Корнилова Т.В. Смирнов С.Д. Методологические основы психологии

Подождите немного. Документ загружается.

lnaea

2. hcroprar

pagehrhs

11 cospeNaeFrHsre npeacrasneFthr...

rNI{CCKOI"I

CB"q3I,I NICX{AY KOCBEIIHO BEPIIOUUI{PYCMbIMII H IIP.qMO BEPI{SN-

qrlpyeMbrN{r{

yrBep}KAeHr.reN{r4).

fIo,loxeHrr.s HayqHbrx reopHii orHocqrcq

uNfeHrro K KocBerrHo BepIl(DI{uilpyeNrbrM

yTBep](AeHn.qN{,

no3ToMy rrpr{3Ha-

rrue frpatso\repHocTlr

Tar(oi.i npolle^vpbr Bepild)uriatlL{r.t npriBe,To

r( rroBbl-

llreHuro craryca ca\{ori Hayvur-lii TeopuII, IIocKonbKy reoperxr{ecKaa

pa6o-

ra rrpuo6pe,ra oTHocr{TeJ'IbHyro

He3aBHcr,rN'locTb

oT 3N{nrIpHr{ B oTcyTcTBr.re

Tpe6oBaHrls rtouaroBoii

pMrl].rpHqecKori

eepr.rQuxarlr{u xaxAoro HoBoro

yr-

BepxAeHrr.s rrnr4 BbrBOAa.

Kpnrrrxa

ro3rrrr{tsr{3r\{a,

BKJ'IIoqar ero IIo3AHue

pa3HoBr{AHocrr{,

BeJracb

pa3nbrNrr

NreroAoJron{rrecKr.tN,Ir{ HarrpaBneHrraulr. Aueplrxaueu V. KyairH

(

1908-2000), uuenruuii cB.s3r.r c BeHcrrnr Kpy)KKoNr, c rrolnrrtrtt JtozuqecKozo

npa?Jvamu3.rta o6nnlf.'.tt cTopoHHI{KoB IIo3LITIIBtt3Ma B HeAocTaTor{HoN{ BHIr-

NtaHI{I{ K TaKOMy CyUeCTBeHHOMy CJ'IOrc Hayr{HOrO

3HaH}Lg, KaK Cr{CTeMa r,rH-

Teprrperarlur{ aMfir{pxqecrux

AaHHbrx,

ponb

Koropoii nrrnorH.qer uMeHHo

Teoplr.rl, u c[paBeAJlr]no o6paqa-r B]rrrMaHlre Ha 3aBucuMocrl

cauoti

3MrIu-

prrH

or reoptrr{. Eo,ree

pa3BepHyra.{

u KoHcrpynruBHa.s

Kplrr}rKa rro3r{Tr{Bv

cTcKor"I MeTOAoJIOTUH B nOHIINIaHHTI CyUIHOCTTT 14

pasBUTHg

HayqHOrO 3Ha-

Hr.rx ocyuecrBJreHa n

pa6orax

T. Kyua, K.

flonrepa, tr4. Jlaxatoca, a ral(xe

psAe

Apyrux

HarrpaBJreHnrt n

Qu,rocoQr.rn

rr HayKoBeAeHrrrr.

2.5. ilounrxr napaanrMbr u Haymoit

peBollouhh

no T. Ky"y

Izlcroprrn

HayKrr

aMepnxaHeu T. KyH

(1922-1996)

rae,r

qe,rlrii

prA

ocHo-

Borror'rsf

arorl{rrx

noH.qrr{ii

An.q

oIIHCaHHq 3aKoHoMepHocreli

QyHrqlrouu-

poBaHr,rfl

pa3BnTur

HayKl{.

HayuHaa napa.qlrrMa

coBoKynHocrl tpyHgaueHTaJ'rbHbIx

AocruxeHuit

AaHHoii

o6iracrn Hayr(lr, 3aAarour.rx o6qenpn:HaHHue o6paaqbr,

rrpuMe-

pbl

HayrrHoro

3HaHuq,

npo6,reu I{ MeroAoB }IX I{ccr'IeAoBaHwA

rr [pl{3Haro-

urlxcg

B TeqeHt{e

o[peAeJ'reHHoro

BpeMeHI,r HayqHbIM coo6tqectnou

xax

oc HoBa ero

Aa.rllgeii

uieii

Aeqre,'r

rrrocrH.

Tarne o6paatlrt

Aon)KHbr

6lrri, n

AocraroqHori

nepe 6ecnpeueAeHrHbl,

.{ro6rr

npnBJreqb Ha cBoro cropo[y cropoHHr.rKoB n3 noHKypr{pynilIux

HarIpaB,TeHurl,

u n ro

xe BpeM.rI

Aocraror{Ho

orl(pblTbr,

,{ro6H

HoBbre [o-

Ko,'rerrus

yqenbrx

1\{or,'rH uairrlr

l:ts

ce6s Hepeue}rHbre npo6,reuu

rp6o-

ro BrrAa.

3ro

lroAe,ru, u3 Koropbrx Bbrpacraror rpaArrrluu HayqHoro

uc-

cJ'teAoBaHLIg.

Vvenlre,

Aerre.{bHocrb

Koropbrx crpor,rrc.{ Ha ocHoBe oA}rHaKoBr,Ix

rrapa-

Ar,rrM,

ofl[parorcs Ha oAHrr u re xe npaBrr,ra uayvHoi.i [paKTr{Kr.I.

B onpe-

AeneHHoM

cr\{brcJre o6rqeuprtsHaHHag

[apaAurlra.rrBJr.aercq

octtonuot't eAn-

2.5.

floHnrzq

napaahrNaur

h Ftavqnoi

peaoatouuH

no T.

KvHy

Hurleii

lr3MepeHr.rs

A,'Iq

Bcex, u3yqapruux

nporlecc pa3BHTnq

HayKrt.

3ra

eArr-

HUIIa

KaK llenoe

He Moxer

6url coe4elra

K ee J'Iol-llqecKt{t\{

cocraBJ'Iqrcuull.

Oopltrponantre

ilapaAlIrN,r

qB,7r.qerc.s

npu3Har{oN,r

3penocru

rrayvHofi

4ucqun-

"TI'IIIbI'

T. e.

rIoKa3aTe"rIeM

BbIxoAa

AIICUI'II1J'IIIIIbI

craAulo <.ttopltantttoi.i

IrayK[>.

flpr.rurrlraerrarr

lrarlecrBe

rrapa.qr.rrN{bl

Teopu.q

AoJr)r{Ha

Ka3arbct

rpeAlor{THTe,Tbrree

l(oHnypupyrcqux

c ueli.tlpyrrrx

reopul-"r,

Ho o}ta

BoBce

IIe

o6raaHa

o6rgcH.grr

nce

(raxrrr

rr orBeqarl

lra Bce

Botrpocbl.

fieare,rrHocrb

yrrerrblx

AonapaAlrr,r.ra,rlHlrr"r

flep]ioA pa3tsurnq

HayKr.r

lrellee crrcreN{arnr{r{a

u rloABepxerra

NrHorI,Il,t

c"tyuaiinocralt.

Kor4a

nnep-

Bbre co34aercr

cI,IHTerrrqecrat

reopnx

(sapo4r,rut,

npoo6pas

napa4nrlrrt),

cnoco6uas

npuB,'reqb Ila

cBoro cropolly

6orournncr.so

yqeHblx

cJreAyrcrqe-

ro rtoKo,rreHrrr,

rrpexHrre

rtrxoJtbt

rrocrerreHno

rrcqe3alor,

qro qacrHgHo

o6y-

cJiIoBJ'IeHo o6paueutreu

I{x

r{J'IeI{oB

x Itonoli

napaAIlrN{e.

Haqa,tsulre

3Ta[bI

rrpr.rH.rlTl{r

napaAlrrMbr

o6bt.IHo

cB.s3aHbI

c co3AaHI{eNr

clleulranbHblx

xyp-

HaJ'roB,

opraHusaurreii

nayvnlrx o6u1ectn,

rpe6onaHllaMu

BITIAeJ'reHrH

crequa,'IbHbIX

KypcoB

yrrrrBepcrlTerax.

flapa.4urr,rbr yrperrJ'r

flrorcfl

Mepe

Toro,

KaK t{x Hcrro,'rb3oBar{ue

flpttBoArrr r

6o,ree 6rrcrponay yclexy,

qeNr

rrpr,rNreHeHHe

KoHr{ypnpyuur,rx

Hr,rMr4 cnoco6on

peule}rns

ocrpbrx

HccJre-

AoBarerbcxrrx

npo6leu.

Hoplra"rrHag

HayKa

cranvs pa3BLITHs

HayqHoro

3IIaHuq,

ua xoroporii

OCHOBIIOIIf

OCyTUeCTB,'IgrcTCt

HaIT0IIJ'IeHI'Ie

U CIICTeNIaTLI3aIIU'

3HaHUg

paM-

Kax cJ'to)Kl,rBuret?c.q

[apaAxrN{bl

paapa6orxa

flapaAr{rMalr,rroii

reopnr.r

ue,'Igx

pa3pexler{rrs

Heroropbrx ocraBllrr.rxcq

He.qcuoctefi

ynyqureHfl.g

pe-

tueHil.fl

npo6aeu,

Itoropble

paHee

6nltr

3arpoHyrbl

J'Ir{rrrb

noBepxHocrHo.

Peruesue

rar(oro

poAa

3aAaq T.

KyH

yno4o6,rxer

peuer{rrrc

roJ'roBo,'ro-

MoK, rAe

raKxe neo6xogrrnro

Aeiicrnosarl

paN,rr(ax

crporux

rrpaBr{Jr-rrpeA-

nucaHr.rfi. floarolry

npo6,relmr uoplra,rtrroii (epe,roii)

Hayr{t{

B oqeHb

Ma-

.ttoii

crenesu oplleHTHpoBaHbr

Ha orr(pbrrr{e

r{oBbrx

rparron

HJrrr

co3AaHr{e

Hosoii

Teopuu.

leficrnua

paMr(ax

crporr{x

npaBr{J'r-npe

gnucamuft

Mo-

ryT

[pI{BeCTr{

K CO3AaHHIO

HOBbIX napaAI,tIN{,

r{To

paBrro3HaqFro

peBoJ'rlo-

IlHr4

B rrayKe,

T. e.

paAtrKa,'rlnoii

cnrerre

clrcreMbr

npaBrrn-[peAlucar{Hfi

Ha-

yvuoii

Ae.rrreJrbHocru.

Orrprrrua

Har{uHarorcq

c oco3HaHLIt

aHoltalnli,

ycraHoBJIeHI4fl

roro

Qaxra,

rrro

[prrpoAa KaKr4M-To

o6paaou

HapyrxuJ'ra

HaBeqHHbre

napa-

Auruori

oxr.rAaHr.rq.

3ro npllro4r.rr K

pacu[peHr{ro

rrccJre4onaunit

s o6ra-

cru aHoMaJ'IHtr.

Boanuraer

napaAoKc

KaK HopMaJ'rr,Hag

lrayKa,

I{e crpe-

M"rICb

HerrocpeAcTBeHHo

HoBbIM OTKpbTTL{qM

r.r HaMepeBa.scb

BHaqale

Aaxe

IIOAaBr,rTb rIX,

MoxeT cJlyxHTb

rrHcTpyrueIrToN{,

nopoxAaloul{N{

3TI{

OTKpbI-

Tng.

OTBeT cocToI,IT

B ToM,

rITo

aHoMaJ'rr4r

MoXeT rlpo.rlBr,rTbcg

To/IbKo

tpoHe

napa4nrnru.

9ena

6oree ro.{Ha r,r pa3Br,rra

rrapaAurMa,

reu 6olee

vyn-

--t_

frtaea

2. Vlct

CTBIITCJIbTII,INI

IIHAIIKATOPON,I

AJ'Iq

O6HAPYXCUUfl

AHO]VIA.IUI{

OHA

BI,ICTYIA-

er'

B oupeAeJlellIIoIi

crerIeIIlI

ilar{e

conporr,luJ'reHIIe

rr3r\reHetIHK)

IIprIr.rocur

noJrb3y;

oHo

fapaHTnpyer,

qro

rrapaArrri\{a

}re

6y4er

or6porxeHa

cr'rr{tuKo}r

J'IefKo'

r{To

K 1"13}IeHe}lHIo

flapaAlrrNtbl

rtpllBeAyr

ro,rrbKo

arIOr\Iil,rIItH,

ilpoHll-

3brBaroIIIHe

HayqHoe

3HaHtre

caMoii

cepAIIeBr.{Hbr.

Ho orxpurug

qBJrflrorcq

eAuHcrBeHHbrM

r{croqHrlroM

Aecrpy*rrrB-

Ho-I(oHcrpyKTIItsHbIX

ltalteHegrtii

napaAIIrllr,I.

Bropuirr

rrcroglrr{KoNr

6au-

KporcrBa

crar{oRnrcr

IIocro.qHHblr"r

poc'r'TpyArrocreti

perxeHrrr.r

HopN{a"rrb-

uoii

uayroii

ctsor.rx

ro,'roBo,'ror{ox

s rorl

il,repe,

B xaxoji

orra

AoJrxHa

JTo

Ae"TIarb.

Kax rr

R rrporr3Bo.rlcrBe,

B HayKe

cN{erra

rrHcrp}rN,reHror

(opylr.rii

rpy-

4a)

aro

xpaiiuxx

Mepa,

Koropafl

rrpr.IMeHrrercfl

ToJ'rbI{o

npr{

Bo3HrrnHoBe-

HHrr cepbe3Hbrx

cncTer,rHblx

KpI,r3trcoB.

SrccrpaopAHrrapHafl

Hayna

HayKa

Ha c-railvv

ocrporo

Kpr.r3r{ca,

KorAa

aIIOMaJ'IIt.fl

pa3BllTn.q

CTauoBrITc.q

cJ'IIItrrKoM

.gntroii

u npu3rraerc

x 6onr-

rrrrrHcrBoN{

rrccr're4oBare-{eii

rarruol"r

o6,racrrr.

