Звягельская И.Д. (ред.) Проблемы и перспективы урегулирования на Ближнем Востоке
Подождите немного. Документ загружается.
2010
! .
.: ; , 2010, 190 "#$.
%&#'( %$ %$)* "#
+ , -*"./$& (+)
*'#( %$*# #(0 .*
#$ *
#'#"#',0 $*#$ .. 1'2&(3"*2
*#$ .. "#-&
"0 2009 & ' "*' ""#2("3 $ "-
$/0 &$%%, % %$/(.. /()'"#&
$&($'2, $&' +. ,
-*"./$&. "#240 "/$* '5( "##3 '#$',
.-46"2 0 %$/(.#*0. /")2 .&
"%*#, "#7 (). "#*, '#$, ."#-
$$-# $(, %6, * %$/(.. $$52
*8(*#,6 "#70 ' '". "6) #* $2,
*#$, .&# %$"#'(2#3 #$" ** (2 "%7(-
"#', #* (2 5$*& *$& ##(0.
%/(*', .#$(, #$)-# #* $2
6 '#$', *#$, /2#(3 "'%-# " %6-
. $*'#(0 %$*# $*#$.
ISBN: 978-5-93660-082-1
© #$ "#$#&"*6 %(#"*6 ""('0, 2010
3
!
/.. / ..........................................5
..
!
–
1! 1
..........................................................................7
..
«
1
-
»
:
99
1 !
+
.......................................................................16
.. !"#$!
-
19 +
:
1
................................................... 42
.. %$
!
9 9
.............................................52
.. $
-
19 +
:
1! 9
? ......................................... 65
..
1
1967 &. ..................................................................90
4
. &'()*
: 19 1; <
9 : !
....... 120
Shlomo Brom
CAN WE GET THE MIDDLE EAST PEACE PROCESS OUT OF ITS
PRESENT STAGNATION
?..................................................... 143
Abdel Nour
SYRIA
'
S ROLE IN THE PEACE PROCESS IN THE MIDDLE EAST
.
IS SYRIA THE CENTER OF THE WORLD
?................................ 149
Mossi Raz
THE ROLE OF RUSSIA AND THE EUROPEAN UNION
IN THE MIDDLE EAST
.
WHY SHOULD EUROPE AND RUSSIA
HAVE A ROLE IN THE MIDDLE EAST
? ................................... 160
Elias Samo
ARAB
-
ISRAELI PEACE PLANS
:
A SYRIAN PERSPECTIVE
.......... 167
Dr. Arne C. Seifert
“
UNION FOR THE MEDITERRANEAN
”
–
A ZONE OF DOUBLE
SECURITY STANDARDS
...................................................... 181
.................................................... 188
5
$(&.,0 ##(- "/$* "##0 % %$/(-
.. /()'"#& $&($'2 2'(2#"2 $(3-
##. /")0, %$6'56 ' $.*6 $/0 &$%-
%, % (). "#*, $&',6 #$. "#$-
#&"*6 %(#"*6 ""('0 (""2) ' "-
#$"#' " +. , -*"./$& (+). /2
&$%%, *#$2 '*(-( %$"#'#(0 "',6 "#-
$, ''(,6 ' /()'"#,0 *8(*#, /"%-
( "'/, #$"' #'$"* /")-
/( "#$,6 %$/(., %$%2#"#'-46 "#)-
- .$.
(& %$"#'(2( "/0 % "4"#' %%,#* $&-
#$' #*$,#3 '.)"# (2 «%$(((30 -
%(.#», %$".#$'-40 ',$/#* $*.70
%$()0 (2 "#*' /()'"#& *'$#-
# $&(3,6 %"$*'.
.. "##0, #$)-46 ',"#%(2 %"$-
"#',6 "#*' $/0 &$%%,, ' "/$* /,( $-
5 '*(-#3 #*) "*(3* $/# "%7("#', %
$,. %$ "#'''5. ' /")26, -
'"#,6 "'. $&(3,. ")2. %6..
