Ващенко Ю.В. Банківське право
Подождите немного. Документ загружается.
291
+,", E$'" E%&" !H'%J%. =!&*;< E@%
+, ! #&"$!&= #$$"& %+!!'"+, %+!!'"<* E!?"$+* &
C"?!'* $ &?;$* E!?"$+* D!+%' R %J& E!& E!-
&!$, &=!< "D '"J!= ECE"& * DD<%"F #%".
22 ?E 1944 ., "J!"F &?;$!-"#!&"F +!%-
%C", H’I= C"F * %$$!-*#" () H*?! *=&?%!
"R% E! #$&!% "J!!@! &?;$!@! !* (L).
#!&" ECE &?;$!@! %@*?;& D+"E?%" * $$*$"
L, +F H& <!#$" 27 @* 1945 . #A!@!" L —
E!&" '"J! &?;$!-+%$ !@"DC", + D 1947 .
'I #$$*# #E%C"?"D!&!, *#$!& . T <?%#A+' #+?!'
L I @?!H?A!; '"J!!; !@"DC"I;, & "?A!#$" +!,
H%% *<#$A E%%&J +"?A+"#$A +, #&"$*. 1950 . <?%'
L H*? 49 %J&, E!<$+* UU #$. — 184 %J&. +-
, H*? <?%#$& & L 3 &%%# 1992 . #!&" D&
L — #$H"?"DC" &?;$= +*#"&, #E +!&%$!&!#$"
&?;$, +,'-<?%' +%$"& ? &%@*?;& %"-
C$"& E?$"J= H?#"&, *#$!&?% '"J ' H@$!#$!!-
A!, ##$%' E?$%J"& D E!$!<' !E%C"', +!#*-
?A$$&!, !E!'!@ D "#!&= $ &?;$= E$A, &E*#+
#E%C"?A= E& DE!D<%A (KT)
153
.
T +?#"+C"I; L, " * #&"$" E+$+*;$A E’$A !#!&-
= $E"& &?;$= %J'"&: +*#, "+#!&F M!! !"I, &-
?;$; "+#!&F M!! +!R+ &?;$; D !H'%J%!; @*<+"#$;; D
+%!&!; @*<+"#$;; %D?%J! E?&;<F +*#. +,, + "
H"?AR"#$A %J& , &=!$A ! @*E +, "D +%!&'
E?&;<' +*#'.
?;$F +!$!?A — C% +!'E?%+# '""#$$&= D=!"&,
#E'!&= #$'*& &&%D% " #$'*?;& E!&%-
% &?;$= +!R$"& * +,*. ?;$F +!$!?A '!J% E!-
R;&$#A + &#" !E%C",, E%%H<%" E?$"J' H?#!'
+,, $+ " ,= <#$*. [+ E&?!, &" E!R;I$A# *=
+E"$?"& ? D=#$* #$H"?A!#$" @!R!&!, ##$%' $ &?;$=
%D%&"& * E%"! %!'*& %+!!'"+ " I !' "D %-
&"’I'= %?%'%$"& E%%="!, %+!!'"<!, E!?"$+. ?;$F
+!$!?A + "#$*'%$ #$H"?"DC", *=* +E"$?"& * '?= &"+-
$= %+!!'"+= !H'%J*I +!?& E!C%$= #$&!+ $ !H-
'"= +*#"&, !+ % H*% #!'!&! !D&*$* +!&* "-
#$*+$** " % #$% '!J?&' %@*?;&$ *= +E"$?"&,
153
> &. "J!F &?;$F !: <?%#A+F #+?, +&!$ // "#+
. — %%#%A, 2004. — . 44.
. .
292
&"$+ " '"+* !H'"!@! +*#* <%%D &E?& "&%A E!C%-
$= #$&!+.
H'%J*;< *= +E"$?"&, +, !$'*I '!J?&"#$A '%&-
* ? &#$!&?% E!C%$!, #$&+ & "$%%#= %?A!, %+!-
!'"+, % &+?;<! ? DH%DE%<% C"?%F +*#!&!, E!?"$+
H! D?%J! &" "& E!C%$= #$&!+ D +!!!'
