Звягельская И.Д. (ред.) Проблемы и перспективы урегулирования на Ближнем Востоке
Подождите немного. Документ загружается.
81
.%0 , ,"
,+#" "$,%$)
#"#"#' .* ' %$&'$. %$7""
$(3,6 "('0 (2 %$#'$2 ' )3 %$7%
'6 &"$"#' %("#7, ''$4-#"2 * $5-
2 *8(*# "' %$7% & &"$"#'.
?## '$# 6# %$)* ' %"( "2#(#
"$ "# #((*#(3& "/4"#' 1%0
'$%,, – ' .350 "#% – ' :
21
.
& %("#"* .$, 2#(, "6$22
%$'$)"#3 %$7% '6 &"$"#', %$-#,
# $5 *8(*# & "' %$*#"* -
"4"#'.. ',$)- %$# '$"##
(3-" $ ""0/, «.,"(3 ')#"2 ' "#$-
, $(3"#3 – ' $&-»
22
. =#6 *$&6 ',"*,'-#-
"2 %$()2 '.)"# $"%"* ("#"*0
."#$7 ''$4 * %$'(- #$$#-
$2. % "6. 1994 &., *& %("#"* $/,
"4"#'(2( ."# ".%$'( %$ "6$
$(3"*0 **%70 ."#$7. *0 "##"
#$$#$0, ** "#-#, %'(# 6 "(- /-
$#3"2 "(3"#',. .#. $(7- "'-
6 %$' ' $.*6 & &"$"#'.
$&$.., % $5- %("#"*& 7(3-
& '%$" $$/#,'-#"2 ' %("#"*0 "%$
' %,6 "#$6. «$%% %("#"*0 "#$#&»
23
,
21
.. % =#0 #.: http://www.one-state.net; Tilley V. The One State
Solution: A Breakthrough for Peace in the Israeli-Palestinian Deadlock.
AnnArbor: University of Michigan Press, 2005.
22
The Times. 02.03.2009.
23
http://www.palestinestrategygroup.ps
82
',"#%'52 " "'. .8"#. (#. 2008 &. ' (-
*/$#, ## %$%# %$7% '6 &"-
$"#'. # ) '$.2 (, =#0 &$%%,, 2' % '(2-
. "'#"*6 (/$(3,6 0 %,6 #((*#-
(', $$/#,'-# "7$0 & &"$"#' **
%$%$) $(- '.). 6 $'#2 "-
/,#0 ' "(, "( /# /(*$'#3 " %-
("#"*& &"$"#'.
'$4 %("#7' * & &"$"#',
'$2#, 2'(2#"2 ".,. %(',. #&. %$556
'6 "2#(#0. 3 %("#"* 7(3 "-
#* ".$("3 " "4"#''. $(2,
=# #. /( %", # $2 " "'#"*. %("#-
"*. 7(.. & "(."#"*0 "%$*, "62
$&& .$'$2, #*) %$$)'#"2 "#$#-
& #$72 %$#'"#240 "#$,. "#"#',
# %$ #*6 "('26 %$') & '-
7(3& &"$"#' $"".#$'#"2 ' $(
** &$ ".. "4"#''- '$0"*& "(2.
%)1 %(! '%21
(2 $(2 %$7% & &"$"#' #
#$7 '"& ""#"*& %$*# '"6 $(3##'
& $(7. .&"(, "#$* =#& '-
$# "$ ".6 '$' 4 ' &"$"#',0 %-
$ %'$&("3 "#$*. %$"#'(2( .$&-
(3 # ' ".. ' 5 #(3,.
%$"#'#(2. $(3"*6 *."*6 *$&'
*(3#$0 =(#, "6$ '$0"*& 6$*#$ &"-
$"#' *)#"2 #*. ) /""%$,. .%$#'..
. . %'(2-4 /(35"#' $(3#2
"&2 '# ' "#$"*. ',/$, "(. 60 (#
83
#. , *& /,( " '$0"* &"$"#',
".,"( "4"#''2 $(2.
%$'. (&$ ' $( "()("3 #'$2 /)-
"#3 ' #., # (-/, %$&'$, " %("#7.
#$$#$(3, "#%* . #(3* "&/(2-# %$/(-
., /%""# "#$,. $&.#. "3 "()# -
#8 (3-*",, $"".#$'.2 ** %$2. "("#'
.$& %$7"" "(. #$2 ('"*2 '0 2006 &.
& %$"#'#(0 + , (#.
2007 &., '"("#' & /,( %"#'( % &$
/%""#3 -& "#$,, #*) "#-#"2 $(3##.
%(#* "'$#,'2 $(3"*& %$"#"#'2 -&
' ' "*#$ . *#$, %$', (#*
%"#2 /)-# #$- ' 7("/$"#
"2 %("#"*& &"$"#'
24
. $ %$"%*-
#', " 6 #* $2, "6$ "##"-*', %-
"*(3*, ** %*,'-# %"( "2#(#2, $(3
"#'#"2 "(3, %("#7, "(/.
