page_277
file:///C:/Users/User/AppData/Local/Temp/Rar$EX01.335/The%20War%20for%20America%20%201775-1783/files/page_277.html[1/17/2011 2:26:54 PM]
< previous page page_277 next page >
Page 277
As Lord Howe wrote, 'd'Estaing will be found a more troublesome neighbour, than in our time, if he makes his
headquarters at Rhode Island'; and in 17801 a French fleet and army did indeed find there the secure base from
which they contributed to the victory at Yorktown. But Arbuthnot and Clinton had immediate realities to face. Its
possession tied up 5,000 troops and half a dozen warships at a time when all quarters were crying out for help. And
if d'Estaing came north it could not be relieved: Howe had barely been able to save it in 1778, and Arbuthnot with
only five ships of the line could certainly not save it from d'Estaing's twenty. Five thousand troops might make a
new Saratoga for a possession whose value was small to Britain and uncertain to the enemy; troops which were
needed for the coming expedition to South Carolina. It is true that the evacuation eventually assisted the enemy, but
in war it is impossible to insure against every risk.1
D'Estaing had first proposed a return to America in the previous spring, suggesting a joint expedition with
Washington against Halifax or Newfoundland. Washington had been discouraging. He could not spare the troops
for these divergent objects; and he doubted whether New York could be attacked, though the French might burn
the British transports and attack Staten Island. D'Estaing remained in the West Indies throughout the summer; but
in August he received an appeal for help from the Governor of South Carolina. Prevost was threatening Charleston;
and the Governor's appeal was supported by French representatives on the spot. They painted a frightening picture
of confusion: shortage of regular troops, a feeble undisciplined militia, and quarrelling leaders. But they believed
that if the French fleet could appear in September, the British army and flotilla could be destroyed by a single
stroke.
D'Estaing could see the difficulties; but his original orders had demanded a coup d'éclat to demonstrate the value
of French support, and he was influenced by his failure at Rhode Island in 1778. He warned the American
Governor that his absence from the West Indies would have to be brief, and that success would depend on the
speed and promptitude of the American troops. 'M. Rutledge m'a demandé de venir frapper un coup, c'est tout ce
que je peux.' On 1 September he swooped on the coast of Georgia with twenty ships of the line and 5,000 troops.
Surprise was complete. The fifty-gun ship Experiment fell into his hands with pay for the troops in Georgia; so did
a frigate and two storeships. But
1 CL, Germain, 10 Oct. 1779, William Pulteney to Germain; CL, Clinton, 4 Dec. from Germain;
Huntington Library, HO 15 (13 Dec., Lord Howe to Captain Curtis). For some contemporary estimates of
Rhode Island as a base, see Pulteney's letter cited above; Mundy, Rodney, I, 42832; and for alternative
bases, Sandwich, IV, 174, 180, 196, 197.
< previous page page_277 next page >