154
.
K CA!'* %+!!'"#$ D&%$;$A *&@* $%, M! &?;$F +!-
$!?A 'I #%# $"?A+ $!", +!? E!&!$A# +!'E?%+#!: %%+$&-
"#$A +!$!?; D?%J$A &" '"C!#$" F!@! F#?HR!, ?+.
?;$F +!$!?A + $+F % '!J% D'"$ %+!!'"<*
E!?"$+* " DH%DE%<$ !&@!$%'"!&* #$H"?A"#$A !H'"!@!
+*#*. +!@! %D*?A$$* '!J !#@$ ?R% &" H;J%$=
E!@' $ E !#@%" +,!; D!&"RA!$!@!&%?A!, "&-
!&@. + &?;$F +!$!?A '!J% DD$ D+ #E%+*?-
$&= $+ E!$ C"!?A!, &?;$ $ &"E!&"! — %&?A-
&C",. +#*& &?;$!@! +!$!?; #$!,$A !#$"' * #E#+*
D=!"& ?"H%?"DC", " 'I &"H*$# E"#? #$&!% *'!&, +!?
C"!?A" +!E<% '!J H*% *$'$ &#%%" +,
D !E!'!@!; #*<#= +!+*%$!#E!'!J= "#!&= '%-
="D'"&. "RA!'* %$E" %+!!'"<!@! !D&$+* +,"
#?" % #+#!&*&$ ##$%'* &?;$!@! +!$!?;, &!#+!?;-
&$ F!@! !'
155
.
#!&" D# &?;$!@! %@*?;& $ &?;$!@! +!$!-
?; D+"E?%" + & +$= D@?A!@! D+!!&#$&, $+ " & +$=
#E%C"?A!@! D+!!&#$& +,.
"E!&"! ! #$$$" 92 !#$$*C", +, &+?;<! D+!-
' +, &#$!&?;I$A# #$$*# C"!?A!, &?;$, $-
+!J #$$*# "!D%'= &?;$ $%$!", +,. T@"! "D #$$-
$%; 10 !#E!#A+!@! +!%+#* +, &?;$ E!?"$+ I
!' "D !#!&= E'+"& %+!!'"<!, E!?"$+ +,, M!
#E'!& &#$!&?% " E"$' E$%$!@! +*#*
C"!?A!, &?;$ M!! "!D%'= &?;$, #$'*?;& D!#-
$ %J&= &?;$= %D%&"& $ ,= %%+$&% &+!#$-
. "E!&"! ! #$$$" 19 CA!@! +!%+#* !"I; "D #%, * +=
D"F#;I$A# %J&F +!$!?A $ @?, I #% &?;$!@!
%@*?;&; '%$!; CA!@! +!$!?; I DH%DE%<% !$'
&?;$!@! D+!!&#$&.
%J' D"F#% &?;$= !E%C"F $%$!", +,,
D@?A" ECE &?;$!@! %@*?;&, E!&!&J% %-
154
D !. #!H?&!#$" &?;$!@! %@*?;& & +," // "#+ . —
&%A 1999. — . 22—24. — . 23.
155
' #'!. — . 24.
293
J&= !@"& " *+C", H+"& $ "R= +%$!-"#!&=
*#$!& +, & %@*?;&" &?;$= !E%C"F, E& F
!H!&’D+ #*H’I+$"& &?;$= &"!#, E!!+ D"F#% &-
?;$!@! +!$!?;, &"E!&"?A"#$A D E!*R% &?;$!@! D-
+!!&#$& &#$!&?%" %+%$!' H"%$* ""#$"& +,
«K! ##$%'* &?;$!@! %@*?;& " &?;$!@! +!$!?;»
&" 19 ?;$!@! 1993 . - 15-93 (?" — %+%$).
?" DD<$, M! <' D+!!&#$&!' +, % I$A-
# &D<% E!$A «&?;$% %@*?;&» $ «&?;$F +!-
$!?A». K!$% * %+%$" &D<%" !@, *E!&!&J%" D"F#-
;&$ &?;$% %@*?;&, $ ,=" E!&!&J%. T@"! D
!'' %+%$* !@, +" D"F#;;$A &?;$% %@*?;&:
i H"%$ ""#$"& +,;
i C"!?AF H+ +,.