J}o6oir

Kprr3lrc

Hagr'ruaercs

coN{Heuu.q

a rrapaAr{rNre

rocrerreHrroro

pacruarblBarrug,

fipaBl,ln

HOpN{aJ'rbrrofo

rrccr'reAoBaHux.

cnryaq

ilq

Havu]Ha.

er Harrorvf

IrHarb

AorlapaAntua,rrHlrii flepxoA

pa3Blrrrrn

lrayrr.r.

Kpuauc

3aBeprxaercr

oAHuM

lra Tpex

rrcxoAoB:

1)uopuarrna.{

Hay^a

Mo}Ker

Aor{a3arb

croK)

cnoco6Hocrl

pa3peur.rrb

npo6,reuy,

lopoAr.{Brxylo

Kpn3r.rc;

2)6onlrutrrrcrBoM

yr{eHbrx

npu3Haercr,

vro rrpo6,reMa

6rfuxaiiurer?

lepcnel(Tr{Be

noo6rqe

j\{o}Ker

sal"Irlr

cBoero

pelllerrr.r.rl

u oHa

xar

6rr

ocraBJ'Ifl

erc.q

B HacJ'reAcrBo

6yayureuy

noKo/IeHHIo;

3) noxn,raercs

uogrrr'i

ilpereHAeHT

poJ'rb

napaAr{rN,{br,

pa3Bopaqr.r-

Baercq

6opl6a

3a <<rrpecroJr>>.

Ho.{acro

rroBar

flapaAtrl\ra

Bo3Hr{Kaer

(lo

rpaiiHerl

Nrepe

B eapoAuue)

TOTO,

KAK

KPII3HC

3AUICJI

CJII1IUKOM

AAJ'ICKO

V,IU

6gI .'IBI{O

OCO3}IAH.

4pyrlrx

c.nyqa{x

[poxoAr{T

3HaqtrreJrbHoe

BpeMs

MexAy

rrepBbrM

oco-

3HaHUeM

KpyueHr{t

crapoii

[apaAr{rMbI

rr B03HuI(HOBeHrreM

Honor"r.

B eror

neprroA

rra6,rrc4aercrr

yBe"rrr.rqeHHe

o6palleHr.rii

3a rroMoulbro

dru-nocoQuu,

6ypuoe

nupaxeHr.re

HeAoBoJrbcrBa

cocro.sHtreNr

Ae,T,

pe0,ret

ar"

6yrr4ur"n-

TaJIbHbIX

no,toxeHr.rii

HayKr{

BCe

3TO CrIMrrrON.{br

nepexoAa

HopN,laJ'rr'-

uofi

uayru

r( aKcrpaopAr.rnapHoii.

HayuHaa peBonloqu.g

aro

HeKyMyr.trt{tsHbre

3IIu3oAbl

pa3Br4-rvr

Ha-

yKlI,

KOrAa

B pe3y,lrbTaTe

Kpr.r3r{ca

cTapas

[apaAr,rrN,ra

3aMeulaeTc.,

uerlr_

KoM

t4J'tH

qacrhqlto

Hosoit.

ueMeHenr.rsx

raKoro

po4a

Kyu

ycuarpr.rBaer

N,rHoro

o6qero

pe-

so,IrcIlueii

corlua"rnHoli.

tr4l,reuHo

yrreHuu

nprrpoAe

u Heus6exuocrn

2.5. flounun

AhTMbI

Bontouhh

T. K

rrayt1110t"

peno,rrcqlrrl

anrop

rrarr60ree

rly60ro

pacxoAr{Tcfl

B3ur.sAax

c IlC)3IITIIBHcraMI{,

yrBep)fiAaBrrItNflr

HerrpepbrBrro

HaKorrrrreJ'rbHlrrl

xaparrep

p;l3BHTIrq

3HalllIfl

u BHexcropxr{Hocrb,

ItestI6,Teltocrb

ocHoBIIblx

[paBI{n-

rrpeArrr{caHrrii

rr ara,roHoB

Hayq}rot-o

LrccJ'reAoBaHua.

HayuHlre

peBoJ,rrour4H

IrPI4BOA.{T

He ror'IbKo

paAuKaJrb}rblN{

r3N.{eHerru.rlN{

B3rJ'rrAon

Ha lrnp (ne-

pecrporire

Kaprr,rHbI

uupa),

r{ K

I{3MeHeHUrr.r

caN{oro

N{r{pa,

B KoropoM

)I{IIBET

qCJ'IOBCK.

laxe

loc-re yrBep)KAeHr{s

rra rpoHe

uonoil

rapaArrrl,rbr

conporuB-rreHue

Aoirro

He nper{pa[laerca.

or4e,rlubre

yqeHbre

nprIHrrr,raror

HoByro

rapaArrr-

Nly r]O

cal\{brN{

pa3rrbrr.{

coo6paxenrr.sM,

B ToN{

r{trc-Ile

/rex(aurrrM

BHe

c$eplr

rrayKr{

(uarprrntep,

Ky.rrbr

coJ'rrrqa

nouor

tr4.

Ken,repy

crarb

Ko[epHr4Karrqeu).

Eo,rluyro

ponb

rr'par,or

ra*)Ke

acrerr.rqecKr{e

earropr,r.

flaxe

uaqnouanr-

Hocrb

r{ npe)KHqq

penyraurrq

HoBaropa

N{oryT

cbrfparb

sToM

npoqecce

3r{aqrrreJ'rbHyrc

poJ'rb.

o6pauleHne

B HoByro

nepy

6yaer

[poAor)Karbcs

rex

I]OP,

IIOKA

HE OCTAHCTC.q

B ){TIIBbIX

HII

OAI{OIO

3ATIUTHTKA

CTAPOfi

NAPAAI{IMbI.

ro.{Ku

3perr'q

KyHa,

rrporpecc

rrayKu

sBr,r-serc.s

crporo

,ocry_

laT€r'rbrrbrtf.

oH rrau60-rree

orieBrrAeH

B leprloAbr

ee HopNla/rbHoro

(xyuy_

,rarunuoro)

pa3BrrrHq.

flpu

clrerre

napaAHrM

r{Hc.rro

BHoBb

orKpbIBarorlilxc,

npo6,retnt

o6rt.{Ho

rlpeBbIIrlaer

r{lrcJ'ro

pa3peuaeN{btx.

Ho nlrengo

orKpbrrl{e

HOBOTO

no,ra

npo6,relt

o6ccneqnBaer

AaJrbHer'rruee

4n[xeHrre

BrrepeA

or{epeAHor.r

sTane

cyrrlecrBoBaHuq

HOpua"uruoii

HayKu yxe

paNlKax

}ro-

BOr"r

napaAxfnrrr.

Kyu

rarrxe

o6paulaer

BHUMaHT{e

Ha ro,

rrro

Hotsr{3Ha

paArl

rroBH3Hbr

qB"rrserc.q

ueJ'rbro

r{ayKH,

KaK 3TO

.raCro

6ltsaer

Apyrt{x

o6,nacrsx

rBopr{ecrBa.

xor.g

HoBbre

[apaArrrNrbr

peAxo

uJIr{

Hr{KorAa

o6,ra4arcr

BCeMrr

Bo3NioxHocrrl{r{

cBoLIx

npeAuecrBeHHr.rq,

oHu

o6uquo

coxparrqror

orpoN{rroe

KoJ'ruqecrBo

uan6oaee

r(oHKperHbrx

sJreMerrroB

rrpo-

Ix'TbIX

Aocrl'txeHlttl,

orlipblBa.q

nplr

groM

Bo3MorKHocrr,r

HoBbIX

KoHKper-

Hbrx pelreHHii

craplrx

npo6,relr.

lroxHo

,'rH

crrnrarb,

gro

c KaxAoti

uayvHoi'r

peno,rrcqnefi

Mbr

Bce

6,rrrxe

rroAXoAr,rM

HeKOeMy

no,'rHoMy,

o6renrunuoMy,

r{crHHHoMy

IIpeA-

craBJrIeHHro

npupo4e?

K no,roNureJrbHON{y

OTBery

raK

nocrag,reHHnii

BONDOC

KYH OTHOCI,ITCq

CKOPCE

CKCIITTIqECKI,I

I]POCTO

TIOTONfY,

qTO

TAKO-

ro a6co,rrcrHoro

3HaHr4q

B rlpr.rHur{I]e

cyxlecrBoBarb

He r\,Io)Ker.

Ho uu

uo-

xeN{

roBopr{rb

Bce

6o,rtueii

coo6paauocru

r.rHcrpyMeHToB

npoqeAyp

I{CCJIeAOBaHU-g

TON{y,

qTO

NIbI

H3yrIaeN{.

gax,rrcqesHe

cneAyer

o6paiurl

BHr.rMaHr.re

oco6oe

3Har{eHue

rroH.s-

TurI <<HaygHoe

coo6rqecrno>>

rro/'IxoAe

Kyrra. <.flapaAlrrua

aro

ro,

rrro

o6re4nHaer

HayrrHoe

coo6ulecrro,

r.r

nao6opor,

HayqHoe

coo6ulecrno

co-

cror{T

r{3

ln4eir,

rpr.r3Harourrx

lapaAr.rrNry>.

Brre

KoHrperHor.o

HayyHoro

coo6ulecrna

rorrrrrre

[ap:rAnr-Mbr

repr{er

csor-r

cN,{lrc,,].

Tur,rr

o6r,ro"ou.

50 lnaaa

2. Zcropxr

pagghrhn

h coepeN,teHHure

npeacraeneHur...

Ilaparxl,rfN{br

He )KuByT

ca\.{tr [o ce6e;

u KorAa IoBopqT

o [epeocMbrcJleHr.Ir{

paMKax

rot'r urr.r nuoii

napa4nrNrbr HoBbtx

rpaxrou r,rr'tlr

cMeHe rrapaArrrN{,

I4Meerc.g

B BrrAy

pear'rbrras

xu3Hb Hayrrnoro

coo6rqectna.

lloarouy

corluo-

J'tornt

Hayl{u

HeorbeM,Tc;urtii

acneltr

J'IofnKlI

pa3BHTuq

I{ayKI{.

2.6.

llpunuhn

+a^bcr+huhpyeMocn4

rhnore3

B reopHh

KpxrHqecKoro

peaAH3Ma

K. flonnepa

Oco6oe Mecro B

4anlHefiureu

pacKpbrrr.rr{

rryru

pocra

o6lextunnoro 3rraHu;{

cneAyer orBecru

K. flonnepy,

xoroplrrl pa6ora-r

s XX s.l

B neplroA cocyue-

crBoBaHHr pa3r{brx

ararroB

rrafr}roro no3HaH}Ir.

Ero nr,raA

paaBrirrre

reo-

pl.ru

o6terrtrBHoro

3Halrus 6but

csxeaH c HanpaBJ'rerrlrocrL,ro

pacxpbrrrre

nyreii, KoropbrMu.qBuxerc.s

Hayra,

T. e. c

pacxpblTner\{

rropMarnBoB

Hayr{Ho-

ro N,{bIIIrJ'reHr{.s, fAe

Teopil[ [poBepqrcTc.q

Ha rrcTl4HuocTb

sMnHpuqecKu,

cJ'ro)KHbIM

rlyreN{, BK,'rroqatorll{ivr

38eHo BbrABu)Kerrr{rr

rHrrore3.

Hay+ruii nyrt

noeHauu.s 6lrJ'r

rroHqr rrM KaK craHoBJ'reHr4e

HaAbIHArrBuAyarIbHbtx

cxeNl Kpr.r-

TI{rIeCKOfO

MbItUr'IeHI{g

HayqHOrO COO6UIeCrea.

OcuoeHLtlr IIopN,rarr.rBoM pocra

o6lexrt{Br{oro

3HaHI,I.l

K. flonnep cvu-

TaJr BbrBeAeHHe

r{3 reopuii

(rar

AeAyr{T}rBrrbrx

KoHcrpynuurl)

c,re4crnlrr1,

[poBep.seMblx

orlbrrHbrM

rryreNl. B axctreprtirreHTar'rr,HoM

TIJIII

ApyroM

Teo-

peTI{KO-sMrIUpUqeCKOM

r.rCCJ'IeAOBaI{IIU

[pOBep.qrcTc.fl

r.{MeHHo

STLI [peArro-

JIATAEMbIE

C"TICACTBI{.{

II,ITIOTE3bI

KAK BbICKA3bIBA]III{,

HCTI,IHHOCTb

IIJ'IIII

noxHocrb

Koropblx

Helt3BecrHa, Ho

N{oxer 6urr,

ycrauoBJ'IeHa

o[bITHbIM

nyreM.

Sxcnepuueurbr rrpoBoA-flTcs,

nJrfl

roro,

uro6lr oMnHpuqecrr{

[po-

BepgTb HayrrHble

II{IIoTe3br,

yTBep}KAanuue

[pIItII{Hrro-cneAcTBeHHbIe

oT-

HOrlrerrH.q

N{e)KAy [epcMeHHbrMH.

B cauolr flone

HayqHbrx rlrrrore3

npr{H.{To

BblAeJrgrr,

KaK MHHLIMyM

ABa

ypoBHq

ypoBeHb

o6rqux rrrrrore3

(reopernuecKrrx,

AeAyKTltBHbrx

KoHcr-

pynqufi

Qopuy,lupoBoK

3aKoHoB) u vacrHr,rx (sunupnvecrux,

orHocr{Mbrx

x o6o6uleuuqM aMrtnprrqecKr{ ycraHoBJ'reHHbrx

3axorrol{epHocrer?).

TeopernuecKHe

rl{rloresbl

3To

noJro)KeHHg,

trpsl\{o

He rlpoBepgeMbre,

AeAyKTHBHo

rroJraraeMbre

paMr{ax

roii

n"nu uuofi

reopnn.

B Hayre reopu.{.{acro

sa6efaer

BrrepeA. fi.rnoreetr

nopofi

yAaercr

[po-

Bepl,rrb B HacrogureM,

Ho 3aro JTo

cr1 laercx

n 6y4yIueu,

KorAa, HarIpI4Mep,

oxa3blBarorca

paapa6oraHHbrMH

coorBercrBylourlre

MeroAuqecKne

cpeAcrBa.

3ro naelrsaerc.s raKlKe

npo6leuort o[epaur{oHan].r3aunn

nepeMeHHbrx.

