Корнилова Т.В. Смирнов С.Д. Методологические основы психологии
Подождите немного. Документ загружается.
f,nasa
B. flcnx<.r,lorhqecKaq
B
TIYBCTBCHHOI"I
JIAIIHOCTII.
TET,{
CANIbINT
BOCI]PTI'ITNE
I{
ACIiCTBI{E
(NrrAUr,)
qeJrloBel{a
BbJCTVIIaTOT
Kan
83arrr,IoAeficrnne,
conpuKaca.scb
c troBepxHo-
crbro
cyilIelo,
cvurecrtsyroIIlefo.
3ro craHonl..Tcfl
rr
r{cxoArrbrN{
]tyHr{ToM
rJ'I.q
reopHll
IIo3HaHut,
n ocIroRaIII{eM
BI{-IIIoqeHI{.q
r{eJ'IoBeKa
(n
cosua-
ulrr)
a e4rrHyFo
lplrrilrHHVro
rlenr co6rrrru?.
To ecrb
HeJTb3r{
Te[epb
or-
Ae,'IbHo
paccNlarpuBarb
llprtlnHHocrb
llr'Lq
]\IUpa
BlIeilrHero
r,r
N{Hpa
BHyr-
peHrrero;
[pnqr,rHHocrb
3aAaHa
eAnnorl
o6ueri
AerepMr4HarIr{eri.
Boenpaulaqcl
r npo6;relte
KpLITr,rKr{
floHrrrrt
clrryaqr{u
B re[ITar,rbr-
rcr{xoJTorur{
rr noAXoAe
Xaii4errepa,
Py6urrurTerlu
noAqepKr.rBaer,
r{ro
cr.{Ty-
arlHs
BCerAa
BK,{K)rraer
n ce6"q
qro-To
eue
-
rrpo6errrr,
r(oropbre
6y.lyr:a_
rroJrHeHbr
s ueri
qe,ronerolr.
Cnryarln.s
cB_q3brBaer
npou,,roe
u 6yayulee,
oHa <<Heu36exIto
ecrb
tsbrxoA
3a
ee IIpeneJrbI>>.
I4J-UIIO3Uq,
np].IpaBHHBaIOUra.{
ceo60gy
K
urrAerepr'rirHu3Nry,
c-rreAyer,
cor-jracHo
aBTopy
Ae.{Te,rbHocrHofo
noAXoAa'
u3
cN'IeueIIlIq
floH.srn'l
HeAepMI{HupoBaHHocrI{
rra,ru.rHlrN.{
6bl-
Tr'rer{
c HeAerep}rr
rH r rpoBaHrrocrlro
noo6qe.
Ha canrol.r
aeJ,re
Bo3r,Io)KHocrr.r
qeJ'roBeKa
onpeAen.qrb
csoe
5ynyruee
cts.s3arrbi
c
pa3BrrrueM
npeArxecrBy-
rotrlr4x
sTarroB
efo
xtr{3rrr{,
raN4ltri
u3
l(oropbrx paHee
6lr,1
5yayunlr.
tr'le [olrr{1\,1aHr,rq
coorHo[reHrr.{
qeJroBeKa
c MupoM
xax
o6lexlltBrroro
orHo-
IreHlt-g
cneAyer
raKll(e
paccJ'IoeHhe
eAI'IrIofo
noHIrMaHH.q
flpflquHHocru
Ha
cneAyrcuue
ocHOBaHU.S.
BO-nepnrrx,
pa3BereHr.re
npuqr.rH-ycroBr.rfi
u rrpnvnu-
[poueccoB.
Bo-nroplrx,
r'r3NfeHe]rre
rpaAr.runoHHoro
npeAcraB,'reHHJr
o eAr{-
r{ol"r
BpeMerrrroii
ocl.r
B Kay3a.rrbHocrrr.
B-rperlr,rx,3TO
onpeAeJ'reHHoe
rroHr.rr.ra-
Hrre o[ocpeAcrBoBaHu_s
xar
4ericrnrr;r
BrreuHero
qepe3
Br{yrpeHHee.
llpuvnHa,
lopo)KAarouaq
cner'ICTBue
KaK'3'{eHerru.q
s o6lexre,
Aaer
pa3-
ulre arpQerrbr
B 3aBr{cr{Nrocrrr
or BHyrpeHHux
yc,ronHr.i.
llpnpoga
o6rexra,
ero
cocro.sFrr.lc
lr3N{er{rrer
ee
BJ'Ir{qHue.
6o,ree
rofo, cyMMaprrlrfi
as$err
4efi-
crBH.fl pa3Hbrx
[prrq]rH
He aAAIrrHBeu,
o6u1ee
cJ,reAcrBue
He
paBHo
cyMMe
orAe"rrbHblx
cle4crnnii.
BosHnxarcr
taxNe
o6parHbre
npxqnHHo-cJreAcrBeH-
Hbre orr{o[Ieuna:
<.1)
Aeiicrer.{e
cneAcrBrr.q
Ha
npr.rqr.IHy
3aK,lrcqaerc.s
B ToM,
qro
r{3N,reH-qerc.rl
caMa
npHr{[Ha;
2) o6paruue
cB.rr3r.r
u3r{eH.sror
r{aqe
He
caMy
npr4qr.rHy,
a Jrr.[trb ycJ'roBr.rq
ee
Aeiicrsr.r.s>
[py6r.rHrureiiu,
1973,
c. 290].
A.
H.
"IleorrrbeB
rar{)Ke
o6par4a-nca
K
rtoH.srilK)
o6pamuoil
caasu
(n pa-
60rax
-,Ilaure,
6epHurrer"rHa
Lr
coBpeNreuHoii
xu6epuernre),
4euoucrpu-
pya
o6qeuayrrHoe
3HaqeHfle
rrpuHrlr.rlla
o6paruori
cBl3rr
v.
B ro
xe BpeMq
ero HenocraroqHocrb -
npu npHH.rrrnr{
4nyv,rerrHoii
cxeMbr
npr.{quHHoro
aHanI,I3a -
An.a
o6r.qcueHu.q
AerepMI.IHarIHII
rrcI{xuqecxoro.
B rcorruenur.tr
Py6nuureiiHa
naxHrrl{
TaK)(e
qBrr,Tocb
rroHrr\.{aHUe
rrpH-
r{uHbI
B KOIITeI{CTe
I]OHqrllt
B03N,IOXHOTO.
Hepa:,rHveHxe
IIpoucxoAfl
Irlero
c,'Iyqaq
u o6o6ruenlrq
ItaK
BbrpaiKeHrls
B noH.qruu
sToro
eAuHlrqHor.o
cny-
qA.S
CTY)fiI,IT
OC}IOBATIHCM
CBCACHU,'I
TIPHqXHHOCTI,I
IT
BO3MO)KHON,IY.
TAX,
8.3. hrMeHeHuq
a nouh^
aHfiri
nph'.14t-tt-locru
e csq:h
c oceoeHhev...
207
JIOIIITIECKUii
sMTIHPIT3M
BbIBOAT{T
IIPIIqI,IHHOCTb
3A
PAMKI'I
CYUITTOCTUOTO.
HO
I]pllqnHHr,re
cts.r{3r{
-
3TO, Cor,'IaCHO
Py6nUUlrei'irty,
He o6o6rr{eunq. OHlt
cyr{ecrByror
s
Aeiicrstrre,'IbI{ocrIt,
flocKonbKy
Aei'icrnnte,rlur'INI
BLIcryrIaer
TO,TIbKO
TO,
.1'1'o
nOa4eiicrnyer
IIa
Apyroe,
qro
yqacrByer
Bo
B3aIrMoAeiicrsI,Itt
rr ABJrtrercs.
eAIlHcrBoM BHe[IHerO
n tsHyrpelrHero.
IIpIIHIIHII
I]pUqHITIIOCTU
tsbrcryrlaer,
TaKuM
o6paaou,4"na
Py6uurureiiua
rre acIleKToM
IIo3Hatsare,'Ib-
rroro
orHorrreHI4rI
K
Aei,ic'rgute,'IlHoc'rtl,
a rlpHHuxnou
6ururlHor-o
pacKpbl-
Trrr
AerepMllIILI3NIa,
[o3Bo,r.qtoulrl{
npeAcraBHTb
caMy
Kareroplrlo
Ael]tctsu-
TeJ'IbHOCTI{.
<.'faXUU O6paaOU,
[prtl]rIIrlocTb
Hepa3pblBHo
cBf3a]Ia
c caMuM
cyulecTBoBaHtleM
I'l ero coxpaHetllleN{,
caN{oe cyIIecTBoBaHI{e
ecTb
H€
TOJIb-
r(o cocro.aHr{e,
rro H arr,
rpoqecc>
[Py6uHurreiirr,
1973,
c.
2BB].
C
yrrepx4el{ueM Ilpoueccya,rlbHocru
cBs3zlHo
tsai(IIoe I{3N{eHeHue
B no-
Hr,IMalrr.rlr
ilpl4HIIrr[a
Aerept\{trHautttt.
Ane,l,'tltpyq
K florlgr]lK)
<<caMoAel-l-
crBns)> ts
Ou3uKe,
Py6uurureiill
roBopur
o eos/Ieiictslrtr
o6r'exron Ha
ca-
Ml,rx
ce6fl,
B
pe3yJrbrare
rlero
oHH Ir Br,Icryrlalor
KaK
oItpeAeneIIIIbIe re,'Ia.
Taroe
cauo4elicrnl{e
Bo3Mo)I{Ho
roJIbt(o
BHyrpu
cucreMbI. 3ar<ou
coxpa-
rIeHr{q
npuTILIHHOCTI{
B
oH3HKe
03Haq
uer
coxpaHeHI{e cy6craHquoHa,'IbIIo-
crlr BHyTpr{
[pnquHbI. 3ra
<.npoueccyaJlbrla.q>>
nputluHa
rlopo)KAaeT HeKo-
Topoe
orAe,'Isrcueecs,
o6oco6,rqrculeecr{
or Hee c,'IeAcrBue.
3axonontepuo
[porel(arculuii
eo BpeNIet{I{ flpoqecc
B cBfl3l{
c BeulIIbIM
TIpeAMeTIILIM
XapaKTepoM
oKpy)KaloUIel'()
BIIe[IHe
Haq]IHaeT
qIeHnTbc.s
Ha
rlpurrnHy
rI
cJreAcrBl4e.
/[ereprtutraur4fl
Ha
ypoBHe
MbIIUJIeHH.fl
ABnxercq
IIo
noBepxrlocrn,
3a xotopoii,
n ee t',ty6trnIroM
c,'Ioe,
peanu3yercg <<rlpuqu-
HeHlre>
(rarc nepe4a.Ia
Aellcrsu.q
no
uefln
npnvHuuocru).
II
p
o4e c cg
aat'Ho cmb npuquHHo
cm u
-'t
or acII
ettT
u3MeIIeI
Iilt n
peAcraB"rle
-
ur{fl
o
Aeiicrnynrqeii
(noa4eiicrnyrculeii) rpualnHe, xoropltfi
nosxe 6ntr
peaJII{3oBaH B
orerrecrBeHuux
o6uencuxoJ'Iornqecrl4x
rloAxoAax K aHa"'II'I3y
MbrrrrJreHr{fl,
B
rrepBylo
oqepeAb B
IrIKo,'IaX
o.
K. TuXorrlupoBa
H A. B. Epyu-
JIHHCKOTO,
npeACTaBJIsIOqnX
pa3BllTIIe
pa3HbIX
AeflTeJ'IbHOCTHbIX
TIOAXO-
/tos
-
A. H. .IleoHrresauC.
I.
Py6uHlrrerlHa. 3ro
BbIpa3I4JIoct' B
rlepexoAe
r( MrrKpoaHaJlu3y
npoqeccoB
petyrquul{
B Mblc,'Il{relruoil
Ae.lreJIbHocrll
IIEJIOBEKA.
3AUCHA
x(E
IOCTAHOBKI{
BONPOCA
O
TOM,
KAK MbICJII{T MbIIIIJ'ICHUC,
Ito[pOCOM
O TON{' KaK MbICJ'IHT
TIeJIOB€K'
IIpl'IBenI{
It CJ'IeAyIOX{UM IIIafaM
-
trpl{3HaHI{IO
BbIXOAa
AeTepMI{HaUI,IH
He TOJIbKO
3a
paMKI'I
CO6CTBeHHO MbIC-
Jt[Te,rlbHoro
flpouecca
(n
vacrnocu{,
B Morl'IBl{pyrcUyrc
Coepy co3HaHuq,
t(aK
To
rlpeArroJraraJl
Burotcxufi,
B
cl{Tyauurc o6ureHuq u r.
A.),
Ho I{ 3a
paM-
KH cxeM
<<Ao
-
[oc,'Ie>.
HapqAy
c rrepeuHrepflperaqueii
axrl'lBHocrll cy6ter-
't
a
B caMoperyJr']d]/v
MbIITIJIeHI{'
3TI,I L{3l\leHeHIls
B I{CC,'IeAOBaTeJIbCKI{X
CXe-
Max rro3BoJulru
yr{eHuKaM
roBoplrrb
o 3apoxAeHllu
IlocrHeKJlaccuqecxoi'i
uapa,4r.rrMbr
B rra3BaHHbrx
rrrKorrax
IKlouro,
2003; 3uaxon,
2003].
l
,]
.-t
fl
c H xorrortr
q
ec rag
PaccltarpnnaeMbrrl
AaJIee
II'AX.A
npeAcraBJr.rler
cKopee
uKoJry
MbIrIr-
JIeHUfl,
a
He 14cc"ireAoBare"[bcr(yrc
napaAr.rrMy.
3ra
urro,ra
BDKHa
AJr.s
[peA-
craBJ'reHII.q
natreHeur.rii
B t\teroAoJtorHqecI(oM
IrOHr.rMaHr.lI{
npuqHHrrocrn
He
croJrr,Ko
noroNry,
rrro
ee aarop
M.
K.
MauapAarlrBr,rJ,rn
qnraj,I
KVpc
Mero.[o_
Jrorv:,i'
IIcrrxo.[orHu
(ua
rparcy,rrrere
rrctrxoJror-r.rr.r
Mlv),
a*orino
roroMy,
IITO
OIIA
3AAAJ'IA
TE
HOBbIC
rOPI'I3OTITb]
B
PA3BTITI,IU
IPCACTABJIEHUft
O6
NC-
ToyHrrKax
rrcilxo"rornqecroii
lpuvurrHocrlr.
8.3.3.
Meroaonoruqecxuit
noaxoa
M.
K.
Ma,r,rapaauBhnr
cucmeuno -npul4uuuan)
noAXoA,
rrperro)r(eHHrrfi
M.
K. Malrap,xarrrBrr/rr{,
o[IHpanc.s
Ha aHaJ'rrrrHqecxnii
NreroA
r{
KoHrle[uurc
fipeBpaqeuHrrx
$opu
K.
Mapxca.
llepnouava,rbHo
cxeMa
MeroAa
Bocxo*A"nr"^o,
n6crpanrHoro
K KoHKperHolry
6ura
npuMeHeHa
r4r\r
K
aHanH3y
coAepxaHr4fl
u
sopru
urrru-
,'rer{nfl
(MalrapAarununr.r,
1968).
