Корнилова Т.В. Смирнов С.Д. Методологические основы психологии

Подождите немного. Документ загружается.

fnaea 3.

Cneurdnxa Meroaonorrlh ncl4xotoruy

3.5. CoepeMeHHoe

npeacraBleH[e

o reoperhvecKxx

u TunnpnqecKHx

MeToaax B ncxxo^orhH

CeroAHq

Hayvuofi

(axa4eunvecxoii)

ncuxonoil4vr

He roBopsr orAeJrbHo

reoperrlr{ecxoft

n oMnHpur{ecKoii ee

setg.qx, a cofiocraBJlrlor

pa3nble

MeroAbr

gMIrI{plrqecKofr

nponepxu

reoperl,rqecKHx rulrore3.

Teoperuvecxne

aM[up]rqecKrre

MeroAbr B rrcuxo,'rorlru

uMelor ry o6rqyro rleJrb,

gro

oHI{

HarIpaBJIelrbI Ha

[o-[yr{eHne Hayr{Horo

[cuxoJlornqecKoro 3HaH]rg.

3to

sua-

HI,Ie BKrroqaer

KaK

QopuynrapoBaHne

rIcHXoJ'IorHgecKI{x

3aKoHoB, TaK u

BbItBJIeHHe

3MnupuqecKux

3aKoHoMepuocreii

I4JIlr onLilTlrblx

AaHHbIx,

ocHoBe

Koropbrx Bo3MoxHa

rrpoBepKa reoperl.rqecKux

o6o6ueHnrl.

CraHog,'IeHtre

MeroAoB trclrxoJ'IoruqecKoro

HccJreAoBaHu.f, Hau6oaee

nor-

HO npeAcTaBJreHo

B Kypcax IIo lrcTopr.ru

[crrxoJroruu

3Kc[epr{rueHTarb-

noft nclrxo,rorrlfi,

no3ToMy

Aa,'Iee

MbI

AaAI,IM

ToJIbKo a6pHc ocHon]IbIx

fpy[n

MeTOAOB,

paMKaX

KOTOpbIX

pe:Ull3oBaH

B OCHOBHOM

Ue,'IOCTHbIfi

Teope-

THKo-aMrluplrqecxuft

[yrb nocrpoeHl{t I]cuxoJloruqecKoro

vccre4oBant4,tr.

KaaccnQuxaquu

reoperurrecKnx

MeroAoB o6lr.ruo

paccr{arptrBarorcs

orAeJrbHo

or crpyro)?br

roir rrJtv raHorl

nclrxo.rroruarecKoft Teoprru.

B ro xe

BpeMr ocHoBHbre aMrtuprrqecKne

MeroAbr a N.{eHruefi creneHll cBq3aHbI

c co-

AepxareJrbHofi

cropoHoi.i [ckxoJrorHqecrux

reopuft . Cnoco6 reoperr.rvecrofi

HHTepnperarlvtr

LrccJre4yeuttx

QeHoueHoB

BKJIIoqeH,

KaK Lr [per4 MyrrlecrBeH-

Ho ncnoJlb3yelrue

cnoco6lr c6opa aN{rlrpuqecxux

AaHHbrx,

B eAHHyro [apa-

AnrMy

r{ccJreAoBaHug,

Koropofi c,reAyror

[peAcraBr{TeJru onpeAeJrerrgoli

ncn-

xoJlorruecKoft

urxo.nrr.

MoxHo craaarb,

r{To

rIcuxoJIofHI{

peAro

[peAcraBJreHa

crequaJrbHa;r

peQ,nexcux

reopernqecroro

MeroAa r{ccJreAoBaHux. flpe4nola-

raerc.q,

qro

Ar.f;

rlcnxoJlonrqecr{Hx pexoHcrpyrqnfr

H3yrraeMlrlx

l'Brenvit u

npoueccoB

AocrarorlHo

t{crloJlb3oBaHlr.s

noroxeHllftroirunn Huofi ncuxoao-

rurrecxoft Teopfin.

cayuae

xe, KorAa

rax;ur MeroAorornqecrat

peQaercu.a

ocylqecrBJlserc.g,

aBTopbI

Kar 6rl sa6uBaror

o roM,

r{To

rrpu

pa3pa6orre

reope-

TurrecKoro uero4a Heo6xoAHMo

r{Merb

B Br.r.(y fiocJreAyronlnfi [epexoA K

ypoB-

Hro aMfiHpuqecrofi

nponepKn rHnorm.

OAnuu H3 BapkaHroB

caMoft o6qefi

raacclrQnxaunu TeopernsecKux

MeroAoB MoxHo cqr{rarb

c;le4yroquii

[ApyxunuH,

2000, c.

3B]:

<...

ae-

Ayrrunnrrft

(arcnouarlt.recKr.rft

H rn[orerr.rxo-AeAyrff

r.rBHuft

uHave

BocxorKAeHHe or

o6uero K

r{acrHoMy,

a6ctparrHoro K KoHr(pernoMy.

Peaymrar

reopuq, 3aKoH r{

Ap.;

2) uHAyKr}rBHbrfi

o6o6uenne

Qar-

ToB, BocxoxAeHr4e or

qacrHoro

rc o6u1euy.

Pery,nlrar

r4HAyKTraBHaJr rH-

nore3a, 3aKoHoMepHocrb,

KJraccnQnraqua,

cucreMaru3aqus;

3) MoAenr{po-

BaHI{e

KoHKperH3arIHt

MeroAa aHutornit,"Tpancgyxqllfl",

yMo3aKrtror{eHng

qacrHofo

rracrHoMy,

KorAa

KaqecrBe

aHa,'Iora 6olee

caoxHoro

o6ter-

3.5.

CoepeveH Hoe npeacraBAeH he o

reoperxqecKhx...

la 6epcrca 6o,ree

npocror:i

(rr,'rrr)

Aoc'r'vnrrlrii

A.rrfl

ucc"reAoBaHrrq.

Pery"nt-

TilT

l\IoACr'rr,

o6lc'ttta, r r

tlecca,

cocToJII I II9

>2.

K.itaccrrrf itraIlrlr

arr rrrrpnrlccrrlrx

Nlel'o/loB R

frcnxo,rlorlrll npe^craBne-

Itt'l o6t,t.ttt()

B'feopeTIrqcc,,tlS

11lipcitX IIo:)rrcncpII[{et{Ta,IbHoI"{

IIcuxo,rtofult.

coupcltertttoii

crtcrertalrll{e

IJDnlro

yrrrrrllBll'nr

pa3BeAerlne

nouqttrt"t ntc-

ToAlr II rleTo/illKll.

Iic"utt r,terol

oT-rtnttae'f ftv'fb IIo3Hallltx,

cnclco6 c6opa

enturt-

pIlqeclfl.l.\

AaltHbrx

I{2rK cTpvli't\rpv 3lr[lrrprrrtecxofo

IccJ'IeAoRaIII,t.q,

NIeTo-

Altt(a

xelpaltrcptt3ver

cttoccl5, lr.{rl <TcxIIIIlty'>, rflrtrrcatlrlll

ficltxo,torlrqecKllx

rora:;arc,reii

rr.rrn

ynpaB.rrcrrrrrr

rrNrrr. I(raccrrtpux:iilrfir

NreroAr,rK

o5trvuo I]pe4-

CTaR"rl€'III)t It IIpaIt'l'IIIiVlfaX,

IIo31'Ot{y 3Aecl IIbI

}la30tseNl TOJ'IbKO

OCHOBIIbIC

NIe-

TO/lbI rrctlxo.rtoulr{ectioro

ncc-qe/IoRalll.rq. Irlx

pa3.[rlrrrrq

3aAaHbr, Bo-rrepBblx,

oco5crtuoctgr,nr

trcnxo,ror-]rqc('turx

fr.IIroi'e:J, :.)]rfrltprlrlecKirq

npoBepKa

Koro-

pt,tx

crpr-rttrcr{

Ha ocrioBc pa3llbtx

cxelr ltpo(tccclloHa{bHbtx paal,tltu,reHl.tti

ficllxoJ]ofa.

Tax,

palltt.taloT

rlltroTe3br onrrcaTeJ-tbgr,te

rr o6r,gc]IrlT€JlbHbre,

IlIIlol'e3l)I o

pa:]Btrfltll,

flllIOTeilbI

I(ay3ZL/Ibllble

(lt"rtlt

nprt,ilttt]tO-CJIeACTBeHtttte),

fIIllorc3br o cBri3lx

Nre?KilY trcpcur.nlu)rrtrr

(trponeparcTcfl

B Itoppen.qurlolllu,tx

ncc.rrc/loBanltlx),

ro.nrr,tcct'Rcllltble

ftlnore3br

o BIrAe rpyuxttuotta,rluoti

3aBIlcul{ocrru

pl/I

Apyt'ttx.

Bo-nroltbrx, p:lt.rntrtnbte

McroAbI or,'tuqacr

orl-

peAe.rteHIIoe

oluotueHHe ri t.tJyrrlclll)It{

lrpotleccarl

aKTuRIloe

(rrrerrtare,rl-

c'r'Bo

B rtsv.Iaer,rbrir

rporlccc

3lo

xaplltircpl.ravcr

tn6ofr, rcnxo,'Iorlt.Iecxtrrr"r

3l{cl]epl.I}leHr') rr-llt

l]accHBlloe

(()I,trrcartrrx

rpoan-reur4ri

Tor"r r]rlr lrsor"t

rrcu-

xo-rloftIlIccltol:i peiutl,ttOcttl

Toftla

3'ro

Nrc1'o/{bt tta5;rlo.deHtrr{,

KoppcJI.gUtIotI-

Irofo IIoAXoAa, o5lc,ltrttaeribre

Ir lt'rracc Irlc:cnRIIo

tta6,rn4arcu1rtx).

yve6rroii

Jrrrrcparype

cJroltrrJracr) Tpaltrrllrrl

orAe.tblrofo rrpe4craBne-

Illr"q r\rcroAoB tta6r,'uo,1ellIIq,

ItcIIXoJtot't4rlec:t{ofo

II3rIepeIIIrr{,

flcllxo,rtofltqc-

cI{o1-o illtctlcplr}tenr:r

II }terolloB rrclrxo^ttanrocrttxrt (xalt

coBoliynIIoct'lt

pa3-

HbrX Iro ocllorlallrrNr rrctrxoArrafrrocllrrecr(rrx

crpencrB).

llepnlrc

rpu rpyrlbr

Nler(r'IoB pac

KpbrBaK)rcr

rrari cpe.ICTBa rro,rry

e H l

(

nocuporrsno;1crna)

nc lr

xoJ'toft{rtecI{Hx

sttatilti:i Il

,ICc"TtcAoBaTe"tLCIflIX I{eJI.rIx

IIer'I.qX It3yqeHn.q

[clr-

xoJIOf Ilrtecltoii peiutr,uocut, pacKprrrrrrr{

rrclxo,rtoftlqecKrrx

3aKoI{olreprrocreii,

Irocrpoerrlrri rr

npoBcpr{rl o(ro6rrlerrrrnx

('lcopr:r-rruecxnx)

rrpe,{crae,reruri'I

uerl. I{apaAy c rl)cilcl'irlt,rrer{uerr

crl).yK'r'.vllbr u ocnoB

nJra}rrrpoBatrirrr

rcn-

xorofIlrlecKoI-o Jticlcpnlle'lra

ttplI aroNl f iil{}uc o6cyN4atorca

or-rtnrulq

Apv-

IIIX, iIe3I{CIIepIINlelt't'iUIrrrl

r,tx

rivr cii IIo.'t}

rJclIl

trl

AOcToBeptILIX

SN,IIIupUltecKIIX

AaHFII,Ix.

OtlteL'tttt cttetltr$rttty

nclrxoilt.lafnoc'flrrt'r

ro oTHorreHllro

tr IJa3BilH-

HLIM

pallee

NleTOiIaN{.

PetUettttte

,4trat'Hocf

irqccKIIX

3aAaq ncuxoJlofot{

o3Ha-

qaer

Aocru)Ketilrc

r1e.le.ii

o,icre,lonltrtrr.

C.'11,.6'1tt,re

grot{y

IIcHXoAIlafHo-

CTLIqec:l{l,le NtCToAbI o'Ull{tlaIOl'cr{

IlclIO.rll,l}oBill

Ill('1\f I rHbIX n porfieCCttOHunb}IblX

HOpIIitTIIBOB

o'fHOUleHLrfl

OI]btfilhlt\{

/lailtltt[I

3N{IrnpLIaIecKIIX

UCCr'teAOI]ii-

ntril,

,1s'11

c.irolKIilililucct

l] Jtrcrrepfi\rcrrra./ihltoll

ilo/IXOAc,

c lIlIbIIl coorlle-

Ka MeTOAOAOf

hV nCVxoAo

f t4 t4

ceHHeM

TeoperurrecKr.rx

rr,rrrore3

ctroco6()B

opr.arnr3autlu.

Kporre

co6-

crBeHHo

[cLIXOAUafHOcr],Iqeci{oro

I{HCTpyN{erITaplrfl

AaHIIbIe

tra5.un4eHr.ra,

SKCrIepI{r.IeHTaHil]/,

6ecertt

rar{)Ke

Nfofvr

cJ'tym[Tb

lle,l,Iil,I

ilOCTaHOBIflI

IICI,I-

xoJlof

HqecKoIo

AuaflI()3a.

B noc,re4Hlre

roAbr

nc'rxoJ'rorll

craJ'ru yAer'r.srl

ocodoe

BHr.r\,raHrre

Mero-

AY,

O6I'CAITHUBIICN{Y

IIOA

HA3BAHIIEM

<<KBA3I,I3I{CIEPNMEHT>

AOBONbHO

PA3-

HbIe

cxeMbr

c6opa

4alttrlrx.

Moxuo

cKa3arb,

r{To

KBa3IIsKCnepuMeHTbI -

aro

coBoryrrHocrb

lrccJre4onanni,i,

3agnN{arorqr{x

rpor,le}r{yroqrroe

Mecro

Me)KAy

SKcIrepI{MeHTar'tbHbIM

H noppen-qqlIorIIIbrN,I

Irccr'IeAoBaHI{qN{H.

Kax

I'I 3KcIIepllMeHT,

KBa3lI3KcIIepIrMelIT

IIaUeJIcII

I]potsepKy

IIp11qIIIIHo-cne/l-

CTBEHHbIX

fHIIOTC3.

KAr

Tr N

KOPPCJ'I,'{UTOIIHONI

I,TCCJICAOBAHHI,I,

B KBA3II3ITC.

I]epHMeIITaJ'IbHoM

1\{oxer

AOcrurarl]cq

KoHTpoJTb

Ha{

gKcrlepI,IMeHTaJ'Ib-

urru

$arcropoM

r{JrH

ApyrrrNrH

ycJroBr4.rrNrr{,

rroaroMy

o6uul,r

onp"4"n"n""",

STOfO

rIOHgrua

6yAer

c,re/rlyrcIIIee:

KBa3u3I{CneprN,IeHT

3TO

3l(Cfleplil\IeHT

c orpaHrrqelln.qMr,r

tpoplrax

KoHTpoJ'r.s

rrepeN{er{Hbrr,rrr.

