PROCESS EQUIPMENT IN PETROLEUM REFINING 993
Table 18.24. Comparison of compressor drivers
Available Efficiency Common
Driver HP range speed, RPM % applications
Synchronous motor 100–20,000 3,600 90–97 Reciprocating compressors
Induction motor 1–15,000 3,600 86–94 All types of compressors
Wound rotor induction
motor
– – – Normally not used
Steam engine 10–4,000 400–140 60–80 All types of rotary equip.
Steam turbine 10 to 2,000 2,000 to 15,000 50 to 76 Centrif, axial and recip.
Combustion gas
turbine
3,000 to 35,000 10,000 to 3,600 19 to 24
see note 1
below
All types of compressors
(except recip)
Gas and oil engines 100 to 5,000 1,000 to 300 35 to 45 Reciprocating compressors
Note 1: The efficiency given here does not include for waste heat recovery. With WHR the efficiency can
be increased to between 28 and 35%.
therefore be greater than:
Driver Brake HP =
Max compressor BHP @ the most severe duty
Mechanical efficiency of the power transmission
.
The mechanical efficiency in this case includes for energy losses for bearings, seals,
lube oil etc, in the case of centrifugal compressors and gears in the case of reciprocating
compressors.
Electric motor drivers
Squirrel cage motors are preferred for this type of duty. These may be drip proof open
type where the location is not a fire or explosion hazard. Where it is required that the
units must be explosion or fire proof these motors must be totally enclosed type. In
sizing the motor, efficiencies for squirrel cage motors up to 450 HP given in item 4.6
for pumps may be used. The following Table 18.25 is used for motors above 500 HP.
The driver rated brake horsepower is the compressor horsepower times a load factor
divided by a service factor. Normally the load factor is 10% and a service factor for
an enclosed squirrel cage motor is 1.0 and 1.15 for an open type.
Example calculation
Calculate the Operating Load and the Connected Load for the driver of a 4,000 HP
centrifugal compressor (includes Leakage, Seal, and Bearing losses). A gear is used
and this has a 97% efficiency. The load factor is 10% and the motor is open type
squirrel cage with a service factor of 1.15. There will be a normal operating unit and
a spare, both motor driven.