Ващенко Ю.В. Банківське право
Подождите немного. Документ загружается.
251
' H+', D %F$@!', % J<', "J «"&%#$C"FF
+?#»;
x E!&"F= #+?#A+= #&"!C$&, M! '"#$$A #+?#A+" #&"!-
C$& $ D#$&" #&"!C$&, D *'!& H+!' +%$* E"
,= DH%DE%<%;
x "E!$%<= #%$"+$"& "D "+#!&!; !=""#$; (?R%
"'%" !+*'%$");
x !H?"@C"F E"EI'#$&, M! &"?A! !H%$;$A# +*, H!
!H?"@C"F E"EI'#$& D !$+!&' DH%DE%<%';
x !H?"@C"F '"#C%&= E!D+, M! &"?A! !H%$;$A# +*;
x D#$& 'F!&= E&, M! &+? & H+* & %D*?A$$" *+-
?% +%$!@! !@!&!* '"J ' $ &"E!&"' #*H’I+$!'
@!#E!;& ($"?A+ ? +%$"& %"#*& E! 14
"&). C"!?AF H+ EF'I & D#$&* 'F!&" E& D
+%$', +" &D<%" + #$$" $ E" +!$!?%' &"E!&"-
! ! !'$&! — E&!&= +$"& C"!?A!@! H+* D E-
$A !'*& $ &+!#$ %D%&* ? &"R+!*&
'!J?&= *$$ D +%$' !E%C"' H+"&.
$! DD<$, M! !D'" %"#*& &D<%! * E!-
C%$!'* &"!R%" ! DH%DE%<%.
+ ';$A D"F#$ !C"+* 'F, +% I$A# E" DH%D-
E%<% +%$* %"#*&, &"E!&"! ! D+!!&#$&
+,.
%$!"?A" *E&?" ';$A E%%&"$ E&?A"#$A &-
D<% H+' #E&%?&!, &$!#$" $ +!#!#$" C"=
EE%"&, +" " E" DH%DE%<% +%$"& C"!?A!@! H-
+*, &"E!&"! ! !'$&!-E&!&= +$"& C"!?A!@! H-
+*, $+!J * D" %!H="!#$" &'@$ &" H+"& E&%% *
&"E!&""#$A = C"= EE%"& ! #*' !%J!@! +%-
$* %"#*& C"!?A!@! H+*.
%$!"?A" *E&?" ';$A E%%&"$ E&?A"#$A
!!'?% " DH%%J% 'F, !@! #*H’I+$!' @!#E!;-
& H+* E" DH%DE%<% &+! #&!,= D!H!&’DA D
+%$' !@!&!!', 'F!&" E& D +' E%%" H+!' E"
DH%DE%<% +%$* %"#*&.
5 (
T '%$!; &"&;& $'<#!&= +!?&A ?"+&"!#$" H-
+"&
, «$!+!@!» %@*?;& @!R!&!-+%$!@! +* C"!-
?AF H+ D"F#;I E"$'+* +!!$+!#$!+!&!, ('$$I&!,) ?"+-
. .
252
&"!#$" H+* & C"!?A"F &?;$" <%%D E!#$"F! ";<* ?"";
%"#*& (?" — ?"" %"#*&).
%$ <%%D ?""; %"#*& #$!+!' ! !H!<F
%A (?" — +%$ !&%F$) I$A# *'!&=, +" &D<-
;$A# K!?!J%' $ @%%?A' +%$' !@!&!!'. !R$
+%$* E%%=!&*;$A# & %A !$' C"!?A' H-
+!' D&+ &" H+*.
C"!?AF H+ '!J% &$ H+' +%$ !&%F$:
x E" DH%DE%<% %J&' C"' EE%';
x H%D DH%DE%<% (H?+!&F).
H!&’D+!&!; *'!&!; ? E! H+!' D&+ !%-
J +%$* !&%F$ I *+?% @%%?A!@! +%$!@!
!@!&!* D C"!?A' H+!' E! &+!#$ H+!' ?"",
%"#*&.