MeroAr,t,

nexaxlKe

B ocIIoBe

rlocrpoeHr,r{

TaI(rIX

lIccJIe4onaulIii,

KaK

J'IoH-

rl{TroAHbre,

KpoccKyJ'rbTypr{bre,

[c]r{xoreHeTrlqecKrre

p_rrA

Apyrxx,

Moryr

6ltrn ycaonuo

orHeceHbI

K KBa3ugI{crepuMeHTaJ'rbHbIM

Irr,IeHHo

IIo

Kpr,rre-

purc

ofpaHuqeHu.s

Qopu

rourpo,ra

IMero4br

Hcc,rreAoBa1us

B rrcrlxoJro-

rr{lt:

KBa3rraxcrrepr.rMenr,

998].

OpueHruponKa

yxa3aHlrbre

rroAxoAbr

lre

ucqep[brBaer

Apylrrx

Bo3-

MO)I{HbIX

nprlHuLInoB

x,lacclr@t.rralluH

MeroAoB

IIcIIxoJIOruqecKoro

tlccJre-

AOBaHT'rr

n o6creAoeaHua.

llpu

sToNr

N{eroAbr

rrcrlxo.Irorl,IqecKoro

t{ccJre-

AoBaH[r

He c,rreAyer

rryrarb

rrpeAcraBneHH.qMr.r

N{erorax

o6pa6orxn

AalrHbIX.

Iloc,re,qHee

[por,rcxoAtrr,

rracrHocrr.t,

B cBr3r,r

c o6paqeHuell

ncuxo"rrofoB

orrpeAeJ'rerrHbrM

MepaM ycraHoBnelrH.s

cnseeiil

Me)Kny

nepe-

MeHHbIMU

KOBaptrau

vL1.

Jrrt

Koppen'lulrr4

Me)KAy

rrepeMeHHbrN{

I{.

Srcnepr.rnreHra,rlurrfi

Merorx

gau.q,'r

oco6oe

Mecro

B Bbr,IleJreHr.ru

uclixo-

Jlorut{

B caMocro.sreJrbHylo

Hayxy.

Ec,ru

ueroA

uHTpocrrexuu[

paccMarpu_

BaJrrc.g

KaK

rlpeAnoJlararcrlnrl

cy6terrnBlrylo

LrHTeplperaur.rlo

sMrII{pUqecKr4x

AaHHbIx

o cocToqHI'{.sx

cosHaHl'I.fl'

To [epexoA

SKCI]epIrMefITxpoBaHHIo

IIo-

craBrrJl

Borrpoc

BO3MO)KHOCTu

Kpr{Tepwsx

o6t

extwBHofo

3Harru.g

B rrcn-

B xoppeaaquoHHoM

I4ccJ'IeAotsalIIIn

ycraHaBrruBaerca

tlraxr

nelleuerrux

o4uoii

nepeneulroii

(lr,ru

uecxo;lr,xllx)

e calan

c tr3McrreHuqNrr4

.{pyrori,

rro

He rrpeAno.na_

raercs,

qro

KaKas-To

l.r3 arlJx

ncpeNrerrHrJrx

,{tsJ'r.rrercq

rrpnvl,1uno

4eiicraynuleii.

Ec_rrrr

xe 9Tu

rIpeAnoJ'loxeH'Is

o Kay3aJlLIIbIX:laBI{cIrN{ocrtx

Ilocryr'lr{pylorcs,

To uN{cerc'l

Br4Ay }rx

coAepxarear,Hoe

o60cttoBaHlie

paMKaMu

c60pa

4aHur,rx,

e. HeBo3-

MOXHOCTb

r.tX

o6octrosaHr.rJ{

caMr,rM

rpaxrolr

ycraHoBJreHr

cBs3t4.

XOppe.taqI,torr-

HOM

rro

Tlrny c6opa

rxaHHbrx

r'rccJlieAotsar{uu

tso3Moxtro

tr r4crroJ,rr'3oBaHr4e

Nrep pa3-

"nuuuii

(cparueuue

nlr6opourrbrx

cperl{fix

mr6opxau

A.).

3.5.

CoepeveHHoe npeacraBneHhe

o reoperhqecKhx...

xoJ'IofHqecKoNI

Ircc,'reAoBaHLIu.

BHeIxHee

ua6,rrc4euue,

HJ'II,I aKcrepocrleKulrg,

TaK )Ke

xax u lrc6ue rpoplrr,r

caNtoorqeroB,

flBJrgercg.,IIuIrIb

nocraBulr.rKoM

gM|InpnqecKr{x

AaHHbrx.

tr4 aru

4auulre,

TaK

)r{e Kar{

r,r sKCnepl{MeHTar'rbHbre,

c,'ryxar rleJrr{

gNrrrtrpr{qecxoii

[poBepKt,t

ncr,rxo,'roruqecKr{x

runorea.

OAHa-

Ko nyrn o5o6ueuuli

rrpn

r.rcrror'rmoBaHrr,r

pa3Hbrx

NreroAoB

cyruecrBeHno

oT"qi{qaloTct.

StccnepulteHT

B cucTeN{e

Ircl{xoJrtorllqecK}tx

MeToAoB

BbICTy-

Ilaer B KarrecrBe

r.r4eanlHoii

ToqKu orcr{era,

rro orHo[IeHrarc

rc roropoji

o6-

cylKAaxlrcg cnoco6lr

c5opa

4auur,rx

rr orpaHr.rqerulq

o6o6ueur.rii

ua ocHoBa-

Hr,rrl [pr,rMe]reHlrr

Apyrr.rx

tueroAoB

KopHn,rona, 2003

lI.

3uHqeHr{o [pritser'r raxoii <<r]aHerr{pnr(

alrcnepnMeHTr,rpoBaHl4ro>>,

06-

cy)KAaJr Bbr.qBJ'reHrrbre

o. ManAe,rt[rTaMoN{

npueMbr

o6paqeur.ra

K orrbrTy

pa5ore <.O

AaHre>,

yArrBrrre"rrbHo

ror{Ho

nepe4auqrrrT

orrurrile

aroro Mero-

oT rrnJll.ocTpaTlrBHoro

nyru o6paqeHr,r.rl

K 3N{nupl{r{: <.ArrTtlHorr,rnqHocTl

AaHTOBCKOIO

OIIbITa

3aKJ'IIOqaeTC.q

B TON!,

IITO

MeqeTC.rI MeXAy

npl4MepoM

axcrrepuMeHrolr.

flpuuep

r43BJ'rexaercr

r.r3 rarpr.rapueii

rop6nr

ApeBHero

co-

3IraHH.{

c reM,

qro6bl

6ltrr

nosupailIeuHblNf

n Hee o6parHo,

KaK

ToJ'IbKo

MHHer

Ha4o6uoctr,.

Srcnepunrerrr, BbrAeprlrBarr

r4s

cyl{Mbr orrbrra

u"{u rrHbre

Hyx-

HbIe

eN{y

Qrarru,

y)Ke

rre tso3Bpau{aer

ux o6parHo

rro 3aeMHoMy

rrl4cbMy,

nycKaer n o6opor>

(qnr.

no KH.:3rrHqeHKo,

1993, c.

B). B ar(clepuMeHraJrb-

HoN{

N{eroAe r,raBHoe

He o6paqeune

rfarry

KaK K rar(oBoMy,

lporleAypa

ero

ycTaHoB"rretrtrflrl

j'rorr.rKa

paccy)KAeHrIr,

paMI{ax

KoTopoii

I,I3BJ'reKaeT-

c.q

HayqHoe 3HaHHe.

Orlternlt

roJ'Ibxo re

xapaxTeprcrl{I{H

oxcllepl{MeHTaJ'IbHofo

MeroAa

B rIclIXoJ'IorHrI,

c KoropbIN{rI

cBt3aIIa

6o,rttuag

cre[e]{b

crporocru

B aMrIH-

puuecroii

orleHr{e

reoperr,rqecKHX

rr4rlore3.

3xcnepulretrr npeArror'Iaraer

aKTI{BHoe

tsMeulareJrlbcrBo

B Ll3yrraeMbre

[po-

ueccbr

r{.sB,'reHu.s,

rprr aroM peanrr3yerc.q

BbrrroJ'rHe}rue yclosr.ri.i

rtpilrrr4HHo-

ro BbrBoAa,

cQopl,ruponaBrrrrxcr{

B ecrecrBeHHo-uayvrroii

r{cc"/reAoBareJrb-

cxor.i napa4urN,re.

Ho rcnxoJ'rorr,lqecr(as

[pr4rlHHHocrb

Moxer

rloHl{Marbct

nHaqe,

rreM

llpu'ir.rHrrocTb

B MaTepr{arrblro\,r

MHpe,

nosToMy peKoHcTpyKuI4Il

rcrrxoJ'ror[qecxoii peanr,gocru

ueo6xoAr{Mo

BI!'Iroqaror

onopy

Ha ttojlo)Ke-

Hr1fl Tov utlu

unoi.t rcllxoron4qecxot)i

reoprrrr.

Pearuaaqna pa3lrbrx

$oplr

axcnepr{N{eHranbHoro

KoHTponx

o6yctov-

Jrr{Baer

Bo3N{o}nHocrtI

r,r orpaHr4rlcHr4q

BbrBoAon (rourponl

euno4on).

rHrrorerrrno-AeAyKTrrBHbrfi

xapanrep oKCrreplrMeHTaJ'rbHoro

paccyxAeHu.rl

He rlpeAnonafaer

AoKa3are"IrbcrBa

LIcrI,rHnocrl{

fHrlore3,

Itocxo,rlry

lrc6tte

sMrrr.lpugecKr{e

3ar{oHoMeprrocTr{

AonycxapT

r.rx BbrBolltrMocTb

r,I3

apyrori

Teopur{

(nycrr

Aa)Ke

noKa ue

c$opr,ry,rHponauHoii).

tr4rax, axcnepr{Nre}rranbHnii

lreroA rrpe/I[onaraer

nepn$uxaqun

(onur-

Hyrc npoBepxy)

$a,rrcncfnraqr.rru

t'urrore3

(ornepxeuue

rurrore3br

KaK

f,naea

Cneulr Ka

MeTOAO^Of

ncnxo\or

rlh

coorBercrBylouJel"I

oIlt'ITHLIII

larlllbrrt).

Sxcileptrlleurupv'I,

llcc-rte/t(]tsal.eJlb

pa3pa6arblBaer

ollpeAeJlellltbte

JKCnepultenraJtbul,rc

t\toAe"rlI{,

orpa:)xaK)uILIe

efo

ItoHllN{a}ltlc

fiptIr]IIIIHo-c.rteltct'BclIlbrx

ot.uoilctttrr'i

r tt:,lV.raelrclii

ctrcreue

rlepeMeiIiIbIX,

peIIpe3eIITrlpvI()lllllx

II3y(racr\tvto

rrcilxoJoft1lJL.cr{yl()

pea.rtblIOc.t.r,.

3.6.

Moaenhpyloluxi

noaxoa

reoprn

no3HaHHc

h nchxo^orhqecKhe

rHnoTe3br

llptt peantraarlr{u

uoAerlll)\/lorrlelo

no/lxo/la

cLln.aercrr,

rl.l.o

rrcc.reAoBa.r'eJrrr

B XoAC

r{brc-rre'rruofo

3K(:lrcl)rr}rerrra

(N{3)

otrcprrl)yer

l\roAc.rrrrN,lu,

3a}leruil1)-

lltrutt

o6lexrbl

rla ocHoBitltlrlt

orltorlc.llrn

lor'loalra.

Ilpir

3ToNt

rrl)lltr{Nlaet.,

c.lt,

qro

e rrc6olt

ai{c[epllNrcnre

\rbr n]\reeu

jle,rro

c caNILIl\t

l.rily(r?leNrblxr

lpeil-

l\Iel'or'I,

T. e.

lrccile/(yelroii pt-lutt'rr()ct

bto, u

c voTrl€,;n,ro

arrtii

ltcanr,irocrrt.

MoAe'rrt

aro t{I)tc"rterIrIo

rrpercrats.riJtcual

l.rJr}r i\,ra'repua.rrbro

pea"4uily-

e\,tag cllcre\{a

ltepcN{e}rrIbrx,

I{olol)aa

or.o(rpaxacr

]rccJre/lyeu.vrc

peiub-

IIOCTb tI

CttOco6tta

3ar.{eural'L

ee rltrr,

rlro

cc tlilyltelrrle

irliler

IIou.vn

lttttpclp-

N,rauIIXl

o6 u:yuzrer.rlrx

3aRIrcLINlocr-ax.

Pe:yllraror{

Teoperlr{e(rrtofo

}roile.rlrrl)oBaJrrl

lrJ,rrrclcr{

r{reajlbrrar{

}Io-

Aenb

(tr4M),

npeAcrraBntlorrqax

co6loii l/lcilJurillrposarrrilrji

o(tlta:t

o6'leura,

cl'ITyauilu

Ir r. IL,

flpeAc-faB.ilc]rrr

r,rii

I co.llullri{IJ

I.tccJ'teAogare;tr{.

ocHosrtLte

cpeAcrBa

rroc'rpoerrr.rs

14N,{

cro

lt/lctirT}rilailrrn

a(tcrparuponarlte.

flprr

rIoMouII

:r6crpaurponaHII,l

Nlt,r BI)tAe,rttet\t

c-vfllec'l'BelIHblc

cl'opotlbt

N{oIe-

JIupyellloro

o6r,erra

tt or(tputct,tttaerl

Ilccvllr.cl'uetitlbte,

vcrpzltltg 11crrorl-

IInItIt

cllcrer'raruqecKofo

(:Nlctlteung.

] lvrclt

l/lc:trl:lautru

IIbI ftepcxollrrrl

K aHaJIlr3y peanbHocru

c ilitcaJllHrr\ilt

r:uclr'icts:rililr

1'.

c. K tre

cyuecruyrurrleti

nel,icrlltlTe.rlbHocrll,

IIo

Nlbtc.rlIlrroii

lrax

o(rpa:lcti,

no ot'rrotleHuto

I{ l(oloix)-

r{y 3NlllnplltiecItat

peaJ'ILllocrl,

3al

pv)'Kelt;l

}lttoiKccruo}t

/Ipyfltx

cuoiicre.

I4ctto,rr'eoBatit're

tr4M

AeJIaer

N{i)

(lo,'rcc

cr,,rb}n,rr{

rorlur 3l)enllr

Bo3N{oiR-

ttoctet"l

TeopeTtlrrecl(oro

n6o(tttletrrtl.

j,lNI

IICtro.,th:l.VeI

Itc tr).'11,t(()

aililapa.r

a6crpaxruo-Jlofrlqecl{ofo

rrtll"r€rrllLq,

}ro

lt cl)L'1cr'}Ja

Rn:r},a-rll13aurttt.