Hecro,rlxo
[o3xe
opHeHrHpoBKa
Ha
pe-
II]EHUC
BOIIPOCOB
O
POJII,I
I]PCAMETHOI.'T
ACSTC"IbHOCTH
I4
KOHCTPYTTUTUOfi
poJrll
co3HaHU.q
rprrBeJ'ra
Qu'roco$a
K r{Aee
anrn,rr.rouxaropoB
pa3Bur{.s,
Brrr'rorHylo
cs.flsaHHoii
c rr3MeHeHr,reM
rrorrr.rMaHU.rr
IIpHrruHHocrlr.
llocxo,rr,xy
ETO
METOAO,'IOTI{qCCKI4E
PA6OTIT
H3AABA/IUCb
MAJIbIMH
TI4PAXANII{,
MbI
IIPEA-
craBrrM
HHTepecyrcuyro
Hac
npo6"reny
no oAHofi
r.r3
HHX,
o6paruaqcr
x as-
ropcKoN{y
TeKcTy.
<.
KnaccHqecruii
u
ueraaccrlqecxurl
rrAeaJ'rbr
pauuoHaJ'rbHocru>
-
cpaB
-
Hr'rreJrbrro
He60"rluran
no o6reuy
uoHorpaQua
Qu,rocoQa,
BbrrrreArua.s
s
1984
r.
(nocre
ropa3Ao
ryr{ure
sHaxoN{orl
rcr{xo"loraM
coslrecrrroil
ero
crarbrr
c B.
lI.
3nu,{eHxo
1977
r.), K
r{TeHHro
roroport
ficuxo,rror
Ao/rxeH,
Ka3aJ'IOCb
6rr,
6lrrr,
roroB
Jlyque,
rIeM
KTO-JI1160
4pyrofi,
r{MeHHO
6raroAa-
ps
BbrABnxeuuro
npo6,relru
Ha6lrc4arerIg
u reM
caMbrM
co3r{aHu.rr
qero-
BeKa
B
ueHTp
Hosorl
Raprr.rHbr
*rupa.Ll\etunozoJt4epHocmuuJttHozx?lpoTtrc-
BOCn
U C 03
H O
H U A,
l
pO6a
eua
o
rpa
H r4qe
H r.rr
Bo3
MO)K
HOCrerl
H a6,r
roaareJrlq,
Qeuoueu
<<rperbr{x
Berqeii>
rax
[peAMerHo-Aefi
creyrcunx
MexaHu3NroB
co_
3HaHu.s
(npo6,renaa
apreSarron)
-
Jrv
u
ps.A
Apyrzx
ocHoBanrlft
nepeclror_
pa
Kraccuqecror?
rapruubr
Mrrpa yxe
npHcyrcrByror
B cr.rcreMe
[cuxoJro-
rl4r{ecKoro
3Hatl'us..
Ho
sMecre
c
relt pa6ora
pe4xo
craHoBurcq
rrpeAMeroM
OCBOEHfiq
TICHXOJIOTAMU.
14
ACNO
3AECb
HC
TOJ'IbKO
B
TPYAHOCTI4
,3bIKA
UJITI
crnilg.
aBTopa.
!e,ro
n
roM,
qro
Ha3BaHHbIe
npo6,reuu
BBOArrc.q
r
Kpyr
coBceN{
HHbIX
TIOCTaHoBoK
BO[pocoB.
tr4
npo6"teua
[pHrILrHHOCTrr
3Aecb -
JIIIII]b
OAIlH
I{3
ACIIEKTOB
TIPEACTABJIEHI,I.'I
HEKIACCU'{CCrOii
KAPTIIHT,I
MHPA.
Kar rareroprrr
AerreJrbHocr,
pacmlrpuila
AJr,_
py6lrHruiefiHa
paMKr.r
Kaprurrbr
6vnus (ve.nonexa
n
uupe),
raK
Karerop
ufl
co3HaHnfl
(rranva.a,
KaK
roBoprrr
cau
MatlrapAalrBrr,'rI{,
reH}raJIbHyro
fiAeIO
Ae.{TeJ'rrHocru) nu-
AOI{3MCHHJIA
B HCKJ'IACCllqCCXOii
K
PTUHE
MI{PA
IIPEACTAB"[EHU.'I
O KOHT}I-
8.3. hr,raexeHlrs
e noHHNaaHhri
nph.ltaHHocrh
e cgqgh c
ocgoexhev...
209
HyyMe
BHerrrHero-BHyrpeHHero
n nyrsx
no3HaHu.s.
Caua
npo6reMa
B3ar{-
MooTHo[]eHI{q
BHeIIlHelo
H BHyTpeHHero'
BKJIIoqag
uAelo
IIpHr{I4HHocTI{,
6ura nocrawrer{a
B r.rHoM
par{ypce.
He npuHrlurr
<<BHerrrHee
4eiicrnyer
vepea
BHyTpeHHr.re ycJroBr{s>>
14 He r{MMaHeHTHarI
npoueccyaJrbHarl
Ipur{I4HHOCTb
ycJloxHter
cxeMbl
AerepMnHaur.tr{,
a
co3Harealnrtfi
orKa3
or
<euanvnocru
Halrrero
r\{brrrrJreHHq>
[ManaapAaurnnnu,
1984, c.
47]
-
c r.rHbrM
Bo3BparoN,r
qeJroBexa
a 6rrrue
-
pea/rr43yer
rrpuHrlt{[
cucrelrHorl
npnqr4HHocrn
no
Ma-
MapAaIxBHJuI.
flocrpoeHne
r4Horo
[pocrpaHcrtsa
MbrcJrH, orJlrtr{Horo
or
Ae-
KAPTOBA
TIPOCTPAHCTBA (C
CTO
NPOTHBOIIOCTABJIEHIIEM
<<OTI]1.,CAHH'-
II3BHC>>
I{
<<orrucaHr{fl
ueHyrpu>), paccMarpuBaerc.s
KaK Ha3peeurlrtl
aran
pa3Br4TH.tr
CO-
rpelreHHoii,rornKr,r
r,r
MeroAoJlorurr
Hayru.
KJacclrqecKarr
KaprlrHa
MHpa rrpu
3TOM r.rAeT
no
[yTIt [pocTolo
nepeHoca
Ha
qeloBerrecKylo
peaJlbHocTb
ToIO
KoHTTTHJO/Ma
MbrcJruTeJrbHux
onepaqnii
lr cnoco6on
n4eHruQurauHz
o6rer-
ToB, Koropble
[p]IHqHTII{a,'IbHo
He[plIMeH]rMbI
x
6rtrnrc
r{eJ'IoBeKa
B
crr,'Iy
H eycTpaHI,IMOCTtr
TaKOTO <<
I,I3MepeHI,It
>>
ero,
KaK
co3HaHI,Ie.
flpnsuaHne
Heo6parnlrocrr{
rrpoueccor
Ha6arcgeHyrs
yr
alaHvrfl.
B cvrJry
HeycrpaHuMocrr
sa3opa
uetrc)y
uupou KaK
maKoebuu (6ea
ua6,rro4areaa)
v
-tvtupotr
y)ffe
socnpuHambL\l
(ua6lrc4aeuuu)
c.nyxur
gla
MauapAarrrBu-
JI}I
OAHI4M
II3 OCHOBAHI'ft
NPNHqZNUAJIbHOIO
NPH3HAHI'I'
HCOTIPCAEJ'ICHHO-
crI,I
KaK
ycJtoBr4s
QyHxqr.roHupoBaHns
rreJ'roBeKa
B
MHpe.
Dror eaaop
ne-
ycrpaHrrM
Bo BpeMeHHofi
nepcnerruBe,
t{ B
pe3yJrrrare.urc6oro
Ha6.lr,r4enua
I{JII,I
3KcnepunaeHra
6yAer
ocraBarbcq
HeycrpaHIIMaJr pa3HI{Ira,
Korop;ur
<<cy-
I{ecrByer
B cuJrry
rori npocrofi
[puqr.{Hbr,
.{ro
rro6rre
$arru
HJrr{
nporBJre-
vug
AeftcrsuflMrrpa,
HaMrr
BocnpfiHlrMaeMbre,
AaHbI
HaM
BcerAa B
pe3yJrbra-
Te KaKr,rx-To
AaJree
Hepa3Jroxr,rMbrx
naalruo4eitcrsuit
c
MHpoM,
nnyrpeunefi
cropouoft
KoropbIX
flBJrterc.rl
pa3Burl{e
Hac caMlrx
B KaqecrBe
noo6qe
cno-
co6unrx
.rro
6rr ro
un 6rr,ro
Bbrpa3lrrb, yqacrByrounx,
creAoBareJrbHo,
B KaKoM-To "q361ss";
IMartrapaalrsutu,
1984, c. 70].
Ll
[eno
He roJrbro
B
ToM,
r{To
4eficrnua
Mltpa
ltpn arottr
neo6xoAl4Mo
I{HTepnperI.IpoBaHbI,
Ho
H
Mbr caMr{
yxe
He MoxeM
BepHyrbcrr
B rrpexHee
rroJroxeHr.re;
r. e.
earr
Ha-
6lrc4eHua
co3Aaer
Hepa3AeJrnMocrb
<<BHyrpeHHero
axpaHupoBa
Hfiq
ulrvr
HrrAr{Br.rAyautnr
co3HareJlbHbrMr.r
Qopnrarr,rr,r
caMr.rx
ce6s u BHerrrHero
npo-
(:TpaHcrBa
ux Ha6"rro4eHlra,>.
B cu"rly aroro
3a3opa,
B
qacrnocrr{,
rIpHr{I,IHHocrr
4orxHa
6bITb
BbIBeAeHa
la
paMrr4
npenaenuoli
ocn.
YraeanHa;r
Heo[peAeJreHHocrb
nopoxAaer,
Ta-
rr u u
o6paaou,
Hepa3AeJrHMu
ft xoHruns4lu
<.6trrug
-coaHaHr,rr
>.
lI tpuuun
-
llble
[pocTpaHcTBeHHo-BpeMeHHbIe
TepM]IHbI'
KaK L TepM[IHbI
flocTpoeHlrt
co.rHareJ'rbHbrx
cMbrcJroB
o co6urusx
u npoueccax
B
uupe,
SynrquoHt4pyror
'r'oJrbxo
B
oroM o6qeu
KoHTItHyyMe
KaK
coBMecruoft
ocHose. <.TorAa
coBep-
f lf
()lrlro
sBHo,
rrro
cau
SeHonaeH
oco3HaBaHug
uJlr4 co3HaHue
xax
eeHoueH,
lnaea
B.
flcHxonorhqecrar
fiplrHaA,'lexarquii
erouy
KorrrrrHyyMy (r.
e.
coaHarilre,
Koropoe
HaxoAurct
B AI(TYANbIIOM
COCTOq}Iil1I),
OKAXCTC'
MHOTOMEPHI,IM
H MHOTOCNOi,iHbIM>
IMauapAarusunu,
7981t,
c.
73]. B
rroHr.rMaHr4r.r
eAr.rrrcrBa
xonrnuvvlra
<.61r-
rrrs-co3HaHua>
MauapAaurBr.rJrr{
o6paqaerca
He
K [o3rrux|
py6nHrureiirra,
a
K lr03urlu.qnr
ferapra
u Mapxca
xar sa$uxcupoBaBrur.rM
ABa
ocHoBHbrx
HarrpaBJ'reHtr.q
B
rronr4Marr[tr
3aKoHa
xax
o6o6urerrHofo
rlpeAcraBJ'reHl'rt
o
AerepMnHarlt{u
-
po/ru
rroHrruii
o
apelrerrH
rr
rrcrvne.
!exapr
I1ocraBr{Jr
oqerrL'
BaxHyrc
npo6,relry
npeueuHoii
AucKperHocrr.l
6Hrufl
rIeJIoBeKa:
<<...To,
qro
lt ecrb
ceii{ac,
He
tsbrreKaer
H3 Toro,
qro.s
6bI"rI
HecKo"rrbxo
ruLHoneHl.rri
Ha3aA, rI
TO,
r{To
g
6yly
qepe3
Hecxor,Ibl{o
MtHoBe_
uuri nnepe4u,
HMe"q
B
roJ'IoBe
I4.rIU
B
pylrax
MbIcJIb,
*
He BbITeI{aer
1.13
.r'OfO,
rrro
.{
ecrb
ceiiqac
17
llBuHyJrctr
ts
}ralpaBnet]f'ru
aroii
MbrcJrH>
[Mauapaa-
ITIRH,'II{,
1984,c.64).
IlpuuuuyrretbsanocmaaumbsospetreHutrcmorbKosne-
ped,
ruo u
uasa)
-
nepeA
coBepmarctrtrnrcq
co6rrru"nn
l6orrrrr
u"nn
urrcrn).
KoHruHyynr
ar(Tr{BHocrl4
rrpeArronaraer,
.{To6br
Eor
uettpeptrtsHo,
cHoBa
L{
cHoBa
rropoxrla-n
cBorr
rBopeHrrJ{.
Ho ec,rn
60r
lopox4aer
qro-To
B coor-
BercrBt{l1
c
xaxoii-ro
ncrulHoft,3Har{IIT,
ecrb
rrro-To
IlpeBblllle
ero,
a STOIO
Aorrycrlrrr,
Herb3.q.
roarouy,
cqr{raer
{erapr,
uc'ruwoii
cJreAyer
cqilrarb
UMEHHO
TO,
I{TO
6OT
CACIA,T,
IITO
YCTAHOBIIJ'IOCb
}I KAK
COCTO'IHUE
T,IIIPA,
H KAK
MbICJ'rb,
Quxcnpyroruarl
3To
cocrotHr{e
ts Ha[reM
r\{blrrr.[eHuu.
Eor xe
fJ sroM
Kapre3uaHcKoM
tloHHMaHr{t{
IIe
rBopHT,
a tsocnpoI'I3BOAHT
u coxpaH.aer.
Hanougul,t
rapr(e,
rrro
AJ'r.s
pear'ru3au[u
aKTr.rBHocrH
rela (no
flexapry)
UCT HCO6XO4I{MOCTI{
HE
TOJIbKO
B TIPCAIIOCT,IJ'IKC
6OTA,
HO IT B
NPEAIIOCbIJ'IKC
o6paaa.
Te,ro
4eiicrnyer
KaK aBroMar,
a
aBroMar
He HyxAaerca
n o6paae
OKPY)KEHU.q.
IIPCPUNUCTOCTb
IIPHIII,IHI{OCTII
-
KAK
I{ BCC
B KAPTCsI,IAHCTBE
-
ABO{Karr.
Marepna,rrubre
rrpur{HHr,r
6urniicrnylor
B Mrrpe
tea. Eoxecraerr-
HbIe
npuquHbr -
B
Mr4pe
coxpaHerrr4rl
KoHTr.rHyyMa
6lDtrug,t{
MbIcJiIr{.
tr4 e eroN{
coAepxr'lTcs
AoraAKa
o6 0cHosHoii
npo6"reue,
Koropyrc
o60u]-4a
cropoHorl
HAYXA
HONOIO
BPCMCHI
C
PACCMOTPEHHbIM
PAHCC
IIOHI,IMAHI,IEM
KAY3AJIbHO-
cru.
3ro
AofaAKa
o roM,
rrro
BBeAeHr.Ie
npelreuuoii
oclr
B
ue[b
[pHrrHHHbrx
co6urlri.i
AeJraer
Hepa3perxuMoii
aara4xy
6Hruq
Mr.rpa
u
cno6o4ri
Aeitcrsus
qeJ'roBeKa
B
HeM.
lax
MauapAaIIIBI{JItr
BaXeH
<<OHTOJ'rOrt{qecKuIl
cMuc,r>,
UJII,I IITOI
sTOTO
TIPH3HAHI,I{:
HI,TqTO
HC
IPEAYCTAHOB.IIEHO
B BIIAC
3AKOHA,
3A-
KOHbI
JII4IIIT'
IIOTOM
YCTAHAB"II}IBANTCS.