+ '!J*$A E!&$ D&+ ! C"!?A!@! H+*
!%J +%$* !&%F$ E" DH%DE%<% %J&= C"=
EE%"& D *'!&, M! &! E%%H*&;$A * &?#!#$" H+* — +?"-
I$ %E!D$"; %J&= C"= EE%"& (H! %E!%$ —
+?"I$ %E!D$";) C"!?A!@! H+* " % !H$J%" H*A-
+' D!H!&’D'.
T&+* !%J +%$* !&%F$ (H?+!&!@!) H+ '!-
J% E!&$ ! C"!?A!@! H+* D *'!& !$' &M%-
DD<%= D@?A= &'!@ ? %"#*&, $ +M! +%-
$ (+"' +%$"& #$!+!' E! ! "+), M! !$'" H+!'
'"JH+"&#A+!'* +* +,, % E%%&M*;$A 20 E!C%-
$"&, $", M! " "R' H+', — % E%%&M*;$A 15 E!C%-
$"& &" D@?A!, #*' D!H!&’DA H+* !#$; D&"$* $*,
M! E%%*I $" D&%%.
!D'" E!C%$!, #$&+ D +%$!' !&%F$ (H?+!&')
*#$!&?;I$A# % J<', "J !H?"+!& #$&+ C"!?A!@!
H+* E?;# & E!C%$= E*+$.
%%?AF +%$F !@!&" (!$!+ 1 ! &M%DD<%!-
@! K!?!J%) E! C"!?A' H+!' <%%D ?"";
%"#*& +%$"& !&%F$ *+?I$A# H+!' D &"E!&"-
' $%$!"?A' *E&?"' &"E!&"F +?%F
"+ %D?%J! &" E%"!<!#$" +!#$*& $+' +%$!' $
&!#$" DH%DE%<%.
%F !@!&" 'I E%%H<$ $+!J !H!&’D+!&" *'!& M!!:
x H%D#E"!@! #E# C"!?A' H+!' DH!@!&!#$"
(#*' !#!&!@! H!@* $ E!C%$"& D +!#$*& +%$!') D
+!%#E!%$#A+!@! =*+* H+* &"E!&"! ! #$$$" 73 T+!-
* +, «K! C"!?AF H+ +,» * D" %E!&%-
253
% H+!' +%$* $ E!C%$"& D +!#$*& ' ! 14-,
@! #$*E!@! E"#? !$' +%$* !H!<!@! ;
x E%%=*& +!R$"& D *'!& /E!&%% +%$*
!&%F$ E" DH%DE%<% %J&= C"= EE%"& D !!<#-
' H?!+*&'/!DH?!+*&' &"E!&"= %J&= C"=
EE%"& =*+= * C"= EE%= H+"& D@"! D E!+!',
&D<%' !'$&!-E&!&' +$' C"!?A!@! H+*
D E$A %E!D$!, "?A!#$";
x D!&!?% &'!@ D =*!+ !$'!, @$", H! &=!-
&!@! &%+#%?, &?A!&!@! "R' H+!'.
C"!?AF H+ D"F#;I %"#*& H+"& #$!+!'
! 14 "& $ ! 365 "& R?=!' E!&%% +"?A+"#!@! H!
E!C%$!@! $%%. K!!+ E!&%% $%% &D<%F *
K!?!J%".
5 *(
? !$' #$H"?"DC"F!@! +%$* H+ E!I ! $%-
$!"?A!@! *E&?" +?!E!$ " D$&%J%* !; H+*
E!@'* "#!&!@! !D!!&?%, + &"E!&"I &'!@' !-
'$&!-E&!&= +$"& C"!?A!@! H+* D E$A %@*?;-
& "?A!#$" H+"& & +,". K"#? D"F#% ?"D* "-
#!&!@! #$* H+* " F!@! E!@' "#!&!@! !D!!&?%-
$%$!"?A% *E&?" #?I &"E!&"" E!E!DC",
%E$'%$* H+"&#A+!@! %@*?;& " @?*.
%E$'%$ H+"&#A+!@! %@*?;& " @?* @!$*I E!-
E!DC", !D@? K&?" C"!?A!@! H+* M!! '!J?-
&!#$" H+*, +F E%%H*&I & #$" "#!&!@! !D!!-
&?% H! &D& #%H% H!@ H+*, M! E%%H*&I & #$"
"#!&!@! !D!!&?%, #$H"?"DC"F!@! +%$*.