IIctt-

xo,rorv

rlcHo'

qro

rill(

rolt,I'rLIC

cl)c,{c'lBa

Il03lIaHlls

c.vtt{cct'BCtttto

}rnpotlla-

rcT

pea.rlbllocl'b

I'IlITeJlnell't't'lt.tt,ttoii

.t('t

t'r'.-tt,ttocf

qc.rloBel{lt.

Tci *.c

rtaca-

eTC.s

II IlpcAcTatsileluta

clrl,rrntltrii

rrr;.rironr,rx

Nlo;:(e-rrcii.

I'Iilcrurr,rra.q

rro./Ic.rrb

Iiil3blBaeTct{

:ttaronoii,

KOflla {-'e

lioNfrtotletrl'lrt

cnliJirul)t

c J,ire}Ietit-zi}t}1

op1-

rullal:r

ro,{bro

fropltartlrro,

uc tr:rxolli]cr,

c Iil.r}Ul

B ril'iloIrctIUlt

rtojlo(tr.rl.

OArrot:i t13

pa3llotstlAHocleii:lllarriorlblx

lro;1<,:,rcii

HuJltrelctr

rclr6eprie.r'rr-

qccKaIl

t\roAe,rtb.

l{cno,rlgctnanltc <il{o}{tl,to'lcprtoii

lrc'rarJloltr,t>

rcllxojto-

Iult

'IB"rlqeTcq

IIpIJN{epoNI

1'ofc), ItaCI{o-ltrttrt

5vttBa.lt,ltC)

IIcc.rte/'{oBiiT'e"rIL

lto-

)KeT I,rC[OJIb3OBaTb

CpeAcTi]a

NIoile.Tilpoi]ilrilt'l

li-rtfl

lltr'fcptrl)c'l.atlilotrlilt\

qerteri

nprt

Uityrrclull

roallar;]rc.rlblrr,rx

trporl{'('coIJ

(tc,,rouet{a.

iJla

corjl)c-

3.6. Moaenrpvroutht

noaxoa

s reopxu norHaxran

N nchxonorhqecxlae...

IueuHofi

KorHIdrI,IBHoii

ncnxo.norlrl4

TaK Ha3blBaevoe <.6aoqHoe>

MbrnrJre-

HVr€,

HJ\H

<.6roKoBoe'>

npeAcTaB./reHHe

aTaIIoB u

yponHeii

aKTyanreHe3a

rIo3HaBareJ'rbHbIX

npoqeccoB,

KaK BbrtroJ'rHger

aBplrcrr4rlecKylo

QyHI(uurc,

TaI( noAqac u o6eAgser

coAepxaTeJlbHble

o6Tr.rIcHHTeJrbHbIe

cxeMbr.

Qu,rocoQcKlrx

Hayr(oBeAqecxnx pa6orax

MoAe"rrrrpoBaHne

KaK

BrzA

no3HaBareJlbHofi

AeqreruHocrlr

yrleHoro

paccMarplrBaerc.s

B KoHTeKcre

cooTHeceHrrr MbrcJ'reHHo ycTallaBJ'rHaaeMbrx

H peaJrbHo

rrpeAcTaB,'reHHbIX

crpylrryPHo-QyurulloHa,rbHblx

xapaKreprrcrl{r(

HccJreAyeMoii

pealrHocrr.r.

fIpH

roeuoxHocrH

Bbrno,'rHeHHs

yclonuii

npuqr4HHoro

BbrBoAa

B MbrcJreH-

nofi ruo4e-nu

$urccupynrcs

KaK

aKcnepr4rvreHTaJIbHble

ycJroBllg,

TaK u rrpeA-

rroJraraeMble

rrrrroTeTl,IqecKrre

KoHcTpyKTbr, o6bqcH.rlrcIr{He

3aKoHoMepHbIit

xaparcep

nocryJrr{pyeMbrx

3aBHcHMocrerT.

Mrrc"reugoe

gKc[ep]Ir{eHTHpoBaHI,Ie

Moxer KaK

npeABap.rrrb,

TaK H 3a-

Meularb c6op

aunupuqecKnx

AaHHbIx.

Ogo uoxer

noHHMarbc.g KaK <rrpo-

firpbrBarrr,re>

HccJ'IeaoBare,TeM

Bo BHyrpeHHeM

rr,'IaHe

Aeitcrsuia

roro uJrrd

lIHoro

cnoco6a

AoKa3aTeJIbcTBa

rlcnxoJ'rorlr.recxoll

rn[oTe3br,

6eeorHocu-

TeJrbHo K TOMy,

BO3MOXHa

Jrr{ OpraHl{3auH.rr

cooTBeTcTBylouero

3Mrrlrpn-

qecKoro

vccle

/IoBaHvs'

I4rax, npu rpaAnrIHoHHoM

noHr{MaHr{t{

MoAenb

paccMarpr.rBaerc.rr

KaK

Bocnpou3Bo.uq[Ias

"re

uJrH

nHrIe

csor;crBa nctrxo,rrornqecxofi peaJlb]Iocrr{

ynpouleHHoii,

cxeuaruvecroii

Sopue.

O6H.ruo

rar(oe

rroHuMaHne

MoAeJrr.r

xapaKTeprr3yer

TaK

Ha3brBaeMbre

Teopr{H <cpe.rlHero

ypoBHr>,

KoTopbre

npe-

TeHAyIor

Soprraa"n

mauuro

npeAcraBJreH

uft o6 uccne

/lyeM

brx ncuxoJroru-

r{ecKux

3aBncr4Mocr.sx.

Tar, roBop.r{T

o MoAenrx

ce,'IexrHBHoro

BHHMaHr,I.q

6poa6euravtnu

A. TpericuaH,

MoAeJru MornBaquoHHoit perynxqvv

Bbr-

6opa

r1e.aefi

[x.

ArrnHcoH a

vrrw Moilerv ilprrnflTus pelreulrit

A. TsepcKoro

Kagelraua

H T.

HafrHa:.

reoprrfl

npl{ aroM BbrrroJrHrer

aHaJrrrlTr,rqecxyro

$yHrqzrc

rpo.flcHeHu.q

crpyrcrypHo-SynrqnoHa.trHlrx

cssseft MexAy

[epe-

r{eHHbrMr,r,

yrITeHHbrMIr

B MoAe,rIu.

SrcnepuuenraJlbHzul npoBepKa

cJleAcrnuli

arr{x MoAeJreft crpolrrc.s

[ocpeAcrBoM

BbTIBI{xeHus Kay3a,'IbHbIX

fr{Ilore-

3 O TOM,

qTO

KarcUI-TO rrepeMeHHuul

MoxeT

paccMaTpHBaTbc.fl

KaK IIpnquHHo

gefi

crnyrcqaa (r parrlrax

aa4auHofi

3KcrreptrMeHTaJrbHofi

MoAeJ'rr.r).

9au1e

ncero noA MbrcJ'IeIIHbrM

aKcneplrMeHTupoBarr?reM

B rrrlrpoKoM

cMblcne

rep-

MrlHa EMeror B Br4Ay

r,rMeHHo sror <yMo3pr,treauuii>

xpurepuli:

nnyrpeHHufi,

u"ru

tr,tHclenrruii, naatr

c6opa

4alltIbIx

H BK.rlpqeHr.re

npeAtroJroxeH

ufi o6 ux xapaKTepe

cr,rcreMy

pa3MbrrrrreHHfi

nsaeuunarcullrx

npeAnoJ'IaraeMbre

AaHHbIe

<3a>

r.r <npo-

TnB>

paccMarpuraelroft

coAepxarenbHoft

runorealr. IIpu

raxotr

pacunpr{TeJrbHoM

noHHMaHuH

M3 on craHoBllrcr

cr4HoHnMoM

ap6oro o6cvxaesus

rp6ltx

rlirrore3

sTarra

npoBeAerrur peaJlbl{oro

14ccJreaoBaH14s.

-t

flpNvNHxocrb

KaK

npHHuhn

HayqHoro

o6uqcHeHNs

ycrpoiicrra

Bce,rennorl

fienrorplrroru

He Hau]J'Iocb

Mecra cBepxbecrecrBeH-

HbIM cIIr'Iar\{,

ttocKo"rlbKy Bce

[oArILIHeHo

Heo6xoAr.IMocrl{,

nort.grot?

KaK

uettb

[puquHHo-cJ,reAcrBeHHbrx

orHo[reHHrl.

Vveunr<

leMoKpHra

flporarop

nne"rr

uAelo oTHocLtTeJ'rbHocTH

n03HaHH;I.

B ulealucruqecKoii

TpaKToBKe

Haqa,'r

6urws

fl"tarouolt

neo6xo4truocrb

r,rMeJIa

llrroii uctoqHux

rrAelo

KaK

I]PTII{UHN

BEUI{, KAK CMbICJ'IOBYIO

MOACJIb CC

6CCqITC,NCHHbIX

I{YBCTBCHHbIX

npo.an.rreuuii.

Tnoplrr )Ke r{Aen

MHpoBa.q

llyxta,

vM.

yru-AeMr.rypr,

}re BbrBo-

AI,IMrIT"I

LI3 MarepI,IaJIbHbIX

IiarIaJ'I.

fieuoxpltra

Ha opraHIr3M

MexaHnqecrn

71elicrsosa"rrv

rrorol(n

aroMoB.

Oqyueulrq

xe fipoucxoAnnu

6tarogaps

r{crer{eHLrro

or rrpeAMeroB

roHKr,rx

rrJrerroK, orpaxaeMbrx

nnaxnofi

qacrblo

r,raea

6,raroAap.rl

BcrperrHblM

aroM-

HbIM rroTol{airr.

!,nx

llraroua

no3HaHr,re

AoJrxHo

6u,ro

ctarr, He

qyBcTBeH-

FIbIM, a TOJTbI(O

yMCTBeHHbTM;

paIII4OHa.lbHOcTb

ero 3aAaHa

Bo3Molr(HocTbro

Ilcno"rrb3oBaHr.r.rr yHI.{BepcarbHbIX

cxeM MbrIlIj'IeHr{.{,

Ho 3Ta <<parluoHaIbHocTb>

BaK,rroqa/racb

B <<npnrroMr4uaHrfir>

ayurotl

ITcTHHHbIX

cyllrHocrel?,

Koropbre

He npeAcraBJreHbI

B BtrAr.rMoM

lnrpe.

Ocranr.rr.q B cropoHe

rrcropllro-rtcuxo-

,toruqecxnti paKypc

npo6,reur,r cBr3u

Bo3Moxuocrel"I

rro3HaHr{fl

c troHr{Ma-

HL{eM

qeJroBe.recKor,i

AyuIn,

[poAoJIXI{M paccMorpeHLre

BoaHI{KHoB enug.

o6-

uIHx rrpeAcraueulli

AerepMr{HX3Me.

Apucrore,rr, pa3AeJ'rr.rn

lpr{r{HHbr, onucblBarorlne

MHp npupoAHbrx

reJI

r{ xrr3Hb

xcHBbrx

cyuecrg.

Ero

npa6uonozuuecrcoe

repMr4Ho/roruu

ller-

poBcKoro

M. fipourercxoro)

AerepMHHr,rcrcKoe

Bo33peHr4e

[peArronara-

4eiicrnue

Heroii <<KoHerIHor"I>,

HJIH

<<Ue,TteBOiir>,

npltuttubl

Kax oTJl[r{arc-

nleli

ue,recoo6paenocrl,

rrpucyuyn )KtrBoMy

opraHr.r3My.

Pacrrpocrpaueuue

STOIO rroHr4MaKng,

Ha BCe Cyruee,

T. e.

Ha Bce .rrBJreHHg

B Mr{pe

B IIeJTOM, rIO-

,lyquno

Ha3BaHI4e

Te"rIeOJ'IOInn.

Teneo,torns,rt

Te-leo,rorusra

lpornBorrocraBrfl.Jrrr

AerepN{r.rHual.ly.

B Cpe4Hue

BeKa ts

yqe-

Hllu AnrycrnHa

Ay[Ia

6ltla

Ha4e-neHa

crroHTaHHofi

artunHocrblo,

Koropal

<ABlrxerc.fl

s Eorer>. Erraoaaneprreuouu)emepuuuucmcKoeroHLlMaHHe

[pr.t-

rInHHocrH

KaK

lleJ'recoo6pasHocrlr.

LI sAerepuusu3M

03HarraJI

B rlepByro

oqepeAb

HeIIoATI r4HeHHocrb

ABr{xe-

ttuit

gyllu

3aKoHaM

Marepl{a,'rbHoro

MHpa,

n CpegHue

BeKa oH craJl

o3Ha-

t{arb

npuHurr[rraJ'IbHo

HHyro r{x

AerepMrrHauurc

6oxecrBeHHbrM

rrpoBr,I-

AeHr{eM.

He"noner

BblcryrraJl JII{IIb

ero

Hocr{TeJreM.

B nepno4

oQoplr,reHn.fl

KJ'raccurlecxofi

raprnHbr

Mr4pa,

nplruxnurefi

Qopr"ry

ilexaHucmuqecKozo

AerepMr{HH3rraa,

paapa6arr,IBaJ'rI4cb

Bapr4aHTbI

npeduexauucmuqecKoz.o

AerepMr4Hr43Ma.

'Iax,

s XIII B. Bo3HI{I(

TaK Ha3bI-

saeN{rti.i <<oflTllr{ecKI,IIZ>

4erepnrnurr3M,

cBr3aHHr,lfi

c ucc.rre4oBaHvflMuBpw-

fnaea

llputr4HHocrb

aerepMvrlusM

MeTOAOAOTUU

HayKH

4.1.

l-lpNvhHHocrb

KaK

npxHuhn

HayqHoro

o6bacHeHufl

4.1 .1

. fiprHurn

aerepMxHh3Ma:

or aHThqHoro

K MeXaHHCTHtteCKoMy

H BeporTHocTHoMy

flpu

nocraHoBKe

pelreHr.ru

npo6,reu

4erepMrlHaur{r{

rrcHxHr{ecKoro

ral( u,In

r.lHaqe

Bcraer

Bollpoc

$rr,rocorfcro-MeroAoJ'roruvecroii

rpanroBKe

[pr4rruH-

HOCTIT.

oAHaxo sTtrx

rpaKToBoK

B ICTOpITH pa3Br,rrllr

qeJroBeqecKo

fr. rrttc/lu

6ntlo

ugoxecreo.

tr4 Mbr 3Aecb

npeAcraBrrM

l'oJrbr{o

re, Koropble

oKa3ar'Irlcb

Hau6o,ree

ocBoeHHbrMtr

npr{

nocrpoeHr{H

trcuxo,'Iorr{qecxux

reopufi.

4ocoxparoncxtrii

[eplron

Qraaoco0un

aHrrlrrHoro

Mr{pa rroHsrl{

xnpu-

ltuHbt

u Hal4ata

He 6rr,ru

pa3BeAeHbr.

Tarc,

AHaxcarop

(nepraa

no,tonlrHa

V s.

