“That’s interesting! So they walk and run and swim. Maybe they also fly like
birds?”
“Don’t be silly.”
“Well, all right. But airplanes are not birds, and they fly.”
“Airplanes are built by people. And people fly on them.”
“And bears also ride bicycles, right? I saw them when I went to the circus
with mama.”
“Yes, they do. But only in the circus, and they are specially trained to do this.”
Analysis
The use of the indeterminate verb of motion is the focus of this dialogue from the
child’s very first question, “Do white bears swim?” The idea of swimming as an
activity is of prime interest. Yes, bears (can) swim. The father immediately follows
up by adding that they swim well, putting emphasis on the manner of the action.
Later, the father mentions that bears have to swim, and again, the emphasis is on
general necessity rather than a specific goal. They live on ice floes and therefore
must know how to swim. The child then muses on the characteristics of the bear’s
locomotion: it walks and runs and swims—and perhaps flies? These four verbs are
all indeterminate, that is, they do not specify any direction or time but rather
define the type of motion typical to bears. The child then says, “Airplanes fly,”
again using the indeterminate verb: people walk, planes fly. They are not flying to
any place in particular. They simply have the ability to fly. The same applies to
people who fly in planes. They fly back and forth, here and there, at various times.
Last, the child inquires as to whether bears ride bicycles. Again, this is an indeter-
minate verb mentioning only the bear’s ability to perform this action. No goal or
time is specified.
Did you find the one determinate verb of motion? It is in the second line of
the dialogue, when the father says, “Look how fast that bear is swimming
(плывёт)!” The reasons for using this verb are quite specific and differ from the
criteria for choosing indeterminate verbs. The context here—Look! The bear is
swimming (toward us)—specifies one time (the present) and one direction (no
matter where precisely the bear is swimming, he is swimming in one direction—
forward). Second, the English translation uses the present progressive form of the
verb, and ninety-nine percent of English present progressive verbs (the -ing form
of the verb) will be rendered in Russian by the determinate verb.
Verbs of Motion 257