HO
CAMO
ABIIXEHI,IE
MITPA
H
qEJIOBE-
Ka
-
sro
nyrb
coaAaHlr.fl
HoBofo,
uonoo6paaonauul)i.
Hn
nopx4ox
B Mrrpe
nerqefi,
Hr{
rrop{Ao* (noc,re4onare^uocrr)
lruc,refi
He
Moryr 6rrrt
norrsrlr
B
paMrax
r.rAer{
[peAycraHoBJ,reHHoii
rapuoulru.
Hn
AO6PY
VI
HV II,CTYftIC
<<HE
HA
qCM
AEPXATbC.{
B ECTECTBCIIHOM
XOAE
NPI4POAHT,IX
gn,reultii>
(ulr
crasa,ru
6r,r,
r ectecrBeHHo
rroH.sroii
npuvunuocrn
co6rr-
ruli). Ho
qenoBeK
KpoMe
ecrecrBerrHoro
coBepuaer
u BTopoe pox{AeHr.re
*
8.3. Z:veHeHNr
s noHzl4auhtl
nprl.izl,tHocrta
a caR:z c ocaoeHheNa.,.
211
ucKyccrBeHHoe,
Ky-qbrypHoe.
Os
cranoBurc.s
qer'roBeKoM
B t\{Hpe <<Tperbr{x
neqeri>,
r.r,rrr apreQaxros.
tr4 3Aecb npilquHHocrb
y)Ke
rrHoro
xapanrepa
-
npuqlIIIHocTb,
cB.q3LrBaeN,Ia"q
c HeKIaccl,IqecKLIN{
IIOHI{NIaHI,IeIt paq}IOHa,rlb-
Hocrll.
3ro npnvuuHocrb
lra
ypoBHe
AerepMtrHaurrr{
i{rr43rrr{
u rctlxlrKtr
(ve,ronexa
KaK cyxlecrBa
rrcKyccrBeHHoro)
<<trpeBpaqeHulruu
Qopuar,rrr>.
<.flpespaueHHocrb>>
(a
He
ucrnuuocrb
lr.lrr,rroxuocrr,)
Qoprtr,
Ha Koropbre
opreHTLIpyercq
qeJ'roBex
s
csoeri
Ae_flTeJ'IbHocrlr,
B Koropbrx
rpeHoueuanlno
[peAcraBJIeHo
Aeiicrntre
HeI{3BecrnbIX eMy
3aKoHoB,
qBJ'I.sercq
<<HarraJ'IoM)>
I{
<<I{CTOTIHI{KO\.{>>
BOCIIpOI{3BOACTBa,rrc6OrO
XIIBOIO
Ael"ICTBil.q
u ulrc,tu.
Ta-
KOe Har{a-{o
-
KaK
I{CTOTTHI4K BOCIpOI3BOACTBa
-
Ue lroxer
6bITb
[oiro]Ke]Io
Ha Bpe\.{eHHyro
ocb, oHo
yxoAHT
B noHTtrHyyNr
<.6rrruq-co3rraHr.rr>
KaK KoH-
THHyyM )KlrBbrx
Qopu,
Bo3HuKalo[Ilrx, pa3BuBarorlr.rxcl
rr
yMHparoutrx.
fl
,rx
IVlapxca,
Kar{ loxa3brBaer
MauapAaueruiu,
<<paAr,rKaJ'rbHo
HeKJ'rac
-
cu.{ecxuii
xoA T,IbIIIIJIeIIttt,
ilcKJ'IIoqt{eurI4I"I
KJ'IaccuqecKylo
[po3parrHocrb
co3HaHrrs
r,rnrr
lreroropylo
BrreuHroro crrcreMy
orc{era,
c xoropoii
nrc6as
cr.IcreMa l{orJra
6url
aoclpotr3BeAerra
vxe
B
parlrroHaJTbHo
r{oHTpoJ'rrrpye-
MOM BI'IAe,
IIpeA[oJ'IafaeT
cytlecTBoBaHI{e pa3IIbIX
OqafoB
caMoAegTeJ'IbHo-
crl,r B crlcreMax, pa3Hbrx
noKycoB noci
calronegreJrbHocrtr>>
[Mauap4aunlr-
tru, 1984,
c.
63].
9e,roneK
aKoHolruqecxuri,
o
noropoM
rrrrcaJr
Mapxc, ixuBer
ccrecrBeHHo-rrcropr4rrecKuu
o6paaolr,
rre orpaxafl
B rrHAr,rBr{AyaJ'rbHo
B3.s-
roli ro,roee
BCex 3BeIlbeB
cncreMbl.
Cncrelra
)Ke IIeMbIcJ'IuN,Ia
BHe
ero
Aeg-
TeJIbHocrI{,
oHa
BK,rlrcqaer
ero aKTtIBHocrl.
Axrlt
[oHI,IMaHII{
v npv{qrLrtr
peueHH.q
TaKHM CO3HaTe-rtbHIrIM
afeHTOIl 03ItaqaIOT
neatrtto4eltcTBI,I.fl
ts
paM-
r<ax cavofi
crrcreMbr,
rre npeAcTaroqeri
loarol{v
BHeIITHeN{y
nropy
(r<ax
cyulecrByrorqeMy
B KarrecrBe
npo3parruor,l
rovxn, He
r,r3N,reHslouleit
cllcre-
uy),
4axe
ecJ,ru
oH npr{HaA,'re)Kr{r
cBepxN{or{}toMy yMy.
tr4rar,
Bo3HuKae
l
yqa-
cToI(
Heo[pe{€;lleHlIocTlI,
He npocN{aTprteaeintl,il?
A,'tq
c03IIaTeJIbHOfO
IIOHI{-
MaHug,.
Ho ero
He Merrraer
r{eroBeKv
4ericrnonarr
B TaKoM
uupe. HyxHo
'fo,'rbKo
u3MeHr,rrb
[oHr{MaHI4e
roro, KaK ou
4eftcrnyer
B aro]\{
Hefipo3par{-
rrol\{ MHpe,
B KoropoN{
4eficrnyrcr
rax}r(e
o6que
(coquanlulre,
aKoHoMrrqe-
r'rcr.re)
saxoHtr.
B
palrxax
K,{accuqecKr.r
roHqroro paulroHar'rbHoro
1eiicrnnx
l,To
HeBo3MoxHo (ror4a
HaAo 6lr,ro 5nt
cAe,rarn KoHcrarrraMr,r
r{orr{Bbr,
}Ke-
.'r:rH14s.
flHTepecbr
t{ T.
n.).
Ectecrnesuo-Hay{Hoe
rroHuMa}rrre Kay3anlHocru (ryHxrlr.roHnpyer
B K,Tac-
r'tr.recxoii
KaprrrHe
Mr{pa
-
TaM, rAe rrpeArroJ'rararorc.s
pa3AeneHHbre
cy6t,exr
rr o6rercr
rro3nar{r{q,
r4e
cy6rexr r{o}Ker
rrepeN{erlarr,ca
n;rrc5yrc
ToqKy
na-
6ltro4enna,
flBJlflr,cb
B To
xe BpeM.q
<<npo3paqHbll,I>>,
T. e.
He u3MerlsrcuruNl
('rrcrerlry
cs.q:e11.
tr4e rrpuaHaHns
BKJrrHlIeHrrocru
cy6lexra
KaK
xrlBor.o areH-
r':r co6uruq
cneAyer
HeBo3MolxHocrb
nr'raccHqecr{oii
uporle4yplr paqr{orranb-
f t()fo aHa-rII,I3a;
rr3
fLIIIOTe3br O
MHO|OMepHOCTU
CO3HaHng.
-
pa3pyueHlle
[po-
&
212
lzraea B. f-lchxonorh.]ecKas
nphqhHHocrs
Ir3BoJ'rbHoro
AeraJrbHoro
[oApa3AeJ'reHlr.s
i]puqrHHoii
crpyxryptr
xax
$yu-
AaMeHTaJiIbHOtO
AOIyUeHLI.S
Kr'IaCCUqeCKOTO
MbIIIJIeHIIq.
flpeAnorroNeHr.re
o
cyuecrBoBaHr,rrr
aAeKBarHlrx
4etlctnnri,
pery,rnpye-
Mbrx He
Ha
ypoBne
pe(brercuu,
a Ha
ypoBFre
r,rx BrJrrrorreHHocrt{
B
peanb-
Hocrr 6ttrtr.q
qeroBexa,
I{3MeHger
rIoHuMaH
I Ie
paqrroHanbH
oc-r
u. K"lac cu
-
qecKoe
nowLuaHue pa4uoHarbHocmu
coorvocur
ueJrLr
r{ cpeAcrBa.
3aroHu
courraJrbHbre
gertcrnynr
Ha
ypoBHe
no,rHoii paunoHaJ'rr,Hocrn.
llpu arou
iloJ'IafaeTc.q
KaKat-To
IIpeAycTaHoBJ'teHHa.g
IapMoHI{g
MexAy 3aKoHoM
II eIO
npo.qBJ'IeHr.reM
B aMrrltpttqecroii
ro.rxe
[pocrpaHcrBa
r,r BpeMeHtt.
Cso6oa-
Ho
4eilcrnyrcruue
lrHArrBrrAbr peaJ'rr.rayror
BMecre c re[,r
paquoua,ttHnrri:a-
xoH. <.Ho
aro craHoBl,Irc"a
npo6,reuoii,
ec,ru MbI
Ha IIoJ'IHoM
cepbe3e Bo3bMer{
Qarr
cyuecrBoBaHr,r.rl,
Bo-rrepBbrx,
cno6oAlt
I{, Bo-BTopbrx,
HeonpeAe.rreH-
Hocrrr>
[
Manrap4aur
nunu,
1984, c.
57
f
.
,{onyrqeuueM,
cor;racHo
Malrap4aunLrJ'ru,
AonxHo
6r,rrr
He npeAno-
J'ro)r(eHllre
o
paquoHanbHoM
3aKoHe r{
[peAycTaHon,reHHoii
rapMoHtrH,
a npeAnonolxeHlre
o roM,
rrro
p.rrA
rreJ'roBeqecrtrx
4eiicrer.rii
uoryr
BbIrJ'rg-
4erl
us6r,tror{HbIMH.
Hacra;mHlte pucyHI{Ir,
cl,tN.IBo.[I,IqecKI,Ie
npeAMerbl
*
He
yrnJ'rr.rrapHbr,
Ho
Qaxrnvecxu
AerepMr{Hr.rpyror
craHoBJreHr4e
geJrloBeKa.
Zx
po,rl
-
I{oHcrpyupoBaHr{e,
T. e.
KoHcrpyKTuBHa.q.
Onlr orpe4e,rxlor
BTOpOe
pOXAeHUe
r{e,ToBeKa
-
Kar(
cyuecTBa
r{yJ'rbTypHoro,
<<r.lcKyccTBeH-
Horo>>.
Ho osuaqaer ,Tu,
rrro
raKoe BBeAeHI{e
Kareropl.rit
coauaHl.rg,
rr He-
onpeAeJ'reHHocru
Ae"rraer
HeB03MoxHbrM
HayqHoe
rro3HaHI;te
noo6rqe?
Her,
no
MaltapAattlBIIr'IlI
aro 03Har{aer
KpHTHqHocrb
B rIoHt{MaHLtu,
araK}Ke
cy-
ulecrBeHHoe
rr3MeHeHI{e
caMoro
[pllHr_lHla
npuqr.rHHocru.
3ro coBeprxeH-
Ho neo6xoAnMo
An.q
a*aJrLr3a
npoxn,reuuii
qeJ'roBeqecKoro
co3HaHr{r rr
Ae-
.qTeIbHocTu
v
Ang,
an'a.r.lll3a
MHpa,
A"It
qelo
HeAocTaTortHo
lrpocTo e4r.trofi
npnvr.ruuofi
{enu
co6uruii.
BepHyrl
qeJ'toBeKa
c aKTrIBHocrr,ro
ero
Ae.srenbHocr
rt
14
coslaHr4r
B Mr{p
[peAraraJr
raxNe
C. JI. Py6rzuurreiiH.
Ho oH
ocraBuJr
s csoeri
Kaprr{He Mr.rpa
KraccuqecKylo
rpaKToBKy
rpHr{HHHocrr{
(c
TaKI{Mr4 HoBoBBeAeHu.gMH,
KaK
B Jtwfl.Hl.{e
C ne
AcT
BvIfl Ha
np Hr{I4Hy, ee
[poueccyaJ't
bHocTb,
Bo3MoI(HocTb
aHarrr43a-cvrrre3a
B
rlr'reHeHr{r4
e4llruofr,
qenu
co6rrrufi
Ha
npnvuHbr
I,I
c,TeA-
crBLrs., a
rarxe [pr.rHul4[
eAHHcrBa
co3HaHI{.q
r{
Ae.rlTenbHocrn).
Mavap-
p.aurBLtJrrr
npeAJloxun
Bo3Bparr.rrbca
r Mapxcy,
rr
An.rI
3Toro
B3grb
B Kar{e-
crBe ocHoBHoii
ero
v!.ero cucme.Muoil
npuuuuuocmu (cyuecrnyrcqeii
eHe
cBtr3r4
c npelreuudrnt,
r. e.
Quauxa.rrr{crcruM
ee rroHr{MaHr.reu).
OH
TaKme
crruralr ueo6xo4IzrrrtM
AoMblc/Irrrl
cnoco6lt 6bttuqr{eroBeKa
B
ecrecrBeH-
Ho-r{cropurrecKor{
flpocrpaHcrBe
3aKoHoB
Qlrar.rvecrnx
r{ coqrrar'rbHbrx
I,r
BBeJI
IJrfl
sTOfO rloH.sTrle
HOBOIO
r{CTOqHr.{Ka
AeTepMlrHaquLI
-
<<TpeTbHMr.r
BerIaMH>>,
Koropble.sBr'Iglorc.s
H He
uAear'rbHblMl,r
(paccyAoqHbIMLI
cyIIHo-
8.3. ZrveHeHhn
g
noHh,\4aFtNh
nph.ltiFtHocrN
e caqah
c oceoeHheNa...
213
crxltu),
r.r He
@llsuvecrr,IMl{
Te,TraMrI,
a
qe\,{-To
rperbnM,
vro
Qoxycnpyer
BeIqecrBeHHocrb
H,rII{
ilpeAMerHocrn
4eficrelrx,
Ho
He KoHTpoJ'II{pyerc.q
co-
3HAHI{EM.
Knaccuuecrcuil
npuu4un,
or Koroporo
orraJ'rKr.rBaJrrc.s
M.
K. MalrapAa-
IIIBIIJII{,
6Ul raron: pa{I{oHanbHo
[oHuMaeMO
TO,
{TO OXBaTIeHO
qeJ'toBe-
rIecKuM
geiicrnnelr
or
rrar{aJ'ra
Ao
KoHrIa.
3ro
npnHrlnl
[oHuMaH]t.q
neuefi
qepe3
noHllNlaHrre
cAenaH
uoro. Henraccuqecxu
il n pu
H4u n,
npnxo4auluii
enry
Ha cMeHy: <<rroHr{MaHr.re
cAe"rraHHbrM>
.
y
JT.
C. Burotcxoro
3Tor
npuHllul
rrperBopeH
B orrocpeAcrnynuler?
poJrrr
crr4My,lroB
-cpeAcrB.
M alrapAarueu-
,ru oco6oe
Mecro B aroii
cQepe <<IIoHnMaHH.g
cAe,{aHHbIM>>
orBoAI{T
3HaKy.