H. a.)

[peA[oJraran,

vro

Bce,reHHoli

4nuxer

(<<Hys>>

no-rpevecxlr).

n opraHu3yeT

[opsAor(

B MHpe,

ABr{)KeT

Mr.rpoM,

H no3HaeT

ttup.

fryutr_

crr4r{ecKall

no3r4uHr

eroro

QruocoQa

npoannJlacb

[peAnoJrox(eHrrr{,

rITo

xax

cy6craHur{s

Hyc

BXoArrr

cocraB

To,'rbKo

xr{Bbrx

cyulecrB, ycrpoftcrno

KOTOpbrx

rro3BoJ'rqer

eMy

pa3Hofr

creneHu

llportsngrbc'l,

ABn)KeHr,r.rI

Ay-

rrreBHoro

TeJ'recHoro

cJreAyer

cMelrr{Barb.

coxpar

(470-3gg

e.)

pa3oqapoBalc.g

n AHarcarope,

loroN{y

qro

yBI{Aer,

qro

<<yMoM

He lror'rb3y-

ercq

BoBce

t'I He

yKa3brBaer

HacroqulHx

npuquH

y[op.qAor{eHuocru

neuleii,

ccbrJraerc{

Bc.rrKHe

raM

Bo3Ayxr4,

eQr.rpu,

BoAbI

I{ MHoxecrBo

Apyrxx

He_

J'rerrbrx

neulerl'> (unr.

xH.:

Coxo-[osa,

1995,

c. 49).

To ecrr

vnr KaK

rrprrqu-

Ha rlo;lBJltercg

raM,

rAe HeI{BBecrHofi

oxa3ltsaerc.r{

ecrecrBeHHiul

[puq]IHa.

AuruqHoctt,

Aaila

ps1

BapHaHToB

B noHr,rN{aHHn

AerepMrrHneua

(aro-

MrrcrHqecKl,Iil,

re,'Ieo,rof

n.{ecxuii

Ap.

r.r3 Koropblx

JruHtrrr

flentoxpura,

aBTOpa

[epBbIX

rrc]4xoJ'rornqecKr4x

co.ruueHr.rii

(aropa;r

ro,ronltga

v n.

u. a.),

n Apucrorenx

(384-322

H. a.),

aBropa

rpaKrara

<.O

Ayure>,

oKa3aJlt{cb

Hau6o,ree

recHo

cB.s3aHHbrN{r.{.

B erroxy

aHTl{qHocrr4

AeiicrBo-

Barr rrocryJ-rar

o }repa3AenbHocrlr

Aylxlr

r{ re,ra.

Teu

caMbIM

6lt"rro ueo6-

XOAIIMOCTLI

CTpOI{TL

OTAeT'IbHo

npeACTaBJ'IeHL{e

AeTepMrIHarVIt4

A,t{

MI{pa

BHeUrHero u

MHpa

rcuxHr{ecKLrx

pea,rr.rii.

B lrarepna,rucruqecroii

TpaKToBr{e

r.1

l-naea 4. npuqrlFrFrocrs h

aerepNahH]4rv

e veroaonorhN Hayx]a

TeJrbHbrx Boc[p]rsrl4ii H

ooopMuBrruii 3aKoHbI 3peHr4r r{aK rroAqrrHeHHbre

3aKoHaM oI]TUKH,

qro

B eBpor]eficrofi

sunoco<pnlr

cB.fl3aHo c r{MeHeM Po.4-

)Kepa EaKoHa

(I214-1294).

llpuvuuuufi

px4 rplrauvecrnx

srrenuii n ea-

KOHaX

OTITI4I(U [O,'lyqa,I MaTeMaTHqeCKOe BbIpa)CeHI4e, a nCHXUveCKUrl

cooTBeTcTByrorlIYrc

llpilquHHyro

AerepMrrHauurc.

MexauHcrn.recrclrfi

4erepMrrr{r{3M

rrpeBa,,rnpoBaJ'r B npHHIIilnax HayqHoro

lo3HaHr4q s Hosoe BpeM.rr

c XVII

cepeAuHbl XIX n.,

cMelrlttsrurrcb

$op*raun

6uono zuqe crco zo d emep uuuuatw a.

OAuaxo

ocraHoBr{Mc s, Ha

AByx

ero ocHoBHbrx aclreKTax: ,rruHei.iHoii v. crarvcrvqecroii

4erepMnHaurrr{

eAI4Hon npurIHHHo

o6yclon"reHHoM r\{Hpe.

3Aecl

saxubrM rrorrrrueM

Bbr-

cryflu,ro raK)Ke

Qlrsr.rrarncrcr(oe

rroHr,rMaHr,re rtpHr{fi HHocru.

flo,roxeHua.rr

B ocHoBy K.rraccHr{ecKoii xaprnHrl Mupa rrpuqnH]rocrb Ha-

3brBaerc.{

$narrxaar.rcrcxofi

upnvnuHocrblo,

nocKo,'IbKy orpa}Kaer

83aHMo-

Aeihcr:l;r's.

r rpuenvecxoM Mr{pe, rtpIIqeNt noH.rIToM B

paMKax

KJlaccuqecKoro

€CTeCTBO3IIaHl4fl

rocIIoACTBoBa,'Ia HbIoTOHOBCKa.tI

KapTUHa MI'tpa.

@uaurcaaucrcrca{ rlpilqnuuocrb lrpeA[o,'Iaraer BJII,Iff H]Ie oAHI{x Mare-

puanbHbrx ycnonufi

(Qaxropon)

Apyrlre

ucxoA.q I,I3 npeAnor'rolKeHniA o

3aKoHax, orpaxaeMblx n o6o6uresnbrx

r{JrH TaK Ha3bIBaeMbrx

yHr{Bepc;urb-

HbIX BbIcKa3bIBaHhqx, npoflB,IIeHI{e KOTopbIX

lI cr'IyxI'IT ocHoBaHI'IeM IIpl'l-

r{r{HHbIx

sbrcxaaltsaHlrii.

llpu

eroilr n Hosoe BpeNrq [por{3oruro

yABoeHI{e B

[oHuMaHrrH rtpuqrlH-

Hoii

4ereplruHarlrdr{.

oaHoii cropoHbr, flpuqrrHa

3aJro)reHa

B Heo6xoauMo-

crr{, cBq3brBaenroii c lpo.f,B,'reHr{eM 3aKoHa KaK

roruqecroii t<oopnrHaqutt,

paMxax

xoropofi HaxoAqr cBoe

AerepMLIHllctcxoe

o6rgcHeHue DIVIrtHpl4qe-

cKHe 3aKoHoMepHocrr{. C

4pyrofi

cropoHb-I,

[poqB,'IeHue erofi ueo6xoAr.t-

MOCTr,r

pea,'rrr3yercs

B cBfl3vt

c npwuHtlo-deilcmaynuluMu

acnosuflNu,

fI.e

B KarrecrBe sosAeficrsng Rbrcrynaer

rfarrop, Haasauuufi rlo3xe [pl4qnH-

uo-4eficrnyrculrlM

ycJroBrrenr (u

nnoc,'reAcrBuH

<<He3aBlIcuMoI"I

[epeMeH-

nofi,>).

OcyulecrueHne

BosAeiicrsuii

ua nayvaeuurfi flpouecc

npo.flBre-

Hne aKTUBHOCTI{ t{CCJIeAOBareJr.rr

paN{KaX pea,TH3aUlIlI 3I{CnepL{MeHTaJIbHOTO

r\{eroAa, o

r{eM

Mbr 6yaeu roBop}ITb B cJleAyrouefi

rrase. Ouxcarlu"g c,'reA-

crBufi KaK

aMrrl{puqecxr,r

rpo.sBn.r{eMbrx

H3MeHeH},rit

ocHosa

peKoHcrpyK-

uHfi

aaxoHa r{Jrrl [popbrBa Mbrc,rn

Teoperur{ecKllN{

o6o6ueHlr.aM.

flosxe coorHorrreHue vrtruBtr1yanbHoro

qacrHoro

ll o6uero

3aKo-

HoMepHoro

6lrno

nepeocMbrc,'reHo

B rrpeAcraBneHLrr4

o lepoamHocmuou de-

mepilu?rustil e. Vqurllna.fl MHoxecrBeHHocrb

rIoHI{MaHI{t

AerepMHHn3Ma

BepogrHocrlr,

orpaHr{ruMc.s Har.r6o,'ree rrpeAcraB,IIeHHbIM B I(,'IaccurlecKrlx

Kaprr4Hax

Mr4pa noHqrl4eM,'rarrJracoBcxoro

AerepMuHH3Ma.

3a6eraq

He-

cKoJrbKo Brrepe/I, o6paruttcn K HAeqM

BeJruKoro

Qpauqyecr<oro

MareMarh-

Ka, HaI]HcaBruelo

<.Onur

rpn,rocoQnrr

reopHl{ BepotrHocrefi

> (nuure,r

4.1. flpuuuunocrb

KaK

nphHuhn

HayqHoro

o6urcueHtl

1814 r.). N4r,r orryctnaeNr

npH 3ToN.t crarroB-[eHrre

caN{or-o

npeAllera

t.eoprru

BepogTIIOcTu,

IIocI(or'lblty

o6cyN4aetnt

ToJIbIto

B KoHTencTe

tIeTo/loflOl.tr-

qecl{oro

3llarJeHll'I

BRer'IeHutl

nolltTllt

ueonpede.acutto(mtt

/'lJIq

:)t\tIl4ptrlle-

cr{HX

Haylt Ha araile

K.'rlcclrqecKOii

rclprttttt

t ul.rpa.

B nolxo:-Ie

lI.

C. ,Ilan,raca

(17

49-1827)

nep<;artocrb paccl{arpuBanacb

KaK cBg3aHH:lr{

c }tettoJlHortiii

iiuauil_q,

T. e. u

I(arIecrBe

xapaxl.epucrntc.l

rro3rrallItg,

a He Nrrrpa.

Bxorx4etilte

itcpoq't']IocrHbrx

Nte'fo4oB B

Itayny cral'to

crlllty,rrou

/Iirfl

lllilteHeHLr{

roltlrN,r:rlltfl

AeTepNILII{ll3Nra,

a r:tlrxc rfu.rro-

coQcxot-o

IlpeAcrallncttLlrl

o caNII{x

Bepor{Trrocrgx.

noctuer,racct4.tecrnnii

rreptIo.l pa3BlrrtI'{

$tratrrtlr

ponb

tsepo-qriloc'l'i.l

Bollpo(:,rta

rf_rytr4alrcura,rt-

IIOfO IrpUHllttttit:

<,Hairt

rteo(txorlttult

fte

'fo-rlbl{o

3iltro]tbI,

tr co5Hrr,r.q,

Koropbre

rpntsHocrr

olltlcaHr.{e

rpupoArn

3Jter{eHl'

pitArrr{aJ'Iblior?

uoeus-

y11,1...'>

[Iprrroxurr,2000,

c. 12].Ho yr:Ke

rr B

npeilutccrByrorqrre

neprroAbr

BepOtITHOCTL IIe

OTO}KACCTBJ'Ifl.rIaCI)

C Ile::]flilIIUeM,

tICtt

NTOi;I(HO

fOBOpItTb

rlpI4N{eHrITer'IbIIO

p:i3rlbtlll

cttocorrall

tslt"rlK)qeiltlq

cTaTl{c'flil{rr,

octloBarr-

troii rra Bcpotrgocrr{brx

IIpeAcraB,{eliurx,

B IIa.yr{Hrrlc

tlccjleiloBalI}Iq

npII-

po4t't.

flolta

)Ke' IIpTIBCIeNI

ltcropllqecrrivro

cflpl]tsI{y

o Rliiuo(rcilllu

Bcpogt-

Hocrr bIX llpcAcraBr'teHttii

ocnltc:;rcn

tre

AegH

Ii i

qe"'ronctca.

B XVIII B.

lo.qBr'r,{rrcb

rrepBbre

pa5onr

lro

lrclo-[],:roBaurlo

cr2rrlrcr!,

ttccKofo

rtarel)tlruta

o crfrcpe

urrilcauug

('otura.rbnt)lx

ss,reutrii.

Hclletltc,rrr

eoeHrtHii nacrop

3rocl.Ilr,lr,x raK oIIpeAe,{rr"rt

rpe/]Nrcr

R Ha:Batrurr

csoeii

pa6orn,

nr,rrrre4rrreii

176l r.: <.EoxecL'Bcrrnbrii

rrop-q1oK

B tr3ruerreHusx

qe"qoBcqecKOI-o

porla,

T. e. ocuoBa'Ie"qLIroc

/lotta:iii.fe.itbcrgo

Ilo:xecrgeHIIofo

npoBIIAeHIIJI

II iIpONlblcJ'ta

lto O'filoilIelll]ru

Ir polly

rle"rtoBeqectKo\{y

I{3 cpat}-

HeHl:lr{

por'I}JBIilLIXCT{

y\{epu11x,6rpaxocoveraBllulxcr

poJur]ilII{xcrl,

B oco-

6euttoc'ttt )Ke

LI3 llocrogr{ttofo

coo'fHOrrrcrrrlq

poArrBrlrxc.s

Nra-[br{lIIroB

rr,i(e-

BorleK, II T.

A.>>.

Ott nnepelte IloAoule-q

It crarlicrtllte

lle naK

I{ orllcarcr'Ibttoi,i

Ar,IcuurrJ'rurre,

rrafi aro

6u,ro rrpnlxro

vlxBepcurcrax

ror/tanrrrei.i

fepnra-

I{Ut.t, a Kat(

t{ cpe/IcTIJy

RbIflBJleHllr{

npuqtrHr{btx

cBr{:;cii.

X. I3o,rr,<f

lIaltrcaJl

B rIpeAIJcJ'roBrrH

t( eror{)/

TpyAy,

rlro

orr sB,rrrrerct

(<oIIr>rrot\I,

llol{a3brBaruu{}I[{,

Ratt

reopltn

Bepoq'fHocreii

uoncr

rtpII]ueH"qrb-

c.q t(

rBJrclurs\r

r{eJroB0rlecxoii

rxnrrrrr" (rllrr.

I1o rrH.:

Kynqon,

1976, c.

55).

B cre/iyxtuteN{

BeKe 5e-qr,mlicnuri

yueuurii

Keuc

(1796-I874),

cra-

TlIcruI{, Nlarer,rarr,rn,

acl'poHoN{

rr coqtlor'ror,

yrlerr116

Jlarr,'raca

Apyf

flyac-

coHa,

IIoKa3tu] Ila cTaTUCTIIqeCT{ON{

NIaTepnane,

IlortepllHyToNt

u3 oTr{eToB

yroJ'roBrrbrx

op riuroB

(Dpau

rln

r.r, Be.alrtrlr

rr As r,r

nn, ceHcallrroHHyro

3ar{o-

Irol,reprrocrr,

KoJ[rqec'rBerrHOro

cocraBa

lpccryll"rreut'tir (

1829 rr

]

831

rr-.).

