Звягельская И.Д. (ред.) Проблемы и перспективы урегулирования на Ближнем Востоке
Подождите немного. Документ загружается.
41
*.%$."" $5 %("#-$(3"*& *-
8(*#. (, (&"*0 $/#, *#'"#' «%$-
#» .&# %$2'#3"2 "$, #* ** *#$-
7- "(2, '"%# '& %*(2 "'6 "#-
$*' 62# &,. *#'72 «/ #-6$$»
' ("# %$"#'(2# &$ .$. $&($'-
-, #* ** "%"/"#'# 8$&.#7 $*(7
%("#"*& /4"#', %$%& '$)0 /$3-
/, #$7- ".0 .$& %$7"". 2#(3-
"#3 «/ #-6$$» ' /(350 "#% %$'(
"( 1%& /$&, % *$00 .$ ' #., #
*"#"2 %$'2 %/(,6 .$%$2#0. $2#,
6(8#"#, "#$.2#"2 %(#3 "'/'5-"2 "(-
."#"*- 5, /$''5-"2 %"( 6 .
$ =#. .) %$%()#3, #, ' "'2 " '(3-
"#'. 6(8#"#' 2#(3"#3- ' %"(
'$.2, $&72 *#'$#"2 ' "*#$ .
%""#3 (2 .$#'$"*6 "(0 %("#7'
$(3#2, #*) *"%"$' %$7"" .$& $-
&($'2 (:, "", , ) %$"#'(2# %-
%,#* "#$*' '$)2 6(8# %$'$##3 =#-
-#$$#$(3,0 *8(*# ' $(&,0 &(/(3,0
*8(*# .) "(."*. .$. 1%., ' *#$.
/# ."# *.%$.""..
42
.. !"#$!
-19 +:
1
("#-$(3"*0 *8(*#, ()'50 "-
', $/-$(3"*6 %$#'$0 "#-40"2 6
=(.#., ""#. "#$*#$ #(#"2 # #5-
0 $(2 $/"*6 &"$"#'. 2'(2#"2 .)-
&"$"#',. *8(*#., (2 &, $2 " /-
4. %$. $/-$(3"*& %$#'"#22,
6$*#$ "(3 ',$)2 =##$$#$(32
=#%(#"*2 ""#'(2-42.
* '"#, ' "' *8(*# ()# %$#
'6 $' # ) #$$#$- – ("#.
"#$"* "",(*, "/"# *(3#$& "(2,
2,*' "'/$ – '" '.), $&.#, /$5-
, '", (2 #&, #/, *#3 %$*#"* *-
.: *# .# /(35 %$' =# .(-. $&.#,
#$7 %*$%(2-#"2 ',. %$#'"#2..
#$*#$ *8(*# 2'(2#"2 "..#$,.: ' .
"#'-# "#$,, "$'., % "'0 .4,
% '(2-, % ./(7,. '.)"#2..
"..#$"#3 *8(*# %$2'("3 ' #., #
' & '#2#, ** $&(2$2 $.2, #* $&(2$,
'$), 8$.$'2, %$"#'(2-4 "/0 '-
, #'#'(2 #6 ( ,6 7(3,6 ')0
%$#0. * %$'(, $&(2$, '$), #$2-
, 8$.$'2 &$ /( /#'#"#',. /-
43
(2 ' "( "'0 %$$, /( &$,. "$-
"#'. '& '0"#'2 "#7- ((5, #2-
)(0 #6*, .4& $)2 #..), /$#
'$) #$$$"#"* '$", .#-
,. # ) '$.2 "# ' $(3"*-%("#"*.
*8(*# " "#$, $(2 "'$.0 $&(2$0
$. .)# %$'#3 * %$',5- %$(
"$)'2 * %$',. )$#'..
#(3 (#(3 '-%(#"* %$#'"#2-
"#$. /(-#(- .)# %*#3"2 $$7-
(3,.. 0"#'#(3, %$#2) .&6 (# .-
)$ "/4"#' ',"#%# $&($'
*8(*# "' '6 &"$"#' (2 '6 $'.
+$.(3 " '6 &"$"#' /,( %$()
4 ' 1947 &. ' $(-7 181/II. . )
"6 %$ %$"#2 ' 8$.( $('?
#/, %%,##3"2 #'##3 =## '%$", "#-
# '$#3"2 * "/,#2. /( . 60-(#0 '"#,
'"%.#3 /"#$'5"2 #52 .) %("#-
"*. $/. '$2., .'$$' (*/$#-
, %7 : , "%$"#' ' $/"*.
(&$ #.%. * %$"#'(2#"2, '" =# 6$5 '"#-
, 8*#, "%"/, />2"#3 #(3* #, %. -
("3 .%(.#$'#3 $(-7- ' 1948 &.,
-# #'# '%$", %. ' (305.
#* "#("3 /.& ' *"#' %$.$ .)$-
& %$"#52 ( "*$& /()2.