C"!?AF H+ '!J% &$ #$H"?"DC"FF +%$ D
E?$*, M! % J<, "J !H?"+!& #$&+ C"!?A!@! H+*,
$+' H+':
x "#!&! #$H"?A!'* H+*, +F *D& #%H% H!@ H+*,
M! E%%H*&I & #$" "#!&!@! !D!!&?%, D *'!& C"?A!-
&!@! F!@! &+!#$ $ *+?% D C"!?A' H+!' !-
@!&!* D#$& %J&= C"= EE%"& H! "R= C"!#$%F.
+F H+ D D@!!; +%$!"& H+*-H!J+ 'I *+?#$
!@!&" (+F !I$A# ! E!@' "#!&!@! !D!!&?%)
E! E%%&%% H!@* H+*-H!J+, M! E%%H*&I & #$" "-
#!&!@! !D!!&?%;
. .
254
x H+*, +F !D!H& E!@'* "#!&!@! !D!!&?% "
D&%*&# D +?!E!$' E! #$H"?"DC"F!@! +%$*
E" D#$&* %J&= C"= EE%"& H! "R= C"!#$%F;
x H+*, +F E%%H*&I & #$" "#!&!@! !D!!&?% " D&%-
*&# D +?!E!$' E! #$H"?"DC"F!@! +%$* E" @-
$"; < E!*+* "#!&! #$H"?A!@! H+* H! "R!, "#!&!,
*#$!&, +" D@"! D ,= "#!&' #$!', !#$$"#$; +E"$?*
'!J*$A DH%DE%<$ &+! &D$= #%H% D!H!&’DA.
$H"?"DC"FF +%$ I$A# H+* #$!+!' ! $A!= !-
+"&, +M! E!@' "#!&!@! !D!!&?% DH%DE%<*I !#-
$$" @!R!&" E!$!+, $! H+* '!J% &$# +!!$+!#$!+!-
&F +%$ #$!+!' ! !!@! !+*.
"R% E! H+* #$H"?"DC"F!@! +%$* EF'-
I$A# K&?"' C"!?A!@! H+* E"#$&" ?"D* F !C"-
+ E!@' "#!&!@! !D!!&?%, M! D"F#%" &"E!&"-
' $%$!"?A' *E&?"', E!E!DC"F %E$'%$*
H+"&#A+!@! %@*?;& " @?* $ N<!@! %E$'%-
$* C"!?A!@! H+* M!! ;<!, "F!#$" !@! D-
H%DE%<%. CA!'* "R%" &D<;$A# #$!+ +!#$*&
+%$!', E!!+ F!@! E!@R% " #E?$ E!C%$"& D +!#-
$*& #$H"?"DC"F' +%$!'.
D" EF$$ K&?"' C"!?A!@! H+* E!D$&-
!@! "R% E! #$H"?"DC"F!@! +%$* &"E!&"%
$%$!"?A% *E&?" E!&!$A !@"DC"F" D=! M!!
*+?% D H+!' !@!&!* E! +%$* $ &"E!&"!-
@! !@!&!* D#$&.
§ 3. ' $
E!$%<% +%$*& & +," %@?'%$*I$A#, & E%R*
<%@*, $+' !'$&!-E&!&' +$':
x &"?AF +!%+# +, &" 16 #"< 2003 .;
x !#E!#A+F +!%+# +, &" 16 #"< 2003 .;
x T+! +, «K! "E!$%+*» &" 5 <%& 2003 . - 898-IV;
x T+! +, «K! "E!$%<% +%$*&, !E%C", D +!-
#!?"!&' "E!$%<' H!@!' $ "E!$%<" #%$"+$» &"
19.06.2003 . - 979-IV;
x T+! +, «K! "#!&!-+%$" '%="D' " *E&-
?" 'F!' E H*"&C$&" J$? $ !E%C"= D %*=!'"#-
$;» &" 19 <%& 2003 . - 978-IV;
255
x T+! +, «K! %J&* %I#$C"; %<!&= E&
%*=!'% 'F! $ ,= !H'%J%A» &" 01.07.2004 . -1952-IV.
