M3.1 Differentiation of extensive functions 47
The determinant of this expression is known as the functional determinant of the
transformation from the initial Cartesian x
i
-coordinate system to the general q
i
system. The term
√
g
x
is the functional determinant of the Cartesian system with
√
g
x
= [i
1
, i
2
, i
3
] = 1. The g
ij
q
of the square of the functional determinant are
g
ij
q
= q
i
·q
j
=
∂r
∂q
i
·
∂r
∂q
j
=
∂i
n
x
n
∂q
i
·
∂i
m
x
m
∂q
j
=
∂x
n
∂q
i
∂x
n
∂q
j
(M3.15)
Whenever the relationship between the Cartesian x
i
-coordinate system and the q
i
system is given, it is a simple matter to evaluate this equation.
In analogy to the definition of the covariant basis vector q
i
we define the con-
travariant basis vector q
i
. From the basic definition
dr =
∂r
∂q
n
dq
n
= q
n
dq
n
(M3.16)
and comparing the coefficients of the differential dq
i
, we easily find
q
i
=
∂r
∂q
i
= g
in
q
q
n
(M3.17)
where the second equality is the lowering rule according to (M1.84). If the three
covariant basis vectors q
i
are known as well as the contravariant metric fundamental
quantities g
ij
q
, then the basis vectors q
i
may be computed.
There is a very important point that needs to be mentioned. The contravariant
coordinate lines of the curvilinear system are continuous coordinate lines so that
∂
2
∂q
i
∂q
j
=
∂
2
∂q
j
∂q
i
(M3.18)
applies. In this case the order of the partial derivatives is immaterial. Owing to the
properties of the reciprocal coordinate systems, the covariant coordinate lines can
be defined only piecewise. Therefore, as is shown in textbooks on analysis, the
order of the differentiation cannot be interchanged:
∂
2
∂q
i
∂q
j
=
∂
2
∂q
j
∂q
i
(M3.19)
For this reason we prefer partial derivatives with respect to the contravariant co-
ordinates q
i
. In a later chapter we will encounter this situation involving (M3.19)
when we are dealing with natural coordinates.