306 lnaea 11. Meroaorrorhs
o-reqecrBeHHbtx
h
aapv6exHutx
noaxoaoB.,.
<<tserIHbIr\r>>.
Ec,rlr xe cl6parHrlca
K ar(Ttllrrocrr4
qeJroBer{a
rra
ApyroM
ypoB-
He
-
[pou:]BoAcTBa cN4bICJroB,
To BepTuKaJtr, ator:i crfepu
oKa3bIBaeTcg
BIIe
crpyriryp,
3aAarrubrx
pauKaNrrr
Aerre,'rbHoc'i'Horo
noAxo4a
(lrorrrr,
rqe,rt,
o[epauru,
cMbrc"r KaK orHorrre]rr{e
N,{oT'uBa
rr rle.rru).
He ucnol
sayq [pqMo floHrr']re
Ha/lr,r HAr{ B rrAyiu bHo ro,
Eparycl B\,recre
c
TeM IIOMeCTI{,rI
<<y3eJI
O[OCpeACTBOBaHIIT{>>
B C]\'IbIC,'IOBbIe
[pOCTpaIICTBa,
KOTOpbre cyuecTByoT
o5reKtusuo
KaI{
<<eAtrHoe
crlbrcJIoBoe
IIoJ'Ie
qeJIoBe-
rlecTBa>>.
<.!elte;tluocTb
Ile nopo)KAaeT 3TtIx iIpocTpaIIcTB,
Ho tBJiI.seTc.q
cIIo-
co6ou HX
Bbrpa)Kerflrs u rpuo6uleHr.r.q
K r{rrM>>
[Eparycl,
1999, c. 105].
14
nxnaA
"II.
C.
Bnrorcroro
3aI{J'IIoqa,'Ict B yr{:r3arrrrr{
cauoii eo3N,ro)Krrocrr{
HaAAeTITeIbtIOCTIItIX
lIpOCTpaltCTB,
C IIIIbL\I}j 3al{oHaNILI
}IX CTaIIOIIJIeHII.fl
II
SyHxquonnpotsaHlrs.
CoorHoruenue coqt,taJIbHoto
tt IrHAHtsl,tAyaJ'IIrHoro
B rlpoueccax oaltaqrI-
Barrur
-
He
MeHee Ba)Krrafl [po6neNra,
AeNrorrcrpnpyrcu]aq
pa3,lruque
rrpeA-
craBJIeHIrI"r
o6 aprerpaxrHoNr olocpe.4crBotsaHrrr.r (rro
Koy,ry) r{ 3HaKoBoM
orrocpeAcrBoBaHuu (no
Blrrorcxor,ry).
E.
C. Eparycl
cSopuy,rrrpoBan rrpe/IcraB.lerrrre
o <<HaA,{Hq]rocr}rbrx
cMbrcJrax
npoucxoAflrrlero>>,
I4N,tef B BrrAy,
qTo,
cTaHoBqcb
BHyTpeHHIII\{H,
oHx oflocpeAcrByror
qer'roBeKa.
Mlr 6r,r sAecl'
Ao6aeLrJru:
olocpeAcrByror
<<BTOpOe pO)I(AeHUe>
qe,IIOBeKa,
eCJIU
I{CIIOJ'Ib3OBaTb TepMIlII,
BBeAeHHblii
M.
K. MauapAarxBr{Jrr4 ts crarbe
o6 o6usocrn
-
Kyr'rbryporeHHocru
-
Ha-
yKl{
Lr HcKyccTBa r,rMeHHo
c Tor{Krr 3peHr,rg
ucKyccTBerrHocTII
cpeAcTB, 3a-
K"rlrcqatorlHx
B ce6g HaAbIHAI{BLIAyaJIbHble
cxeN,rbI <<oqe,'IoBequBaHlr.fl>
cy6bercra
IMauapnaruwr,rrr,
1
985
j.
B
4pyrr.rx
pa6orax
MalrapAalununrr
o6cylxAar'r raKxe
cJ'reAyroil{yrc
trpo-
6leuy:
MbIuIJIeHrrc
KaK aKT r!{o)fier cocro.flTbcg
rrJI14 Her, noroMy
rITo
MbIcJ'Ib
c a.Monp uuuHHa.
Ee Bo3
H l.r KrroB eHlrro r{o}KHo
cnoco6crBoBarb,
Ho rre.[b3.s
orBerraTb
(H
xcraru, c
no3IIIInfi ca\.roro cy5lerra
Nrbrur'reH[q) 3a
ro, co-
crourc.q oHa
I,tJIr{ Her. flplr
Aocraroqrror,r
BHr4NtaHuI{
K
po,'rrr
coqHaaluoii
cuTyaIlHI{ pa3BuTu.q
-
c}ITyarlu[
<<rrpa-Mbr>>,
IlpeAno,'rafarcqer1,
uro
pe6e-
HoK
oBJ'IaAeBaer
3Har{eHI{t{N{Ir
ro,rlblto B of)illenun
co B3pocnbIt\t (a
He B cnry
Tofo,
rrro
eMy BpyqLIJrI{
3rraK), r.rAerr cuo6oAbr
are,'roBeKa
B ToM,
ocyulecrB-
JrflTb
MJrLr rrer ar(T
oIIocpeACTBoBaHurr,
fiar(-To
yrxna
lra nepucpepuro
npe4-
cragrertr.rii
o caN{opetyJ'Irqur{
B trrroJle
Burotcrcoro.
Cxo4uaa
po,'rb
KoH-
TeKcra r{ar
ycJ'roBr,r.fl
oBraAeHuq
apre4)aKTaN'rr ro/IqepKuBa,'racb
Koy,rolr.