K!&!&J% DD<%= !@"& D+"E?%" * #$$$" 11 %+%$*.
"E!&"! ! C"I, #$$$" H"%$ ""#$"& +, 'I $+"
E!&!&J% * #%" &?;$!@! %@*?;&:
x &D<I " E!I D$&%J% ! %=!&!, +,-
?"'"$ D!&"RA!@! %J&!@! H!@* +,;
x H%% *<#$A * #+?" E?$"J!@! H?#* +,;
x DH%DE%<*I &+! H;J%$!, $ E!$+!&!, E!?"$+ &
<#$", M! #$!#*I$A# *=* &?;$= C"!#$%F;
x DH%DE%<*I !'*& " &#$*EI !DE!+!' %J&-
!@! &?;$!@! !* +, D@"! "D #$$$%; 14 %+%$*;
x &D<I E!!+ &+!#$ =!J%A * '"J!=
!D=*+!&= (+?"@!&=) !C=, +" &+!#$!&*;$A# *
$!@!&%?A!'* !H!!$" D "!D%'' %J&', $+!J * %+!-
&%$!&= "!D%'= &?;$=, +" &+!#$!&*;$A# * %$!-
@!&%?A!'* !H!!$" D "!D%'' %J&' E"#$&" E!?!-
J%A '"J!= !@!&!"& +,.
C"!?AF H+ +, * #%" &?;$!@! %@*?;&:
i D"F#;I &?;$* E!?"$+*, &=!< D ECE"& D@?A!,
%+!!'"<!, E!?"$+ +,;
i #+?I D!' D H"%$!' ""#$"& +, E?$"JF H-
?# +,;
i +!$!?;I !$' D$&%J%!@! %=!&!; !;
+, ?"'"$* D!&"RA!@!
%J&!@! H!@* +,;
i &D<I * D" %!H="!#$" ?"'"$ DH!@!&!#$" & "!D%'-
"F &?;$" *E!&!&J%= H+"& %%D%$';
i &I * '%J=, E%%H<%= %+%$!', !H!&’D+!&" ? &-
+! !'$&" +$ M!! D"F#% !E%C"F &?;$!-
'* +* +,;
. .
294
i @!'J*I, DH%"@I " &+!#$!&*I %D%& &?;$=
C"!#$%F ? D"F#% %J&!, &?;$!, E!?"$+;
i &I ?"C%D", D"F#% &?;$= !E%C"F $ EF'I
"R% E! ,= #+#*&;
i *#$!&?;I #E!#!H &D<% " &+!#$ &?;$= (!H-
'"=) +*#"& "!D%'= &?;$, &J%= * &?;$" +,, +*-
#"& &?;$= C"!#$%F, &J%= * "!D%'"F &?;$" H! !D=*-
+!&= (+?"@!&=) !C=, D@"! "D #$$$%; 8 %+%$*;
i *#$!&?;I D E!@!J%' D ""#$%#$&!' #$$#$+ +,-
I" !' !H?"+*, D&"$!#$" $ !+*'%$C", E! &?;$" !E%-
C",, E!!+ +!$!?; D ,= !#$!&""#$; $ #&!I<#' E!';
i DH%DE%<*I E*H?"+C"; H+"&#A+= D&"$"& E! &?#" !E%C",
$ !E%C", *E!&!&J%= H+"&.
K!&!&J% C"!?A!@! H+* +, & #%" &?;$!-
@! %@*?;&, H%D*'!&!, D+"E?%" $+!J * T+!" +,
«K! C"!?AF H+ +,». +, &"E!&"! ! E*+$* 14
<#$ 1 #$$$" 7 T+!* C"!?AF H+ D"F#;I &"E!&"-
! ! &D<%= #E%C"?A' D+!!' E!&!&J%A &?;$% %-
@*?;&, &D<I E!!+ D"F#% !E%C"F & "!D%'"F
&?;$"; !@"D!&*I " D"F#;I &?;$F +!$!?A D H+' $
"R' "#!&' *#$!&', +" !$'? ?"C%D"; C"!-
?A!@! H+* D"F#% &?;$= !E%C"F.