Orr

tsIIepBble

ocllbtcnuJrt

I{e Iratr nporlB,'teHllc

EoxecrgeHHoro

flpoMblcJra,

a K;iK

AcrepNrrllrrrpvcl,roe

npup<t4oii

,rrcAeii coBepucrlle

n\rr,r

:-lc{turti,

loArrurrq-

oxlrrxct:Jatrolrilrr,

trat(

t1 BCe B

npItpoAe.

Et'o

<.Cottrta"itr,Hitfl

Qrtortxa>

nperl-

L,*

HHHOCTb

AET AH'43N4

A METOAO

OThH

lo,rrafai'ra

nocrpoeHne

cor{traJ'rb}ror."r

HayKrl

lIo o5pa3y

KJracc]ultecnoii

r]r.rerr_

Kr{,

rAe

lericTByroT

Ar.rHaMlrqecune

3aKo}rbr.

He nr,rAnnHyB

Hr,t

oAHoii

rroBori

tpn,rocorpcr<or"r

u4eu,

Ker,re

BoueJ'r

B r,rcropr{rc

KaK yrBepArrBlrrir:r

BO3Nro)n-

HOCTb

3N{III{pUqeCItOfO

IICCJTe/lOBaIIlI-g

Il TOr{HOIO

N,IaTeNfaTUt{eCKOIO

aHiUllI3a

3axoHoN{epHocrer:i

B rroBe/Ierrrrtr

"rrunel:i.

B 5r,ro,rorurr

(D.

fa,rr,rotr

(1922_

1911)

K. flnpcou (1857-1936) -

$r.r,rocorf-rro3rrrrrBnc:r

rr Nrarer{ar}ir(

pacrIpOCTpaHHJ'IU

lICCneAoBaHllq

lI3N.{eHql,iBOCTI,I

CtTaTUCTI4T{eCI{Iie

N,{eTO-

Abr

Ha li3yqerure

6rrouerptrr(r,r

Hac"[eAcrBe]{}rocrrr.

noc,reAyruuteu

flx.

Cr. [,{rr,r,rl

csoefi <.Cucleue

-[o'rr(r>>

o'eruJrr

rrac"rreArre

Ker,re

Kar{

vcrpaHeHHe

fJ'raBrrol'o

apryNteHTa

nportrB

cyuecrBo-

BaHI,I.g

3aKOHOB

I{CTOptril.

cnx

nop

nptr3l{aHlle

rofo,

qro .{c,'Iosex

net:i-

crByer

cor,'Iacl{I{

co cBolI\{I{

qentl\Iu,

xeJ'IaHI.I.{MlI

r.r

go,refi,

cJ'ry}Kr{J'to

oc-

I{oBaHIreNt

rI03lrIIlIu

tIIIAerepr\'rrrHusN{a.

floc,'re pa6or

Keue

crarr{crr{r{ectgre

3aKOHbI

CTaJ'IU

OIIlICbrBarb

3aKolloo6paaHocrr,

T. e.

AerepN,II{HltpoBaHHOCTb

rlpol{3BoJrIbHltx

4eficrntrr"r

,rnaeii.

flpn,rnnHocrb,

rrpr.rr{eN{

JTatrJ,racotscKOrr

rloHIrItaHI'IlI,

crar'Ia pacnpocrpallqrlcq

cotltraJ'rbttbte

9tsjreIIilg,

cor,'racHo

crapoN{y

N,{cxaHrrcrr.rqccr(oN,ry

noHrr\,raHlrxt

Aerepr.llnr{3_Nra,

Ko-

Toporo

IIpr.rAepxrrB;Lnca

ne,urxuii

tppanqyacxtrrl

trraretrrartrr{,

Bce

B N{t4pe

troA-

qI{H.qerctl

npurtxHHoMy

O6yc,ron,rtrnaIII]lO

AeI"ICTtsI{rc

ALIIIa\f

t lqecKtlx

3a-

KoHoB.

noapaxeutte

eMy,

qro

IloBeAetIIIe

rle,rlOBeKa

He o6tgcn.gercrJ{

l.a61,1N{

lnHeiiuttu

rIoHI{NlaHueN{

/IerepMrIHI{potsaIIltocrIt, Bnr'txlqa-rlo

raK)Ke yl.tseprK-

Aerrr{e

o ro\.{,

.rro

aroii

crf-repe

He lroxer

6ln'r

Hrrr(aKrrx

3aKoHOn.

}lO

e XIX

r,rcc/reAoBaHn,I

IIo coqui]-rrlHclii

crarIcrrrKe

npoAer{oHcrprrpoBa,lrr

B03N,ro}K-

Hocrb pacKPbITrIrI

3aKoHoB

KaI(

3N{IIIrpHqecKu

ycraHaBJlrrBaeMr,IX

crarl{crH-

qecKllx

3aKOIIOMepHOCretl.

3ro noloNtrJ'Io

HavaJro

IIolltIN{a}tHIO

3aKOlla

KaIt

sarcoua-metr)eH\uu,

nporr{B

r{oroporo

Bbtcrynr.lJ'r

loc-rreayrolrleNr

Irpr{Me-

HI'ITeJ'IbHo

peryntlIIIlI

fiotseileHH-fl

qeJ'IoBel(a

trelreqxttii

fic[xo,rtof

"r]e-

rnu

(1890-1947),

a npoAonr(rdJ'r

gro

o6ocHonaHr.re

rronrr\{a}rtrtr

ficllxoJro-

rflsecrrrx

3aKor{ots

cosercKr.rii

rcr{xoJlor

"4oNlos

(1927-1ggg).

fl,ra

XIX

B. 3aBoeBarrueNr

cra-qo yrBepirAer{rie

o roN,r,

vro

4erlcrnn.s

qe,ro-

BeKa

He npolr3BonbHbI

B TOrr

CN{brcJ'Ie,

qro

oHr'I

nprrql'IHHo

o6yc,ron"nenlr,

xor.q

l{x lprrqrrHbr

ropa3Ao

rpyAHee pacKpbrrb,

qeN{

]\{Hpe

suauvecronr.

Tax,

B KoHuelrurrr{

cso6onu

no.au rfipaHuy3cKoro

rrHryrrrlrBrrcra

Eeprcoua

21e-

TepMr{rrl4poBaHHOCTb

rIoCTynKa

npH

cno5o4e

ntt6opa

6ilr,ra

cesaaHa

co BCeN{

rlpeAtrrecrByrorluNr

J'rr{r{Hocrrrbrr{

pa3B

r{Tr,reM

9€r'roB€K&.

Taxulr

o6paaolr,

YeJroBeK,

6ylyuu

cno6o4ulrlr

or 3ar{oHoB

BHeril{efo

ru[pa,

rre

Moxer

oKa3arb-

cno6o4nlrr{

or ca\,Ioro

ce6s

e|o

4erictnua

BHyrpe}rHe

Aerepr{rlHupoBa-

Htr nceti

nuuuefi

ero )Kr,r3Hn.

conpelreHuaa

rclrxo.lorur{

Aaer

ApyDre

l.paK-

tonxu

calto)emepttuHa\ul;.

Ho utt

ocraHaBJ,tIrBaeMct

Ha l'reroaojlol.l{qecKoN{

3HaqeHur

BeporITHocrllbtx

rrpeAcrae,'IeHlrfi

ArJ{

rrayKH.

ocrrosaHueNt

rpeo6paaosarrng

[orlrrr4.s

AerepNrr{Harrr.rn

lrocJry)Kr{no

I43MeHeHI{e

[peAcraBnertun\

o eepoamHocmu

v crAttae.

Bo-nepnux,

B nHrrre

O. Kypuo

(1801-1877),

rppau{yscxoro

rplrao-

coQa-u4ea-lt{cra,

NIareMaruKa

gKoHoMHcra,

<.Octtoau

reoDHI{

[laHcoB

Bepo.rrrHocreti>

(

1843) 5u,ra

o6cyx4eua

npo6,rennu

n"uA"r."urHocrrr

3aKo-

HoB MexaHnKn

nJIfl

<<xtlIBbIX

cylqecrB,

o6,raAarcnlux

MbIIIIJ'IeH}IeN{

I.I

}IpaB-

crBeHHocrblo>.

vraepx4aJ'Iacb

rIocJIeAoBare,'IbHocrb

IIpLIqI,IH

C,re4Crntrii

A,rq,T106oro

px4a

co6rrruii.

r.raeHoe,

6rrlo oHronoru3r{poBaHo

rrpeA-

craBJreHrre

c,ryuariuollt

co6r'trnr.r:

r{e3aBuclrN,Ibre

rpr4r{rlHHbre

lleror{Ku

co6wrnit

nHorAa

rrepeceKarorcg.

Srlr [epeceqeHuq

Aaror

ro,

qro

N{br

Ha-

3brBaeNl

cJ'ryqaeM,

nnu cnyuafiHocrbro.

Taxnu

o6pasoru,

rloHrrl{e

clyvaii-

noro

co6rrrr.r.rl

[epecrano

[pornBopeqrrrb

J,IailJ,racoBcItoMy

npeAcraBJreHr.lK)

AerepMlIHH3[.fe.

Bo-

nropltx,

eoa4efi

crnyrouat

[p'qurra

craJ'ra

AoflorH-srbcx

qe-nenorl,

qe-uecoo6pa3Hocrb

KaK

npuHrIIlrr paUrloHaJrbrrocrr,r

Aono,,rHLLrr

K,'laccrlqe-

cKyro

Kaprrrrry

Mr.rpa.

cor,raoro

Kypno,

BBeAeHHe

rrpeAcraBJrerruit

o nepoxr-

HOCTr.r

ocrroBe yKa3arrHoro

[oHr,rMalrr,rr

clyvarlHocru

rro3BoJ'rrer

pacnpo-

crpaH.rlTb

uplt.ruHutrr.i

B3ur.rrA

Ha Bce

co6inrnfl,

Hextrsorl

xHsotl

nplrpoAbr.

Pery,rxpHocrb

Lr,lt{

}repef};-r-rlpHocrb

Bbrcryrl}rJ'ru

npn

oroNr yKa3aH}I.flr{rr

3aKOH

rr c,ryvaiirrocrt.

oAHaXO 6lr,r

paccl,rorpeH

lt raxori

TIln

BepoqrHocrr,I,

roroprrii

He ornoclrrcq

K KoN{[ereH[rrrl

N{areMaruxt{

n cB.rr3aH

IrHTyhrr{B-

Hor)i oprleurtrponroli

rreJroBeKa

xl,r3IrrI

lr HayKe.

TorAa og

6lr,r

uaaraH <.en-

,rocodrcxttlr>.

B nocle4yrculeM

nprr

[epeocMbrcJreHr{H

3aKoHon

Mr.r,ra.s

BoIxeJI

I.r B 3aKoH

r{HAylclrrn

(xax

nonaa

ero rpaxronxa).

pa6orax

arrr,rnficxoro

6uo,rora

fiapauua

(

1809-

1BB2)

6rrno

no-

J'ro)KeHo

HaqaJ'ro

npnqrrHHoMy

o6t

lcHeuuFo

KaI(

AOCTI{XeHUIO

Ue.necoo6-

pa3rrocrrr.

lloc,re4yrcqa.q

cMeHa

ro3yHra

Ha <.f,a

e4pancrnyer

ano"trorlru!,>

rr3MeHr4J'ro

orHorueHl.re

K cnyqaro (rr

clyvai.iHocrlr).

<,Teopux,

n roropoir

craBurcs

3aAaqa

oIIucarb

3aKOHON,repHrtif

npoqecc

sBoJ'rroullu,

o6t.{cHlrrb

YAIIBHTCJIbIIYIo

TAPN,IOHI4rc

XrrBOii

NPI,{POAI,I,

I\{HCHIITO

MHO|HX,

IPIIHUII-

rlna,'IbHo

He MofJIa

onHparbcs

Ha Bepo.tlTHocrHo-crarllcrt{qecKylo

ocHoBy>>

IKynqon,

r976,

c. 118].

nocneAyrox{eM

AapBr.rHH3M

orrurpiL/rc.rr

roJrbro

rrpornBo[o"[oxHocrb

c"ayvafiHoro

qe,recoo6paaHoMy.

Hac

AaHHoM

cnyqae

HHTepecoBaJ'I

TOJIbKO

OAI{H

aC[eI(T

BKJTaA

npH3HaHI4q

O6rerrns-

ttofi

nepoxrHocrll

u c;ryvaiiHocrn

KaK

He nporuBopeqauux

Kaprr{He

Mr{pa

oAHo3llarrHoii

4ereplrltHr.rpoBaHHocrr,ro

qs,'Ieuuii.

creAyrcuu[{

orarroM yrBepxAeHHs

Bepo.rrrHocrHoro

''oHHr.raHrtr

,,prr-

'rr'ruHol7

AerepMl{Haunv

crarro

o6HapyxeHne

6orlulHx

coBor(ynHocrrx

c"noxstrx

o6T,eKToB

3al(oHoMepHoro

ftcreugperyJr.rrpHbrx

rlpuqrrH (n

lreHl-

rrrt{x

coBoKyrrHocrqx

3areMH.rreMbrx

4eilcrnlralrH

[pl4r{uH

ueperyaaputrx).

2-39.1

fnaea 4. flprvruuocrb

aerepMhHt43M

B MeroaoAorz.u

HayKn

To ecrr,

or,'IurIneM

cmamucmw.lecKozo

3aKoHa craJlo [oHHMaHI{e

ero KaK

npoqBn.seMoro

ToJ'IbI(o B

coBoKyrrHocTt{

gBJIeHI{il.

fIOCrO"nlKy

r{eroBeK

o6r,r.{Ho rrNre,,r

Ae,1ro

c vwArrBnIyaJIbHbrNIII

flBJIeHngMu,

oH rle Mor BI'IAerb

NtIIOrOqlrc,'rerrI{bIX

3aKOHOMepIIOCTeI"r,

paCKpblBaer{bIX C IIOMOITIbIO

CIeIIH-

a.rrbHbrx N{ep

ro,{bno B coBoKy[Hocrsx.

Ho L{

aro He n3MeHgJIo

ocHoBHoro

IIpIIHIIIIIIa

J'IaIJIacOBCKOIo

AeTepN{HHI{3N{4.

Crerura,rluo

o5cyN4a"uacb raKlKe

IIpo6JIeMa, MoiICHo

J'II{ cql{Tarb

crart'I-

cruqecKrre

3aKoHbr sMrnpuqecKr.rrlu.

KoHIIy XIX

orBer craJl

3Byrlarb

KaK OTprluaTe-rnrnrii:

B craTIIcTr{qecrcoii

raxoHol\IeprIocTI{

c,ryvai'iHocru

ult-

BeJrrrrpyror

Apyr

npym

n BbIAeJI.aercs

ro,rrbro o6uas

Anq

IIHX TeHAeHIIIls.

flperlcraaaHr,re

Kacaerc.rl, Talclll\{

o6pasoirl, noBepxHocrll

gsJrenuii,a

He BHyr-

peHHIIX

IIpfirlflH

r.r3yqaelvlblx npoqeccoB.

flo

uneHnn oAHoro

I{3 JIH.4epOB

rreorro3r{rrrBrraua

P. Kapuaua

(1891-1970),

nonrtrlca

t}opuy"ttttpoBarrrs

o6ulecrnerrnbrx

3anorloB

B crarHcrrlqecrlrx

repMfiHax [pqMo

cBq3aHa

c He-

AocraroqHbrru

3rraHltetr{

Aerepr\{LIHaulr}r

couHanbHltx

garetrul?