".& ( $/-'$0"* %$#'$2 ' -
("# #$)( #(3* /$3/ #$$#$-,
"#$-, .8,, #$7 $(&-, "'2, /-
6 $' " =#0 .(0. ,. "('., "$'#(3
/(352 #$$#$2 "#( .$*$. 7(30
#"# ** '$', #* %("#"*6 $/'.
##, $&0 $ .,"(# "/2 ** "#$"*0
44
8. ' =#0 .(, *#$2 %$#2) .&6
'*' 8$.$'( 6 "." 7(3- "-
./,#"#3. $3/ «%$'$"#'», 0"#'#(3
/"(-# $$7(32 " "'$.0 #* $2
$$('#2 " #* $2 $&($'2 *8(*#,
' =#%(#"*. *#*"# *,'#"2 &$ "(3-
/4%$2#0 (&*. 0 &('- $(3 &$-#
".'(,, =.7, $..
""('- "%78* .)=#"*6 *8(*#'
%"'24, $/#, .&6 "%7("#'. (', ','-
, .) "'"# * #", # =#"*0 *8(*# "#
$"".#$'#"2 ** $5.,0 %$()#(3,0,
** /( "(),6 8$. *8(*#, " #*
$2 %$'(2 $&($'2. ( =#"*-
& .$2 %$'# * #., # *8(*# '"%$-
.#"2 %"$"#' *8(*#-4. "#$.
#(3* ** *8(*# #$"', ** *8(*# 7-
"#0. .$*"*0 "%7("# ' =#0 /("# )
$# "(-4. /$. %",'# %2# 7"#:
«"#2. ,'-#"2 # , %$',*, #$7
'$'2, *#$, 6$*#$, (2 %$(0 "7-
(30 /4"#.… 6$ 7"#0 %$ -
4#& &$""'& '$#' %'2…»
1
. #-
$", .&# /,#3 %$.#. (2 #$&, 7"# %$.-
$#3 *$0 "(). ?# #, # ' $(3"*-
%("#"*. *8(*# %$#'/$"#'-4 "#$,
"*(, # "#%* % '%$"., *#$,, % 6
.-, #"2#"2 * %$/(. ',)'2 "6$2
6 $', 6 *(30 *(3#$,.
(2 $*(3,6 "(."#"*6 $&70
"(."*0 )6 2 "2 '6 &"$"#' -
1
Burton J. Conflict: Resolution and Prevention. London: The Macmillan
Press Ltd., 1990. P. 37.
45
%$.(. ' %$7%, #* ** %$-# %$'
$(2 "4"#''. (2 %$',6 $(3"*6 $-
*(' " %("#"*& &"$"#', -4
6 $(2 " #$$#$0 6',6 ' - 1967 &.
() " '"6, "$ %$ /. #(3,. -
"#*.), #*) %$.(. % %$7%(3,. "/$-
)2.. 1.(2 =#, " 6 #* $2, "* %$(-
)# '$2., %%( ' 1967 &. ' 6 $* % )"#'.
%$'-, *# .# %$' - $"%$2)#3"2.
) .$, %(#*, '4 %$&'$,, '"-
%$.-# ='#(3,0 $( ("#, ** '.
"%$'(',0, ** )$#' " 6 "#$,. # ) '$.2
(3#$#', %$()2 '2# "#7- ' %(,0
#%*. *, ' %("#"*0 "$, #(3* ' 0,
'" /(35 '. %$'(*# '$# "2 -
& &"$"#' (2 '6 $', 2, /"(-# %$-
.(.2 (2 $(2. ( ' #., # /4 %(-
"#"* &"$"#', $(3 "#$2#"2 =#$(&-
0 "', # # %$2# .$'2
0 =#$(&0 &$%%, ) "(5*. /(350
"("#. (2 %("#7' – =# "#(3 *#(3-
. %("#"*. &"$"#' (2 $&6 =#"*6
$(&,6 /4 /# ..(30, ' . &"-
$"#', *#$. "0" &'$2# /( $*(3,
*$&, $/, 3 "*$ ". "#( /, .$-4.
=#".. (2 $(2 %$"%*#' "2 & &-
"$"#' # *7 & '$0"*& 6$*#$, #..
*$6 "2 &"$"#', ' *#$. '$0"*0 -
$ .& /, )#3 "'0 7(30 )3-.
$'$)"#3 /6 "#$ "/"#',. «7-
"#2.» ""#'(2# ## *8(*#,0 8, *#$.
$'$#,'("3 $, %%,#* $5#3 %$/(.,
/"#$&$2"3, % '.)"#, # =.7(3,6
%"'"#$"*6 %6'.
46
2/$ 2007 &. %("#-$(3"* #52
'"#%( ' ',0 =#% – ' %(" %$ %"$"#-
' : %$)* $&6 "#*' /()'"#-
& *'$## /,( '/'(, %$&'$, .) (-
$. %("#"*0 ."#$7 $(3"*. %$-
.3$-."#$.. ".#$2 '"3. %#."#, -
2'(2 .$*"*& %$# %$"#'#(0 &
."#$7 #"#(3 '.)"# *(-2
"&(52 * *7 2008 &., ' 7(. %("#-$(3-
"* #52 "#'("3 %$2),.. $-
"* $(3"* #$$#$ -& %'$&("3 $*#-
,. /"#$(. ,, $(3 ' #'# "( $,,
%,#2"3 #)#3 /'*' $&6 $-
*(3,6 $&70.