A. B. Epylr"ru.rHcxnfi yxa3brBan
Ha r{HreJr,'reKrya,'rr.r3M
rcoHuenqnu
Blr-
rorcKoro,
r,'rexyrqr.rii
aa
co6oii
r{Aea,'rH3M
B rrorr}rMaHr{u pa3Burr{.rl
co3Ha-
Huq
rrer'roBeKa
Ha ocHoBe
KoHcrpyKTtrnHofi
po,ru
aHaxa
[6pyrunuwcrcurt,
1968]. Ha
Haru B3ur.qA,
rroHrrMaHrre poJ'rr{
3HaKoB
KaK
ABuxeHu.s
rrpeBpa-
rrleHHbrx
rpopu
aeuo cHfiMaer
o6sI,Irrerrlle
B r{Aean[3Me.
tr4 ue
to,rlro
rloro-
My,
rrro
oHo
BocxoAr{r
x Maprcy,
a rroroNry,
qro
arn
<<Tperbr,r
Betrlr{>>
He
sBJtflroTctr
r,rAeaJrbHbrMlr,
a
yKa3bIBaroT
[pur{r.rHHyro
AeTepMxHaqnro
cTaHoB_
IleHng
ITHAUBl{AyanbHofo
c03HaHI{t
nocpeACTBOM
ocBoeHI,I.fl
3aJ'Io){{eHHbIX
B HHX
<.npeBparueHHbtx
Qoprtlo.
MoxHo
ortllertITb,
qro,
B orJ'Il{que or
BltrotcKoro,4,rx
MauapAaIrIBI,Iru
6o,ree
saNHbIN{
.sBJ'rqerc.s
He
rIpL{HrIun opyAuliHoro
o[ocpeAcrBoBaHr.r.{
(aHar
xax ncrlxor'roruqecKoe
opyAr{e),
a
npe4craBJreHne
apmeQarcmoo
rcarc
<<opzetlos>>
deilcmeua.llounuaHtre
ocyu{ecrBn.qer
He opraH,
a
qe,'IoBeK
rlo-
cpeAcrBoM
opraHa.
14
wves aror
opraH,
rIe,'roBeK
He o6qaaH
3Harb
ero
ycrpoitcrno.
OpraHrr xar
apreQarrbr
<<rrperBop{ror>>
s ce6e <<ABr.rxeHr{e
IIOHr.rMaHr4.rI,
KoTopoe
Tenepb
rr3 Hux caMHX
rrcxoAr.rT
r.r
pacflpocTpaHreT-
cgr>.
OH TIpHBoAI{T
rIpI{Mep
rofo, KaK
CeeaHu <.ntlrc,rnt
q6JIoKaMn>>,
AeMoH-
cTplrpy.{,
KaK Mbr Mo}r{eM
r{To-To
y3HaBaTb
o
MI,Ipe, He 3Hag
nprr
SToM
Tex
cocrogHr.Iii
co6crseuuoto
yMa,
Koropbre
HaM aro 3HaHrre
Aarcr.
lloHnlra-
ilue cAeJ'IaHIIbIM
IIpIIBOALIT
I{ )ItI{3HH <<IIOHIt\.{aTeJ'IbHbIe
BeIUI{>>,
nOCpe.4CTBOM
r(oropbrx
rle,'roBex
H BXoAr4T
B Kar{ecrBe
co6gtus,
B Mr{p.
Tar<uu
o6paaolu,
t(ax
H B rloAxoAe
Py6ngurreilHa,
rreJIoBeK
rrpoAojrxaer
3aKoHbI
Mr{pa.
lIo arltu
cBor{N{
6lrrueu
oH ri orrpeAeJr.{er
rIo.rIBJ'reHrIe
roro 3a3opa,
Koro-
pr'tfi
HapyuraeT
KJraccuqecKylo
KapTrrHy
oTpaxaeMoro
Mr{pa
c ero <<Ilpo3pas-
I t r,IM>
BHe[IHuru
ga6,rrcAareJleM.
CoaHaHlre
-
B eAr.rr{oM
KoHTuH}T/Me
6btrus.-coe*altl
-
oKa3brBaerc.rr
cy-
I r
locrBeHHo
rrHbrM,
r{eM
B
paccMorpeHuoit
Bbrue KoHue
ntryn
P
y
6uurureliHa.
O 6parqeH
lre x npo6,relre
uHm
eHt4u olt cubH
o cmu
c o sHatrua, pa3n
r,IgeH
r.re
lilrTeHUr{OHaJITHOTO
o6nexra (<.yMseMoro
B Br{Ay>>
nHreHrlr.reii,
KoTopajl
caMa
cc(rs
rre cosuaer)
n
pe$"uercurHoro
co3HaHux
(enauust
cocro.rrHr.r.s yrraa)
no-
214
f,laea
B.
flcxxonornqecKae
nphLthHHocrb
3BOJ't-ger
ocBauRarb
<<Mllp
tso3tloiKHocreii
rJe.toBerlecKofo
c03Hallllt>>
rIO IIprIII-
LIlIny IlpoenrlrtsHoii
MOAeJ'IU.
TO,
VrO
B IIO3HaBae]{on{
oST,eKTe
rre/xocryrlHo
KOTIII,ITIIBHbIM
CTPYITTYPAM,
3AI]OJ'II{'CTCq
d)CHONTCHANbHO,
TIPHBHECEH'IC},{
TCX
ur'tl{ TIHbIX
N{oAVcoB
rrJ'ur HHTeprrperauuri.
Vc;ronnqnlu
[oHHNraHnq
Bbrcry-
rraror
rrprl
sToNr
He rorrrbKo
<|uar.rvecrcr.re.
<.llpeAlreruo-BeulecrBeHHan
pa-
6ora uaureri
co6crBelrrroii
Ae.qre.rrbrrocrr{>>
tsr,icryrraer
Hocr.rreJrer,r
rex 3a-
eucnrtocreii'
KoTopble
NIbI pea/III3yeI,I
IIO oTHollleHlIX]
K HaIIut\{
IIocl'ylIKaNf
,
\,IOTI,IBAIII{'M
I,{
T.
I.
TAKUN{
O6PA3ON{,;]€flT€JIbIIO
I{3MEH-flETCq
HE TOJII,KO
N,lUP
BHeIxr{IIfi,
Ito H
Mr,rp
cy6beKTa.
Haesarl
3To lr3trerreHr{f\|ll
TOr-rbr(o
tstryr-
peHHrrx
yc,loBr.ri;i
B KoHrleI]utrn
Mar,rapAarrrBrr,rtr{
}{e"rrb3{,
rrocKonbKy
Aeii-
crBeHHbrNr (lt
eoe4eiicrByrcrlluNl
B Cr'rcTe\.re)
oKa3brBaerc.q
cax{
sTarr
oro-
6paNeu
u.r
cy6beKrou yc.'roBr
rii.
34ecl oueul
Bo,Klro o6pauleHne
K pa3nrIqurc
cour{arrbHbrx
cr{cre\.r
u roro,
KaK oHr,r
oro6paxarcrcl
cy6t,erraMu,
rraAereHHbrMrr
co3Haunelr.
MHoro-
o6paaue
oro6paNeHHii,
n Cnorc
oqepeAb,
Bbrcryflaer
3J,re]reHTaMu
c]rcreN.rbr,
Koropble
npeo6pa:yxtrc.rl,
Br,I3bIBa.s
K ?Ku3HLI
To,
r{To
Mapxc
Ha3bIBaJ,I <<Irpe-
BparrIeHHbrMu
rloprraun'>.
<.Pa4ou
npeo6pa:onaHuirrlirl4lpenpauleHurl
oHr.r
3aKoAl{poBaHbr
B
uHAr,rBHAax
raK,
qro
oHlr,
aru
rpeo6pa3oBaHtrr,
fipeBpa_
IIIEHI,I.'I,
OIIYIUCHbI,
I{ IIHAI{BI,IAbI
B CBOIIX
4CT1CTNNXX
NCXOA.qT
H3
qCI'O-TO,
KaK coBepIUeHHo
HerlocpeAcrBeHHo
AaHHoro'
orreBrAHoro
I{
AocroBepHo-
ro>
[ManrapAa[rBr{J'ru,
1984,
c. 49).
B Bocuprsrurx
H
4eiicrnu
s,x IH/\LIBII-
Aa
peanr{3yrcTc.q
cocTaB"rr.srcxIUe
cncTeN,lbr.
Mrtc,r-q
a6crpaxrlnxuv,
JrrcA:r- pea-qu3yror
Aeiicrnu.q
nru csoricrsa
ueJro-
crnori
ctrcreMbl,
B
Koropyrc
oHtr tsK,rrroqelrbr.
fieuoHcrpupyerc.a
3To,
B
r{acr-
HocrII,
cJreAylour.rNl
[pr.rMepoM.
Tax, r,tu
I\,{brc"[uN.r
a6crpaxqueii
Ktrraccots,
Ho
n
Qeo4alnHou
o6rqecree
BoeBanrr
He K,iraccbr,
a ilrcAl.
Ouu x
roMy )Ke
He
orHocrrJ'rr,r
ce6.s x
reM KJ'IaCCaM,
noropbrN{H
Mbr r,tx
MapKrrpyeM.
lloCrasnrr
ce6s.
na
Mecro areHra (Aeiicrnyrcqero
cy6rexra)
n
Seo4a,rrnou
o6ulecrne
qe,'IoBeK
XX e. He MolKer.
Kpoue
roro,
Halrre
N{blrrrJ'reHr4e
o6rexrr.rrr.rpyer
B
HeM KJIaccbI,
T.
e. ol{ToJlorx3xpyer
no3HaBareJ'rbHble
crpyKTypbr.
Taxuu
o6-
pa3oM,
B rro3HaHurr
cyltuocrn
$eo4anlHoro
o6r{ecrea
Heo6xonuN{o
npor.reoii_
.4er
peAyKulr.q.
creAosare,'rbHo,
Heo6xo4r.riuro
rrplrocraHoBrrrb
Harrre uo6rer-
Tr.lBupyrcuee
MbilIr'IeHrre>,
nopoxAalouee
[pr.r3paxn
(<.Kn2gcoB>>
r,r
4p.;,
n o6parurrcx
x
@euoueuoJ'IoruqecxoNly
ypoBlrro.
Ho
.{ro
rro3Bo,r.ger
roBo-
pt{Tb
o
$eHoueHarrluoii
Aauuocur
rex
rrJrrr{
Hulrx.as,TeHrrii?
,{pyruurr
cJIoBaN{Ir,
KaK
Mo)KHo o6ofirucl
B
HayqHoM
rro3HaHrru
6es
nhe-
ar'IbHbrX
a6crpaxrHlrx
o6bercroe?
Kax nepnyrbc.q
K aHa,rH3y
aN{nr4prqe-
cKoro
ottbrra
n He rroAl.{eHr{Tb
peQ,rexcueii
rro3Harorlero
<.-fl>
To,
rlro
oHO
Qurcnpyer?
Be4r
ulr
(no
Mauapaaurnuln)
yxe
[ycrr.rnu
<,fl>>
ts Mr{p,
a 3Harlrrr,
He
MoxeM oAHoBpeMeHHo
suncnpoBarb
tr
efo
ABu)r(eHrre
(peo-
'qeKcusur,ri'i
arcr),
n coAeplKalrr.re
rraruero yrBep)KrxeHua.
Buxo4
HaMeqerl
B TON.r
npocrparrcrtse (a
o6paulcHHr4
x 5trrni'iuocrlr)
ve,roneKa
B
Mrrpe,
o
r(o-
1'opoNl
cBr{AereJrbcrByror
aAeKBarulre
4eiicrarr,1,
ocyluecrBJ'HeNrbre
5e:
ga_
ltu.sug
co3Hare"qbHol"r
rreJrr,r (l
coeuarelrrHoro
KoHTpo-rtx)
or
HaqaJra
Ao
ronua
neiic'rnrrg.
B arorl
csr{eu paccMarpHtsaerc.fl
KoHuenutrq
veHaAee.
Tax,
B
ycraHoBKe
tIl)o.gBnqerc'I
I]oHtrNfaHr.re
6ee
ocosuaHll.s,
rcuxor'IoruqecKll
rrrrr(aK
He naTet'opr{3trpyeNroe.
Ha6"lrcAenrre
$euolreHoB
rr rrporrecrcots
co3HaHr.rr{,
Koropble
ue
o6.ng,c-
tttturr
6es
AotryureHurr
ux 6lrruriuoro
yl)otsHr,
-
oro
llyrr,
Iro3HaHHrr,
Koro-
PbtN{,
r{po}re
veHaAse,
Irr,rrrl
HeN{e{Kax
(rrltocor}r{9
Tofo
Bper,leHr,r
u
qacrr.rq-
lro
B
pyccrori
rfr,r,roco$nrr
B,r.
Co,roBr,es1.
B. 3.4.
Kpwr
epuir
HeKAaccHq
ecKoi
KaprHH
bt
Mh pa
no
Manapaaui,B|'/,\t4
llepexo4
K Hevnaccuqecrcou
xapmuup
-rtupo
-
aro
orra3
or
I,IAeu
BerrHblx
1{ HeIIOntsTIX}Ibrx
IlcrLIH,
tto,toxeuuoii
r octtony
floH.qrnr{
3aKoHa
(vro
n rcave-
crne rrpo6,relrbr
yBr{AeJ'r
yxe
nexapr).
Maprcc
r3NreHr4J'r
rlryurcrlHro
4errre,,rbrro-
crII,
B KOTOpOii
n
ycraHaB,'IuBaIOTCg
CBfl.J1,
Ha3bIBaeMbIe
rloroM
3aKOHaMH.
ArtneHocrl
B
Kapre3rrarrcnoii
cxenre
-
3lo
Bocrpor{3BollcrBo
r{
coxpaHerrue.
Atctusuoclr,
corJraclro
MapKcucrcr{ori
rcoprrrr
qeJroBexa,
-
aro
Boc[por{3Bon-
c]'Bo
KoHcrpyr(rr{B}rbrx
uonoo6pa^sonaurrrl -
<Tperr,r{x
eeu1erl,,
(no
orHoure-
ttulo
r nfl.rpy
tfx.r3llrrecKoMy
rr
Mtrpy
xAea,'rlHorcl),
qBn.qlouluxc.s
KyJrr,TypHbrMr{
t'opr{3oHTaN{I{.
Ilpocrltu
[pr.rMepoM
3AeCb
flR]'l.qercs
[crroJlb3oBaHrre
KOJreca.
I Ic eaxoltrr
rluaHxtr
orIpeAer.qIor
cro
lrcroJlbllolranre
r{eJ'IoBeKoM,
a er.o
KoHcr-
l)yt{TrrBHoe
Mb[r]"rreHr,re,
BrcrrroqeHHoe
a peanr,rrue
6lrrniiHlre
cs.ssu.
3ru <.rpe-
'ft
r.{
Ber{rr>
MauapAaruerrJ'rr1
Ha3bIBaer
<<noH'l'rilryzullrro4er.icrnyrcur{MX
npeA-
McTIIo-tseUecTBeHHbIN{tt
MeXa}III3MaMl,l
co3ttiltltt,I>,
ctst3blBa'
HMeHHo
c H}jMII
t,o3MolKHocrb
IroJ'rHoro
norruMarrllq.
cxorrcrpyr4toBaB
sTrr
rlpeAMerbr,
N{br BI{-
/lllM
rr
IIor[{MaeM.\4xp
c rlx
IIOMOIIIbTO.
AttrtrnHoctr
B NleroAor'Iort{qecKLIX
IIoAXoAax,
peanI,I3oBaHHbIX
B
Teop[-
tlx
Ae.tITeJ'IbHocrH'
-
3To
Ae.tITeJ'IbHoe
cBt3ytoqee
3BeHo,
Bo3Bpalqarcqee
rtcJtoBeKa
B cucreN,ty
cn.geeii
c N{r,rpoM,
BKrroqa}orur.rM
B ToM
qltcJ're
r{
poJrb
('r'o
co3rraHua.