T@?A" E!?!J% M!! "E!$%+ '"#$$A# * &"?A!'* +!-
%+#" +, $ !#E!#A+!'* +!%+#" +,. E%C"?A'
D+!!', +F %@*?;I &"!#, E!&’D" D "E!$%+!;, I T+!
+, «K! "E!$%+*». TD<%' D+!!', D!+%', I$A#
&D<% E!$$ «"E!$%+», &D<I$A# E!!+ &+%,
D#$!#*& $ E"!$%$ "E!$%+, E!!+ %J&!, %I#$C",
"E!$%+, E%'%$ "E!$%+, *'!& E%%<" %*=!'!@! 'F &
"E!$%+*, &!?!", +!#$*&, !DE!J%, DH%%J%,
#$=*& E%'%$ "E!$%+, !#!H?&!#$" "E!$%+ E%&!@! 'F-
, E"#$& EE% "E!$%+, "#$!$" *'!& "E!$%<!@! !@!-
&!* $ "R" E$.
T@"! "D T+!!' +, «K! "E!$%+*» "E!$%+ — C% & D-
H%DE%<% &+! D!H!&’D %*=!'' 'F!', M! D-
?RI$A# * &!?!"" " +!#$*&" "E!$%+!&C, D@"! D +'
"E!$%+!%J$%?A 'I E&! & D" %&+! H!J+!' D-
H%DE%<%!@! "E!$%+!; D!H!&’D !%J$ D!&!?% #&!,=
&'!@ D =*!+ E%'%$ "E!$%+ E%%&J! E%% "R' +%-
$!' CA!@! H!J+ * E!+*, &#$!&?%!'* C' T+!!'.
E!$%+ &+I E"#$&" !@!&!*, D+!* H! "R% #*-
*. ! "E!$%+, + &+I E"#$&" D+!* H! "R% #**,
D#$!#!&*;$A# E&? M!! "E!$%+, + &+I E"#$&"
!@!&!*, +M! "R% % &#$!&?%! D+!!'.
DI'" E& " !H!&’D+ "E!$%+!&C $ "E!$%+!%J$%? D
"E!$%<' !@!&!!' &+;$A D '!'%$* F!@! !$"?A!@!
E!#&"<%. D" "E!$%+, + &+I E"#$&" D+!* H!
"R% #**, &DI'" E& " !H!&’D+ "E!$%+!&C $ "E!$%+!-
%J$%? &+;$A D &<% &"E!&"!@! E&!<*,
E"#$&" +!@! &+I "E!$%+, H! D H D+!!, #?
"R%' #**.
E!$%+!; '!J% H*$ DH%DE%<%% &+! "F#!@! D!-
H!&’D H! D!&!?% &'!@, + '!J% &+*$ & 'F-
H*$A!'* E"#$&" !@!&!*, M! H& <!#$".
E!$%+ 'I E!="F =+$% &" !#!&!@! D!H!&’D " I
"F#!; ! EE% !#!&!@! D!H!&’D.
D" E!*R% H!J+!' !#!&!@! D!H!&’D &"E!-
&"! ! "E!$%+ "E!$%+!%J$%?A 'I E&! D!&!?A$ D-
H%DE%<%" %; &'!@ D =*!+ E%'%$ "E!$%+ E%%&J!
E%% "R' !#!H', E& < &'!@ += E%%% & "E!-
$%+* %*=!'% 'F! % D%I#$!&" * &#$!&?%!'* D+!!'
E!+* H! D%I#$!&" E"#? %J&!, %I#$C", "E!$%+.
. .
256
[+M! E"!$%$ !+%'!@! E& < &'!@ E%%% & "E!$%+*
%*=!'% 'F! &+I &"E!&"! ! D+!*, $+% E&! < &-
'!@ 'I E"!$%$ &'!@!; "E!$%+!%J$%? ?R% * D"
F!@!/,, &+% $ %I#$C", ! '!'%$* %J&!, %I#$C",
"E!$%+.