* "6$ "##"-*' #$$#$26 #-
"#"#' .* ' %$&'$. %$7"" "'
%$7% '6 &"$"#' ** $ '#2&'# $(3
' $(3"#3 & &"$"#'. &(" ".,. %"-
"."#"*. 7*., $ 5–6 (# $/, /# "-
"#'(2#3 /(35"#' (, % *$00 .$, .
40% "(2 #$$#$, $"%()0 .)
$. $ $.,. .$.. ?# #, #
' %$(6 =#6 &$7 $(3 ".)# ' (&"$-
0 %$"%*#' "6$#3 "/2 ** &"$"#' '$0-
"*& $, ' *#$., ' "#'#"#' " "',. "-
#'*. "., /(35"#' (), ""#'(2#3
'$. $. #&, %$()2 $)'#3 #$$#$,
24
Rubin B. Time is on my side // Gloria Center Global Research in Inter-
national Affairs. IDC Herzlia – 28.09.08/ http://www.gloriacenter.org
84
*#$,6 %$)'-# .((, %("#7', $(3
"#'# % $ "'- .)$- $%#7-. $-
(3"*2 **%72 %(#* # "'2 .)-
$. "/4"#' %$','#3 "( ',
"$"#' /$3/,, %$.2., %("#7. %$#' -
&. 5 #$$#$(30 %$/(., "#'#"2 )-
') (2 $(2. '"#,0 $(3"*0 "#-
$* %(#(& . ""$ .#( ' "'2 " =#.: «-
(32 "#72, *#$- ., "('( %"(
1967 &., *&, ** . *("3, " /,( "*(3*
& '$., #/, %$.#3 **6 $50,
*("3»
25
.
,5. %$.3$-."#$ . #326 *-
#(3 .$ $&($' " %("#7. '#"2
** $2 %((#',6 .$. ' %$'- $3 (#
%$ * "0"#'2 =*."*. $'#-
%("#"*6 #$$#$0. "#%' ' ()"#3 ' %$(
2009 &., $(3"*0 %$.3$ %$',6 %$6 '/4
)(( %/( %$"#3 "*$.#(3- 8$.(
«' &"$"#' (2 '6 $'». 53 % '(.
.$*"*0 %(.# ".& %$# . /.,
. #326 ' "'0 %$&$..0 $ % '%$".
'50 %(#* ' '$"## $-( 14 -2
2009 &. 2'(: «…$ "(' &$#0 .(#$-
7 %$ "(' %$2 %("#7. $(2 **
'$0"*& &"$"#' ., &#', %0# *(-
"#24& .$& "&(52, *& .(#$-
' %("#"* &"$"#' /# "4"#''#3 /*
/* " '$0"*. &"$"#'.»
26
. "#'(, %$
%("#7. %$'$#(3, "('2 (2 %$')2
25
The Jerusalem Review. A Journal of Foreign Policy. Vol. 1. @ 1.
2006–2007. P. 67.
26
Haaretz. 14.06.2009 – http//www.haaretz.com
85
% %# * .$, #. . /,( $''5, *-
*.-(/ /2#(3"#'. $(2 #"#(3 (3-
050 "3/, %"(0 1%. /$&. ' -
$(3"* $*'"#' "$ )"#* $""#'( '" #*
i % #*. *(-',. %$/(.. $&($'2, **,
%$.$, $"(. %("#"* /)7,, ' %-
2#3, # (2 & %$.(., *.%$."", "#-
)2 %$7"" "(.
"4"#' 2'(2 $(3"*. %$'#(3"#'.
%72 2'(2#"2 %'#$. '$# &$0
'#. %("#7' ' $$,6 #$$#$(3
"'2,6 *#6 %$ "6$ ' /( .2&*0
8$. $). "*$.7 $/'. '$2 ( /"-
%# (&"$ "#0' $5 *8(*#, #*
** (*'$# "('0 (2 %$()2 "%$#'-
(2 %("#7' %(#*, 4.(2-40 6 7(3-
, %$' " "/"#'& '".& %(-
7& &"$"#'. ) "&2 %("#"* /4"#-
', ($, ',$)-# '$ ("#"*0 .-
"#$7, *,'2, # %$'$4#"2 ' *((/$-
7"#"*0 $). #% 5, ' &# % /"%-
/%""# $(2. (.$, ' $5 %("#"*0
%$/(., %$'# * ',. '"%,5*. "(2 #$$-
#$26 "#'2# $(3 "('#3 $%$""'- %(-
#*, *#$2 ) "#( . /(350 *$' .#$-
(3,6 #$# "$3 %$'( & .) ' .$.