I-{e,rocrultii
ronrnHyyu
6ltt'us-co3HaHr.rq
npucyrcrByer
rr 06eHx
paccMorpeHHbrx
cxeMax
rlrr,rocoftcroro
aHaJrr{3a.
V
Mauapztaur-
lillJrrI
rryrb
Bo3Bpara
qeJIoBeKa
B
MUp
6trcvx
Huoii
-
3TO
rryrb
Bo3Bpara
I t[eJrocrHyrc
clrcreNry,
r'4e
4eiicrnyer
rrpr4HuHrr
cr,rcreN{Horo
AerepN,{r{Hu3-
I
<'B
cogpeuctttloli
ltctlxoaonrn
raKue
xe
eerlrr
ltafi,,tKl/{anrcr{
l{
B TaK
Ila3bltsaeMblx
'rl((
ll)cN'Ia'rlblIbIXcrll)/alItt.sx,t{ou(aroqrroeAciicrsrreconeputacrcg6caxaxoii-Ilt5operf-
.rtr't(('rilj,
xax 6bt
u ilo/lBcntelllloi\I
cocroltttut
cy6bcKTz,
BbIIllrOlo
noo6ule
t{3
npocrpatl-
{'r'rrt
il
r}l)cMcrllr,
rfle tspcN{r
ocr2}r0Br.r.rrocrr>
[Mavap4:urrerl',rr{,
1994,
c.
55].
i
l
I
,l
8.3.
14:,neHesy,A
B
noHhMaHVV
qhHHocTh
B CB93t4
C
OCBOeHheM,..
216
f,raaa
B. flclrxonorrqecKar
nohr{ilHHocrb
Ma. Ho o6o6lIeHue
DToro
rprrHrllrrla [peAnoJ'raraer
He ro,rrbro cr.Icrer,{rro-
npuqilHHbre
cB.q3H,
rro u Het(naccrrqecl(oe (pacurHpeunoe)
rrorrHlraHlte pa-
ulrolra,'rbHocTH.
MHoroN{epHocTb
co3HaHrl.r{
fiopo)r(AaeT
B sToii cHcTeNfe
Ta-
xue srpQerrbr
B3anMoAeiicrnuq <t\tHoropa3J'rr{qHblx
c,'roeB>>,
qro
oHH He
Moryr 6lttl
noaoxeHbl
B eArrHyro
ueloqKy
npnvnHHofi
cBq3H
B
peaJrbHoM
BpeMeHrr u
[pocrpaHcrBe.
3Tn
scpcpercmot
cucme.nrrccmu
o3Haqaror
cJreAy-
rcrlee;
MHoropa3JrlrrrHble
c.[ol.I
cpa6arblBalor
BMecre II
MrHoBeHHo, a
co-
cro.qHue cucrelrbr
cBopaqI,IBaer
r.r
ynaroRbrBaer
ce6g, (unu paeeopaqr{Ba-
er)
e o4HonpeMeHHo
cpa6arnrarcruyrc
rrepapxuro
cJroeB.
3ro He
Moxer
6lrrl nougto
Har,'r.r{AHo
u npeArronaraer
orra3 or
KJ'Iaccr.rqecxofo
rroHlrMa-
HI4.q
PAIIHO}IAJbHOCTI,I.
<.I4X
OIiToIoTI{IIecKIII1
cTaTyc HeTIpeAcTaBuM
B IIpeA-
MerHoM
s3r,rr(e>>
[Malrap4aursluru,
1984, c. 76].
OrnrerHu raKxe,
qro
HeBo3Mo)KHo
n ux
crpyKTypuo-QynrquoHaJrbHoe
paccMoTpeHr{e,
Kar{ To rrpeAJ'rafaeTcrr
flpurrut{rroM cHcTeMHoro
aHanu3a
B
ApyroM
ero
Baprdar{re, BocxoA.srleu
r
pa6oran
"II.
SoH
Eepra,raH$u
vHar4-
6o,ree no,ruo ocBoeHHoM
B orerrecrBeHnoM
NreroAo.[orl{rIecKoM
rloaxo.qe
F.
(D.
JloNaosa
["IIolron,
1984].
14ueuHo aror
BapraHr
nal.r6olee
u3BecreH
rlcr{xoJloraM
B
paMKax paapa6orrn
ilpr{Hurrla
cncreMHocru.
OH :aHltntaet
Aocraroq
Hoe
N{ecro n
yve6Hr.rxax,
npe4craBn.fl
roIIHX cHcreMy
rrplrHuurIoB
B rrcr4xoJroruu
[Ierponcxuii,
flporuencxuii, 2003].
B ueu
Her ocHoBHoro
or,'rurru.q cucreuuoii
npHrrHHHocrH -
rrpeAcraBrerru"q
o Heo6xo4r.rnaocru
rofi r.re6r,rroqHocrrr,
Koropas
xapalrreprr3yer
M[rp
Aesruuft
qeJroBer(a,
r{ Toro
ecTecTBeHHo-HcTopuqecKoro
6brtHg <<TpeTbI{x
neu1efi
,>,
flocpeAcTBoM
Ko-
TopbIX
rreJroBex
LI oprreHTnpyerc.rl
B Mllpe, rAe
4eficrnyer
[purrl{HHocrb,
BKrroqarculas
ero co6crseHHbre
npeo6paeyrculue
AeiicrBr.r.s.
OpneHrnpoBKa
Ha rax noHqryro
flpuqllHHocrb,
KaK oHa rrpeAcraJla
B
paMKax
HeKJ'Iaccnqecroti
xapruutt
Mupa, He
npqMo cBq3aHa
c
pa3BrrrueN{
TaK
Ha3blBaeMol"r Her,'Iacclr.{ecroii
[cr4xoJlofnr.r,
KaK oHa
npeAcraer
B noA-
xoAax
K rroHHMaHHro
Jrr{qHocrt{
H co3HaHr{.{.
Ho xouuenrluefi
MalrapAa-
rrrBr{,'I}I
yxe
3aAaHbI
Te CB.f,3yIOUlle
HUTUI
MeXAy
MeTancnxonoILIqecKIMH
KareropuqMt{
I,I oKcrpartcI4xoJ'IorilrtecKHMH
(n
repunuo"rrorun
uI,ITupoBaH-
Horo
yue6unKa
rro reoperrr.{ecxorl
lcr,rxoJrortrn),
roropr,re
Heo6xo4uuo
MeHfl Ior rrpeAcraBJleHur
u
o6
o6r,scv.nreJlbHbrx
rlp14HuHtrax
npHMeHHTenb-
Ho
K
ypoBHro
6asosr,rx
xareropuii.
I-naea
9. flapaahrMbt
u
Lvrxorowur
B
nchxofuofrrr
9. 1 .
flcu x
o AorvrA
onxcarenbHafl
h
o6uncn
NrenbHat
'fepunu
<<ornrcareJrbHa.s
[clrxoJroru.q>
B J'rr{reparype
yrBepAl{,rc.fl
trocne
ItbIXoAa
n
1BB4 I. B
cBeT
TI0A 3TI,TN{
Ha3BaHI,IeM
pa6orrl
BbIAaIoIueIoc.'I
HeMeII-
roro rpl.r,rocoQa-u4ea,rucra
Bu,rrre,rlr,ra
f
u,rtrea
(
1833-
1911).
Dro 6u,ro
tlpeM.s
foc[oAcrBa
accou]raH]r3Ma,
B3aUN{OrrpoHrlKHoBeHI{.q
U4eii
$ueuolo-
t'aqecxoii
rcl{xoJ]ofl{t{
pI
rcuxo,rtoflllr
co3HaHU'I,
HO
TaK}Ke
u BpeM.s
llocre
BbIXoAa
ocHoBorronararounx
rpyAoB
l.
Oexuepa (
1
B0 1
-
1 BB7
)
u l.
O66unra-
yoa
(1850-1909),
xor4a
ro.rrBuracb
rraAe)KAa
Ha
pa^:pa6orry
o6terrnnuoro
MeroAa
r{ccJleAoBaHrrg.
s o6nacru
lcr{xoJ'roru}r.
cnop
MexAy
onlEcare,trgoii
tt o6tgcuure,rr,Hoir
ncnxoJ'Iorneii
.Iacro
cBfl
3brBalor
c trporr{BorlocraBJrleHu-
oM
I'IMeH
Au,rrreg
u
S66unraysa (c
ero
opr.reHrauueii
ua
ro,
qro
rrcuxoJro-
l'uq
Mo)Ker
crpol{Tbc.g
no IIpl'IHUI'Iny
[IcrIoJ'tb3oBaHHs
aKcrlepHMeHTa,rrb]roro
NlcroAa
u 6lrrt
Hayxoii
o6l.acutrre-rtr
Hoii; <.sKc[eprlMenroN{>
rorAa
6ua
ncu-
xotpuauvecrnrt
n accoqnarnnHuii).
HaAo
cxaearb,
qro
caM
flu,rnrefi
n cno-
ci.i xunre
aneJrJrupyer
He
K Hl{erru
366uurayza,
a
K npoAoJrNare.trc
l.rAefi
llo,rrQa.
flpe4craruu
ero
rro3r{uurc
Ha'{I'IHaerc.fl
KHHra
c
AoKa3areJ'IbcrBa
roro,
q1o
cropoHHLIKI,I
MarepflaJrI{-
("f
r'rqecKoro
rroHrrMaHr{s
IIpnHqr.rla
accouHaur{rr
(fep6apr,
cneucep
u
Tarr)
ttc06ocuosauHo
I]puBJ'reKarcr
Qn:nvecKoe
rroHr{MaHHe
IIpuqnHHOCTII
AJ'rs
l(oHcrHTyIIpoBaHI{t
ncHXO,'Iorl{qecKIrx
3aKoHoB
I]o IIpIrH{uny
npuvlaHuofi
('lJt3lr
<<IIpI{
[ocpeAcrBe
orpaHuqeHHoro
qrlcJ'ta
oAHo3HarrHo
ollpeAen.seMbIX
:fJrcMeHroB)>
[[u"nrrer)i,
2007,
c.5].
Anrop
KpurnKyer
ocHoBHoe
3BeHo
B
ilocrpoeHr{tt
K-rraccr.rqecKoii
rapruHlt
ulrpa
(Ken,repou,
la,ru,teel,r,
Htrc_
't
oltoru)
-
3BeHO
ZUnOme3 -
r,r Bbrpaxaer pe3Koe
Henpu.rrrue ponrl
rHnore3
rr
()crecrBeHHo-HayqHoM
[o3HaHuH.
HanouHrll,r,
rrro
rorAa
eue
He 6r,t,ro
't'('oplru
KpHTr{qecKoro
peaJ'rr,r3Ma
K. llonnepa,
n
roropoii
ror
o60cuona.r
ciloco6
rHnoreruKo-AeAyI{TrrBHOfO
BbIBOAa
KaK
MeroA
o6bexrusHoro
[o-
illlitllH's
[MeHHo
Ha ocHoBe
BbIABI'l)ceHIL{
TeopeT[{ecKIIX
InnoTe3,
fipoBep-
l(ir t(oropbrx
u3MeHqer
npocrpaHcrBo
uayuHoii
rrpo6leutr.
ltn fiur.vrexto'
Lt4f Mbt A
ArlXOrOMt4l4
B 1C/.XOAO|
Vt4
IIaIaHile
B IIO,{e
fIIIIoTe3
I4cKJ'IXlqaeT
B03N{O}I{I{oCTb
IIpl{qUHIIOTO
II03I{aHIItt.
To ecrr,
AJTg
Hero
B rrepByro
oqepeAb
HerrpxeMr'reMa
r{MeHr{o
ara
xapaKTe-
pl{crI{Ka
ecrecrBeIIHo-HayqHoro
I1ol]ItaHu.q
-
rlyrb
tsbIABIlxeHll.q
rHrore3,
a ue
co6ctgel{Ho
sKCrleplllleHtatlHutYt
NIeroA,
r{aK
3.I.o
IIIIOIAa
CeroAllq
rlpeA-
craBJ'rrlor
cropoHHIrKH
olrr,rcareJ'rbr{oii
ucrrxo,ror-irrr ((lyHxrluorurpyrorqeii
B
ApyroM
ee rroHr.rMaHrrr{,
qeM
:a4a,r
Ir.llreri).
cae4yrorqufi
I{eAocraro*
o6oacuument
ttou ncutotto
auu c
rorrKu
3perrnq
aBTOpa
[orxoAa
noHu"Manuleil
ncu.rottozurl
-
flepeHeceHl,re
BHe[IIter"t
no-
cJreAoBareJrbHocrl,r
KaK npr.rvHHrroil
r1enil
co6lrrr.rri
Ha
4yureefryro
)Krr3Hb.
14 zgecn
Balrrrbr
o6e
coctan,r.qruulle
-
Bo-rrepBbrx,
BbrABr,r)(errr{e
HoBolo
ilo-
HHMaHU.g
[peAl\{era:
I]CI,IXOJ'IOIU{
Teilepb
tIayKa
I{e o5
accotluaqnqx,
a IIayKa
o
Ayxe,
Ayruenuofi
rrr,r3Hr{.
Bo-eroprrx,
nepexoA
K rrocJteAoBarellHouy
odo_
cHoBar{uIo
nprqnHHocrr{
KaK
3aN.rr{Hyroii
ro.rrlrco
n crpepe
4yrrresHoi;i
xlr3rrrl.
3ro
ssuo
xoA B
uHyro
cropoHy
rroHrrrraHun
AerepN{xHarluI{,
qe\{
rraMeqaJ'r-
ca
y
lxeriuca
u
Apyrilx
aBropoB,
orHocuMLJX
r( rra[paBJreHrrrc
Syunrluo-
tra-nlHoii
[cfixoJ'Ioruu.
3ro raxxe
u co3lareJrr,Hlrii
orras
or
Bo3tr{o)K}tocrrj
paccMorpeHH.q
eAr.rHofo
llpuquHHoro
xpyra
co6lrrufi
n rrpr.r.rr,rHrrolo
o6y-
cr'roBJruBarrr{q
-
xor.s
6tr
Ha
yponue
rrJ)rr3HaHrrq
lrpr,rqnHr{o-Aelicr.nyroqnx
yc,rorHii
-
Ha ypoBHe
4eficrrna
3aKoHoB
AyuenHoft
xr43Ht{.
c ro'IKu
3peHrrt
flrl,rrrex,3BeHo
runore3
ue Nro)Ker
IIot..Iorarb
lrcr{xoJlo-
rxqecKoMy
[o3HaIruIo,
[ocKoJ'IbKy
<<B
ll()3HaHI{r
npxpoAbl
cBgl]Hble
KoNITI-
JIeKCbr ycraHaBnlIBaruTCs
6tarogapx
o6tpaaoeaunrc
r.Hlrore3,
B rrcfixoJ'rorr{r,r
)Ke
I4MeIIHO
CBrI3aIIlIr'Ie
KOMIIJ'IeKCbI
IIepBOIIaqaJ'IblIbI
I{ IOCTeIIeH]IO
AarIbt
ll
rrepe)KnBarrnp>
[f{u,rnrei.i
,2001,
c. 11].
Kpoue roro,
Saxru
n
o6nac.ru
gy-
lxesuoii
xu3rru
He
Aocrrrrarct
rartori
crreIlerrH
onpeAeJ'rer{Hocrrr,
Koroparr
Heo6xoAnua
AJirs
coorHeceHu.s
lrx
c reopneii.