K!&!&J% C"!?A!@! H+* +, * DD<%"F
#%" D+"E?%" * #$$$" 44 T+!* +, «K! C"!?AF
H+ +,». T@"! D C"I; #$$$%; C"!?AF H+ "I +
*E!&!&J% %J& *#$!& E D#$!#*&" D+!!&#$&
+, E! &?;$% %@*?;& " &?;$F +!$!?A.
! +!'E%$%C", C"!?A!@! H+* * #%" &?;$!@! %@*-
?;& $ +!$!?; ?%J$A:
1) & !'$&!-E&!&= +$"& M!! &%% &?;$-
= !E%C"F;
2) &< $ &"+?+ ?"C%D"F, D"F#% +!$!?;, * $!-
'* <#?" R?=!' D"F#% E?!&= " E!DE?!&= E%%&"!+,
D "?A"#$; H+"&, ;<= $ "D<= !#"H (%D%$"& $
%%D%$"&), +" !$'?
?"C%D"; C"!?A!@! H+*
D"F#% &?;$= !E%C"F, & <#$" !$' ' &?;-
$!@! D+!!&#$&;
3) &#$!&?% ?"'"$"& &"+$!, &?;$!, E!DC", ? H+"&
$ "R= *#$!&, M! +*E*;$A $ E!;$A "!D%'* &?;$*;
4) D#$!#!&*& '" &"E!&"?A!#$" ! H+"&, ;<= "
"D<= !#"H (%D%$"& $ %%D%$"&) D E!*R% E&?
&?;$!@! %@*?;& F &?;$!@! +!$!?;.
295
"E!&"! ! #$$$" 45 CA!@! T+!* C"!?AF H+ &-
D<I #$*+$** &?;$!@! +* +, $ !@"D!&*I $!@"-
&?; &?;$' C"!#$' A!'* &"E!&"! ! D+!!&#$-
& +, E! &?;$% %@*?;&.
T@"! "D #$$$%; 46 T+!* +, «K! C"!?AF H+
+,» C"!?AF H+ E!&!$A #+!$* $ %&"D* &-
?;$* E!?"$+* " D#$!#!&*I & %!H="= &E+= &?;$" !H-
'%J%. C"!?AF H+ D"F#;I #+!$* &?;$* E!?"-
$+*, D'";;< !H?"+!&* #$&+* C"!?A!@! H+* ?
%@*?;& *=* +E"$?* $ H?#*& E?$"J= D!-
H!&’DA, $+!J +!@*& +*#* @!R!&!, !C" +,
! "!D%'= &?;$.
C"!?AF H+ D"F#;I %&"D* &?;$* E!?"$+* E"-
#$&" %@*?;& +*#* @!R!&!, !C" +, ! "!D%'=
&?;$ R?=!' +*E"&?" $ E!J* "!D%'!, &?;$ "#!-
&= +=.
"E!&"! ! #$$$" 47 T+!* +, «K! C"!?AF
H+ +,» ? DH%DE%<% &*$"RA!, " D!&"RA!, #$H"-
?A!#$" @!R!&!, !C" +, C"!?AF H+ 'I D!?!-
$!&?;$F %D%&, M! #+?I$A# D $+= +$&"&:
x '!%$% D!?!$!;
x #E%C"?A" E& DE!D<%;
x
%D%& E!DC" & L;
x "!D%' &?;$ * &@?" H+!$ $ '!%$ H! +!R$
=*+= D +!!!';
x C"" EE% (+"' +C"F), M! !E?<*;$A# & "!D%'"F &-
?;$";
x H*A-+" "R" '"J!! &D" %D%&" +$& D *'!&
DH%DE%<% ,= "F!#$" $ ?"+&"!#$".