.&"(, $*(3 "#$, *$0
%$', 7("#, ' $( '*(-2 ($ %$#
«"$=(3 0#» . /$., .-4& %"# .-
"#$ "#$,6 ( ' %$'#(3"#' . #36, "-
&2 ''3 %.-# '%$" #$"8$ (',"()
$/' " **%$',6 #$$#$0, " #$$#$
$(2 ' &$76 1967 &. #$%$#7 /$.,
' /4 %("#"* &"$"#' (), /,#3 '*(--
86
, $0, *.%*#& %$)'2 $(3"*6 $-
/', '$0"* %"(2 1%. /$& (),
"##3 "#3- "$"#' $(3. #. #&, #
/(35"#' $/', &$) $(2, #$7#(3 #-
"#"2 * %$"%*#' 6 "(3"#'0 %$ %
"'$## %("#"*& &"$"#', '$2 ( **0-
(/ $'.,"(240 $(3"*0 %(#* '3.#"2
"4"#'( =#0 . *& $ =#"* "#*
*'(87$-#"2 ' "'$.. .)$. %$'
** %$"#%( %$#' ('"#. (2 .&6 $-
(3#2, ' 7(3. " *#$,6 &(/* *-
$("3 %.2#3 .&'*',6 &26 '$0"*0
$, " .$(30 #* $2 #* $5 $/"*&
'%$" %$"#'(2#"2 %"#.,..
%"( '$.2 ' =*"%$#,6 *$&6 /()'-
"#*' "#("3 #",(* * «$"*.», ' ,-
56 "('26 * «$"*-&%#"*. '$#»,
%$.'-4. **--# 8$. #&$7 1%-
& /$& " $0, "*#$ " &%#.. &
#$ /")#3 '"$3, #* ** / $/"* "#$,
&#', '2#3 "/2 =# #'#"#'"#3. (5*.
/(35. .&# *#3"2 $)* #*& $52 (2
&%#, *#$,0 ' # .&6 "2#(#0 '#
'#$-- /$3/ " $*(3,. "(."*. &$%%-
., %$) '"& " $&70 «$#3'-."(3.».
, & ' "#24 '$.2 .$# , '$2 (
.)# %$"#'(2#3 "/0 %$'(*#(3 #$$#$-
(3 %$/$# (2 &%#.
$ ' #( # 1940-6 – ( 1950-6 &&.,
*& 5.#"*2 "#2 %$#'( '(
'"0 ("#0, ' "#24 '$.2 "()("2 *"""
#"#(30 "/"#'0 7(30 #"#,
',$),0 ' 8$.( «$2 "#3 $2». $
=#. ' $ ) %$)'#, % *#$,. 7*.,
87
%# 2 .(. %("#7', # ""#'(2# *( #$#
'"& $"*& "(2. *(- ' ""#' &"-
$"#' %(#(3 .((,6 ."" %("#7'
/) "#'# % &$ ',0 2'(,0 6$*#$
$"*& &"$"#', # %$#'$# #$". &
7(30 =(#,
27
.
* %$"#'(2#"2, "&250 3 %$7%
'6 &"$"#' "##"2 "#',. '$#., *#-
$,0 .)# /,#3 %() ' "' $&($'2 %(-
"#-$(3"*& *8(*#. $"%*#' & $(-
7 ' /(350 "#% '"# # *#'7 .)-
$& %"$"#', ' #. "( # /( .-
,6 0"#'0 '"6 (' «*'$##» '*(-2 ""-.
,6 :##6 '2 ."#$72 %$#
. /., 2' ."#$$# .$ "(#3 ).
/ "#$, *8(*# ' 7(26 %$')2 ' -
%$'( "2 %("#"*& &"$"#', %* =#
'.)"#3 *$,("3 *#(3. , =#.
%# "## .( "$3,6 %$%2#"#'0. ' $(,
%("#"*6 #$$#$26 ' %"( "2#(#
%$5( "$3 *$%( %70 =*"#$."#-
"*6 "(. ',/$6 ' $( ' 8'$( 2009 &. %/
$)( %$', %$#, "#3 *#$,6 %("#3- #-
'$&# - %("#"*& &"$"#', $&2 "#3
&#' * *$(3,. #$$#$(3,. *.%$."-
". $ & "2. %("#"*0 "#$ )"#*2
$(3"*2 %$72 ' ' 2'$ 2009 &. %$'(
* ")- %%(2$"# ')2 .
) "##"2 #, # 7%3 "(2 ' #5-
26 $(3#2 %("#7' .&# $$'#3 (53 $-
27
.. % =#. '%$": Lynch M. Jordan’s Identity and Interests/ Iden-
tity and Foreign Policy in the Middle East / Ed. by Sh. Telhami &
M. Barnett. Cornell University Press. 2002. P. 47.
88
(3##', %$&'$,, *#$, /# ."#$$-
'#3 #0 $&0 "#$ 2', %$.4"#' # $(-
7 "#&#,6 .$,6 &'$"#0 % "$'-
- " ,50 "#70 %$&'$& #%*. ",(-
* ,0 %,# %$7"" "( %$"#'(2-#"2
/#(3,.. (32 /,'#3, # =# /,( %$'2
.& "2#(#2 "$32 %%,#* /#3"2 **6-
(/ '.%$.(.,6 $50 ' %$2.,6 %$&'$6.