.#"2, (). "#* %" .&, ,
'$2#, /()'"#,0 *8(*# 4 (& %$-
"## /,#3 %$.#. %$"#(3& #$" %(#*',
,6, )$("#'. "/$* %$"#'(, $/#,
#6, $&6 #$#36, # #(# & # %$',,6
%/(*70, #* ** %'(2# '#3 # ) %$-
6
/(., % $,. &(. $2 – '&(2 "#7-
" #* $2 %(#*' "##"2 ' . " ,.
(. )$("#"*. 7%*. '.. * #(2.
'"#2..
, %(&., # 2 %/(*72 /# %( (2
'"6, *# .#"2 %$/(.. ()& "#*, ',$-
/#,'# "#$#&- $&($'2 # %$"62-
4 %$7"",. '" "'$., #7 %((
"'4 ' %/(*.,6 "##326, *)- 6 #(-
# "'0 "/,0 %6, $&(32 #$*#'* ','-
,. .), *#$, 6 %*)#"2 *.-# "%$-
,.. . ' =#. *(-("3 &(',6
+, '56 "#$# /")2. '%$". /()-
'"#& $&($'2 ' $.*6 $/0 &$%%,. ,
%,#("3 '/#3 "'50"2 ' %"( '$.2 #-
$" * /()'"#. *8(*#, ','#3 "%$,, 4-
%#3 '.)"# ',6 %6', ' *#$,6 #* )-#-
"2 '" "#$, $, ()& "#*.
."2, # 2 %/(*72 %()# ( $-
&(2$,. 2. .#$(' % '%$". /()'-
"#& $&($'2.
$*#$ "### '"#*'2
$# ,
..., %$8. .. .*
7
..
! –
1!
1
""0"*2 %(.#2 ' "#24 '$.2 %$'&#
- %$'2 ' "*' '0 '"#$ " "#. '"6
"#$, "%$"#,6 * %"*. .$ (). "#-
*, ' 7(26 «%$%"*» %$&'$& %$7"". $-
&. "('., $3 # #., #/, %'#$#3 – #%$3
) ' ',6 "('26 – #, # /,( "4"#'(
' $ ' 1991 &., %# '7#3 (# .
=#. *#*"# %$'.$ %"#'#3 ' *(--
',6 '%$", #" "'2,6 .) "/0:
1. . %$, #%*' ' /()'"#.
$&($'? (32 %$#3 ## 8*#, # "#$#-
&2 #*#* 0"#'0, ** $"%(),6 "3 "#$, #*
.)$& "/4"#' ' 7(. ' *(-',6 /(*6
/"%2 /%""# ' $&, %$"# )(.,6
$(3##';
2. # **$# .) /,( /, %$()#3 (2 #&,
#/, ','"#, *7, $& %$.#0 %$2-
)"# *8(*#'?
# *"#"2 %$'& '%$", # 5 '&(2, "',
%$, '$5"# /()'"#& .$& %$-
7"" .) /,( /, 6$*#$'#3 "(-4. /$..
$7 *(-',. «*8(*#,. $(..»
(). "#* (& '$.2 /,( %$2# "##3
8
$/-$(3"* %$#'"#2. * "&25-
0 3 %() ( ' $& #(3 .("3
"4"#' #(#"2 # #&, # /,( 6$*#$
(2 %$5"#'-46 "2#(#0. #72 '*$& $-
, '0 ' $*, /,"#$ '( «*8(*#& %-
#7(» #$$#$ "#$#&"*& %$"#$"#'
8$*"*& & (.(, =8%-=$#$0"* %$#-
'"#2), $"%()& ' %"$"#'0 #$$#-
$(30 /("# # ()& "#*, #(3 "-
()2-# "('2, ' *#$,6 %$"62# %"* «"#$-
"*& *.%$.""» .) $(. $/"*. &-
"$"#'.. *, ( 2'(0 $(3"*6 %(#-
"*6 ',6 2#(0, #$)-46 «5*( /-
"#0» ' "8$ 7(30 /%""#, "'-
#(3"#'# #., # «2$, $*#, ./7» -
&$ '(-# $(3#2 .35, . "#72
' 1%. /$& $.