")(-, /. $. "#( %$',,. **.-
%.#. * %("#-$(3"*. #52. '
'"."# # ""#22 %$&'$& %$7"". $-
/(. *(-#"2 ' 0., %(#"*. #$$#-
$(3. $"*( %("#7' %(. #"#"#' *-
#$(2 " "#$, + 0"#'2. "'6 "(."#-
"*6 %%#'. (#"*0 %$7"", 7$'-
,0 ' %(", 6'#,'( (53 (&(3-, .)-
$ %$- "#3 %("#"*& "#/(5.#,
%$"#'#( *#$0 '# %$&'$, / *#(3-
. "##".
%(#(3 &#' '0"#' %$7""
%$&'$' *,'( #$2 "&("'"#3 '#-
$ $(3"*& %$'#(3"#'. *, /$'#(3 ?0#
/$ &#, «#» %"(: « (0, "&/ =&-
"#0 #* $2, ?6 (3.$# ) /#3"2
%(#"*6 "#)0 # /" " / .: %$-
6 * "&(5- %"#2. $&($', $5-
%$/(., #$$$, (-/ %(#"* $5
".2&# '.),0 $ *."" &$ (*.""2
47
% $""('- %$.6' ' '0 ' ' 2006 &.)
%'(# (3.$# "##3"2 '("#. #0 ) (0,
"&/ =&"#0 #* $2, ?6 $* )
/#3"2, #/, & *((& (3.$# ',5( /"
" /-. " %"#,. $*., #/, .) /,( ',-
"#'#3 &(' %$'#(3"#' ('*., *#$,0 $"#$-
#( $. '" '-%(#"* '.)"# -
& "(( (2 &"$"#'. , "*)#, # " (0,
=&"#0 #* $2 – =# %2#. # " &"$-
"#'.? # " .? , 6$5. , ( "'0 '%$"»
2
.
*(32 "#3 %("#"*& ')2, %$"#'-
(2 , #*) .( %$2., *#*#, " $-
(. %$ %$'( %$'#(3"#', "8$.$'& %$-
#0 .. #*#, /,( $&', %$ &%#-
"*. %"$"#' *"("3 "#)2 (&"$-
& %$.$2 (6). $(3"* ."#$"#' /$,
*#*#$'( " $ &%#"*6 %"$*'
%$#2) (&& '$., ".#$2 /0*# %$&-
'$, " =#0 $&70, *#$,0 /,( %$2# $(3#2-
., "#3- %("#7' #*) "#*. *'$##
/()'"#,6 %"$*' – : . #*#,
%$()("3 ) %(( %(#(3,0 .%(3",
' # '$.2 ** «%$# 5 /'2( #6, *# «'# %-
$&'$, " #$$$"#. $*(.», ',"#%2 %$
$(3"*. ""#.. ** "*( $(3"*0 *.-
.##$ &( '#$. *( '"#0, ".#$2
*(5 %$2#, "(', $3 5 /# .#3
'(22 $(3"* *#*#, " »
3
.
"()'50"2 "#7 / "#$, /,( #$"-
', ' "&(5. $'#(3"#' "#$.("3 /"-
%#3 '.)"#3 $52 "7(3-=*."*6
2
/$ %$"", '$# (26–31.08.2007).
3
Common Ground News Service. 22–28.05.2008 – www.commongroundnews.org
48
%$/(. "(2 "*#$ , 624&"2 &$
&.#$0 *#"#$8,. $(3"* %$'#(3"#'
)("3 ' "%*0"#' "'6 -),6 &$76,
' 4# "(2, "#$-4& # )',6 /"#$-
(', ' ''$4, *7, 6'& ' 2006 &. %(-
"#"*. /'*. 8$0#$ ( :(#.
$*$4 &2 " , *#$ /,( "#&-
# ' - 2008 &., .,'("3 ** "&(5 -
"*(3*6 =#%', *#$ #"2, % "('. ."#$
/$, ?. $*, ** «"%*0"#' ' /. "%*0-
"#'». /"#$(, " #$$#$ , #$$$"#"*2
*#'"#3 %$*$#2#"2, $(3 %$*$## '5,
(#, ., %$7.
"( "#)2 "%*0"#'2 $(3 # %-
"#% /( /(* "*#$, %$(((3 /#
'"#"3 %$&'$, / "'/) ( :(# ' /-
. "'/) #-$. %("#"*6 *(--
,6. "(-4. =#% %$&'$, (), /,( %$-
'"# * #*$,#- %$6 86 &%#"*0 &$7
' "#'#"#' " %)(2. . //", #., %"(
''$42 :(#, – * #*$,#- '"6 %$6'
"2#- /(*, ,.
