378 Lubricant Additives: Chemistry and Applications
would have increased volume swell in petroleum-based uids. This caused many problems. Programs
driven by the military had material and chemical engineers working together and adjusting both uid
and seal formulations to solve the problems. The results of these coordinated efforts were the develop-
ment of uids and seals that were complementary.
It is very dif cult to speak in speci c terms with regard to seal swell additives, as commercial
uids have additive packages, which are considered very proprietary and highly con dential. To
address seal swell additives, we will follow the development of military uids and seals in three
basic time frames: 1935–1960, 1961–1980, and 1981–2007. In general, speci c information of com-
positions of most aircraft uids, including seal swell additives, is extremely limited and is usually,
again, company con dential. However, because these developments were, at least, in part supported
by the military, more information is available. We describe what is known about swelling agents, yet
recognize that generalities will have to suf ce due to the con dential/proprietary nature of formu-
lated uids. Industrial uid development, including seal swell additives, followed the military uid
development, and the additives used in military uids were used in the industrial uids, therefore,
in essence, by following the military uids, we are also following the industrial uids as both used
essentially the same seal swell additives.
14.2 FLUID/SEAL SWELL ADDITIVES DURING 1935–1960
During this period, petroleum-based uids predominated as the uid of choice for hydraulic uids.
The earliest versions of the military uid designated MIL-H-5606 (mineral oil) had a higher aromatic
content and thus provided suf cient volume swell for the high-acrylonitrile (ACN) NBR (nitrile) seals
used in the low-pressure (∼1500 psi) hydraulic systems in piston engine aircraft. As aircraft develop-
ment proceeded, more powerful piston engines were developed for the very long-range bomber mis-
sions, primarily the B-17, to be used by the Army and Air Force for attacks on enemies in Europe and
the Far East theaters. The long-range bombers ying at very high altitudes, 35,000–45,000 ft, caused
oil thickening and seal leakage, which resulted in sluggish performance. The seals used were nitrile
seals designated by the military as MIL-R-25732. Fighter aircraft, both land-based and aircraft car-
rier-based, did not experience problems because they ew at lower altitudes and for shorter missions.
To solve the bomber uid problem, the mineral oil base uid was further re ned to replace some aro-
matic content with aliphatic content to improve low-temperature viscosity at −65°F. This resulted in
a revised version of MIL-H-5606 hydraulic uid. Low-temperature sealing performance of the high-
ACN NBR-content MIL-R-25732 seals was improved by replacing some of the high-ACN NBR with
medium- or low-ACN NBR as the base polymer or replacing part of di-2-ethylhexylphthalae (DOP)
processing oil used in seal compounding formulations with di-2-ethylhexylsebacate (DOS) oil. Fluid
formulators added suf cient diester uid, such as DOS, to the MIL-H-5606 to maintain 18–30%
seal volume swell. Although very early piston engines used petroleum-based oils as lubricants, this
gave way to pentaerythritol ester-based uids to improve low-temperature performance at −65°F
and maintain high-temperature performance at 275°F. MIL-R-25732 seals were used for engine lube
sealing. For naval aircraft, antirust additives were added to uid formulations for obvious reasons.
Commercial aircraft versions of military aircraft were developed during this era, that is, Douglas
DC-3 (C-47 military transport), Douglas DC-6, and Lockheed Constellation. These aircraft initially
used military aircraft hydraulic oils/seals and engine lubrication oils/seals. However, because of the
short ight duration and many takeoffs and landings of these aircraft, a new, more re-resistant uid
was introduced. This new uid had a phosphate ester base stock, which created the need for seals
made with a polymer compatible with this new base stock.
14.3 FLUID/SEAL SWELL ADDITIVES DURING 1961–1980
As advanced military aircraft with enhanced performance ( jet aircraft) and missions were
developed, both hydraulic system and engine operating temperatures increased. Oil companies
CRC_59645_Ch014.indd 378CRC_59645_Ch014.indd 378 11/12/2008 7:48:54 PM11/12/2008 7:48:54 PM