Walpole administration to flood Ireland with
worthless currency. Because Swift called attention
to this scheme, it was withdrawn, and he became a
national hero.
Swift was also a poet. Two of his most notable
poems are “The Lady’s Dressing Room” (1730) and
“A Beautiful Young Nymph Going to Bed” (1731),
which display an apparent misogyny. Feminist
critic Margaret Doody, however, argues that Swift
was actually more respectful toward women than
many 18th-century writers: “When Swift deals
with the dirty or disagreeable in females, or when
his tone is scolding, he is still urging self-respect,
and he never imposes the injunctions to docility,
obedience, and mental lethargy so commonly re-
peated to women throughout the century.”
Swift’s first major work was A Tale of a Tub
(1704), a wildly experimental satire accompanied
by The Battle of the Books, a more straightforward,
comic piece in which he dramatizes the “ancients
vs. moderns” debate (the hotly contested debate
over whether modern learning had surpassed that
of the Greek and Roman classics) as a literal battle
between ancient and modern books.
Critic Nigel Wood comments that A Tale of a
Tub is “one of the most self-conscious pieces of
writing. The Teller’s desperate desire to please his
readers by incessantly putting them in the picture
so determines the mood of the writing that it
usurps what would seem to be its main function:
to tell a tale.” Before the tale even begins, readers
encounter a parody in the form of a list of other
works by the author, including “A Panegyrical
Essay upon the Number
THREE” and “A general
History of Ears.” The text then goes through
dozens of pages of prefatory material before be-
ginning its ostensible subject, an allegorical story
of three brothers, Peter, Martin, and Jack, who rep-
resent Catholicism, the Church of England, and
Protestant Dissenters, respectively. The narrator
continually strays from his subject, even including
“A Digression in Praise of Digressions.” Swift
scholar Ricardo Quintana has attempted to sum-
marize the text’s main themes: “The two themes of
zeal in religion and of enthusiasm in learning and
knowledge have been inextricably woven into one.”
Norman O. Brown, critic of psychoanalysis, has
analyzed what he terms Swift’s “excremental vi-
sion”: “Any reader of Jonathan Swift knows ...his
analysis of human nature ...becomes the decisive
weapon in his assault on the pretentions, the pride,
even the self-respect of mankind.” Examples of this
can be found in almost all of Swift’s writings, but is
perhaps most pronounced in his poetry. His early
poem “Description of a City Shower” (1710)
vividly portrays the filth of urban living: “Sweep-
ings from Butchers Stalls, Dung, Guts, and Blood,
/ Drown’d Puppies, stinking Sprats, all drench’d in
Mud, / Dead Cats and Turnip-Tops come tumbling
down the Flood.” In “The Lady’s Dressing Room”
Swift humanizes a poetic nymph by revealing what
goes on behind the scenes of a lady’s boudoir.
Strephon is disgusted to learn that “Celia, Celia,
Celia shits!” but the moral of the poem seems to be
that this is only natural: “Such Order from Confu-
sion sprung, / Such gaudy Tulips rais’d from
Dung.”
In his later writings, Swift became concerned
about the condition of the Irish people, most fa-
mously in “A Modest Proposal” (1729), which is
also a masterpiece of irony. Taking on the persona
of a “projector,” he proposes a novel and strikingly
satirical solution to Irish poverty and famine:
I have been assured by a very knowing Ameri-
can of my Acquaintance in London; that a
young healthy Child, well nursed, is, at a Year
old, a most delicious, nourishing, and whole-
some Food; whether Stewed, Roasted, Baked, or
Boiled; and, I make no doubt, that it will
equally serve in a Fricasie, or a Ragoust.
His ironic intentions reveal themselves by the
end of the essay. The projector lists a series of other
solutions, including taxing absentee landlords and
buying Irish rather than imported goods, but dis-
misses them: “let no Man talk to me of these and
the like Expedients; till he hath, at least, a Glimpse
Swift, Jonathan 279