?<*&$ DH! ! L!*.
<#+!' L!* I H+, +F &+!*I &#$!&?%" C"!-
?A' H+!' +, %+!!'"<" !'$& M!! !#$$!#$"
+E"$?* " E?$!#E!'!J!#$" $ '!J% &+!*&$ #&!, D!-
H!&’D E%% &+?+'.
+ — *<#+ L!*, +" % &+!*;$A &#$!&?%=
C"!?A' H+!' +, %+!!'"<= !'$&"& M!! !-
#$$!#$" +E"$?*, E?$!#E!'!J!#$" $/H! +' D "R%'
C"!?A!@! H+* +, D*E%! "; H+"&#A+!, ?"C%D",
C"!?A!@! H+* +, D"F#% H+"&#A+!, "?A!-
#$", E%%&!$A# D "R%' '""#$$&!, L!*, E-
F$' E"#$&" "!'C", C"!?A!@! H+* +,,
!%J!, D %D*?A$$' '!"$!@* "?A!#$" H+"&, ! +-
$%@!", $'<#!&= *<#+"& L!*.
K"#? E%%&%% ! +$%@!", $'<#!&= *<#+"& L!*
H+, &+? "D<= !#"H ! +!@! D?*<%" ! F!@! E%%&%-
% ! C"I, +$%@!",, D!H!&’DF #E?<*&$ DH! ! L!*
! E!&!@! &+! D!H!&’DA E%% &+?+' E! &E?$"
,="= &+?"& $ =!&= &"#!$+"&.
D" &"+?+ H+"&#A+!, ?"C%D", C"!?A!@! H+*
+, D"F#% H+"&#A+!, "?A!#$" '""#$$&
L!* D E!' C"!?A!@! H+* +, EF'I
"R% E! &+?;<% CA!@! H+* D <#? *<#+"& ($'<-
#!&= *<#+"&) L!*.
+?;<% H+* D <#? *<#+"& ($'<#!&= *<#+"&)
L!* % E!DH&?I &+?+"&, &+? += H*? D?*<%" !
&+?;<% F!@! D <#? *<#+"& ($'<#!&= *<#+"&)
. .
280
L!*, E& &"R+!*& $+= &+?"& * D" #$ ,=
%!#$*E!#$" &"E!&"! ! T+!*.
T@"! D" #$$$%; 3 T+!* L! @$*I +!J!'* &+?+*
H+* — *<#+ ($'<#!&!@! *<#+) L!* &"R+!*&
+!R$"& D F!@! &+?', &+?;<;< &"#!$+, & !D'"" &+?"&
%A #$ %!#$*E!#$" &+?"&, ?% % H"?AR% 1200 @-
&%A E! &+?= * +!J!'* "D $+= H+"&. TD<%F !D'" &"-
R+!*& +!R$"& D &+?', &+?;<;< &"#!$+, D =*-
!+ +!R$"& L!* '!J% H*$ DH"?AR%! D "R%'
'""#$$&!, L!* D?%J! &" $%%C"F !D&$+* -
+* %#*#"&, D?*<%= &" &+?+"& H+' — *<#+'
($'<#!&' *<#+') L!*.
D" !D'"M% &+?+!' & !!'* H+* — *<#+*
($'<#!&!'* *<#+*) L!* +"?A+!= &+?"& L! @$*I
&"R+!*& +!R$"& D $+' &+?', &+?;<;< &"#!$+,
* !D'"" D@?A!, #*' &+?"& D #$!' %A #$ %-
!#$*E!#$" &+?"&, ?% % H"?AR% !D'"*, &#$!&?%!@! &"E!-
&"! ! <#$ E%R!, #$$$" 3 T+!* «K! L! @$*&
&+?"& "D<= !#"H».
[+M! &+?+ 'I &+? * +"?A+!= H+= — *<#+=
($'<#!&= *<#+=) L!*, +" & E!?AR!'* %!@"D*&-
?# R?=!' ,= D?$$, EI H! E%%$&!% & ! H+
— ;<* !#!H*, L! @$*I &"R+!*& +!R$"& D C-
' &+?' ! D+"<% #$!+* ", !@!&!"& D C' &+?'
$= #'= *'!&=, M! F ! %!@"DC",. +?, D?*<%" E"#-
? %!@"DC", H+"& — *<#+"& ($'<#!&= *<#+"&) L!-
*, @$*;$A# L!!' * D@?A"F #*'", ?% % H"?AR% !D'"-
*, &#$!&?%!@! &"E!&"! ! <#$ E%R!, #$$$" T+!*.
+?, !D'" += #$!&$A '%R% 1 @&", % E"?@;$A
&"R+!*&;.
"R+!*& &+?"& & "!D%'"F &?;$" &"H*&I$A# * -
C"!?A"F &?;$" +, E"#? E%%=*& #*' &+?* D
!"C"F' (!H'"') +*#!' C"!?A!@! H+* +,
%A #$ %!#$*E!#$" &+?"&.
T&%$I'! *&@*, M! * #$$$" 4 T+!* &#$!&?%" !H'%J%
@$", &+?"&. +, D@"! D C"I; #$$$%; L! % &"R+!!&*I
@$!&* #*'* D &+?', !D'"M%':
1) <?%' @?!&!, , %+$!"& " %&"D"F!, +!'"-
#", H+*, &+? & +!'* I %!#$*E';
2) EC"&+' %D?%J= *$!#A+= "' (*$!'),
+" D"F#;&? *$!#A+" E%%&"+ H+* E!$@!' !#$"=
$A!= !+"&;