
22.5 The Fischer Determination of the Structure of D-Glucose 1153
22.5 The Fischer Determination of the Structure
of
D-Glucose (and the 15 Other Aldohexoses)
In the following pages, we will approximate the reasoning that led Emil Fischer to the
structure of
D-glucose.The structures of the other 15 aldohexoses can be determined as
we go along. As a bonus, we will also derive the structures of the eight aldopentoses. A
risk in this kind of discussion,which straightens out the actual twisted history of the Fischer
determination, is that the work will seem too easy, too straightforward. Fischer’s papers
appeared in 1891, less than two decades after van’t Hoff ’s (Jacobus Henricus van’t Hoff,
1852–1911, received the first Nobel Prize in Chemistry in 1901) and Le Bel’s ( Joseph
Achille Le Bel, 1847–1930) independent hypothesis of the tetrahedral carbon atom.
Determining stereochemistry was no simple matter, and Fischer’s work depended criti-
cally on a close analysis of the stereochemical relationships of complex molecules.
Moreover, the experimental work was extraordinarily difficult and slow.
5
Fischer’s work
was monumental and remains an example of the best we humans are able to accomplish.
Fischer recognized that it was impossible for him to solve one of the central problems
in this endeavor,the separation of the
D series from the enantiomeric L series. In the 1880s
there was no way to determine absolute configuration,which is hardly surprising given that
the structural hypothesis of the tetrahedral carbon atom was barely 15 years old at the time.
However, Fischer recognized that the 16 aldohexoses must be composed of eight pairs of
mirror images and that if he knew the structures of one set, he automatically could draw
the structures of the mirror-image set.The problem was to tell which was which, and this
he knew he could not do.So, he did the next best thing, he was arbitrary; he just guessed.
The odds aren’t bad, 50:50, and there are times when it is best to accept what is possible
and not give up because a perfect solution to the problem at hand isn’t available.So Fischer
simply defined one set of eight isomers as the
D series, knowing that it might be necessary
for history to correct him. In the event, fortune smiled and he made the right guess. Be
sure that you understand that the correctness of Fischer’s guess wasn’t due to cleverness—
his success was not the result of a shrewd guess or the product of a well-developed intu-
ition; there really was no way to know at the time. He was just lucky.
The Fischer proof starts with arabinose, arbitrarily assumed to be the
D enan-
tiomer. The first critical observation was that the Kiliani–Fischer synthesis applied
to D-arabinose led to a pair of D-aldohexoses (as it must).These were D-glucose and
D-mannose (Fig. 22.44). Because this synthesis must produce a pair of sugars that
5
Here is what Fischer had to say to his mentor, Adolf von Baeyer, about this matter in 1889. “The investiga-
tions on sugars are proceeding very gradually....Unfortunately, the experimental difficulties in this group are
so great, that a single experiment takes more time in weeks than other classes of compounds take in hours, so
only very rarely a student is found who can be used for this work.”
Kiliani–Fischer
synthesis
CH
2
OH
?
OHH
?
?
?
D-Arabinose D-Glucose and D-mannose
share these partial structures
CHO
C
C
CH
2
OH
?
OHH
OHH
??
CHO
C
C
CH
2
OH
??
OHH
HHO
??
CHO
C
C
C(3)
C(2)
C(4)
C(1)
?
+
FIGURE 22.44 The first step in
Fischer’s determination of the
structure of glucose.The
Kiliani–Fischer synthesis applied to
D-arabinose led to D-glucose and
D-mannose, which must share the
partial structures shown.