POLITICAL
ANTHROPOLOGY
in
the
evolution
of
social organization. Maine
believed
that
societies developed along
an
evo-
lutionary line that would eventually lead them
to
what
he
believed
to be the
most developed
system
of
political
and
social organization: mod-
ern
European society.
Another unilineal evolutionist
was
Lewis
Henry Morgan. Morgan, unlike Maine,
had
actually done
fieldwork
in a
non-Western soci-
ety,
the
Iroquois Indians
in New
York
State.
Working
primarily
with
data
on
kinship
and
technology,
he
used these
to
construct
an
evolu-
tionary developmental sequence consisting
of
three main stages:
savagery,
barbarism,
and
civi-
lization.
The first
stage
of
mans social organi-
zation
is
that
of no
organization
at
all, what
he
called
a
"promiscuous
horde." Later, kinship
be-
came
a
basis
for
groups, which were exogamous
and
so
became linked
to
each other through
in-
termarriage.
At
this
and
other early stages
of
social
development, there
is no
political special-
ization because
the
technology—hunting,
fish-
ing,
and
gathering
or
horticulture—does
not
produce enough surplus
food
to
allow
the de-
velopment
of
cities
or
support
a
specialized
po-
litical leadership.
This
can
only occur when
agriculture takes place,
and
this requires,
as a
precondition, private property, which Morgan
had
supposed
did not
exist
to any
large degree
in
early stages
of
social evolution.
In
1884,
Engels used Morgan
s findings to
support
Marx
s
theory
of
communism, which involves another
similar
form
of
unilineal social evolution.
The
idea
of a
unilineal line
of
social evolu-
tion
has
been discarded
by
anthropologists
and
others
for a
number
of
good reasons.
First
of
all,
it
cannot
be
shown
that
all
societies
are
advanc-
ing
along
one
line
of
evolution. Some societies
have
changed
in
ways very
different
from
the
ways
in
which European societies have changed.
Second, there
is no
reason
to
suppose
that
all
societies
would,
if
they
had
been
left
alone
and
not
been
influenced
by
Western society, become
at
all
anything like what Western society
has
become.
Third,
it is
ethnocentric
to
claim that
Western
society represents
the
pinnacle
of so-
cial
evolution
and to
suppose that
all
other soci-
eties
are
going
to
eventually
end up
like Western
societies. Finally, these unilineal evolutionary
models
are
primarily based upon measurements
of
technology, something
that
Western socie-
ties
can
with justification claim
to
have devel-
oped
to a
greater degree than peoples
in
other
parts
of the
world. However,
to
measure
an en-
tire
society's
development upon this
one
criterion
alone
is
meaningless; other criteria
maybe
more
important
to
those
who
live
in
other societies,
and
by
these other criteria there
is a
good chance
that
Western peoples
may not be as
advanced.
The
next
major
development
in
anthropol-
ogy
generally
was the
work
of
Franz Boas. Boas
attacked grand theorizing supported
by
insuffi-
cient data,
as was
practiced
by the
unilineal evo-
lutionists. From
the
turn
of the
century
and
into
the
1940s,
he
influenced
American anthropolo-
gists,
many
of
whom were
his
students,
to be-
come very
mindful
of the
minute details
of
the
cultures
and
societies they visited.
He
felt
that
if
enough data were collected, many
of
the
patterns
of
society
and
culture would
be-
come
evident without
the
need
to
impose arm-
chair theories
of
dubious value
and
accuracy.
The
Boasian approach
is
known
as
"historical
particularism."
Whereas Boas
was the
major
influence
on
American anthropology
in the
early twentieth
century,
in
Europe
the
dominant theoretical
in-
fluence
was
provided
by
Emile
Durkheim,
a
French
sociologist.
Durkheim championed
the
idea
that
the
historical development
of any
par-
ticular society
is due to
invisible internal social
forces.
This
idea
was
later
seen
in a
slightly
al-
tered
form
in the
writings
of the
British anthro-
pologist
Edmund Leach, discussed below.
Durkheim's
model
of
organic solidarity, which
saw
some societies
as, by
analogy, similar
to
liv-
ing
organisms, appeared
in a not
dissimilar
form
in
the
writings
of
A. R.
Radcliffe-Brown,
a
Brit-
194