#. =#& %$"#'(2#"2 /6.,. % -
'. "8$.($'#3 %'"#* 2 "%"* %#7(3-
,6 "#*' «%$%"*» /()'"#& .$-
& %$7"". .. $/-$(3"*& *8(*#,
/") (), /,#3 '," #* '%$",, **
«$"* "3», «$*"* "3», /"#'*, "*(,-
'-42"2 ' "%$(3,6 "/$&6 ($" .$,
8$*"*0 &). "#"#', =# #(3 "()-
# %&#'* 8$., «#2)(#» %'"#* 2. *
0 %#3 – $"".#$ #(3* $/-$(3"*6
'.#50 – ' #$,' # $&6 «""#'(2-46»
$&(30 /%""# – #%$3 %$"#'(2#"2 '-
. «),.».
#*, %$ %&#'* '0 '"#$ ' "*' % '-
%$". /()'"#& $&($'2 ' %$'- -
$3 "(# "&("'#3 "%"* "#*', #*)
#.#"*0 &&$8"*0 "%*#, %$"#240
9
*8$7. "3. '),. %$"#'(2#"2 '.0-
"#' =#. %$'( .) %$"#'#(2. "-
"0"*0 +$7 '$%0"*6 "#$.
$&0 ',0 "%*# $&(30 "#7 ""#-
# ' /6."# "#'('#3 %$.(., #-
52 " $*'"#'. $*(3,6 &$%%$'*, $(3
'(2 *#$,6 ' %"( &, $"##. "6 %$
"(2 =#. %$'( /,( "##,.,
' #. "( '"("#' '2("# %%,#*, %$%$-
..,6 %(.#"*. 8$#, #"#"#'2 *-
*6-(/ %#',6 $(3##' ' %"*6 .$,6
$'2* /()'"#& *8(*#. 2 #*6 &$%-
%$'* %(( "## ',"*- "#%3 (&#.-
"# ' $(3## %$',6 ',/$'. /(
'),0 %$.$ =#& $ – "( %(#"*&
'" '(22 .
", # $(3 "#( 87(3,6 %$&'$'
" %/& $ $*(3,. &$%%$'*-
. "2#.
."# " #. "#$, *8(*#, ' #. "( $-
(3#2, %"#2 ','&-# %$(, #$/'2
* , /(( $&. &$%%$'*., #. ".,.
%$'2 -8*# 6 .- $(3 ' %$"624..
=#. *#*"# '"## '%$", ' **6 8$.6 .)
/,( /, /"%#3 %$'( #*& $ $&-
70 * ',$/#* *.%$."",6 $50.
$"#'(2#"2 $("#,. "#'#3 '%$" %$-
$'& "##" "#*' /46 %$&'$'
&"$"#'. $& '-%(#"*. $&72.
$*(3& #(*. "( =#& ". '"#$ .) /,-
( /, $&'#3 ' ' «'6>2$"&» .$%$2#2.
(%$', "#* %$&'$' – &"$"#'
.)$, ($&(3,) $&7 (),
/,( /, .#3 '.)"#3 %$'2 $/#, % «#$-
10
7,.» "6.. – %($, "2, "2
'.),6 %$/(.,6 &$%% #.%. # *"#"2 %$-
'#(3"#',6 $&70 />0, ' #. "(
'-%(#"*6 &$%%$'*, # .&( /, /-
$'#3 "'/$,0 «)0 2$"» %$&'$&
%$7"" ' ' /4"#'-%(#"*6 «**"'»,
& ',$/#,'("3 /, %6, * /").,. %$/(-
.., *#$, /# $"".#$'#3"2 ' 6 "0
%(%$',6 "#*' '"#$.
$&0 '$# – %$. #* ,'.0 «"-
"*0 8$.(,» %$&'$' ' #5 %$"#'#(0
$*(3,6 &$%%$'*, &#',6 "#''#3 ' .$.
%$7"". "%(3' =#& '$# %.&( /, /-
)#3 "#70, *#$, %$.(., (2 $(3#2,
#*) *#$,6 $&6 $&('. ."# " #., .)
/,( /, «' $). $(3& '$.» '#3 $*7-
'"3. '(2#(3,6 "#$ .-46"2 *8(*#,6 «"-
%$2)0» /")., %$()2.
"#"#', #*0 %$2* %$'2 *8$7
() ' %$'$#(3. %( /,#3 "&("' " '".
