FROM LOUIS XIV TO NAPOLEON
208
strength did not prevent the arrival of six battalions in Canada in 1755, two in 1756, two in
1757 and another two in 1758. Numbers were not the issue when the British attacked
Martinique in 1759. They rapidly retreated in the face of a local militia able to take effective
advantage of the difficult local terrain. Nevertheless the exceptionally large resources devoted
to the struggle in Canada by the British in 1758–60 stacked the odds against New France.
37
After the war, France was very much in the position of challenger, but, unlike after the
Wars of the Spanish and Austrian Succession, she was helped by close relations with Spain.
Thanks to much shipbuilding in the late 1760s and 1770s, especially by Spain, then one of
the most dynamic states in Europe, France and Spain combined had a quantitative superiority
in naval tonnage over Britain of about 25 per cent by 1780.
Partly as a result, when conflict resumed in the War of American Independence, the
British were unable to repeat their success of the Seven Years’ War. Their navy gained control
of neither European nor American waters, and in 1778 was unable to defeat the French before
Spain entered the war. The British concentration of naval strength on defending home waters
enabled the unblockaded Toulon fleet to sail to American waters. In 1779, when France and
Spain sent a fleet into the Channel, their attempt to invade Britain was thwarted by disease
and poor organization, not British naval action. It was not until the Battle of the Saintes on
12 April 1782 that there was a decisive British naval victory to rank with Quiberon Bay in
1759, and it was a testimony to the rising importance of colonies and transoceanic operations,
and the British failure to maintain an effective blockade, that this battle was fought in the
Caribbean, south of Guadeloupe, not in European waters. In 1782, the British were concerned
about a possible Bourbon attack on Jamaica, not – as in 1759 – with blocking an invasion of
Britain.
Naval strength was crucial to colonial operations in the War of American Independence.
Besieged British positions that were relieved, such as Gibraltar, were held, while those that
were not relieved, such as Yorktown in 1781, were lost. French success in blockading the
Chesapeake in 1781 was crucial to the course of the war in North America, and is a reminder
of the limitations of assuming any structural determinism in eighteenth-century military
history, not least of arguing from total fleet size and the supporting political, administrative
and financial infrastructure, to inevitable results. The British navy was more successful in
helping prevent the overthrow of the British position in India. Bussy had far fewer troops
than the 10,000 men he had requested in 1778, in part because of the ships that were
prevented from sailing or were intercepted by the British navy. Had Bussy reached India, as
Rochambeau did America in 1780, without delay, with healthy troops and with all his
artillery, he would have been more likely to achieve his objectives, not least because Suffren
was a better naval commander than de Grasse, his counterpart off North America.
Without assured naval dominance, the articulation of the British military system was
weak and the success of the individual parts limited, but the loss of British dominance did