T@"! D" #$$$%; 48 &+D!@! T+!* E!E!&% D!?!$!&-
?;$= %D%&"& E!&!$A# C"!?A' H+!' R?=!':
1) +*E"&?" '!%$!@! D!?!$ $ "!D%'!, &?;$;
2) !$' !=!"& &" !E%C"F D "!D%'!; &?;$!;, H-
+"&#A+' '%$?' $ "R' '"J!! &D' %D%&-
' +$&';
3) D?*<% C"!?A' H+!' &?;$= +!R$"& &" '"J-
!= "#!&= !@"DC"F, C%$?A= H+"& "!D%'=
%J& $ "R= +%$!"&.
+!#$ D!?!$!&?;$!@!
%D%&* D"F#;I$A# C"!-
?A' H+!' $+" C"?":
1) E!J &?;$ "#!&= += ? E!&%% @!-
R!&!-+%$!, E!?"$+, &+?;<;< E!?"$+* !H'"!@! +*#*;
. .
296
2) &$$ E! !E%C"= D "!D%'!; &?;$!;, '!%$'
'%$?', $+!J "R' '"J!! &D' %D%&'
+$&'.
% !E*#+I$A# &+!#$ D!?!$!&?;$!@! %D%&* ?
+%$"& " @$"F $ "R= D!H!&’DA %D%$' "
%%D%$' +,.
"E!&"! ! #$$$" 49 DD<%!@! T+!* C"!?AF
H+ I DH%"@<%' %J&!@! D!?!$!@! DE#*, $+!J !!@!-
C"= '%$?"&, !!@!C"= +'%"&, "R= +!R$!&!#$%F.
% &?;$!@! +!$!?; &D<% * #$$$" 12 %+%$*. "-
E!&"! ! C"I, #$$$" &?;$" !E%C", D *<#$; %D%$"& "
%%D%$"& E"?@;$A &?;$!'* +!$!?;. ?;$!'* +!$-
!?; E"?@;$A $+!J D!H!&’D M!! %+?*& &?;$-
= C"!#$%F $ "R!@! 'F, +" &E?&;$A D E*+$* 1 #$$$"
9 %+%$*. @, M! D"F#;;$A &?;$F +!$!?A, ';$A
E&! &'@$ " !%J*&$ &" %D%$"& " %%D%$"& E!&*
"!'C"; E! D"F#% ' &?;$= !E%C"F, #$ H-
+"&#A+= =*+"& & "!D%'"F &?;$" * '%J= E!&!&J%A, &-
D<%= #$$$%; 13 %+%$*, $+!J E! 'F!, M! E"?@I %-
+?*&; D@"! D E*+$!' 1 #$$$" 9 %+%$*.
T@"! D" #$$$%; 13 %+%$* C"!?AF H+ +, I @!-
?!&' !@!' &?;$!@! +!$!?;, M!:
x D"F#;I +!$!?A D &+!' E&? %@*?;& &-
?;$= !E%C"F $%$!", +, D *#"= E$A, % &"%#%-
= %+%$!' ! +!'E%$%C", "R= %J&= !@"&;
x DH%DE%<*I &+! *E!&!&J%' H+' *+C"F
M!! D"F#% &?;$!@! +!$!?; D@"! D %+%$!' $ "-
R' +$' &?;$!@! D+!!&#$& +,.
E!&!&J%" H+ D"F#;;$A +!$!?A D &?;$' !E%-
C"', M! E!&$A# %D%$' " %%D%$' <%%D C"
H+. ! I @%$' &?;$!@! +!$!?;.
%J& E!$+!& "#E%+C" +, D"F#;I "#!&F
+!$!?A D &?;$' !E%C"', M! E!&$A# %D%$'
" %%D%$' $%$!", +,.
""#$%#$&! D&’D+* +, D"F#;I +!$!?A D !%-
J'
E&? E!R$!&= E%%+D"& $ E%%#? &?;$=
C"!#$%F <%%D '$F +!! +,.
%J&F '$F +!'"$%$ +, D"F#;I +!$!?A D !-
%J' E&? E%%'"M% &?;$= C"!#$%F <%%D '$-
F +!! +,.