%#7(3,. "#*. %$&'$& %$7"".
$#0 '%$", #$/-40 "'& $52, – =#
%&#'* *7%7 '"#$ %$*#' *.#',
*#$, 0 .&# /,#3 %$2#,.
$6#"2 *"##$'#3, # ' "#24 '$.2
$/# % =#. *(-'. – «"/"##'.» – -
%$'(- %$*#"* '#"2. $5( ) "*(3-
* (# %"( %/(*'2 «$)0 *$#,». (-
"#3- %#$2( "'- *#(3"#3 '$., %$.#$,,
*, ' =#. *.#. ."# " #., "#( "-
'$5 ',. #, # *7%72, ()2
' «$)0 *$#», )#"2 ' *$. %$".#$
%$' ' "#'#"#' " $(2. "&25&
2. . =#. *.# () /,#3 $$/#
11
',0. & '. .&( /, "##3: «"', %$-
7%, /()'"#& $&($'2».
#/, "*$#3 %$ %&#'* #*& $ *-
.#, "('( /, "#3 '#$##- '".-
%$'#(3"#'- &$%% =*"%$#', *#$2 %$"#-
'( /, – ' "## «%$'#.» ' – "#'#"#-
'-40 %$*# *.# $"".#$ 87(3,6
(&70 "#$.
$(((3 %#$/'("3 /, #(3, "(2
% ( '# %""# . "6 %$ .)-
$-%$2 $.#'2 / /()'"#&
$&($'2 % "4"#' &$'#"2 (53 $-
(-72. 242 338, *#$, "$)# "8$.($',
' ".. /4. ' $#$, .$& %$7"". (32
/(35 *$,'#3 &( #, # =# *.#, /,(
%$2#, ' "'". $&- =%6, *& ""#. $&-
(3,6 .)$,6 *$# *$,. /$.
#(("3 # "&250. "' .$& $&($-
'2 () ()#3 '.%$.(. $5 %$-
/(., "'2,6 " ()4. /"%. /-
"#0 ' "8$ /%""# '"6 "#$, ''(*.,6
' .$,0 %$7"".
1967 &. "/- $(3 ' %&#'* %$*# $(--
7 242 ",&$( /$#"*2 %(.#2. & "#72
6$*#$'("3 (. "$3,6 %$#'$0 %
( '6 "%$$)' %$#'"#246 '-
%(#"*6 /(*'. %$3 =## 8*#$ 5( ' %$-
5(. .-#"2 '.)"# ',$/#* "'."#0 $"-
"0"*-.$*-'$%0"*0 7#',. (2 =#&
"('( /, ** .) «%(#» &$#3 «*'$##»,
*#$,0 ' %"( &, '# "/2 #*$' '2(,
/,7#', ' "'. (53 $&$2 %$"6-
24 "/,#2. ) /,( /, %$'(3 * & 2#(3-
"# "%7("#' ',"*& $'2.
12
'3 %$6#"2 &'$#3 #., # $5-4-
$(3 ' %"* *.%$.""' (),, /"(', &$#3
"#$,, %$2. ''(, ' *8(*#. (#3 6
$/#, "'2- " "/(). %70 "#$, .-
)# *#. * 8*#. "##"2 #, # .)-
$, %"$* 5( %* «*(-» (2 %$'
/()'"#& *8(*# – ' '"6 & "',6 «"-
"#'(2-46» – ' "#- $&($'2.
=#. *#*"# "(# #*) #.##3, # ' -
"#24 '$.2 "(/ "%(3-#"2 '.)"# #* -
,'.& «%$(((3&» %$&'$& %$'(2,
..& &(0"*. 2,* «track two».
1 ' "2#(#2, %$556 %"( $"*0
*8$7, ',2'("3, # .&, *("3 /,, "#-
# (&, "6., '$#, $'2*, /()'-
"#. %$'( «"$/#,'-#».
*, (* ' %(0 .$ %$'("3 ),
"%(3' *87(3,6 *(' ',$/#*
$50. &(52 «"(-1», «"(-2», .)# /,#3,
0"#'#(3 (& /,( $$/##3 '( # )$(-
"#' '(2 $(,6 /4"#'-%(#"*6
"(. * ' (305. "#&#, &'$"#
«'"(», 62 %$)* "$ .4,6 «7#$'
"(,» ** ' $(, #* ' "# %("#7' $/'
' 7(..
