joined by increasing numbers of gentry, lawyers, and clergy. Their sympathies
differed from region to region, but rather more inclined towards the royalist
cause; indeed they stand as a warning against any facile assumption that in
the countryside the middling sort were as a class basically parliamentarian.
They were moved by an attachment to old ways and to the rule of law, and
many of their declarations called for the retention of the Prayer Book services,
which became formally illegal in March 1645 when parliament prescribed
the exclusive use of the Assembly’s Directory for Worship. They breathed
some of the same grass-roots conservatism, at a more popular level, as the
abortive neutrality pacts of 1642–3, though no one still believed that with a
bit of collective goodwill his county could be spared the ravages of war. Self-
help was needed now, and what nerved untrained countrymen to confront
battle-hardened soldiers was not just exasperation but sheer mass. In most
counties where they appeared they easily outnumbered the locally stationed
troops, claiming as they did (perhaps with some exaggeration) 20,000 adher-
ents in Wiltshire, for example, and 16,000 in Berkshire.
17
Fairfax was to have much experience of the Clubmen, but they were not
among his problems when he took the field at the end of April, with his army
still at barely half strength. His main impediment was the Committee of Both
Kingdoms, which insisted on directing his operations from Westminster, and
showed the characteristic tendency of chairborne strategists to think defen-
sively and react to the enemy’s last move but one. It ordered him, against his
own judgement, to march to the relief of Taunton, but when he had got all the
way to Blandford it recalled him, directing him to detach six regiments for
Taunton. It was alarmed by the movements of the king’s forces and lured by
a false report that the faithful governor of Oxford, Colonel Will Legge, was
ready to betray the city. Fairfax must have thought that there were better
ways of raising the morale of raw and reluctant infantry recruits than taking
them on long marches with no evident purpose. The chimera of besieging
Oxford before engaging the king’s main army in the field continued to seduce
the committee for weeks, but there was indecision and misjudgement on the
royalist side too. Rupert wanted to march north, first to relieve Chester from
Brereton’s besieging forces and then to attack Leven’s now much reduced
Scottish army, which was besieging Pontefract Castle. But Cromwell was still
in the field with a brigade of horse, making the most of the forty days that the
Self-Denying Ordinance allowed him, and on 25 April he captured Bletching-
ton House, an important garrison only seven miles from Oxford. He went on
310 War in Three Kingdoms 1640–1646
17
Morrill gives the best brief survey of the Clubmen movement in Revolt in the Provinces,
pp. 132–51, 200–4. The earlier version of this book, The Revolt of the Provinces (1976), prints
a number of Clubmen manifestoes (pp. 196–200). See also R. Hutton, The Royalist War Effort
(1982), and D. Underdown, ‘The chalk and the cheese: contrasts among the English Clubmen’,
Past & Present no. 85 (1979), 25–48.
ch10.y8 27/9/02 11:11 AM Page 310