6 6 /,( ',$/# $2 %$()0 0,
$'2*, *#$, "'#(3"#'-# $(3"# *.%$-
.""', #, %"(-4& %$*$42 %("#-
-$(3"*& *8(*#. %$&'$,0 %$7""
*("2 ()*. '#$%(#"*& %$#'"#2-
2 % / "#$, «/$$*» – /$3/, '("#3 **
' $(, #* ' %("#"*0 "$. "#&#, &-
'$"# ## ) "%(3'("3 %(#"*. %$-
#'*. &'$'-46"2 ($' ** *,$, *$-
#, (2 6 "*$#7 ".42 " $*'246 %-
70. $. #&, &#'- $(3 ",&$( /"-
', $"#, . $8# "%(3'#3 "(' '(-
$(3#2 %"$"#'. .%(27 =*"#$."#-
"*. %("#"*. &$%%$'*.. "'- $3,
%$' %$'#(3"#' ' $(, %$55 * '("#
' 1996 &., .$ #$.( ',%( "#&#,6
&'$"#0, "%'(3 %#(*'2 * %$'*7-
,. ',"#%(2. *$0 7("#"* *$&
'#$ $(2 =*"#$."#"* "#$- "#3 %-
"(7'. '5. 8*#$., #$7#(3 "*'-
5."2 6 .$& %$7"", "(# #"# &
"(/- %$)* $/"*. "#$., *#$,, ** )
"(("3 $, $*'"#''("3 "*(-#(3 "/-
"#',., %$#'$'5. $& $& #$"..
'" ) /%""#3 &"$"#' *)& &$)-
, *#$, "&2 "#'2#"2 ' &(' &( $*'"#'.
89
$(2, .&# /,#3 /"%, / "#'(2 .-
$. "#$"*0 %,# "'#(3"#'# #., # ' $-
(3## "#)2 .$,6 &'$"#0 " &%#.
$0 /,( "#$ '2 &$ $(- " "#-
$, '46 $/"*6 "#$, , "('#(3, '"&
$/"*& .$. %(( '.)"#3 (2 "%*0&
'#$& $'#2, #*) 7(,0 $2 %(#"*6
%(.#"*6 %$.4"#'. # ) *"#"2 #$$-
$., # ' (*'7 & &$, $(3##',0
.$,0 %$7"" .)# ",&$#3 '"3. "$3- $(3.
"( %("#7, /2#"2, # .$ '.0"#'
" $(. 0"#'#(3 #*$,'# "'$5 $(3-
- %$"%*#' "2 )"%"/& '".-
& &"$"#' "#',. #$.. =#. %#
*,'#"2 , # ' %("#"*. /4"#' '-
*# .#'72 (2 *$& .2 #52
* =#0 $&7, (2 #* # %$)* (-/,6
0"#'0. (3* (272 '#$ %("#"*-
& /4"#' .)# (5#3 & "%"/"# %$'#3
"'- ,5-- (-.
90
..
1
1967 &.
(',6 ')26 %$#"# ' $( %" -
.&. 6 "#,(' .('-# #"#', '-
#$,, $(3"* ""('#(, ' "#2 6
%(#"*. .$&(., *,''5. '(22
/40 %(#"*0 *$". * /,(, '*-
' – # "/ %$.#(3 – ' "('26 =08$
%"( :"#'0 '0,. $""* / 6 2#(3-
"# $(3"*2 "#$2 %$"## /( %$2.(0-
0, (50 #(3,6 *$"* ##*'.
:"#'2 '0 %("#3- .( %(#-
"* "." $(3#2. (3##, =#0 '0,
*( '"3. "4"#' '(2 /4"#'-
)3 "#$,. ' ( '" %(#"* "(, ' "#$
$(("3 ' (&$2: "#$*' «(*& -
$(2», ".''56"2 ' &#'"# $/' *(-#3
.$ (-/,6 "('26, #6, *# "#(, # .$
$(3 .) /#3"2 (53 %#. #$$#$(3,6,
' #. "( #(3,6, "#%*.
?# $( 5( "' ',$) ' 2#(3-
"# '6 $&70 – ') (*0 $(3
') .$ /%""#3. «&(2,'2"3 ' %$-
5(, .) '#3, # "#* $*(7 ' -
$( ' %"( "2#(#2 "62# . =#6
91
'6 ')0 6 .$'$2», – %"( $(3-
"*0 ""('#(3
1
.
) =#6 ')0 $32 %$%&$'(
"'- %(#8$., %$'( ".%., ""#'(2(
%#7. 7(. 2#(3"#3 /6 /,( %$'(
'' /4"#'0 %$)*. *
=#6 ')0 $&','( (, %$#"#,
( ."#$7.