?## $* "('( /, ' %(0 .$ "'#3
' (305. (#3 "#'* 87(3,, #*$,#,
%$&'$,. $(((3 ') /,( /, /#3"2 $"-
5$2 '.)"#0 (2 '(22 %$&'$,0
%$7"" " "#$, %$"#'#(0 «(&$2 .$» –
' $(, ' $26 %("#7', $/'. 1"3 .#"2
.( $/$,6 $"$"', *#$, .) /,( /,
0"#''#3. ?#, * %$.$, .)%$#0, "'2, *-
#*#, % ( ,6 )$("#"*6 *$&' #.%.
13
4 '),0 ..#.
«+$.(» .$& %$7"" (). "#*, "-
&("'2 ' 1991 &. ' "%"*0 "#(7, %$%(&(
"# %($,6 "0 *8$7 '"#-
$6 «#$*'». $ =#. $2 (&70, ' #. "( "-
'#"*2, "6( #&, # %($,0 8$.# .#
"'& $ %$$## . ' 6 %($,6 "0
/# #'$)#3"2 &'$"#, "#&#, ' $-
(3## %$2.,6 '"#$6 *#*#' %$&'$'.
(305., *, %($, "2 «',6-
("3», %$"#( ",'#3"2. '# %5( % '-
"#$. #$*. – " $0 "*$"#3- " $,. $-
(3##.. #& – $/("$'* '"& .$& %$-
7"". $ =#. ') %$*#3, # /,( /, *$-
$*# ','#3 «"#)2» '"#$& 8$.#
%$&'$' %%" .$& &'$ .) $-
(. $0. /6. %$#3, # *#*#,
.) =#. "#$. 5( #-3 % =&0 -
$"*& %$&'$& %$7"", "&/ ' '"#$-
. %(.
/4., ' "( '/'( /()'"#-
& .$& %$7"", ') /,( /, '""#'#3 -
%($,6 "0.
4 $* %$556 (# – ' .&. )( "-
/2 %$7% «$/(2» =#%, %$&'$& %$7"-
" (=# #"#"2, %$) '"&, * %("#-$(3-
"*. #$*). **0-# %$ ("#$# %$&'$&
.$8) "%(3' =#& .# '2 ( .(
".,"(, #* ** %.&( «"#3» "#$, "#( %$-
&'$'. *, ' %$ %&#'* $"*0 *8-
$7 ' 1991 &. %$ 8$.($' .$& %$-
7"" %("#-$(3"*. %$'( /,( $5
%$'#3 '#$0 =#% %$&'$' /( #$-
$$5., %$/(., (/)7,, /4 $"(.,
14
*#(3,0 "##" %("#"*6 #$$#$0 #.%.)
* %"#2 %$*(,' « %#.» %$7-
%(3,6 '%$"' /()'"#& $&($'2
'( $*(. %' #'$)#3, # .$,0 %$7""
«' "( "'0 %$$,» «"#,6 .$0 "#$»
2*/, .)# %$'"# * $5- *$,6 %$/(.
$&($'2, # (53 «.#$#» ') * .-
$. ' "$ %("#7', ' (&$ $(3#2 ' "#2-
4 '$.2 $-#"2 &(", #$/-4 $>2"#3, ' *-
*. %$'( # .$,0 %$7"". ' #*& %-
()2 '" /(35 "#( 44#3"2 %#$/"#3 '"#
%$("#3 ' %$.#$, *,6 &'$"#0.
" =# /"#2#(3"#' /6. "#3 %$ %$-
( .(3"#0 «%$%"*» .$"*& .$-
& %$7"" – #%$3 ) ' *"#' '. – «."-
*'"*.» 8$.#.
*. '2#"2 %# %' * '0 .)$0
*8$7 % (). "#*?
$) '"&, "(# "8$.$'#3 "'& $
«7#'- &$%%» % %$%"* .$& %$7"".