+' <!', &?;$% %@*?;& '!J &D<$, + *%-
@*?A!&* !'' D+!!&#$& "?A"#$A *E!&!&J%= !-
297
@"& %J&, #E'!&* &#$!&?% E!+* D"F#%
&?;$= !E%C"F %D%$' $ %%D%$' $%$!",
+,, $+!J %D%$' +, D +!!!', &?;$F
+!$!?A — + "?A"#$A *E!&!&J%= !@"& %J&!, &?-
, "R= *E!&!&J%= #*H’I+$"&, #E'!&* DH%DE%<%
!$' &#$!&?%!@! E!+* D"F#% &?;$= !E%C"F.
§ 2. 6% %
[+ ' &J% D’#*&?, &?;$!'* %@*?;&; $ &-
?;$!'* +!$!?; E"?@;$A #'% &?;$" !E%C",, $!H$!,
!E%C",, !H’I+$!' += &#$*E;$A &?;$" C"!#$". $J%, %-
!H="! D’#*&$, M! #'% !D*'"I D+!!&%CA E" &?;$'
C"!#$'.
"E!&"! ! #$$$" 1 %+%$* ! +$%@!", &?;$= C"!#-
$%F &"!#$A#:
x &?;$ +, — @!R!&" D+ * &@?" H+!$"&, +D-
<%F#A+= H"?%$"&, '!%$ " & "R= !'=, M! E%%H*&;$A &
!H"@* $ I D+!' E?$"J' D#!H!' $%$!", +,,
$+!J &?*<%" D !H"@* H! $+", M! &?*<;$A# D A!@!, ?% E"-
?@;$A !H'"!&" @!R!&" D+, +" E%%H*&;$A & !H"@*, +!-
R$ =*+=, * &%#+= & H+"&#A+= $ "R= +%$!-
"#!&= *#$!&= $%$!", +,;
x E?$"J" !+*'%$ $ "R" C"" EE% (+C",, !H?"@C",, +*-
E! ! =, H!, &%+#%?" ($$$), H!@!&" !DE#+, +%$&,
<%+, H+"&#A+" +D, %E!D$" #%$"+$, !M" +J+, "-
R" "#!&" $ H+"&#A+" !+*'%$), &J%" * &?;$" +,;
x "!D%' &?;$ — "!D%'" @!R!&" D+ * &@?" H+-
!$"&, +D<%F#A+= H"?%$"&, '!%$, M! E%%H*&;$A & !H"@* $ I
D+!' E?$"J' D#!H!' $%$!", &"E!&"!, "!D%'!,
%J&, $+!J &?*<%" D !H"@* H! $+", M! &?*<;$A# D
A!@!, ?% E"?@;$A !H'"!&" @!R!&" D+, +" E%%H*&-
;$A & !H"@*, +!R$ * @!R!&= !C= "!D%'= %J& " '"-
J!= !D=*+!&= (+?"@!&=) !C=, M! E%%H*-
&;$A =*+= H! &!#$A# ! H+"&#A+= $ "R=
+%$!-"#!&= *#$!& D '%J' +,;
x E?$"J" !+*'%$ $ "R" C"" EE% (+C",, !H?"@C",,
+*E! ! =, &%+#%?" ($$$), H!@!&" !DE#+, +%$&,
<%+, H+"&#A+" +D, %E!D$" #%$"+$, "R" "#!&" $
. .
298
H+"&#A+" !+*'%$), &J%" & "!D%'"F &?;$" H! H+"&#A-
+= '%$?=;
x H+"&#A+" '%$? — C% D!?!$!, #"H?!, E?$, '%$? E?-
$!&!, @*E, !&%%" ("!&") ! F&M= E!H &"E!&"!
! #&"$!&= #$$"&, * D?&+= " E!!R+=, M! ';$A #%$"-
+$ +!#$", $+!J '!%$, &!H?%" D !!@!C"= '%$?"&.