*(72, *#$2 .#("3 %"( :"#-
'0 '0,, "#( "('#3"2, #* ** '$.2 5(,
&(',0 '%$" – .$, 1.( $(2 &$76 –
"#'("2 $$5,..
&(' %/'50 ' '0 "#$, "#2( %$'-
#(3"#', .'5 #*0 0 %7 ' #5-
(3056 %(#"*6 5&'. "( (&& -
%$2)2, ' *#$. %$/,'( "( ' )
/)0 '0,, "#%( &(/*2 =08$2 # (&-
*0 '0 %/, $/., # '.)"# "'-
/& "#% * '$0"*. "'2#,2.. $(3"*
/4"#' (*'( %$'( /("#24- %/,
*#$2 "2( %$2)"#3, *%'5-"2 ' %$'-
,0 %$, ' # *#$& .& $(3#2
'"#''( &$ '"$3 %$)'( /4
"'0 "#$,. / ), "/ "#$.#(3"#3,
#$*#'("3 ** , ** "%".
?08$2 # %/, $""'("3 .(. *
# %(#"*& $*'"#' )( **$#,6 $-
50. ""#' %$'#(3"#' 7(3& "#-
' '6( .$-42 (0/$"#"*2 %$#2
%$',0 /(* ' &(' " . &..
1
" . 0 .6 67-%$(.#$# (#$$: (.# %(-
## /"$=( () '%$(.#"*. %$#"#. #$$$.: %(-
#"* "( ' $(). $"(., 1995. . 48.
92
72 & /,( )"#*0. %$'( *-
*6 *.%$.""'.
(, %$'#(3"#' # %$2'(2( %"#2-
- /#(3"#3 " #., #/, (0/$"#"* ($,
%$%$2( 5&', *#$, .&( /, %$'"#
* #$$#$(3,. "#%*.. 6#2 %$#2
"#(3* '"( # /(* , #/, %"#3"2
'#. '$2 ' ""#, ($, /,( "*(,
"6$#3 %$'#(3"#' ' . ""#' "&(5-
("3 " *#$,. %72. /(* .
"*(3* $/, /,( &#', *.%$.""
%$&'$, " $(., '42 %$'#(3"#'2
%$#2 %$2( «$5 %$.#3 %(#-
"*6 $50». *2 #*#* "%"/"#''( "6$-
- %$'#(3"#' 7(3& "#' '."#
" #. '(#'$2( $(, 8$*7, "4"#'''5
'#$ ".0 $# #$, %$) '"& %#., #
.&( %$# * . %(#"*. "&("-.
0"#'-40 %$.3$-."#$ ' ?5*( ( ) –
%$.* -$ ' ()"# &(', ) -
5( *.%$."" $5 #$$#$(30 %$/(-
.,. $(3 "#$( %(' ' #5 **%$-
',6 #$$#$0; "#("3 (53 «(&.»,
$)'.,. #6 %$, %* $/"* "#$, %0-
# (&. *) ','&("3 #$/', # $/,
(), "&("#3"2 '"# %$&'$, ' "#'#"#'
" "#� #*40 ..# "#70. %$*#-
* =# (, # $(2 /,( %$"## '$-
.. # ) '$.2, / (/$(30 .*$#-
"*0 "#$0, $(3 () /,( $&','#3
%$)'#3 %$.(., "('2 %$)'2 (2 -
"(2 **%$',6 #$$#$0.
"( '0, ("3 "*"" / $(3##6
(3050 "3/ **%$',6 #$$#$0. #-
93
5 $(3"*6 %(#"*6 "( * '.)"#2.
$(,. %#2. $&($'2 *8(*# /,( -
. #$* *7%7 «.$ ' /. #$-
$#$», #.. 6 "*#$ , " 1%& /$&
$. $ ("*6 ',"#, %(( ' «&(-
/». #$* «(*& $(2», #.. "6$2
**%$',6 #$$#$0, /,( ', «2"#$/,».
5 %$# « %$.#3 %(#-
"*6 $50» #"#(3 **%$',6 #$$#-
$0 ','( '(3"#' ** «2"#$/'», #* «&(-
/0». ?*"%""#, "%$' '"%$.( $5
(0/$"#"*6 ($' ** &#'"#3 ##3 #$$#-
$ ' /. .$, ' "( "( $/, /# &#',
# $&($' *8(*#, #. %'$
%""# .# «(*. $(».
«(/» ('& *$,(, " "'0 "#$,, /'2(
%$'#(3"#' ' #., # "## "%(3#
%(, 7#',, *#$, .&( /, %#(*#3
$/' .#3 "'0 '"#',0 "#$0 %$#' -
$(2. #*) #$/'( # %$'#(3"#' .$, %$-
%2#"#'-46 "- %"(0 **%$',6
#$$#$26.