I13}Iyrpl{.

"IIllHeitrroe

lorrrrNraHue [puqnHrrocrrl

B KoHrlelqrtLI

AereplluHIl3Ma,

Boc-

xo.4sulerl

KaprrrHe

Nrl{pa, [ocTpoeHHoiI

Ha rlpl'IHulrflax

N{exaHHcTl'IqecKo-

ro N{arepr{aJlu3Nla,

H tsepotrHocrHttii

4erepuuHx3M

6bIJIId npeAcraB,leHbl

Bo I\{Ho)KecrBe

ncuxoJlornqecKlrx

reopttii,

a raxxe ncltxotpusltoJloruqecKllx.

4.1

.2. SnonorrqecKlf AerepMunnsM

H KnaccxqecKars

KaprHHa

Mtlpa

6rrororuqecruii

4erepultttnelt

6ltr cBq3aH c

pa3BIrrI{eM

npe4cran,reHuft

o )KuBoM

opraHll3r\Ie. OH

sx,'IrcqHJI [peA[oJ'IoxeHIIe

pa3BuTtrt{, o B3aIt-

NroAefi

crsnu B

cI4creMe

<opfaHI{3NI-cpeAa>>,

MexaH}t3Max

cra6nnnsal\uu

6uororlr.recKr{x

fipoueccoB Ha orIpeAeJIeHrIoN{

ypoBHe,

AerepMI{I{auuu6y-

AyuIrrM

n r.

ecrb 3Aecb

yxe He [peAcraBr.sercfl

Bo3Ir{oxHbIM

roBo-

pltrr o6 oAHorlr rrlrle

AerepM

vna\vu. OctanonHucg,

oAHaKo,

Ha rlo3l'ttIHI'I

@paucnca

farntoua,

rrl{oHepa s o6racrn

npI4MeHeHIIt

BapnaulroHHoii

cra-

TI4crI{KH

K rIHAr.IBHAya.[bHbII{

oco6euuoctgM

qe/IoBeKa,

anuufi

croro lrcH-

xoJlora

I{ aHTpofionora.

fa,rlrosa npouene,'Ia

6oJ'IbuIoe BneqarJIeHHe

rullra

A. Ker-ne. OH

pac-

[pocrpaHI{JI

rIpllHIrHn

crarncruqecKoro

3aKoHa

yt\lcrBeHHue cnoco6-

Hocrn.

OAuar<o

ecJIII B

<<collr{aJlbHofi

rpusure> orKJIoHeHIIg

or cpeAHero

noJraraJil{cb

<<r{rpy

cryr{aq>,

fa,rlro}Ia

OHII crpofo

AerepMuHHpo-

raur,r

$axropoM

HacJIeAcTBeHHocrl{.

B erou oH

rIoJIaraJIca.Hav4eu

cBoero

ABoropoAHoro

6para

r{.

/{apsuna,

pa3Bl{rble

B rlrrloreae

o nPoncxoxAeHuH

BrrAoB

nyrel{

ecrecrBeHHoro

or6opa. Ctan ocHonare,rent

4ra$QepeHIIHaJIb-

nofi

ncuxo.rrorHt{,

oH uan6o.ree

rIoJI}Io

peanII3oBaJI

trAerc

6no.noruqecKoro

AerepMr.rHr.I3Ma

B cBoeM nocrpoeHuH

o6losuteuuil

Paentieasuteec{

na-

panne,'rbHo accoqllaHllcrcKoe

yqeHne

pa6oru

Ax.

Mun,r.s

o6xoAnlocl

4.1.

flpn'tunHocrb

KaK nphHuhn

HayqHoro

o6rrcHeuzr

ItpuHIlIrnaNIu

N{exaHI,IcrrlqecKoro

AerepMHHr{3NIa,

a nocJIe

ero

Da6or'

xu-

MUqecKoIo.

B HayvHux

rrrKo,{ax,

trplilreArrrHX

Ha c\,reHy

rrcrrxororurr

coaHanlla,6r.ro-

roru'recKrtii

AerepN{rtrr.t3M

craJ'r

oAHuM

tts o6t'stcttute,qbHbtx

rrpr{H

rroB.

I.{lt

yrnepx4aJ'Il{ct"

Bo-IrepBbIX, poJ'tb

aAarrTaIIIIIr,

Ipncnoco6,reHlra

opra-

Hr{3Ma

K cpeAe

B rle,'rsx

Bbrxr{BaFrilr

u, Bo-BTopbrx,

BepoqrHocrulrii

xapax-

rep

pearqHii

KaK

rrpllHrlr{r ecrecrBe}ruoro

or5opa.

3aslrcrnlocrb IIcrIXI,IqecKltx

gs,'IeHrri;i

He or

lrepBHoii

crtcrelrr,t,

a or cpe-

gut

o6urauus

opraur,r3Ma -

Bor ror

ocHosrrorl

Te3uc,

Koroplrii

6lr,r

nono-

xeH

<<ocHOBbI

IICUXOJ'IOIUUr>

cneUCeporr.

Mrt

yNe

foBopIrJ'IrI

r"Iase

efo rIoHI{rlatilIlr

5uo.nortt.recKoii

AerepMuHautrtl

IIpHNreH[Te,rtbHo

K BO3HI{K-

HOBeHTTIO

accorluaqrtri.

3aHuNla.s B

Teopr.Ir4 no3}raHrrq

ilo3rrllillo,

cor/IacHo

xoroport

ueo6xo4Hr,ro

pa3Aen.srb

rro3naBaer.roe

He[o3HaBaeMoe,

pac-

cMarpnBarr

caMoorieBrrAHocrb

anprlopHoro

3HaHrr.{

KaK pe3yrTbrar

Srlelro-

JIOrlrqecKoIo

3aKpeIL'reI{t{.{

oItbrToNI

MHoforrncIeIIHbrx

tIpeAKon,

nptrcnoca6-

Jrr.rtsaBrrrHXc_s

cpeAe.

3ru npnHrlrlru

6u,rn

qerKo

[peAcraB,'reHbr,

rracrllocrrr,

B KoHuerrqllr{

HayqeHrr.rr, paepa6oraHrrori

3. Topu4ar"rxolr (1874-1949)

n ero

ort,rrax

xr.rBorl{brMrl.

Sror aMepuKaHcKt.Itl

ncHxo,tor paapa6ora,t

uosbtrt

Tr,rrr N{e-

TOALITIeCKOIO

OCHaUIeHT{,I

3KCIIepr,INIe}ITOB:

TaI{ Ha3bIBaeNIbIe

<.npo6aerrulte

rulrrKrr>,

ocno5oxgeune

r{3 Koropblx

r{Jru BxoA

B Koropbre

Mor ocyurecrB-

JrflTbcfl

ToJ'rbxo

nyreM

npo6 lr ouu6ox.

Ec,ur

xe c,ryuai;iHo

no BeporrHo-

cTHOMy

IIpLIHUT4IIy

XIIBOTHOe

BbrIrOiIH'J-IO

Hy)KHOe

ABLIXeHI{e,

TO BO3_

Hr.rKa.rra

cB.rr3b

r,{exAy arHNr

ABrrx{eHLIeN{

tr cnryaquefi.

Ho era

cB.s3b

AoJ'r)KHa

6r,t,ra

6nrr

[oAxpenJreHa,

vro5rr

Bo3H]{n

rrHcrpvNreHTalrnrrr-r

yc,rorHr,rfi

pe$rexcl.

tr4rax,

crxau

saKpen,'r.rrrorc{

HepBHor? cncreue

5naro4apl

ne-

pexnBaHIlK)

yAOBneTBOpeHrrfl

floxa

yraxeNr

ro"rrbKo

Ha c,'reAyroulyto

/rrHuro

BrrLts*ufl

5no,roruqecro-

AeTepMr{Hr,r3Ma,

KoTopa.s

He cTa,ra

lpou.nbIN,I

B HcTopt{rr

MeToAo,'rofuu

IIcnxo-{orHr.r.

Ane,t,r.sung

AerepMr{HaIIr{].r,

cBr3a}ruoii

paereprbrBaHr{eNI

upoueccoB

r HepnHoii

cr.rcreMe,

o1rrr

H3 oclronHbrxny"refipedgK4uotlu3-

,illa

B IICI4XO

JIOrLIII.

CyuecreeHHbIM

HarrpaB,rleHlreM pear'rr.t3aqr{14

6Ho.rrorn.{ecxoro

Aerepr\rH-

Hr43Ma

6nt,ro peruenlre

npo6,relttbl

orHolueHn-q

llcilxHlru

AeflTe/tbHocrl,I

Mo3ra,

npoc,'re)KI{BaeMoe

B XX n. s oreqecrBeHHoti

ncuxo,torur.{

B xoAe p.qAa

Aucnycclrii

Illlopoxona,

1968]2.

Brrru,ru

raKxe

KHr{ru,

3aKperrJ'rsBruue

3arcou eQQexma,

one4enuuri Toprr4aiixou,

rrpeauoraraJ'r,

qro

ecr,rr{

pcaKuut

)KI4BorHoro

no/IKpeni'lqercl

uarpa4ori,

To ona 3aKperrJrrercr

B lroBeAerrfir{.

B nocae4yiouue

roAbl B oreqecrBeHHoii

dln;rocoQcKo-rrctrXo;'rorrJ.{ccxor:i

r,rxrepa-

Type cocrorJracb

AncKyccl4.g

npo6,reue urearrbHoro,

roropori

flporr4BorrocraB-rrr-

l l-{

100 fnaea

4. [-lph.lr4uHocrb h

aerepMuHH3M

B Meroaolorhh

HavKh

MeTOAO,rrOIUqeCKoe

O6oCHOBaHT{e ny'reii

peureuIIg

I]cuxo0l{3HoJ'ror}IqecI(oii

npo5,rel.rr,r B cropolry

pacKpbrrr{s

nce

6olee

uy6orux MexaHII3MoB

cBq3I4

rrcHxl{qecKoro r{ [cuxo(blr3lro,rrorrlqecKoro

KaK .sKo6br cHHMaIoil{xx

3Ty

npo6,reny

["IIouon,

1984].

Oco5yro,rr

r,rHuro B

pa3Br.rrrr

n 6no,toruqecKoro

AerepMHHrI3Ma

c,rleAyer

cBq3arb c KoHuerqr{efi II. K. Asoxuua

(1989-1974).

6,'raro4ap{ ero reo-

pHn

$yHxql{o}ra,'rbr{brx

cucreM

roH,rrne aKIIe[Topa

4eficrnlra

BBeJIo

Ho-

Boe llolrlrlraslre

ue,reeoii

[pHqrIHbI B cxeMbl

HayrrHoro noeuartng. IrI He

clyvaiino

ptrlloM

ncrlxo,'IoroB

ora reopl,rs npoAo,'IlKaer

pacc\,{arpl4Barbct

KaqecrBe ncrrxorlHslro,{oruqecKoro

ocHoBaHu.s,uerepN{I{HucrcKoro no-

H Ir MaH n.a

ue,r

en o ii

peryJ'r.q

r4 rr

eAeH

r,r.g.

Eule

paurure

B rrpr{Hur,rlax

{ruslrolornu

aKTuBHocrLI H. A. EepuurreliHont

(

1896- 1966)

6rtnt

pa:pa6oraHu

AposHesae

rpeAcraB,'Iellnt o

pery,II.tIuHI{

AglrxeHrrtl

4elicrwrii,

rAe rle,'rb cBr3blBa,'racb

noHr{T}IeNI

4wtrare,rluoli

aa-

ratrnnoHxrue

o6paaa norpe6uoro 6yAyulero 6rtro

rKarcqeuo B rlcuxoJlou{-

qecKylo

pery,{qrlnrc,

a He

roJrbr(o o ncuxoonslro,'rorHrlecKylo.

Ho e ncnxo$l.rsuororrrvecKux

rrccJreAoBalrr{tx

pa3tsIlBalorc.g

u 6o,ree

<<rrpocrbre> npurruHl{ble npeAcraB,'IeHuq

o cBfl3u ncuxl{qecx}Ix.gereHlrii lt

[polleccoB,

c oAnoii cropoHbr, ]I ilpoueccoB,

rlpoucxoA.xul.Ix B N{o3roBbIX

crpyroypax,

4pyroir.

Onu

nocras,'r{ror

Bce

HoBbIe

cBeAeIIr{t o c"roxHo-

cTr{

MexalII43MOB

pa6oTbr

MO3fa, Ho

ylpouapr cauy npo6,reMy rrcllxllqecKoro

o6paaa

Qynruuii

flcr{xuqecKoro),

yrnepN4as

MoHI{3M

KaK cBeAeHt.Ie I{e-

xarru3MoB rrcrrxlrqecKor"I

perynflulrlr K rlpoIIcxoAqIIInN{ B Nt03ry [poqecca]{.

Ilplr4epxlrearcurnecq

raxofi nocraHoBI(Ir Borlpoca

IIccJIeAoBare tu se o6

paqaloT

BHUMaHII' Ha [oJIOXeHL{g

TOM,

qTO

MO3rOBbIe MeXaHH3MbI

MO-

ryr

paccr{arpilBarbcJr

KaK rrpoAyKT

<<pa3Br,rrr,rq calrofi npe4rrleruoii

AefreJlb-

Hocrx>

(A.

"{eoHrree),

vro KarrecrBeHHbre oco6eHnocrn

Apyroro

ypoBHs

cucrer\{Hocrr{

He Moryr 6ltrr nupaxeHrr

Qr.IauoJrofuqecKllx

lroH.{Tuqx

lr r.

IrIueHHo raroro

po4a

nclrxoQu3[o,'roruqecKnfi

MoHH3M N{oxHo

pac-

cN{aTpI{BaTb B KaqecTBe BapHaHTa

peAyKUHor{I{3M4.

PeAyruuounru

(or

nar.reductio)

cunxeHue, cBeAellue;

paccMarpu-

BaeTc.q KaK xapaKTepHcTr{Ka

reopnii, IHnoTe3

BbIBoAoB H3

rlcl.Ixororu-

I{CCKOfO

HCCJIE.UOBAHI1Ig, TIOAMCHqIOIqI{X

S O6OCUOSAHI{'X IIOHI{MAHHC IICH-

xo,'IoruqecKot?

rpuulruuocrr{ [pr{H rIHnaMr{

o6rrscueuu fi

cnoft

crneuurtx

rrpeAcraB.rreHnro ilpeAMera u3yqeHu.q

ApyrHX

HayKax. PeAyxqfiouneN{,

rroHrrMaeMbrfi xax

cHHxeH Ire>>,

03Har{aer

yrrpoueHHe

upe4cran"neHnfi o6

,'rucb lrr:ler4

3. tr4,rberrxosa

!. [y6poecxofo,

npeAcraBI,rtsurtx

cyillccrBeHHo orJnrqalo-

ul{ecq

no3Hur{u B MaTepHa,'Ir'{cTuqecKom

llolII{MaH[Ir

AeTepN{I,IHauI{Il

oT cpeAcTB

TpaHc,'IflllrilI

Aeqre,rbltocru

KaK orrocpeAcrByrcruero 3Rerra

nttQoplratlrrortlblx Ko-

/lOB

AegTer'TbIIOCTII

MO3fa.