«#'$*» .)$,6 %"$*' '$2 ( ".-
)# "(#3 =# . "(2 (), /,#3 %(-
, $&(3,. =(.#.. ?# .&( /, /,#3 #*
"#$,, ** &%# (*$%052 "#$ $/"*& .$,
«%$» .$,6 %$&'$' " $(.), '"*2
$'2 ('#$ «$/"*0 .$0 7#',» 2002 &.,
'.),0 '40 $ .$%$2#0 % "#'(-
.$ ' $&), $2 ("#$, .-42 (#(3,0
' 7(. "%5,0 %,# *#*#' " $(3#2.).
«7#'2 &$%%» .&( /, '2#3 "/2 #'#-
"#'"#3 %&#'* %'"#* 2 "/"##',6
*.#' (2 /40 *8$7.
$(((3 "#( /, «%"##3» .6. 5$-
*& /4"#'-%(#"*& (& " "#.
15
%$"#'#(0 "#$ %$#'"#22. (3 – "
/( /(&%$2#& %(#*-%"6(&"*& *(.-
# (2 $&7 %$&'$& %$7"" "#)2
#&',6 &'$"#0, #*) "# ' $$/#*
*.#', *#$, /# %(), ' "' $50
*8$7.
) /,( /, %$%$2#3 4 %%,#* $-
.$'#3 .&"#$0 %$7"" ' ' 2#(3"#
% .350 .$ #,$6 $/6 &$%% – % *#$(-
'$)2. $&(30 /%""#, % '-
,. $"$"., % /)7., % =*."*. '%$"..
"/ .-# 8*#$, %(#*-%"6(-
&"*& 6$*#$. /6. 8$.$'#3 /4"#-
' . ' "#$6 $& ' %(3 /,"#$05&
6)2 *.%$.""' ' $&($' %$6
* "#$#(3"#' '&, .$& "#/(3& ()&
"#*. "%(), "3 "#$, "#$"* #-
-3 #"("3 * &$%% . $'#,6 &"-
$"#'. * 8*#. "##"2 #, # ' %"( "2-
#(#2 =## /(&#,0 – " #* $2 "'& %#-
7( – $0 .$ $''#"2 #(3 . -
., ., * %$.$, $0 ; &-"#0 , ,
& %2'("3 ', .4, "#$(3, &"$"#-
' *$(3 .("3 * (5. "('2 )
"'0 "# "(2 '6246 ' & "#$.
$(.#3 &#', =*."* #7
(). "#* .) /# #(3* ' "('26 "#-
'(2 .$ ' $&. " =#& – .4,0
8*#$, "%"/"#'-40 "%6 $(7 %(' '-
/'(2 %$&'$& %$7"" " 7(3- "2
"#/(30 ""#., $&(30 /%""#.
16
..
«1 -» :
99 1
! +
( XXI '. #$"8$.72 %("#-$(3-
"*& *8(*#, 6$*#$-42"2 $"#. $( "(.-
"*& 8*#$, #*) $"#. #22 ' .""6
%$7"". $*(7, /"('('# '*'
',6 &$*' ' %(#"*. %$"#$"#' ("#,.
%"( 3–4 & %("#"*6 #$$#$26 *$%-
("3 «$#2 "(."*& "'/)2» («/ #-6$$
(3-"(.0»), 2#(3"#3 *#$0 "#'#"2 '" /-
( .#0, 6#2 '#$0 "#$*#$ ($6
'"# .&.
$%",(* (2 $"# %%(2$"# $&7,
%$,'-40 * '""#'(- "(."*& 6(8#,
"#( *(,'#3"2 4 ' 1990- &&., /(&%$2#,
"('2 (2 $'#2 "8$.$'("3 . ' %-
"( &,. ("#-$(3"*0 .$,0 %$7"",
%$'50 * /$'- ("#"*0 7(30
."#$7 (( ("#"*0 '#.) ' 1994 &.,
#8 (3-*", '52"2 ' "#2/$ 2000 &.,
$5( '%$", 7(3& ".%$(2 %-
("#"*& $, "2 & '".& &"$-
"#' $$52 %("#-$(3"*& *8(*#.