"( «2"#$/,» '( ' %7 %$'#(3"#' #6
# *#(30 *" **%$',6 ' 1967 &.
#$$#$0, # «&(/» ".#$'( ' $5 %$'-
#(3"#' "*$,#,0 %( %(40 *"
2
.
' )( %$'#(3"#' %(#3 #$$-
#$(3, "#%* ' /. .$ #$.( *#'-
7- /4"#',6 "( ' "#$. * " '$..,
% .- .$,6 («&(/0»), *#$, /"#2#(3-
"#' %"#'( % ". .$ %$'#(3"#'
2
Bar-On M. In Pursuit of Peace. Washington, D.C.: US Institute of Peace
Press, 1996. P. 45.
94
*(-#3 .$ " $/.. #*. /"#2#(3"#'.
.) #"#: " '$0"*& %"( ' '$-
(1968 &.), $& %("#"*6 ."#$#' ' "*-
#$ , #) %("#"*6 .', 62'
*#$,6 2*/, "#$-# " #$$$"#., #*
%$'#(3"#' $$5#3 '"#$ . (3., %$-
# , " %$#. &%# #.. ?# "/,#2
*( "%('-40 =88*# &$. *("#'
$(3"*6 «2"#$/'», '(' 6 "*%"" "#
.$0 %$'#(3"#' $&($'#3 *8(*# " $-
/. $ %"* #$$#$(3& *.%$.""
.$,6 %$&'$'.
$&$ /4"#',6 /#' /46 &$76
$(2 &$%% «2"#$/'», "/ =.7(3 %$.'-
5 «(*& $(2», $2' %$#
#(3*, ' &(' " %=#. . (3#$.. ()
%"#(. . :.$. () $&'( (//
%$#' 6 " **%$',6 #$$#$0. 31 *#2/$2
1967 &. .#& ' (3-'' 87(3 /,(
8$.( ') (*0 $(3. $2#,.
'). .8"# /,( %%" 57 ',-4. -
$(3#2., '*(-2 %"#(0, %=#', ,6, '-
(3*', %$"#'#(0 *$%& /" $'-
''. ') '5( ($, 7(30 $(-
&0 %$# (+), $2 *' 1.! /#-
"*&, /(35"#' ""#'( ',67, $2'
3
.
#2 /(35"#' (' ')2 /,( $(-
&,., "#3 & .8"# /,( "8$.($'
' "# $(&,6 #$.6. #*"# & &'$#"2:
«"2 1.(2 $(2 6#"2 "0" ' $*6 '$0"*-
& $, ** . %'( #*#3"2 # "-
3
Bar-On M. Op. cit. P. 49.
95
$"#' $(3, #* . %$* "6$#3 #, #
., %(( #. # 1.( $(2. , /2#(3 /-
. '$, 7("#"# 50 "#$, – ** $ %$-
5(&, #* $ /4& 5& $, – %"*(3*
%$'#(3"#' ' $( .# %$' #*-
#3"2 # =#0 7("#"# ("#$,. – .#.)»
4
.
«"#$/.» ' $( %$#'"#2( .$, *$&
/4"#'"#. $%%, "#$*' .$ " $/. "-
4"#''( ' $( 4 '0, 1967 &., 6#2
/,( "'". '(* % "("#. "',. '%$-
"., *#$,0 6 />2(, /,( '%$" %("#"*6
/)76 6 %$'6. "( 6'# ',6 #$$#$0
' 1967 &. /,( ##" %$/(.0 /( &(/(30 –
".. 6$*#$ "$"#' $(3 & &$76
5
.
#$* .$ – #, 32 #* $2 $/-
$(3"*0 *8(*# 4 '0, #(("3 # %-
7 /(35"#' $(3#2, – #"("3 * ''-
- 1%& /$& "*#$ ** * '0 '-
.)"# (2 *(-2 .$ " $/..
9 -2, %$*#"*, *& '0 4 *-
("3, '"#,0 $(3"*0 )$("#, ' ## %$
%## ""# $ '$, /$#("2 * %$.3$-
."#$ . ?5*( " %"3.., ' *#$. «.(2(» &
"#3 %("#"* &"$"#' #(3* # **%-
$',6 #$$#$26 *(-#3 " =#. &"$"#'.
.$,0 &'$
6
.
2 " (# 1967 & $2 '46 $(3"*6 -
,6 – "#$*, "7(& $. – %$"* %/(-
4
Isaac R.J. Israel Divided: Ideological Politics in the Jewish State? Bal-
timore: John Hopkins University Press, 1976. P. 61 (in: Hall-Cathala D.
The Peace Movement In Israel 1967-87. Oxford: St Antony’s/Macmillan
Series, 1990. P. 6).
5
Hall-Cathala D. Op. cit. P. 29.
6
Bar-On M. Op. cit. P. 46.