4.2.

3apoxaeHrae

npeacraeneHri

o nchxonorh.{ecxoi

nphqhHuocrh

101

I4ccJ'reAyeN{blx

6asucnrrx

nporleccax,

KaK <<cBeAeHrre>> -

r4x

[oAN{eHy

npo-

qeccaMI4

ApyrHX

yponueii

(ue

nclrxo,rou{vecKor"r,

nHoii rpoprlrlr peryJrfl-

uIrH

cot{ualnnoli,

ncuxo$lrsr.roJ'torr{qecroli

n r.

a.).

CeroAHs ncuxoQneuo,rortl.recKuli

peAyrur{oHrr3M

rtprrHqr'r

uorue

rpop-

Mbr; 3ToNry

cnoco6crsogaJ'rrr

cyluecrBeHHbre

cABI,rru

pacxpblTHfl

<<Mexa-

HI,t3MoB

coarraHr{q>

B cxeN.tax

o6o6UeHr.rtl

<.HefipoH-uoAer'Ib-Teopllg>,

T. e.

Mrrrryrr

ypoBeHb

co6crneuHo

I]crrxoJrorHqecKr.rx.rrB,rreHnri.

lloAueua

c.ropoH-

HuKaMr.r

raKoro

rroAxoAa

coAepxaHu.q

rcnxo,ron{qecKoro

3HaH11fl

o6ocHo-

BaHI,IeM

Apyroro

rI4rra

lcuxo$rrar.ro,{ornqecKrrx

rrrnore3

u ro3Bor.ser

IoBopI4rb

peAyI(qIIoHLI3Me.

pauxauu

Harrrero

toco6us

ocrarorc.fl

TaK)Ke

Bonpocbr

co4ucuwro.rl

)emepuuuusue,

coorBercrBeHHo

H o BapuaHrax

courraJ,rbHoro

peAyKurlo-

HI,I3Ma

IlocrpoeHI{H

rlcuxoJrlorl{qecKI4x

o6r,"qcuenufi

4.2.

3apoxaeHhe

npeacraBle*uit

o nchxolorhqecKot

npHqHHHOCTh

4.2.1

. BosFtxxHoaeHre

npeacrasneHNi

o nchxolorHqecKoi

npl.tqhHHocTh

Parree ualttt

6rt,lo

noxasaHo,

rrro

BbIAeneHI{e

HayqHoro

ficuxoromqecKoro

3HalrH.q

npot{cxoAHJlo

B xoAe

$opnuponaurlq

accoqlraHr{crcnoro

HarrpaBJre-

HH.q,

np[r{eM Ha pa3rrbrx

ocrroBalrrr.sx

paMKax

rpr.r,rocor}uu (uerarSlrsnxH)

Qnauo,roruu.

flepronavarblro

ero cralroB.rrenl{e

cyx{ecrBeHHo

Br,lrs,Jrrr

ycnexu

ecrecrBo3HaHl'I.g'

qro

BtIPDKaJ'Iocb

B rIpHHgrI{t{

I{AeI,I

AerepMI{HI{3Ma

cHaqala

MexaHrrcrurrecKofo,

IloroM

6ttoaotnqecroro.

{a-tlHel"fluee

pa3BI,ITLre

flcllxoJrorr.rqecxoii

uayr<u

6lr.7lo

cn.saaHo

c r.r3MeHeHHeM

KaK O6Iur.rX

o5lscurt-

TE,]IbHbIX IIPIIHUIITIOB,

BKNIOqATUIUX

TE IIJ'II{

IIIIbIC

IIPEACTABJICHII,fl

ACTEP-

MHHI{3Me'

TaK H IlcuxoJ'IorllqecKl{x

HayqHblx

[apall{r\4

B TIOHHMaHI{11

Trpv-

qEHHOCTT4.

AaHUOl,t

naparpaoe

[peAcraBJ,IeHbr

MeroAoJ'IoruqecKue

cxeMbr

noHuMaHrr.fl

rrpr{qr{HHocrtl

B oprleHTupoBxe

Ha ro,

rrro

yue6Hou

toco6uu

Bo3Mo)KHo pa3BecrH

3TH

ABe

B3aI{MocB.{3aHHble

J'II4HHrI

ncl{xoJlorHqecKofo

o6t.scueHn.q (Aerepuuull3M

rpnqHHuocrl),

rocKonbKy

oHH

He rroJrHocrbto

coBlaAar'rrl

B JloruKe

pa3Br4Trlg.IrCHXOJrOrUqeCKux

KoHqenqHii

MeroAoB

KaK

MeroAo,'rorrqecKr{x

ocHoeaHnfi

pacKpbrr'l.tq

rcuxoJroruqecKr,rx

3aKoHoMep-

uocrerl.

3eo,rrcqu.q

rc[xororuqecxoli

urrlc,rr4

Hayq]Ioii peno"nnqun

XVII

HcIIoJ'Ib3oBaJIa

rIpeAcraBJ'IeH!I.q

IIpeAMexaHrIcrl{qecKoro

AerepMIrHlI3Ma.

lleprao4

ABux{eHHr

Ilcnxor'IoruqecKux

npeAcrae,'reHuii

B cropoHy

rrepexo-

Ha ararr,

coorBercrByrcqNft

nr'raccrrqecKor.l

xapruue

MHpa,

c,,reAoBaJ,ro

'102

lnaaa

4. flphquHHocru

aerepvhgr4gv

veroaonorhh

Havrrl

6lt Ha.larb

c rprr,roco$un

PeHe

flexapra,

uarrryBrlefo 3a paMKrl

cxoJ'racrr.rKH

I,t 3aJ'ro)KI{BIrIero

oc}{oBbl

dqanusua

B IroHIrNraHue

rrpttrJuHHo]."1

AerepMlrl{a-

ullrl

Ha rrHoNI ypoBHe,

rlet\{

gro

rlpocJ'Ie)KllBanocl

Aplrcrorer'It.

paane,rr

AerepMunaunro 4eiicrnulr

qenoBexa

pa3nbrM

ypoB}r-rrN{ -

Te,rra rr

Ayun,

c<$opuy,ruponaa

ucux-crcpu3r.{qecxyro

npo6neuy

AaB

peilreHr.re

paM-

Kax zunome

su s s auuo d e ilcmBufl

flcuxrr.Jecr{oe (o6paa)

He BKJ'rrova,lrocb

B [pr{r]uHnbre ycr'roBr

gefrcrnwx

re,ra

(lrax

arror.rara).

flprrur.rHa

rroJriirzr-rzcb

BoBHe

pa3Apo{rlrreJ're.

HenporaxeHHa.q

AyxoBHax

cy5crauqrr.rr

He N,rol'J'ra aHaJTrr3rrpoBarbc.s

Ae-

TepMrIIIrIcTcKIrx

rlo3lrlll4ri.

Ho c TaI{oBItx

Nlot"IIH o6t

gcusttt'cg

ABI4xeHIr.{

opraHH3NIa

KaK aBToN,rara,

T. e. N{arrr{Hbl.

K arolry

BpeN{eHu orHoclrrcf

IIo-

-aBJreHre

rep\{uHa <<MexaHr,r3l\r>

rax o6osHaqeuue ycrpoi'rcrna,4eiicrnyrc-

u{efo

col;IocHo 3aKOHaNl

MeXatIUKI4

(nO:Xe

OH CTa,'r IICIIO,rIb30Barlc.q

B 6o-

,'Iee

ruuporoM

cMbrcre).

Iarorenux Ayuru

coBeprua,rrucb

n rapreauaucxoii

KaprlrHe

qe,iroBel{a

ro cBorrM 3axo}Ia\r;

rrr{

}{e rpe6oaa,rocl

rpurlnHHoro

o6ocuosaHug,

[ocxoJlbny oHII

IIe orHocr,Ir'u,Icb

crrcreMe [pocrpaHcrBeH-

rro-BpeNreHHoir

lprrvurrrrocrr.r,

AeiicrByroulefi

Bo BrreurHelr

l\1r{pe.

Aa,ree

ocraHotsr{l\{c.fl

rra roN{

[pe4craBneH

rrrr, Koropoe

xapaKTepLr3oBa-

-4O

I]epBoe rrcuxoJrrorrrqecr(oe

norrtrMaHle

[pnqrH]{ocTI{,

cB.{3aHHoe

c Bbr-

Ae,'IeHrleM

ncrlxo"rroruIn B ca\.tocro.qrenbIIyrc

o5,ractr

3HaHIIl"I.

XVII

no XIX B.

K.rraccrrqecra.q rravra rrpoAenana

6o,rluofi

rryrb

K3N{eFreHHr,r rroHHMaHrrs

Ipr{HrIuIIa

AeTepMr{r{rr3Ma,

qTo

ar(Tr{BHo

rrcnonb-

3OBa,'tOCb

nepBbIMI,I IICUXOJ'IOfLIqeCKlrN{I{

KOHIIeI]LI}IflMLI,

HaqlrHa.fl

C BbIAe-

"rreHr{r

rcr,rxoJ'Iorlrqecxoir

trpo6,reil{aruKH

B r,rcc,'reAotsaHuxx

!x.

,Iloxxa n

X. By"rrrQa, MbrcJ'rqulux

r,r3Haqa"rrbHo

rrcrrxoJTorrilo

paMKax

(rr,roco$-

cKoro

3HaHLrq. flosxe

Ha cMeHy srnNr

KoHrlenuHsN{

rrp}runu

v4ev 6vono-

f HqecKoIo

AeTepMI,IIIU3N{a.

Accoql.rarnnnoe

HanpaBneHrre (nr-nrcva-q

[pHMbrKaroulyrc

K HeN,ry KoHr{e[-

uuto

H. O. fep5apra)

n uepnorl ro,rroBlrHe

XIX

e. npeAcraBr.rno

repByro KoH-

uelul{rc

flcuxo,'tofllqecKofi

npuq]I]IHocrll.

Srtrna ouo orr'Illua.rlocb

or accoun-

aHn3Ma

6olee

paHHero

BpeMeHrr

(nepuoga

pa3Brrrrrr

K,naccriqecxoii

Hayxu),

<<nad)oc

noroporo

cocro.sr n

ton, vro6u o5rgcHurr

cBq3b

H cMeHy [cilxuqe-

CKHX .rIBJIeHr,rrt

o6texrnnHori

AHHaMilxofi

re,recuux

flpoqeccoB

(xor<lpaa,

cBoro

oqepeAb, IIoHT,IMaJ'Iacb

cIIepBa IIo

TI'Iny MexaHr{KI'I,

3aTeM

aXyCrtrxn)"

["fpouencxuii,

AHulrQeposa, 1974,

c. 1BB].

CxoAcreo B ro3rurr.qx

aHrnuii-

cKrrx H

HeMeuKux cropoHHuKoB

aMnup[qecrotl

nclrxo,torllu

6blno B

ToM,

qro

oIIIr orKa3a,rlI4cb

I'rcKarb rpLIrtI4HHbIe

06ocHogaHu.{

ncr{xllqecKoro

B TaKr{x 06-

,Tacrqx,

KaK

Ayua,

c oAnoii

croporrbr, u

SHalro,rorlu

4pyroli.

Ecnu

aroro nepuoAa

n.ue.s 3aKoHoNrepHoro

riporeKaHr,rn

[cr{xuqe-

cro{x IpoueccoB ocHoBbtBa,rracb

IIa aner.-rrunfx

rpueuuecxo.rry

nan

$n-

4.2.3apoxaenr4enpeacraeneHtalionchxonorh.tecroinph.+it-'tHocrr

103

314oJIolugecKo^{y'

To TeIIepb

IIcIIxHqecKoe

cTa"rlo BblcTynaTb

ts KarIecTBe

ca-

MocTosre"'rbuoii

pea,rr'uocrl.r,

xapaKreplrayelrori

He roJlbr{o

cnequrltnxoii

,{ueHilIi,

Ho rr cnerlr4(bnxoli

aaxouoB

Kan

3aKorroN{epnocreii

4yurennoii

Ae.fTeJIbHocTLI,

He ctsoAItMIIIX

ApyrIIM.

Acco4ua4ua

cra"{a paccNrarpr.{tsarbcg

KarlecrBe

oc}roBHoro

[pnqflH-

HOIO OCI{OBaHtrq

rcnxrqecKoro

6arcus,

a flocr(oJlbt(y

[ctlxor'rolr{g

B sTor

rlepl4oA

r'{blcr'Ill-rlacb

KaK

u3yqeHl'Ie

co3Ha}II4g,

To I'I MexaIlII3M

accoUlla-

uIIr{

craJl paccNlarprrBarbc.q

KaK

I.ti\{MaHeHTrrbrfi

rtpl{Hqnn

co3rrarruq.

flo3-

)tt e C

B lIT II e il{ 3

l( C I ep

U N{ e IITaJ'l

b H O f O

N{ €TOA a B

lI C I{ X O,'l O IlI

U, II 03

B OJ'I II B

IUeIO

3aBepIIIIITL

BbIAeJIeHLIe

IICl{XOJ'lofIIII

B caN{OCTOtTCJ'IbIIyp

IIayKy,

HayqHbIM

coo6rrqecrnoNl

6bulo

npr.rHtro

Apyroe

[orrrrMaHr.re

rIpI{qrIHHo-

cr}j, rrJrri

Kay3ar'rrrHocrfl,

onrlparc[leecr

IIoHqrrIe

4ciicrnynqeii

npuvrr-

HLt

(eos4eiicrelrx).

(Doprr,ruponaHrre

HayrrHo-KareroprlaJrb]roro

arulapara

TaKxe

g.tsrl[Jrocb

tlcroKoNt

rloplrnponailIl'I

[cIIxo,rIorIIlI

KaI{ or4e,unoii

o6tactw,

rrayqHbrx

3HaHr.rri.

rplrleprul

Hayqnocrr.r

B rrcuxoJ'rorrrrr

rr3i\re-

II.flJ'II'tcb

B cB.tl3l{

AUHaNIIIKoI"I

rIoAxoAoB

It l]olttr]\raHllru

[puIIII]Ila

npn-

qI,{IIHOCTI,I.