1937 r.

pa6ora,r

e BeHc,

Jlou4oue, rAe

cepeAr4uu 1970-x

,'I I,ITUI{CCKI.IX HAYK,

1937 no

1946 r.

Hosofi

3e.nasAuu u 3areM

rr.6rt,r nporleccopov

lUxoau

arorroMnKr4

tr rro-

2.6. flphxuran

Sanucx$hunpye,raocrh

rv nore:

reophh

Kprrhqecxoro... 51

Fleueqxnii

yveHrrit

K. Xo,rrqxalrn, aBrop KHHrr{

<.Teopnl

lr aKcnep].r-

MeHT B rlcl{xoJlorul{,>

[Xo,rlqxaun,

1981], aHaJrlorr,ItrHo

K. llonnepy cyue-

crBeHl{oe

BH[MaHrre

yAeJrlrj]r

r{oBbr\r

Qopn,ty,rnpoBKaN{

rrpnHuutla

I{HAyK-

IIrIH KaK He rrpr,rMeHuMoro

B c$epe lrocrpoe]ruq o6t,eKrueHoro anauuq.

lo,rrara,rl,

qro

o6rque

BbIcKa3bIBaHuq 3aAaruT

<<cerb>>

Teopun.

tr4 veu

fxe

qqeiirll

aroll cerrr, reu 6oree 3naHu.q 6yAer nrt,rorJ'teHo

ygellbru.

To ecrl

o5ulre

BbrcKa3brBalruq KaK 6lr nepneu4rrKyJr.{pHbr

qacrHbrM.

K. llonnep, B orrnr{He or 3roro,

paccN4arpuBan

qacrHbre

H o6uue srr-

cKa3bIBaHHt

IiaK

ABa

ypoBHfl,

KOTOpbre

pacIIonaraloTc.q

cKopee B IIapaJ'I"]IeJIb-

Hbrx rrJrocxoctsx.

tr4 r{exAy HIINTT{ cyulecrByer Bo3Mo)K}rocrb nepexo4a:

o6-

ullre BbrcKa3brBaHr.rr, Kacarculr.Iecg

@opuynupoBoK

3ar(oHoB, nroryr 6lrrl

npoBepeHbr Ha Hcrr.rHHocrb

B aMnupi.rqecKoM r{ccJreAoBaHrl.r. Z ocxonHoii

npHHIrIIr

raxori nponepKu

aro rrpr{Hrlr{[

$aarcuQuraqun.

I4tax, cqueu rvcr

cKag.

ycraHoBxa

B HayrIHoM Llcc,ireAoBaHr4r.I rroApa3y-

MeBaeT

BO3MO){{HOCTb

yCTaHOBJIeHI{,'I

IICTUfIH OCTU LIJILI

-[O)I{HOCTH

npOBe-

pxeuoii

rHrrore3br.

tr4crnunocrr ttprr aro]r roHHMaercq KaK coorBercrBLIe

Qaxrau

(u,rn

4eircrwlTeJ'rbHocrn).

Tovnee, Teopus Lrcrrrtnas' ecJ'II{

H ToJIb-

ecJTI{

oHa coorBercrByer

Sarrau.

Vcrauos,'IeH}Ie J'IoxHocrrL, uJtr4

Qa,'rl-

cltQuxaqua reopnii,

ocHoBrroii nyrb rrpupocra Hayr{Horo 3HaHu.q.

@a.trr-

cuQnraqnx

s xureiicxor4 cMbrcJ're o3Haqaer

rroAnor, r. e. o6uaH.

OAsaxo

HayqHbrx rrccJre.4oBarru.sx

gror

repMrIH nNreer coBceM I4Hoe 3HaqeHue. Hal.r-

6o,ree

.{erxo

ouo

6u,ro crpopny,urpoBaHo B

pa6orax

flonnepa.

Ou npo-

TllBonocraBr.r,'r nprrHrlr.r[y nepnQuxaqrlr.r rHrrore3 npr.rHul{fi

lrx orBepxe-

Hlr's., vJrH

$a,rrcr.r0HxaqnH.

flpu arol{ aBTop rrcxoAun r,r3

Tofo,

.Iro

rlo6oe

TeopeTI4Iro-3N{nilpuqecKoe

Hccr'reAoBaH}re HarrpaBneHo Ha

pelueHHe

o[pe-

AereHHoii

uayvuofi npo6.reulr.

Hayunaa

npo6reua

ero

SopuynlrpoBxa,

e. oco3HaHr{e,

r(axoro-ro

fipoTuBopeqtl'l,

pa3peueHr,re

KoToporo BHocr{T BK,'raA rrpoBeAeHIIe

Hayq-

HOrO UJrr{ rIpaKTr4r{ecKu

HaIIpaB/IeHHOTO rICCJ]eAOBaHr.Is.

TeoperHxo-aMrtupuqecKoe

Hcc,TeAoBaHile BK,'rrcqaer KaK rrocraHoBKV

npo6.uelrlr,:aBepIUarcuyrcc.g

o6ocHoBaHHeM Teoperr,IqecKoii runoreer,I,

Tax

LI npoBepKy 3Mrrr{puqecKu

HarpyxeHHbrx rlrrroTe3.

Bepn$r.rxaqus

nonyqeHr{e otrbrrHbrx

AaHHbrx

rroJrb3y

rrpeArronarae-

lroii

runorearr.

3eeHo

rlrrrore3 B HayqHoNr

tro3HaHHrl

or.rrHqaer ory

rpaKToBKy or roro

Kpr.rrepr.r.{ neplrrpuqupyeMocru, rcoroplrii 6nr,r

pa:pa6oraH

B rro3rrrrr-

BH3N{E.

no4xo4e K HayqHoNry rro3HaHuro, Ha3BaHHoNry KpururrecKr.rM

pe:urua-

MoM, llorl[ep o6ocuoran HeBo3N.roxHocrb r.rHAyKTr,rBHoro

rryrlr

nptr

oueHKe

I4CTHHHOCTH |U[IOTC3L'I.

HAY.IITAS IIITIOTE3A IIHI{OfAA TIC MOXET CqI,ITATbC'

fnaea 2. Vlcropnn

pa3Bhrnfl

h coBpeMeHHbte

npeacraale+nfl...

<<.4oKa3aHlrofi>> TaI(Xe B

pe3y,'IbTaTe

BepuolIKaIIHl'I,

IOCKOJIbKy HI{KaKHe

yT-

BepxAeHHt

Saxrax

(yponeHr

vacrHbIX

BblcKa3LIBaHuii)

rre uoryr cJlyxl{rl

ocHoBaHrleM

A,'Ifl

npI{3HaHI'j'g,VLCTIIHHOCTU

TeOpeTnr{eCKOIO

IO,'IOXeHI{.{,

Bbl-

paxer{Horo

ypoB}Ie yr{uBepca,'Ibuoro

(o6o6rqeHuoro) BbIcl{a3blBaHI{s.

flpyrulur

cJ'roBaMu,

perrb

HAer

o roM,

qro

HI{KaI{oe MHoxecrBo

AaHHblx

rlo,rlb3y

3xcnepuMeHTa,'IbHoI"I rrllrore3bl

He craHoBHTcl

ocHoBallueu,

vro6lt

cqI{TaTb Bbrcxa3aHHoe

B r}IrloTe3e [peArIoJIo)KeHue

IICTI{HHbllvl.

HayvHrte

o6o6ts\eruug, He crpo.trcs I{HAyKTIIBHo.

BcerAa

cJleAyer

oxl'{-

4arl

o6napyxeHrls

HoBbIX

IaHHbIX,

npUMepoB,

KOTopbIe N{OIyr

rIpoTI{Bope-

qr.rrl,'rrc6oMy

MlloxecrBy

HaKoIIJIeHHblx

pallee <<noATBepxAeHltfi'> o6o6rqeu-

Horo Bblcl(a3brBauuq.

Hayrca

Qoptuy,'Illpyer

cBou reoperllrIecKHe

tronoxeHllg

uMeHHo

xax o6une BbIcKa3bIBalI

us. VI s,'IoruKe

rarltx o6o6rueHnfi

c,re4yer

npeAnoJlararb

pa3pr,rB

MexAy rl'IocKocrflN{H

qacTHbIX

cyxAeHHit, Ha KOTO-

pbre paclpocTpaHfleTcq

IPUHIII{I

HHAyKUII]I, lr

yHHBepCar'IbHbIX, ItOTOpbIe

He Moryr

6lrrl noArnepxAel{bl

IrHAyKrIrBHo. Ho

sru

yHuBepcaJlbHble BbI-

cKa3blBaHHg, rrpereHAyrollll4e

poJIb

TeopeTllr{ecKHX

3aKOHoB, rtOryr

6lnr

onpoBepfHyTbl

oTIbITHbIM [yTeN{, T.

e. C TIOMOIqbIo

npoTlrBopeqa[Iux

HM 3N{-

[]rpr{qecxux

AaHHbIX.

B arolr H 3aK"'Iloqaercs

TIpI4HIIHn

acuMrlerpt{I{ BbIBo-

.4a

o HayqHoii

runorese Ha ocHoBe

sKcrlepuMellTa"'IlHofo

I,ICCJ'IeAOBaHI'IS.

Ilpuuqun acHMMerpLIu

3ax,'Iloqaercfl B ToM,

r{To

rnlore3y

NroxHo

Qa.nlcu-

$uquponarl

(orneprHyrr),

uo ue,rrsa

[oATBepAHrl

(Aoxasarl

ee llcruH-

nocrl) Ha

ocHoBe orrbrrllblx

AaHHbIX.

OaarcnQuqfipyeMocrb

HaJIuqLIe [pLIHuHlI4aJItHofi

soeN{o)KHocrl{

Ans,

rt;ro6ofi. rnnore3bl, npereHAylouefi

craryc Hayunofi,

6rIrr ornepr-

Hyroft

B xoAe oM[upl4qecKoft nponepxn.

Tarltu o6paaou,

npoBepnfl HcrI,IHHocrb

reoperllrlecKl'Ix

runore3,

rIcH-

xoJlor,

xax u,'Irc6ofi

apyroii

HccneAoBareJlb,

rlcrIoJIb3ylouIHI"I

sKcflepHMeH-

ralnHufi MeroA,

4eiicrnyer

rro [prIHqI{[y

<<or

rlporl4BHoro)>.

To ectr

BbIHyXAeH

OnpoBepraTb HeBepHbIe

fHrIoTe3bI, a He

roJIbKo l{cKaTb

rIoATBepx-

TCHlj.fl

BEPHbIM.

I4rar,

onpoeepxeHl,Ie HerIpaBHJIbHrtx

teopufi

[porllBopeqauux

ycraHaB-

.rIrIBaeMbIM

axcrreprlMer{T;Lrrbno oIIbITHbIM

AatlHbIM,

ocHoeuofi nyrb

3Kc-

[epuMeHTaJrlHofi

npoaepKH Hayr{HtIX

r}Inore3. Sror

npnHqun, uanectxntft

TaKXe

KaK

AoKa3are,'tbcrBo

or rlpornBHoro

(ultt

acuMMerpufl

BbIBoAa Ha

ocHoBe aKcrrepr{MeHraarHofi

[poBepKI,I

reopuu),

6r,Lr sHseAeu n

pa6ore

llonnepa 1933

r. xax o6uag

MeroAoJloru.a

aKc[epl.IMeHra,'IbHoro

MeroAa

B Hayre

(ouy6.rruxonaHo

pyccroM

n 1983 r.).

14 aro BMecre

c aKcllepu-

MeHTaJIbHbIM

MeroAoM Boc[pIIH.aJ'Ia s XX

n. nctrxoJ'Iorll.s.

OAnaxo

sAecb cKpbITo Hexoropoe

nporuBopeque,

Ha3BaHHoe

B MeroAo-

JrorLtru. HayKr{

oIIHI{M I43

rlapaAoKcon Kap,ra

flonnepa. OHo

gax,tto'Iaerc.q

2.6.

flpraHuhn

SanucvtSzuhpyer'rocrh

rranoreg

reophh xphrhqecxoro...

B TOM,

r{TO

pa3BUTUe

HayqHorO

3HaHrI{ [AeT IIOCTynaTe"IIb]IO KaK IIpUparUe-

Hne. B

x(e BpeMr rryrb orrbrrHorl nponeprn reopufi

rpeAflonafae'r ux

oflpoBeplr(eHr.te.

Calr

llonnep

gro

rlporuBoperlue

BKJ'IIoqnn B

pa3tsrrrlle

N{e-

TOTXO,'IOfltLI ItptlTIlqecKOfO

p8?:-IlI3NI.1:

tlayqIIOe

3HaHtle pa3BIltsaeTc.s TaK,

qTO

o16pacrrnaercs BCe 6o,'rrrue

ea6,ryx4euufi

peey,rlrare

ricc,'reAoBarrna

yveHrttl oKa3brBaercr

yrre

rlepeA

Apyroii

npo6,renaoft,

qeN{

Ta, c xoropoii

oH r{aqa,rr rlocraHoBKy rrccreAotsare,rlcrotl

qe,rn.

flpocrpaHcrBo npo6,relru r{3N{errur-rrocb. Taxrrlr

o6paaou, B

HayrrHoN{

rIo3HaHtItI

qe,,toBer{ecKaq

lrIbIc,'Ib

ABI{)Kerc.{

Bce

xe locTyrlaTe,'Ibuo

rfiop-

Mynr{pyroTc.s Bce HoBble rH[oTe3bI o IpuqHHHoM

BJII4.TIHnI{ TeX ltJ'lt{ I'IHbIX

rlaxropoa

Ha u3yrraeMlle

peaJlIIu.

BaNHrru

Anq

MeroAonoru.rx flonnepa sB,'rqercs

pa3Ae,'renl,re

calrux

Sar-

ToB Ha

ycranoBneurrue

ro.v

rrru l.rHort r{cc,'reAoBaHIJu) u npuHurlaeMbre B

KaqecrBe uHeHutl, aepoaauuri

rrJIrr r{rrbrl{ o6pa:olr rrpeACTaBJrenHoii cy6rex-

ruenorl

pea,'rbHocru.