Bpe4 noar.rrr.rBrr3Ma,
cB.q3l,r-
BaeMofo
c o6r.qcunre,rlHoii
lrcttxoJlo]']Ieii,
sar,txrvaetcg
g
<.5ecrl"rtonnorl
sMrrHpl'rKe>>.
Kaut,
xar
r{
Apylue
rHocL-oJ'rorrr (rfiu,roco$rr,
pa3B}lBanuue
Teopurc
noeHaur.u),
pa3pbrtsaer
eAr{rryrc
cB.s3r}
AyxoBuoro
rf)axra
u
roro
<<IIpeAcraBJteHH.rr
AyxoBHoii
cs.s3r.r>,
ua
dtoHe
xoropoii
4arr
eror
tlaxr.
B pacropaxeHl{e
fHoceoJtofuli,
no
{tralrero,
Hy)r(rro
rrlarb
<<i,}Iaqr,Iuble
ro-
J'ro)KeHlIs
o
cllr3tl
Ayuenrroii
xr{3Hr{>.
tr4 :Aecl oH
crpor{T
xaprrrrry,
Aeii-
crBLITeJrbHo
HoByro
no cpaBrreHtrro
c acco(uannctcnoti.
B
noucrax
lpeArrocbr,rror{
cBoHX
B3rJ'rrAoB
flullreii
o6parqaerca
n
Apy-
roMy
I{eMerlKoruy
r}n,rocotfy
X. Bo.lr'rpy, paccN{ar?rrB:nr
ero parIrroHaJrbHyro
ficr{xoJrorrlrc
xax o6r.qcHrrreJ'rbHyto.
Memarpusuuecrcuil
e"teuertm
o6rttc.uw-
re,rtrrori
I]ctlxoJrorflr{ -
I]epBeHcl'BO
pa{rorraJrbHbrx
KOrrcrpynqnri,,rilrur,
llpoBep-qeMbrx
B 3il{[npxqecrofi
ttcr.rxoJrorull,
-
Bor c
rIe\I
croprrr
{n,rl-
reii.
tr4 oH
crrerlHaJ'rbuo
o6paulaer
Bnr{NraHue
Ha rrpeAcraBr.rre,ra
rep6apr.oe-
cnoti
lttr<o,tnr
T. Baiturla
KaK Bnepnble
rrocraBl{Brrrefo
rjrrr,re
rpnopl,ITerr,r:
9.
l .
ff craxonorhr
onhcaren6Hae
v o6uscHzre,nuHan
219
oIIItcare/rblla,r
[cuxoJ'Iofur,
coorBercrBeHHo
Hayr(aN1
O6
OprauHuecxori
)KII3HU,
IIOCTaBJ'rfler
3r{IItlptlqecKrrI"I
MarepIra,r,
a
o6lr{cH].ITeJ'tbHa.q
onepu_
l)yer
STrrM
N{arepIIaJToNt.
flplr
3ToN{
OHa
CTpeN{r.rrc.s
BbtAerr{Tb
3aI(OHOt!{ep-
rrr,[i
n,raH
an-neHut)i,
He
or-rrrolua-qcb
3Berro]{
futrore3
rax nterarfiH:I{qecKllr,1
3,rreMeHTO\{.
frr,rnreri
He
flporrrB
TaKofo
rroHrrr,raHr.r.q
o6b',(lteH1sl.
BlrxoA
:ia
rpeAeJ'rbr,
rra\,1er{eHHbre
Bartrrqelr,
lJrr,lr,refi
RuAr.rr
B
c,rreAyrotuer,r.
Pac'J,'IeHeuue
Bocnprl-qrl{q
LI
BocIIoMrIHaIIlIt
-
Bor
c
rlero
HaqaJ,Iacb
o6)t.scu[te,rbna.s
[cuxo,rotlt-s.
<.Mofvval
4elicrnure,rlbuocrb )I(I{BHr{>
na-
JleKo
BbIxoAt{T
3a
npeAeJ'Ibr
3TI{X
rartnTnil
o6b_qcHl{re,'IlHoii
lcHxo,rotnH.
Kpoue
roro, pca,rrbHa.s
[cuxo,{orrrr,
Kal{
ee rorrrlvraer
/{tr,rlreii,
/loJr}Krra
6lrrt
npovHo
o6ocuonasa
rr
AocroBeprr:r
(n
or-{rrq}re
or
frrloreryrrec6nx
o6rqcHerrur"r).
oua
4o,rxHa
rlopBarb
c cl(rr,.qcHnre-rrbHor-r
rcrrxoJ,rorreii
rax-
xe
rroroMy,
vro
ra He pa3
cB.a3brBar'ra
ce6fl
c Nrar€prr2rtrrr3Nrol,r.
Henpr.reu,te-
Mocrb
B3rr'r.q40n
Byu4ra
n
f,xeliuca
(nax
rrpe,lcrasnrejreii
conpenreHHoii
cNIy
IlcllxoJrrorlrrt)
flu,rlreti
cu.sgbtgacr
c
rer{,
rtro
oHrI, yBer,IurIL{Ba,
are_
l\,t
eHTbI
il
llprreNtl,I
o6r'"qcuertuii,
ocraB.{g,rt
rr
/ un om
emuqe
cKu-Lt
caM
xaDalr-
'r'cp
o6r'xcHnreJ'IbHbIX
J,'lexlerJToB.
<,
fIoA
o
[ucarellnoli
[ctrxo.irorrleri
.q
par,vNre]o
nso6paNeuue
e,IuHoo6
-
l)a3Ho
npo-sB-rlqrcuILIXC{
nO
ecgxoli pasertrotl
rreJ'roBeqecKot?
lvurenHoit
)ltlr3Hu
COCTaBHbIX
,{acreri
tt
cuacli,
o6lc4trHarculflxc.q
B
"an*,yK)
ctsq3b,
l(oropa-g
He IrpItr,rbIIIJJrqerctr
u He
BbrBorilTc.q,
a
nepelKttBaerc.fl>
[Au,'rr,reii,
2001,
c. 20].
Aue,r,rxwrfl.
K
nepewrBettuto
Bbrr-rr.sA'r
cBr{3yroruxM
3BeHor{
i\te)I(Ay
Ax-rIbreeBclrI,IM
14
COtspeN{eHHbIN{
IIOIIITN{aHHeN{
ficuxo.rloruu
[epe)KrI_
uaHu.s
KaK
nBil)Kenu.s
B
cropoHy
ryr{aHrrraprroi,i
napa4rrrnrn.
OAHaxo
6o_
ICC
NOgPO5UO
IPEACTABNCHI,IC
IIO3IIIIUi1
NCI
IJOIIPOCANI,
KAK
TIOHI4NIAIOTCS
rr('pexrrBaHr{e
rr ortseqaloull.rii
lcnxo,rorl{I.1
NferoA,
He
ro3BoJ't.{er
yBlrAerb
rl)tMyro
cB.s3b
Mer{Ay
rrcrrxoJ'rorueri
4yrrrrr
no
f,n-llrerc
rr rrcuxoJ,tor-rqe-
('trHMI{
rroAxoAar,{n
B
paN{Kax
coBper.feH}roii
rvlrarrrrrapuofi
napa4urMbr.
l]
'racrttocrH,
oII
rIo/IqepI{uBaJ'I
aHarumuqHocmb
rrclxoJrofllqecKoro
3Ha-
illrrl,
AaHHOTO
HenocpeAcrBeHHO,
go
tte
6ee
ocN.{bIC,{eHL{.q
ero
qeJIoBeKOM.
Baxuerirueri
xapaxTepr4crnxori
onncare,rlrioii
rlcnxoJ,rorrr14.sBJ,r.qerc,
To,
'r'11)
<<xoA
ee
AoJ'I)xeH
6ltrr
aua,rtrrlrvecrnti,
a He
flocrporte,trultt-t>.
To ecrl
ilontlMalol]ra.s
rcuxoj'Iorll'I
NIbICJIITJ'IaCr'
!rr.lnreeu
He B
rlporlrBoBec
aHa_
.rlllrIIqecKol\'{y
MeToAy'
a B
rporllBoBec
IIcIrxoJ'IorlrqecKHl,r
peKorrcrpyKr]H-
ril\f
,
noropbre
rraAcrpar.lBarotcs
uad
uenocpedcmoeuuo
\auutrtu.
Taxr.ru
o5-
l);r:joM,
aro
o60cuonaHl{e
Bce
rofo
)Ke
nocrynara
HerIocpeAcrBeIIHOCTI,r
B
il('lrxoJlofrlr{.
BHyrpeHuee
Bocnpn.arlle
MO}KeI
HenocpeAcrBeHHo
aaBarb
I
cloraacuo
ero oIJcHKe,
Tor'it
Ko 6eanpeltenttax
KoHr{r4}Ia
Barlnqa
no1{eulaJ,ra
eMV
r'rir
l, r] pgA
c raxnN{ti
Be.llrqultar{r
B Hayxe,
xar
,rlort1e
rt Oexuep.
I
220
cBeAeHHs
o
AyureBHoii
xH3Hr{.
z xaxoslr
6lr Hu
6lr,ru
npuvuHHl'Ie
oTHo-
ueHu.g,
B KoTopbrx
Bo3HrrK
lrc11xtrqecKl,Ifr
aXr
(nocnpvflTrfl,,
N{bICJIUTeT'Ib-
Hbrii
aKT),
BO BHyTpeHHeN,{
Mlrpe
oH
o6pa3yeT
Her{To
HOBOe,
He I{MeIoUIee
aHa,,IoIa
B Mrtpe
BHe[IIIeM.
llpu
erolt
fiu,rlreii
[oArIepKuBaeT
UHTe,'IJIeK-
Tya,lbHocTb
BHyTpeHHeIO
BOCtlpIIgTl{fl,
onocpeAcTBOBaHI',Ie
ero
J'IoII4r{eCKI'l-
N4r.{
ilpoueccaMu.
3To
poxAaeT
rrcgxoJ'roll{qecKoe
HaS,lnAeHI{e.
B
peey,rl-
TaTe
pacq,leHgloxlag
oIIucaTe,'It,Ha.g
[c]'IXoJlOrLIq
<<KOHI{aeT
II{nOTe3al\{H'
rorAt
KaK
o6T,scH,TerbHa.fl
c
HI{x
Har{}IIIaer>
[flullrefi,
2001,
c' 51]'
K o6r,qcnnre"rlbHblM
MoMeHTaM
B
paMKaX 0[I'lcaTeJ'IbHoii
nclrXoloru'tn
oH
oT-
HOCI{T
IIpe.4CTaBJIeHlIff
o
cTpyKTypHoN',t
3aKoHe
I{
3aKoHe
pa3BuTU'q'
I4ure.n,lexr,
qyBcrBo
(no6yx4errue)
u Borq
cBssbrBaroTcf
B
pacq,IleHeH-
HbIe
r1eJlbre
AyueBHoii
xr{3Htr.
tr4
qro6u
1,1]\r
BHoBb
BepHyTb
ue,rlocTHocTb,
.[g/IbTeeBCKa.a
11CUXOJIO1H;I
B03BpalUaeT
K
I,IAee
meleoIOZULr9CKOil
\p1y.tq146-
HOCTU.
crpyxrypna'l
cBs3b
HocrrT
TeJ'reo,rroruqecKilii
xapaKTep:
oHa
AaeT
ocHoBHoii
3aKoH
AyIxeBHoii
)t(u3Hu
-
3aKoH
pa3Bl{rllfl
(<<Ael:icrByloquii
KaI(
6u n HanpaaJreHr{lr
Anr{Hbr>>).
B xaxAon
oTAeJrbHoM
aKTe
CO3HaHHq
BCerAa
HaxoAl{Tcfl
6o4pcrnyroulull
[y'{oK
no6y)KAeHlit
u
r{yBcrB'
Kpolre
roro'
cBg3b
AyuleBHoii
xn3Hu
<<coAepxlrr
KaK
6u
npasuno,
om Komopux
3a6u-
cum
meqeHue
omaenuhtzc
\gweouotx
npoqeccos>>
(alt4eleHo
B'
n')
ltrv.r^:o-
reit,
2001,
c.57).
A aro
yxe
yra3aHlre Ha
3aKoH
KaK
AerepMnHaIIHlo'
Ho
Iro3rrrHBHOrO
paCCMOTPeHI4s
sToii
npo6neMbl
B KHI{re
Her'
Mlr
npune,ur
6olee
no4po6uo
cxeuy
Arr,'rbreeBcKoii
ncuxo.irorun
IIoTo-
My,
IITO
OpLIeHTI{pOBKa
Ha
Uenb
nolltLlvaHua
He
03Haqa"'Ia
Ang
elo
onucaTeJlb-
Hoii
ncuXonoIIII4
oTKa3a
oT
aHaJ'II{THqecXofo
MeTOAa
Hr'IH
J'I61IIKII
BbIBoAoB.
OHa
paccraeJl.s,{a
IIHL,Ie
IIpHopI{TeTr,I
Me)I{Ay
IIcl{Xo,IIoflIr{ecKHMl{
$aXranalt
u
o6bqcHeH
v'.M:/-l
IIO CpaBHeHrzro
c rilrrorerr4Ko-AeAyKTr.rBHbrM
MeroAoM,
KOTopbIii
IIM
cBs3blBa*[c.f,
oTHIoAb
He
c sKcIIepHMeHTanbHoii
ncl{xonoll{efi
(KaK oHa
cIoXuTCq
,rUIIIb
IIo3Xe
-
B
XX n.),
a
c 3a,'IolICeHHbIM
Bo,rrQolr
rrpL{Hur{IIOM
IIepBeHCTBa
paul{oHanbHolo
KOHCTpyUpOBaHHg
3aKOHoB
IICU-
XHKr{
([pr.rHUr.rnoM
MeTaOH3ur{ecKoIo
II9HIIMaHIIfl
Ilcl{Xuqec6oro).
PflA
no-
JroXeHI4ii,
tr3JIoxeHHbIX.{U,rr,reelr,
[peAcTaBneH
CeIoAHt
B 1168bIX
[apaAIII-
Max,
c LIHbIM
[epeocMblc,'IeHl{eM
B,'IOXeHHOTO
B HI{X
COAepxaHHs'
flouunaaHue
-
3TO
He BOCCO3AaHI{e
CTO{Ueii
BOBHe
(3a
r'IOIHKOfi
OTHO-
rrreHrrii)
paur{oHanbHori
cBfl3lr,
a ee
ycMorpeHge
B caMofi
AyueBHoii
)I(H3-
HIl:
<<...KaK
HaIIIe
CO3HaHHe
MI{pa,
TaI{
U Halue
caMoco3HaHne
BO3HHKIII
1I3
9.1 . flcr.rxo,rorhr
onhcaren6Hag ,'t o6ulcHrre,ruHar
221
xI43HeHI{oclI4 Ha[Iero "f",
v
gra
iKII3HeHHocrb
-
6o,rtue,
.uev,
Ratio,>
[nnrref,
200I, c.78].
