ROSCOE
“
FATTY
”
ARBUCKLE
. The meeting not only changed
Keaton’s plans; it also changed his life.
Keaton was invited to watch the filming of a comedy short
at Arbuckle’s studio. Mesmerized by the camera, that very day
he turned down the guaranteed $250 per week vaudeville
salary to accept a $40 per week offer from Arbuckle.
Keaton learned everything he could about film comedy
from Arbuckle, working for the popular comedian for four
years (minus a stint in the army). His first film was The
Butcher Boy (1917). From the very beginning, his persona
was that of the unsmiling stone face. Keaton had developed
his stoic expression very early on in his vaudeville career,
noting that audiences laughed when he didn’t smile.
Nonetheless, Keaton laughed once on film, in Fatty at Coney
Island (1917).
Keaton took over Arbuckle’s studio in 1921 when his
rotund friend went to another company, and it should be
noted that he remained loyal to his mentor during the
famous Arbuckle rape case.
Just before he took over the studio, Keaton appeared in
his first feature, The Saphead (1920), a film he did not write or
direct but a movie whose success would soon pave the way for
his own features. The features, however, came soon after
Keaton’s classic two-reelers, such as The Playhouse (1921), The
Boat (1921), and Cops (1922), all movies with an absurdist
quality that seems thoroughly modern today. Keaton was a
huge popular success, and by the early 1920s he and Chaplin
ruled the comedy roost.
Keaton shared his directorial chores with Eddie Cline,
but Cline himself graciously conceded that 90 percent of the
comic inventions in their films belonged to Buster. Their first
feature together was The Three Ages (1923), an amusing take-
off of Intolerance (1916), but Keaton really hit his stride with
his second feature, Our Hospitality (1923). Virtually all of his
silent features through 1928 were as good or better.
He presaged
WOODY ALLEN
’s The Purple Rose of Cairo
(1985) with his Sherlock Junior (1924), a film in which Keaton,
as a film projectionist, jumps in and out of the movie he’s pro-
jecting in the film. The Navigator (1924) was his biggest box-
office success. But The General (1926) is considered his
masterpiece, with one of the greatest chase scenes in all of
film comedy. It was so good, in fact, that the
MARX BROTH
-
ERS
stole it for their climax in Go West (1940).
Keaton was his own boss, making movies the way he
wanted to make them, when suddenly everything fell apart.
In his book, My Wonderful World of Slapstick, Keaton
explained, “‘I made the worst mistake of my career. Against
my better judgment I let Joe Schenck talk me into giving up
my own studio to make pictures at the booming MGM lot in
Culver City.’” The other great comics of the day, Chaplin
and Harold Lloyd, begged him not to do it, but Keaton was
not a businessman, and he relented under Schenck’s offer of
a $3,000 per week salary.
From the very beginning, MGM tried to change the way
Keaton made his films. The first movie he made at his new
home was The Cameraman (1928). It was an excellent comedy
and a hit, but Keaton had to battle for every gag. He made
two more comedies for MGM that were hits, including his
first talkie, Free and Easy (1930), but the quality was already
falling off.
His films thereafter were bombs. In an attempt to make
him a dramatic actor, Keaton was screentested for the Lionel
Barrymore role in Grand Hotel (1932). Nothing came of that,
and his subsequent comedies at the studio continued to do
terrible business. By this time, Keaton was drinking heavily,
divorced, and broke. In 1933 MGM fired him.
During the next two decades, Keaton only occasionally
appeared in films, usually in minor roles. He was the prover-
bial forgotten genius until Chaplin made Limelight in 1952,
featuring Keaton in a small role. Slowly, the rediscovery of
Keaton’s artistry began. In 1957,
DONALD O
’
CONNOR
starred in The Buster Keaton Story, a movie of minor merit
except that it introduced a new generation to the once
famous silent star. His fee for the rights to his life story also
finally ended Keaton’s poverty, allowing him to live comfort-
ably for the rest of his life.
In 1959, Keaton was given a Special
ACADEMY AWARD
“for his unique talents which brought immortal comedies to
the screen.”
Finally recognized for his contribution to film comedy,
Keaton spent the rest of his years making guest appearances
in movies as diverse as It’s a Mad, Mad, Mad, Mad World
(1962) and How to Stuff a Wild Bikini (1965). More impor-
tant Keaton’s silent films (which had been found and
restored during the 1950s) reached new audiences who
laughed in the ensuing decades just as loudly as audiences
had back in the 1920s.
Keaton, Diane (1946– ) An actress who has surprised
many critics with the depth of her talent in a film career that
has been going strong for nearly three decades. Originally a
discovery of
WOODY ALLEN
who directed her in many of his
films of the 1970s, she emerged in her own right as an effec-
tive dramatic actress in the late 1970s and throughout the
1980s. Tall, gawky, with a vulnerable off-center style, Keaton
has slowly become one of Hollywood’s major actresses.
Born Diane Hall to a middle-class family in California,
she dropped out of college to become an actress. After trav-
eling to New York, she studied at the well-known Neighbor-
hood Playhouse. Her rise was meteoric by show-business
standards; after mere months of playing in stock, she won a
modest role in a show that became the hottest ticket on
Broadway during the 1960s, Hair. She also had the job of
understudying the lead, eventually inheriting the role in 1968
after the star left the show.
As big a break as starring in Hair might have been, it was-
n’t half as big as when Woody Allen tapped her to be the
female lead in his Broadway production of Play It Again, Sam
in 1969. The two subsequently became lovers, and he later
featured her in a great many of his films.
Before Allen introduced her to filmgoers, however,
Keaton made her movie debut in a small role in Lovers and
Other Strangers (1970) and played a more important support-
ing role as
AL PACINO
’s wife in The Godfather (1972), later
reprising her role in the sequel, The Godfather, Part II (1974).
KEATON, DIANE
227