{rx

nocrpoeuua reopur?, npererrAyrorunx Ha o6rex-

TUBHoe 3HaHrre, Heo6xo4urro

yqurblBarb p?3r'IlrvrI€

noH.qruii cy6texrunuo-

ro rr o6r'exruBrroro 3HaHua. K.

llonnep,

paspa6oranuruii

anorrcquousr,Iii

noAxoA K rIoHI,INIaIIurc

pocra

Hayquoro,

a 3Har{lIT, o6texrueHoro 3HaHlIq,

npeAno)Kr.rn

pa3,lrHqaTb

Teopun

IIo3HaHI4.q, oc]IoBaHHyxl Ha 3ApaBo\,I cN{bIc-

re, u co6crseHHo Hayr{Hbre

reopr{H. C ero ro.{xH 3peHns, rny6ovaiinrnl,t aa-

6,ryxAeHneu.flB,'rserc.a cNre[reHHe

Mupa tlclrxonorrt.Iecxorl

pealruocrtt (oH

Ha3brBaer ee co3HanueM, r{,'ru

mind) tt nupa reoplli u rllrlore3, uMeIoxrHX

craryc

o6t,exrltsuofo 3rraHr{r.

K. llonnep

qerxo

pa3AeJrsn

Mr.rp cy6rexrunHoro rr Mr{p o6bexrr.rsHoro

3r{ar{Hs. Mup 1

aro Mr{p

Quauvecrori,

flpeAMerrror"r

pea,{brrocru.

IIcuxo-

J'IOfltqeCKaq

peaJIbHOCTb,

CBq3aIIHa.g C I4H^LIBIIAyaJ'IbHbIM IIO3HaHlleM, IIO-

MeuIeHa

r{M B Mrrp 2.Teopnu H rlrrlore3ll

xrrByr B MHpe

ua4uu4unu-

Aya,YIbHOM,

[peACTaBn.flrOUleM

AOTaAI(r{,

n O6beKTUBHOe 3HaHl{e.

Crapat

reopu.rr rro3HaHrlg,

ocHoBaHHaq Ha 3ApaBoNI cMblc.ile,

BHoclIT,

corJracHo llonnepy,

<<HauBHyIo nyraHl{Uy>>.

OHa

npocra rI Ha3blBaeTcq aB-

TOpOt{ <.6a4efiHOri'> reopueii

(or

c,rona

<.6anaqr>,

Koropas Monrer 3arro,'r-

Hxrncr). Cxeua

<.6a4eiiHoii'> reoprrH u:o6paxeua Ha

puc.

OAHaxo

cHaqa,ra flpnBeAeM

ocHoBarurfl frocrpoeHlloii raxuv o6parort

Teopuu rro3HaHu.s

(cy6t'errunHoii

reopun, ottnparcqeitcs wa e4panln:i

cN{brcJ,I).

<.Ecrr,r

BbI

l{'1rr .q xoruM

ysHaTb

r{Hpe HeqTo

erle

Hen3BecTHoe,

HaM

HaAO OTKpbrTr' f,'ra3a rr

orrqAeTbc.q Kpyror{. w ruaMI }IaAo HacTopo-

xHTb

vulI{

n np]rcJ'IyuaTL'crI

K 3ByKaM, oco6errHo K TeM,

r{To

u3AaIoT

Apy-

rl4e,'IIoAu.

Taruu o6pasou,

pa3Hbre Halrru

qyBcrBa

cny)I{ar HaNl lrcroqHrr-

KaMu 3HaHI4g, I,rcroqHnxawll',

rrJrrr BXoAaMH, B HauI[ co3HaHllrt

(minds)r>

IIlonnep,

2002, c. 66].

Prac.

"EaAeiluaq"

Teop!4q

no3HaH!4q

r'lurepnperall,lh

nonnepa)

6a4eiiHax

Teopug

HecKoJIbKo

ynpou{aeT Teopurc

rIo3HaH

LIr{,

I43BeCT-

Hyro

OtrJrocoQntl

KaK Teopl{s

co3HaHll.fl

v.nw

tabula

rasa,

corJlacHo

KoTo-

poii

Ha1re

co3HaHHe

qt4cTasAOCKa,

KoTopoii

TIyBCTBa

Bblpe3aloT

cBou

noatun"".

CosHaHue,

corJlacHo

3ToI1

Teopl{u,

3To

6a\sg,

KoTopa's

[oHa-

qa,'Iy

6o,'ree

IIJIU

MeHee

[ycTa

B I{oTopyrc

qepe3

optaHbl

qyBCTB

lroxer

6nit,

uepes

BopoHKy

cBepxy)

npoHr{Kaer

N{arepr{ar'r,

Koropblii

Hefi

co6n-

paercs

nepeBapr{BaeTcs.

Sror

uarepua,'r

cy6beKTr{BHOe

3HaHr{e.

oop-

TaKoil

Teopun

[o3HaHI{g

MoXeT

IIMeTb

caMblfi

coBpeMeHHbIl"I

BIIA

Ha-

IIpHMep,

B TeopI4I{

HHQopluaqnl'l

(rorAa 6aN.q

c*a6xeHa

KoMllblorepHoii

nporpaMMofi).

n IIO6OM

Cnyqae

o6ullru

ocTaeTc.fl

Te3rrc

ToM,

IITO

BCe

caMoe

r,,raBHoe

Mbl

y3HaeM

6narogapa

BXoAy

orrblra

(3Mnl{plII4)

.repes

or-

RepcTnq

HaIIIUX

OpraHoB

rryBcTB.

flo Ir,rueHurc

flonnepa,

<,6agefrwaa,>

reopuq

Bcex

ee BapHaHTax

co-

BeprueHHo

oillu6oqHa

ocraercq

BeAyilIeii,

no)Ka,'tyr.'r,

TonbKo

An.q

6tlxenr1o-

pr,rcroB. B

.{r4cro

ee olxu6oK

BXOAqT

CneAyIoIrIHe:

3HaHH.rI

flpeAcraBn.grcTc.g

KaK

<<[oAo6Hbre

BerrIaM

CyIrIHOCTI4...

(U4eU,

BTIETIATJIEHU.'I,

qYBCTBEHHbIC

AAHHbIE,

SJIEN{CHTL'I'

ATOMAPHbIC

NCPEXT'I-

BaHnfl

rrJrv,

MoxeT

6ltrr,,

uyrovlty

ryque

MoJIeKy-[gpHbIe

[epe-

}ICIIBAH

I,Ifl

I{,'II{ TCIITAJIbTbI

)

;

3HaHlI.s

HaxoAqrcq

B Hac

(I4HOopMaI{uq,

Koropyrc

MbI

cyMeJTu BIIIIrarb);

IrpnHI4MaeTCt

nocTyJIaT

HenocpeAcTBeHHOCTll,

COL'IaCHO

KOTOpON{y

Cy-

UIecTByeTHenocpeAcTBeHHoeH"III{IIpflMoe3HaHI,Ie'T.e.qllcTble'HeI{c.

KDKeHHbIe

sJIeMeHTbI

I'IHoOpMaI{I4I',I,

KOTOpbIe

Bxo.4gT

B HaC

II OnpeAe-

JIeHHOe

BpeMt

coxpaHsloTcs

<<HerlepeBapeHHbIMII>.

flocleAuuir

nyHKr

pa3BuBaercs

c"rreAyroult{M

o6paaou.

Bce

orun6o,{HlIe

3HaHr{t,

ocHoBaHHbIe

3Toil

TeopHH

3ApaBOro

cMt'IcJIa'

lpollcxoA.gT

IrJroxoro

HHTeJIJIeKTya,'IbHofo

nI{ueBapeHIIfl,

KOTOpOe

IIopTI{T

ilepBur{HbIe

AaHHble,

BHOC.'I

HUX

Cy6TreKTI',IBHbIe

npI4MecH'

2.7. h. Aararoc n xoHuenuNr eHyrpenFtero

eahncrea norurra...

ocHose

Kpr,rrr{Krr reoprrH rro3HaHlrq, ocHoBaHHoi.t

ua 3ApaBoM cMbrc-

.[e, lloflflep r,r BBoAr4T cxeMy <<Tpex

MlrpoB>>, rro3Bo./rqroulyrc u36e]Karr, rry-

T a H u II bI, B H o c l,I M o I"I <. 6 an e

tl H o ri

Te o

r.r e fi rr 03 H a H r{s.

2.7.

Vl. Aaxaroc h KoHuenurfl

BHyrpeHHero

eahHcrBa

hofl4Kt4

aoKa3aTe^bcTBa

onpoBepxeHHfl

tr4 rtpe Jlaxar o c

(

1922

197 4), aur

nuficrrr r"r r oc JreAoBareJr b

(

aeu

repc ro ro

nponcxoxAeHr.I.q)

MeTo.4o,'roruqecKoro

Qa,ltcuQlrxauuoHrr3r\{a,

xax r.r T.

Kyu,

He orpaHnqu"'rcr KprrrnKoii

no,toxeHHii,roruqecKoro rr03lrrI4Br,I3Ma,

a ilo-

rIblTa-rcg rlocrpoIITb pa3BepHyryro

KoHUenUnIo

Hayr{Ho-no3HaBarenbHoil

Ae"rrTeIbHocTI4.

B IIeHTpe ee cTor.rT IIoHqTHe

IIccJIeAoBaTeJIbcKori IIporpaM-

MbI, ocHoBaHrrorl Ha BrryrpeuHeM

eAHHcrBe JrorlrKrr

AoKa3arenbcrB

ott-

poBepxeHr{ii.

OcyUecrBJ'r.{.s,rroruqecKyro

peKoHcrpyKrIHro peaJrbHoro

[poqecca

]IayqHoro tlo3rraHr.rq, tr4.

Jlaxaroc lrpnrxeJr K BbrBoAy,

r{To

oH flpo-

reKaeT

<poplre

ABr{xeHrrfl

or <<HauBHoi.i

AoraAKu>

(npanulluoii

oruo-

rrreHlrrr BecbMa rrpocrbrx

c"nyuaea) K

aocraroqHo

c,'roxHoii

Qopnay"re,

oxna-

TbrBarouefi 6o,r luoii

crer(Tp o6rexron. B

HyrpeuHnlr MexaHr,r3l{oM TaKoro

ABlrxeHr,rs

BbrcTy[aer KpilTuqecKuii

analr.re uuerculeiicx

r4cxoAHoit rr{[o-

Te3bI

(llarlBHori

4ora4xu)

qepe3

[olbrrKu ee

AoKa3aTenbcTBa

rroMorrlbro

Nrbrc,'reuHoro

aKCrlepHMeHTa c

H/IearIbHbtM o6beKToM, B orHorrreHr.rr,t

Koro-

poro

crpopuyJrrrpoBaHa r.rcxoAHaq

fr{Ilore3a. llpu arou

ilo;lBrglorcq,rro(il/rb-

nble I,L'Iu r,'ro6arbHbre KoHTprIpllMepbr,

rrporr{Bopeqaune

I4cxoAHoIl ru[o-

Te3e. I4MeHHo oHH

Bblcrylalor reM oceJ'rKoM,

Ha KoropoM orraqr{Barorct

3HAHI,Ifl.

14. Jlararoc o6ocuosrrsaer Bo3MolKHocrb

rpex cnoco6oe

Aeiicrnua

(rpex

cTpaTH reM

)

n eror:r Kplr3r4 cH

o it c r{ Tyarlrr u.

1. Meron

ycrparleHrrt

<<MoHcrpoB>,

[pI{ KoropoM nepBoHar{aJ'rbHa.g

rll-

noTe3a

(nannHaa

4ora4ra)

coxpaH.serc.q 3a

cqeT TaKoro [epeonpe-

.4eIeHn.q

ee TepMHHoB,

qTo

KoHTprrprrMep

I{cToJII{oBbIBaeTcq KaK na-

ToJ'IornqecKr.rit

c,ryvait

(rrloHcrp),

roropuil He craBr.rr noA coMlreHr4e

caMy

AofaAKy.

3ro

cKopee

o6opouure,rbHaq,

Hex(eJrr{ HacTynaTeJ'rb-

Hag cTpaTerHq, TaK

KaK MbI 3aKpbIBaeM nyTb

AJ'rg Aa'lbHefiIIeIO

Co-

Bep[reHcrBoBaHvfl

3HaHI{t Ba cqer ero

pacnpocrpaHe}ruq

na 6o,ree

cJIOXHble CIyrIaLI.

2. Meroa

ycrpaHeHu.q

llcKJ'rrorreHrlii

stlgsaeHue

ycnoBuii,

orpaHu-

r{rIBaIourl4x

o6racrb npLIMeHeHLIq

rulrore3L,I,

repBoHarlaJrb}Ioe

rlpeArlo.rlolreHue

He or6pacblBaercq,

yrorrHfl.ercg.,

Ho 3To

yrorIHeHl{e

Irocr{T BHerxHxit xapaKTep

rro orHolreHl{ro

K cyrtr caMoro

Aoxa3areJrb-

crBa B

Sopl,re

Mbrc.rreHHoro sxcrrepnMeHTa.

l,raea 2.

l4cropha

paaehrrin

h coepeN,aeHHure npeacrae^eHus...

M ero.{ Bx,'rroqeHr{.q JreM M, 3aKJI roq arcul

ufr,cg.

yroq

HeHuu ucxoAHo

$optuy,rupoBrr{

rr{rlore3bl

rlyre\{ Br{rIorIeHI,rt B Hee B KarlecrBe

orpa-

Hr{r[rBaroulero n Ko]rKpeTr.r3r.{py}ouero

yc,loBttq

Tex HetBHbIX no-

cbr,'roK, npeHe6pexeHue KoropbrN{r{

<<HanBHofi'> (c,rnurroru

o6u1efi

HeKoHKperHofi) rpopuy-rrfipoBKe

H nopoxqaer Bo3MoxHbre KoHTpnpu-

uepu.

otxpbrTHe

3Aecb He HAeT rrr{ B}il{3, Hu BBepx,

c,rleAyeT rro 3rrr-

aaroo6paeHoMy rlyrx;

To./rKaeMoe

KorrrprrpuMepoM, oHo

ABrr)Kerc.g

Haunuoii

AoraAKr,I

rIpeArIocbL'IKaN{ Ir rorol{ Bo3Bpaulaercg Ha3aA,

.Iro6br

yHr.rrrrol(urb

HarrBHyIo

roraAlry

3aMeHrITb

ee reoper{or:i.