?" E"+%#?$, M! !H’I+$!' &?;$!@! +!$!?; '!J*$A
H*$ % H*A-+" !E%C", D &?;$' C"!#$', #'% $", +"
<"$+! &D<%" * %+%$" H"%$* ""#$"& +, «K! ##-
$%'* &?;$!@! %@*?;& " &?;$!@! +!$!?;». T@"! D
C' !'$&!-E&!&' +$!' ! &?;$= !E%C"F &"!-
#$A#:
x !E%C",, E!&’D" D E%%=!!' E& &?#!#$" &?;$"
C"!#$", D &$+!' !E%C"F, M! D"F#;;$A# '"J %D%$-
' * &?;$" +,;
x !E%C",, E!&’D" D &+!#$' &?;$= C"!#$%F &
'"J!!'* !H"@* + D#!H* E?$%J*, D E%%&' DH!-
@!&!#$%F $ "R= D!H!&’DA, E%'%$!' += I &?;$"
C"!#$";
x !E%C",, E!&’D" D &&%D%', E%%+D*&' " E%%#-
?' $%$!"; +, $ &&%D%', E%%+D*&' "
E%%#?' D ,, '%J" &?;$= C"!#$%F.
§ 3. ( *
* $
H#@ E& $ !H!&’D+"& *<#+"& &?;$= E&!-
&"!# D?%J$A &" $!@!, I &! %D%$', < %%D%$-
' D &?;$' D+!!&#$&!' +,.
D<% E!$A «%D%$» $ «%%D%$» '"#$$A# *
E*+$" 5 #$$$" 1 %+%$* H"%$* ""#$"& +, «K! ##-
$%'* &?;$!@! %@*?;& " &?;$!@! +!$!?;». T@"! D
%+%$!' %D%$' I:
x "D<" !#!H (@!' +,, "!D%'" @!', !#!-
H H%D @!'#$&), +" ';$A E!#$"F% '"#C% E!J&
$%$!", +,, * $!'* <#?" $", M! $'<#!&! E%%H*&;$A D
+!!!';
x ;<" !#!H, #*H’I+$ E"EI'CA+!, "?A!#$", M!
% ';$A #$$*#* ;<!, !#!H ("?",, E%#$&C$& $!M!),
299
D '"#C%D=!J%' $%$!", +,, +" D"F#;;$A #&!;
"?A"#$A E"#$&" D+!"& +,;
x E?!'$<", +!#*?A#A+", $!@!&%?A" $ "R" !"C"F"
E%#$&C$& +, D +!!!', +" ';$A "'*"$%$ " E-
?!'$<" E&"?%,, $+!J "?", $ E%#$&C$& E"EI'#$&
" !@"DC"F +, D +!!!', M! % D"F#;;$A E"EI'-
CA+!, "?A!#$";
#&!; <%@*, ! %%D%$"& &"!#$A#:
i "D<" !#!H ("!D%'" @!', @!' +,, !#!-
H H%D @!'#$&), +" ';$A E!#$"F% '"#C% E!J& D
'%J' +,, & $!'* <#?" $", M! $'<#!&! E%%H*&;$A
$%$!", +,;
i ;<" !#!H, #*H’I+$ E"EI'CA+!, "?A!#$", M!
% ';$A #$$*#* ;<!, !#!H ("?",, E%#$&C$& $!M!),
D '"#C%D=!J%' D '%J' +,, +" #$&!%" F ";$A &"-
E!&"! ! D+!!&#$& "!D%'!, %J&, * $!'* <#?" ;-
<" !#!H $ "R" #*H’I+$ E"EI'CA+!, "?A!#$" D *<#-
$; ;<= !#"H $ "R= #*H’I+$"& E"EI'CA+!,
"?A!#$" +,;
i !D$R!&" $%$!", +, "!D%'" E?!'$<",
+!#*?A#A+", $!@!&%?A" $ "R" !"C"F" E%#$&C$&, '"J-
!" !@"DC", $ ,= "?",, M! ';$A "'*"$%$ " E?!'$<"
E&"?%,, $+!J E%#$&C$& "R= !@"DC"F " "', +" %
D"F#;;$A E"EI'CA+!, "?A!#$" E"#$&" D+!"& +-
,.
%!H="! DD<$, M! E+$C" $&?F <# "#*&?