$52 "&(52 ("3 "$ %"( &
%%"2. "$"#'6 .""'0 8$.7 ''3
"#( /")#3"2 '$# ."5#/0 %$7 '
" 7(3- #)2 '("# "#0 $*-
*%7 "*#$ ($.42 #. %"( '$52 %-
$7 "#0 $(3"*0 $. ."# /,'56 '$0-
"*6 %"(0). $(3"*. %$.3$ (3.$# 3
6#("3 #3 .- %$7- %$#' ,
*#$2 /) %'(# "/0 )$#', "$ -
$(3"*6 '"()46, '.), "$ .$-
& "(2, .)# #2#3"2, "()#3 #5-
2 $(2 " &%#. $0, #*) " '$%0
49
""0 #.%. # ) '$.2 (3.$# /,( ',)
',/$#3 '$# ,, %"*(3* "&(5 %$*$-
4 &2 ',$)( "%,#2. $(3"*2 %$-
72 ' ' *7 2008 – ( 2009 &. 4 /(35 "-
()( %() / , ) "( ' "#'#"#-
' " (&*0 /,( %$#' "(/(2 "'6 "(-
."#"*6 %%#'.
3 "$3,0 $$,' .) %72. /6 "#-
$, .) /4"#'. ($., *#$,. '-
$2#, , *7, .) .$(-/',. 2'(2.
$(30 "#70 " /(*%"#., /"#$(. ',.
%"(2. "#("2 ' "("#' '. $(3"*.
%$.3$ . #326 & */#. +*#"* '"
'$("3 *$& "'2 – " ',. "#$#(3"#'. %"-
(0 ' "#. $"(. & %$(.,
" $"5$. "#$,6 %"(0, " %$"*. /-
"#$(. #.%. ) ' "3/ ""#& ( :(-
# %$5( %$..
."# " #. %$.,, *, /,(. : %2-
'("2 =$&,0 %$# $* /., %$"#'#(3
.*$#"*0 %$#, %"#''50 "'0 7(3-
(5 #50 : " ."(3."*. .$. –
' *"#' & "%"/' – *#', 5& % $&-
($'- $/-$(3"*& *8(*#. ) /,-
( %$%$2#,, '" "' #$.("3.
.)"# .2 "#7 ' 8$.# %(-
"#-$(3"*6 #50 %* #"#"#'-#. #
**6 %$*', *,'-46 #, # "#72
%" $.#$#"2. *$ %$#', "#$.
(& )#3 " "4"#'-4. %$/(.. (".#$2
&$.* 2'(2 "#$.( * .$), . # $
=#& .$ "$3- *$$*#$'* "'0 %7.
.)# *#3"2 *$0 /(0 (2 /6 "#-
$. %$.$, $(- %$#"2 ='*$'#3 %"-
50
(7' " 1%& /$&, %("#7. #*$,# #*-
#3"2 # ''$42 /)7' ' $(3. ?# -
# %$6 * '. *$", &#', %"("#'2
*#$& (2 "#'#"#'-46 %(#"*6 =(# .)-
(&* %$"##3, ' # '$.2 ** '%$", $ &
=# "(# (#3, "##"2 #*$,#,.. ,. "('.
.$ (2 .&6 $(3#2 %-%$). ',&(2# /(
%$(,. %",. %$%$2#., . "6$-
"##"-*'. %$.$, #*& .$ " $/. .-
( '6'(2-#. $ " &%#. $0 "##"2
«6(,. .$.» .( # # (2 $2'& -
$(3#2 "*(-. '.)"# ">#3
' ""-- "#$, # .)# /$#3"2 %$*#*
=*"#$.(3,. #$... (#* *,'( #,
# **0 .$ " &%#. .5# 6."'7. %$-
#2&'#3 #( , &%#"*- #$$#$-
%$#"*'#3 % . #(3* %$.#, 5$*&
"%$", $). (0" =# .("3.)
(2 %("#"*& $*'"#', "%,#,'-4& '"
/(35 '0"#' $*(', .$ " $(., *#-
$& "#(3 ) (*, ** %$), '$2 ( %$"#'(2#-
"2 "*(3*-/3 $(30 (3#$#'0 ,5.
%()-. "# %$&'$, $ %$&'$', *#$,
(53 %$,'-# '#$## %("#"*& $*'#(2,
# ".,"(. "(0 / 2'( ' 2/$
2009 &. )( /((#$'#3"2 %$#"*6
',/$6. (32 #,'#3 %7- #0 "# %(-
"#"*& $*'"#', *#$- $'$#( %"#22
%.43 - &$7,. ?# 2#( ' #$#( '(2-
."",, ". ."", #$"-# 6 (53 ** $-
"$", /"%'-40 %"#%( %.4. . #)
(5 %"#'(2#3"2 & .2#3.