Taxlru o6paaom, noAnHHHar

MeroAonofrq, rlo urlal(arocy, He

AonxHa

6url Hu r{HAyKTrIBLIcrcxofi, Hr{ oAnocropo}r}re

AeAyKruBncrcxoii.

Oua

Ao,'IXHa

HccJIeAoBarb KoHcrpyI(TIrBHbre rtpoqeccu o6orau etrfl,,

pa3BrTrrs,

coAepxaHr,r.rl HayqHoro 3HaHrrr

nupa6arrtBarb coorBercrByrorque HopMbr,

rrprreMbr,

croco6u r4ccJ]eAoBaHux.

llporunopeqne MexAy BbrABHHyrr,rMrr

IIoJIO)I{eHUSMIT H I(OHTpnpIrMepaMrI BbrcTynaeT CTr{MyJrOM

AJ.rr

<<BK"'IrOqe-

Hr4sl> KpvITVxo-peQ,rercr.rnuofi

ycraHoBKH

no orHo[IeHnIo K

c,'roxHsilreii-

c.q rIo3HaBare.nrsoli cr{Tyaquu, BbrsBJreHlr.g ee

cKpbITbIx

(nexnHux)

rocbr-

JIoK,

qro,

cBolo oqepeAb,

BeAer K

3alycry

Irolrcrpyr(TlmHofi rsopuecroii

Ae.arerbHocrr{

MbIc,'Ir{ rto fipeoAo,'reHrrro c,'ro)Kr{Burel"rcq xpusucnoii cvrya-

uHr.{

rryTeM BbrxoAa 3a ee rrpeAe,'rbr,

pacuupeH}u

rro3HaBaTe"rrbHoro ropH-

3oHTa I{, HaKoHeu,

$oprrry,'llrpoBaHr{s

6o,ree 6oraroro, rro,rrHoro u r,ry6oro-

coAepxaHu{ MbrcJrr,rMoii

pea,rrHocru.

Tax14.

Jlararoc

peanu3yer

B cBorrx

paHHrrx pa6orax

KoHrlenuuro

BHyr-

peHHero

eAnHcTBa JIorltKH

AoKa3aTeJ'IbcTBa

r{ o[poBepxeHH.g, Jrorl{Kr,r oT-

Kpbrrr{s u

onpoBepxenug.

cqrrrar

csor? noAxoA 3aBepruarcuuM

ara-

rtoM B

pa3Burr.ru

Qa,rlcuQuraqnorursMa

H HacralrBa,'r Ha roM,

r{To

HyxHo

orxa3arbc.a or reoperur{ecxoii lro4e,tu

K. llonnepa, B Koropoll

3a BbrABr{-

xeHr{eM uexoropoii rurrore3bl

Ao,'IxHa

o6.ssate,'It,Ho

c,'IeAotsarb

rlpoBep-

Ha oflpoBepxl{Mocrb. Hu o.{uH DKcnepr{MeHT

gBJl.{ercfl

perxarcIquM

AocraroqHbIM

A,'Iq

onpoBep)KeH vfl

Teoprrr4. tr4cxoAsul,r

nyHKroM

Ao"[xHo

6urr

ycraHoB"rIeHne

Sa,rlc

nSHur{pyeMocrrr

rurrore3br,

BbrABI4xeHr{e

r{ccJreAoBaTeJrbcKoii

nporpaMMbr.

llccaeAonarenbcxas [porpaMMa

reopr4s

(nepuee,

cept,ts

reopHii

pa3-

Horo

ypoBH.rI),

cnoco6nax 3arrllrIIIaTb ce6xnpucTo,'rKHoBeHr.rrr

c KoHrprrpI,I-

MepaMH. B nporpaltnae BblAer.flerc.q

<<TBepAoe

-{Apo>

(ocHonHrre

nprrHrll{-

Irbr I{Jrr{

3aKoHbI) n

<<3aulrlTHbre

rrogca)>, KoTopbrMI{

{Apo

oKpy)raet ce6s,

B CIyqae

cTo,'IKHOBeHU.S C sMnUpHqeCKItMlI 3aTpyAHeHngMI{.

Hanpuuep,3aroHbr tr4. HrrcroHa

o6paayror.rrApo

[ocrpoeHuofi HM Hc-

c"'reAoBareJrbcxoii nporpaMMbI, cro,TrHynurefi ca c Ko HrpnpHMepoNr,

pac-

cqHTaHHas rro orHM 3aKoHaM op6wra rrJraHerbr

Vpau

oulrva,racr or rofi,

2.7.

h. Aaxaroc

h roHuenuhs

aNyrpeHHero

eahHctaa,\orhxr...

KOTOpyrc

QaxctrponaaH

acrpoHoMl{qecKrre

ua6,rrcAeHng.

osuaqaJo

-rru

3To,

r{To

cJ'reAoBa'ro

or6pocurb

3Tr,r

3aKoHbr?

orurcAr

uer.

AcrpoHonron

Jlene-

pse

6rr,ro

cAeJraHo

AonoJ'rHrrrenbHoe IIpeArIoJ,roxeHHe

(saulurnufi

noac)

cyulecrBoBaHlII{

eI]Ie

o4HOr:i

[JraHerbl

co,lue.IHofi

cucreMe,

r{epe3

roA

3ra

nJTaHera (llnyroH)

6uta

o6wapyxeHa.

Ecnu

sra

rr{rrore3a

He rro.rl-

rBep.4rrJ'racb,

npHAyMaJTr.l

4pyryn.

Taxuu

o6paaou,

Teopu.rr

HltxorAa

Sa,rrcnSrzu

npy

er cs.,

a BbrrecHrercx

4pyrofi

lyvruefi

14.

Jlararoc

ro"raraer,

r{To

HccJ'IeAoBareJlbc*a.s

[porpaMMa

c nueuruefi

cropoHbl

IIposBn'lerc{

KaK

cepHs

reoplrfi,

IIocJ'IeAoBareJ,rbHocrb

I(oropbrx

3aAaer

sApo

r.rcc"rreAosare,'rr'cxoii

[porpaMN{br.

ocuone

roro,

I,rMeerc.rl

nr{

flporpecc

B perrreHr'ru

npo6"nenr

cepuerl

reopuii

KoHKypHpyrouIHX

rac-

cJ'IeAoBareJ'IbcKIrx

npotPaNIM'

HX N{ontHo

oUeHI{Barb,

cpaBHlrBarb

H roBo-

pI4Tb

O TOr{Ke

HacbrilIeuu.g

roit

l.utu

unofr

Hcc"rreAoBare,tlcrcorl

npofpaMMbr.

o6rexrou

MeroAoJ'rorrlqecKoro

alaJrr43au

coorBercrBeHHo

oueHKLr

ee$erc-

THBHOCTII

.'IB"IIqIOTCq

CPABIII{TCJTbHT'rC

O6t,.'CHUTCJ'IbHO-NPEACKA3ATCJIbHbIC

Bo3MoxHocru

cepurt

reopuii,

r.rMeroqnx

o6uee

a4po.

or4e-nbHbre

rroJro-

)Kr,rre"TrbHble

rI orpHqareJ'rbHbIe

[pnMepbr

rlo

orHotrreHuro

K or.ue.nlHori

teo-

prflI

N{a,'IO

r{TO

3HaqaT.4n.g

ee oueHKLl.

tr4.

,rlaxaroc

Hapr{coBar'r

AocraroqHo

[rr4poKyro

Kaprr{Hy

J]roruvecrofi

pe-

ItoHcrpyKuIrI{'

I{croJIKoB

a}llds,

ncr

opwrecKoro

npouecca

rro3HaHl{t

oop-

B3ar{t\{oAeitcrsus

pa3nuqHbrx

ltccJle.4oBareJlbcKrIx

[porpaMM,

nugui4

pa3BHT

rLfl

3HaHr'Ig,

or[paBJ,I.qrcutrxc.q

ltcxoAHof

ocHoBaHHr

(rnep40ro

tgpa)

u flpeAloJ'rararcur{x

KaqecrBe

MexaHu3Ma

cnoeii pery,r.sunr{

Hera-

Tr{BHbre

r{ rro3r{rr.rBHbre

sBpr{crtrKu.

Ilepntre

Hoc.{T

cKopee

o6opoHureat-

Hur?

xapaxrep

r4 HarrpaBJreHbr

Ha coxpaHeHne

rBepAoro

rApa

[porpaMMbr

rrpx

croJ'rKHoBeHur,r

KoHTpnpHMepaMn;

BTopbre (uacrynare-nlHue)

yvar

ToMy'

KaK

pa3Bl'{Barb

ucc,IIeAoBaHI4.{

paN'II(ax

nporpaMM,

KaK

coBeplleH-

crBoBarb

reopuu,

co3AaBaeMbre

Ha ocHoBe

4auHofi

nporpaMMbl,

KaKI{M

HC-

TIbITaHI{'IM

Hy)ICI{o

rloABeprHyrb

AJ'I.[

aroro

IIprrHgrbre yrBepxAeHH.t.

Izlcc"neAonare,rbcKa-q

[porpaMMa

Moxer

6u,,

nn6o

npoip"..rpyrouleii

(ecrlr

reoperu.recxr4fi

pocr

rrpeABocxurlaer

pocr

aMnuplr.{ecrnri

n npo-

rpaMMa

ycnexoM

rrpeAcKa3brBaer

r{oBbre

Qaxru),

"ru60

perpeccrapyrol]1er?

(ec,ur

uonrte

rfarrrt

[o.rlBn{Iorcg

HeoxI{AaHHo,

[porpaMMa

Aaer

r{M

3a-

rro3Aa,rbre

o6'sscueuus).

Ec,ru

oAHa

H3 KoHKypHpyrourrx

nporpaMM

rrpo-

rpeccr.rBHo

o6'nqc:rfie"r

6o"tlue,

qeN{

Apyrar,

rrepBa,

BbrrecHser

Bropyrc.

f,raaHoe,

tr4.,Ilaxarocy,

oro

BHyrpeHHee

eAr.rHcrBo

reH4euquii

onpaB-

AaHrrfl

ll onpoBepxeHu.{

ucxoAHbIX

rIpeArIo,'toxeHHii,

Koropoe

onpeAeJT.rler

HEIIPCPbIBHOCTb

PA3BI.ITI,Iq

HAYK,

O6OTAUICHNC

KOHKPCTI43AIIUIO

HCXOAHOIO

coAepxaHrr.rr,

BbrBeAeHrre

oAHHX

Sopu

aHauu.tr

Apyrux

rroA

BJrnrHneM

rtporHBopeqllfi

calroro

rro3HaHu-s.

2.8.

Crapbte

ahxoroMurr

B coBpeMeHHblx

MeTOAOAOIXqeCKXX

nOAXOAaX

2.8.1.

Hosute

KphrepuH

HayqHoro

3HaHHe

MeroAo.nornr{

HayKlr

cocyx{ecTByror

pa3r{bre HanpaBneHL{f

aKUeHTlIpy-

rcIIIneoAI{I{unupg,ALl3cJIeAyIoUIHxacIIeKToBpaccMoTpeHngpocTalIayq-

HOro

3HaHlls:

courroJlorlruecrnii,

r{cTopr{Ko-rrayvnlrii,

Qopltallno-,rortt-

.recxlrii,

JIIiHIBIIcTI{r{ecxHii,

TeopeTL{Ko-3N,lnI'lPlIuecKI'Jit,

a rarxe

3aAaHHbIe

AilxoToN{I,I.qNIH

IyMaIII4TapHoe

ecTecTBe}IHoHayqHoe'

pauI4oHa,'Ib}Ioe

r{HTyr{TuB}Ioe

U T.

O6paulaacb

IIoIta

npo6-nelte

acCI{N{HIIUHII

trx

B rrCt{XoJIoInn

reu

5o,ree

nopoxAeHI,Ig

co6crneUnUx

MeToAo,rIoIrIqe-

CKI{X

[peACTaS,'reHuii

paNlKaX

trc11XOroruqecroii

Hayxll

npaxrttxr',r)'

rrpeAcTaBtrM

HeKoTOpbre

u3 Hrrx.

oAHoepelreHHo

paclxIIpHM

TepMTIIIOJIO-

rIIIo'

KoTopag

[pII3BaIIa

OXBaTI{Tb

n,'Iu

[oAI{epKHyTb

IIpeBa,'IlIpoBa}IIIe

3Tr.rx acfle;Tos

Halt6o,'Iee

u3BecTHbIX

N{eToAoJIornqecKlrx

no4xo4ax.

flpu

aToM

Bceii

orIeBtIAHocTb!o

nposBn.{eTcq

oIpaHualeHIIocTb

N{apKUpoB-

KIl

aBTOpCKI,IX

KOHUeIIUUI"I

KaK

IIpOIUCbIBaHLIr

Vx B

paMKax TOfo

TIJIII

ilHOfO

HanpaBJeHl,Iq.

B rouuenuutr

T. Kyrra,

KoTOpbIii

BBeI

[oHqTr.Ie

Hopl\Ia,rIbIIOn,

LInlI Iapa-

AHfManbHoli,

HayKH,

coqeralorcfl

ucropuorpaSHqecKuii

counonornqecKl{i'i

acneKTL,I

MeToAo,{ot-tlqecKoro

aHa,'Ill3a.