E!H?%' E $?*'<%" DD<%!@! E!?!J% & <#$" &-
D<% %D%$!#$" E%#$&C$& "!D%'= ;<=
!#"H
& +,". %% #E%C"?"#$"& "#*&? $!<+ D!*, M! * &-
?;$!'* D+!!&#$&" +, ( &"'"* &" E!$+!&!@! D-
+!!&#$&) &D@?" % '"#$$A# E!$$ «E%#$&C$&! %%-
D%$"&», " +M! F!@! !D@?$ !+%'!, $! &D@?" &+?;-
<I$A# '!J?&"#$A D#$!#*& &?;$!@! D+!!&#$& !
E%#$&C$& %%D%$"& + * %@$&!'*, $+ " & E!D$&-
!'* E?"
156
. K!$%, H%D*'!&!, D $+!; E!DC"I; % '!J E!-
@!$#. "E!&"! ! D+!!&#$& +, (D!+%', #$$$
1 %+%$* H"%$* ""#$"& +, «K! ##$%'* &?;$!@!
%@*?;& " &?;$!@! +!$!?;», #$$$ 5 T+!* +,
«K! D!&"RA!%+!!'"<* "?A"#$A») & +," '!J*$A #$&!-
156
# . . "#$A D+!!&#$& & #%" &?;$!@! %@*?;& // +!!'"-
+. L"#. K&!. — 1996. — E. 2. — . 6—8.
. .
300
;&$# $+" & E%#$&C$& #*H’I+$"& E"EI'CA+!,
"?A!#$":
x E!#$"F" E%#$&C$&, <%%D +" % D"F#;I$A# E"EI-
'CA+ "?A"#$A E"#$&" D+!"& +,;
x E!#$"F" E%#$&C$&, <%%D +" E!&"#$; H! <#$+!&!
D"F#;I$A# E"EI'CA+ "?A"#$A E"#$&" D+!"&
+,
K!?"D*&&R E*+$ 5, 6 #$$$" 1 %+%$* H"%$* ""#-
$"& +, «K! ##$%'* &?;$!@! %@*?;& " &?;$!@!
+!$!?;», '!J D!H$ &#!&!+, M! +?#"+C" ;<-
= !#"H $ ,= E%#$&C$& %D%$"& $ %%D%$"& &"E!-
&"! ! D+!!&#$& +, D"F#;I$A# E"#$&" &!=
+$%",&:
i '"#C%D=!J% ( $%$!", +, < D ,, '%J');
i D"F#% E"EI'CA+!, "?A!#$" E"#$&" T+!"&
+, (D"F#;I$A# < ");
% !D<I, M! +M! E%#$&C$&! %%D%$ !D$R!&-
% $%$!", +,, $! &D<% F!@! %D%$!#$" D?%-
J$'% &" $!@!, < D"F#;I$A# <%%D A!@! E!&"#$; H! <#$-
+!&! E"EI'CA+ "?A"#$A E"#$&" D+!"& +,.
[+M! <%%D A!@! E!&"#$; H! <#$+!&! D"F#;I$A# E"EI'-
CA+ "?A"#$A E"#$&" D+!"& +,, $! C% E%#$&-
C$&!, &"!#$A# ! +$%@!", «%D%$», +M! ", $!, &"E!&"-
!, — ! +$%@!", «%%D%$».
[+M! E%#$&C$& %%D%$"& !D$R!&" D '%J'
+, " ";$A &"E!&"! ! D+!!&#$& "!D%'= %J&,
$! &! &"!#$A# ! +$%@!", «%%D%$».
§ 4. <* # $
' %"
"E!&"! ! #$$$" 5 %+%$* C"!?AF H+
+, &I # $ " '$ D"F#%-
&?;$= !E%C"F, +" E"E;$A E" %J' ?"C%D*&
D@"! D %+%$!'.
@ '$ &;$A# +!'%C"F' H+' $ "R'
+%$!-"#!&' *#$!&' +, D"F#% &?;$=
!E%C"F, M! % E!$%H*;$A "&"*?A!, ?"C%D",, &%#A E%"-
! ", %J'* &?;$!@! %@*?;&. E!&!&J%" H+ $