O6parnM raK)Ke BHuMaHtre Ha ro,
rrro
noHrrNraHr.re
3AeCb
-
3TO OTIIIOAb He IIOHIIN,IaHHe
ApyIOfO
qe,loBeKa
I{JIII K,'IHeHTa, KaK
3TO
npeAcTaB,rrrrroT
B coBpeMeHlro rl ficuxonpaKTtrKe, onepupy.q
noHflTLlfl
-
MH 3MrraTr{n
fi
ap.
fIoH[MaHHe 3Aecb 3aMeHreT,lroruKy ycTaHoBJ'reHLrt
Br{eu]-
HHX IIpUrrUH Ha
BHyTpeHHrOrO Te,'reoJrorr.il.O
AymeBHbIX
cTpyKTyp.
flpouuqare,rbHocrb
flwnntex
3aK,'tloqaerc.rl TeM caMbrM,
Ha Ha[I 83r,TqA,
ne B co3AaHrlu
npeArrocbr,rroK ryt\{anlrrapHorl
lapaArrrMr,r B rrcrrxo,'Iorun,
a B ocTpoM
He[Ipu.qTuu KaK
nonbITKIl nepeHecTH Ha llcuxo,rlofHlo
SaKoHbI
1\{exaHr,rKr{ (rrTo xapaKTeplr3oBa,'ro
coBper.leHHyro eMy
ecTecTBerrHo-Hayr{Hylo
oplleHTaIII{rc
accour,rarr.rBHoii ncuxolourr.r),
TaK lt N,reraQu3urIecKoro
[pr{H-
uuna
IIpu
cTapoM IIoI{IIMaHIIIt <<patlnOI]a"rtbIIOIO>
IIOCTpOeHUg.ICI4XOJ'IOIt{-
rrecKoro
3HaHr4s.
oroxAecrs,leHue
}xe
r{N{ sToro IlprrHut{fla c [pHHurlrroM
ABHlKeHIr.s
rnrroTe3 N{orKeT
Terrepb
paccN{aTpr.{BaTbcr
KaK
cyIIecTBeHHbrr"r
flpocqeT.
llepe4
flr.r,rlreenr
B ero flepuoA rBopqecrBa6lrilna
HHa.q KaprHHa
o6ocHosaHufl
o6bg,c{trre,Ilbllofo
r,Ierola: accoul{aHu3Nl
KaK [cl{xo,'Iof}{.q
co3HaHr.rs
B ee cTpyKTypaJ'rr,rcTcKoM
rr
dtyl{Kur'roHa"{bHoM
BapuaHTax,
t\{eTa-
Queura
r{ rro3nrrrBrl3lr.
Bepuyrtcs
K
ue,tocrHbrM
cBs3.sM xrrBofi
AyIu}I
-
3To 6bln OALIH
tr3 Bapr,raHToB oTr{a3a
or orrocpeAcrByrouero 3BeHa rlcHxo-
JrorrrqecKr{x peKoHcrpyKuuii.
Apyrue
Bapua}rrbr
-
B rrocJreKpr.r3r4cHbrii
rreprroA rrc[xoJron{r.1
s
XX a.
*
nanv
o6ocuonarrus
pa3HbrM
}ranpaBJreHH-
fl r\l 3Trrx
peroucrpyr<qri.i.
[a,rr,neiiuree
pa3Bl{Trre
ArrJrbreeBcr{ori
rtcnxo,rrorr{r'r roHuluaHr.r.s ocyxlecrB-
Jr.snocb ero
yqeHuKoM
3.
IIInpaHrepoN{,
r{oropbrii aKueHTupoBaJr
yxe
HecKonb-
tco truori acrreKT
npoTlrBorrocTaB"rreHur
AByx
[cnxo.rrornii
-
[cuxonornr{ sJre-
MeHToB
H
AyxoBFlo-HayqHofi
[cr{xoJrortrrr.
tr4 eAecl uura
per{b
He 06 orKa3e B
l)aMKax
rIoHHMaIoUeit
[apaAurMbr or
rrpr{HuurroB rrocrpoeHuq HayrrHofi rtcu-
xoJrorur4, a
o cyTrr 3THX
IrpxHIIr{rroB. B nepeoli
r,'IaBe cBoeii KHI,IIu
<.ooplrtr
)Kr,r3Hrr.
{yxonHo-HayqHa.s
llcuxoJrorrrs>>,
HarrHcaHHoii s
IgI4 r., lulpaHrep
orMerI,IJ'I,
rITo
<<TaK
llpocro>, KaK 3To
rlpeAnara/I
fluntteit,
npo6neMa
crpyK-
'rypbr
Ayrxu
He
peuaeTc.fl,
a rrpuqrIHHocTb
He N{orKeT orpaHurluBaTbcr{
paMKa-
Nr!I
BHyrpeHHeii reneo,'rornH
(B
oIIucaHnr.r
aroii crpyKrypbr KaK oMoUr{oHaJrb-
rf oro
peryn.flTopa
roro,
rrro
rrMeer
r,r He r,rN,{eer
rleHHocrll
A"rr
fl.uH!.rrB:,1|/ta). Ec,ru
ra
Hl{3nlux cryrreH.rrx
cBoero
SyHxqllorrupoBaHrrr{
lepexr{BaHrr{
perynrrpy-
rolc.q 6uo,'Iorur{ecKrIM
-
I{€r'I.flMI4
caN{ocoxpaHcHl{.fl
opraHH3Ma, To Ha 6oJlee
nr,rcorcor? cryrleHu )Kr43Hr,r,
oco6eHno
r,rcroplrqecKoii,
uHAunlrAya,TbHarr )Kr{3Hb
1y
uu o6y cnoB/rr.rBaeTcs
AyxoBrrbrMt{
cBr3.qiuu,
UeHHocTHbIM
u cBfl3trMrr
c o6rexrneuori
r<y,rtrypoii.
Ou
paanepuya
o6ocHosaHue
o6lexrlrsHocrll
B Tpex nrrocrac.sx: <<...Kpo-
rtc... o6textuBHocrlr, ,rexauler.i
B
Marepuanbrroii
n"nocxocru,
rt o6textltn-
1B
nepnyrc
ouepeAb
3To
rlorll{Mal{ue
HenocpeAcTBcllsoii
Aauuocrr
Qaxra
xax
cal-
3t{
B
AyIUeBl{oii
xttsulr:
<.Cnq3b.{yBcTBeHHofo
Bocnpl{.xTfis
He BbITeKaeT
U3
qyBcTBeII-
not"
p*np*egtrii,
B
sefi
coeAuuelHbrx...
oHa Bo3HnKaeT
,'ILtlIIb
II3
XUSOfi,
eAnttoit
netTeJrbHocTr4
B
HaC,
KoToparr,
B
cBolo
oqepeAb,
caMa
sBrrleTct
cBrI3bIo>
[2001,
c.7
a].
t L-
222
lnaea
9. flapaazruu
v
atxoroMvlu B ncl,xo/\ortt
9..1 . flcrlxonorhr
onhcarenr,Hafl
h o6ulcuurenssar
223
Hocrrr,,rexauleri
B cr{creN{e
AaH}rocreii
AyxoBr{oro
pa3BHTfl.q
u naauuo4eii-
cTBr4"q,
B noTopblx
oHa
BO3HI{naeT
HcTopHqecnr{
II 3aKoHor.fepHo,
Hy)KIIo
pa3J'nrrraTr'
er{e rpeTur.i
n naxrreiiruvii
Btt[, o6bexrusHocTrr,
a r.rMeHHo
HaAbrr{llrlBr{Aya,'rbHbrri
cNrbrc,'r,
KoTopbrr?
B rrrlx coAep}Kr1Tc.s>
[lIIrrpaurep,
1980, c.
288].
3ro rperbe
-
cMbrcnoBoe
-
HanpaB-qeHr{e
lfhpaHrep
lpeA-
,'lo)Ku,II
Aa,'Iee
Ha3bIBaTb
KpUTnr{eCXn-o6texruBIlbIM,
a
AyXOBHbIe
3aKOHO-
MepHocrI,I
co3uAare,'tbHo
fi
4exre,r
tHocr
t{
I
..
.fl
>
-
HopN.IarnBHbIMI{.
<.
O uncate,tlHocrb
>>
tIcI4xoJ'IorI{I4
fll l
paurepoM
cB.s3blBaercq
c ucro-
puvecroii
oTIHCAT€;-IbHocrLIo
(a
He c orxa3oN{
or 3BeHa
fuflore3
B Hayr{-
HOM
rrO3HaHHr.r),
a HayrfrocTb
-
c rrpnHrlrrnoN{
npr{Tr,rqecKr.r-HopMaTIB-
Hori
ycraHoBKr{
Ha ro,
qro
oHa
AoJ'r}K}ra
crarb
}rayxori o
Ayxe.
Or
o6pa:on
lcnxrrqecKr.rx
aroN,roB
l.r,rr.r
npocrer)irurrx
npoueccoB (3Aecb
rrpr,rBoAHTcr
B
rrpxN{ep
Byuar)
oH cr{ura,rr
ueo6xogrrlrrrN,{
orxa3arr,cr
B rronbay <<rrprrH-
uuna
pacr{r'IeHqloluero
aHaJlH3a
>
(nr,tecro
[pt,tIIIII{Ia
rBopqecKoro
crrHTe-
3a aneMeHToe).
Tarnu o6paaou,
To,
qro
ncr{xoJ'rorr{q
noHHMaHrr.q
[peA-
floJ'raraer pacqreHtIoulltt"t
aHa,Ttte,
BbrcryllI{r'Io
o6rurtll
A.IoMeHToM
AByx
xoHqenunii.
Or,rn.rlre r{oHrlerruHlr
lUtpaurepa
-
BK,rrlorreHtre
trcr4xoJ'ro-
IuqecKofo
<.fl>
e lopa3Ao
50,ree
uupoKl{e
IIeHHoCTIIbIe
CBA3LI,
qeM
<<CaN,I()-
y.4oB,lleTBOpeHI,Ie>;
paccMoTpeHI{e
HaAbIHAHBrrAyanbHr,rx
r{opM KaI{
$opruu
oSrexrunaur.rr.i
Ayxa;
HanpaBneHHocrb
Ha <<FropN{aruB}rr,rri
aaxon
ue}rHo-
crI,I>
u roHut{aHlre.4yuenuon
xH3ui.r
re\I caMbIN,I
KaK cMbrcJ'Ionoii
cexcn,
r xoropoii
o5lexrrrsulrri
rr cy6ter<rrlBubrii
cNtbtc-/rbr <<Aocraror{Ho
llporu-
BOper{ar
Apyr
Apyry>.
Ill
lpanrep
rpefi,rrarar-r
urro ri n o4xoA
K Kyl
bl.ypHo-
rrcropnrrecr{oMy
uo
-
IrlrNrarrr{rc
-
rr re]\{ caN{brNr
o5t,exu4sHo}.ry
paccx.rorperrurc
-
crpyKTyp
Ay-
urenttoii
xI,t3I-Iu,
r{eN,I
Tor, xoropltii
uo3HIIK
IIo3}Ke
B oreqecrBeHtloti
xy,rt-
rypHo-r.rcropn'recxoii
ruKo,rre.
Ho aro He 6rrrr
rryrb orKa3a
or rrocrpoeHul
Hayunoii
rrcHXo",rortru;
Hanporr{8,
6u,ra
no4vepKHyra
oco6euuocrr,
rro3Ha-
Hrlx
B brcurlrx
Qoplr
ncnxr.rqecKolo
xaK
r]peAnonararcrrlero
B brcrpar,rBaHre
o fiocpeAcrByrou-llrx
cBr3e
ii
-
c lut rpo l\1
l(yJrr,Typbl,
HaAbruAr,rtsulyaJ'rbr{brx
qeuHocrell,
6"uaro,1apa
qe\{y
pacxpbrBaercff
<<rleJrocrHocrl
4yxonnoil
c l'pyK-
Typbr)>.
06bexrusHlre
3ar(orrbr
nocrpoeHHq
arux
crpynryp
orpa)KanT
HaAbrHrirrBlrAya-rrblibre
cMbrcJtoBbre
o6paaonaHns,
a
He r{HAlrBriAyanbHbre
lepe)t<iltsarrr{a.
Henocpe4crBerr}{ocrb
trepexr{Bar{H.q
xapaKTepneyer,rrrvHuii
oIIbIT
OTAe,'tL,HOIO
<.-fl
,>,
HO UX COO5UeiIHe
CO3AaeT
V)Ke
IIeqTO O6beKtUeHOe.
1
LUirpolco
n38ecrHo
o6ocrroearure
lrr{ uecrr.r
rulea-tbHbrx
Ky,'rbrypnbrx rrrrroB
qe-
JroacKa
-
qc.r()BeK
TCopcrlq('cNlrri.:rr1e1161114,1gcrttii.
tcreluqecxuri,
corlra.rr,Hstii,
irojrr4TlrqccKUii,
pc,rrlruo:;ur,rii.
Orr ur,rgc:ra,rr pa3Hbrc
rHrrbr 3aKoHoB
-
R o6"lacru aro-
IION{|iqCCKUX
OtHOUreHUii,
CO3rJraHns
u
rBopqecrBa
u r.
A.
To,'rbxo cBeAeHfie
rurlii
K 3aI{OllY
C/IeJaeT <.nClHstrroti
BHyTpclIIIlox)
t{oilcl.pyKlltlIo
sTOfO
Tlllla>.
tpuxcupyeuoe
B
.q3brre,
npor{3BeAerrr4n
ucxyccrBa
LrJ'rH TexH}rrrecKoM
co-
()py)KeHuH.
flonyrapHocrb
rrplr3blBa
<<Ha3aA,
x
flu-ur,t.eror>,
aacraBn,rra
Hac
[octs.srrrrb
IlcxoAHbIM
npI4HUurIaM
ero
MeroAo,'Iorl4ll
ocHoBHoe
BHHr.{aHI{e,
nocxoJ'Ibl(y
TO,TIKOBaHU.S
AaBHO
ymJ'ru
or r'rcxoArroro
aBTopcKoro
reKcra.
B
totr
qucne
ato
I4 To,'IKoBaHLIe
roro,
qro
rroHrlMarb
rroA
orlllcare,rtrroii
ncuxo,torutefi.
B
ro xe
BpeMt
[oHrrMaHHe
o6r'.gcunte,rbrrori
napaArrrN{bI
KaK
Cg.SaaHrrori
c sKcrrepu-
MeHTaJIbHbIN{
MeroAoM
Mo}KHo
cqurarb
AocraroqHo
ycro.qB[]uMc.rl,
r{To6bl
He
troBTopsrb
efo ocHoBaHuii
B sTOM
naparparfe.
or'Iuaxo
c/reAyer
orMerr4't.b,
sro
ceroAH.r{
MeroA
nolrxMatlnrr
rrpeAcragJ'reH
lrrraqe,
rreM
Bo Bpel,reHa
flu,rtrex.
OAHo na
MeroAoJ'rornqecKux
3aMeqanurj
no ero
noBoAy
-
Kar(
lroBoii
napa-
AIITMbI,
yqurlrBalor[eii
cneqtr$nKy
<<N{rlpa
qeJ'IoBe(IecKHX
OTrrotuerll{iii>
rlo
cpaBHeHr.rrc
c MupoM
nprrpo4br,
-
c4c;ra-l
{x.
Epyuep
IEpyHep,2001]
(n
rerc_
cre
AoKnaAon
Ha
xou$epeHrll{n,
nocB.queH}rori
cro,rerr.rrc
co
AHr
po}KAeHr.{.rr
x. lluaxe
u Ha
II KoHrpecce
corlrJoKynbrypHbrx
r{ccneAoeauuii).
on orrn-
pa,'Ic"g
npn
sToll
Ha UORltii
IIOAXOA
K noHrrNtaHl4rc
orI,Icare,{LHOtO
:KaKH(lppa-
muBHozo
IIyTn
no3HaHH{.
OH rsr4e,rn,r
ABa
nyrl{
npHo6pereurrq
qeJ'roBeroM
:lHatr'ii
o N{npe.
