but he probably felt a genuine repugnance at the prospect of setting one part
of the navy against the others, and by March an orderly and conditional
restoration may well have struck him as a better solution than any other that
was then feasible. At any rate he responded gratefully to a letter of goodwill
from the king that he received early in April.
One man whom February’s turn of the tide caught sadly adrift was John
Milton. He had seen how dangerously the current was running as the quarrel
mounted between the army and the Rump in the autumn of 1659, and
between October and December he had twice taken up his pen to propose the
outlines of a constitutional settlement that would heal their rifts and guarantee
the future of the Good Old Cause. He was possessed by a heightened sense of
urgency, however, amid the clamour for a free parliament that followed upon
Monck’s arrival in London and his ultimatum to the Rump. In haste he set
about dictating a larger tract which he called The Ready and Easy Way to
Establish a Free Commonwealth, though he knew the way would be far from
easy. What he proposed was by no means his ideal model of a republic, sup-
posing one could have been devised from scratch, but what in the straitened
political circumstances of February 1660 he thought might yet avert the
absolute evil of a return to monarchy. In his words, ‘to fall back, or rather to
creep back so poorly as it seems the multitude would, to their once abjured
and detested thraldom of kingship, not only argues a strange degenerate cor-
ruption suddenly spread among us, fitted and prepared for new slavery, but
will render us a scorn and derision to all our neighbours’. The Rump had
voted to fill up the House, so if the people will elect ‘able men, and according
to the just and necessary qualifications decreed in parliament, men not addict-
ed to a single person or House of Lords, the work is done: at least the foun-
dation is firmly laid of a free Commonwealth’. Then comes the shock: once
chosen, let the resultant assembly be renamed the Grand or General Council
and empowered to sit in perpetuity, with full authority to dispose of the land
and sea forces, raise revenue, make national laws, control relations with for-
eign powers, take decisions of peace or war, and appoint a Council of State
for day-to-day administration. The only spheres that Milton would have
withheld from its sway were those of religion and civil justice. Matters eccle-
siastical, he held, should be outside the authority of the civil magistrate. In
civil affairs, his one concession to anything remotely resembling democracy
was a proposal that every county in the land should be made ‘a little com-
monwealth’ and its capital town a city, ‘where the nobility and chief gentry
may build houses or palaces, befitting their quality, may bear part in the gov-
ernment, make their own judicial laws, and execute them by their own elect-
ed judicatures, without appeal, in all things of civil government between man
and man’. From their ranks would be filled the vacancies in the Grand or Gen-
eral Council when they occurred, though he did not say how. An inveterate
770 The Collapse of the Good Old Cause 1658–1660
ch27.y8 27/9/02 12:19 PM Page 770