K"!$%$ E& "E!$%+!%J$%? D!&!?% DH%DE%<%-
= "E!$%+!; &'!@ D =*!+ E%'%$ "E!$%+ &"!#! D%I-
#$!&= * &#$!&?%!'* D+!!' E!+* E& < &'!@ "-
R= !#"H E%%% & "E!$%+* %*=!'% 'F! &+I D
'!'%$* %J&!, %I#$C", "E!$%+. T%I#$!&" E& $
&'!@ %*=!'% 'F! E"?@;$A D!&!?%; D@"! D ,=
E"!$%$!' — * <%@!&!#$" ,= %J&!, %I#$C",.
K%'%$!' "E!$%+ '!J*$A H*$ ! H! %+"?A+ !H’I+$"&
%*=!'!@! 'F D $+= *'!&:
x %*=!'% 'F! ?%J$A "E!$%+!&C; E&" &?#!#$"
H! E&" @!#E!#A+!@! &", +M! "E!$%+!&C%' I %-
J&% H! +!'*?A% E"EI'#$&!, *#$!& < !@"DC";
x %*=!'% 'F! '!J% H*$ &"<*J%% "E!$%+!&C%' "
A!@! &"E!&"! ! D+!!&#$& '!J% H*$ D&%%% #$@%;
x %*=!'% 'F! D%I#$!&% * &#$!&?%!'* D+!!' E!-
+* + !+%'F &"?%F * $*" !H’I+$ E& &?#!#$", +-
M! "R% % &#$!&?%! T+!!'.
K%'%$!' "E!$%+ $+!J '!J% H*$ !H’I+$ %D&%R%!@!
H*"&C$& H! "R% %*=!'% 'F!, +% #$% &?#"#$; "E!-
$%+!&C E"#? *+?% "E!$%<!@! !@!&!*, D *'!&, M!
"E!$%+!&%CA '!J% !+*'%$?A! E"$&%$ E&! H*$$
' * &?#"#$A &"E!&"!@! %*=!'!@! 'F * 'FH*$A!'*.
H$J% $+!@! %*=!'!@! 'F "E!$%+!; E"?@I %J&-
"F %I#$C", * &#$!&?%!'* D+!!' E!+* %D?%J! &"
$!@!, =$! I &?#+!' CA!@! 'F <# *+?% "E!$%<!@!
!@!&!*.
#$ !H’I+$ %*=!'!@! 'F '!J% H*$ E%'%$!' "E!-
$%+ ?R% E"#? ,, &"?% & $*" " %I#$C", E& &?#!#$"
%, + !+%'F !H’I+$ %*=!'!#$", +M! "R% % &#$!&-
?%! C' T+!!'. E!$%+ E!R;I$A# <#$* !H’I+$ %-
*=!'!@! 'F, + % '!J% H*$ &"?%!; & $*" " H*? E-
I ! E%'%$ "E!$%+ E"#? *+?% "E!$%<!@! !@!&!*
H%D %I#$C", E& &?#!#$" %, + !+%'F !H’I+$ %*-
=!'!#$".
%*=!'% 'F! E%%I$A# & "E!$%+* D!' D *#"' F!@!
E?%J!#$', +M! "R% % &#$!&?%! "E!$%<' !@!-
&!!'.
257
D+ &E+!&!@! DM%, &E+!&!@! E!R+!J% H!
E#*& E%'%$ "E!$%+ %#% "E!$%+!&%CA, +M! "R% %
&#$!&?%! "E!$%<' !@!&!!'.
$"#$A E%'%$ "E!$%+ &D<I$A# D D@!!; '"J "E!$%-
+!&C%' " "E!$%+!%J$%?%' H! R?=!' E!&%% !C"+
E%'%$ "E!$%+ &"E!&"' #*H’I+$!' !C"!<!, "?A!#$" *
&E+=, &#$!&?%= D+!!' H! !@!&!!'.
D" E%%<" & "E!$%+* H*"&?" (#E!*) "E!$%+ $+!J E!-
R;I$A# ?%J* "E!$%+!&C; E&" &?#!#$" D%'%?A*
"?+* H! ,, <#$*, +"F !D$R!& &"E!&" H*"&?