OAuaro,

qro6bt

6o,ree

qetKo

[peAcraBr.trb

tsKJraA pa3Br{Tut

3r(crrep,Me'-

TanbHoro

NteToAa B

Lr3MeHeHU.q

rroHuNrafirrr

Itpr{qtrrrHocTrr,

cJ'Ie/IyeT

Bep-

Hyrbc.s

n rny6l

BeKoB

yqeHrrro

Apucrore,rx,

BbrAe,rrr,rBnreMy

qe.rbrpe

Br4Aa flpuquHrrocTrl.

Or,rlr.rne

B rIoHt{t\,IaHLII,I

npnqHHHocrII y

aHTI,Iq}tblx

NIbIcJltlTe,reii

u trc-

cJreAoBare.rreii

n anoxy

KJrraccrrqecKoii

nayrclr

cocrorrr

B ToNr,

qro

B 3[oxy

aHTIITIHOCTI,I

nptrqr,rrlHocrb

He cBg3bltsajracr,

soaAeiicrBuelr.

14lterilro

ecte-

crBerrHo-HayqHarr

rrapaAurN{a yrBepAr.rJ'la

norrHMaHr.re

Qnalrvecxofi

npnvuH-

Hocrlr KaI{

BxJl}oqarcqeti

npe4craB"rleHtle

ro1\{,

rrro

oAHa

luarepnaJlbHarl

Tor{Ka Moxer

4eiicrronarb

Apyryn,6yAyrtvr

pa3AeJ'renrrbrM}t

B rrpocrparr-

crBe

n BpeMeHr.r.

I{e,necoo6pa3HocTb

xe rorAa

erle

paccNraTpHBaJracb

B Korrrexcre

npncnoco6,reHr.rs

HHAlrBtr4a (opratrnaua)

x cpe4e.

Apucrore,rr, pacnpocrparlu,r

rtoH.srl{e <<rrprlqIIHbI>

Ha Bce NIIIpo3AaHIIe.

<.KoHeqHa.q>,

r4.rlrl <<ue,treBa.q>,

fipuqnHa 6una

BBeAeHa

A,rIt

yra3aHr.Ig

c[e-

qu$uru

peryJrs[r.ru

rrotseAeHnr

)KuBbrx

re-lr.

Bcero, corJracHo

<.Meradtu-

3[Ke>

ApucToTeJ'rq,

cJleAyeT

BbIAeJI.gTb

C"rreAyrutque

rleTblpe

BuAa

lp]lqrrH,

cBs3ar{Hr,rx

rvrexAy

co6oii:

rrepBas

rpur{r4Ha (causa

mateialis)

Marepus

rurr cy6crpar;

Bropaq

(causa

formalls)

rfopua,'rbHarr,

a roqHee

$opun

HrH ci6-

pa3a

BerI[,

orpaxarcuag

<<...cyulHocrb,

rr.Jltt

cyrb 6blTtrr

BeuII{...>>;

Tperbt

UeJ'reBa.q

[pr.rquHa (causa

finalis)

<.ro,

orKyAa

HaqaJ'ro

ABtr-

)Ker{ug>>;

[pr,r sToM

noA

ABlr)KeHlIeN{

uN{eeTc{

B BtlAy

TOJTbKO rlpo_

cTpaHcTBeI{HOe

IIepeN{eruelIne,

Ho t{ KaqecTBet{Hoe

LI3NIe}reHIIe;

1..]id

104

lnaaa

4. fiph.lnHHocru

aereplahxh:,\a

Naeroaonorh,a

Hayrh

qerBeprarr

(causa

efficiens)

npnqr{Ha,

lporr4BoJl€xarqa-s

nocleAneit,

a HrvIeHHo <<To, paAr1

r{efo>>,

<ttlu

6rtaro...>.

Ero

uerarpopa

II3roroB.rreHrLrI

Beulrr Kar{

Ae.{HI.r{

N.facrepa

AelvroHcrpLlpyer,

rrTo

Hr.r o/[Ha

r.r3 Ha3BaHrrbrx

ilputrnrr He rroA,lexr{T pacc\roTpeHtrro

Kay3a"/rb-

Hor:r cBr3rr.

KaNAas r{x 3TLrx

rprrqrrH

rro-cBoel\{y

olpeAenser

cyrb, trpoucxox-

Aellue

l-l rra3HaqeHue

Bell].r, Ho Hu

oAHa He flBng,ercfl

noe4eiicrnyrculeiil.

llo

Aplrcrorenrc,

oAyrrreBJrel{r{oe

re/ro r{t\{eer

[pnquny

ABHxeHnt

B ]reN,r

ca\{oN{,

Tor.qa Kar(

Nra[ruHa, N{exaHr{r{ecKoe

opyArre, [pnBoAHTcrr

ABHxe]rIIe

u3BHe, o6nraHbrsa.q

npupoAy,

rloJlb3yrcb

HeKr.rN{ ee

cerperoN{.

r{e,toger.an-

Irserctr

nprrpoAHbllr

re,,roM,

AJr{

Hero

ueJ'reBa.q

[putrlrHa

Jrexur

n Yrue

(Hyc

lo Aprrcrore"nro).

Apr.rcroreJrb

Mblcr'rr{,rr

Aytxy

tr reno Hepa3AeJrbHbrMu,

I4 ero

ueneBarr

[purrHrla

BbrpaxaJ,Ia ycTaHoBlry,

r{To

<<[pupoAa

Hrrqero He

AeJraeT

HaIIpaclIo>>.

Te,reo,torlr.iecKtrrl

xapaKTep

TpeTber"r npnqt{Hbr

03HarIa,'I

nepBo-

HaqaJrbHo

opHeHTlrpoBaHHocTb

uenb

Toro, B

r{eN{

Hepa3AeJ'Ibr{o rrpeAcTaB-

,teHo 6rro,torlrqecKoe

H rrcnxr{qecKoe.

3ro cKopee

qelecoo6paaHocrb,

qeM

HarrpaBJ'terrHoctt

4eiicrelrg

nctrxo./roruqecrr,r

rtoH.rlToit

uenbro

(rax

cosua-

Te,tbHbr v npeaBocxHruetruev).

IIoc.ne Kpaxa

arrrHrlHocrrr

peJ'tlIrrro3rroM

yr{eHr,ru

AnrycrnHa

reJleo,ro-

rur{HocTr,

KaK

uer'reBa{

HarrpaBJrerrHocrt

npuo6pe"la

Qopuy

14HAerepMr.lHH3-

ua. Ho

pa3Br{Tue

[rayKr.{

BbIABr.rHyJro

lrHorl npnnqllrr

npr,rql{}IHocrr,r,

I(o-

TOpbIM n 3aKpeIII{J'IOCb

Ha3BaHUe

Kay3anbHolo;

rt oH o3HaqaJ'r

[popbrB

rroHHlIaHlrrr

[prlr{II}rbr

KaI( Bo3Ael"rcTBilfl,

cneAcTBrle KoToporo

npeA-

onpeAeJrer{o

3aro}roM

(

Heo6xo4lruocrbro

AocraroqHocrblo

cnonuit

gnz,

ero

npotBne

uua). Ilpuuuurto

ut e 0 cm a

euuani

BbrBoA KaK

Hayr{rrbrii

strsoA o

Kay3a,'rbHbrx B3ar4MoorHoueHuqx

NrexAy JtBJ'reHr{stlrH

ue 6u,r

pa3BI{T}reM

apI,IcroreJ'reBcKLIX

[peAcrae,'Ierrtti.i

o npllr{flHe

cNIbIcJIe

<<Har]aJIa

ABI{xe-

tilrq'>. B Hayre Honoro

BpeN{eHH

cJ'ro)KtlJrrocb

r.rHoe

IIoHnMaHue

[pHrruHrlo-

cru.

3To

ngex eosdeilcmeyrcu,eu

nplrqlrHbr,

Koropa.rr

6tt,ra

BocnpuH.qra

B CXeMaX

peanLI3aUr{u

sKcnepr{MeHTa,'rbHof

N,reToAa.

4.2.2. Kayt;tlbHocrb

B Klaccrqecxoi

l,t

uexlacchqecKhx

napaaxrMix

K,taccuqecxa.s

KaprHHa

Mlrpa

fiepBoHaqa"rl

bHo 6aalrpona,racb

Ha 3aKoHax

NIexaHI{Krr

B IIoI{I4MaH}II{

AereptlulHusN{a.

Ho oAI{oBpeN,{eI{Ho

oHa

rlo"nara-

J'Iacb H Ha

gKcnepu,veHmcubHArc

napa)uz.trty

pa3Br,rrrrr{

Hayr{Horo 3HaHnq,

Koropaf,

cra"rra o6uleii

rJrfl

pAAa

ecrecrBeHHbrx

HayK It o3HaqaJ'Ia

K oKoHrra-

Cor,ractro

4pyroii

auttllu pa3N,rbrIr.[erllt,

ltJraroHotscKot-t,

raxoe

geaHl.Ie

03rraqa-

co6urnc,

l,tJilr <<nepexoA

H BbrxoA

.rero

6b|ro

nlr 6r,rao rr3

llecyillecrBoBalu4t

npucyrcTBr4to,>

(llaaroH,

.,fIup,>).

YlreHue,

fi,'rn TexrritKa,

TaKxe

He flBrreTcs npn-

qnttHo

AericrnvX)ilItrNl

$axroporr.

orro larll BbIBoAt.rr

cyrllce

143 rroraeltltoro,

o6ec-

IIerIlIBaeT efo

npHcyTcTBHc,

Ho He npHrltilty.

4.2.

3apoxaeurae npeacraerreH14i

o ncnxonorh,recxoi nph.{tiuliocru'105

Huro

HoBoro BpeMeHH

yxe

rrHoe

[pr,rHtrue

olpeAe,'IeHHoIi,rorltrlt npo-

Bepr(n

reoperuqecxrrx rurore3

Ha rlyrll, xoroptn:'t 6tt,l nrtpa6oraH B

Irpo-

TuBoBec

r{riAyr(rrrBHoN,ry MeroAy. O6ureii ocHosoii

aroii napa4nrNlbl craJl

nyrb

AoKa3areJILcrBa

or lrpornBHoto,

o6ocuonauultfi s 1934r. K. llonne-

polu Kar( o6uta.s J'IorrIKa

ycraHoBJleHu.q

aKcnepuMenTaJrbHblx

Qarror

npll

rrpoBepr(e

Hayqlrbrx reopuit. Taxunr

o6paeolr, coBceM rle IIo3IITrtBrl3NI c,IIe-

AycT

no,'rararb B ocHoBy raK Ha3brBaerroii

3KcncpHlrerrraanHoi.i napaallf-

MbI

B IIayKe. B or"rtt.Iue or MeroAoJIorIrLI

no3I{TLIBIIBN{a, NIeroAoJIorLIg

3Kc-

Irepr{Mer{TrrpoBaHLrq

c noaltullit

KpumuqecKozo

pearus.IrL

[pe[rloJzla"rlz

ocHoBHoe

3BeHo

reoperuqecKrrx

peKolrcrpylrrltrii

onopy

rIoHuMaHrIe

3aKoHa

Kaprnrre r,rlrpa.

flpyroii

nonpoc, KaI(

arn

pa3Hble

MeroAo"rlorlrlt

flrlpoBo3rnalll'aJl|4cb

pea,'IblIo

ucno"tlb3oBa,'Illcb

B HayqHbIX lIIKo,'Iax.

Tpu

ocnonubre

ycnoBuq

rtpur{HHHoro

(raysa-nruoro)

nueo4a 6rIrut soc-

flplrHnrbl

ncrrxo,rorueii elrecre c BK,'noqeHrreM

3KclepuN,IeHTa"'Ibuoro Mero-

B KaqecrBe cpeAcrBa rtalr6o-nee

crpororo cnoco6a [poBepKI{ Teoperl{r{e-

cKIIx

rurlores.

3rH

yc,'IoBug

o3Harlar'II{

o[peAeneHrly]o B3aIIMocBg3b J'IoTLIKII

BbrBoAa

opraHu3ar{rrH npe.ql{errro-rryBcrBeHuofi

4eRrerlHocru

Hcc,'Ie.qo-

Barers,.

OHa

cra,ra Ha3brBarbcg no3)Ke

arcrlepuMellranrtroti napa4trruoii,

IIOCKOJIbKy

K,'raCCUqeCKOe IIOrrHMaHrre npHqIIHHOCTIT

fip'IN{O COOTHOCTIJIO

paapa6orry reoperrrqecKux 3aKoHoB

orlucaHuq Ml,rpa c 3KcrIeprIN{eIrra,'IbIIbINI

MeTOAolr

npoBepKH

HayrrHr,rx

IrrnoTe3.

frrnotetrilro-AcAylrTuBHbttj

trrcroA

HanpaBngn

flonyqeHlte

sNrrIrrpr.rqecKlrx

Aa]IHblx

ue"'rbIo

IIpoBepKI{ TeopeTrl-

rlecKux

yTBepXAeHIII"{,

ilpeAlloJlaratl

Tpl{

ycJIoBlIf'

I{oTopble BbIIIo,'III{JIItcb

TaKI{M

IICCJIeAOBaHIIeil.

fIpn.rr.rHa rrpeArlrecrByer Bo BpeMeHu

cJIeAcrBIrIo. lloc,re4yrcql,Ie BbI-

soArr o6 l,rMrrr'rlIKaruBHor\.I

orHolreHr{r{, BblpaxaeMble B BbIcI(a3bIBa-

HI{.gX TtIila

<.EC,'il1...

TO...>>,

O6eCreqrrBaIOTCq

y[paBJ]IeHHeN{

rIpUqIlHI{O

Aeficrgylotqero

Sarropa,

uJIIr

aKcIIeplIMeHTaJIblloro uoaAetlcrgrtq.

Qyqecrnyer

KoBapuaqux

(ue

cryr{a}"rHaq cna:n) MexAy u3MeHeHH.q-

MH ilpuqnHHo

4eiicrnyrcqeft

nepeueHrrori

(HasltnaeNloii

raxxe He3a-

ilrcuruoii

)

c,rreAcrBrre M, Lr:/rrr Ir3MeIreHI{sMu

(tuxcupyeMoii

ean trcil

naofi nepeueHnoii.

OrcyrcrBylor

lioHxypnpyloure

rllnore3bl, r. e. [poBepseMo]i reope-

ruqecroii rurrrore3e KaK o6bscHq

nuleii

ycraHaBJ'II{BaeMy}o

aMnnp}I-

qecrylo

3aroHoMepHocrb He

Moryr 6urr npoutBorlocraBneHbl croJlb

:xce

cn./rbHbre

o6rscwesux,

ucxoA.rruue ua

4pyroii

reopnu

vrv

aHart4-

Apyroro

Kpyra

nepeMeHHbrx

(rar

noa4eltcrByloulllX

Saxropon).

{erepunultsM

TaKoro Kay3aJrb}roro rI{IIa

orpaKarr rIoI{{THe rtputllrHHocru

Hosoe BpeM.g Ha arane craHoBreHu.q

B ecrecrBo3HaHruKraccltuecxoii rap-

TrIHbr

Mrrpa. B XX s. B

paMKax

npaKTuqecKl4

Bcex rlcuxoJlornr{ecxux ruxor,