3garonoe onocpeAcrBonaHr,re
rr
pa3Burlte
Mr)rrr,rerru.s
-
Hepa3pbrBrrbre
npoqeccbl
B TeopHrLrI.
C. Br,trorcxol-o. MttuueHtre <<operleB,rtqercrl>>,
a
perrb
<<IIIITeJL'IeKTyaIH3L{pyeTC.rI>
-
STtl
ABe
JI}IHr,IU pa3BHTIltI
IIepeCelrarcTc.q
LIMeH-
Ho 5raroAapr{
3HaKoBo\.ry olocpeAcrBoBaHr.rrc.
Ec,tlr c,re4onarl o6ueii
rcoH-
r1erruuu Brrrorcxoro
o6 uucrpynresra.rrr,Hoi;i
rpynr<r1un 3rraKa
Lr
yqurbrBarb
I I .1.
CoepeveHHar
rpaKroBKa
KynbrypHoi
aerepMhH a.tr1r4...
307
IIpIIBOAI,IMbIe
B KHL{re <.Mltut,'letttte
II
perlb>>
IIcc./IeAoBaHLra,
ro
Heo6xo4n-
MO
pa3nHqaTb
pa3Hbre
ypoBHrr
3HaKoBoro
ollocpeAcrBoBaHuq,
cooTBeTcTBy-
t<lurre
AByN{
ypoBHflM
o6o6ulerrnj.i
(ua
ocrrone
HcrIoJ'rb3oBaHu.q
xnreficxux
rr
HayqHbrx
nonnv.it).
Texcrrr
JI.
C. Br,rrorcroro
ocraBJrrror
6o-nlnryrc
ceo6o4y
n nu6ope
roro,
t{To
)Ke 6lt,ro
r,ragHblM
B aroit
Ko}rqenqr{r,r.
Paccnrarpunag
aKT
oBraAeHu.a
3HaKoM
KaK <<r{3roroB,reHlre>
3rraKa B
ero lrrrcrpyMenra-rttHoii
QyHxquu,
A. A. flyalrperi
noguepxuy,'r
[cuxorexHr.rrrecKuri
acnexr
craHoB,'renur
c.l.pyK-
ryp BbIcrilLIx
IICHXnqecrKtrx
Qyrrxuntir
[|lyer,rpel:r,
1986].
i4neuHo <<cr4rHri-
Qnxarnn
nlre aft TbI >
rtpeAcraBJ'r.qrcr
co6o ii
qer
o
Ber{ecKufi
cloco6 pefyr'rfl -
quu
rroBeAeHr.rq.
B Htrx
peopraH[3yercr
flcrrxtrr]ecxuii
annapar.
B xoHrexcre
orrbrrots
no
Qopllr.rpoBarrulo
14cKyccrBeHrrlrx
noHqrr.IIZ
Blr-
rorcruii
rr3MeHr.r.[
TepMr{}ronorurc
u craJr roBopr.irb
o cruMyJ'rax-cpeAcrBax
He KaK
o <<rrcr{xoJ'roruqecxr4x
opyAl{flx>>,
a KaK
o 3Harax
[,{eoHrlee,
l9B2].
flpyrr.le
uccneAoBarenx yxa3brBaror,
o/lHzlKo,
rra Bo3Mo)r(Hocrb
lIHbrx
TpaKToBoK
B3l'rfl
AoB
B urorcxoro
Ha cyrb
coqna,r lHoii
AerepMr.rHaII
Hu ncr4-
xnqecKofo pa3Br,rrrlg.
Anrop
KarrnraJ'rbHoro
rpyla
no
ucropurr
reoperr.r-
qecKux
4uclcyccrrri
s
cosercxofi
ltcr.rxoJ,rorlrr{
A.
A.
CuupHoB
orMerraJr,
r{To
rIpeAcraBJIeHHOe
g
erofi KoHueIuull
noH],IrIaHt{e
3HarIeHLLrI
cJ,IoBa
KaK eAlI-
Irr4ubl
aHaJ'Itr3a peqeBolo
Mbrrr,'IeHr.lr
ecTb
KJ,rroq
K rroHHMaHI{n
npHpoAbl
qeJloBeqecKoro
co3Hallnt
B
IIe.TION{, a
He OIAeJ'Ibno
ssgroii
.re,'IoBe.Jecxoii
MbIC,TIr.
B
rarolr KoHTeKcre
Bce peqeBoe
Mb[trJ'IeHHe
ecrb <<o6lqecrBeHHo-
rcropnrrecxax
Qopua
rroBeAeHr{{>
[Cuupuon
A.
A., 1975,
c. 1751.
Z
n
apy-
roM
KoHTeKcre rrporIuTbrBaercfl
<<onocpeAoBaHHocrb
crpyr(Typu
4eft
crwta
apreQaxrou>>
B KHrrre
M. Koy,ra
IKoy,r,
Igg7, c.
142].
Taxuu o6pasolr,
o6ulHocrr
Asyx
paccl{orpeHHbrx
reopuii
ua
cauou
Ae,re
Moxer
Br{Aerbcs
B rrHoM paKypce,
qeM
3To 6rt,ro
npe4craBJ'teHo
B
Arlcryc-
cr.{oHHbrx crarb.flx.
B ro xe
BpeMs
ronbKo KoHKperH3aqr,ra
6a:onlrx
noHa-
'rnii
n oruoureHurl
K
yr{HrbrBaeMoMy
aMfluputrecxoMy
MarepxaJry
r,r
Kare-
I'OpUaJIbHO
rrpeAcratsJTeuuoii
ncnxo,rorur.Iecxorl
pea,rlr,HocrH
tro3BoJrlser
orreHl4Tb
oco6eggocru
sTtrx pa3Hblx
ficuxoJ'roruqecKHx
reoptrii
lt
llx npe-
CMCTBEHHOCTI{.