(#"*0 %$7"" %("#"*. %$'(
*#(3 5( ' #%*. *(,'#"2 '%#(,
51
#, ".#$2 .$*"*- *#'"#3 *#'"#3
$&6 (' *'$##, & %$"6# %$-
0#. 1 $,. %$*$4. &2 /# "(-
'#3 ', 0"#'2 ' -& ', "#(3 )
/"%(, & .2-4, ** '$.2 # '$-
. '/'(2-4"2 %$&'$,. . (35 (#"2
%$#'"#2, #. /( %$.(.,. (2 "# %(-
"#7' $(3#2 "#'#"2 %$. "(2,
#. . #($#,. "#'2#"2 %6, * %$"#-
'#(2. $&6 =#"', #. /(35 .(,6 %("#-
7' &#', '(#3"2 ' /', /$&, '" /(35 $-
(3"*6 "(# /$, %$6#3 "()/ /(*%-
"#6 " '". ',#*-4. %"6(&"*. %"("#-
'2.. '" ) /4"#' &#', "*$ %(##3 =# 7-
, . # $*(3, %$., (% 0,.,
%$*#"*. ( ,. "/$)2. – .# /(3-
5& 2). ('#(3, '- "#$#&- /-
# ' (5. "( ','#3"2 *".#"* .$,,
"4"#'(2., % %"#2,0 **.%.# $#(-
($0"*6 $'.
("#-$(3"* %$#'"#2 "#'(2#
&(/* $,, #, ** %(3 =# %$'#3,
/4"#' . /6 $' %-%$). &-
#' =# %$','#3 /$3/0 *(3#$- "./,#-
"#3 ',)'. (35"#' "*( %$)-
'#3 #6 ($', *#$, ."#$$-# #'$ -
.$ %"#%#3"2 %$7%., 442 #$-
", ".'(,, "#$"* "8$.$''5"2 ' "(-
'26 %$#'/$"#' 2'(2-4"2 & %$*#.. #
%. %$&'$, 2'(2-#"2 (2 ,56 «'("##-
(0 .» (/ ''" 0 %$.(.,., (/ #2-
)(0 /2"#3-, '20 '5. &$*..
1#, '$.2 .$#'$7' 4 %$5( – 6 %$"#
*# )#…
52
.. %$
!
9 9
32. #326 '#$0 $ '&('( %$'#(3-
"#' $(2 ' ## "#$"*0 ..#, *& /()'-
"#,0 $& *("2 ' "#7, .# #(-40-
"2 # %$,4& %$ & %$.3$"#' (1996–1999).
"#24 '$.2, $2 " #$7,. .,
"'2,. " $&($'. $(3"*-%("#"*&
*8(*#, $/"*0 .$ 2# $&., '624.
' *$& =#& *8(*# $&(3,. %$/(... 6
"( ',', $*(3& "(. 7(3,. $/-
"*. $).. $&, "#72 ' $* 8&"#,
$"*2 2$2 %$&$.., 8#2, %$/(.,.
$(3 /(35 2'(2#"2 $&(3,. &.. (
#&, $"*2 &$ "(( '.)0 ',$/#* 0
#*#* $(2 .$,6 $/"*6 $).' ' #5
%#7(30 &$, " "#$, $. * %(),
*("3 /,, # ', '.)"# (2 %"* «"')6 $-
50» ' "8$ /()'"#0 %(#* '& */#
."#$' % $*'"#'. *. * "#72 ' /-
("# $&($'2 %-%$). '"3. "()2.
#326, %$550 ". %$.* . :$-
– ?. (3.$#, %(( "#$, ''3 "#24- $"%-
#3: # #$$#$(3, "#%* " $0 (-
"#"*0 7(30 ."#$70 () ' /.
,/*0 .$, &$#$-40 /%""# #$$#$
53
$(2 # /"#$(' ',(* /((,,
*#$,. "## $; ( '". "(. #$.#3 (-/,
(305 "#%*, "6$22 "##"-*'.
%$',/$,6 %$&$..,6 2'(0, %$)
'"& '"0 (&* $'#2 %70 . #326 ' /-
("# $&($'2 $/-$(3"*& *8(*#,
"#'#"2 ',., # %(#* '& %$.3$-
."#$ /# /$'#3"2 "(-46 %$7%6:
1. ("#"* %$'( *8(*# – =# $(3-
## "#3 $/-$(3"*& %$#'"#22. ,0
*8(*# .# $52, %* $/"*0 .$ %$-
# %$' $(2 "4"#'' ** '$0"*& &"-
$"#' ' /()'"#. $&. . =#%, %
.- $*'"#' *, "(# %$'"# '.
.$'0 /4"#'"# " %$/(., (& "
%$/(., &$, " "#$, $; 0# # %(#"*6
%$&'$' $50 %# «.(& =*."*&
.$» – =*."*& "#$"#' " %("#7..
,"#%2 ' ""# 7$. #'$)2 '-
& %$'#(3"#', ',0 %$.3$-."#$ $(2 2'(,
# .$ %$()#3 .$,0 (& " %("#7-
.: « &'$- %("#"*. ($., # "( 0"#-
'#(3 6#2# .$, "#)., – "*( #326. –
."# " %("#"*0 ."#$70 ., /. "*#3
.$ % #$. %$'(2.: =*.*, /%""#3
%(#*»
1
. $'#(3"#' * %$%## "6$-
2#3 "##"-*' . %$'( %* %'"#*
2 "#$ "## '%$" %("#"*. "#'
2
. 7-
1
, 02.04.2009.