! "#* .$,, %$%$2#, $(. ' #'# '#-
$- #8, ' "/"# "#$#(3"#' $(-
17
#(3& /$3$, %$624& % **%$',. %-
("#"*. #$$#$2. 1%& /$& $. $,
%$'( * #., # '""# ' 2004 &. ',6("3.
2/$ #& ) & "*("2 ($ ("#"*&
')2 "%$#'(2 () ')2 "'/)-
("#, (+) "$ $8#. 6. #*0
#(30 %(#"*0 8&$, /"#$("2 *$",
%$)'.,0 ("#"*0 '#.0. /$,0
' 2'$ 2005 &. %"# %$# "$#* . $-
8# 6. //", 6#3 2'(2#"2 %,#,. %(#-
*., /(# 6$.0 %$5"#'*, %'-
(2'50 #. $''5'#3 =88*#'-
"#3 +. '. %$# ("3 /#3"2
(52 "7(3-=*."*6 %*#(0 ' -
("#, "(/#3 $(3"*0 **%7,0 $).,
%$'"# $8$., ' "8$ %$'(2 '#.0, "-
*$#3 *$$%7- #.%. *. /$., /42
+ )2 %("#7', ** ' '#$0, #*
' '50 %(#*, *("3 $(',..
(',0 **$# + "( %("#"*6 $-
&70 – ') "(."*& "'/)2 (),
" *7 1980-6 &&. %$.'5 *#' "# ' %$-
#'"#2 " $(., ' /4"#'-%(#"*0
"7(3-=*."*0 ) '#., ' '$.2
%$'(2 . $8# '$)'("3 # "#2 ' $/-
# 87(3,6 $&' '("#, "#2 6 "#3- **-
%70 %(#* $(2. 2004–2005 &&.
%(( '.)"#3 "##3 %(#"*0 "(0, $'0
% '(2- +. 6 ) . $8# "(/(
"'#"* $&7, ='*72 '$0"*6 %"(0
',' $(3"*6 '0"* "*#$ ' '&"# 2005 &.
' &(6 .&6 %("#7' ',&(2( ** $(3## %-
$''50 "/2 '$)0 /$3/, %$#' *-
*%7. "# " #"#"#'. "%6' ' 2#(3-
18
"# ."#$7 . //" =# 8*#$, /"%(
%/ ',/$6 ' ("#"* *-
#(3 "/$ ' 2'$ 2006 &.
%"(-4 %(#$ & ("#"*2 '#-
.2 %$)'( &(/*0 '#$%(#"*0 "7-
(3-=*."*0 *$". "%"/"#3 +
"#3 *.%$.""' % '%$". $( '(-
"#, %(#* ' #5 $(2, '.,6 "#%*,
#*) )( %$2#3 #$/'2 .)-
$& "/4"#' #"#(3 %$2 "#&-
#,6 $ %("#-$(3"*6 .$,6 &'$-
"#0 #6 # '$)0 /$3/, – ' #& ',(("3
' *$'%$(#, "#(*'2 ' "*#$ ' .–
- 2007 &. / ' 6 $)( "(."#,, "'-
5 #$$#$ *(' (3#$#' %("#"*
%$'#(3"#'.
6$'5 '("#3 1%,. /$&. ')
+ ' *7 2007–2008 &&. %%,#("3 "#3 .$-
& $&($'2 " $(3"*. %$'#(3"#'. ?6
(3.$#, %$"#'(2'5. 7#$"#"*- %$#- -
., .$, %$&'$, '("3 "%6. -
"(/"# /6 "#$ &#'"# * "#%*..
10 8'$(2 2009 &. ' $( ""#2("3 %$(.#-
"* ',/$,, % #&. *#$,6 %$"#(3 %$'0
%$# * 32. #326 "8$.$'( %$'-
#(3"#', *#$ %$"#%( * $/# 1 %$(2. %$-
6. * '("# ' $( %(#*' %$'& (&$2
.$,0 %$7"" %$*$#("2. ',0 $(3"*0 %$-
.3$-."#$ %"#'( ' &(' &( /"% /-
%""# "#$,. ."# #$$#$(3,6 "#%* %-
("#7. "2 '".& %("#"*& &"-
$"#' . #326 %$()( ""$##3"2 /$3/
" #$$$.. " )"%"/0 %("#"*0
=*.*.