(#E!*) " + %!H=" ? &+!#$ C"I, H*"&?" (#E!*)
D C"?A!&' ED<%'. [+M! C D%'%?A "?+ ?%J$A
"R"F !#!H" " H*? E%% "E!$%+!&C; & !%* (+!#$*&-
), E"#? D&%% #$@% E%'%$ "E!$%+ F!@! !&F
&?#+ H*&I E& " !H!&’D+ "E!$%+!&C D E&!<!',
+' &#$!&?%! *'!& !% (+!#$*&).
D" E%%<" & "E!$%+* D%'%?A!, "?+ "E!$%+ $+!J E!-
R;I$A# !D$R!&" "F H*"&?" (#E!*) $ !H’I+$
%D&%R%!@! H*"&C$&, +" ?%J$A "E!$%+!&C; E&"
&?#!#$".
K"#? D&%% #$@% E%%* & "E!$%+* D%'%?A* "-
?+*, +"F !D$R!&" H*"&?" (#E!*), M! ?%J$A "R"F
"J "E!$%+!&%CA, !#!H", !&F &?#+ C"I, D%'%?A!, "?+
D!H!&’DF DH%DE%<$ &?#+* DD<%= H*"&%?A (#E!*)
$" J *'!& !% (+!#$*&) D%'%?A!; "?+!;, M! -
&?# "E!$%+!&C%'.
E!$%+ !H’I+$"& %D&%R%!@! H*"&C$& D"F#;I$A#
R?=!' E%%<" & "E!$%+* D%'%?A!, "?+, +"F &+!*I$A-
# H*"&C$&!, H! R?=!' E%%<" & "E!$%+* %*=!'!@! 'F-
, E&! &?#!#$" "E!$%+!&C +% &+% & 'FH*$A!'*.
"!# * #%" "E!$%<!@! +%$*& %@?'%$*;$A#
T+!!' +, «K! "E!$%<% +%$*&, !E%C", D +!#!-
?"!&' "E!$%<' H!@!' $ "E!$%<" #%$"+$».
T@"! "D DD<%' T+!!' "E!$%<F +%$ — C% E&!-
&"!#, +" &+;$A E"#$&" !@!&!* E! "E!$%<F
+%$ '"J +%$!&C%' " H!J+!' D E&!* +!R-
$"& * +!#$*& D &#$!&?%' "E!$%+.
%*;<' "E!$%+!; I H+, +F D"F#;I !H#?*@!&*&
"E!$%<= +$&"&.
E!$%<F +%$ %?"D*I$A# E" <# &+! !@!&!* E!
"E!$%<F +%$ D *'!& !$' &#$!&?%= C' T+!-
!'
&'!@. %$!&%CA ! *+?% !@!&!* E! "E!$%<F
. .
258
+%$ 'I !D+$ !#!&" %+!!'"<" $ E&!&" &'!@ M!!
+%$*. "!'C" 'I H*$ !E?;% +%$!-
&C%' * E#A'!&"F !'" " '"#$$:
x !E# *#"= @!R!&= DH!"& " &$$, E!&’D= D *#$!&-
?%' "E!$%+;
x ECE &D<% E?$ D !@!&!!' E! "E!$%<F
+%$;
x E!?!J% E! "?C"F% D#$%%J%;
x E!!+ !#$!+!&!@! &+! !#!&!@! D!H!&’D *
D" %E?$!#E!'!J!#$" H!J+ H! %&+! H!J-
+!' #&!,= D!H!&’DA D !@!&!!' E! "E!$%<F +%$ $
;<" #?"+ CA!@! %&+!;
x E&! H!J+ E!E%%J$ +%$!&C E! '!J?&%
%&+! !#!&!@! D!H!&’D;
x "R" *'!& D "R%' +%$!&C.
'!& !@!&!* E! "E!$%<F +%$ $ "E!$%<!@! !@!&!*
!D!H?I +%$!&%CA.
%$!&%CA '!J% DE!&J*&$ !$+!&" E!C%*
M!! &#$!&?% E?$!#E!'!J!#$" $ "%$"+C", H!J-
+.
!@!&!" E! "E!$%<F +%$ '!J*$A H*$ DD<%":
i &$"#$A !#!&!@! D!H!&’D $ E!!+ F!@! '!$D-
C",, #$!+ $ !D'" E?$%J"& D *=*&' "?C"F!@! D-
#$%%J% H! *'!&, M! !D&!?$A ,= &D<$;
i E&!