2
$ 16 .2 2009 &. %$ %"$"#' &%# ("2 $0
$ %$&'$' %$.$ .) %$#'/$"#'-4. %("#-
"*. ')2. + . $ =#. %$"#'#(3
2'(, # "(."#, .$, /")#3 '%$" %$ %$'
$(2 "4"#'', *', # =# #. «*$,# (2 "*""0».
54
(., %$2 * '("#, * ( %2#3, # (2 & ".-
$ 2$,6 ./70 $ – /( ')2 , -
)( '/'( '2(#*46 %$&'$' " $"*(-
#,. $*'"#'. ("#,.
$ $$/#* ',6 0 ',6 %6' * %(-
"#"*0 %$/(. %$'#(3"#' #26 /# ',-
) "##3"2 " #., # */#, ** ' 1996 &., /-
# 0"#''#3 ' /"#'* "(3& .)$&
'(2 % '%$" '".. %("#"*. &"-
$"#' " "#$, "#$ – "#7 *'$##, %$)
'"& :; %& /4"#'& .2 ' 7(.
("/ " "#$, '$%0"*6 "#$) $/"*6
"#$ $&. $ %"( #&, ** /,( "8$.$'
' %$'#(3"#', 11 .2 2009 &. '# %""#
' "%7(3. 2'( %#'$( %$7% "-
"4"#''2 '6 &"$"#' – $(2 ("#,,
#*) ',"*("2 %$' ' "*' .)$-
0 *8$7 % (). "#*. '/ %$'(
«* ',. "$,. "(2. "#$ .)$&
"/4"#' (2 "#)2 '"/>.(-4&, "%$'(-
'& (&"$& .$ (). "#*». 2'(-
* %$)* '#. %""# «/$-
#."# '"#$6 %$&'$', "',6 %$)-
6 /2#(3"#'6 $(3"*0 $/"*0 "#$».
2. "( #.0 ',5 %$, $(3 % "-
/$)2. /%""# .)# '$#3 '" (,
$. $ %$). %$'#(3"#' %$"#'#( -
$(2 $ ' # '6 (# "4"#'(2( #0,
*#*#, " 7(3- "2 %(#8$., (2 %%"2
.$& &'$. #*#, %$"6( " "#2/$2
2004 &. % -(3 2006 &. 6 %$&'$' /,( %&#'-
( %$*# 87(3& "&(52, *#$. /,(
%"#'(, ' '"#"#3 ($, /6 "#$. $(3,
*, '2,'( ( (& " %$*$4. %-
55
$)* ."*. ('"*& ')2 /(( %(-
"#"*6 $*(3,6 &$%%$'*, $2 – " ''$-
4. (. ".#$2 #, # ?. (3.$# 14 *#2/-
$2 2007 &. #( %$* / #) 2$& $*#-
$ ' $, # "()( / #& #$,0 %$&-
'$,0 %$7"" " ."*., $2 $(3 87(3-
/>2'( ( .$,6 %$&'$'
3
.
?# "#$'# ' %$'#(3"#' *, *#-
$ "##, # '.) "( $( $ ()-
. "#* ',)# $(3"* $*'"#' 4
"$3 %0# * '%$" $52 %$/(., (-
"*6 ',"#. . #* .) 7'#3 2'( -
#326 #., # $(3 () %*#3 " "'.
%$"#"#'. ("*6 ',"#6 %$#3 6 %
"$0"*0 "'$##. $ $ =#& "#$#&-
"* ')& (2 /%""# $(2 &&$8-
"*& %(7$. #, # $ %$"#'(2#"2
'.)"#3 $."##3 #. "' '$), "(,.
%$7%, "## *, " (. ** "#3- #$-
$#$ $ .)# %$0# #, # "(("3 ' -)-
3
21 .2 %$.3$-."#$ $(2 ?6 (3.$# 2'(, # ' #
& %$()("3 %$'$#(3, *#*#, '6 "#$. . "
''3 2'( )( '/'#3 .$, %$&'$, " $-
(., %$*', # .$ "##"2 «"#$#&"*. ',/$.» ."*,
& "#) '.) (53 %$ "(' ''$# $ **%-
$',6 ("*6 ',"# '.)"# *(-2 .$& &'-
$. ?# %$72 .( ' %(#"* 7(: /#3 "( ' #.,
# %2'( %/& $)2 ""& &"$"#', " *#$,.
$(2 # %(.#"*6 "&(50 .$& &'$, &$-
)( & 7(30 /%""#. &(' – =# %$72 ()
/,( "#'#3 &$ .#3"2 "/"#',. 2$,. $$-
/#*., &, '%$., %$5( ) ".#$2 #, # (3.$#
"*(-( '.)"# %'#$2 %/0 ) %$7 ' #5-
$ [ .. $ "$0"*-$(3"* %$&'$, //
http://www.iimes.ru/rus/stat/2008/02-07-08b.htm#top#top Haaretz, 16.01.2007].