O6palleuue

coUualbHo-ICIIXOJIo-

fIIr{ecKu}I

acIIeKTatlI

AegTenbHocTu

yreulrx,

o6UIe}Iun'

[oArIepKuBaHue

ponu

HayrrHoro

coo61lecTBa

KaK

coo6qecrBa

nloAeii

ro.nrrco

u4eii)

3TH

Qaxroplt

pa3Buruq

HayKIr

qerKo

[percraBneHbl

ero

<<IIapaAIIrMa[bHoM

TIOAXOAE>.

llapaAurnlr

K,'raccnqccKoii

uayxu

B rreplroA

cTaHOB,lleHII.q

ecTecTBo-

3HaHr.Ig

Bt{JIIoqarI[

Ta6ne

cyU{ecTBeHHbIe

Tpe6OBaIInfl'

KaK

cJ]eAoBaHIIe

K,'IaCCUqeCKOMy

I{Aea-[y

paquoHaJIbHOCTIt,

TOM

r{I{C"Ie

npoBepl{y

AocTo-

BepHocTr.I

3HaHU.q,

I{JIII

KpIITepuii

ncruHnoctll,

a TaKxe

rtp14IIgTUe

CaMooqe-

Bt{AIlocTI{l'IcTlIH'I{oTopbleHeIIpeAnonafaeTc'[poBepqTb(rleilocpeA-

cTBeHHafl

AaHH9CTL'

lexaprona

<<q Mblc,'l1g>).

fIepeocullc"IleHlIe

TaKI{x

KapTe3uaHcItlIXKpuTepueBHayqHocTII3HaHIIg'KaI{eIoAocToBepHocTblI

carr.rooqewtAHocr;,

6rt,ro

ocyt{ecrB,rlego

tI.

llupco1l

70-e rr'

XiX s'

flpaxruuecxne

[ocneAcTBLI.tI

AeiicTBgii

ocuone

3HaHuq

BoT

HoBblii

xpurepuii

HayrrHocrH

HarrpaBJrerrutr

rro3lITlIBLIcrcKoii

$nloco$tltl,

uo-

ryr{nBueii

Ha3BaHUe

<< IIparNlarr3M>>.

Ilparnrarnslr

HanpaBJreHue

IlO3HTtrBI43Ma,

<< paccN{aTpl'lBaxlulee

3Ha-

qeHue

rIoHflTLIit,

cy)KAeHIIii

u np.

Teplvll{llax

[oc,'IeAcTBItt"I

ocHoBaHHoro

HlrX

AeiicTBL1q,

ycI]eluHoCTb

ltoTopoIo

CocTnBr-l11€T

eAUHCTBeIIIIbIii

KpH-

2.8. Crapute

azxotovtth

coapeAaeNHutx

A4eroaor\orrqecxNx

noaxoaax

TepHri

trcTt{HHocTI{

oroXAecTBl1.qeTc51

c HeIo>

[Ou.rroco$cKat

3HUIIKJI9-

ileILrfl

1967, r.

4, c. 336].

B 90-e

rr.

XIX n.

5,raro4apa

pa6oraM

Stl,rocorfa

rcuxoJ'Iora

Ixeiilrca

(1842-19I0) nparltarneM

ro,'IJ/rIIrr'I

lxlrpoKylo

nonyn"qpHocrb.

EraroAa-

pfl pa6orail

,41)yroro

aMepHKaHCKoro

OllJ'locoQa'

ncttxo-lora

u neAarora

!x. filron

(1859-1952), Itoropbli'I

Ha{IIHarI

c flparMaruqecKoii

lrHrepnpera-

qur.r.rro|HKII,TaKOL"IBapUaHTrlparMaTll3Ma,KaKUHCTpyMeHTa,'It{3M'[peBpa-

TrtJtcs.ByIII{Bepca[bHblii!

MeToA

N{bIlU-IIeHI{s,

craB B CL[lA

<<IIoqTH o$UUua,'Ib-

Hofi

Ou,{ocotfueii,>.

OcHosori

,rlort{qecKl{x

$opu

3aKoHoB

lnruu

o6lxnu,r

He oTpDKeHUe

3aKOHOB

6ArWs,

<<crloco6

Aei{crB[ii>.

HHCrpylreHTa,'rH3M

3TO

pa3HOBrlAHOCTb

rlpafN{aTrr3N{a,

pa3pa6oTarrHaJI

filrcrl

paccMaTpr{Barolua.rr

HHTe,'rJreKT

B KaqecTBe

cpeAcTBa

npficfloco6-

ileHLr

s. K 113

NI e Hs

lOUIt',lMC

noBrrq

M cpeAbl.

2.8.2.

@annu6unuzra

9. llnpca

(1839-1914)

ynpera,ru B

c1\{erreHrrr{

J'ror}rqecKtrx

H rrcuxo,'roru-

I{CCKI{X

ACICKTOB

IIO3UTI{BI{3MA

KAK

METOAO,TOIHII

HAYqHOTO

Mb]III''IEHIIq.

Oruerur,r

3Aecb ro,rrbKo

ABa

NloMeHra.

llepnufi

paccMorpeHl'Ie

ocHoBHoil

Syrrxqtru

MbtIUJIeHus

u Hayr{Horo

rlo3Halrllrt

Boo6ue

rlo3lllluit

6uonoru-

qecKoro

U trclrxo,rlornqecKoro

y,{oBneTBopeIIHs.

ColnacHO

IIIIpcy,

IIo3IIa-

Hrre

no3BoJIqeT

npeoAo,'IeBaTb

<<6egloKoliHoe

u HeIIpIIsTHOe

cocToqHue

coMHeHI,I.q>>,

pe3yJlbraTe

qero

AocTllraeTcg

Bepa,

ocHoBaHIIu

KoTopOfi

qe,,roBeK

Moxer

AeiicrBoBarb

6ee colttteutti't

u xone6asnrl.

Bropoit

BBe-

Aer{tre

1peAcTaBneHuii

ToM,

qTO

HayqHOe

rIo3HaHlIe

MOXeT Har{UHaTbc.q

n106bIX

rr{rloTe3,

B ToM

qqcJle

It otUnSorIHbIX.

AKUeHTupoBaHI4e

[peAlono-

)KHTe,,rbHoro

XaparTepa

HayrIrloro

3IIaHH.{

np}IBeJIo

llnpca

K o6ocHoBa-

Hrrro

oanJrrx6w,tuawa.

B csoeli

olgcaTeJrrbHoii

ncnxonor11u

flu,rrreii

BbIAer'Irln

HMeHHO

npeAIIOIO}KnTe,'IbHocTb

IInoTe3

B KarIeCTBe

OCIIOBHOTO

ynpeKa o6b.qcHnre,{bHoMy

MeroAy

B HayKe

o6nxcruurenbHoii

[c[Xo,TIo-

II.ru

An.'I

Qaltu6umrcMa

f urlorerl{qHocrb

Hayr{Horo

3HaHuq

Bblcrynaer

ecrecTBeHHOfi

COCraS,'Igmueii

ero craHoB,'IeHIrt.

a;^vu6utnt3M

sro MeroAo,l

or11qe

c Ka.q

II o3I{

H.fl

co r,'iI

ac H o Koropoli

rro6oe

3HaHI4e

nnIUb

rlpil6nH3IlTeJ'IbHo

I{ Bepo.qrHocrHo'

Y. Ilupc

noAqeprHyr,

trro

HayrrHoe

3HaHue

Moxer

llaqlrHarbc'fl

c nlo-

6nx

npe4noJlo)I(eHl'Iit,

ToM

qlrc,'Ie

omu6orrHblx'

Hay'IHoe

ucc,'IeAoBa-

Hr{e

3TO

<<XLI3HeHHbIii

npouecc>,

fiporeKalouuia

B Kpl{THtIeCKXX

CnOpaX

npoBepKax

IIpeAnonoxeHHfi

KaK

HayvHbIX

ru[oTe3.

fIo:urunHrtM

pe3ynbraroM

TaKoro

IIpo{ecca

flBrfl'ercs

KoppeKTIrpoBKa

rnIroTeTI{qecKolo

3HaHH.fl

IIOBbI[IeHI{e

BepO.STHOCTII

ero KaK

3HaH]',IC

I4C-

rrrHHoro.

B xpuruvecxoM

peaJII{3Me K.

llounepa

vnes,

Qailm6ulnalra

npe-

60 ft,aaa

2. lrlctopun

pa3Br,trru'fl

coBpeMeHHbte npeacraBneHhr...

oopa3oBar{a

yr{eToM

opr4eHTrrpoBKH

poJ'rb

KpnTr,rqecKoro pa3N'rbrrxne-

HHq B nocrpoeHl{n

o6r'er<tttettoro

3HaHrrq il

BO3Mo2KrroLrrb orle}Ir.IBaHLrs

ripaBAoII0A()6ux

uayurrt,rx

rrrrrore3. llpe4cran,reHuro

aroIl

N{eroAoJrortrqe-

cttot"I

KoHUeIqlril,

npoTIlBoIIocTaBlrBltIeI"I

rIo3IITtrB].IcTcKI{M ycTaHoBKaM

Te-

opr4ro HaIr6o.nee

cTporoii IIpoBepr{r.r

rnrroTe3 KaK

TeopeTrrqecKt{x peKoHcT-

pyKuHri

Ha ocl{oBe

orrbrTHbrx

AaHHbrx,

N{br nocBrTtrJ'rr{

c[eur{a"IbHoe

MecTo,

rrosToMy

flaJree

r{p?TKo ocTalroBr{MCq

Apytrrx,

vrroN{}tHaBlIlHXC.rr

eilIe

KOHrIeIIrItr.rrx.

Corirrr-r,lorn.iecxrrr.i

aclexT

qerro

Bbrae,rrrerc.q

B no.4xoAe

Ax.

Araccu,

pacci\{arprrtsae}ror{

KaK BapnaHr

$tannw6wtntar.ra

IAraccrr

,1994].

flocraenn

Bonpoc o coorr{oureHllll

aBTonoMriocrll

HayKI{ s

o6ruecrse }I aBToIroMHo-

cru

yrreHoro

B paMKax

HayrrHoro

coo6ulecrBa,

on HacrarrBaer

Ha npuopu-

Tere aBTolIoMHocrrr

yrJeIIofo.

Y.{eHrrii B3J'Iat\,tbItsaer ycro.rlBtIII{ecq

KaHo}{b]

Hayuuoii pa6ortr,

BK,rrrcqa.q B KoHTeKcr

HayqHoro

rto3rraHr4.q <.Slr,rocoQ-

cKue,

[oJIIrrI{qecKIIe

I{ aKoHONIr,Ir{ecxne

6ara,rnH, I,IAyIuI]e

n ror"r o6ulecrneu-

Hoii cpeAe, B Koropyrc

lorpy)Keua

HayKa>. To ecrr,

ycroqBrxr,rec.rr

Hop-

MaTI,IBbI HJIlI [apaAl,tfNfa"rIL,HbIe ycTaHoBKII

yrIeHbIX,

a HX ]te3aBllct{MocTb

r{ caMocTo.rrTe.rrb}rocTb

B BbrIBr{xeHun

npo6lenr

rr norrcr(e nyreir

peue-

HI{g JIe)KaT

B OCHOBe

pa3BLITIt

IIayqHOfO 3HaHH.q.

2.8.3. Pen-fl

rNeHsAl',r onepauhoHanl,t3M

flptrauaune

orHoclrre,rrbHocru Hayr{Hofo

3HaHI,Iq

uMeer I{HbIe LlcroKLI

B cra-

pux

Qu,rocorpcxnx

KoHuefluu.qx,

[o,'ryqrrBrrux

Ha3BaHr,rq

pen.sruBr.r3Ma

Ho-

NltlHa,'IH3Ma.

MeraSnsuuecrnii

pe,rxrr{BH3M,

rrpr.r3HaBaBrrrr.ui

cyurecrsoBaHr{e

aerqeii

rr rIX cBoiicrB To,rrbxo

B orHo[reHr{.{x K

ApyroMy

(uanprntep,

Bocrrpr{Ht{N{a-

IorueN{y ux cy6texry),

nocxo4ur eil{e

K no3r.rqr.ru

Eepxalr

(1685-1753),

Bbrcra3aHHofi

nnr s

<.Tpartate

o Haqa.{ax

qeJroBeqecKoro

3HaHHI>.

fgoceo-

,lIOf I,IqeCKUM

peJl"fl

TLIBH3MON,I OTJ'II{qarcTcg

BCe KOHIIeIUI{H,

Cr{HTaIOIUHe

Ha-

ytIHLre

3Har{u{ 3HaqI{MbIMtr

Jrrr[rb B onpeAer'reH]rbrx

rrpeAeJrax

aHauur,

Heo6nertuaHuntr). llporaropoBcKoe <.He,rotser

ecrb

MepnJro

Bcex nerqefi'>

IrepBoe o6ocHoaaHlle

srori no3r4rIHH,

cBg3brBarouleii ,rru6oe

3HaHr.Ie

c ul.g.u-

Br{AyaJ'rr,r{brM

orrbrroM.

llyrl or

Qn,rroco$Hu

oMrrupr.r3r,ra

Qn.roco$nn

er,r-

flr{pr{oxpurr,rur{BN{a

oAHa us nuuuil oSocHosauns

orHocure,{bnocru

aHa-

uufi a

reoplrr.r rro3rraHur. Kpurnuecrurii paquoua,rrlsN{

K. flonnepa

4pyrofi

rryrb, rrpeArro,raraxtrueii

Bo3MoxHocrn

o6lexrfi sHoro

3r{aHrrs

(na

ocHone

OIpaHnrIeHl'I.fl IloJI.q

HeBep]ItIX f]tIIOTe3 B

pe3yJ'IbTaTe

IIX

3KCIIepHMeHTar'Ib-

uoii npoaepxu).

Cnryarnnuocrb,

ycJ'toBHocrb

I{ orHocHTe,rbrlocrb

Hayr{Horo

3HaHu.rI

[o.{-

qepKuBaeTc.fl

peJ'rtTr,IBHcTcKr{x

I{oHrlcnqtrtx,

IlepBalr

H3 KoTopbrx cB_{3aHa

2.8.

Ctapue

arxoto",ah r

coepu"eHnux

r,etoaonotr"ec*r"

noa*oaa*

c r'rMeHeN{

f,xefilrca.

llparuarualr

lxefivca

3aAaBaJr

raroft

xpurepuii

lrcrllHrlocrl{

MbIIrIJIeHn.g,

I(aK ero

noJ'Ib3a,

BblfoAa,

x xoropoii

oHO TIpLIBOAt{T.

flpe4cran,reHbr,rr

B MbIIII"rreHHn

npo r43

BoAcrBe

HH L,Ie,

6 uroBue, pe,,rrrrno3

Hbre

Anu

HayqHble

cBs3rt

aro

MeHee BaxHo,

qeM

To 6,raroycrpotlcrno,

K r(oropoMy

onrr

MoryT

flpr.rBoAlrrb.

Taxuv

o6pasou,

ara

KoHuerluu.fl

npeA-

IIOJ'IATACT

OTHOCI{TENbHOCTb

IICTIIHHOCTU

C TOqKI4

3PEHN'

TIOAI{I4HCHHOCTIT

rHocrrrqecKrrx

ue,refi

r.lHbrM

- [parMarnrrecrulr.

