The Greek Elements and the Indivisible Atom 3
The atoms are compact and full and are in constant motion. The atoms of Leu-
cippus and Democritus differed from each other by their size and shape. Fire, water,
air and earth, are organisations of certain atoms. The theory of atomism reached its
pinnacle one century later with the work of Epicurus who introduced the notion of
weight in addition to size and shape and the idea that in void, all atoms moved with
the same speed.
Plato
Although Plato’s philosophy was based on Empedocles’s theory of the four primor-
dial substances – fire, earth, air, and water – he did invoke some of the ideas of
Pythagoras through the attribution of geometric shape to each of the elements i.e. the
introduction of geometric atoms. The attribution of the elements with polyhedra was
as follows: fire (tetrahedron), earth (cube), air (octahedron) and water (icosahedron –
20 faces). These geometrical objects could all be constructed from Plato’s polyhedra
atoms based on two types of primordial triangles. Of particular interest in Plato’s the-
ory is the fact that through dissociation and recombination of these primary triangles
to form new objects, the idea of transmutation of elements arises naturally.
Aristotle
In contrast to Plato, Aristotle did not believe in atomism. Instead of primordial ele-
ments, he introduced the idea of primordial qualities of warm, cold, dry, moist. The
four primordial substances derive from these qualities i.e.
warm + dry = fire
warm + moist = air
cold + dry = earth
cold + moist = water
By interchanging qualities, transmutation of elements again arose naturally. By in-
terchanging, for example, dry with moist, the element fire could be transmuted into
air. Chemical reactions were seen as combinations and separations of elements.
Modern Atomism
These ideas of the Greeks were to persist for more than two thousand years until
the introduction of scientific atomism which can be traced to the 18th Century.
Through the work of Lavoisier, Cavendish and Priestly, it was shown that the idea
of four elements was incorrect through the demonstration that water and air are
compounds. The discovery by Proust of the laws governing the combinations of
chemical elements and by Dalton of the law of simple multiple proportions cemented
these ideas further. In particular, it was the work of Dalton which forms the basis
of modern-day quantitative theory of matter. Whereas Dalton maintained that atoms
are indivisible and indestructible, he advanced our ideas through postulating:
• All atoms of a elements are similar and have the same weight
• Atoms of different elements have different weights