+%$!&C #'!#$"F! &#$!&?;&$ !D'" <#-
$!+ E?$%J"&, !$'= D !@!&!!' E! "E!$%<F +%$, $
!DE!"?$ ,= '"J C"!; D!H!&’D $ !=!!' +%$!&C;
i D@! H!J+ EI F!@! !#!&!@! D!H!&’D
! +!#!?"!&!@! "E!$%<!@! H!@* $ &+?;<% "E!$%+ !
"E!$%<!@! E*?*;
i E&! +%$!&C &"<*J*&$ !#!&% D!H!&’D H!
E&! !$' E?$%J"& D !@!&!!' E! "E!$%<F +%$;
i "?C"F% D#$%%J%;
i *'!& #$=*& "#!&= D+"& M!!:
%&+! !#!&!@! D!H!&’D;
%!$' E?$%J"& D C' !@!&!!';
%#&!I<#!, %?"DC", E%'%$ "E!$%+;
%#&!I<#!@! !$' #*', &*<%!, &" %?"DC",
E%'%$ "E!$%+, H! %!#$$A!@! ,, !D'"* ? D!&!?%
&'!@ +%$!.
'!& !@!&!* E! "E!$%<F +%$, &+?;<%F ! +!#!-
?"!&!@! "E!$%<!@! H!@*, D'"' % E"?@;$A.
259
T&%$I'! *&@*, M! D@"! D" #$$$%; 3 T+!* «K! "E!$%<%
+%$*&, !E%C", D +!#!?"!&' "E!$%<' H!@!' $ "E!$%-
<" #%$"+$» D" D'"', &%#%' T+!!' +, &"
20.01.2005 . - 2378-IV, * D" &D<% & !@!&!" E! "E!$%<F
+%$ &$!#$" !#!&!@! D!H!&’D $+% D!H!&’D 'I &+?;-
<$ C"* D!H!&’D $ !=" +%$!&C. "!; D!H!&’D *
CA!'* D" I #*' +!R$"&, +%$!&C%' H!J+*. +'
<!', +%$!&%CA #'!#$"F! &D<I #*'* +%$*. " D'"
';$A *J% &J?&% D<%, !#!H?&! ? "D<= !#"H, !#+"?A+
E!E%% %+C" C"I, #$$$" '"#$? !H'%J% M!! #*' +%-
$*. K%%H<?!#, M! !D'" +%$* % '"@ E%%&M*&$ 70 &"#!-
$+"& &" !C"!, &$!#$" E%'%$ "E!$%+. %+C" #$$$" 3
T+!* I '!J?&"#$A H+' &$ +%$ H%D E!<$+!&!@!
&%#+* H! D '""'?A' E!<$+!&' &%#+!' H!J+.
T+! $+!J %@?'%$*I E!!+ !C"+ E%'%$ "E!$%+,
&D<I E&! "E!$%+!%J$%? E!J 'F, M! I E%'%-
$!' "E!$%+, E!!+ E'*#!&!, %?"DC", E%'%$ "E!$%+ D
&+!&<' !+*'%$', %!'*& $ !H#?*@!&*&
"E!$%<= +$&"&, E!!+ %'"#", $ !H"@* "E!$%<= #%$"+$"&.
T+!!' +, «K! "#!&!-+%$" '%="D' " *E&-
?" 'F!' E H*"&C$&" J$? $ !E%C"= D %*=!'"#-
$;» &D<%! D@?A" ECE, E&!&" $ !@"DC"F" D#-
D?*<% +!R$"& "D<= " ;<= !#"H & *E&?" D
'%$!; "#*& '#!&!@! H*"&C$& J$? $ !#!H?&!#$"
*E&?" C' +!R$'.
T+! +, «K! %J&* %I#$C"; %<!&= E& %-
*=!'% 'F! $ ,= !H'%J%A» %@*?;I &"!#, E!&’D" D
%J&!; %I#$C"I; %<!&= E& %*=!'% 'F! &#"=
!' &?#!#$", ,= !H'%J%A $ *@! M!! %*=!'!#$". T@"! D"
#$$$%; 19 CA!@! T+!* !"I; D E"#$& ? %J&!, %I#$-
C", E& %*=!'% 'F! I !@!&! E! "E!$%+*.