{pyroii

cyuecrneuHrrii

ee acneKT

rIpI{3HaHHe

B KagecrBe

peaJ'IbHocrll

Bcero,

r{To

BepHT

qeJ'Io-

nex.

KpltrepnI{

}TCTLIHHOCTH

r,I

peaJlbHocru

Har{HHaror

coBrraAarb,

ecJrrt

cy)t<-

AeHHe

(6yar

3HaHlre

r4nr4

BepoBaHne)

npneo4nr

HyxHbrM

(yaosner-

Boprrc

uI4M

ve-noaera

)

nocJ'IeAcrBHqM.

AnroHouuocrb

r.I

orHocHTe,'rr,Hocrb

BHaHr,rs yrBepxAarorc.q

s oAHoii

roHuen{nli

orrepauuo]ra,rru3Ma,

c rf

n;rocorpcrl.rM

o6ocHosaHr{eM

xoropoii

Bbrcrynr4Jr

7927 r.

rI. Epn4xr,reH

(1882-1961)

n ero <..IIoruKe

coBpeMeH-

Hoil

Qusnr<n>

rtrcrasa,'r

ary

HAero

1920 r.

eu:llx

H. Keun6e,rn).

B arofi

MeroroJ'Iorulr

aKcnepuMe

HTarb*acrlpoueAypa

crana

Bblcrynarb

KaK

cpeAcrBo

BLItBneHI,I.rr

roqHofo rpnsltuecroro

cMbIcJ'Ia

Her(oropblx

tpuanve-

cKHx noHgrrivl,

T. e.

onpe.4eJleHue

noH.qru.g

I,IMeer cMbIc,'I

ToJIbKo

B KOHK-

peTHor,I

o[epaunoHaJIbHOrvl

KOHTeKCTe.

cyuecrneHHefinrtu

npH3HaKoM

Hay{Horo

3H aH:l,A

flBilsercq

Bo3Mo)nHocrb

o[epaquoHanuza\uvt

KaK

ycraHoB

ileH]1.g.

onepaquii,

nocpeAcrBoM

Koropbrx

qeJ'IoBeK

3a,4aer

rrpeAcraBJrleHne

o6 onrrrHblx

AaHHbIX

(ary,ruul.ilo

[percraB-

reHug Harrlroro

3Halrn.q

N,rbI

yxe

paccMarpnBar'Ilr

npr.I 3}IaKoMcree

o6uuN{u

noJIoxeHII.aMH

Heono3urunnelta).

OnepaqnoHaal43M

[oArIepKHy,'I,

r{To

Ha}n{-

HOe 3HaHtre

He Mo)r(er paccMarpllBarbc.g

6eeotHoc[terbHo

I]cI{xr4K

e LrHIr4Btl-

u urryar\r4H

ero

[oJ'Iyqeuu.g.

3Ha.reHu.rl

Ha)ArHbrx

nou.qrlrfi

onpeAen.rrlorc.q

onepaqu.gMfi,

Koropbre

orHocrrcq

r cnoco6au

noJrr) {eHH.{

rdHAI4BrrAyaJIbHoro

orlbrra.

onepaquu

ofpaHI,IqeHbI

BpeMeHHr,IM

acrIeI{ToM

r{x

ocyuecrB

rreHvfl,

AOJIXHbI

PACCMATPI{BATbC.'I

KAK HAAbIHAHBI{AYZUIbHbIE

CYIqHOCTI4.

O6'U"-

crBeHHaiI

HayKa,

c roqKlr

3peHfi.q

aBTopa

3Toii

roHuenqntr,

Mr{(b,

nocKonbKy

Ila) {HaiI

Ae.srerbHocrb

3TO

Jrr4qHOe

qacrHoe

4e,to.

<.Mo.a

HayKa oflepaquo-

HarbHo or,'Il{qaerct

salllelz

HayKI4,

KaK

r.r

MOfl 6o,rl

or"[n.{aerc.s

naueii

6o,ru.

3ro BeAer K

npr3HaHrro

roro,

qro

cyqecrByer

cro,Tb*o

HayK,

cKoJ,IbKo

IrHAHBr.rIoB > (

Ullr.

no xH.

:,rlerropc

ut tfi

197 2).

2.8.4.

HomxuaanrM,

peaAH3M,

paul.toHant43M

Houuuaanau -

Qlr,rocoQcroe

yqeHue,

corJracHo

KoropoMy

o6ulHe

nou.r-

TI,I.fl

He r{Melor

oHToJrorr4qecKoro

coAepxaHu.q.

o6ruee cBo/.urcs,

K cJ'roBaru,

HrTlr rrMeHaM (nomina).

cxolactnxe -

CpeAHI4e

BeKa

HoMHHaJ,rrr3M

rrporr.r

Bocro.rrJr peaJ'r

H3 My

(

ueu u

n I

po6,r

enr

wnn

t:a

mrk).

fnaaa 2.

Vlcropun

pa3Bhrhe

h coBpeMeHHbre

npeacraBleHug...

KourlenryaarraM rrprr3lraBaJr

y)Ke

cyuecrBoBaHHe 06urrlx

rIoH.qrllfi B rlo-

3HarorueM r{x

yN{e.

Peaauau

<.o6t,exrltBHo-IrAea,IIltcrIrqecKoe

$n"uocorpcxoe

yqeHue,

co-

r,TracHo KoropoMy o6ulee o6"raAaer

o6lexrunHr,rM

cyu{ecrBoBaHr{eNr,

rrpeA-

urecTByeT eAHHrrqHbil\r KoHr{peTr{brN{ rrpeANreTaM rre3aBrrcuN.{o

or unx>

[@i.r-

.nocoScxaa aHuIIKJIoIIeAur,

1967

r. 4, c. 47 4).

raxnlr rroHrrNraHrreM He

c,rreAyer nyrarb rprrruvecxnri

pea/rl{3M

K. florr-

nepa,

Koropbrii a4exnaruee Ha3brBarb Kpurur{ecKuM

parluoHa,'rH3NroM.

Pe,rqruetreNl B

coqeraHurr c noMuHa,'rr{3MoM cra,r xapaKTepHbIM

I,I

A"[q

HoBbrx

Qn.rocoQcxrlx

HalpaBnerrHii, n

qacrHocr[

Heorro3r{Tr{Blr3]!{a

yxe

ynoMIIIIaBIXefOCg KpTITI{Ka nO31{TltBt{3N,{a, a[{epI{KaHCKOTO ,'tOfLIKa, Nf aTer{a-

ryrnau

Su,'rocoQa

Kyaiiua.

pacclrarpunaa

rpo6,revy noauoxHocteii

Hayr{HOIO IIO3HaHK.tI KaK

BbI.flBJ'IeHI'lt

efo IIpeAe,'IoB,

3aAaBaeMbIX

paMKaMII

Qoplra"rluoii

crrcreNrbr, o5r,eAuHgtou{eii nolyvaeuL,Ie c [oMourrrc

ua6,rrc-

netng.I{

aKcrlepHMeHTa

AaHHbre.

,l[orn.{ecxrle

rI nI{HrBucruqecK}Ie acrIeK-

Tbr aHanH3a

pocra

Hayr{Horo

3HaHH.s

cranr{ B atoii

xoHqenrlHrr rnaBeHcrBy-

rcur,rNru. B cnope c

oAHuM r43 K,rraccnKoB Heono3r,rrlrBr{3Nra P. KapHanolr

OH nOAqepKHBa,'I,

r{TO

IIpI{H.flTIIe TeX I{,IIU IIHbIX t3bIKoBIrIX Kapl(aCOB

pe-

3yJrbrar, no,ryuaeunli

B rrpaKrr{Ke uayvuoii

Ae.srerbHocrr.r

yqe}rbrx.

B3a-

HMHOe

COUIaCUe, IIJIII KOHBeHUI{g,

3TO

COUUa,'Ibuo-[ClIXOJIOrtrVeCXUit,

a ue

cpopuanbHo-Ju.rHrBrrcrn.recxuft

Saxrop.

Q alru6vnu3My cetoAHq

[porr,rBocroqr

pa3nurrHbre

KoHuerlqun

pat1no-

Ha,'IbHocrll. Oruerurr.r

caMoe tunpoKoe IIoIII4NIaHI,Ie olrro,'IorilqecKoro

pa-

ur{oHa,'r}{3Ma

(u4yqee

or ll'Iaroua u ,rleii6Hl.Iua

fere,rx).

PaI1uorra;ruau

<.,rto6oe

yqeHne,

corJracHo KoropoN{y

BclKalr

peaJlb-

I{ocrb

rrMeer s ce6e caltoii u,'u,I B Haqa,'Ie,

Koroporo

oHa nponcxoAlrr,

Aocraror{Hoe

ocHoBaHr{e

AJrrr

cBoero 6bttttsl>

[(Dn,roco$cKarr

3HI{HK,'IoIIe-

tus,

1967.r.4, c.4701.

B reopuu

no3HaHr,rs

paqfior{anr.r3il{

craJr roii

Qn,locoQcxori

6asoir

n XVII 8., Koropaq [porLrBonocraBi{ra

oproAoKcanbHoMy reo,'Iornqe-

cKoMy Mr{poBo33peHnlo

ocMbrcJreHne

AocruxeHuri

NrareMarr,rKrr n

ecre-

crBeHHblx

HayK, rAe rroJryqeHlre rrcrllHbr c

JroruqecKr{vtr

csoiicrraMl{

Bce-

o6ulHocru lr Heo6xoAuMocru

cB.s3brBa,rocb He c orrbrroM, a co

cBoIlcrBaMr{

caMofo

pa3yMa. <.

oc,ra5;reulre>

K,rraccuqecKoro

pauHoHa,'rH3Ma o6cyx4a-

"rlocb

Bbuue B cBrBr4 c reopneii

rto3HaHuq tr4.

Kanra.

PaulronarneMy npo-

Tr{BOCTOSJTH

UHTyHTTIBH3M

Apyrl{e

Hppaur{OHa,TnCTnr{eCKHe

reopUI{ nO-

3HAHH'.

Hoslre

aapy6eNHnre KoHuerluHH

pauuoHar-rbHocrlr

cBt3bIBalorcfl c

oqe-

HUBaHUeM

KaK OcHoBo[oJ'IafarclUI{X

HayqHblx rilnoTe3' TaK I{ npaBIn

rrpoBeprcu,

I,rHcrr.Ilyunannallpyrcuux

flyrb K rIcrrIHHoMy 3HaHI,I]o. tr4

erv

2.8.

Crapue ahxoro,r.urh

a coepe,\aeHFturx

veroloaorhqecrhx

noaxoaax

nyrn colpnr{acrHbr

Apyr

Apyry,

TaK KaK ,'rroA}r

cnoco6uu

4eueHrprrpoBarbct

oAHr,rx

Tr{IIoB

paulroHaJirbHocT[

ApyrHe,

IIoHIINra.s

Apyf Apyra.

Pea.[neNa

rar)r(e

flpocJ'Iexr{Baerc.rr

B coBpeMeHrlbrx

MeroAo,rorl{qecKr{x

KoHllerrqusx.

Anrop o4Hoii

lrx <<ctrJrbHbrx>

nepcuii pearn3Ma

B. HlrcroH-

Cvur

SoplryJrr.rpyer

cneAylotr1r{e yrBepxAerrux:

)

reoperuqecKHe

BbrcKa-

3bIBaHI,Ig

I{CTI,IHHbI I{J'lI'I

JIO}KHbI

3aBIICI{MOCTH

OT TOIO,

I(aKI{N{

MUp OKa3bI-

Baerc.rr

caM rro ce6e,

a He B

cr{J'ry no3Harourero

ero yN{a;

Aoxaeare,rbcrBaMrd

I{CTI{}THOCTH

TeOpUil

MOfyT BbrcTy[aTb

cBrrAeTeJ,rbcTBa

cyIIecTBoBaHHq

TeX

cyuluocrefi,

r(oropbre

Ao,'IxHr,r

cyulecrBolrarl,

vro6u

reopug

6tuta ucrnv-

uofi;

MoxHo pallrroHar'rbHo

peilrr{rb,

KaKar{

r{3 KoHr(ypr{pynqnx

reopuii

6o,ree

6"nnexa K

rlcrurre;

)

ncropn.lecKl{

cJrorxrlB[ra"{c"rr

locr'reAoBare,]rb-

Hocrb

reoprlfi

ecrecrneHHofi

Hayre sBlrfl,ercfl

rlocJileAoBareJ'IbHocrblo

re-

opuii, pacnoJrolrceHHbrx

Mepe 6o,rlruero

upu6,ruxeHrrJ{

l{crrrHHocrrr

(qur.

no xn.: flolrorart6tru,

2001,c.

386).

uaroHeq, orNlerll\{

)Kl{3}IeH}tocrb

nocJ'IeAl{er.o

I.t3 IIa3BaHHLIX

uDorn-

BorrocraBJreHnii

paquoHa,'rlr3Ma

I{ HHTyrrrr.rBlr3Ma.

2.8.5. Vnryutneuzm

Vluryurunu3M

B Teopur{

loaHaHr.r.s

Bbrcryrraer

r(ax

pa3HoBuAHocrb

r{ppa-

ul4oHaJ'nr3r\{a.

B XX B.

ero Kpylueiiuue

flpeAcraBtrreJ'ru -

Eeprcou,

3. fyccep,rl,

H. ,IIoccr<r.ui.

B noaspeuuax

lexapra

r.r

CrrlrHoan

nHre,rr,'rer-

TyaJ'rlrrraq

uHTyr{qug

IIpeAcTaBnsJa

co6ol"r sbrcIIIrru

aKT

pa3yN{Horo

rro3Ha-

Hnq, He

ucKJ'Iloqal,outrii,rorttqecKoro

MbIIu,'IetIur{ H

qyBcrBeHHoro

orpa)Ke-

}IHg. B lrrrryIITrrBri3t\{e

r{aK r\{eroAoJrorr{H

II03]Iarlr.u{

r.rHTynun.rl

craHoBrlTct

HppaqrroHaJlbH

brM ar{Tor\r

rro3

HaHrrq, B KoropoM

qxo6

lr npeoAo,rreBaerc.s

IrporHBorroJro)r{Hocrb

N{e}KAy

cy6t,er<rorvr

u o6t,errolr.