96
*'( ' %$"" "##3 %$#' **%7 %$,'(
%$'#(3"#' %$#3 %$' %("#7' %$%$-
2#3 5&, *#$, .&( /, #*$,#3 %#3 * %$&'-
$. " "". $/"*. "#$..
"#2/$ 1967 &. &$%% /4"#',6 2#(0
$(2 %/(*'( ' &# «$7» /$4,
' *#$. "$)("3 %$%$), # «**%72
'(# "/0 )- '("#3. )2 '("#3 '(#
"/0 "%$#'(, "%$#'( – &#, &-
# '(# "/0 #$$$ *#$#$$$. ! $#'.
#$$$ /, /,'-# ', (-… 6$
**%$',6 #$$#$0 %$'$## " ' $, *-
#$,0 /'# *#$& /'-#»
7
.
* $5 %$'#(3"#' « %$.#3 $5-
0» ( « 0"#''#3». "#$, – "#$-
* "(2 **%$',6 #$$#$0 %$'(2(
"' "(2 " %$7#' («8*#' .-
(»), #'$)-46 $(3"* %$"#"#' =#6
#$$#$26. $5( "'". .& '$., &$%-
%,, %$)'-4 **%7- $/"*6 #$$#$0,
$5( "#.($'#3 %$'#(3"#' %$2# )-
,6 . $50 $ %$)* 87(3,6 %$-
&$.. "2 %"(0 =#6 #$$#$26. "(-
%$',6 "#$0 ' /4"#' /0"#' %$'-
#(3"#', ',,'( #$'& ' $26 (/$(30 #(-
(&7 %"2, # %(, % "(- #$$#-
$0 "4"#'(2-#"2 % 7#' &"$"#',6
'("#0. ?# (- "#( "'. (&. %%,##3"2 "-
#'#3 «"*#,' /4"#' '%$'»
8
.
( 1969 &. %$8""$, '$"##' $&-
'( &$%% – $,' * .$ /%""#. #3 6
7
$. (3-''. 1970. @ 4. . 10.
8
Hall-Cathala D. Op. cit. P. 28.
97
«%$,'» /,( ' #., #/, $'#3 %", ((--
, '*'5 "#$*' «(*& $(2».
6 ',"#%( "$)("2 %$,' * %$'#(3"#'
/,#3 /( ".#$#(3,., %"*(3* '$, 0-
"#'2 ' "()'50"2 "#7 .&( /, %$'"# * %-
2'(- &%(#"*0 7,, %(' "(2
*#$0 ""#2( /, %("#"*6 $/'. =#6 "-
('26 "$"#' $(3 &$)( '6:
(/ %$"##3 /,#3 '$0"*., (/ %$"##3 /,#3
.*$#"*..
$ %$8""$', ',"#%'56 " $,'., /,(
. (., . #"#$0*, . $(, . 7 :.. 0-
5## – ', , *#', %(#*. #2
"$ $(3"*6 ,6 %$8""$' /,( "#-
$* .(#$. "(3"#'& %$"2
#$$#$0, /(35"#' "(2 $(2
. %$"#'#( $,' * .$ /%""#
%(3'("3 /(35. ".,. '#$##..
(# #.##3, # ($, =#0 &$%%, /,( (*
# "2 %%7 $). "4"#'-40 %(#-
*. "#( "/2 (53 "#'*. %$%$)-
(, %$/$) 6 "'#. /0#"2 $(-
"(5*. $&
9
.
$(. '#$) %$'=*"#$."#"*& $''-
:. '&$ & "#$*' ' $/"*0 &$
?(3-((3 ('$) "' #. '$0"*0 5',
%$ %(. %%"##(3"#' %$'#(3"#' %#(*(
*."* *$& * /( $5#(3,. 0"#'2..
1 -(2 1968 &. *8$7 ' (3-'' /,( "-
') .$ /%""#3. $2#2 ')-
. 6$#2 "$)( #$/' * %$'#(3"#' «2-
9
Kaminer R. The Politics of Protest. Sussex Academic Press, UK, 1990.
P. 9–10.
98
'#3 '".,"(, # "$"#' $(3 .-
$ *"$'#3 #$$#$. /# %$$)'#3-
"2 %$7%' 6 " *#$($.,6 #$$#$0, %$
"#) .$& "&(52, "'& "&(-
"',6 /%",6 &$76»
10
.
=## %$ '* 7(,0 $2 /(356 ""#-
"*6 &$%%, ',"#%'56 ''$4 **%$'-
,6 .(3 $&($' /()'"#& *-
8(*# "' $(-7 242 '# %""#
. . #"("3 .## .$- 7#',
$# 6".( (- (',6), #*('50"2 ' 1969 &. #
%$# , *& %"(22 '5( ' ""#' /(*
$6, #*) $2 $&6 $&70. ?# /,( .-
("(, .('(2#(3, &$%%,, * *#$,.