§ 4. "
"
K&!&" !#!& ? E"?A@!&!@! '!?!"J!@! +%$*-
& D+?%" * #$$$" 10 T+!* +, «K! #E #!C"-
?A!'* #$!&?%; $ !D&$+* '!?!" & +,"» & %+C", T-
+!* +, &" 23.03.2000 . - 1613-.
. .
260
T@"! D C"I; #$$$%; %J& DH%DE%<*I '!?!' @!'-
' "&% D "R' @!'' E&! J$?!, #EI '!?!"-
J!'* J$?!&!'* H*"&C$&*, #$&!%; '!?!"J= J$?!-
&= +!'E?%+#"& $!M!. !?!" #"'’, $ '!?!" @!' '!J*$A
!%J*&$ D =*!+ H;J%$= +!R$"& E"?A@!&" !&@!$%'"-
!&" %J&" +%$ H*"&C$&! " EH J?= H*-
+"& " +&$, !E?$* &#$*E= EF!&= &%#+"& E &#$*E" !
'!?!"J= J$?!&= +!'E?%+#"&, J$?!&!-H*"&%?A= +!!E%-
$&"&, $+!J !HD&%% !'R"' @!#E!#$&!'.
K CA!'* E%%H<%!, M! '!?!" #"'’,, +" % ';$A "$%F,
#E?<*;$A +%$ D &"#!$+!&!; #$&+!; * !D'"" $ &"#!$+
"<= &" #*' DH!@!&!#$" E! +%$*.
!?!" #"'’,, +" ';$A !* $*, D&"?A;$A# &" #E?$
&"#!$+"& D +!#$*& +%$!'; '!?!' #"'’', +" ';$A
&!= "$%F, D =*!+ H;J%$= +!R$"&, +"' $!@!, E!@RI$A#
25 &"#!$+"& #*' D!H!&’DA E! +%$*, '!?!' #"'’', +"
';$A $A!= " H"?AR% "$%F, — 50 &"#!$+"& #*' D!H!&’DA E!
+%$*.
K!!+ E"?A@!&= !&@!$%'"!&= +%$"& '!?!'
#"'’' $ ,= E"?A@!&!@! E!@R% &#$!&?;I$A# H"%$!' ""-
#$"& +,. K !J%" "$%F * '!?!"F #"'’,, + !$'?
+%$, C"F #"'’, '!J% H*$ ! !E!'!@* ? E!@R% +%-
$* D =*!+ +!R$"&, M! D?R;$A# * !DE!J%" E"E-
I'#$&, % EC;I '!?!% E!*JJ ('$ H! H$A+!).
K%%H<%!, M! " C"I, #$$$" E!R;I$A# '!?!= &<%-
=, E!*JJ, & +!'* <!?!&"+ H! *J I '!?!' &<%-
', $ %E!&" #"'’,, & += '$ (H$A+!) I '!?!' &<%',
+M! DD<%" '!?!" &<%" I @!'' +, $ EC;;$A
%J&= E"EI'#$&=, * %J&= *+!&!-!#?"=
(*+!&!-$%="<=) *#$!&= $ !@"DC"=, &M= &<?A-
= D+?= $ D+?= E"#?E?!'!, !#&"$ —V "&"&
+%$C", E!#= *+!&= (*+!&!-E%@!@"<=) EC"&-
+"&, E%%?"+ += &D<I$A# H"%$!' ""#$"& +,,
H! &<;$A# D %!; !'!; &< & #E"$*",
’;+$*", !+$!$*".
&+! DD<%!, #$$$" E!#$!&!; H"%$* ""#$-
"&
+, &" 29 $& 2001 . - 584 D$&%J%! K!?!J%
E! E!!+ E"?A@!&= !&@!$%'"!&= +%$"& '!?!-
' #"'’' $ !!+' '!?!' @!'' H*"&C$&!
(%+!#$*+C";) " EH J$?.
DD<%!'* K!?!J%" &D<%! E!!+ +%-
$"& &D<%" C"?", E!!+ E!@R% +%$* $ &"R+!*-