19
*. /$., ' %"( &, #(3 "(
%("#7' *("3 $$' ** ' +, #*
' , *#$, ".&( "#3 "&("2 ' '-
%$"6 "'."#& %$'(2 ("#"*0 '#.-
0, $&($'#3 *8(*# " $(., "#3
'". &"$"#'. *#$, %("#7, %$62#
* .,"(, # ' "#24 '$.2 =# $&7 /(-
-# "##,. "(. '.)"#2. (2 $5-
2 %("#"*0 %$/(., ** $ %$&'$, " -
$(. (%72 +), #* %#. '$)0 /$3-
/, ' "# " %$&'$. (%72 ). (
#&, ' &(6 .&6 %("#7' $/"*0 .$ %$'2-
4 (). "#* "'#"* $).,, "#$-
-4 " 1%., #*) "%"/, "4"#' %-
.3 . ' "#) %"#'(,6 7(0. #& ' -
("# '*( /(&%$2#2 "#72 (2 2#(3-
"# .)$,6 "(."#"*6 $&70.
%*, ' *#$,0 5( .$,0 %$7"", *$"
' "#'(2# %("#7', ** =# *$# %$-
"6( %$#2) '"0 "#$ *8(*# " -
$(., "*#3 '" ', "%"/, $52 %$/(.. ?#
%$'( * $"# %%(2$"# $*(3& "(..
«/ #-6$$». $&72 /,( " 1%-
. /$& $. $, '6'5. ' ""#' $
1967 &., ' $(3## $"*( $"*6 «$#3'-
."(3.» ' 1953 &. 1956 &. «%$#2» /,( %$4,
#* ** , ' #( # «/$#3'», /,( "#$
"#$"#' " $"*. '("#2., #$7( (&-
#."#3 $"*0 .$6 %$,'( * "-
/>& "(."*& &"$"#'.
*7 XX '. «/ #-6$$» %$)( '$)-
, $"%$"#$'5"3 ' /( . 40 &"$"#'6,
' *#$,6 %$)'-# %"('#( "(. – # '"#$-
(, ; &-"#0 #$(30 '$0
20
8$*, 1%0 '$%, :. "( ".$# "'-
#(2 %$# * - -/6 &('0 $&-
7 "#( &$) $ %("#7 % %$"6-
)- /(3 . 1((., ' 2003 &. & ".(
$"*0 %("#7 # / 5#.
(&"*2 %(#8$. =#0 $&7 %$-
".#$'# /6."#3 '""#'(2 "(."*&
6(8#, *#$,0 "4"#''( " VII '. 1924 &., *&
/,( (*'$' #$7*. ($. "#80 .(.
(##-$*.), "'/) ."(3."*0 .., #
"#$& '(22 ' '"6 /("#26 (%(#"*0,
"7(3-=*."*0, *(3#$0). *) «/ #-
6$$» %$,'# * "#$&. "('- 5$# '
'"6 "8$6 ) &"$"#', /4"#' #(30
("#. "" 6(8#, % .- (&'
$&7, '.) /(&$2 '- %$%&"#-
*0 $/#, – "(."*& %$,' (´'), %$/$'-
- /4"#' ". «%$',6» %$'#(0. 0
/2"#0 /4& 6(8 "## $"%$"#$-
"(. %#. .""$"*0 2#(3"# '2
"'240 '0, %$#' '$,6 ()6).
#* $2 «/ #-6$$», ' "#24 '$.2
"#$ ."(3."*& .$ 2'(2#"2 "-
# "(."*. &"$"#'., # #"#"2 * .
*. /$., ("#"*2 '#.2 $"".#$'#"2
** «//),0 $).», "# ' %$#"*6
%$(.#"*6 ',/$6 ' '#., % .- $&-
7, %"#..
(&"*2 2#(3"#3 «/ #-6$$» ' -
("# "6 " $/#0 ' $&6 "#$6. $%'-
* '$)'-#"2 # %$,'' * '$)0 /$3/,
(2 *7#, %$) '"&, «'#$. )6»,
#* ** ')05. %$'(. (2 $&7 2'(2-
#"2 . %$/$' /4"#', #, ' "'- -