56
,6 $&6 ', & '%( "'/ '"#'-# "-
/2 %$(2 $"*& $%" "#$)0 "(."*0
$'(-7 (). "., *, # ' /()'-
"#0 %$&$.. * "$0"* %$'( -
.# ')056 ."#. & "'2 "#$#&-
"*2 #$'#3 $- # "8$, '(22 $
'"%$%2#"#''#3 %$()- %$)* - $-
*(3,6 $&70 – /((, . 87(3-
2 )"#*2 %$',/$2 %72 #326 #*
'$#3 ("* ',"#, %$%2#"#''( '.),.
%')*. ' =#. %$'(.
."# " #. "%7("#, )-#, # . #326
% ).. '0 .$*"*0 ."#$7 .-
# "'- %7- ' #5 "$0"*6 (. "0
2009 &. ' ."*, "#'5. 7#$. %(.#"*0 *-
#'"#, '), %/,'( ',"*%"#'(, %$-
"#'#( "% :. '$( "$0"* $*-
'"#' ' %$'$)"# '0 .$*"*0 .-
"#$7 .$. %$7"" ' $&, *#$,0 /#
'*(-#3 ' "/2 "$0"*-$(3"*0 #$*. $. #-
&, .$*"* %$"#'#( ( %2#3, # (2 (-
*'"*& %$'#(3"#' $(2 «%$&$"" "$0-
"*. %$'( *$0 )(#(»
4
.
3. *'"* %$'#(3"#' /), # ".-
$(3- &$ "4"#''- $(2 %$"#'(2#
$. %$ %$'(2 ?. (3.$# %$5( ')-
05 "/,# $&(3& .)$& ."5#-
/ – %$6 * '("# ' $ ' - 2005 &. 6. 6-
.) "( $*(3& "(.. ().
"#*. . 6.), *#$,0 %$*#"* ' *).
"'. %/(. ',"#%( %$()# &$)#3 "-
'$## $(2, ( .4,0 #(* (2 *#'7
4
http://www.iimes.ru/rus/stat/2008/02-07-08b.htm#top#top
57
'"6 =*"#$."#"*6 "( ' $&. 2007 &. $7(0-
"*0 *8$7 %$5( "*""2, *#$2 ,'("3
«.2 ' %$&. $(3"*-%("#"*6 #-
50 ' # $"*0 &$, '0, %$#' /(-
(,». "*"" ( /,'50 %$"#'#(3 :
' ) (#, *#$,0 2'(, # : %(-
$-# %$.#3 $5#(3, .$, (2 (*'7
$"*0 2$0 &$,: «5 .$'#"2 0"#'-
'#3 ' =#. %$'(. .$* & "((, -
& (# & "(# *7 ,50
%$#"*0 *7. $(3 "##"2
%$ (7. 2$0 &$,»
5
. "('. (#, *#-
$,0 %$/$( '"#"#3 ' '$.2 "'0 *7
' %"('#(3,. %$$(3"*. 2'(2-
., (2 $(2 %$5( '$.2 $5#3, /# .$#3"2
" $"*0 2$0 /./0 ( ) &#' * '0 %-
$7. 4"#'# ., .-4 ' $( .&
"#$*', # %/(*72 ' ( */$2 2007 &.
*( .$*"*& $','#(3& "/4"#',
"&(" *#$. $ 4 ' 2003 &. "'$( '-
2$- %$&$.., ( &$ (,0 "'# %$-
() 2$,6 $$/#*. & $(3"* %(-
#* "#-# #*), # %$5( '$.2 $""*$##3 -
#( '0 %$7 $(2 ' $, %$'0
24 "#2/$2 2007 &. .'50 "'. $(3##. -
#) "$0"*& 2$& />*#, #* ** 2$
"#$"#' $ '$0 $, "%"/"#'-
''5 "- =#& />*#, /5("3 / $-
"*& "#2
6
. '2 %/ . 6.) ',/-
5
Interdisciplinary Center (IDC) Herzliya. Institute for Policy and Strat-
egy (IPS). Discussion: “The Changing Paradigm in the Shadow of Iran
and the War against Hezbollah”. The Seventh Annual Herzliya Confer-
ence // Herzliya, 21–23.01.2007.
6
. ).
58
$6 ' - 2009 &. #(3* "(( '.)"# #-
$(3"*& «*$» ' $&(30 %(#* $. -
=#. $"* %$'( />2'( *. %$$-
##,. %$'(. $(3"*0 '50 %(#*.
4. ' (*'"* %$'#(3"#' /), #
$(3 $ ' $' $/-$(3"*& *8(*#
', ". &(' – %2'("2 $(3,0 8*#$
$"*0 &$, '". .$: /( $. 2$,.
$). "# ' "/ &(/(3- &$. (2 "#$-
2 /6. "#3 .)$- ""./(-, 7-
(3- *#$0 /# "$)' $
7
. &$, /%"-
"# $(2 " "#$, /((, ' '
' %$.3$ $(2 $"".#$'# ** #$)
$"*& '(22 $(7- & #$"'. "62
=#&, #326 & "#$* ' $*'"#' *
%$'240 *(7 "#-# /6.,. '.),.