B pau-
Kax
nepBoro
MeroAoJrortlqecKofo
rryrrr,
ocBoerruoro
o6b.qcHnrealnoii
rcu-
xolorneii (nyaa
nu orHoc.src.s
Bce
Hor.rorcrnqecKrre
no4xo4lr),
npeAno/r:r-
faercs
[puqrrHHo-cJ'reAcrBeHHaJ{
AerepNtr'rrrauux
co6urnii
n o[pcAeneHrrbre
cxeMbl
coorlleceHH-q
<<JIOrItqccKIrx
r
gNIIIrpIIqecKI{x
I1potscpor{HbIX
npo{e-
/llp>.
3ac.ryroii
llua)Ke
Epyrrep
cqr{raer
pacr(pbrrue
r.rHtsaprraHrHocrr.r,
rrjTr.r
lla[paBJ'IeHur
pa3Brl'tlrg
I'1HAI'IBI'IAya/IbHOro
rlo3llaHrjg
ro 3ToMy
nyrr{
[pn
treo6xo4nlroii
ane,r,rquuu
r(
Jrorr{gecKoNry
rrpe/tcraBJ,reH]Ito
rrcuxo,rrorr,rqc-
r:nnx pea,tuii
B craAu{x pa3Bxrr.r{
r,rHTe.rrJ'reKTa.
flpunqunua,rlHo
r.rHor.i
rryrr
pasBrrrH.rr
yl(a3an
Brrrotcxrrii,
AJr.rr
r(oroporo
yMcrBeHHbre
npoqecclr
ueo6-
xoAI,IMo
o[ocpeAcrByrorc.rl
83alrMoAeiicrBrleM
c
Apyrr{Mr{
J,rro4bMLr.
<,3oHa
6r
nxafi
urero pa3B'Tlt.s >>
nor
rqenryanluo
(rlrttcr.rpyer
r,r ocr]oB
H ou saxou
l)a3Bl{Tlr.g
B KyJTbrypIIo-ucropnqecxotT
nclrxoJrofvrl,
r{
nptrHrlil[Ha,rrbHo
lllloe
HaIIpaBJ'IeHHe
I'ICTOqI{trI(OB
pa3BUTrIt.
SruNt
ucro,{HIrKoM
BbICTyilaer
Kynbrypa.
z ntrcune
lcr4xr{rrecKrre
rfyHrrlHn
cyrb
rrpoAyKrrr
aror)i
rcyrr-
'fypbr,
a rre 3HAOIeHHOTO
pocTa.
<.oHI,t
rre ToJrrbKo ycBar.IBaroTc.g
r.r3
Lluc.r.py_
McHTapI'It
KyJ'IbryPbI
I4 ee.q3blKa,
IIo I,I 3aBIIc.qr
or
rtpoAor'I)KalorIeroc.q
co-
I
I
t{aJ'r
bHoro
naanuo4erlc
rBnsl>
[
6pyrrep,
200 1,
c. 7
].
Taxuu
o6paaou,
BropbrM
rryreM
npno6peren
us zwauuitBbrcrynaer
arren-
'tltll\ufl
K Ky/IbType'
a
3Har{llT'
K
KoHTeKcTy
cHTyaUIlI4,
AI4HaI\II,IKe
aHa.IeHLIii
tt
cMbIcJ'IoB,
a r"naBltoe -
K
HaJ'II,IqlIIo
B3auMoAeircrsug.
c KeM-To,
KTo yrI[T
ilJrH
Koro yvar
(xoHreKcryarbHocrb
-
cyrqecrBeHHoe
npuo6pereHr.re
It
]'paKTOBKe
HaAbIHAI'IBHAyaJIbHt'IX
cN{bIcr'IoB
B coBpeMeHHrrx
no4xo4ax).
224
lnaea
9. flapaarn'au
,1
avxorowvlrt
q
!!!I949IIt4
fl"rrr
Epyuepa
BaxHo,
qTo
o6a BeJIuKI{x
MbIcJII{TeJIt
He
HrHopI4poBaJIII
Bo3-
MO)ICHOCTb
BTOpOft :LlbTepHaTIrBbI,
XOTq
I,I COCpeAOTOqUJ'IHCb
B CBOITX I{C-
c,'Ie,40BaHuqx
Ha oAHofi I43
HI{X. BOaUOXHO,
3AeCb
yMeCTHO
6bUIO
6lI SneC-
TI'I
H TIPEACTABJIEHI4.'I TAKOIO
HEOAHOPOAHOIO
TEI{EHHfl, KAX
CO4UANUUAIil
KOHCmp
g
K4uo?ltt3rtt, KoTopbI
ft
rlpeAJlaraer
orKa3aTbct
or Kp I4Tep
HeB
<<
HC -
TI{HbI>
r.r <,Qartar>
AJrIg
oueHIrBaHH.x
ueHHocru
pa3rl4qHbIx npeAcraBJIeHI{ft
o Mrrpe. B xoHrexcre
xe
AaHHoro
flapatpa$a BaxHbIM
6trao
4pyroe:
rIoA-
qepKHyrb
u4en
Epynepa
o roM,
r{To
pacKpblTrre KyJIbrypHo-oIIocpeAcrBo-
BalrHbrx
ficuxuqecKlrx
peaanfi
lpeArloJlaraer
rlepexoA K
HoBOii MeroAoJIO-
ruu,
Koropylo
oH Ha3blBaer
<<noBecrBoBareJlbH^ofi>
(Happarnnuoir)' Ho
JIorHKa
HapparHBa
raKxe
rlpeAnoJlaraer
onocpedcmqogaHHocmb
[cHXoJIo-
fHr{ecKofo
3HaHHs, a He JIOTHKy
uenocpe)cmeerT?l2?o
nepeucusaHu"a
(a
cra-
pofi
napaaurMe
olucarelrHoft
ncnxoloruu)-
<.Buecro roro
rrro6bl
npoBeprlTb
Hatrllr
AoraAKI'I
o npuqI4HHblx
ll
,'IorH-
rlecKux
ocHoBaHl{gx
[epexl{BaeMoro
orIbITa, KaK
3TO nMeeT
MecTo
IIpu
HoMorernqecxoM
noAxoAe,
rrpn
BTopoM
rloAxoAe MbI
crpeMI{Mcg
o6r'g.c-
HHTb
OIIbIT TIOCpeACTBOM
eIO
[peo6pazosanul
B rIoBecTBoBaTeJIbHyIO
crpyKrypy>
[
bpyuep,
2
00
1, c.
1
0
].
llonecrBoBare,llbHa
s' seo6xo
EttMocrb
TeM CaMbIM
TIpIIXOALIT
Ha CMeHy
ycTaHoBJIeHUIO IIpLIr{HHHofi
AeTepMuHa-
uuu.
OAgaro
3Ty
rloBecrBoBareJlbHyto
ueo6xoAl{Mocrb
He
c,'IeAyer ny-
TaTb c
yHuKaJIbHbIM onl{caHlreM.
Bos\,Ioxubl
pa3Hble rIoBecTBOBa1,1.Ug
O6
oAHoM
rI ToM xe.
Kpoue
rofo, KpuTepufi
ncruuHocrv
vJrv JloxHocrlr
K
rroBecTBoBaTeJIbHoMy
o6l.scuenuro
TpyAHo[pI'IMeHUM,
noCKOJIbKy
I{ BbI-
MbIIIIJIEHHbIE
HCTOPI{U
IIOAI{UHgIOTCS
<<TIOBCCTBOBATEJIbHOft
CTP}KT}PC>>,
KaK
H IIoAJIHHHIIe.
TaxnM
o6pa3oM,
peqb kIAer He
o nporllBonocraBJle-
HHr{ onUCaHVIA
V O6"blrcHeHl{fl,
a 06
nC[OIb3oBaHI4tl
IIOBeCTBOBaHI{.g
B
ueJrrx
noHI,rMaHI,Ig.
floHlrlraHne,
cneAyloqee
sa
QaxroM,
<<3I{)KAercg
Ha
I.IHTepIIpeTaqUU>.
He
oTKa3
OT IUIIoTeTUqecKHX
IIcUXOJIST7TIeCKI{X
pe6oH-
crpyxUr,rft
orrnqaer
HoBbIft
noAXoA,
a
4pyroit
TI'In
llcuxoJlorHqecKoro
o6rscHeHu.s
(cro,'Il
xe rI{noTeTI{.IuHfi
n B sToM
cMbIcJIe
HetrpHeMJIeMbIii
Ar.f,
onltcare.nr,uoii
[cnxoJIorHI,I
B
npeAcTaBJIeHl{I{
ee
flunrreeru).
Kay-
3aJIbHoe
o6tqcHeHI,Ie
H rloBecrBoBareJlbHoe,
T.
e.
IIHTepnperallI{oHHoe'
uo
Epyuepy,
crposrc.fl
Ha
pa3Hblx
MeroAax
rIo3HaHHs,
14
HescHo'
Moryr JIL
AJrs
Hr{x
6url nafiAesu
o6ullle
npI,IHI{IrnbI.
fIoeecrsonaHH.fl
[pHAaIor
Sopuy
co6blrl4sM,
noApa3yMeBalor
IIpaBI{JIa,
HopMbr
(n
nosnoxHocrb
HapyueHl{sx
ux). To
ecrb
3ro ue
Qeuoueuono-
zultecrcue
o[ucaHrr.'I.
crcxern
u
nepcoHaxu
co6mrufi
BbIcTy[aIoT
rlpu-
1
3to
eHaKoN{creo
o6ecnequaaer
ny6auraul'ls
crarlu
B. Eapp
[Eapp'
20041
B xypHa,'Ie,
B Ha3BaHI4e
KoToporo
BbIHeceHa
era npo6,renarnra:
<Xypuaa Koltcrpyx-
uuonucrcxoti
rclrxo,rorl4ll
x HapparlrBHoro
fl
oAxoAa>.
9.2. MopSo,rorhLrecKar
h
ahHaMhgecKat napaahrMbl
225
MepaMr{ 6o,ree
o6unx rrrrroB.
3Aecl [peAcraBJrenue
Epyuepa
6olee no-
xoArrr Ha rrorrr{N{aHHe
rrpoflB.rreHus rwrra
B .aBJreHr{H
(ulll
aaroHa),
xax o6
:)ToM
rllrcar'I
"IIesuH.
Ot,rtil.ILte
-
To,
rITo
IIoBecrBoBaHI,IeN{
LI3 I(y"rlbrypbl
n
Ky/rbTypy MoryT TpaHcr'rr.lpoBaTbcrr yHuBepca,'rbHbre
Tunbr
H croi(eTbr.
Ho ero nHa.{
yH14Bepca,'rbHocrb,
r{e\.{
yHuBepcanbHocrb
3aKorroB
,'rorr{\re-
cr{r4x cy}r(AeHlrrt.
flpuvnuHtre o6r'qcrreHlrr
r,ro}KHo
rlepeBecrr{ B
loBecrBo-
Bare,'rbuble, Ho c
norepeii uaua.ra,'rtHbrx
crpyKTyp.
Tarrru o6paaolr,
4nc
paccMorpeHHbre
no3HalametrbHae
napa)uzttat
rB,'rrrorcq He cBoAr,rN,{brN,rr.r
Apyr
K
Apyry,
Ho
cB.tI3aHHbIMIr
NIexAy
co6ol:i.
3aaepuaer cnol.i aua,rue
6pyHep c,'roBaN{r.r,
qro
3To
rpyArro, Ho rrpeArrorrrr4TenbHo
-
oluparbcq
Ha
3rrarrae
o6orrx rrollXolloB.
9.2.
Mop{onorrve
cKaA u
ahHaMrqecKafl napaar.trMbl
f{r.rxorolr
rlx
n'rop@o.torrrvecxori
n
Ar{HaN{uqecKoii
napa4urlrbr orHocr,rrc.q
r(ar
r(
pacKpbrrrto
Bo3r\roxsocreii
AeqreirbnocrHoro
noAXoAa
B rrcnxo.rro-
r-un,
qro
6r,r,ro ctlopuyJrupoBaHo
A. f. Acucl,roBbrM
rr B. A. llerpoBcKrrM
B
ux crarbe
IAcuoron,
flerponcrni'r, 1978], raK
r.r r( 6o,ree urupoxori
npo6-ue-
MC
opr.reHTr{poBKu
rrcnxoJrorurrecKtrx
reopuri Ha aHaJ'n{3
crpyKrypHo
o$op-
r\'rJ'IeHIIbIX
UJ'III
AI4HaI\,IHqeCKUX
KONIIIOIIeIITOB B aKTLIBIIOCTII
qeJ'IOBeKa.
3ra
/tlrxoroMu.rl
tBJIgercs He ro,'rbKo 6o.ree
troa4Heii e N{eroroJrornrl
rrcuxoJro-
luqecror-"I lrayKrr, rro u 6o,ree aApecHo
orrroclrlrori
K r(oMloHeHTaM
TeopIlu,
;r lle HCIIoJIb3yet\{ofo
MeToAa.
V;rce
g
rcHXOJorllu co3HaHu.g crot'Ku"rocb
IIporIIBonocraB,'IeHHe
reo-
prrii,
orcrar.tBalo[lLrx
rro3t,rrdrrrr crpvxTypaJ]rucrcKoro
roHuNranu.q
rrcHXu-
rrrr
(8.
Byu4r) rr
dtl'uxqrrorra,rrblroro
(B.
.l{Neiilrc).
34ecr npu o6rqHocrrr
Nrt:ro,ua
-
rIHTpocneKTI{BHoro
-
orJ'IurlIreM
6rt"{o sI'rAe,'IeHI,Ie
rofo acIIel(Ta
t'y6retcruntrori pea,rrHocrlr,
xoroptti.i
crarroBrr,rrcs rtpeAMeroNr
u3yr{eHI4q.
llyrrar cneAoBa,'r
nroprfoloruqecKoii rpaxTonKe
-
Ho He
AeflTenbrrocrn,
ir co3HaHr.rfl.
nxeiiuc
B cBoeN.r rpyAe <.llprluqunu
flcr{xoJ'ror}ru>
(1890)
l[]cJI
HOBbre or KCaTe.nbHbre
xapaKTeplrcTrrKr,r co3HaHuq,
n03BoJI.grculne
('r'o
ItpeAcTaBIrTb KaK
<<IIoToK>,
HeI]pepbIB]Ioe
ABIr]KeHL{e,
IpeACTaB,'IeH-
rroe
n cy6t,eKTHBHoN{ olbITe
Ka)KAoro
rreJ'roBeKa.
O4HonpeueuHo
c l{Aeer"r
?
lloToKa co3llaHI,Iq> oCylIIeCTBJI9,llaCb
IIOIIbITKa I{CIIO,'Ib3OBaTb
npeACTaB-
./lcuHq
aBonloulroHHoi,i
reoputl
A,rIfl
Tofo,
qro6st
<<rIoHr{Tb
cBt3b
rIcIlx}IKu
('
)Kr{Br,rNt
opra}rrr3Mor\.r, naauuo4eiicTByrotur{Nr
c oKpyxarcuefi
cpe4oli>
I
ll
pouencxnit,
AHqu<pep ona, I97 41.
Euy
yAa,rocb
orpoBeprHyrb
ror{Ky
:rl)cr{Hs
uHTenJreKTya,rtlcroB
o roNr,
r{To
rro3HaHr,Ie orHorrreHnit
npe4no-
.rrillaer
r(aKlIe-To
oco6lte
qHcrble
anrlt.
CoeHaHI{e KaK
ueJloe
BK,'tloqaer
l)('Upe3erlTaur4I{
oAHr,rx npeAN{eToB KaK
/IaHTIbIX
B oTrlotlleHI4H
r(
Apyrnu,
lt
'
t()l
llx