Vxe fllaroH (427

-347

rr.

H. a.)

yrnepx4a,r

Bo3MolrcHocrb

co3epqalur.s

lt4eli

nyreu BHe3anHoro

o3apeHur,

npeArroJ'rararcqero

Anr{TeJ'IbHyro

IIoAro-

TOBI(y

yMa

r{ BeAyulero

HerrocpeAcrBeHHoN,ry

trHrenJ'rer{ryanbH0My

3HaHnro

(nyrl

uure,r,rexrya,rlnor.'r

rrHrynquu).

lexapr

cqr{TaJ'r,

rrro

pa3yM

Soplre

HHTyI4ur{fl

rrpnBoAl,tr

x 6o"ryee

AocroBepHoMy

3HaHI{to, <<qeM

caMa

AeAyKuI{r)>.

A. EeprcoH (1859-1941),

Br,rcryrrarr

trporlrB

MexaHr,rr{u3Ma

AorMaruqecro-

paurroHa,Iu3Ma,

yTBepxAa,rl

IIepBr,rqlrocTb <<pear'rbHocTt{

xr.I3rIII>>,

CyTTIHOCTb

rcoropoii

rocrr.rxr.rMa

J'rrtxb

uHryuI1ueri.

Bc"ueA

sa A. l[IoneHrayepoM (178S-

1860) oH

Hacrar{BaJ'r

Ha r.rppaur4orra,'rbHocrr.r

urrryr.rruBHoro

rr03HaHr.rq.

<.guc-

rarr

uHTyr.rqrr.s>,

c ero

roqru 3peHn.a,

He rpe6yer

nonsruituoro pa3ruqeHr,rq,

a sHarIIIT,

AaeT

pauHorrzlnbHo

lreBbrpa3l{Moe

3HaHHe.

Irlurynrnnuoe

rro3HaHr,re

KaK

nyrb K r{crnHe

rrporr,rBorlocraB,rr.q/rocb

pa-

rtI,IoHaJ'IbrroMy

tr ts MeroAo"rrorrln.

Heueqxurl

$lr,roco$

fyccep_ul (

1859

1938)

auanuHyJ'r

nporpal{My

rrpeBpaueunx

Qu,rocorpllu

crporyro

Arrc-

tJ-

laaga 2. hcrophs pagehrtr

h coapeveuHure

npeacraaneHilq...

qllrrnuHy,

3a,4aroryyrc

ocHoBbt J'Iorr4Kr{

HavqHoro

3HaHur.

Srolly 6lr,r

uo-

cBt

IIeH eIO

AByXTON{UI.IX

<.,llOtttqecKrre

I,tccJIeAoBaHIIfl

;

IIO3AHee

OH CTa,'I

ycMarprrBarl

$yrrxqun

rlnnoco<[Iu

KaK

pacKpbrtsanilleii

He N[rp

HayKr{,

<<)l(Ir3HeHI{blri

MLIp,>. Paccrrorpen

Kprr3r.rc

enponerlcrnx

Hay( KaK

Kpn3uc

o6t,eKrner4aMa,

rrorrbrranc.{

co3Aarb

parluoHanr.r3N,r

}roBor.o nu4a.

Sruv

HoBbIN{ }IanpaBJ'teHrIeNI

crana

dreuolreno,rof

t,tr{, cAeJ'IaBttlaq

oc}IoBI{bl\{

<<Bo-

npoc o crpyltrype

npouecca

"nepexttnanulr"

trcrr.rH rr o6ulesHaurrMbix

LI71eii,

B3qroro

B BHAe rleJrocrHocrr,r,

B BtrAe HerrpepbrBHoro

rroroKa>

[Conpeuerr-

Haa 6ypxyasHax

@u,roco$trs,

1978,

c.2l4l. f,rasHr,rNr

i{eroAor{

raKor.o rr3y-

qEHH'

TIOTOKA CO:]H HI,Ifl

CTA,TIA I,IHTEJ'INCKTYA.TI

HA.S HHTYH{U.S.

B or,tn.rrre

or r{nryr.rrnBrreua

6eprcona, opueHTrrponaHutrrl

rra <feHorvre-

HoJ'rorr{to

fycceplx

r.rHTyr,rrr,rBrr3M

npeArroJrararr

rre06xoArrMocrb peQnerccrrr.r

aKToB co3HaHHs

AaHHoro

B rrtrx

coAep](aH[q.

flocrr.rxeune

Qenol.re-

HoB

rra oroM

nyrrr flpoucxoAur

nyreM co3r,r4aroruei.i

rrHTyl{U]rr,t,

Koroparr

rpe-

6yer oceo6oAr'rrbc.s

ilpr,rBbrrrHoro

xoAa r\{brcJrrr

ero

<ecrecrBerrrrbrN{r't

ycraHoBKaMr.r'>),

vrcl6tr BepHyrbc.q

K n3Har{ar'rbHor)i

gautocrrr

nro6brx .qB-

-neHur:i.

3rouy cJrvr(r{T

$euolreno,roftrqecKaq

peAynqltr{

[orrbrrr{a <<rrp!1-

ocraHoBKr{>

rplrBbrqHbrx

cyxAerruii n neponarrnri.

Henocpe4crBeHHoe

6ecnpe4nocttror{Hoe

co3epuaHr,re <(qucrbrx

cyrurocreii

e4rrrrcrBeHHo

npa-

BH,'IbHbrii

rlyrb rroHrrNraHu.a

co3rrarru.s c

rpaHCuelrAeHTa/rbHo-$eHonreuolo-

ruqecrofi

rr03rluuu.

oplreHrnpoBKe

Ha rre[ocpeAcrBeHrroe

3narrrre

Nrbr 6yAeN{

AaJ'ree

fotso-

pllTb

B KOHTeKCTe

npOTLIBOnOCTaBJ'IeHrr.g

COBpeMeHHbIX

IlapaAlrtI\'r B Ilclr-

xoJrorlrlr

(r,rana

9), a o nouuuaHr,rrr

raKofo rryrr,r rro3HaHrrs

KaK l,reratprrar.r-

tlecKoro

B rlporflBorrocraBJ'tenuw

JI.C. Butotctrttlr

AByx

ncuxo,roruri

(r.lana

5). B

aanHoii

)Ke Kparxoii

crpaBKe orN,rerr{t\{

Tor'rbKo,

rrro,

HecMorpfl

ero rrporpaNrNrrrbre ycrpeN{J'rerrr4s,

trMx

fyccep,ra cra,'ro cB.s3brBarbcq

HNrer{-

Ho c uppaurronaJ'rrrcruqecKllMr{

TeqerrurNrrr n <fulocoSun.

Ero accr,rcreHT

M. XarlAerrep

[oc,'reAoBare,rrL,Ho

pe:Llu3oBa-[

Qeuonreuo,rornqecrl.tii

]\{eroA

Ang

KpnrHKr4 HayqHoro

no3HaHrrq

(calr

fyccep,tr, cqr{Ta-rr,

rlro

nclroJlb3ye-

Mbre rrM rroHrrru.q

rrcKDKeHL,r B rroAxoAe

Xaii4errepa). Ho n

qe,ror{

d)eHONre-

HO,'IOltlg IIpI,I3HaeTcq

OAHUNI II3 IICTOqHI'tKOB 3t{3UCTeHI{IIa.rlU3N{a.

2.8.6. TeoperNvecKoe

aMnr,rpr4r{ecKoe

Oruouegne reopur{ K orrbITHbI[I

AaHHbrM

r{ Kpr{Tepr{rr, orJ,tr{qarculrre

co6-

crBeHHo

reoperr.rqecKoe

3HaHr{e, o6cyx4arorcr{

ro,'rbxo

n rfu,roco$-

cKo-MeroAoJrorrrqecKilx

pa6orax,

Ho rr B rt03nuu.qx yqerrbrx,

alrpa6artr-

Balorqux 3TH Kprrrepur,r

KaK o6o6rtleHuq

xoAa HayrrHori

4eare.rrlHocrrt.

llpune4eu B

KarrecrBe rrpt{Nrepa Kpr.rrepun

reopnrr, [peAJror{eHHble

Be-

"rr14KI.IM

$ualrxolr

3iiHurreiiuou. .IIrc6a.s HayrrHarr reopus orJruqaerc.s

2.8. Crapure ahxorovrh e coeper,.4eHHurx A/eroaonorhqecrhx noaxoaax

reM,

qro

oHaAonxHa

(unr.

no xs.:

flolrorair6nrr,2001):

<.a)

ue flporr{Bo-

pequrb

rxallHbrrr

orrbrra,

Qanran;

6) 6rrrr rlpoBepqeMori Ha

uuercuqenrca

orrbrrrroNr Marepl4ane; e) ouuuarrcg

"ectectneHuoctt,lo",

t. e.

",toflrqe-

crori npocroroii" rrpeAnocbrJror{

(ocHonHlrx

norrsrurl n ocHotslrbrx

coor-

Houreurrrl

N{elxAy

Hnltu); r) co4epxarr, rrarr6o.rree onpeAeneHHbre

yrBep-

)K/Ieilr.rfl:

oro

o3lraqaer,

rrro

r{3

AByx

reopnii c

oAuHaKoBo

"npocrbrMu"

ocrroBrrbrNrr{ rroJro)Ker{r.sN{u cneAyeT npeAnoqecTb

Ty, IroTopar cr,rr'rbr{ee oI-

paltrrr{uBaer

Bo3N{o)KHbIe ailpnopHbre Kar{ecrBa cucrel\t;

le aa,rxrncg. Jro-

ruqecxr4 rrpon3BoJlbllo ntr6paHHoit cpe4u

upn6,rrr3lrre,'rbHo

patsHorIeHHbIx

aHa./rorur{Ho nocrpoeHHbrx reopuii

raxov cnyqae oHa rtpeAcraB,'rserc.rr

Hau5o,ree

qerrHoii);

or,rlrvarlcs

r{3srrlecrBor\{ H Kpacoroii,

rapruoHrrv-

HOCTr,ro; X) Xapanrepu3oBaTbc.q lrHoroo6paaHeM rrpeAl\{eToB,

KoTopbre oHa

cBq3brBaer ts

uenocrHyn

cr.rcreN{y a6crparquii;

a) uuerr urupoxyn

o6-

JIaCTb CBOefO npIIMeHeIIHq C

yqeTON{

TOfO,

qTO

paN{KaX

[pLIN{eHHll{OCTtl

ee ocrroBrrbrx noHr{rrri.i oHa }rr{KorAa ue 6y4er onpoBeprrryra;

yxaslr-

Barb rryrb cro3AaHrrs uonori, 6cl,ree

06ulefi

reopuu,

paMKax

roropoilr

oua

c2rMa ocTaeTcrI IlpeAenbHbIN{ cJIy\taeM>.

r o x u s tu t,t \{ cq B e cr e c r B 03 II a H rI I{

N,t

r oA

i'I o rllq e c K II tu o

c H

B aH I{ e ]\{

rrocTpoeHuq TeopeTHrrecKoro 3HaHr{q

cIyxtIT r,rcno,'rb3oBaHrIe

TaK Ha-

3brBaeNrbrx rrAea,qbrrbrx o6t,exroe. Taxlre uAeaJ'IbHbIe

o6t,exru

urpalor

uelrl'panbHyro

ponb

B rrpeAcraBneHlrn

HayqHbrx 3axoHoB. Teopernvecxaa

r\{oAe;'rb

cyulecrBeHrrrrx cn.saeii xax 6rr

[o,raraerc.s Ha u3yr{aeMyru pearb-

iloclb. flprl arolr rrrilorerilqecroe 3HaHr.re, c oAHofi

croporrbr, oQopu-

r.{ercJr cpeAcrBar,{H }rAeaJIn3auHu

(nx-rruuaa

N{oAeJIr{poBaHue

tl\,rblcJIeHHbre

sxcrrepuil,{eHru), a c

Apyroii

[poBepqercs

no orHorueHr.rrc

K Bo3N{oxHo-

crrr oflncaHrr x u ct6tscuerrrr.s eroii

Dea,'rbHocrn

c rroMourbrc

vcraHaB"/rr,rBa-

eMbtx 3at(oHots.

{"ux

rynrarrnraprrbrx rrayK rryrrl u cpeAcrBa

locrpoeHr4s reop[t{

Moryr

6rrrl

uHrrun. 3Aecr Moxer

6brrb

HeaAer{BarHoii xar uAes

flo,'raraHu"s

(aeay-

quponaHua)

3aKoHoB Ha n3yrlaeMyro

pearrrt,Hocrb,

TaK u

nyrb rlocrpoenllg

I{.qeaJru3rrposaHHrrx o6T,eKros. Ho c roqKu 3peHuq

ocHoBHtIx cpeAcrB

MbIIr-

JIeHtrr{

B t'yMaHI{TapHbIX Hayl(ax

TaKXe

nciloJ'Ib3yloTcs rryTu

lcplrrtrvecrofi

rpoBepnfi o6o6uleuui.i, rroJraraeMbrx B KaqecrB

TeoperilrrecKr4x

npeAnoJlo-

xeHuii.

llcr.txo,rotn.recKt,re reopr{rr

lrMeror oqeHb

pa3Hble

crpyKTypbl,

a MbrrlrJre-

IIr{e ICUXO,'rOrOB

pa3HIrrX

HayqHblx IIIKOJI B

paaHOfi

CTeIIeHtI

OpI{eHTr{pOBa-

Ho Ha MeTOAbr, rrpeAno,'ralarcllll{e oueHKy r4cTr,rHHocTrI

Teopnr{, a He

ToJIbKo

AelroHcrparll,rrc

coorBercrBynurlx eii

Qaxron.

B Hayrone4eHt{r{

rryrr4,

xa-

paKTeprl3yroIIlr4ec'I

I]orIcKoM IIoATBepxAarouIHx r,r, HalpoTr4B,

onpoBepla-

K)rt1r'rx reoprrrc

AaH]rbrx,

cBr3brBarorcq c 6oree

paHHr.IMr{

n 6o"ree

no3AHr{-

1.23e1