%$%$2#3 "(2 % "- #$"*& /(*.
. " $(. (), *"($'#3"2 "#$, $-
&, "'2, " . &'$,. #52., – &-
%# $2, #*) «.$,» $/"* $)., –
'"*2 $'2 $/"* ?.$#,, #*) "&("-
, .$#3"2 " $"*0 &$0. #326 %$*(,
# /# "*#3 «%(& .$» " $/"*. ."(3-
."*. &"$"#'.. 2'(, # $(- &$)-
# "(., «$*(3, $).,, "#$.24"2 %-
(#3 2$ $)»
8
. 7- #326 ' 7(.
$(2-# $& %$#$, % *(7, "/ %$-
"#'#( %$'& 7(3-$(&& (&$2:
%$# «5 . – $(3» (), : «0# &-
». * $ 2'(2( ',0 &(' , %$"#(3
'&$ /$., /6. %$".#$#3 %$-
7
The Jerusalem Post. 11.03.2009.
8
. ).
59
$##, %$#3, # 8$.( «.$ ' /. .(»
%$"# $(3##' ' $&, %=#. "(# "-
*#3 $52 ' $.*6 *7%7 «.$ ' /. .$».
7(. "%7("#, "#-#, # ',0 */# .-
"#$' /# %$'#3 )"#*0 *$" ' #5 %(-
"#7' # %$'#(3"#' #326 &#' * (&
" $/., * "#%*.
9
.
#326, '#$ %$.3$"#' *#$& ''3 %$-
5("3 .*$#"*- %$#"*- ."#$-
7- ' 5&#, #$7 ( "'- *7-
" '# ' :, *#$,. %$"#(3 "(( '"3
$/"*0 .$. $# $* /. 2'( "'. -
.$ ''3 %"##3 %$7"" %$.$2 ()-
. "#*, *#$,0 />2'( . %$$##'
'50 %(#* "'0 ."#$7. ( -
#326 # '6 &"$"#' #*$4'("2. $.3$-
."#$ %-%$). "#(, # %$), . &'$#3
**.-(/ %$&$"" ' .$. %$7"", "(# "#-
$#3 &$ "#/(3"# ' $&.
(' *, ".#$2 .$*"* '(,
"%5( /$'#3 "', %$$##, & *$"
' #5 $52 %$/(. %("#-$(3"*&
%$#'"#22. *7, 14 -2 2009 & %"( ''$-
42 : . #326 ()( "' %7 ' ',-
"#%( ' 7#$ "#$#&"*6 ""('0
$-("*& '$"## $(2
10
.
$(3"* "#$* %7 %$.3$-."#$,
($2 %$&$..- $3 #326, 2'(, #
«%$"* /*» "(( %$'(3,0 ',/$. $.3$-
."#$ %$'( %("#"*6 ""0 %("#"*6
9
. ).
10
– //$'#$ 8.(0 %$.3$-."#$ & %$-
# #, %%"'56 .$,0 &'$ .) $(. &%#..
60
($' * .(. '/'(- %$&'$' .-
$ / **6-(/ %$'$#(3,6 "('0. (',.
%*#. $ #326 "#( (2 .&6 $(3#2
*(-', "(': «.(#$$' %("#"*
&"$"#' $2. " '$0"*. &"$"#'. $(3»
11
.
#*. /$. ',$( "' "&(" " ". %-
("#"*& &"$"#', %$*' %$ =#. "*(3*
'),6 ( %$7%(3,6 (2 %("#7', ** (2
$/"*& .$ ' 7(.) "('0.
"(' %$' *(-#"2 ' #., #, %$) '"&,
/4 %("#"* &"$"#' () /,#3 «.-
(#$'», & "4"#'' /# %$#3"2 «
.)$, &$# /%""#». #$$#$26,
%$,6 %("#7., /# $., /#
&"%"#''#3 ' '5. %$"#$"#', # /#
''#3"2 $). $(2 (), /,#3 &$#, #
«%("#7, ".&# .%$#$'#3 $*#, "'-
#$$#$-, "'#3 $.-, $'#3 ' '5.
%$"#$"#', *$,#. (2 $(2, ( %%"#3 %*#
" /((0 $.».
"(' '#$ – %$ %("#"*. &"$"#-
'. «'$0"*& 6$*#$» $(2. . #326 "%-
7(3 %$*(: «"',. "('. %$*$42
*8(*# 2'(2#"2 #*$,#, /2,'-4 "*$
%("#"* %$ #&, # $(3 2'(2#"2 -
7(3,. &"$"#'. '$0"*& $»
12
.
"(' #$#3 – "6$ '6 '"#,6 $-
(3"*6 «#», *"-46"2 %$ "#& $"-
(., "#-4&"2 «0 "#(70 "$"#' $-
(3», ''$4- %("#"*6 /)7' ' %$(,
$(3"*0 #$$#$.
11
Haaretz, 15.06.2009.
12
Ibid.