%$.*( #(3, (, *#$,6 /4"#',6
$&70, %$"#'#( #'$"*0 0 -
#((&7. *,'( %$)* =#. &$%%. -
'"#, )$("#,, %"#( "##, "62 "-
/$)0 "%$'('"#, 7(3,6 &$)-
"*6 '"#', #*) /2, # **%72 %"#'#
% &$ $(3"*- .*$#-.
""# " "). :"#'0 '0,
%(#* %$'#(3"#' ',"#%( (53 %$#2
(',0 *.."#"*0 "%"*), /$''52"2
' $(3## $"*( ' $26 ' 1965 &.
$' ) '%$(.#"* «%$/)» %"(
'0, %$2'("3 ('. %(#"*. 8(& "-
"$#("3 &(',. /$. ' 2#(3"# '6 .-
("(,6 &$%% – 7% .
7% – .$*""#"*-#$7*"*2, #""#"*2
&$%%, 0"#'''52 ('0 %(#"*0 %$8-
$ $(2. /,( /$' ' 1962 &. #*('50-
10
Bar-On M. Op. cit. P. 50–51.
99
"2 # /(350 #$7*"#"*0 &$%%0, *#$2
/,( "'2 " .)$,. "*$#$#. #$-
7(. %2'( %$5( (2 $(3"*0 /4"#-
'"# .#. 87(3 ' =#0 $&-
7 /,( «$(3"*2 "7("#"*2 $&-
72», '"# % '- "'0 &#, «7-
%» («.%"»). $%% =# .( .& /4& " -
(&,. %'$%0"*. $&72. #&
%$. " ' ( 1960-6 &&. /,( $#$'-
, $#0 .$ & &$': =, :
, +(2 "#$ '$. $( =#
/,( *#(3, ',,'( #(3* ".%#,
#$".
* =# ('$*(32 &$%% "#(, # %-
"( :"#'0 '0, $(3, **%$''50 #$-
$#$, %$()'5 "#$. $#3& .$, %$-
"("2 #*. /$. * .)$. .%$-
(.. #*$,#2 "($"#3 " /$3/0 %("#"*&
$ **%$',6 #$$#$26 %$"#'(
7% $*- '.)"#3 ',%(#3 %$/)-4-
/$)4- /4"#'"#3 8*7- %/ -
',. (',. #$7*"#"*. &$%%. ' '$%
11
.
7% $'$( *#'- 2#(3"#3 %$#'
**%7. %$'( (, ."#$7, *-
7 %$#"#, '"#%( ' "('", %$%(*. $(3-
"*0 ,0 ?. :%$7* #.(, # 7% /"%-
( "/ &, ') ."# ' &('*6 $(3-
"*0 %$"", ' %$( %'"#* 2 /4"#'-
,6 /#'
12
. 0"#'#(3, "("#3 =#0 &$%%,
11
" . 0 .6 67-%$(.#$# (#$$... . 48.
12
" . 70 %(#* 5( -(&#.-# /"$=(
1967–1972 ("#* %(#* (&#.7 ' $(, 1967–1972).
$"(., 1973. . 42–51.
100
( /(35 40–50 ('*) ** "#'#"#''(
$'- *#'"#. /42 ."#$726
',"#%(26 7% %$*#"* "6( " %$',6
%(" )',6 &#. (&$2 $*(30 *$#*
$(2 & $( ' $& &$%% %$'(*( '.-
.)$,6 *$&', $*(. #$7-
87(3& *$" 4 (& *,'( '(2
.&6 .(,6 $*('.
$%% (.( "$=( 65 – $(3"*
', (',) '*( ' 1969 &. % '(2. ',6
(',6, "4"#'''56 ' '$% : ' "$
1960-6 &&., 8 "%$#'(2 $(3"*0 **-
%7 1%& /$& "*#$ . ""#'
'5(: &$%% .(), "'20 " *//7"*.
')., ' &(' " . =., #*('52"2 ' 1969 &.
# %$# , *& %"(22 '5( ' ""#'
/(* $6; %*'52 &$%% ' &('
" . #$.; #*) &$%% %$"#'#(0 $(3-
"*0 #((&7
13
.
, ' #( # 7%, /,( ' "'0 "'
""#"*0 &$%%0. (, ""#, "*$ '-
$(, # .) "#3 .$ " $/., "( $(3
'$#"2 * &$7. 4 -2 1967 &.
14
. *".(3,0
./(7,0 $"$" ')2 "#&( "*(3*6
"# *#'"#' ."#$#'. "( 8"-
$'- .&(, *, "$'#3"2 " %$(.#-
"*0 8$*70, * % =$&#* =#. '%(-
"()'( /4"#'& '.2.
, ' "4"#, ""#2( '6 &$%%, "-
,6 ' (3-''"*. $"(."*. '$"##6,
(3 '$)'("3 # $/#, % **0-(/
13
. 10.08.1970.
14
" . 0 .6 67-%$(.#$# (#$$... . 49.